Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
SHOUGRA Digitally signed by
SHOUGRAKPAM
KPAM
DEVANANDA
DEVANAN SINGH
Date: 2023.01.10
DA SINGH 13:57:11 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
1. Ningombam Dineshor Singh, aged about 44 yeas, S/o (L)
Nongthombam Ibobi Singh of Kongba Makha Nandeibam Leikai,
Singjamei, Imphal East District, Manipur-795008;
2. Kshetrimayum Surjit Singh, aged about 43 years, S/o (l) Ksh.
Ibotombi Singh of Uchekon Khunou Keirao Bitra, Imphal East
District, Manipur – 795008;
3. Ferdinand Gangmei, aged about 37 years, S/o (L) Gailenglung
Gangmei of Dimdaijang Thangmeiband, P.O. & P.S. Lamphel,
Imphal West District, Manipur – 795004;
4. Pathan Surfaraz, aged about 34 years, S/o (L) Md. Belal Shah of
Minuthong Golapati, Imphal East District, Manipur – 795005;
5. Luwang Pheiroijam Priyobarta, aged about 35 years, S/o (L)
Pheiroijam Birendra Singh of Kongpal Khongkham Leikai, Imphal
East District, Manipur – 795005;
6. Tongbram Priya Devi, aged about 46 years, D/o Tongbram
Nutankuma Singh of Sagolband Kongabam Leikai, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795001;
7. Thoudam Sophia, aged about 32 years, D/o (L) Th. Rajen Singh
of Khurai Thoudam Leikai, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795010;
8. Dearri Sinruwng, aged about 32 years, D/o (L) Becheng
Sinruwng, Tampi Village, Tampi, Chakpikarong, Chandel District,
Manipur – 795102;
9. L. Lhingboi Haokip, aged about 43 years, D/o Paokhoneh Kuki of
Old Lambulane Jail Road, Imphal West District, Manipur -795001;
10. Hatneithem Tuboi, aged about 36 years, D/o Paolun Tuboi of New
Lambulane, Imphal East District, Manipur – 795005;
11. Sorokhaibam Jimeshori Devi, aged about 39 years, W/o
Wangkheimayum Bikramjeet Singh of Wangkhei Khunou,
Poropat, Imphal East District, Manipur – 795005;
12. Khumanllambam Rita Devi, aged about 31 years, D/o Kh.
Rajendro Singh of Lal Moriba, Kongba Makha Nandeibam Leikai,
Imphal East District, Manipur – 795005
…Petitioners
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[2]
-Versus –
1. The State of Manipur, represented by its Chief Secretary,
Government of Manipur, Imphal – 795001;
2. The Addl. Chief Secretary (GAD), Government of Manipur,
Imphal – 795001;
3. The Special Secretary (DP), Government of Manipur, Imphal
– 795001;
… Respondents
4. K. Hemanta Singh;
5. S. Guneshwor Singh;
6. M. Charan Singh;
7. H. Romeo;
8. K. Bisheshwor Singh;
9. Dhaneshwari Devi;
10. Eddy Lianminthang Guite (ST);
11. Suraj Kumar Khuraijam;
12. H. Birjit Singh;
13. Victor Singh Soubam;
14. Ningthoujam Sanjeev Singh;
15. Kennedy Ningombam;
16. L. Jugin Singh;
17. Laishram Thomas Singh;
18. Mayanglambam Bhagat Singh;
19. Khumbongmayum Rakesh;
20. Th. Sureshchandra Singh;
21. Ningombam Anilkumar;
22. Kshetrimayum Jevel Singh;
23. Naresh Ningombam;
24. H. Munal Singh;
25. Thounaojam Arunkumar;
26. Okram Bidyashwor Singh;
27. Saikhom Rakshajit Singh;
28. K. Manglem Singh;
29. Mayengbam Bonny Singh;
30. Daniel Konthoujam;
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[3]
31. Ningombam Bikramjit Singh;
32. Kailaizom Gangte (ST);
33. Elangbam Bidyananda Singh;
34. Sanjenbam Somorjit Singh;
35. Sougaijam Haripriya;
36. L. Seikhojang Milhiem (ST);
37. Konthoujam Chandrasekhar;
38. Sarita Laishram;
39. Laishram Priyadarshani Devi;
40. Laishram Subash;
41. Roger Maibam;
42. Ningthoujam Rustam Singh;
43. Bob Chanambam;
44. Barunkumar Thoudam;
45. Nameirakpam Debendra Singh;
46. Mayanglambam Lucy Devi;
47. L. Pilot Singh;
48. Naorem Naresh Singh;
49. Smritee Thapa;
50. Karam Surdeep Singh;
51. Kangjam Sunil Singh;
52. Sorokhaibam Sonia;
53. Konsam Bikram Singh;
54. Lairenlakpam Binita Devi;
55. Rajkumari Sandhyarani Devi;
56. Sarangthem Herojit Singh;
57. Kanghujam Romita Devi;
58. Lairenlakpam Pakasana;
59. Usharani Nandeibam;
60. Laiphrakpam Prameshwor;
61. Mohd. Mohsin Khan (MP);
62. Khudongbam Gobin;
63. Alice Kimneihoi Dimngel (ST);
64. Ningreingam Ramror (ST);
65. Ramneithang (ST)
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[4]
66. Thanmila Kumrah (ST);
67. Simon Loitongbam;
68. M. Molightson Kanshouwa (ST);
69. Tongsin Konatha Anal (ST);
70. R.K. Binaton Singh;
71. Narhang Koshang (ST);
72. Dangsha Khullakka Peter (ST);
73. D. Shonronton Duidang (ST);
74. Khapaishimrah Peter Kapam (ST);
75. Fondy L. Khartu Monshang (ST);
76. Mohon Dangsawa (ST);
77. Josiah Panmei (ST);
78. Molhouyang Dangsawa (ST);
79. Soraisam Indrajit Singh;
80. Wahengbam Eden Singh;
81. Zingcharla Raman (ST);
82. Kaiminlun Vaiphei (ST);
83. Telvum Letmang Haokip (ST);
84. Thangminlien Hangshing (ST);
85. Md. Abdus Shahid (MP);
86. Mohamad Ezaz Ahamad (MP);
87. Thokchom Nilamani Singh;
88. Yengkokpam Roger Singh;
89. Henry Tinmuanthang (ST);
90. Konsam Bankimchandra;
91. Moyangphun Charanga Maring (ST);
92. Gairillung Thaimei Kabui (ST);
93. Fanai Lalhriatkima (ST);
94. Chongom Rinigkhosan Aimol (ST);
95. Tarachand Singh Oinam;
96. K. Methew Maring (ST);
97. S. Keshorchand Sharma;
98. Kansham Angphun Maring (ST);
99. Mamlienlal Samte (ST)(PWD/Eye);
100. Wairok Pakpi Makunga (ST);
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[5]
101. Dangshawa Korungini Maring (ST);
102. Md. Azharuddin (MP);
103. Shamjetshabam Nandakumar (SC) (PWD)/Hand);
104. Moirangthem Indrakumar (SC)(PWD/Loco).
…. Private Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioners
:: Mr. S. Biswajit, Advocate
For the respondents
:: Mr. Lenin Hijam, Advocate General
asstd. by Ms. Caroline, Advocate; &
Mr. A. Mohendro, Advocate
Date of Hearing
:: 23-11-2022
Date of Judgment & Order :: 10-01-2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. S. Biswajit, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate General assisted by Ms.
Caroline, learned counsel appearing for the respondents No. 1, 2 and 3
and Mr. A. Mohendro, learned counsel appearing for some of the private
respondents.
The issue involved in the present writ petition is about fixation
of Inter-se-Seniority between employees appointed under the Die-inHarness Scheme and direct recruit/ promotees.
[2]
The petitioners, 12 (twelve) in number, were all appointed as
Office Assistants (LDA) in the General Administration Department under
the Die-in-Harness Scheme during the period between 18-02-2016 to
21-11-2016 and they have been serving as regular Government
employees for the last about six years. On the other hand, all the private
respondents were appointed as Office Assistants (LDA) as direct recruit
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[6]
candidates on 01-12-2016. Accordingly, the petitioners were appointed
earlier than the private respondents.
By an order dated 19-09-2019 issued by the Under Secretary
(GAD), Government of Manipur, the posts of Office Assistant and Senior
Office Assistant were re-designated as Secretariat Assistant and Senior
Secretariat Assistant respectively with effect from the date of issue of the
said order.
[3]
The next promotional post from the post of Office Assistant (now
Secretariat Assistant) is the post of Senior Office Assistant (now Senior
Secretariat Assistant) and according to the petitioners, they are all eligible
and qualified for promotion to the next higher post in terms of the relevant
rules. It is the case of the petitioners that there is at present more than
100 vacant posts of Senior Secretariat Assistant available in the General
Administration Department and as a measure for filling up the vacant
posts, the authorities issued a Tentative Inter-se-Seniority List of
Secretariat Assistants of Manipur Secretariat by issuing a Notification
dated 05-11-2020 calling for claims and objections to the fixation of the
Inter-se-Seniority. In the said Tentative Inter-se-Seniority List, the names
of the petitioners are placed above the names of the private respondents.
[4]
On publication of the said Tentative Seniority List, some of the
private respondents submitted a joint objection to the said Tentative Interse-Seniority List stating, inter alia, that indicating Die-in-Harness
appointees as direct recruit is not appropriate as they were appointed
without undergoing any recruitment process and that placing all the Diein-Harness appointees of 2016 above the direct recruit and promotees of
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[7]
2016 batch gave them undue advantage. It has also been stated that
under the Office Memorandum dated 11-11-2010 issued by the
Government of India, it is provided under para 4.8 that persons appointed
on compassionate ground in a particular year may be placed at the bottom
of all the candidates recruited/appointed through direct recruit, promotion,
etc. in that year irrespective of the date of joining of the candidates on
compassionate ground.
[5]
Under para 4.8 of the said Office Memorandum dated 11-11-2010
issued by the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension
(DPT), Government of India, certain guidelines had been laid down with
regard to fixation of seniority of persons appointed on compassionate
ground to the extent that persons appointed on compassionate ground in
a particular year may be placed at the bottom of all the candidates
recruited/appointed through direct recruitment/promotion, etc., in that
year, irrespective of the date of joining of the candidate on compassionate
ground. The said guidelines were reiterated under para 16 of the Office
Memorandum dated 16-01-2013 issued by the Ministry of Personnel,
Public Grievances and Pension (DPT), Government of India for
information, guidance and necessary action by all concerned. Para 16 of
the said Office Memorandum are reproduced hereunder for ready
reference:“16. Seniority –
A person appointed on compassionate ground in a particular
year may be placed at the bottom of all the candidates
recruited/ appointed through direct recruitment/ promotion,
etc. in that year, irrespective of the date of joining of the
candidate on compassionate ground”.
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[8]
[6]
It is the case of the official respondents that under the Manipur
Secretariat Sub-ordinate Services Rules, 1982, there is no provisions for
fixation of seniority of an employee appointed under the Die-in-Harness
Scheme. In order the supplement the lacuna in the relevant service rules,
the State Government issued an Office Memorandum dated 06-03-2021
adopting to follow the guidelines under para 16 of the aforesaid O.M.
dated 16-01-2013 issued by the Government of India with regard to
fixation of seniority of a person appointed on compassionate ground.
However, in para 2 of the said O.M., it is provided that the adoption shall
be with prospective effect for new appointment and no retrospective effect
will be allowed. Subsequently, the State Government issued another
Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 amending para 2 of the earlier
O.M. dated 06-03-2021. The amended para 2 reads as under:“Para 2. Henceforth, the O.M. shall be applied in fixing Interse-Seniority List for group of employees which include Die-inHarness appointee whose Final Seniority List has not yet been
finalized. Seniority List already finalized shall not be reopened”.
[7]
After notification of the aforesaid Office Memorandums dated
06-03-2021 and 13-07-2021, the Under Secretary (GAD), Government of
Manipur, issued a Notification dated 06-10-2021 publishing a Tentative
Inter-se-Seniority List of Secretariat Assistants of Manipur Secretariat and
inviting objections to the fixation of the inter-se-seniority. In the new
Tentative Inter-se-Seniority List, the names of the private respondents are
placed above the names of the petitioners in terms of the guidelines for
fixing of seniority between persons appointed on compassionate ground
and candidates appointed through direct recruitment/ promotion, etc. as
contained in the aforesaid O.M. dated 06-03-2021 and 13-07-2021.
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[9]
Despite the written objections submitted by the petitioners to the
Tentative Inter-se-Seniority List, the authorities issued a Notification
dated 16-12-2021 publishing the Final Inter-se-Seniority List of
Secretariat
Assistants
(formerly Office
Assistants)
of
Manipur
Secretariat. In the said Final Inter-se-Seniority List, the private
respondents are placed above the petitioners. Having been aggrieved,
the petitioners approached this court by filing the present writ
petition with the prayer for quashing and setting aside the Office
Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 issued by the Department of
Personnel and Administrative Reforms as well as the Final Inter se
Seniority List of Secretariat Assistants dated 16-12-2021.
[8]
Mr. S. Biswajit, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
submitted that the O.M. dated 06-03-2021 of the State of Manipur has
already created a lawful legal rights to the petitioners and the said O.M.
cannot be amended behind their back without following the principle of
natural justice and without giving an opportunity of being heard. The
act of the official respondents in amending the earlier O.M. dated
06-03-2021 by issuing the subsequent O.M. dated 13-07-2021
unilaterally and without complying with the principle of natural justice
amounts to bias, arbitrary and mala fide in nature and the same is not
tenable in the eye of law. It has also been submitted that the second
clause of the impugned O.M. itself clearly demonstrated the mala fide
intention of the concerned authority to do away with the seniority of the
Die-in-Harness appointees, whose seniority could have been finalized
long back and the same was delayed intentionally by the concerned
authority waiting for the private respondents to be qualified for
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[10]
promotion to the next higher posts. It has also been submitted that the
amendment of the earlier O.M. dated 06-03-2021 was not necessary
at all as the same had already been finalized, clarified and settled.
The dispute regarding inter-se-seniority between the compassionate
appointees and other appointees and that the conduct of the concerned
authority clearly shows that they have just wanted to favour the normal
direct recruits/ private respondents and promotees by neglecting the
essence of the O.M. of the Government of India as well as the State
Government.
[9]
The learned counsel also submitted that once the State
Government accepted the fact that there is no rule for determining
seniority of the employees appointed under Die-in-Harness Scheme,
than the O.M. on which the determination of the Seniority List is based
on cannot be changed / amended arbitrarily and that in the absence of
any statutory rule governing the field in a particular Department,
seniority would be reckoned from the date of appointment and the same
cannot be affected retrospectively by adopting an O.M. It has further
been submitted that an amendment having retrospective operation
which has the effect of taking away a benefit already available/ accrued
to an employee under the existing rules/ O.M./ regulation, etc. is
arbitrary and discriminatory and violates the fundamental rights
guaranteed under Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India and that
a administrative/ executive order cannot have retrospective effect so as
to take away the right accrued to an employee as per the earlier
Circular. The learned counsel also submitted that the Tentative
Seniority List dated 05-11-2020, even though a final of the same was
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[11]
not published, can be assumed to be finalized as the first four
incumbents in the said Seniority List have been promoted to the higher
posts on 18-08-2021 in order of merit by acting upon the earlier
Tentative Seniority List and much before the publication of the
impugned Final Seniority List dated 16-12-2021.
In support of his contentions, the learned counsel cited the
following case laws:1.
“S.K. Ghosh and anr. Vs. Union of India “
(1968 AIR 1385)
Page 8. “……….It is thus, clear that the revision of seniority in the
grade of Directors of Postal Services by the order dated 17th
January, 1966 was not based on any rule r appropriate principle
applicable to determination of seniority in that grade, and must,
therefore, be held to be totally arbitrary. Such an arbitrary order,
which affects the civil rights of the petitioners in respect of future
promotion, must, therefore, be stuck down as violating Art. 16 of
the Constitution. Once this order dated 17th January, 1966 is
quashed, the petitioners will no longer be affected in future by the
revision of their seniority in the time scale of the service by the
order dated 5th June, 1965 and, ……..
……. We allow this petition and quashed the order dated 17 th
January, 1966 revising the seniority of the petitioners and
respondents Nos. 3 to 7 in the grade of Directors of Postal
Services……”
2. “Ajit Singh and ors. (II) Vs. State of Punjab & ors. “
(1977) 7 SCC 209
Para 22. “Article 14 and Article 16(1) are closely connected. They
deal with the individual rights of the person Article 14 demands
that the “State shall not deny to any person equality before he law
and equal protection of the laws”. Article 16(1) issues a positive
command that
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[12]
“shall be equality of opportunity for all the citizens in matters
relating to employment or appointment to any office under the
State”.
It has been held repeatedly by this court that clause (1) of
Article 16 is a facet of Article 14 and that it takes its roots from
Article 14. The said clause particularizes the generality in Article
14 and identifies, in a constitutional sense “equality of opportunity”
in matters of employment and appointment to any office under the
State. The word “employment” being wider, there is no dispute
that it takes within its fold, the aspect of promotions to posts above
the stage of initial level of recruitment. Article 16(1) provides to
every employee eligible for promotion or who comes within the
zone of consideration, a fundamental right to be ‘considered’ for
promotion. Equal opportunity here means the right to be
‘considered’ for promotion. If a person satisfied the eligibility and
zone criteria but is not considered for promotion, then there will
be a clear infraction of his fundamental right to be “considered” for
promotion, which is his personal right.
“Promotion” based on equal opportunity and “seniority”
attached to such promotion are facets of fundamental right under
Article 16(1).”
3.
(2007) 5 SCC 447
“Southern Petrochemical Industries Co. Ltd. Vs. Electricity
Inspector & Etio and ors.”
Para 118. “It is in the aforementioned context, that the doctrine of
promissory estoppel is sought to be invoked. We will notice
hereinafter that even a right can be preserved by reason of
invocation of doctrine of promissory estoppel.”
Para 130. “We therefore, of the opinion that doctrine of promissory
estoppel also preserves a right. A right would be preserved when
it is not expressly taken a way but in fact has expressly been
preserved”.
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[13]
4.
(2006) 13 SCC 542
“Union of India & ors. Vs. Asian Food Industries”
Para 48. “The Delhi High Court, however, in our view correctly
opined that the Notification dated 4-7-2006 could not have been
taken into consideration on the basis of the purported publicity
made in the proposed change in the export policy in electronic or
print media. Prohibition promulgated by a statutory order in terms
of section 5 read with the relevant provisions of the policy decision
in the light of sub-section (2) of section 3 of the 1992 Act can only
have a prospective effect. By reasons of a policy, a vested or
accrues right cannot be taken away. Such a right, therefore,
cannot a fortiori be taken away by an amendment thereof.”
5.
(1997) 6 SCC 623
“Chairman Railway Board & ors. Vs. C.R. Rangdhamaiah & ors.”
Para 24. “In many of these decisions the expressions “vested
rights’ or “accrues rights” have been used while striking down the
impugned provisions which had been retrospective operation so
as to have an adverse effect in the matter of promotion, seniority,
substantive appointment, etc., of the employees. The said
expressions have been used in the context of a right flowing under
the relevant rule which was sought to be altered with effect from
an anterior date and thereby taking away the benefits available
under the rule in force at that time. It has been held that such an
amendment having retrospective operation which has the effect
of taking away a benefit already available to the employees under
the existing rule is arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of the
rights guaranteed under Article 14 & 16 of the Constitution. We
are unable to hold that these decisions are not in consonance with
the decisions in Roshan Lal Tandon, B.S. Yadav and Raman Lal
Soni.”
6.
(2010) 2 SCC 422
“Union of India & anr. Vs. Kartick Chandra Mondal & anr.”
Para 12. “It was also submitted that neither CAT nor the High
Court has any power to direct absorption of the respondents when
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[14]
they have worked only for two years and on the date when OA
No. 285 of 1990 was filed before CAT they were not even working
as casual workers. The further submission of the counsel
appearing for the appellant was that the office memorandum
which was issued in 1985 could not have been relied upon or
made the basis for issuing orders in favour of the respondents,
particularly, in view of the fact that on the date when the aforesaid
office memorandum was issued the respondents had already
been disengaged from service and were not working with the
appellant 2.
Para 14. “In the light of the aforesaid submission of the counsel
appearing for the parties we have considered the entire records.
So far as the Office Memorandum dated 7.5.1985 is concerned,
the same was issued by way of relaxation of the condition of
recruitment of casual workers. But the fact remains that the
respondents working with the appellants only for two years i.e.,
from 1981 to 1983 and admittedly on the date when the aforesaid
office memorandum which would indicate that there was an
intention to give a retrospective effect to the contents of the said
notification. Instead, the language used in the aforesaid
notification clearly shows that the same was intended to be
prospective in nature and not retrospective.
Para 16. “As has been noted earlier, the said Office Memorandum
stated that the same would apply only to those persons who might
have been continuing as casual workers for a number of years
and who were not eligible for regular appointment and whose
services might be terminated at any time. Therefore, it envisaged
and could be made applicable to only those persons who were in
service on the date when the aforesaid office memorandum was
issued. Unless and until there is a clear intention expressed in the
notification that it would also apply retrospectively, the same
cannot be given a retrospective effect and could always operate
prospectively.”
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[15]
7.
(2015) 7 SCC 412
“Canara Bank Vs. M. Mahesh Kumar”
Para 17. “Applying these principles to the case in hand, as
discussed earlier, the respondent’s father died on 10-10-1998
while he was serving as a clerk in the appellant Bank and the
resident applied timely for compassionate appointment as per the
scheme” Dying in Harness Scheme” dated 8.5.1993 claim on
30.6.1999 recording that there are no indigent circumstances for
providing employment to the respondent. Again on 7.11.2001, the
appellant bank sought for particular in connection with the issue
of the respondent’s employment. In the light of the principles laid
down in the above decisions, the cause of action to be considered
for compassionate appointment arose when circular No. 154 of
1993 dated 8.5.1993 was in force. Thus as per the judgment
referred in Jaspal Kaur Case, the claim cannot be decided as per
2005 scheme providing for ex-gratia payment. The circular dated
14.2.2005 being an administrative or executive order cannot have
retrospective effect so as to take away the right accrued to the
respondent as per Circular of 1993.”
8.
(2004) 3 SCC 723
“Pramod K. Pankaj Vs. State of Bihar & ors.”
Para 12. “The policy decision of the State as contained in the
resolution of the State Government dated 17.1`.1979 is not in
question. It is accepted that the said resolution was adopted in the
special situation that 20% quota which was earlier reserve for
graduate engineers was abolished, as a result whereof they
suffered immense prejudice. Clause (cha) of he said circular stats
that the promotion on the vacant posts of Assistant Engineers
under the quota, mention in Clause (ka) i.e., 3% would be made
on the basis of seniority. In absence of any statutory provision or
rules made thereunder or under the proviso appended to Article
309 of the Constitution of India, it is trite that once an incumbent
is appointed to a post according to rules, his seniority has to be
counted from the date of his appointment.
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[16]
9.
1994 Suppl. (3) SCC 451
“Uday Pratap Singh & ors. Vs. State of Bihar & ors.”
Para 6. “By a catena of decisions of this Court, it is now wellsettled that by an executive order the statutory rules cannot be
whittled down nor can any retrospective effect be given to such
executive order so as to destroy any right which become
crystallized. In this connection, it is profitable to refer a decision of
this court in T.R. Kapur V. State of Haryana wherein it is held that
rules framed under Article 309 of the Constitution cannot affect or
impair vested rights, unless it is specifically so provided in the
stator rules concerned. It is obvious that an executive direction
stands even on a much weaker footing. It is true, as laid down in
Bishan Sarup Gupta V. Union of India, that effect of upgradation
of a post is to make the incumbent occupy the upgraded post with
all logical benefits flowing therefrom and can be treated as
promoted to the post still it cannot be gainsaid that no
retrospective effect could be given to any merger or erstwhile
lower branch into higher branch in the cadre so as to effect the
vested rights of incumbents already occupying posts in the
erstwhile lower branch into higher branch of the cadre……”
[10]
Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate General submitted that there
is no provision under the Manipur Secretariat Sub-ordinate Services
Rules, 1982 for fixation of Inter-se-Seniority between the employees
appointed under the Die-in-Harness Scheme and employees appointed
by way of direct recruitment/ promotion in the same year and accordingly,
the guidelines/ instructions issued by the Government of India in its
Office Memorandum dated 16-01-2013 with regard to fixation of Seniority
of compassionate appointees were adopted by the State Government by
issuing Office Memorandum dated 06-03-2001 in pursuance of the
Cabinet decision taken on 09-12-2020 and the subsequent amendment
dated 13-07-2021 was issued as per Cabinet decision taken on
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[17]
06-07-2021. It has been submitted that the said Office Memorandum was
adopted to bring clarity in fixing of Inter-se-seniority amongst the direct
recruit, promotees and employees appointed on compassionate ground,
who were appointed in the same year and that the Office Memorandum
is limited to those cases only where seniority has not yet been finalized
as reconsidering seniority list already finalized on the basis of the new
Office Memorandum would be unjustified. It has further been submitted
that the adoption of the aforesaid Office Memorandums was a policy
decision taken by the Government and the Government has the power
and authority to issue such guidelines/ instructions for fixation of the
seniority and the petitioners have failed to point out that the said Office
Memorandums have been issued in violation of any statutory act/rules.
[11]
The learned Advocate General strenuously submitted that the
petitioners have neither pleaded in their writ petition that the impugned
Office Memorandum violated any of their Fundamental Right nor have
they denied the stand taken by the respondents in their counter affidavit
and accordingly, the petitioners have failed to make out a case for
interfering with the impugned Office Memorandum and the impugned
seniority list and as such, the present writ petition is liable to be dismissed
as being devoid of merit. In support of his contentions, the learned
Advocate General cited the following case laws:1. (2013) 16 SCC 147,
“Union of India and anr. Vs. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal”
“58. A Constitution Bench of this Court while dealing with a similar
issue in respect of executive instructions in Sant Ram Sharma v.
State of Rajasthan, held: (AIR 1967 SC 1914, Para 7)
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[18]
“7. …..“It is true that the Government cannot amend or
supersede statutory rules by administrative instruction, but if the
rules are silent on any particular point, the Government can fillup the gap and supplement the rule and issue instructions not
inconsistent with the Rules already framed.”
“59. The law laid down above has consistently been followed and it is
a settled proposition of law that an authority cannot issue
orders/office
memorandum/
executive
instructions
in
contravention of the statutory rules. However, instructions can be
issued only to supplement the statutory rules but not to supplant
it. Such instructions should be subservient to the statutory
provisions. (Vide: Union of India v. Majji Jangamayya; P.D.
Aggarwal v. State of U.P.; Paluru Ramkrishnaiah v. Union of
India; C. Rangaswamaiah v. Karnataka Lokayukta and Joint
Action Committee of Air Line Pilots’ Assn. of India v. DG of Civil
Aviation).”
“60. Similarly, a Constitution Bench of this Court, in Naga
People’s Movement of Human Rights v. Union of India, held that
the executive instructions have binding force provided the same
have been issued to fill up the gap between the statutory
provisions and are not inconsistent with the said provisions.”
“61. In Nagaraj Shivarao Karjagi v. Syndicate Bank, this Court has
explained the scope of circulars issued by the Ministry observing
that it is binding on the officers of the department particularly the
recommendations made by CVC.
“62. In State of U.P. & Ors. v. Maharaja Dharmander Prasad Singh,
this Court held that the order must be passed by the authority
after due application of mind uninfluenced by and without
surrendering to the dictates of an extraneous body or an
authority.
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[19]
2. (1988) 2 SCC 233
“R. Prabha Devi & ors. Vs. Government of India & ors.”
“16. It has also been observed:
"In any event, the appropriate rule-making authority is the
best judge in this regard. The rule-making authority is certainly
competent to amend the Rule and extend the period from six
years to eight years so as to make the direct recruits more
experienced and suitable for the higher post. That is a matter for
the rule- making authority; the Tribunal cannot sit in judgment
over the opinion of the rule-making authority. No court or Tribunal
can substitute its own view in a matter such as this. Such a rule
framed by a competent authority cannot be struck down unless it
is shown to be violative of any Fundamental Right guaranteed to
a citizen under the Constitution."
[12]
I have heard the arguments advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties at length and carefully examined the materials
available on record. The impugned Final Inter-se-Seniority List dated
16-12-2021 was prepared on the basis of the Office Memorandums dated
06-03-2021 and 14-07-2021 issued by the Department of Personnel and
Administrative Reforms (PD), Government of Manipur. The petitioners
only assailed the subsequent Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 in
the present writ petition. Under the first Office Memorandum dated
06-03-2021, it is provided that a person appointed on compassionate
ground in a particular year may be placed at the bottom of all the
candidates recruited/appointed through direct recruitment, promotion,
etc., in that year, irrespective of the date of joining of the candidate on
compassionate ground. In para 2 of the said Office Memorandum, it is
provided that the said Office Memorandum shall be with prospective
effect for new appointment and no retrospective effect will be allowed. By
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[20]
the second Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021, para 2 of the earlier
Office Memorandum dated 06-03-2021 was amended as under:"2. Henceforth, the O.M. shall be applied in fixing Inter-seSeniority List for group of employees which include Die-inHarness appointee whose Final Seniority List has not yet been
finalized. Seniority List already finalized shall not be
reopened”.
The said amendment was with prospective effect as no
retrospective effect was given.
[13]
The petitioners assailed the subsequent Office Memorandum
dated 13-07-2021 basically on the ground that they have accrued a right
under the Office Memorandum dated 06-03-2021 with regard to fixation
of their seniority vis-a-vis direct recruit/ promotees and that such a right
cannot be denied or curtailed by the authorities by making the
amendment under the second Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021
retrospectively. According to the petitioners, if the authorities published
the Final Seniority List before issuing the second Office Memorandum
dated 13-07-2021, the provisions under the first Office Memorandum
dated 06-03-2021 would not have been applicable in their case in view of
para 2 of the said Office Memorandum and their names would have been
placed above the private respondents in the Final Seniority List.
It is the case of the petitioners that authorities have deliberately
delayed the publication of the Final Seniority List and published the same
only after issuance of the second Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021
which amended the beneficial provisions under para 2 of the first Office
Memorandum dated 06-03-2021, thereby depriving the valuable right of
the petitioners with regard to fixation of their seniority position. It is also
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[21]
the case of the petitioners that the authorities cannot retrospectively
amend the beneficial provisions under para 2 of the first Office
Memorandum dated 06-03-2021.
[14]
As noted herein above, while making the amendment under the
second Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021, no retrospective effect
was given and accordingly, this court is the considered view that the
amendment brought about under the second Office Memorandum dated
13-07-2021 will have only prospective effect. Accordingly, the arguments
advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that the
accrued right of the petitioners had been denied or curtailed
retrospectively by the authorities by bringing in the amendment under the
second Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 are misconceive and
baseless.
[15]
This court is also of the considered view that no Government
employee, including the present petitioners, can claim to have any
Fundamental Right with regard to fixation of their seniority even though
they might have a legal right. The Inter-se-Seniority between the
petitioners and the private respondents was fixed for the first time by the
Government under the impugned Final Seniority List dated 16-12-2021
and prior to issuance of the said impugned Seniority List, there was no
Inter-se-Seniority between the petitioners and the private respondents. In
view of the above, this court is of the considered view that the Office
Memorandum dated 06-03-2021 read with the subsequent amendment
made under the Second Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 are
applicable in the case of the petitioners and the private respondents in
the matter of fixation of their Inter-se-Seniority and this court did not find
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[22]
any irregularity or illegality being committed by the authorities in issuing
the impugned Final Seniority List. The seniority of Government
employees have to be fixed as per the relevant and applicable rules and
in the absence of such rules, their seniority have to be fixed as per
applicable guidelines/ instructions issued in that regard. As the Inter-seSeniority of the petitioners and the private respondents have not been
fixed prior to issuance of the second Office Memorandum dated
13-07-2021, this court is of the view that the applicable rules for fixing of
their seniority is the provision under the first Office Memorandum dated
06-03-2021 read with the subsequent amendment bought in the second
Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 and that the petitioners cannot
claim that they have a right to have their seniority fixed vis-a-vis the
private respondents solely on the basis of the first Office Memorandum
dated 06-03-2021.
I have also carefully perused all the case laws cited by the learned
counsel for the petitioner and in my considered view, none of the case
laws are applicable in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
[16]
In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent No. 2 and
some of the private respondents, it is clearly stated that the Final Seniority
position of the persons appearing at Sl. Nos. 1 to 4 in the Tentative
Seniority List dated 05-11-2020 have already been fixed by the
Government under the Final Seniority List of Office Assistants (now
Secretariat Assistants) notified on 13-04-2018 and that on the basis of the
said Final Seniority List, the said four incumbents were promoted to the
next higher posts. It has also been categorically stated that the
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
[23]
Government has never acted on the basis of the said Tentative Seniority
List dated 05-11-2020. The petitioners have not controverted or denied
such categorical statement made by the respondents and accordingly,
this court is not inclined to accept the contentions made on behalf of the
petitioners that the Tentative Seniority List dated 05-11-2020 had already
been acted upon by the Government before publication of the impugned
Final Seniority List and that the said Tentative Seniority List can be
assumed to be finalized.
[17]
In the present case, the petitioners have failed to make out a case
that the impugned Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 had been
issued in violation of any statutory provisions or that by issuance of the
said Office Memorandum, any of their Fundamental Rights have been
violated. In such view of the matter, this court did not find any ground for
interfering with the impugned Office Memorandum dated 13-07-2021 and
accordingly, the present writ petition fails and the same is hereby
dismissed as being devoid of merit. The parties are to bear their own
costs.
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
WP(C) No. 948 of 2021
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review