Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
18.03.2026
SL No.6
Court No.12
(gc)
MAT 2272 of 2025
CAN 1 of 2026
CAN 2 of 2026
Smt. Niva Basu
Vs.
Sri Avishek Basu & Ors.
Mr. Abhijit Majumdar
Mr. Amales Ray, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Aman Gupta,
Mr. Ishan Bhattacharya
…..for the Appellant.
…for the Respondent No.1.
1. Affidavit of service is taken on record.
2. CAN 1 of 2026 is an application for condonation of
delay of 114 days in filing the appeal.
3. The appellant is a widow and a septuagenarian.
She
has been suffering from serious ailments. Thus, it was
not possible for her to approach the Court within the
period of limitation. Explanations given in paragraphs
2 to 5 of the application are satisfactory. The delay has
been sufficiently explained. We condone the delay and
regularize the appeal.
4. Accordingly, CAN 1 of 2026 is allowed and disposed of.
5. CAN 2 of 2026 is an application for stay of the judgment
and order dated July 28, 2025 passed by the learned
Single Judge in WPA 22622 of 2022. Instead of hearing
the application separately, we propose to hear and
dispose of the appeal along with the application.
6. Mr. Majumdar, learned Advocate for the appellant
submits that the appellant is the mother of the
respondent no.1.
The respondent no.1 was the writ
petitioner. Aggrieved by the order of the Sub-Divisional
Officer, Barasat Sadar, being the Presiding Officer,
Tribunal for Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and
Senior Citizens the writ petition was filed. The Tribunal
passed an order that, the transfer of property in favour
of the respondent no.1 to the extent of the share of the
mother was void and the family members of the
respondent no.1 were directed to vacate the mother’s
portion to the extent it was occupied by them, within a
month.
7. This order was challenged by the son/respondent no.1
on two grounds.
Firstly, that the deed of gift was
executed by both the parents and the same did not have
any condition that the property was being gifted by the
parents on the condition that the son would look after
the parents till the end of their lives. Secondly, that the
Presiding Officer did not consider whether the son had
actually failed to maintain the mother or not, by taking
evidence.
8.
The learned Single Judge set aside the order of the
Presiding Officer on the ground that the conditions
precedent to declaring a gift deed void, were not
satisfied in the instant case.
9. The specific finding of the learned Single Judge was
that, mere mention of the fact that the son was looking
after his parents in deed of gift, did not constitute a
covenant that the deed of gift was subject to the
condition that the maintenance would continue forever.
10. In the decision of Sudesh Chhikara Vs. Ramti Devi
& Anr. reported at (2024) 14 SCC 225, the Hon’ble
Apex Court held that, an effective transfer subject to the
condition of providing basic amenities and physical
needs of the transferor was a sine qua non for
applicability of sub-section (1) of Section 23 of the
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens
Act, 2007.
11. According to the learned Single Judge, an obligation
that the son or the donee would be looking after the
parents/donors till the end of their life should have
been incorporated in the deed of gift.
Such pre-
condition was missing.
12. In the instant case, the deed provided that, as the
parents were satisfied that the son was looking after
them in their old age and also being aware of the fact
that
the
son
did
not
have
any
alternative
accommodation or property, they had decided to gift the
property in favour of the son.
In the said deed, no
further condition was attached.
13. In Sudesh Chhikara (supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court
held as follows:“12. We have given careful consideration to the
submissions. Before dealing with the factual
aspects, it is necessary to advert to the legal
aspects. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate acting as
the Maintenance Tribunal under the 2007 Act has
invoked the power under Section 23 to declare
that the subject release deed was void. The 2007
Act has been enacted for the purposes of making
effective provisions for the maintenance and
welfare of parents and senior citizens guaranteed
and recognized under the Constitution of India.
The Maintenance Tribunal has been established
under Section 7 to exercise various powers under
the
Act. Section
8 provides
that
the
Maintenance Tribunal, subject to any rules which
may be framed by the Government, has to adopt
such summary procedure while holding inquiry,
as it deems fit.
13. Apart from the power to grant maintenance,
the
Tribunal
exercises
important
jurisdiction
under Section 23 of the 2007 Act which reads
thus:
“23. Transfer of property to be
void
in
certain
circumstances.— (1)
Where any senior citizen who, after the
commencement of this Act, has transferred
by way of gift or otherwise, his property,
subject to the condition that the transferee
shall provide the basic amenities and basic
physical needs to the transferor and such
transferee refuses or fails to provide such
amenities and physical needs, the said
transfer of property shall be deemed to
have been made by fraud or coercion or
under undue influence and shall at the
option of the transferor be declared void by
the Tribunal.
(2) Where any senior citizen has a
right to receive maintenance out of an
estate and such estate or part thereof is
transferred,
the
right
to
receive
maintenance may be enforced against the
transferee if the transferee has notice of the
right, or if the transfer is gratuitous; but not
against the transferee for consideration and
without notice of right.
(3) If, any senior citizen is incapable
of enforcing the rights under sub-sections
(1) and (2), action may be taken on his
behalf by any of the organisation referred to
in Explanation to sub-section (1) of section
5.”
(emphasis added)
14. Sub-section (1) of Section 23 covers all kinds
of transfers as is clear from the use of the
expression “by way of gift or otherwise”. For
attracting
sub-section
(1)
of Section
23,
the
following two conditions must be fulfilled:
(a) The transfer must have been made
subject to the condition that the transferee
shall provide the basic amenities and basic
physical needs to the transferor; and
(b) The transferee refuses or fails to provide
such amenities and physical needs to the
transferor.
If both the aforesaid conditions are satisfied, by a
legal fiction, the transfer shall be deemed to have
been made by fraud or coercion or undue
influence. Such a transfer then becomes voidable
at
the
instance
of
the
transferor
and
the
Maintenance Tribunal gets jurisdiction to declare
the transfer as void.
15. When a senior citizen parts with his or her
property by executing a gift or a release or
otherwise in favour of his or her near and dear
ones, a condition of looking after the senior citizen
is not necessarily attached to it. On the contrary,
very often, such transfers are made out of love
and affection without any expectation in return.
Therefore, when it is alleged that the conditions
mentioned in sub-section (1) of Section 23 are
attached
conditions
to
a
must
transfer,
be
existence
established
of
such
before
the
Tribunal.
16. Careful perusal of the petition under Section
23 filed by respondent no.1 shows that it is not
even pleaded that the release deed was executed
subject to a condition that the transferees (the
daughters of respondent no.1) would provide the
basic amenities and basic physical needs to
respondent no.1. Even in the impugned order
dated 22nd May 2018 passed by the Maintenance
Tribunal, no such finding has been recorded. It
seems that oral evidence was not adduced by the
parties. As can be seen from the impugned
judgment of the Tribunal, immediately after a
reply was filed by the appellant that the petition
was
fixed
for
arguments.
Effecting
transfer
subject to a condition of providing the basic
amenities and basic physical needs to the
transferor – senior citizen is sine qua non for
applicability of sub-section (1) of Section 23. In the
present case, as stated earlier, it is not even
pleaded by respondent no.1 that the release deed
was executed subject to such a condition.”
14. The decision relied upon by the appellant in the matter
of Urmila Dixit Vs. Sunil Sharan Dixit & Ors.
reported at (2025) 2 SCC 787 is not applicable in this
case in view of paragraph 3 of the judgment which is
quoted below:“3. The Appellant herein is the mother of the
Respondent (son). The subject property was
purchased by her on 23.01.1968. On 07.09.2019,
the Appellant executed a Gift Deed in favour of the
Respondent wherein it has been stated that the
donee (Respondent) maintains the donor and
makes provision for everything. This deed came to
be registered on 09.09.2019. Allegedly, on the
same day, a vachan patra / promissory note is
executed by the Respondent wherein it has been
stated that he will take care of the Appellant till
the end of her life and if he does not do so, the
Appellant will be at liberty to take back the Gift
Deed. The Respondent, before this Court, has
alleged this vachan patra to be fabricated.”
15. In the facts of the above decision, simultaneously with
the execution of the deed of gift, the donee had also
executed a ‘vachan patra’, undertaking that he would
look after the donor and if he failed to look after the
donor, then the donor would be entitled to revoke the
deed.
16. The facts are distinguishable. We are conscious of the
fact that this is a beneficial legislation and the son’s
obligation to maintain the mother is irrespective of
whether there is any deed of gift or not.
17. Under such circumstances, although we uphold the
order of the learned Single Judge upon carefully
perusing the reasons afforded, we direct that the
mother will be allowed to enter the premises and shall
continue to reside in the premises till the end of her life.
The son (respondent No. 1) will look after the mother
and maintain her with dignity and respect by providing
food, clothing, medicines and ensuring her comfort.
Further, a pocket money for an amount of Rs.2,000/shall be paid to the mother every month for her
miscellaneous expenses.
18. The police authorities will ensure that the mother is
kept in comfort and the order of this Court is complied
with.
The day the mother wants to return to the
premises, she will inform the local police station and
the Inspector-in-Charge of the local Police Station will
ensure that the mother is put in possession.
19. The order passed by the learned Single Judge is
modified accordingly.
20. We are of the view that the conditions for enforcement
of Section 23 of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents
and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 do not exist in the
particular case and the learned Trial Judge rightly held
so. The learned Trial Judge did not make any provision
for maintenance of the mother which the mother is
entitled to under the statute as also under the moral
obligation of the son.
21. We also find that the learned Presiding Officer did take
into consideration whether either of the two conditions
existed for declaring the deed partly void, i.e., to the
extent of the share of the mother. The mother’s share
has not been specifically demarcated in the deed of gift.
22. Accordingly,
the
appeal
and
the
application
disposed of.
23. There shall be no order as to costs.
24. Parties are to act on the server copy of this order.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
are
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review