Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.S.DIAS
WEDNESDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF AUGUST 2024 / 16TH SRAVANA, 1946
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
CRIME NO.1424/2023 OF NORTH PARAVUR POLICE STATION, ERNAKULAM
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED IN SC NO.692 OF 2024 OF ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT COURT & MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL , NORTH PARAVUR
PETITIONER:
NIKHIL PRAKASH
AGED 30 YEARS
S/O.PRAKASAN K.R, KUZHIPPILLY HOUSE, VANIYAKKADU,
KOTTUVALLI, NORTH PARAVUR, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT., PIN 683519
BY ADV NIREESH MATHEW
RESPONDENT:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
ERNAKULAM, KOCHI., PIN - 682031
OTHER PRESENT:
sr pp smt seetha s
THIS BAIL APPLICATION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 07.08.2024, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
ORDER
The application is filed under Section 439 of the Code
of
Criminal
Procedure,
by
the
1st
accused
in
Crime
No.1424/2023 of the North Paravur Police Station, Ernakulam,
which
is
registered
against
the
accused
for
allegedly
committing the offences punishable under Sections 8, 22(c)
and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act, 1985 (in short, ‘the Act’). The petitioner was arrested and
remanded to judicial custody on 07.12.2023.
2. The essence of the prosecution case is that; On
03.12.2023, at around 8:20 hours, the accused, in furtherance
of their common intention, transported 1.810 kgs of MDMA to
the State of Kerala and had stored it in a rented house of the
4th accused.
On getting secret information, the Detecting
Officer and party conducted a search and seized 1.810 kgs of
MDMA, which were stored in four packets, from the stepney
tyre of a car bearing registration No.HR-26/AW-5754. In the
further search that was conducted in the house of the 4th
accused, 14 gms of MDMA was seized from the top of an
almirah. Accordingly, a total quantity of 1.824 kgs of MDMA
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
was seized from the possession of the accused. Thus, the
accused have committed the above offences.
3. Heard; Sri.Nireesh Mathew, the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner and Sri.Seetha S, the learned
Senior Public Prosecutor.
4.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
submitted that the petitioner is totally innocent of the
accusations levelled against him. The Investigating Officer has
deliberately made the petitioner an accused in the case,
without any cogent materials. In fact, even going by the
prosecution case, the petitioner was only a passenger in the
car from which the contraband was allegedly seized. By
Annexure A4 order dated 22.07.2024 in BA No.3719/2024, this
Court has enlarged the 4th accused on bail on a prima facie
finding that there is an infraction of Sec.52A of the Act and
Rules 3, 5, 8, 9 & 10 of the NDPS (Seizure, Storage, Sampling
and Disposal Rules, 2022. The petitioner has allegedly played
a lesser role than the 4th accused. Therefore, the petitioner is
entitled for parity with the 4th accused. Hence, the application
may be allowed.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
6.
application.
Learned
She
Public
submitted
Prosecutor
that
there
2024:KER:59802
opposed
are
the
incremating
materials to substantiate the petitioner’s involvement in the
crime. Since the contraband involved is of a commercial
quantity, the rigor under Sec.37 of the Act applies to the facts
of this case. Nonetheless, she did not dispute that fact that the
4th respondent has been enlarged on bail by Annexure A4
order of this Court. She prayed that the application may be
dismissed.
7. The prosecution allegation is that, the accused had a
hatched conspiracy to transport MDMA to the State for the
purpose of sale. On the basis of the secret information
received by the Detecting Officer, a search was conducted in
the house of the petitioner and 1.824 kgs of MDMA was seized
from a car and the petitioner’s house. Nonetheless, the
contraband has now turned out to be methamphetamine as per
the chemical analysis report. Even then, the contraband is of a
commercial quantity.
8. On a perusal of Annexure 4 order, it is seen that this
Court had, after appreciating the rival submissions made
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
across the Bar, directed the Investigating Officer to file an
affidavit stating the reason why the contraband in five packets
were mixed and transferred to a single packet before
producing the same before the Magistrate. The Investigating
Officer had filed an affidavit stating that it was the Detecting
Officer who had transferred the contraband substance from
the five packets, mixed and put the substance in one packet. It
is taking into account this crucial aspect, that the Detecting
Officer
transferred
and
mixed
the
contraband
before
producing the same before the Magistrate, this Court allowed
the application by Annexure A4 order.
9. Section 52 A of the Act, which is germane to the
case on hand, reads as follows:
[52-A. Disposal of seized narcotic drugs and
psychotropic
substances.—
[(1)
The
Central
Government may, having regard to the hazardous nature,
vulnerability to theft, substitution, constraint of proper
storage space or any other relevant consideration, in
respect of any narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances,
controlled substances or conveyances, by notification in
the Official Gazette, specify such narcotic drugs,
psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyance or class of narcotic drugs, class of
psychotropic substances, class of controlled substances
or conveyances, which shall, as soon as may be after their
seizure, be disposed of by such officer and in such
manner as that Government may, from time to time,
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
determine after following the procedure hereinafter
specified.]
(2) Where any [narcotic drugs, psychotropic
substances, controlled substances or conveyances]
has been seized and forwarded to the officer-incharge of the nearest police station or to the officer
empowered under Section 53, the officer referred to
in sub-section (1) shall prepare an inventory of such
[narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, controlled
substances or conveyances] containing such details
relating to their description, quality, quantity, mode
of packing, marks, numbers or such other
identifying particulars of the [narcotic drugs,
psychotropic substances, controlled substances or
conveyances] or the packing in which they are
packed, country of origin and other particulars as
the officer referred to in sub section (1) may
consider relevant to the identity of the [narcotic
drugs,
psychotropic
substances,
controlled
substances or conveyances] in any proceedings
under this Act and make an application, to any
Magistrate for the purpose of—
(a) certifying the
inventory so prepared; or
correctness
of
the
(b) taking, in the presence of such
Magistrate, photographs of [such drugs, substances
or conveyances] and certifying such photographs as
true; or
(c) allowing to draw representative samples
of such drugs or substances, in the presence of such
Magistrate and certifying the correctness of any list
of samples so drawn.
(3) Where an application is made under subsection (2), the Magistrate shall, as soon as may be, allow
the application. (4) Notwithstanding anything contained
in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872) or the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), every court
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
trying an offence under this Act, shall treat the inventory,
the photographs of [narcotic drugs, psychotropic
substances, controlled substances or conveyances] and
any list of samples drawn under sub-section (2) and
certified by the Magistrate, as primary evidence in
respect of such offence.]
10. By virtue of the power conferred under Section 76
of the Act, the Central Government has promulgated the
Narcotic
Drugs
and
Psychotropic
Substances
(Seizure,
Storage, Sampling and Disposal) Rules, 2022, which came into
effect from 23.12.2022.
11. It is gainful to refer to Rules 3 and 10 of the said
rules, which reads thus:
“Rule 3. Classification of seized material. – (1) The
narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances and controlled
substances seized under the Act shall be classified based on
physical properties and results of the drug detection kit, if
any, and shall be weighed separately.
(2) If the narcotic drugs, psychotropic
substances and controlled substances are found in
packages or containers, such packages and containers
shall be weighed separately and serially numbered for
the purpose of identification.
(3) All narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances and
controlled substances found in loose form shall be packed
in tamper proof bag or in container, which shall be serially
numbered and weighed and the particular of drugs and the
date of seizure shall also be mentioned on such bag or
container: Provided that bulk quantities of ganja, poppy
straw may be packed in gunny bags and sealed in such way
that it cannot be tempered with: Provided further that
seized concealing material such as trolley bags, backpack
and other seized articles shall be sealed separately.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
(4) The classification, weighing, packaging and
numbering referred to in this sub-rule shall be done in the
presence of search witnesses (Panchas) and the person
from whose possession the drugs and substances was
recovered and a mention to this effect shall invariably be
made in the panchnama drawn on the spot of seizure.
(5) The detailed inventory of the packages,
containers, conveyances and other seized articles shall be
prepared and attached to the panchnama.
Rule 10. Drawing the samples. – (1) One sample,
in duplicate, shall be drawn from each package and
container seized.
(2) When the packages and containers seized
together are of identical size and weight bearing identical
marking and the contents of each package give identical
results on colour test by the drugs identification kit,
conclusively indicating that the packages are identical in all
respects, the packages and containers may carefully be
bunched in lots of not more than ten packages or containers,
and for each such lot of packages and containers, one
sample, in duplicate, shall be drawn: Provided that in the
case of ganja, poppy straw and hashish (charas) it may be
bunched in lots of not more than fourty packages or
containers.
(3) In case of drawing sample from a particular lot,
it shall be ensured that representative sample in equal
quantity is taken from each package or container of that lot
and mixed together to make a composite whole from which
the samples are drawn for that lot.” (emphasis supplied)
12. While interpreting Section 52 A of the Act, the
Honourable Supreme Court in Union of India v. Mohanlal
[(2016) 3 SCC 379] observed as follows:
“15. It is manifest from Section 52-A(2)(c) (supra)
that upon seizure of the contraband the same has to be
forwarded either to the officer-in-charge of the nearest
police station or to the officer empowered under Section 53
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
who shall prepare an inventory as stipulated in the said
provision and make an application to the Magistrate for
purposes of (a) certifying the correctness of the inventory,
(b) certifying photographs of such drugs or substances taken
before the Magistrate as true, and (c) to draw representative
samples in the presence of the Magistrate and certifying the
correctness of the list of samples so drawn.
16. Sub-section (3) of Section 52-A requires that the
Magistrate shall as soon as may be allow the application.
This implies that no sooner the seizure is effected and
the contraband forwarded to the officer-in-charge of
the police station or the officer empowered, the officer
concerned is in law duty-bound to approach the
Magistrate for the purposes mentioned above
including grant of permission to draw representative
samples in his presence, which samples will then be
enlisted and the correctness of the list of samples so
drawn certified by the Magistrate. In other words, the
process of drawing of samples has to be in the
presence and under the supervision of the Magistrate
and the entire exercise has to be certified by him to be
correct.
17. The question of drawing of samples at the
time of seizure which, more often than not, takes place
in the absence of the Magistrate does not in the above
scheme of things arise. This is so especially when
according to Section 52-A(4) of the Act, samples drawn and
certified by the Magistrate in compliance with sub-sections
(2) and (3) of Section 52-A above constitute primary
evidence for the purpose of the trial. Suffice it to say that
there is no provision in the Act that mandates taking of
samples at the time of seizure. That is perhaps why none of
the States claim to be taking samples at the time of seizure”.
(emphasis given)
13. The Honourable Supreme Court has followed the
principles laid down in Mohanlal’s case in the subsequent
cases
of
identical
nature,
namely,
Bothilal
v.
The
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
Intelligence Officer, NCB [2023 SCC OnLine SC 498],
Simarnjit Singh v. State of Punjab [2023 SCC OnLine SC
906] Mangilal v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2023 SCC
OnLine SC 862] and Yusuf @ Asif v. State [2023 SCC OnLine
SC 1328].
14. In Yusuf @ Asif’s case, the Honourable Supreme
Court has held that in the absence of any material to establish
that the samples of the seized contraband were drawn in the
presence of the Magistrate and that the inventory of the seized
contraband was duly certified by the Magistrate, then the
seized contraband and the samples drawn would not be a valid
piece of primary evidence in trial. Therefore, the trial will
stand vitiated.
15. On a comprehensive evaluation of the above
referred section, rules, and their interpretations in the above
cited judgments, leaves room for no doubt that it is mandatory
for the Investigating Officer to prepare an inventory of the
seized
narcotic
drugs/psychotropic
substances/controlled
substances with all such details relating to their description,
quality, quantity, mode of packing, marks, numbers or such
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
other identifying particulars, and then make an application to
the Magistrate to permit him to draw the representative
samples of such contraband in the presence of the Magistrate
so as to certify the correctness of the inventory so prepared. If
the contraband is found in packages or containers, such
packages/containers shall be weighed separately and serially
numbered for the purpose of identification and one sample, in
duplicate, shall be drawn from each package/container seized.
16. The word used in the above provisions is ‘shall’ and
not ‘may’, which establishes that the rule is mandatory and not
directory.
17. It is to be remembered that it is after a cleavage of
opinion
on
the
interpretation
of
the
Standing
Orders/Instructions on the procedure to be followed in the
drawal, storage, testing and disposal of samples seized under
the Act, that the Central Government has framed the above
Rules, making it mandatory to draw representative samples
from each seized package/container.
18. Even before the framing of the rules, in Khet Singh
v. Union of India [(2002) 4 SCC 380], the Honourable Supreme
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
Court observed in the following manner:
2024:KER:59802
“10. The instructions issued by the Narcotics
Control Bureau, New Delhi are to be followed by the officerin-charge of the investigation of the crimes coming within
the purview of the NDPS Act, even though these instructions
do not have the force of law. They are intended to guide the
officers and to see that a fair procedure is adopted by the
officer-in-charge of the investigation.
19. In cases of a similar nature, where the Detecting
Officer mixed the samples contained in different covers and
put the contraband in one cover and sent the sample for
analysis, the Rajasthan High Court in Netram v. State of
Rajasthan [2014 (2) WLN 394 (Raj).] and the Delhi High
Court in
Edward Khimani Kamau v. The Narcotics
Control Bureau [2015 SCC OnLine Del 9860] and Amani
Fidel Chris v. Narcotics Control Bureau [2020 SCC OnLine
Del 2080] relying on Section 52 A and the Standing
Instructions/Orders have held that the mixing of contents and
the failure to send representative samples not only lose the
sanctity of the case property in the individual cover, but also
the evidence of the quantity in each cover, and it causes
serious prejudice to the accused. [Read also the decisions in
Shajahan v. Inspector of Excise (2019 SCC OnLine Ker
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
3685) and Kulwinder Kumar v. State of Punjab (2018 SCC
OnLine P&H 1754)].
20. In the instant case, irrefutably, the Detecting
Officer had found four packets in the stepney tyre and one
packet on the top of the almirah. Without obtaining the
permission of the Jurisdictional Magistrate, the Detecting
Officer had mixed the alleged contraband in the five packets
and then transferred them to one cover and then produced the
same before the Magistrate, and then drew the representative
sample from the one cover, and sent the same for chemical
analysis, which is in total contravention of the provisions of
law. When the statutory provisions mandate a particular
procedure to be followed, the Detecting Officer was dutybound to follow the prescribed procedure. No person can
assume the nature of the substance on speculation and
conjectures. It is to ensure a fair trial that the legislature has
incorporated the above safeguards in the above provisions.
21. Now, the question is whether the above question
can be considered in an application filed under Section 439 of
the CrPC.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
22. In Bharat Chaudhary v. Union of India [(2021)
20 SCC 50], a three-judge Bench of the Honourable Supreme
Court, in an appeal arising from an order cancelling the bail,
has held in the following manner:
“13. In the absence of any clarity so far on the
quantitative analysis of the samples, the prosecution cannot
be heard to state at this preliminary stage that the
petitioners have been found to be in possession of
commercial quantity of psychotropic substances as
contemplated under the NDPS Act. Further, a large number
of the tablets that have been seized by DRI admittedly
contain herbs/medicines meant to enhance male potency and
they do not attract the provisions of the NDPS Act. Most
importantly, none of the tablets were seized by the
prosecution during the course of the search conducted,
either at the office or at the residence of A-4 at Jaipur, on 163-2020. Reliance on printouts of WhatsApp messages
downloaded from the mobile phone and devices seized from
the office premises of A-4 cannot be treated at this stage as
sufficient material to establish a live link between him and A1 to A-3, when even as per the prosecution, scientific reports
in respect of the said devices is still awaited”.(emphasis
given)
23. In State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh [(1999) 6 SCC
172] a Constitutional Bench has observed in the following
lines:
“45……… …….. ……… If Pooran Mal [(1974) 1 SCC
345 : 1974 SCC (Tax) 114] judgment is read in the manner in
which it has been construed in State of H.P. v. Pirthi Chand
[(1996) 2 SCC 37 : 1996 SCC (Cri) 210] (though that issue did
not strictly speaking arise for consideration in that case),
then there would remain no distinction between recovery of
illicit drugs etc. seized during a search conducted “after”
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
following the provisions of Section 50 of the NDPS Act and a
seizure made during a search conducted “in breach of” the
provisions of Section 50 of the NDPS Act. Prosecution cannot
be permitted to take advantage of its own wrong. Conducting
a fair trial for those who are accused of a criminal offence is
the cornerstone of our democratic society. A conviction
resulting from an unfair trial is contrary to our concept of
justice. Conducting a fair trial is both for the benefit of the
society as well as for an accused and cannot be abandoned.
While considering the aspect of fair trial, the nature of the
evidence obtained and the nature of the safeguard violated
are both relevant factors. Courts cannot allow admission of
evidence against an accused, where the court is satisfied that
the evidence had been obtained by a conduct of which the
prosecution ought not to take advantage particularly when
that conduct had caused prejudice to the accused. If after
careful consideration of the material on record it is found by
the court that the admission of evidence collected in search
conducted in violation of Section 50 would render the trial
unfair then that evidence must be excluded….. ……”
24. Again in Khet Singh’s case it is held as follows:
“16. Law on the point is very clear that even if there
is any sort of procedural illegality in conducting the search
and seizure, the evidence collected thereby will not become
inadmissible and the court would consider all the
circumstances and find out whether any serious prejudice had
been caused to the accused. If the search and seizure was in
complete defiance of the law and procedure and there was
any possibility of the evidence collected likely to have been
tampered with or interpolated during the course of such
search or seizure, then, it could be said that the evidence is
not liable to be admissible in evidence”.
25. It may be true that in the present case when the
quantity of the contraband allegedly seized from the accused
is added, it will fall within the ambit of a commercial quantity
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
as specified in Serial No.159 of the Specification of the Small
and Commercial Quantity of Narcotic Drug or Psychotropic
Substance (SO 1055 (E) dated 19.10.2001 as amended), and
consequentially the rigour under Section 37 of the Act will
apply.
26. Section 37 mandates that a person who is accused
of an offence under Sections 19, 24 and 27-A of the Act and
also involving commercial quantity shall not be released on
bail unless the court is satisfied that there are reasonable
grounds to believe that the accused is not guilty and is not
likely to commit any offence while on bail.
27. The prosecution does not have a case that the
petitioner has criminal antecedents.
28. In Dheeraj Kumar Shukla v. The State of Uttar
Pradesh [2023 SCC OnLine SC 918], the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held that the second limb under Section 37 of the
NDPS Act can be diluted if the accused has no criminal
antecedents.
29. On an overall conspectus of the facts, rival
submission made across the Bar, the law referred to the afore-
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
cited judgments and my findings rendered above, particularly
regarding the infraction of the statutory provisions by the
Detecting Officer, which has obviously caused prejudice to the
petitioner, and on comprehending the fact that petitioner has
no criminal antecedents, I find that there are reasonable
grounds to hold that the petitioner has not committed the
alleged offence and is not likely to commit the offence.
Therefore, the rigour under Section 37 stands diluted and the
petitioner is entitled to be released on bail. In the result, the
application is allowed, by directing the petitioner to be
released on bail on him executing a bond for Rs.1,00,000/(Rupees One lakh only) with two solvent sureties each for the
like sum, to the satisfaction of the court having jurisdiction,
which shall be subject to the following conditions:
(i) The petitioner shall appear before the
Investigating Officer as and when required;
(ii) The petitioner shall not directly or
indirectly make any inducement, threat or procure
to any person acquainted with the facts of the case
to dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
court or to any Police Officer or tamper with the
evidence in any manner, whatsoever;
(iii) The petitioner shall not commit any
offence while they are on bail;
(iv)
The
petitioner
shall
surrender
his
passport, if any, before the court below at the time
of execution of the bond. If he has no passport, he
shall file an affidavit to the effect before the court
below on the date of execution of the bond;
(v) In case of violation of any of the
conditions mentioned above, the jurisdictional court
shall be empowered to consider the application for
cancellation of bail, if any filed, and pass orders on
the same in accordance with law.
(vi) Applications for deletion/modification of
the bail conditions shall be filed and entertained
before the court below.
(vii) Needless to mention, it would be well
within the powers of the Investigating Officer to
investigate the matter and, if necessary, to effect
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
recoveries on the information, if any, given by the
petitioner even while the petitioner is on bail as laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sushila
Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another [2020
(1) KHC 663].
sd/C.S.DIAS
JUDGE
Nsd
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024
2024:KER:59802
APPENDIX OF BAIL APPL. 6254/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure 1
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF THE SEARCH LIST DATED
03.12.2023 PREPARED BY THE SUB INSPECTOR OF
POLICE, NORTH PARAVUR POLICE STATION
Annexure 2
TRUE PHOTO COPY OF THE FIRST INFORMATION
REPORT IN CRIME NO. 1424/2023 OF NORTH
PARAVUR POLICE STATION DATED 03.12.2023
Annexure 3
ORDER DATED 22-07-2024 IN BAIL APPL.3720/2024
ON HIGH COURT
Annexure 4
ORDER DATED 22-07-2024 IN BAIL APPL.3719/2024
ON HIGH COURT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review