Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 51971 of 2021
BETWEEN:1.
NIHARIKA JOSHI S/O SHRI NAVEEN JOSHI,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SERVICE B-8, DONGRE NAGR, RATLAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SHEETAL JOSHI W/O SHRI SANJAY JOSHI,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HOUSEHOLD B 8 DONGARE, NAGAR. (MADHYA
PRADESH)
3.
NAVEEN JOSHI S/O SHRI SANJAY JOSHI, AGED
ABOUT 36 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE B 8
DONARE NAGAR. (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI C. L. YADAV, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH SHRI ARPIT YADAV,
ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION
HOUSE OFFICER THRU. PS. D.D. NAGAR,
RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
ASHOK DHAMAN S/O LATE HANSRAJ
DHAMAN,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SERVICE KARAN NAGAR.
RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI KAPIL MAHANT, P.L./G.A. FOR RESPONDENT No.1)
………………………………………………………………………………………
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed
the following:
ORDER
None for the respondent No.2, despite service of notice.
2]
Heard finally. It is found that on 02.11.2023 also, none had
appeared for the respondent No.2, hence, this Court observed that
no further adjournment shall be granted. Thereafter, the matter was
again listed on 08.11.2023 but on the said date also nobody
appeared for the respondent No.2. Hence, the matter is heard
finally today in the absence of respondent No.2.
3]
This petition has been filed by the petitioners under Section
482 of the Cr.P.C., for quashing the FIR lodged at Crime
No.561/2020 and the subsequent charge-sheet as also the further
proceedings of the Trial Court in Sessions Trial No.138/2021
pending in the Court of Special Judge (SC/ST) Ratlam.
4]
In brief, the story of the prosecution is that the deceased Anil
Dhaman committed suicide by hanging on 19.10.2020, leaving
behind a long suicide note sent by him through WhatsApp to his
wife. The facts leading to the aforesaid suicide are that on
11.10.2020, the petitioner No.1 Niharika Joshi an employee in
IDBI Bank and wife of Navin Joshi the petitioner No.3, gave her
laptop for repairing to the deceased Anil Dhaman, who was the
security guard in the bank, as the deceased was also involved in
repairing the electronic items. However, when the aforesaid laptop
was returned by the deceased to the petitioner No.1 on 12.10.2020,
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
it was found that hard disk and RAM were missing from it and
thus, the petitioner No.1, her husband the petitioner no.3 and his
mother Sheetal Joshi the petitioner No.2 started harassing the
deceased and threatened him that if he does not give back the hard
disk and RAM, they will have his services terminated from the
bank and also demanded money. It was also threatened by them
that they would publish his name in the newspaper, which led the
deceased Anil Dhaman to commit suicide by hanging and these
facts have also been stated by him in the suicide note sent from his
WhatsApp account to his wife.
5]
Shri Champalal Yadav, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner has submitted that the facts of the present case are not
disputed, and even considering the suicide note left by the deceased
on its face value, it cannot be said that the petitioners ever had any
intention to abet the deceased to commit suicide. It is also
submitted that the laptop was given by the petitioner No.1 to the
deceased in the normal course of the transaction with the hope that
it would be repaired by him, however, as she found that the hard
disk and RAM were missing, she and her husband must have
scolded the deceased, which cannot be said to be an act of abetment
of the deceased to commit suicide. So far as the petitioner No.2 is
concerned, it is submitted that she has nothing to do with the
offence and merely because she happens to be the mother of the
petitioner No.3 and mother-in-law of petitioner No.1, she has also
been dragged into this litigation.
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
6]
In support of his submissions, Shri Yadav, learned senior
counsel has also relied upon certain decisions rendered by the
Supreme Court in the case of M.Mohan Vs. State reported as AIR
2011 SC 1238, relevant paras 26, 45, 46 and 50; Rajesh V. State of
Haryana reported as AIR 2019 SC 478, relevant para 8; Gangula
Mohan Reddy V. State of Andhra Pradesh reported as AIR 2010
SC 327 relevant paras 20 and 21; Bhagwan Das V. Kartar Singh
and Ors. reported as AIR 2007 SC 2045 relevant paras 15 and 16;
Sanju alias Sanjay Singh Sengar V. State of Madhya Pradesh
reported as AIR 2002 SC 1998 relevant paras 13 and 15 and
Mangat Ram V. State of Haryana, reported as AIR 2014 SC 1782
relevant para 20.
7]
Shri Yadav has also submitted that the petitioner had also
submitted a complaint to the concerned Police Station on
16.10.2020, regarding the loss of the hard disk after it was given to
the deceased, in which it was also stated that as the hard disk of
laptop is missing, if it is misused by any person, then they would
not be responsible for the same. A copy of the complaint with
receipt of the concerned Police Station is also placed on record.
Thus, it is submitted that when the petitioners have themselves not
alleged any theft against the deceased, there was no reason for them
to harass the deceased to such an extent that he would commit
suicide.
8]
Counsel for the respondent No.1/State, on the other hand, has
opposed the prayer and it is submitted that looking to the long
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
suicide note left by the deceased, no case for interference is made
out.
9]
Heard. At this juncture, it would be relevant to refer to a
decision rendered by the Supreme Court in the case of Mahendra
K.C. v. State of Karnataka, reported as (2022) 2 SCC 129 which
considers the various earlier rulings of the Supreme Court
governing the field relating to inherent powers of the High Courts
and the cases involving abetment of suicide u/s.306 of IPC. The
relevant paras of the same read as under:“21. In Bhajan Lal, this Court laid down the principles for the
exercise of the jurisdiction by the High Court in exercise of its powers
under Section 482 CrPC to quash an FIR. Ratnavel Pandian, J. laid
down the limits on the exercise of the power under Section 482 CrPC
for quashing the FIR and observed : (SCC pp. 378-79, para 102)
“102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various
relevant provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the
principles of law enunciated by this Court in a series of decisions
relating to the exercise of the extraordinary power under Article
226 or the inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC which we
have extracted and reproduced above, we give the following
categories of cases by way of illustration wherein such power
could be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of any
court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice, though it may not
be possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and
sufficiently channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid
formulae and to give an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases
wherein such power should be exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first information
report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their
face value and accepted in their entirety do not prima
facie constitute any offence or make out a case against
the accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report
and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do
not disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an
investigation by police officers under Section 156(1)
CrPC except under an order of a Magistrate within the
purview of Section 155(2) CrPC.
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the
FIR or complaint and the evidence collected in support
of the same do not disclose the commission of any
offence and make out a case against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under
Section 155(2) CrPC.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint
are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of
which no prudent person can ever reach a just
conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding
against the accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in
any of the provisions of the Code or the Act concerned
(under which a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the
institution and continuance of the proceedings and/or
where there is a specific provision in the Code or the
concerned Act, providing efficacious redress for the
grievance of the aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly
attended with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is
maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for
wreaking vengeance on the accused and with a view to
spite him due to private and personal grudge.”
The judgment in Bhajan Lal has been recently relied on by this
Court in State of Telangana v. Managipet.
22. Based on the above precedent, the High Court while exercising
its power under Section 482 CrPC to quash the FIR instituted against
the second respondent-accused should have applied the following two
tests : (i) whether the allegations made in the complaint, prima facie
constitute an offence; and (ii) whether the allegations are so improbable
that a prudent man would not arrive at the conclusion that there is
sufficient ground to proceed with the complaint. Before proceeding
further, it is imperative to briefly discuss the law on the abetment of
suicide to determine if a prima facie case under Section 306 IPC has
been made out against the respondent-accused.
X X X X
24. The essence of abetment lies in instigating a person to do a thing
or the intentional doing of that thing by an act or illegal omission. In
Ramesh Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh, a three-Judge Bench of this
Court, speaking through R.C. Lahoti, J. (as the learned Chief Justice
then was), observed : (SCC p. 629, para 20)
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
“20. Instigation is to goad, urge forward, provoke, incite or
encourage to do “an act”. To satisfy the requirement of
instigation though it is not necessary that actual words must be
used to that effect or what constitutes instigation must
necessarily and specifically be suggestive of the consequence.
Yet a reasonable certainty to incite the consequence must be
capable of being spelt out. The present one is not a case where
the accused had by his acts or omission or by a continued
course of conduct created such circumstances that the
deceased was left with no other option except to commit suicide
in which case an instigation may have been inferred. A word
uttered in the fit of anger or emotion without intending the
consequences to actually follow cannot be said to be
instigation.””
(Emphasis Supplied)
10]
In the case of Arnab Manoranjan Goswami v. State of
Maharashtra, (2021) 2 SCC 8 also the Supreme Court had the
occasion of dealing with s.306 of IPC. The relevant paras of which
read as under:“55. More recently in M. Arjunan v. State, a two-Judge Bench of
this Court, speaking through R. Banumathi, J., elucidated the essential
ingredients of the offence under Section 306 IPC in the following
observations : (SCC p. 317, para 7)
“7. The essential ingredients of the offence under
Section 306 IPC are : (i) the abetment; (ii) the intention of
the accused to aid or instigate or abet the deceased to
commit suicide. The act of the accused, however, insulting
the deceased by using abusive language will not, by itself,
constitute the abetment of suicide. There should be
evidence capable of suggesting that the accused intended
by such act to instigate the deceased to commit suicide.
Unless the ingredients of instigation/abetment to commit
suicide are satisfied the accused cannot be convicted under
Section 306 IPC.”
56. Similarly, in another recent judgment of this Court in Ude
Singh v. State of Haryana, a two-Judge Bench of this Court, speaking
through Dinesh Maheshwari, J., expounded on the ingredients of
Section 306 IPC, and the factors to be considered in determining
whether a case falls within the ken of the aforesaid provision, in the
following terms : (SCC pp. 321-22, para 16)
“16. In cases of alleged abetment of suicide, there must
be a proof of direct or indirect act(s) of incitement to the
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
commission of suicide. It could hardly be disputed that the
question of cause of a suicide, particularly in the context
of an offence of abetment of suicide, remains a vexed one,
involving multifaceted and complex attributes of human
behaviour and responses/reactions. In the case of
accusation for abetment of suicide, the court would be
looking for cogent and convincing proof of the act(s) of
incitement to the commission of suicide. In the case of
suicide, mere allegation of harassment of the deceased by
another person would not suffice unless there be such
action on the part of the accused which compels the person
to commit suicide; and such an offending action ought to
be proximate to the time of occurrence. Whether a person
has abetted in the commission of suicide by another or not,
could only be gathered from the facts and circumstances
of each case.
16.1. For the purpose of finding out if a person has
abetted commission of suicide by another, the
consideration would be if the accused is guilty of the act
of instigation of the act of suicide. As explained and
reiterated by this Court in the decisions abovereferred,
instigation means to goad, urge forward, provoke, incite
or encourage to do an act. If the persons who committed
suicide had been hypersensitive and the action of accused
is otherwise not ordinarily expected to induce a similarly
circumstanced person to commit suicide, it may not be
safe to hold the accused guilty of abetment of suicide.
But, on the other hand, if the accused by his acts and by
his continuous course of conduct creates a situation
which leads the deceased perceiving no other option
except to commit suicide, the case may fall within the
four-corners of Section 306 IPC. If the accused plays an
active role in tarnishing the self-esteem and self-respect
of the victim, which eventually draws the victim to
commit suicide, the accused may be held guilty of
abetment of suicide. The question of mens rea on the part
of the accused in such cases would be examined with
reference to the actual acts and deeds of the accused and
if the acts and deeds are only of such nature where the
accused intended nothing more than harassment or snap
show of anger, a particular case may fall short of the
offence of abetment of suicide. However, if the accused
kept on irritating or annoying the deceased by words or
deeds until the deceased reacted or was provoked, a
particular case may be that of abetment of suicide. Such
being the matter of delicate analysis of human behaviour,
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
each case is required to be examined on its own facts,
while taking note of all the surrounding factors having
bearing on the actions and psyche of the accused and the
deceased.”
57. Similarly, in Rajesh v. State of Haryana, a two-Judge Bench of
this Court, speaking through L. Nageswara Rao, J., held as follows :
(SCC para 9)
“9. Conviction under Section 306 IPC is not
sustainable on the allegation of harassment without there
being any positive action proximate to the time of
occurrence on the part of the accused, which led or
compelled the person to commit suicide. In order to bring
a case within the purview of Section 306 IPC, there must
be a case of suicide and in the commission of the said
offence, the person who is said to have abetted the
commission of suicide must have played an active role by
an act of instigation or by doing certain act to facilitate
the commission of suicide. Therefore, the act of abetment
by the person charged with the said offence must be
proved and established by the prosecution before he
could be convicted under Section 306 IPC.”
58. In a recent decision of this Court in Gurcharan Singh v. State
of Punjab, a three-Judge Bench of this Court, speaking through
Hrishikesh Roy, J., held thus : (SCC pp. 206-07, para 15)
“15. As in all crimes, mens rea has to be established.
To prove the offence of abetment, as specified under
Section 107 IPC, the state of mind to commit a particular
crime must be visible, to determine the culpability. In
order to prove mens rea, there has to be something on
record to establish or show that the appellant herein had a
guilty mind and in furtherance of that state of mind,
abetted the suicide of the deceased.”
59. In Vaijnath Kondiba Khandke v. State of Maharashtra, a twoJudge Bench of this Court, speaking through U.U. Lalit, J., dealt with
an appeal against the rejection of an application under Section 482
CrPC, for quashing an FIR registered under Sections 306 and 506 read
with Section 34 IPC. A person serving in the office of the Deputy
Director of Education, Aurangabad had committed suicide on 8-82017. His wife made a complaint to the police that her husband was
suffering from mental torture as his superiors were getting heavy work
done from her husband. This resulted in him having to work from 10
a.m. to 10 p.m. and even at odd hours and on holidays. The specific
allegation against the appellant was that he had stopped the deceased’s
salary for one month and was threatening the deceased that his
increment would be stopped. This Court noted that there was no
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
suicide note, and the only material on record was in the form of
assertions made by the deceased’s wife in her report to the police. The
Court went on to hold that the facts on record were inadequate and
insufficient to bring home the charge of abetment of suicide under
Section 306 IPC. The mere factum of work being assigned by the
appellant to the deceased, or the stoppage of salary for a month, was
not enough to prove criminal intent or guilty mind. Consequently,
proceedings against the appellant were quashed.
60. On the other hand, we must also notice the decision in Praveen
Pradhan where a two-Judge Bench of this Court, speaking through
B.S. Chauhan, J., dismissed an appeal against the rejection of an
application under Section 482 CrPC by the High Court for quashing a
criminal proceeding, implicating an offence under Section 306 IPC.
The suicide note which was left behind by the deceased showed, as
this Court observed, that “the appellant perpetually humiliated,
exploited and demoralised the deceased, who was compelled to
indulge in wrongful practices at the workplace, which hurt his selfrespect tremendously.” The Court noted that the appellant always
scolded the deceased and tried to always force the deceased to resign.
Resultantly, the Court observed : (SCC p. 741, para 19)
“19. Thus, the case is required to be considered in the
light of the aforesaid settled legal propositions. In the
instant case, alleged harassment had not been a casual
feature, rather remained a matter of persistent harassment.
It is not a case of a driver; or a man having an illicit
relationship with a married woman, knowing that she also
had another paramour; and therefore, cannot be compared
to the situation of the deceased in the instant case, who
was a qualified graduate engineer and still suffered
persistent harassment and humiliation and additionally,
also had to endure continuous illegal demands made by
the appellant, upon nonfulfilment of which, he would be
mercilessly harassed by the appellant for a prolonged
period of time. He had also been forced to work
continuously for long durations in the factory, vis-à-vis
other employees which often even entered to 16-17 hours
at a stretch. Such harassment, coupled with the utterance
of words to the effect, that, “had there been any other
person in his place, he would have certainly committed
suicide” is what makes the present case distinct from the
aforementioned cases. Considering the facts and
circumstances of the present case, we do not think it is a
case which requires any interference by this Court as
regards the impugned judgment and order of the High
Court. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed accordingly.”
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
The contents of the FIR, therefore, indicated that the deceased had
been subjected to harassment persistently and continuously and this
was coupled by words used by the accused which led to the
commission of suicide.
61. In Narayan Malhari Thorat v. Vinayak Deorao Bhagat, this
Court, speaking through U.U. Lalit, J., reversed the judgment of a
Division Bench of the High Court which had quashed criminal
proceedings in exercise of the jurisdiction under Section 482. This was
a case where the FIR was registered pursuant to the information
received from the appellant. The FIR stated that the son and daughterin-law of the appellant were teachers in Zila Parishad School. The
respondent used to call the daughter-in-law of the appellant on the
phone and used to harass her. Moreover, despite the efforts of the son
of the appellant, the respondent did not desist from doing so. This
Court noted : (SCC p. 603, para 12)
“12. We now consider the facts of the present case.
There are definite allegations that the first respondent
would keep on calling the wife of the victim on her
mobile and keep harassing her which allegations are
supported by the statements of the mother and the wife of
the victim recorded during investigation. The record
shows that 3-4 days prior to the suicide there was an
altercation between the victim and the first respondent. In
the light of these facts, coupled with the fact that the
suicide note made definite allegation against first
respondent, the High Court was not justified in entering
into question whether the first respondent had the
requisite intention to aid or instigate or abet the
commission of suicide. At this juncture when the
investigation was yet to be completed and charge-sheet, if
any, was yet to be filed, the High Court ought not to have
gone into the aspect whether there was requisite mental
element or intention on part of the respondent.”
The above observations of the Court clearly indicated that there
was a specific allegation in the FIR bearing on the imputation that the
respondent had actively facilitated the commission of suicide by
continuously harassing the spouse of the victim and in failing to
rectify his conduct despite the efforts of the victim.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
11]
In the case of M. Mohan V. State, AIR 2011 SC 1238, the
Supreme Court has held as under:“26. The case of the prosecution is that on 14th January,2005, the
deceased wanted to use the family car to go to the Theme Park at
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
Madurai from Karaikudi along with other family members but she was
denied the permission to use the car. At that juncture Easwari (A-3)
taunted the deceased that if she wanted to go around in a car, she has
to get a car from her parents. These words deeply hurt the deceased
and she had committed suicide on 18th January,2005 at 1.30 p.m. at
her matrimonial home.
X X X X
45. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or
intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act
on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide,
conviction cannot be sustained.
46. The intention of the Legislature and the ratio of the cases decided
by this court are clear that in order to convict a person under section
306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also
requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit
suicide seeing no option and this act must have been intended to push
the deceased into such a position that he/she committed suicide.
X X X X
50. Undoubtedly, the deceased had died because of hanging. The
deceased was undoubtedly hyper-sensitive to ordinary petulance,
discord and differences which happen in our day-to-day life. In a joint
family, instances of this kind are not very uncommon. Human
sensitivity of each individual differs from person to person. Each
individual has his own idea of self-esteem and self-respect. Different
people behave differently in the same situation. It is unfortunate that
such an episode of suicide had taken place in the family. But the
question remains to be answered is whether the appellants can be
connected with that unfortunate incident in any manner?”
(Emphasis Supplied)
12]
In the case of Sanju @ Sanjay Singh Sengar v. State of
Madhya Pradesh, AIR 2002 SC 1998, the Supreme Court has held
as under:“13. Reverting to the facts of the case, both the courts below have
erroneously accepted the prosecution story that the suicide by the
deceased is the direct result of the quarrel that had taken place on 25th
July, 1998 wherein it is alleged that the appellant had used abusive
language and had reportedly told the deceased 'to go and die'. For this,
the courts relied on a statement of Shashi Bhushan, brother of the
deceased, made under Section 161 Cr.P.C. when reportedly the
deceased, after coming back from the house of the appellant, told him
that the appellant had humiliated him and abused him with filthy
words. The statement of Shashi Bhushan, recorded under Section
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
161 Cr.P.C. is annexed as annexure P-3 to this appeal and going
through the statement, we find that he has not stated that the deceased
had told him that the appellant had asked him 'to go and die'. Even if
we accept the prosecution story that the appellant did tell the deceased
'to go and die', that itself does not constitute the ingredient of
'instigation'. The word 'instigate' denotes incitement or urging to do
some drastic or unadvisable action or to stimulate or incite. Presence
of mens rea, therefore, is the necessary concomitant of instigation. It is
common knowledge that the words uttered in a quarrel or in a spur of
the moment cannot be taken to be uttered with mens rea. It is in a fit of
anger and emotional. Secondly, the alleged abusive words, said to have
been told to the deceased were on 25th July, 1998 ensued by quarrel.
The deceased was found hanging on 27th July, 1998. Assuming that
the deceased had taken the abusive language seriously, he had enough
time in between to think over and reflect and, therefore, it cannot be
said that the abusive language, which had been used by the appellant
on 25th July, 1998 drived the deceased to commit suicide. Suicide by
the deceased on 27th July, 1998 is not proximate to the abusive
language uttered by the appellant on 25th July, 1998. The fact that the
deceased committed suicide on 27th July, 1998 would itself clearly
pointed out that it is not the direct result of the quarrel taken place on
25th July, 1998 when it is alleged that the appellant had used the
abusive language and also told the deceased to go and die. This fact
had escaped notice of the courts below.
X X X X
15. A plain reading of the suicide note would clearly show that the
deceased was in great stress and depressed. One plausible reason could
be that the deceased was without any work or avocation and at the
same time indulged in drinking as revealed from the statement of the
wife Smt. Neelam Sengar. He was a frustrated man. Reading of the
suicide note will clearly suggest that such a note is not a handy work
of a man with sound mind and sense. Smt. Neelam Sengar, wife of the
deceased, made a statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. before the
Investigation Officer. She stated that the deceased always indulged in
drinking wine and was not doing any work. She also stated that on
26th July, 1998 her husband came to them in an inebriated condition
and was abusing her and other members of the family. The prosecution
story, if believed, shows that the quarrel between the deceased and the
appellant had taken place on 25th July, 1998 and if the deceased came
back to the house again on 26th July, 1998, it cannot be said that the
suicide by the deceased was the direct result of the quarrel that had
taken pace on 25th July, 1998. Viewed from the aforesaid
circumstances independently, we are clearly of the view that the
ingredients of 'abetment' are totally absent in the instant case for an
offence under Section 306 I.P.C. It is in the statement of the wife that
the deceased always remained in a drunkened condition. It is a
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
common knowledge that excessive drinking leads one to debauchery.
It clearly appeared, therefore, that the deceased was a victim of his
own conduct unconnected with the quarrel that had ensued on 25th
July, 1998 where the appellant is stated to have used abusive language.
Taking the totality of materials on record and facts and circumstances
of the case into consideration, it will lead to irresistible conclusion that
it is the deceased and he alone, and none else, is responsible for his
death.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
13]
Having considered the rival submissions and on perusal of
the charge-sheet, it is found that the only piece of evidence
available in the charge-sheet is a long suicide note left by the
deceased, sent through his WhatsApp account to his wife, and so
far as the statements of other witnesses are concerned, they have
only supported the suicide note. A perusal of the suicide note also
reveals that the deceased was feeling offended by the allegations
levelled by the present petitioners when the hard disk and the RAM
of the laptop of the Petitioner no.1 was found missing after it was
given to the deceased for repairs.
14] The chronology of the events reveal that the laptop was given
to the deceased Anil Dhaman on 11.10.2020, it was returned by
him on 12.10.2020, a complaint was made by the petitioner no.3 on
16.10.2020 which is also filed along with the charge sheet, only
informing the police that since the hard disk is lost somewhere, if it
is misused by any person, they would not be held responsible for
the same, and on 19.10.2020, in the midnight Anil Dhaman
committed suicide by hanging, i.e., after 7 days of the return of
Laptop, and prior to that he also sent a suicide note through
Whatsapp to his wife.
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
15] In the considered opinion of this court, it is difficult to
perceive that loss of some part of a laptop can have such serious
consequences, and even assuming the story of the prosecution to be
true, response of the petitioners on such loss of their Laptop’s vital
parts cannot be said to be excessive when they scolded the
deceased to whom the Laptop was given for repair just a day prior
there to, in order to find out if it was the deceased only who had
stolen the same, however, it appears that the deceased was
oversensitive, and overreacted on the allegations levelled against
him by taking extreme step of committing suicide. It is also apparent
that the petitioner no.3, even in his complaint made to the police on
16.10.2020, did not allege that the parts were stolen by the
deceased Anil, but he only informed that their was laptop was
given to Anil on 11.10.2020, which was returned by him on
12.10.2020 saying that its RAM and hard disk are missing, and
they are surprised as to how and where these parts have gone
missing. And it was also stated by the Respondent no.3 Naveen
Joshi that anybody who finds those parts may return the same,
otherwise they would not be held responsible if the same is
misused by any person.
16] Testing the facts of the case on hand on the anvil of the
decisions rendered by the Supreme Court as aforesaid, it does not
appear to be a case where the petitioners intended that the deceased
should commit suicide but who committed suicide within a period
of 7-8 days of the incident, thus, it cannot also not be said that the
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
deceased was subjected to harassment by the petitioners for a
prolonged period of time and instigated him to commit suicide.
17] In view of the same, this Court is of the considered opinion
that no purpose would be served to prosecute the petitioners for the
offence of abetment of suicide as even assuming the documents
filed along with the charge-sheet on their face value, no case for
abetment can be made out against the petitioners, and the trial
would only be the misuse of the process of the Court and an
exercise in futility.
18] In view of the same, the FIR lodged at Crime No.561/2020 as
also the subsequent charge-sheet and the further proceedings of the
Trial Court initiated in Sessions Trial No.138/2021 in the Court of
Special Judge (SC/ST) Ratlam are hereby quashed.
19] With the aforesaid, the petition stands allowed and disposed
of.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
Bahar
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/29/2024
5:02:27 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review