The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. 05.2018 [Annexure 2 to the writ petition] that all the petitioners were made the permanent labourers on 01.10.2014. It has been further contended that the petitioners filed three separate writ petitions being WP(C) No. 1377/2019 (Smt. Laxmi Rani Das vs. The State of Tripura & Ors.), WP(C) No. 1379/2019 (Sri Nirmal Malakar vs. The State of Tripura & Ors) and WP(C) No. 1380/2019 (Smt. Anima Nath vs. The State of Tripura & Ors.). Those writ petitions along with WP(C) No. 1378/2019 (Sri Jogesh Sabdakar vs. The State of Tripura & Ors.) were disposed of by the common order dated 27.02.2020. By the said common order dated 27.02.2020, it had been observed that a fresh tentative seniority list will be published, the petitioners will have a right to object, if according to the petitioners their position is not correctly reflected in such list. It may be noted that the memorandum dated 15.10.2014 [Annexure 8 to the writ petition], the petitioners were declared permanent labourer in terms of the notification dated 10.09.2007 w.e.f. 01.10.2014. By the memorandum dated 12.06.2020 [Annexure – 9 to the writ petition], a tentative seniority list of the permanent labourers were published by the Department of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare. In terms of the order dated 27.02.2020, passed in a batch of writ petitions by this court, it would be apparent that the said tentative seniority list was publ…
01. 01.2007. Surprisingly, the petitioners have not mentioned about it. Even the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 who filed a joint counter affidavit has stated as under: “10. That , in reply to averments and/ or contentions made in paragraph – 5 of the writ petition, it is stated that Agriculture Department implemented the Permanent Labourers Rules in the year 1983 and on the basis of that 1389 Nos. of Daily Rated Workers (DRWs) had been absorbed to the post of Permanent Labourers, subsequently, in different phases absorption to the Post of Permanent Labourers is still going on. As 1389 Nos. of Permanent Labourers were serving under the Agriculture Department for long time, therefore, Deptt. has felt the necessity to provide them minimum relief in the form of regular employment, and as such Department initiated a proposal for creation of Group – D posts to the Finance Department and Finance Department agreed to concur the creation of 400 Nos. of new posts in the rank of “Farm Worker” (Group – D Category). Subsequently several concurrences were given by the Finance Department and till date total 3115 Nos. Permanent Labourers has already been appointed to the Post of Farm Worker in 5(five) phases on the condition that the posts will be abolished immediately after retirement of the concerned Farm Worker. As all the Permanent Labourers of Agriculture Department have been rendering their ser…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No. 775 of 2021
1. Sri Nirmal Malakar,
son of late Niranjan Malakar,
resident of Panisagar,
P.O. Panisagar, P.S. Panisagar,
North Tripura
PIN: 799 260
2. Smt. Anima Nath,
wife of late Subodh Nath,
resident of Panisagar,
P.O. Panisagar, P.S. Panisagar,
North Tripura
PIN: 799 260
3. Smt. Laxmi Rani Das,
wife of late Sushil Chandra Das,
resident of Panisagar,
P.O. Panisagar, P.S. Panisagar,
North Tripura
PIN: 799 260
---- Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented by its
Principal Secretary,
Department of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare,
Government of Tripura,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
District: West Tripura,
PIN: 799 006
2. The Director of Agriculture,
Department of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare,
Govt. of Tripura,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura, PIN: 799 001
3. The Principal Secretary,
Finance Department,
Government of Tripura,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
District: West Tripura, PIN: 799 006
---- Respondent(s)
4. Smt. Sukla Nath
W/0 - Unknown
5. Sri Pranoy Kumar Das,
S/O – Unknown.
6. Sri Suman Kumar Dey,
S/O- Unknown.
7. Smt. Prasanta Das,
W/O- Unknown.
---- Pro-Forma Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Adv.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Whether fit for
reporting
:
No.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Judgment & Order (Oral)
28.02.2022
Heard Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. D Sharma, learned Addl. G.A appearing for the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 3. Also heard Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent No. 6, a private respondent.
Despite due notice, for the respondents No. 4, 5 & 7, there is no
representation. It may be noted further that the respondents No. 4, 5
& 7 had refused to accept the notice of the court and hence, by the
order dated 11.02.2022. This court has observed that for refusal, the
service on the respondents No. 4, 5 & 7 be deemed to have been
complete.
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
has stated that the petitioners are engaged as casual labourers under
the respondent No. 2.
The petitioner No. 1, Sri Nirmal Malakar, was initially engaged
as the casual
labourer on 21.05.2000. The petitioner No. 2,
Smt. Anima Nath, was engaged as casual labourer on 21.03.2000 and
the petitioner No. 3, Smt. Laxmi Rani Das, was engaged as casual
labourer on 21.03.2000. According to the petitioners, the respondents
No. 4, 5, 6 and 7 were also engaged as casual labourers on diverse
dates i.e. on 05.12.2001 (Smt. Sukla Nath, the respondent No. 4),
19.04.2003
(Sri
Pranoy
Kumar
Das,
the
respondent
No.
5),
04.10.2004 (Sri Suman Kumar Dey, the respondent No. 6) and
01.09.2021 (Smt. Prasanta Das, the respondent No. 7).
The petitioner has averred that even though the petitioners are
seniors in the position of casual labourers, but those respondents were
engaged as the permanent labourer w.e.f. 01.01.2007. But the
petitioners were not made the permanent labourers. In this regard,
the petitioners have placed reliance on the memorandum dated
11.05.2018 [Annexure - 2 to the writ petition] wherefrom it can be
gathered that the petitioners No. 1, 2 and 3 were appointed as the
casual
labourers
respectively.
It
on
21.05.2000,
further
appears
21.03.2000
from
the
and
21.03.2000
memorandum
dated
11.05.2018 [Annexure 2 to the writ petition] that all the petitioners
were made the permanent labourers on 01.10.2014.
It has been further contended that the petitioners filed three
separate writ petitions being WP(C) No. 1377/2019 (Smt. Laxmi Rani
Das vs. The State of Tripura & Ors.), WP(C) No.
1379/2019 (Sri
Nirmal Malakar vs. The State of Tripura & Ors) and WP(C) No.
1380/2019 (Smt. Anima Nath vs. The State of Tripura & Ors.). Those
writ petitions along with WP(C) No. 1378/2019 (Sri Jogesh Sabdakar
vs. The State of Tripura & Ors.) were disposed of by the common
order dated 27.02.2020.
By the said common order dated 27.02.2020, it had been
observed that a fresh tentative seniority list will be published, the
petitioners will have a right to object, if according to the petitioners
their position is not correctly reflected in such list. It may be noted
that the memorandum dated 15.10.2014 [Annexure 8 to the writ
petition], the petitioners were declared permanent labourer in terms
of the notification dated 10.09.2007 w.e.f. 01.10.2014. By the
memorandum dated 12.06.2020 [Annexure – 9 to the writ petition], a
tentative seniority list of the permanent labourers were published by
the Department of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare. In terms of the
order dated 27.02.2020, passed in a batch of writ petitions by this
court, it would be apparent that the said tentative seniority list was
published. The petitioners have been shown engaged as permanent
labourers w.e.f. 01.01.2007 in the said tentative seniority list. But for
this purpose, the petitioners could not produce any office order or
memorandum. Even the respondent did come forward to show the
basis of such entry in the said seniority list.
The petitioners have placed their reliance on a decision of this
court (in the order dated 03.02.2021 delivered in WP(C) No. 297 of
2020)
where
this
court
has
observed
that
in
terms
of
the
memorandum dated 12.08.2014, the petitioners are entitled to be
absorbed or appointed as the Farm Worker on completion of 15 years
of service, including the service they have rendered as casual
workers/ daily rated workers, etc., subject to the condition that they
had to complete 7 years of service as the permanent labourer for
being the Farm Workers. For purpose of reference, the text of the said
memorandum dated 12.08.2017 is reproduced hereunder:
“No. F. 10(2)-FIN(G)/2008(PART)
Government of Tripura
Finance Department
Dated, Agartala the 12th August, 2014
MEMORANDUM
Sub-Reduction of minimum length of service required for
regularization of Permanent Labourer in the post of Farm Worker
from existing 10(ten) years to 7(seven) years.
Some Departmental engaged Casual Workers, Daily Rated
Workers in the past as per existing circular of the State
Government, such workers have to be absorbed a permanent
labourers before regularizing them as Farm Workers after 10(ten)
years of continuous service. But it is seen that a large number of
such workers have already serve more than 10(ten) years of
service before absorption as Permanent Labourers. Therefore such
workers shall have to wait for another 10(ten) long years for
getting their service regularized as Farm Worker which may
ultimately hamper pensioner benefits.
In view of the above mentioned facts, it has been decided to
prescribe the minimum length of service as Permanent labourer
form the existing 10(ten) years to 7(seven) year for eligibility to be
absorbed as Farm Workers, provided a Permanent Labourer
should complete total service of at least 15 years including the
service length as Casual Workers, Daily Rated Workers etc. and
subject to the condition that after regularization as Farm Workers,
such workers shall continue to do the same job in addition to any
other job given by the Controlling Officer and the said posts from
which such Farm Workers were inducted shall stand abolished.
The concerned Department may approach the Council of
Ministers with comprehensive proposals for regularization of such
permanent Labourers who had served minimum period of 15 years
including the service period as Casual Workers or Daily Rated
Workers of which at least 7(seven) years service length should be
as Permanent Labourers.
Sd/- illegible
(M. Sengupta)
Under Secretary to the
Government of Tripura
[Emphasis added]”
Thus, the petitioner has urged this court to treat them as the
permanent labourers w.e.f. 01.01.2007 and to regularize them as
farm workers on completion of 7 years of service as the permanent
labourers counting from 01.01.2007 and also on completion of 15
years of total service including the service of the casual labourers/
daily rated workers.
Mr. Bhowmik learned counsel has submitted that in terms of
the memorandum dated 12.08.2014, the Government of Tripura had
adopted a policy to absorb permanent labourers as farm workers after
10 years of continuous service.
But, by the said memorandum dated 12.08.2014, the said
policy was modified by reducing the years of service as permanent
labourer for absorption as the farm worker. 10 years’ tenure has been
reduced to the tenure of 7 years. But as stated, one permanent
labourer can only be regularized as the farm worker after completion
of service minimum for a period of 15 years including the service
rendered as the casual labourer/ daily rated worker.
Mr. Bhowmik learned counsel has submitted that from the
memorandum dated 12.06.2020, it will be further apparent that the
petitioners’ names appear at Sl. No. 4, 6 and 8, in the column under
heading ‘Date of engagement as P.L’. It has recorded in the column
that all the petitioners were engaged as permanent labourer on
01.01.2007. Surprisingly, the petitioners have not mentioned about it.
Even the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 who filed a joint counter affidavit
has stated as under:
“10. That , in reply to averments and/ or contentions made in
paragraph – 5 of the writ petition, it is stated that Agriculture
Department implemented the Permanent Labourers Rules in
the year 1983 and on the basis of that 1389 Nos. of Daily Rated
Workers (DRWs) had been absorbed to the post of Permanent
Labourers, subsequently, in different phases absorption to the
Post of Permanent Labourers is still going on. As 1389 Nos. of
Permanent Labourers were serving under the Agriculture
Department for long time, therefore, Deptt. has felt the
necessity to provide them minimum relief in the form of regular
employment, and as such Department initiated a proposal for
creation of Group – D posts to the Finance Department and
Finance Department agreed to concur the creation of 400 Nos.
of new posts in the rank of “Farm Worker” (Group – D
Category). Subsequently several concurrences were given by
the Finance Department and till date total 3115 Nos.
Permanent Labourers has already been appointed to the Post of
Farm Worker in 5(five) phases on the condition that the posts
will be abolished immediately after retirement of the concerned
Farm Worker. As all the Permanent Labourers of Agriculture
Department have been rendering their services for a long time
satisfactorily and for the benefit of the cultivators of Tripura,
relaxation is required for the proposed Farm Workers in respect
of age of those whose date of birth is on 02.12.1947 onwards
and withdrawing any kind of bar of qualification to make them
eligible for providing appointment to the post of Farm Worker.
The age bar for the candidate for the post of Farm Worker is
minimum 18 years and maximum 40 years, relaxable 5(five)
years for ST/SC candidates. And minimum educational
qualification for the post of Group – D (Farm Worker) is Class
VIII Pass, relaxable upto Class –V Pass for ST/SC Candidates.
Regularization of Permanent Labourers to the post of Farm
Worker has been considered on the basis of the final Seniority
list of Permanent Labourers. Senior most Permanent Labourer
who fulfills the required criteria becomes eligible for the same.
In the instant case the Tentative Seniority List of Permanent
Labourers was published on 24-06-2014. After publication of
the Tentative Seniority List, one Md. Kazi Muslem Miah raised
some objection and filed a Writ Petition before the Hon’ble high
Court, Tripura vide No. W.P.(C) 02 of 2015 for quashing all
orders related to seniority list and requested the Department
not to publish the Final Seniority List till disposal of the Writ
Petition. The Hon’ble High court allowed the Writ Petition and
passed the Judgment on 13.07.2017.
Apart from that, the above 4(four) Nos. permanent Labourers
also filed Writ Petition on the same issue before the Hon’ble
High Court of Tripura and vide a common order and judgment
dated 27.02.2020 against Writ Petition No. 1377, 1378, 1379 &
1380 of 2019, the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura passed an
order directing the Competent Authority to consider the
petitioners representations against the tentative seniority
position. After that, removing all objections, the Final Seniority
list was published.
The file was moved to the Finance Department for obtaining
concurrence to regularize 20 Nos. senior most eligible
Permanent Labourers out of total 73 Nos. who fulfill the criteria
as on the date of initiation of the proposal as Farm Worker, but
due to administrative and other reasons the matter was
delayed. By this time 7 (seven) Nos. Permanent Labourer has
also become eligible to be regularized to the post of Farm
Worker raising total No. 27 and total No. of Permanent
Labourers also reduced at 68 due to retirement/ death/
termination etc. The Finance Department returned the file with
a direction to furnish the approval from the Council of Ministers
for one time relaxation of educational qualification/age etc. of
the eligible Permanent Labourers.
On receiving direction from the Finance Department a proposal
for regularization of 27 (Twenty Seven) Nos. permanent
Labourers to the post of Farm Workers “Group – D” in the Pay
Level – 1 of Tripura State Pay Matrix – 2018 was initiated and
placed before the Government to place the matter before the
Council of Ministers for consideration. The names of the
Petitioners Sri Nirmal Malakar, Smt. Anima Nath and Smt.
Laxmi Rani Das are enlisted in the list of eligible candidates at
Sl. No. 08, 06 & 04 respectively.
(A copy of the List of Permanent Labourers are annexed and
marked as Annexure R/1)
Meantime, 3(three) Nos. Permanent Labourers approached
before the Hon’ble High Court, Tripura and filed writ petition
vide No. 154, 155 and 156 of 2021 for regularization of their
service as farm worker. By a common order dated, 29.07.2021,
the Hon’ble High Court, Tripura directed to absorb the
petitioners in the post of Farm Worker within in 2(two)
months.
Thereafter, views from the Law Department was taken and
further, the Addl. government Advocate advised to approach
the Cabinet Secretary for early placement of the matter before
the Council of Ministers for their decision as per order dated
03.02.2021 against W.P(C) No. 296 of 2020 passed by the
Hon’ble High Court of Tripura. Accordingly, “Memorandum for
the Council of Ministers” for regularization of 23 Nos.
Permanent Labourer has again prepared and placed the file
before the Government, from there the file was endorsed to the
Finance Department for their concurrence. The Finance
Department requested to indicate the additional financial
implication per annum connected with the proposal for
regularization of 23 nos. Permanent Labourer to the post of
Farm Worker.
Accordingly, a detail statement in respect of additional financial
implication in the event of regularization of 23 Nos. Permanent
Labourer to the post of Farm Worker has been prepared and
placed before the Finance Department vide file No. 2 (637)Agri./Estt./2013-14/Part-III and views of the Finance
Department was yet to receive. [Emphasis added]”
The crux of the reply filed by the respondents No. 1 and 3 is
that the department is not averse to regularize the petitioner as the
farm worker. For this purpose the steps have been taken. The Finance
Department, Government of Tripura has been approached but the
views of the Finance Department are awaited.
The respondents have given the list of those 27 permanent
labourers who are being considered for absorption. Those names have
been catalogued in the form of Annexure - R1. The names of the
petitioners appear in the said list at Sl. No. 4, 6 and 8.
Since the respondents have prepared the list of 27 permanent
labourers under the Department of Agriculture as eligible for the post
of farm worker after their completion of 15 years of service as DRW
and permanent labourer (at least 7 years).
Now their eligibility for
absorption as the farm worker cannot ordinarily be questioned. It has
been stated by the respondents that the file for such absorption is
lying in the Finance Department.
Be that as it may, the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 are directed
to complete the process of absorption of the petitioners whose names
are reflected in the list of 27 permanent labourers, Annexure – R1 to
the reply filed by the respondent No. 1 and 2 having considered the
date of declaration as the permanent labourer on 01.01.2007, the
date when the similarly circumstanced casual labourers who were
engaged after the petitioners were declared the permanent labourer.
Even the respondents have reflected the said date as the date of
declaration as the permanent labourers (for the petitioners) in the
tentative seniority list. But no arrears of wages will be entitled for
inordinate delay as occurred in filling the writ petition.
It is not in dispute that the petitioners have completed the
requisite years of service as daily rated worker/ casual labourer
(08 years or more) and as permanent labourers (minimum 07 years).
The said exercise of absorption of the petitioner as farm
workers shall be completed by the respondents No. 1, 2 & 3 within a
period of 3 (three) months invariably from the day when the
petitioners shall furnish a copy of this order to the respondent No. 2.
The
respondents
shall
also
consider
to
engage
them
retrospectively as the petitioners were eligible for consideration for
appointment as farm worker since 2015.
In terms of the above, this writ petition stands disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Munna S
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review