The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. When the above was pointed out to the appellants during the course of hearing, they filed an application as 1/2025 on the adjourned date of hearing, seeking leave to amend the Original Petition to incorporate a prayer for recovery of past maintenance for a period of three years and also for future Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019 2025:KER:30105 -: 8 :- maintenance. The Original Petition is of the year 2012, and this appeal is of the year 2018. For all these years there had been no claim for maintenance. Respondents 2 to 4 assigned the property to respondents 5 and 6. They mortgaged the property in favour of the additional respondent Co-operative Bank. The Bank obtained an award in ARC proceedings and as of now the amounts due is more than ₹ 3.25 Crores. We do not think that at this distance of time the petitioners are to be permitted to amend the original petition to incorporate a relief claiming maintenance. The application is liable to be dismissed.
12. With regard to the claim based on Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act, we do notice that proper issues with regard to, the entitlement of the petitioners for maintenance, as to whether Exts.A1 to A3 Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019 2025:KER:30105 -: 9 :- Sale Deeds were for valid consideration and without notice of the right of the petitioners, etc. were not raised. The Court on finding that some amounts have been credited into the account of the deceased on or near the date of Exts. A1 to A3 Sale Deeds, held that the transactions are supported by consideration. Apart from the fact that there has not been proper consideration of the said aspect, the other ingredients of Section 39 were not considered at all. Hence the finding of the Family Court on the claim under Section 39 is liable to be set aside and we do so.
13. However, having found that the claim for a mere declaration of maintainable, dismissed. charge over the property is the Original Petition Hence, though for varying only is to reason, not be the dismissal of the Original Petition by the Family Court Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019 2025:KER:30105 -: 10 :- warrants no interference. Resultantly, the appeal fails and is dismissed. No costs. Sd/SATHISH NINAN Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN kns///True Copy// P.S. To Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30105
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 815 OF 2019
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 30.07.2019 IN OP NO.1542 OF 2012
OF FAMILY COURT, IRINJALAKUDA
----APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
NIRMALA CHERIYAN,
AGED 48 YEARS,
D/O. KUNNIYIL CHERIYAN, MARILAND DESOM,
KADANAD VILLAGE, MEENACHIL TALUK AND
W/O. SREEKUMAR MENON, ANIYIL HOUSE,
THAZHEKKAD VILLAGE AND DESOM, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK,
NOW RESIDING AT ERRA 33, ELAVUNGAL ROAD,
PALARIVATTOM, PIN 682 525.
SOORAJ SREEKUMAR,
AGED 18 YEARS,
S/O.SREEKUMAR MENON, ANIYIL HOUSE,
THAZHEKKAD VILLAGE AND DESOM, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK,
NOW RESIDING AT ERRA 33, ELAVUNGAL ROAD,
PALARIVATTOM, PIN 682 525.
BY ADVS.
K.S.BHARATHAN
SRI.ABEL ANTONY
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
SUNIL,
AGED 48 YEARS,
S/O. MADAMBIKKATTIL SOMAN, PAMBOOR DESOM,
KOLAZHI VILLAGE, THRISSUR TALUK, PIN-680 002.
2025:KER:30105
MAT.APPEAL NO. 815 OF 2019
-2-
SHINE,
S/O. CHANDRASESHAN, ARUNPULLY HOUSE, EDATHIRINJI
VILLAGE AND DESOM, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK,
THRISSUR-680 733.
SUBHASH,
AGED 47 YEARS,
S/O. BAHULEYAN, MUNDAKKAL HOUSE, MURIYAD VILLAGE,
MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK, THRISSUR-680 733.
JOHNSON,
AGED 54 YEARS,
S/O. YACOB, PULLOKKARAN HOUSE, MURIYAD VILLAGE AND
DESOM, MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK, THRISSUR-680 733.
MAGI PAUL,
AGED 33 YEARS,
W/O. CHERATTA PAUL, MUPLIYAM VILLAGE AND DESOM,
MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK, THRISSUR 680 733.
* ADDL. RESPONDENT NO.6
ADDL.R6
MURIYAD SERVICE CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD. NO 479,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MURIYAD. P.O, THRISSUR,
PIN – 680 683.
*[ADDITIONAL 6TH RESPONDENT IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER
DATED 3/8/2022 IN IA 1/2022]
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.V.GEORGE (PUTHIYADOM)
T.N.MANOJ
G.P.SHINOD
AJIT G ANJARLEKAR
GOVIND PADMANAABHAN
ATUL MATHEWS
THIS
MATRIMONIAL
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
08.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:30105
SATHISH NINAN &
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Dated this the 8th day of April, 2025
J U D G M E N T
Sathish Ninan, J.
The appellants, who are the petitioners before the
Family Court, are the wife and the son. The first
respondent is the husband/father. The other respondents
are
the
assignees
of
properties
under
the
first
respondent-husband.
The
Original
Petition
was
filed
seeking to set aside Exts.A1 to A3 Sale Deeds. The
Original Petition was dismissed by the Family Court.
2.
According
to
the
petitioners,
the
first
respondent-husband is a drunkard and did not allow a
peaceful life of the petitioners. He is addicted to
alcohol. The petitioners are residing separately since
2008-09. The plaint schedule properties belong to the
first respondent. The petitioners have a charge over the
same towards their maintenance. Respondents 2 to 5 and
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 2 :-
the
husband
of
the
sixth
respondent
claimed
to
be
friends of the first respondent and aided and influenced
the
first
respondent
to
alcohol
addiction.
He
was
treated at various hospitals. By exerting fraud and
undue influence, respondents 2 to 4 got the plaint
schedule
Exts.A1
property
to
A3
conveyed
Sale
Deeds.
in
their
favour,
The
sale
deeds
under
are
not
supported by consideration. They have been got executed
taking undue advantage of the fiduciary relationship
with the first respondent. The petitioners have charge
over the property for their maintenance. The conveyances
have
been
executed
to
defeat
the
right
of
the
petitioners. With the above allegations the Original
Petition was filed seeking to set aside Exts.A1 to A3
Sale Deeds.
3. The first respondent died pending the Original
Petition. The other respondents denied the allegations
levelled.
They
denied
of
having
aided
the
first
respondent in his liquor addiction etc. The allegations
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 3 :-
of
fiduciary
denied.
It
relationship
was
contended
and
undue
influence
were
that
the
sale
are
deeds
supported by valid consideration. It was also contended
that after Exts.A1 to A3 conveyance the first respondent
had purchased another property having an extent of 5
cents with a residential house thereon which, on his
death, has devolved on the petitioners.
4. The Family Court held that the allegations of
fiduciary
relationship,
undue
influence
and
lack
of
consideration for Exts.A1 to A3 Sale Deeds were not
proved. It was also held that the petitioners are not
entitled for a charge over the property under Section 27
of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act. The claim for
charge under Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act
was also declined.
5. We have heard the learned counsel on either
side.
6. With regard to the challenge against Exts.A1 to
A3 Sale Deeds on the ground of it being vitiated by
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 4 :-
fraud, undue influence etc., as was noticed, the Family
Court has negatived the challenge based on evidence. The
learned counsel for the appellant concedes that the
evidence is not sufficient enough to contend otherwise
before this Court. So also he concedes on the finding of
the Family Court declining charge under Section 27 of
the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act.
7. The only point urged by the appellant before
this Court is based on Section 39 of the Transfer of
Property Act. The wife is entitled for maintenance from
her husband. The alienation under Exts.A1 to A3 cannot
affect her right of maintenance. In terms of Section 39,
the wife is entitled to proceed against the properties
of the husband, which could even be traced to the hands
of a purchaser with notice, he contends. To fortify his
contention that there need not even be a decree for
maintenance to attract Section 39, but a right to claim
maintenance is sufficient, the learned counsel relied on
the judgments in Vaddeboyina Tulasamma v. Vaddeboyina Sesha Reddi (1977
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 5 :KHC 820), Divakaran v. Chellamma (1985 KHC 225), Raghavan and another v.
Nagammal and another (1979 KHC 1710).
Hence, the alienations
under Exts.A1 to A3 are subject to the charge for
maintenance of the petitioners, is the contention.
8. The relief claimed in the original petition
reads thus :“A) കല റ കര സബ രജസ 2012-ൽ 1110, 3031, 2942 എന ആധ രങൾ ഹർജ പടക
വഹകൾല ഹർജ രട ചലവന ക ടവ നള അവക ശതലന ബ ധകമ എന കണ
ആയത റദ യ .
B)
ഈ വ2വഹ രതട3 സകല ലക ത ടചലവകള എതകക ലയ
തരവ ൻ കലച .
ഹർജ
ർ
C) വ2വഹ രമല;2 ഹർജ
ർ അലപക കനത ലക ത യകടമന ലത നനതമ യ
ന വർതകൾ അനവദ ച ഒര വധ ഉണ കവ ൻ വണ മ യ അലപക കന.”
The petitioners seek to set aside the sale deeds on
entering a finding that it cannot affect their right of
maintenance. Section 39 of the Transfer of Property Act
reads thus :“39. Transfer where third person is entitled to maintenance.—Where a
third person has a right to receive maintenance, or a provision for
advancement or marriage, from the profits of immovable property, and
such property is transferred, the right may be enforced against the
transferee, if he has notice or if the transfer is gratuitous; but not against
a transferee for consideration and without notice of the right, nor against
such property in his hands.”
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 6 :-
Evidently,
even
if
the
petitioners
have
right
to
maintenance, the conveyances under Exts.A1 to A3 does
not become void or voidable rendering them liable to be
set aside. Therefore, the prayer sought could not, at
any rate, be granted. Even the learned counsel for the
appellant would not contend otherwise.
9. The learned counsel for the appellant would
argue that, the Court can very well mould the relief and
grant a declaration that the petitioners have charge
over the property for their maintenance and that Exts.A1
to A3 conveyances are subjected to the said charge.
10. It is important to note that, the Original
Petition does not contain a prayer for recovery of
maintenance. If the relief sought is considered as one
for
declaration
of
charge
over
the
property
for
maintenance, such a prayer for a mere declaration is not
maintainable in terms of the proviso to Section 34 of
the Specific Relief Act. Section 34 reads thus:
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 7 :Discretion of court as to declaration of status or right :Any person entitled to any legal character, or to any right as to any property, may
institute a suit against any person denying, or interested to deny, his title to such
character or right, and the court may in its discretion make therein a declaration
that he is so entitled, and the plaintiff need not in such suit ask for any further relief:
Provided that no court shall make any such declaration where the plaintiff, being
able to seek further relief than a mere declaration of title, omits to do so.
Explanation.-A trustee of property is a "person interested to deny" a title adverse
to the title of some one who is not in existence, and for whom, if in existence, he
would be a trustee.
The proviso obliges the petitioners to seek for the
further relief of recovery of maintenance. The mere suit
for declaration of charge over the property could not be
maintained.
11.
When
the
above
was
pointed
out
to
the
appellants during the course of hearing, they filed an
application
as
IA
1/2025
on
the
adjourned
date
of
hearing, seeking leave to amend the Original Petition to
incorporate a prayer for recovery of past maintenance
for
a
period
of
three
years
and
also
for
future
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 8 :-
maintenance. The Original Petition is of the year 2012,
and this appeal is of the year 2018. For all these years
there had been no claim for maintenance. Respondents 2
to 4 assigned the property to respondents 5 and 6. They
mortgaged
the
property
in
favour
of
the
additional
respondent Co-operative Bank. The Bank obtained an award
in ARC proceedings and as of now the amounts due is more
than ₹ 3.25 Crores. We do not think that at this
distance of time the petitioners are to be permitted to
amend the original petition to incorporate a relief
claiming maintenance. The application is liable to be
dismissed.
12. With regard to the claim based on Section 39 of
the Transfer of Property Act, we do notice that proper
issues
with
regard
to,
the
entitlement
of
the
petitioners for maintenance, as to whether Exts.A1 to A3
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 9 :-
Sale Deeds were for valid consideration and without
notice of the right of the petitioners, etc. were not
raised. The Court on finding that some amounts have been
credited into the account of the deceased on or near the
date of Exts. A1 to A3 Sale Deeds, held that the
transactions are supported by consideration. Apart from
the fact that there has not been proper consideration of
the said aspect, the other ingredients of Section 39
were not considered at all. Hence the finding of the
Family Court on the claim under Section 39 is liable to
be set aside and we do so.
13. However, having found that the claim for a mere
declaration
of
maintainable,
dismissed.
charge
over
the
property
is
the
Original
Petition
Hence,
though
for
varying
only
is
to
reason,
not
be
the
dismissal of the Original Petition by the Family Court
Mat. Appeal No.815 of 2019
2025:KER:30105
-: 10 :-
warrants no interference.
Resultantly, the appeal fails and is dismissed. No
costs.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
kns///True Copy//
P.S. To Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review