Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
CRR 5060 OF 2024
NIVEDITA GOSWAMI (DHOL)
VS
SRI DEBARGHYA DHOL
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Ranjan Kali,Adv.
Ms. Payel Nath, Adv.
Ms. Mohul Nandi, Adv.
For the respondent
:
Mr. Sanjoy Chakraborty, Adv.
Ms. Shaswati Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Reserved On
:
25.09.2026
Judgement on
:
29.09.2026
Uploaded on
:
29.09.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J.:1. This is an application filed by the petitioner/wife against an order dated
August 20, 2024 whereby the Learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court,
Barrackpore has passed a judgment in connection with Maintenance Case
no. 352 of 2022 filed under Section 125 Cr.P.C. whereby refused the prayer
of the petitioner after setting aside the order of interim maintenance granted
in her favour by the Learned Magistrate.
Brief Facts
2. The case of the petitioner in brief is that she is the legally married wife of
the present Opposite Party and their marriage was solemnized on February
5, 2017 under the Hindu Rites and Customs. Since after the marriage both
parties lived as husband and wife however there were disputes and
differences between the parties because of demand of the present Opposite
Party and his family members of gold ornaments, furniture, utensil etc. The
marital discord started from the very night of Reception and increased day
by day and the mal treatment and physical torture increased to such an
extent that life threats were given to her and she had to lock herself in her
room and finally on February 25, 2021 she compelled to leave the
matrimonial house and took shelter at her father’s house and lodged a
complaint before the Dum Dum Police Station on February 26, 2021 against
the respondent and other in-laws.
3. Further case of the petitioner is that the petitioner tried to join a service as
Assistant teacher for an amount of Rs.6,000/- per month but she was not
allowed to join after marriage and hence she had no income of her own to
sustain. She has her ailing father who is medically unfit and has his own
expenses. Hence she filed a petition under Section 125 Cr.P.C before Court
of Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate at Barrackpore which was
transferred to 5th Judicial Magistrate at Barrackpore on April 3, 2021.Due
to Covid situation and serious mental condition of her father she could not
follow up case and it was dismissed for default.
4. It is further case of the petitioner that the Opposite Party is a web designer
and earns Rs. 45,000/- per month and also has other earnings from his
fixed deposit, amounting to Rs.10, 500/- per month. His father is a retired
Government Employee and is a pension holder and thus the opposite Party
has no one to maintain except the petitioner but despite having sufficient
means he only paid Rs. 2000/- per month which the present petitioner
refused to accept. She being a destitute and deserted lady having severe
financial
crisis needed an amount of Rs. 20,000/- per month as
maintenance allowances and hence filed the second application under
Section 125 Cr.P.C. before the Learned Court of Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate at Barrackpore in the year 2022. The Opposite Party after
entering appearance filed written objection and also filed an application
under Section 340 Cr.P.C alleging she has made false statement on
Affidavit.
5. The Learned Magistrate considering the materials on record and that it was
at the stage of interim maintenance and Affidavits of Assets and liabilities
was filed by the petitioner when Opposite Party did not file the same, passed
an order of interim maintenance of Rs. 5000/- per month to be paid to the
wife from the date of filing of the petition. The said order was challenged
before the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Tack 3rd Court,
Barackpore, North 24 Parganas by the present petitioner for enhancement
and vide an order dated March 6, 2024 the revisional application was
allowed and the order of the Learned Magistrate dated November 19, 2022
was modified. The interim order was enhanced to Rs. 7000/- per month to
be paid from date of passing the said order and in terms of the said order
the Opposite Party was paying the said amount.
6. The husband did not adduce evidence and the trial witness
action started.
On conclusion of the evidence the judgement was delivered by the Learned
Court of Magistrate where it was observed that the present petitioner had
obtained the interim order by misrepresenting the fact and filing
a false
affidavit and used this provision as a tool to secure extravagant living at the
cost of husband for the marriage which did not work out and thus rejected
the petition filed under Section 125 Cr.P.C. The petitioner was further
directed to return the maintenance amount paid by the husband in
compliance with the interim order and as well as by the Learned Revisional
Court. This revisional application has been filed challenging the said order.
Submissions
7. The Learned Advocate representing the petitioner submits that the learned
court had a pre-conceived notion and thereby such caustic observation
made against the petitioner without considering the basic object of
incorporating provision of 125 Cr.P.C by the legislature. The order dated
August 20, 2024 has been passed which de hors the provision of law and
reflects a complete non application of mind causing utter
justice.
miscarriage of
The Learned Court did not appreciate the situation of the
petitioner/wife as a whole and failed to scrutinize effectively the evidence
adduced and also that the Opposite Party throughout flouted the order of
the Court ,did not file the Affidavit of Assets and Liabilities as mandated by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Rajnesh Vs Neha & Anr.1. It is
further submitted that it is settled law that merely because of wife is
possessing a higher degree of education or her parents are well established
2021 (2) SCC 324
will not absolve the petitioner from his liability to maintain his legally
married wife who under compulsion left the matrimonial house.
8. The further submission made by the Learned Advocate that during evidence
she stated that the amount which was found lying in her name was of her
father and on the advice of the Learned Advocate she did not mention same
in her Affidavit of Assets and Liabilities in the petition and hence the wrong
advice of an conducting advocate cannot be the cause of refusing the
maintenance. The Learned Advocate has relied upon the decision reported in
Manish Jain vs. Akanksha Jain2,
Shailja vs Khobbanna dated 18th
January 2017, Sunita Kachwaha and ors. Vs. Anil Kuchawa3 and also
the decision of Rajnesh vs. Neha & Ar.(Supra).
9. On the contrary the Learned Advocate representing the Opposite Party/
husband submits that the Learned Magistrate after analyzing the evidences
found the manner in which the present petitioner tried to suppress the
material facts and portrayed herself being a destitute and in utter need of
money. The Learned Magistrate on careful consideration of entire situation
and considering that the petitioner did not come before the Court in clean
hand passed such an order when interim order was allowed in her favour.
The order being a very well-reasoned order is not required to be interfered
with.
10. The Learned Advocate further drawn the attention of this court to the
evidence adduced by the present petitioner in the proceeding under Section
125 Cr.P.C
and submits that the application made under Section 125
Cr.PC itself is not maintainable since the petitioner
AIR 2017 SC 1640
AIR 2015 Supreme Court 554
admitted that she
voluntarily left the matrimonial house and also that
she filed all the
application as a counter blast to the writ petition filed against her by the
parents-in-law since she became traumatized and panicked and thought to
do something against them.
11. It is further submitted that the writ petition was originally filed by the
mother in law of the present petitioner against the police authorities for not
taking appropriate action and thereafter the instant complaint was lodged.
That apart on the date of filing of 125 Cr.P.C application few lakhs were
lying in her accounts which she deliberately suppressed in her affidavit of
Assets and liabilities. Hence prayed for dismissal of the instant revisional
application.
Analysis
12. Heard the submission of both the Learned Advocates. The order assailed
before this Court was passed by the Learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court,
Barrackpore, North 24 Parganans dated August 20, 2024 whereby the
prayer for maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C has been dismissed. The
factum of marriage in this case is not disputed. It is also not disputed that
presently parties are not residing together and at the initial stage the interim
order was passed by the Learned Magistrate on the basis of the application
filed under Section 125 Cr.P.C and the affidavit of assets and liabilities filed
by the petitioner. The Learned Judicial Magistrate at the time of
pronouncing judgement has meticulously considered certain areas which
would manifest that the present petitioner in order to impress the court
averred certain facts and circumstances which were found later on,
absolutely misleading and also found in course of cross examination that
the facts she relied upon by filing an affidavit were not correct statement.
13. The age old maxim “he who comes to equity must come with clean hands”
mandates that a litigant who is seeking relief from a Court must not
represent the facts incorrectly or suppressed any material facts and her
claim should be free from any taint of fraud. The rationale behind this
doctrine was to protect integrity and sanctity of the judicial process and also
to prevent the abuse of court procedure by unscrupulous litigants. In
plethora of Judicial pronouncements, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
reiterated that if this doctrine is not followed and if the complete disclosure
is not made before the Court while the Hon’ble Supreme Court and High
Court exercises their inherent jurisdiction and found that fraud and
suppression was there in making misleading statement, there can be
consequential action which can go up to dismissal of the prayer, imposition
of exemplary cost or denial of equitable relief. Even a contempt proceeding
can be initiated in such egregious cases. It is also settled law that any order
obtained by fraud from a Court of law can be set aside at any stage to be
considered as null and void.
14. In the touch stone of the above principle of law let it be ascertained that
how far the present petitioner being a lady is entitled for getting
maintenance in terms of section 125 Cr.P.C . In the petition filed before the
Learned Court of Magistrate by the petitioner under Section 125 Cr.P.C she
mentioned that she did not have any source of income and is living on the
charity of her ailing father. She alleged the behavior and cruelty meted out
to her by the opposite Party who also neglected and refused to maintain the
petitioner and also did not allow her to get a job in Academy of Intellectual
in the post of Assistant Teacher for a compensation of Rs.6,000/- per month
and lastly under compelling circumstances she had to leave the matrimonial
house on 25th February, 2021.
15. From her application for maintenance it is evident that previously an
application was filed in the year 2021 but
could not be followed up and
was dismissed for default. The instant Misc. case was filed in the year 2022
where she claimed herself to be deserted and destitute lady living in
financial distress and specifically averred that she filed the previous
application because she was facing acute starvation and she had no other
source of income to sustain normal livelihood.
16. The Learned Magistrate considered the said fact and passed the interim
order of maintenance in the month of November 2022, despite raising
objection by the Opposite Party and an application filed under Section 340
Cr.P.C on that ground stated therein. In course of evidence during cross
examination when the Learned Advocate of the opposite party placed a
photocopy of a statement of SBI Bank Account in the name of the present
petitioner being the 1st holder, the petitioner admitted such fact and stated
that all the pass books and cheque books of such joint accounts are in her
possession. The Learned Court on perusal of the statement of such bank
account found that balance of such account on October 7, 2020 was Rs.
8,06,193/-, on March 17, 2021 was Rs.7,10,057/- and on January 24, 2022
was Rs. 6,40,084/- which means when the application under Section 125
Cr.P.C was filed
claiming
to be a destitute lady and on the verge of
starvation she had an amount of Rs.6,40,084/- in a joint account of which
she was the first holder.
17.
She admitted that she did not disclose this account in her Affidavit of
Assets and liabilities but did as per the direction of her advocate. It has
further come out from her cross-examination that she left the matrimonial
home and her husband paid her Rs. 2,000/- per month since March 2021 to
October 2022. She stated on oath before the Court that the husband is
impotent and her marriage was not consummated. According to her version
her father gave the money on the joint account with her husband of which
she is the first holder but she did not mention in her petition or in her
Affidavit of Assets and Liabilities that her father gave the said money. It was
further detected in course of cross-examination she failed to say whether
she mentioned about 8 Lakh, 20 Lakh NSC and 3.9 Lakh MTS or not but
further in her Affidavit she did not mention. She did not mention in her
petition or her Affidavit of Assets and liabilities that such money was given
by her father and she does not earn any interest from NSC and MTS. She
even could not say whether any interest accrues from Post Office deposit.
She further mentioned that her father has not gifted the money to her but
further stated after maturity of the aforesaid deposits her father has taken
money. That apart the Learned Court further found from her crossexamination the specific averment which she made before the court that on
January 22, 2021 after receiving the copy of the writ petition through Postal
Department, filed by her parents-in-law she became traumatized and
panicked and thought that she will have to do something against them as
counter blast to the writ petition for which she has filed all the subsequent
proceedings.
18. It further transpires that initially she made statement in the crossexamination that in the affidavit of assets she did not mention about the
existence of SBI account as per instruction of her advocate but subsequently
she said that she instructed her advocate to draft her petition of complaint
two days before leaving her matrimonial home.
19. In terms of Section 125 (4) Cr.P.C no wife shall be entitled to receive an
allowance for the maintenance or the interim maintenance and expenses of
proceeding as the case may be from her husband under this Section if she is
living in adultery, or if, without any sufficient reason, she refuses to live
with her husband or if they are living separately by mutual consent.
20.
In the instant case it is not disputed that she left the matrimonial home
and certain circumstances has been narrated for which she had to leave.
She was found to be traumatized and then filed the subsequent proceedings
like filing of complaint under Section 498A or filing of application under
Section 125 Cr.P.C on receiving the notice of the writ petition filed against
her by her parents-in-law. Therefore the initiation of the proceeding not was
from the side of the present petitioner but from the side of her in-laws.
However she ought to have disclosed all the facts while praying for
maintenance
21.
The admission on her part regarding the exaggerated version of her
vagrancy depicted in her petition for maintenance for immediate interim
relief is proved to be absolutely misleading when it was found that right at
that point she had in her account few lakhs of Rupees and also she
possessed all the documents like cheque book, passbook with her. Further
she suppressed such entire facts from the court while filing her affidavit of
assets and liability .Therefore the facts discussed above clearly manifest her
intention to obtain an order of interim maintenance at the cost of
suppression of facts from the Court hurriedly in order to give a blow to the
husband and his family members. The question now falls for consideration
that whether her overenthusiasm of getting amount immediately as a
counterblast to the writ petition would disentitle her from getting
maintenance when it is not in dispute that she has no personal income of
her own.
22. It is a settled law that Section 125 of Cr.P.C. is a summary procedure and
it is not necessary for the court to ascertain who was in fault and or the
minute details of the matrimonial dispute. It is a fact that in Rajnesh vs.
Neha (Supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court emphasized that the maintenance
cost were enacted as a major of social justice to provide resource to
dependent wife and children for their financial support so as to prevent
them from falling into destitution and vagrancy. In the decision of Samima
Faruki Vs. Sahid Khan 4the Hon’ble Apex Court noted that- “It can never
be forgotten that the inherent and fundamental principle behind Section 125
CrPC is for amelioration of the financial state of affairs as well as mental
agony and anguish that woman suffers when she is compelled to leave her
matrimonial home”.
23. In order to have this order of maintenance in her favour certain factors
are to be considered which were thoroughly discussed in the said decision
2015) 5 SCC 705
and it is an admitted fact that financial position of the parents of the
applicant wife would not be material while determining the quantum of
maintenance. In the case of Bhagwan Dutt vs. Kamla Devi5 which was
taken note of by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Rajnesh Vs.
Neha (Supra) where the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that under Section
125 Cr.P.C only a wife who is “unable to maintain herself” is entitled to seek
maintenance. In this case the husband did not produce any document to
show that she has her own income or she is an earning lady.
24. It is no more res integra that mere possession of higher degree does not
disentitle the spouse from getting the maintenance on the contrary the
liability to maintain the wife is on much higher pedestal.
25. The learned Court found from the conduct of the petitioner that how she
obtained the interim maintenance but the Learned court should have
focused that whether she has her own income which is most important
factor to be considered and not that whether she has residential
accommodation or her parents are having robust financial status.
26.
Therefore the entire gamut of the matter portray the conduct of the
petitioner which has make the case worst for her in getting any favourable
order but this court cannot be oblivious of the fact at no point of time it was
established that the petitioner have her own income or she earns. She
clarified the position in her evidence that she was shocked after receiving
the writ filed by her mother in law against her and lodged the subsequent
steps. She has not yet filed any proceeding to declare the marriage as null
and void on the ground of non-consummation of marriage.
(1975) 2 SCC 386
27. It cannot be brush aside that despite specific direction of this court ,the
opposite party failed to
submit his Affidavit of Asset and liabilities as
mandated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, and also failed to appear before
the court to establish his actual income or to controvert the allegations
made against him .Consequently , in the
absence
of the requisite
disclosure and supporting evidence ,the actual income of the husband could
not be ascertained with certainty while
determining the quantum of
maintenance. Even though the petitioner wife has suppressed material facts
of having the joint accounts with her husband and few NSC lying in her
name the liability of the husband do not get absolved to maintain his legally
wedded wife when Section 125 Cr.P.C. is a measure of social justice,
especially enacted to protect women and children, falling within the
constitutional sweep of Article 15(3) reinforced by Article 39 of the
Constitution. The objective of the provision, is to alleviate the financial plight
of destitute wives.
28. Therefore in order to unearth the truth it is necessary that there must be
a DE novo trial before the Learned Magistrate where both parties will place
their respective Affidavit of Asset and liabilities without suppressing any
facts in accordance with the dictum of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
decision of Rajnesh vs Neha & Anr. (Supra) for arriving at a just
conclusion about the income of the parties and also in respect of a certain
other factors which were mentioned therein.
29. Therefore, even though this Court completely concurs with the observation
made by the Learned Magistrate so far the suppression of fact is concerned
it is not established that the wife voluntarily left the matrimonial house and
she left after receiving writ petition, so there existed a strained relationship
between them in her matrimonial house. Hence, without ascertaining such
fact and when the undisputed fact shows that she was not a earning lady,
total refusal would amount to denial of justice to the lady.
Conclusions
30.
Hence this Court after threadbare analysis of the entire facts and
circumstances of the case and the law laid down in this regard is of the
considered view that the judgement delivered by the Learned Judicial
Magistrate, 2nd Court, Barrackpore in connection with Maintenance Case
no. 352 of 2022 filed on 20.08.2024 rejecting the entire prayer for
maintenance cannot sustain in the eye of law.
31. Hence, this Revisional application is allowed .The order dated August 20,
2024 passed by the Learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court, Barrackpore is
hereby set aside.
32.
The petitioner is directed to file a fresh application under section 125
Cr.PC within a period of 4 weeks and to serve the copy of the application
upon the opposite party /husband .The Learned Court will dispose of the
said application in accordance with law and in the event the Learned Court
found the wife is entitled for the maintenance the order will be effective from
the date of filing the fresh application.
33. All other connected applications if any stand disposed of.
34. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
(CHAITALI CHATTERJEE (DAS), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review