Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:47852
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
903 CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO. 283 OF 2023
NILESH PRATAP MORE
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERS
Mr.H.H.Padalkar, Advocate for the Applicant.
Mrs.B.B.Gunjal, APP for the Respondent/State.
Mr.Shaikh Wajid, Advocate for Respondent No.2.
Mr.A.V.Mundada, Advocate for Respondent No.3.
( CORAM : SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J. )
DATE : 30th SEPTEMBER, 2026
PER COURT :
1.
Heard the learned Advocates for the respective parties and
the learned APP.
2.
This is Criminal Revision Application challenging the
impugned order dated 30.08.2023 passed by the learned Sessions
Judge, Basmat Dist.Hingoli, below Exhibits 47 and 74 in Sessions Case
No.14/2023, thereby rejecting the application Exh.74 of the Applicant
for return of property u/s 457 of the Cr.P.C and allowing the application
Exh.47 filed by respondent No.2/ accused No.7 and handing over
khs/Sept.2026/283
-2-
custody of vehicle to accused No.7.
3.
The learned Sessions Judge, vide the impugned order,
rejected the application preferred by the Applicant for returning the
property u/s 457 of the Cr.P.C.
The Applicant is, therefore, seeking
custody of the said sealed property.
Hence the instant Revision
Application.
4.
The property, which is sought to be released, is a Mahindra
and Mahindra XUV 700 vehicle which came to be seized by the Police in
Crime No.29/2023. The said vehicle came to be seized from one
Jaykant Parmeshwar Jangid i.e. brother of respondent No.2. The said
crime was registered by Aundha Police Station. The vehicle in question
came to be seized on 08.02.2023, by the Investigating Officer on the
basis of the statement recorded of Jaykant Parmeshwar Jangid. In the
said statement, Jaykant also stated that the vehicle is belonging to one
Nilesh More i.e. the present Applicant.
On the basis of aforesaid
statement, the Investigating Officer sent notice to Jaykant Jangid to
bring the vehicle at Aundha Police Station. Accordingly, Jaykant
Parmeshwar brought the vehicle on 08.02.2023 in Aundha Police
khs/Sept.2026/283
-3-
Station.
5.
Accordingly, the notice was sent to the Applicant Nilesh
More. He appeared and filed his say at Exh.73 stating therein that he
had no acquaintance with respondent No./2 Accused No.7 and never
gave the vehicle to him.
Accused No.7 i.e. respondent No.2 also filed
an application before the leaned Sessions Court u/s 457 of the Cr.P.C.,
for releasing the said vehicle. Accordingly, the notice came to be issued
to the present Applicant Nilesh being the registered owner of the said
vehicle.
The learned Sessions Judge, vide impugned order dated
30.08.2023, pleased to grant custody of the vehicle to accused No.7/
Respondent No.2 on executing Supurtnama of Rs.5,00,000/-. Being
aggrieved by the said order, the Applicant has approached this Court by
filing the present Revision Application.
6.
The learned Advocate for the Applicant submits that it is
admitted fact that the Applicant is the registered owner of the vehicle,
who has purchased the vehicle by availing loan facility from
Respondent No.3 and thus, the said vehicle is hypothecated with
Respondent No.3 / Finance Company.
khs/Sept.2026/283
Respondent No.2, according to
-4-
him, is relying upon one fabricated agreement dated 20.04.2022
claiming to be the owner of the said vehicle on the ground that the
Applicant has allegedly sold the vehicle to him. He submits that the
said agreement is totally a false document and cannot be acted upon.
He has taken this Court to the recitals of the said agreement and
pointed out that not only the photograph, but the signature appeared
on the said document, are forged. He submits that on the basis of said
agreement, Respondent No.2 cannot be considered to be the owner of
the vehicle in question. He further submits that as on date, even the
Transport Authorities’ entries are also standing in his favour and as
such, he is entitled for the custody of the seized vehicle in his favour.
Thus, in short, he denies the aforesaid agreement dated 20.04.2022 and
also denies the contention that he has ever received the cash of
Rs.2,00,000/-.
7.
Upon specific query by the Court to the learned Advocate
for the Applicant as regards, as to how Accused No.7 i.e. respondent
No.2 herein came into possession of this vehicle, he submits that the
vehicle in question was handed over to one Sarala Bokefode and he was
under bonafide impression that the said vehicle was in her possession
khs/Sept.2026/283
-5-
and therefore, he was not aware that the said vehicle was involved in
crime and he has never handed the vehicle to Accused No.7.
He,
therefore, submits that the learned Sessions Court, by handing over the
custody of the vehicle to accused No.7, has committed grave error in
the eyes of Law and hence, the impugned order be quashed and set
aside and he be handed over the custody of the vehicle.
8.
Per contra, the learned Advocate for Respondent No.2 /
Accused No.7 strongly opposed the instant Revision Application.
According to him, the order passed by the learned Sessions Court is
correct and proper in the sense that the vehicle at the time of incident
in question was found to be in the possession of Accused No.7.
He
further submits that under the provisions of Section 457 of the Cr.P.C.,
the Court on making an application for releasing the property on
Supurtnama, is required to see as to who is possessing the seized
property at the relevant time and therefore, according to him, the
learned Sessions Court while granting custody to him, has committed
no error. He further submits that the Applicant has sold the said vehicle
vide Agreement dated 20.04.2022 to Accused No.7. After transferring
the said vehicle to Accused No.7, the Applicant cannot claim any right
khs/Sept.2026/283
-6-
over the said property and as such, he is entitled for the custody of the
vehicle. He also submits that the applicant though was not having
possession of this vehicle property, still he has not lodged any complaint
before the Police for almost one and half years.
The conduct of the
Applicant is, therefore, doubtful and he being not related person and
therefore, has not approached with clean hands. Thus, the applicant is
not entitled to have the custody of the vehicle. The learned Advocate
for Respondent No.2 has specifically relied upon Section 457 of the
Cr.P.C. to claim that he is entitled to claim possession of the vehicle.
9.
In support of his submission, the learned advocate for
respondent No.2, relies upon the judgment passed by this Court in the
case of Julio @ Francis K.Budge Vs.State [2007 All M.R. (Cri.) 1069].
He submits that in identical situation, the Court has considered this
aspect and has not handed over the property to the registered owner of
the vehicle. He, therefore, submits that the instant Revision Application
be rejected.
10.
The learned APP has relied upon the affidavit filed by the
Police Inspector, Aundha Police Station, Dist.Hingoli. She has invited
khs/Sept.2026/283
-7-
attention of this Court to paragraph Nos. 6 and 7 of the said affidavit to
contend that the agreement sought to be relied upon by Accused No.2
and sought to be denied by the Applicant, is a matter of trial and cannot
be considered for deciding the issue raised under the provisions of
Section 457 of the Cr.P.C.. The learned APP, therefore, prayed for
passing the appropriate order.
11.
The learned Advocate for Respondent No.3 states that as
on date, total amount of Rs.3,33,445/- is outstanding and have not
been paid by the Applicant.
12.
After hearing the learned Advocates for the respective
parties and on going through the record and proceedings before the
Court, it is found that at the time of commission of crime, the vehicle in
question was used by Respondent No.2 and the same came to be seized
by the Investigating Officer on 08.02.2023 for the purpose of
investigation. After the investigation, charge sheet is filed . The crime
in question is of the year 2023 and though the charge sheet is filed, the
vehicle, which is seized in the crime, is still lying with the Police
Station.
Admittedly, Respondent No.2 was having possession at the
khs/Sept.2026/283
-8-
time of incident in question, however, it is also an admitted fact that he
is not the registered owner of the vehicle. The vehicle in question is
hypothecated with Respondent No.3 / Mahindra and Mahindra
Financial Services Ltd. Respondent No.2 / Accused No.7, if at all wants
to rely upon and act upon the agreement sought to be executed
between the parties, he will have to prove the agreement. However, as
on date, the Applicant is found to be the registered owner of the
vehicle, there is no difficulty in allowing him to have custody of the said
vehicle but subject to very strict conditions. If such an application is
filed, the possession of the vehicle is required to be handed over in
favour of the person, who is entitled for the possession.
13.
Though the learned advocate for respondent No.2 has
relied upon Section 457 to claim possession of the vehicle, however, on
bare perusal of Section 457, it is clear that the Magistrate may pass
such order delivering such property to “the person entitled to the
possession thereof”. Sub Section (2) of Section 457 further states that
if the person so entitled is “known”, the Magistrate may order to deliver
such property to him. Thus, Section 457 reveals that the property to be
handed over to the known person entitled to the possession. In this
khs/Sept.2026/283
-9-
case, admittedly the vehicle is registered in the name of the Applicant
and there is outstanding of the loan in his name. However, respondent
No.2 is claiming possession of the vehicle on the basis of the agreement,
which is disputed by the applicant.
14.
The judgment in Julio alias Francis K. Bugde Vs. State and
Another, reported in 2007 ALL MR (Cri) 1069, relied upon by learned
Advocate for Respondent No.2, is distinguishable on facts. In the said
case, the claim of the person seeking interim custody was supported by
material demonstrating payment of the sale consideration and
possession of the registration certificate, and the version of the
registered owner was not satisfactorily substantiated. In the present
case, however, the Applicant has specifically disputed the alleged
agreement dated 20.04.2022, including its genuineness, and the claim
of Respondent No.2 based thereon has yet to be established. Further,
the vehicle admittedly continues to stand registered in the name of the
Applicant
and
is
hypothecated
with
Respondent
No.3/Finance
Company. Therefore, the principle applied in the aforesaid judgment,
on the facts obtaining therein, cannot be mechanically applied to the
present case so as to confer interim custody upon Respondent No.2
khs/Sept.2026/283
- 10 -
merely on the basis of his possession at the time of the incident. The
said judgment, therefore, does not advance the case of Respondent
No.2 in the facts and circumstances of the present matter.
15.
In view of the above discussion, the Applicant alone is the
known person to be entitled for possession as per Section 457 and
Respondent No.2 is not entitled for possession of the vehicle in
question. However, the learned Sessions Judge has committed an error
while passing the impugned order. The impugned order needs to be
quashed and set aside. Hence, the following order :ORDER
[a]
Criminal Revision Application is allowed and the impugned order
dated 30.08.2023 is quashed and set aside.
[b]
The vehicle MH-15/DM-4993, seized in Crime No.29/2023, be
handed over in the custody of the Applicant Nilesh Pratap More on
executing Supurtnama of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rs. Five Lac only).
[c]
The Applicant shall not sell or transfer the vehicle till disposal of
Session Case No.14/2023, pending before the learned Sessions Judge,
Basmath, Dist.Hingoli.
[d]
On expiry of the insurance policy, he shall get the vehicle insured.
khs/Sept.2026/283
- 11 -
[e]
The Applicant shall produce the vehicle as and when ordered by
this Court.
[f]
He shall not use the vehicle in commission of crime and shall not
make any structural changes in the design and nature of the vehicle.
( SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.)
khs/Sept.2026/283
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review