Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT G WA L I O R
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ROHIT ARYA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE BINOD KUMAR DWIVEDI
FIRST APPEAL No. 1502 of 2019
BETWEEN:NITIN@ANKIT
PRAJAPATI
S/O
SHRI
SUNEEL KUMAR PRAJAPATI, AGED ABOUT
33 YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOUR R/O
BHUTA COMPOUND BHUTA GALI WARD NO.
5 TEHSIL AND DISTT BHIND (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....Appellant
(SHRI RAJESH SHUKLA -ADVOCATE)
AND
SMT. CHANDNI W/O SHRI NITIN@ ANKIT
PRAJAPATI, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS, R/O
HANUMAN CHOWK REHALI, POLICE
STATION
REHALI
DISTT.
SAGAR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(NONE FOR THE RESPONDENT DESPITE SERVICE THROUGH
PAPER PUBLICATION)
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
: 3.1.2024
Pronounced on
: 11.1.2024
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------This First Appeal having been heard and reserved for
judgment, coming on for pronouncement this day, Hon'ble Shri
Justice Binod Kumar Dwivedi pronounced the following :
JUDGMENT
1.
This First Appeal has been directed against the judgment
and decree dated 11.07.2019 passed by the Principal Judge,
Family Court, Bhind in case No.133/2008 whereby the application
under Section 13(1)(ia)(ib) and (1A)(ii) of the Hindu Marriage
Act, 1955 (hereinafter shall be referred to as “the Act”) filed by
the appellant/husband for divorce has been dismissed.
2.
It is undisputed that marriage of appellant- Nitin @ Ankit
Prajapati and respondent- Smt. Chandni was solemnized on
03.07.2014 as per Hindu customs. It is also undisputed that an
application for restitution of conjugal rights was filed by appellant
under Section 9 of the Act, which was decreed ex-parte on
29.04.2017 in case No.112/2016 directing the respondent to
resume married life with the appellant but she did not comply with
the said decree.
3.
Appellant's case, in brief, is that after marriage, he and his
family members gave full respect to his wife/respondent and he
fulfilled his duties as husband, but at the instance of her family
members from parental side, respondent did not fulfill her duties
as wife and deserting him, went away to live in her parental house.
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
Therefore, he was constrained to file an application under Section
9 of the Act vide case No.112/2016. She willfully remained absent
and did not take part in the proceedings, therefore, an ex-parte
decree was passed against her on 29.04.2017. Even after notice
(Ex.P/3) for compliance of the decree (Ex.P/2) for restitution of
conjugal rights she did not comply with it.
4.
It is also the case of the appellant that at the time of
marriage appellant's father gave some jewellery which was with
the respondent. On 17.4.2016 she went to attend the marriage
ceremenony of son of her Tau (father's elder brother) scheduled on
29.4.2016 to Gada Kota Distt. Sagar and after marriage she went
to her parental home along with her brother. There she is running a
beauty parlour and also doing work of stitching and embroidery
and earning Rs.15,000/- per month. Willfully without any
sufficient cause, she is not ready to live with the appellant. When
on 5.5.2016 appellant went to take her back, respondent's father,
who is in police, threatened to falsely implicate the appellant and
his family members. Respondent refused to accompany the
appellant.
5.
During this period when respondent/wife was with the
appellant, without any substantial cause she was creating tension
and unpleasant atmosphere in the family. Despite strenuous efforts
and advice, she did not change her attitude and behaviour, which
made it impossible to lead peaceful life with her, and therefore, the
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
appellant filed an application under Section 13(1)(ia)(ib) and (1A)
(ii) of the Act.
6.
Respondent except the admitted facts denied all the
allegations made in the application filed by the appellant. She has
further pleaded that at the time of marriage her parents had spent a
sum of Rs.7,00,000/-, despite that when she reached matrimonial
house, her in-laws used to say that as per demand Rs.2,00,000/has not been given. She was fulfilling her duties as wife, but she
was constantly harassed. She has further mentioned that on
26.4.2016 when she was in her matrimonial house, at about 8.00
p.m. appellant under the influence of liquor came, hurled filthy
abuses and had beaten her. On hearing sounds of quarrel, fatherin-law, mother-in-law and brother-in-law (Devar) also came there
and demanding Rs.2,00,000/- and brutally beating her, left her at
her parental house. Even after repeated advice, appellant and other
in-laws did not stop harassing her for demand of dowry. On
6.12.2017 respondent was again left at her parental home and
thereafter appellant did not enquire about her whereabouts.
Therefore, she lodged a report at Mahila Thana, Sagar, on which a
case under Section 498-A/34 of IPC was registered. Hence, the
application filed by the appellant deserves to be dismissed.
7.
The respondent/wife at the stage of evidence after filing of
affidavits by appellant Nitin @ Ankit, Smt. Meera, mother of the
appellant, and Smt. Geeta Saini, neighbourer of the appellant,
became absent, and therefore, ex-parte proceedings were drawn
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
against her.
8.
Framing issues on the pleadings of the parties, vide
impugned judgment dated 11.7.2019 learned trial Court dismissed
the application filed by the appellant for divorce holding that
appellant has failed to prove that respondent/wife was given
sufficient time to comply the decree of restitution of conjugal
rights (Ex.P/2). Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree,
the appellant preferred this appeal.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that despite
rigorous efforts made by the appellant, neither respondent came to
live with him nor she gave any heed to the decree of restitution of
conjugal rights passed in case No.112/2016. She did not even turn
up before this Court even after service through paper publication
as it is apparent from the order-sheet dated 23.11.2023 and
11.12.2023. Learned trial Court has failed to appreciate the
evidence adduced by the appellant and on mere conjectures and
surmises discarding the uncontroverted evidence, passed the
impugned judgment dismissing his application for divorce which
is apparently bad in law. Therefore, decree passed by the learned
trial Court may be set aside and as prayed for decree of divorce
may be passed in his favour.
10.
Heard learned counsel for the appellant at length and
perused the record.
11.
To appreciate the provisions relating to decree of divorce on
the ground of cruelty & desertion, it is befitting to reproduce
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
relevant provisions of Section 13 of the Act which reads as
under :-
13. Divorce.-(1) Any marriage solemnized, whether
before or after the commencement of this Act, may, on
a petition presented by either the husband or the wife,
be dissolved by a decree of divorce on the ground that
the other party(i) …..
(ia) has, after the solemnization of the marriage,
treated the petitioner with cruelty; or
(ib) has deserted the petitioner for a continuous
period of not less than two years immediately
preceding the presentation of the petition; or]
….......
1A) Either party to a marriage, whether solemnized
before or after the commencement of this Act, may
also present a petition for the dissolution of the
marriage by a decree of divorce on the ground(i)....
(ii) that there has been no restitution of conjugal
rights as between the parties to the marriage for a
period of one year or upwards after the passing of a
decree for restitution of conjugal rights in a
proceeding to which they were parties.”
12.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Samar Ghosh v.
Jaya Ghosh, (2007) 4 SCC 511 taking into consideration catena
of judgments on the point of cruelty has summarized the legal
position in para 101 as under :-
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
101.No uniform standard can ever be laid down for
guidance, yet we deem it appropriate to enumerate
some instances of human behaviour which may be
relevant in dealing with the cases of “mental cruelty”.
The instances indicated in the succeeding paragraphs
are only illustrative and not exhaustive:
(i) On consideration of complete matrimonial life of
the parties, acute mental pain, agony and suffering as
would not make possible for the parties to live with
each other could come within the broad parameters of
mental cruelty.
(ii) On comprehensive appraisal of the entire
matrimonial life of the parties, it becomes abundantly
clear that situation is such that the wronged party
cannot reasonably be asked to put up with such
conduct and continue to live with other party.
(iii) Mere coldness or lack of affection cannot amount
to cruelty, frequent rudeness of language, petulance of
manner, indifference and neglect may reach such a
degree that it makes the married life for the other
spouse absolutely intolerable.
(iv) Mental cruelty is a state of mind. The feeling of
deep anguish, disappointment, frustration in one
spouse caused by the conduct of other for a long time
may lead to mental cruelty.
(v) A sustained course of abusive and humiliating
treatment calculated to torture, discommode or render
miserable life of the spouse.
(vi) Sustained unjustifiable conduct and behaviour of
one spouse actually affecting physical and mental
health of the other spouse. The treatment complained
of and the resultant danger or apprehension must be
very grave, substantial and weighty.
(vii) Sustained reprehensible conduct, studied
neglect, indifference or total departure from the
normal standard of conjugal kindness causing injury
to mental health or deriving sadistic pleasure can also
amount to mental cruelty.
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
(viii) The conduct must be much more than jealousy,
selfishness,
possessiveness,
which
causes
unhappiness and dissatisfaction and emotional upset
may not be a ground for grant of divorce on the
ground of mental cruelty.
(ix) Mere trivial irritations, quarrels, normal wear and
tear of the married life which happens in day-to-day
life would not be adequate for grant of divorce on the
ground of mental cruelty.
(x) The married life should be reviewed as a whole
and a few isolated instances over a period of years
will not amount to cruelty. The ill conduct must be
persistent for a fairly lengthy period, where the
relationship has deteriorated to an extent that because
of the acts and behaviour of a spouse, the wronged
party finds it extremely difficult to live with the other
party any longer, may amount to mental cruelty.
(xi) If a husband submits himself for an operation of
sterilisation without medical reasons and without the
consent or knowledge of his wife and similarly, if the
wife undergoes vasectomy or abortion without
medical reason or without the consent or knowledge
of her husband, such an act of the spouse may lead to
mental cruelty.
(xii) Unilateral decision of refusal to have
intercourse for considerable period without there
being any physical incapacity or valid reason may
amount to mental cruelty.
(xiii) Unilateral decision of either husband or wife
after marriage not to have child from the marriage
may amount to cruelty.
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
(xiv) Where there has been a long period of
continuous separation, it may fairly be concluded
that the matrimonial bond is beyond repair. The
marriage becomes a fiction though supported by a
legal tie. By refusing to sever that tie, the law in such
cases, does not serve the sanctity of marriage; on the
contrary, it shows scant regard for the feelings and
emotions of the parties. In such like situations, it may
lead to mental cruelty.
13.
Now we will delve into merits of the case in the light of
above legal provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act and meaning of
cruelty as detailed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of
Samar
Ghosh (supra). It is undisputed that appellant and
respondent are husband and wife. On desertion by the
respondent/wife, appellant filed an application under Section 9 of
the Act for restitution of conjugal rights which was decreed vide
judgment dated 29.4.2017 (Ex.P/1). The decree passed therein is
on record as Ex.P/2. The notice for compliance of the above
decree was issued to the respondent on 10.5.2018 which is on
record as Ex.P/3. Postal receipt through which the notice was sent
is on record as Ex.P/4 and service report thereon is on record as
Ex.P/5. The above documents have been proved by appellantNitin @ Ankit (AW-1) in his statement. The appellant has
specifically stated in his statement that he has no physical relations
with the respondent since 29th April, 2016. The respondent has
deserted him without any sufficient reason.
14.
Meera (AW-2), the mother of the appellant, has also given
evidence under Order 18 Rule 4 CPC which supports the
statement of the appellant. Similarly, neighbourer of the appellant
Smt. Geeta Saini (AW-3) has also supported the case of the
appellant. The respondent did not care to come before the Court
and challenged the oral and documentary evidence adduced by the
appellant and his witnesses.
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
15.
Uncontroverted testimony of the appellant and his witnesses
alongwith documentary evidence was supposed to be given due
weightage, but learned trial Court without assigning any cogent
reason, has discarded the oral and documentary evidence adduced
by the appellant which is against the established principles of civil
law. Finding of learned trial Court in para 13 of the impugned
judgment that appellant has failed to prove that respondent was
given sufficient time to comply with the decree of restitution of
conjugal rights (Ex.P/2) is erroneous in view of the law laid down
by the Apex Court in the case of Samar Ghosh (supra) and the
provisions of Section 13 of the Act. Even if for the sake of
arguments we accept the finding of learned trial Court that at the
time of filing of the application under Section 13 of the Act,
respondent was not given sufficient time to comply with the
decree of restitution of conjugal rights, but on the date of passing
of the impugned judgment on 11.7.2019 more than one year's time
has elapsed from the date of service of notice i.e. 15.5.2018 for
compliance of decree of restitution of conjugal rights. The
respondent did not bother to appear before the trial Court during
the proceedings under Section 13 of the Act nor she appeared
before this Court during pendency of this appeal despite service
through paper publication. Thus, by way of oral and documentary
evidence on preponderance of probability, appellant has made out
a case for decree of divorce on the ground of cruelty and desertion.
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
16.
Accordingly, decree passed by the learned trial Court is
hereby set aside and decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(ia)(ib)
and (1A)(ii) of the Act is passed in favour of the appellant. Decree
be drawn accordingly.
17.
In absence of respondent/wife and any material available
before this Court, the issue of permanent alimony/maintenance is
not gone into at present. However, this order will not come in the
way of the wife to file appropriate application under Section 25 of
the Act before the Court of competent jurisdiction and that Court
would be best suited to decide the said prayer for permanent
alimony.
With the aforesaid, this appeal stands disposed of.
(Rohit Arya)
Judge
ms/-
Signed by: MADHU
SOODAN PRASAD
Signing time: 12-01-2024
10:25:52 AM
(Binod Kumar Dwivedi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review