Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:10500
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 16TH MAGHA, 1946
MACA NO. 2390 OF 2012
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 31.10.2012 IN OPMV NO.149 OF 2011 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, KOZHIKODE
APPELLANT/PETITIONER :NIDHEESH M.S, AGED 29 YEARS
KAKKOLI HOUSE, PUTHOOR AMSOM DESOM,
ERANHIKKAL P.O ELATHUR, KOZHIKODE - 673 303
BY ADVS.
SRI.R.SUDHISH
SMT.M.MANJU
SRI.K.R.RANJITH
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS :*1
V.MAJEED, S/O HAMEED (DECEASED)
MADATHIL HOUSE, CHRIYA VALAPPU,
ANJARAKANDY P.O KANNUR-673 612
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
P.B.NO.52, FORT ROAD, KANNUR-670001.
MOHANAN SO.GOPALA PILLAI
R.G. MANDIRAM HOUSE, NELLETTIL P.O.,
KOLLAM - 691 302.
*ADDL.R4 ADDL.RESPONDENTS 4 TO 7 ARE IMPLEADED :AYSHA, W/O LATE V. MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY P.O., KANNUR-673612
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
ADDL.R5
IQBAL, S/O LATE V. MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY P.O., KANNUR-673612
ADDL.R6
ANWAR, S/O LATE V. MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY P.O., KANNUR-673612
ADDL.R7
ABDUL SAMAD, S/O LATE V. MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY P.O., KANNUR-673612
*(R4 TO R7 ARE IMPLEADED AS THE ADDITIONAL
RESPONDENTS 4 TO 7 IN THIS APPEAL VIDE ORDER DTD
02/02/2024 IN IA 3/16[IA 1901/16] IN MACA 2390/12)
BY ADVS.
T.P.SAJID
PHIJO PRADEESH PHILIP
P.VANDANA
ADV.MOHAMMED NAZIR - R2
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 05.02.2025, ALONG WITH MACA.711/2012, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 16TH MAGHA, 1946
MACA NO. 711 OF 2012
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 31.10.2011 IN OPMV NO.149 OF 2011 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, KOZHIKODE
APPELLANT/1ST RESPONDENT :-
V.MAJEED [DIED]
AGED 30 YEARS, S/O.HAMEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, P.O.ANJARAKANDY, KANNUR - 673 612.
*2
ADDL.APPELLANTS 2 TO 5 ARE IMPLEADED :AYSHA, W/O LATE MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY PO, KANNUR- 673612
IQBAL, S/O LATE MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY PO, KANNUR- 673612
ANWAR, S/O LATE MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY PO, KANNUR- 673612
ABDUL SAMAD, S/O LATE MAJEED, MADATHIL HOUSE,
CHRIYA VALAPPU, ANJARAKANDY PO, KANNUR- 673612
*[ADDITIONAL APPELLANTS NO.2 TO 5 ARE IMPLEADED AS
LEGAL HEIRS OF DECEASED SOLE APPELLANT, AS PER
ORDER
DATED
09/04/2024
IN
IA-2/2024
IN
MJC
NO.31/2024 IN MACA 711/2012]
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS 2 AND 3 :1
NIDHEESH.M.S., AGED 28 YEARS,
S/O.JANARDHANA KURUP, DRIVER,KAKKOLI HOUSE,
PUTHOOR AMSOM DESOM, ERNAHIKKAL P.OELATHUR,
KOZHIKODE - 673 303.
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO.LTD
P.B.NO.52, FORT ROAD, KANNUR - 670001.
MOHAN, AGED 49 YEARS, S/O.GOPALA PILLAI,
R.G.MANDIRAMHOUSE, NEELETTIL P.O.,
KOLLAM DISTRICT - 685001.
BY ADVS.
M.MANJU
N.S.MOHAMMED USMAN
K.R.RANJITH
R.SUDHISH
ADV.MOHAMMED NAZIR - R2
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 05.02.2025, ALONG WITH MACA.2390/2012, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
COMMON JUDGMENT
The petitioner in OP(MV) No.149/2011 on the file of the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode, is the appellant in MACA No.2390 of
2012. The 1st respondent in the O.P, is the appellant in MACA No.711 of 2012.
(For the purpose of convenience, the parties are hereafter referred to as per
their rank before the Tribunal).
2. According to the petitioner on 08.06.2010 at about 11.45 pm,
while he was driving a pick up van through Kottayam – Wayanad road, a lorry
bearing registration No.KL-13-R-77 driven by the 3 rd respondent in a rash and
negligent manner, hit on his van. As a result of which, he sustained serious
injuries.
3. The 1st respondent is the owner and the 2nd respondent is the
insurer of the offending vehicle. According to the petitioner, the accident
occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle.
4. The insurance company filed a written statement, admitting the
accident as well as policy, but disputing the negligence on the part of the driver
of the offending vehicle.
5. The evidence in the case consists of the oral testimony of PW1
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
and documentary evidence Exts.A1 to A6 and B1.
6. After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal awarded a
total compensation of Rs.74,200/-.
7. Aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal, the petitioner and 1st
respondent preferred these appeals.
8.
Now the point that arises for consideration is the following:
Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal is
just and reasonable?
9. Heard Sri.Sudheesh R, the learned Counsel appearing for the
claimants, and Sri.A.A.Mohammed Nazir, the learned Standing Counsel for the
insurance company, Smt.M.Manju, the learned counsel appearing for the 1 st
respondent and Sri.T.P.Sajid , the learned counsel appearing for respondents 4
and 7.
10. In the accident the petitioner sustained fracture right femur.
From Ext.A6 OP Ticket/discharge summary, it is revealed that on 30.08.2011
bone grafting right femur was done from the Kozhikode District Co-operative
Hospital.
11. During the pendency of the appeal, the petitioner was referred to
a Medical Board constituted by the Superintendent, Medical College Hospital,
Kozhikode. As per the disability certificate received, the permanent physical
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
disability of the petitioner was assessed as 3%. Since it was issued by a
Medical Board the disability is assessed by the Medical Board and 3% is
accepted.
12. According to the petitioner, he was a driver by profession getting
a monthly income of Rs.10,000/-. However, the Tribunal fixed his notional
income at Rs.4,000/- only. The learned counsel for the petitioner would argue
that even the notional income of a coolie during the year 2010 as per the
decision in Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance
Insurance Co. Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236], will come to Rs.7,500/-. Since the
petitioner being a driver by profession, his notional income is to be fixed much
above that of a coolie. It is true that as per the decision in Ramachandrappa
(supra), the notional income of a coolie during the year 2010 will come to
Rs.7,500/-. Considering the fact that the petitioner being a driver by profession,
his notional income is fixed at Rs.10,000/-.
13. On the date of accident, the petitioner was aged 28 years.
Therefore, 40% of the monthly income is to be added towards future prospects,
as held in the decision in National Insurance Co.Ltd v Pranay Sethi [(2017)
16 SCC 680] and the multiplier to be applied is 17, as held in Sarla Verma v.
Delhi Transport Corporation, [(2009) 6 SCC 121]. In the above
circumstances, the loss of disability will come to Rs.85,680/-.
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
14.
Towards loss of income, the tribunal has awarded only
Rs.6,000/- @ Rs.4,000/- being the income for 11/2 months. In this case, the
petitioner has sustained fracture right femur and he was treated as inpatient for
26 days. Thereafter, bone grafting was done on 30.08.2011. According to the
learned counsel for the petitioner, the petitioner was treated for a total period of
more than 11/2 years. Considering the entire facts, I hold that the petitioner is
entitled to get compensation for loss of earning at least for a period of 9
months, which will come to Rs.90,000/- (10,000x9).
15.
The Tribunal has awarded only Rs.750/- towards transport to
hospital, Rs.500/- towards extra nourishment, Rs.15,000/- towards pain and
suffering and Rs.5,000/- towards loss of amenities. Considering the nature of
injuries sustained by the petitioner and the period during which he was treated
as inpatient, I hold that the compensation awarded on these heads are on the
lesser side. Hence, the compensation on the head pain and suffering, loss of
amenities, transportation and extra nourishment are enhanced to Rs.30,000/-,
Rs.15,000/-, Rs.5,000/-, Rs.5,000/- respectively.
16. No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other heads,
as the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just and reasonable.
17. Therefore, the petitioners/appellants are entitled to get a total
compensation of Rs.2,77,630/-, as modified and recalculated above and given
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
in the table below, for easy reference.
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Amount
awarded by
Tribunal
(in Rs.)
Amount Awarded in
Appeal
(in Rs.)
Loss of earnings
90000
Transport to hospital
Extra nourishment
Damage to clothings and
other articles
Treatment expenses
44,350
44,350
Bystander expenses
Pain and sufferings
15,000
30000
Loss of amenities
15000
Loss of disability
Nil
85,680
74,200
2,77,630
Total
Enhanced/reduced
18.
2,03,430
The Tribunal observed that the 3rd respondent had consumed
alcohol and was driving the vehicle, and hence the 2 nd respondent was
permitted to recover the compensation from the 1 st respondent/RC owner. The
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
learned counsel for the 1st respondent relying upon the decision of the Hon’ble
High Court in Oriental Insurance Company Ltd, Mattancherry v. Vineetha
Nair and others [2016 (4) KHC 392] would argue that unless it is established
that the driver was under the influence of alcohol pay and recovery cannot be
ordered against the registered owner.
19. The learned counsel for the 3 rd respondent would argue that as
against the 3rd respondent there was a police case under Section 185 of the
Motor Vehicles Act. At the time of evidence, PW1 also deposed that the 3 rd
respondent consumed alcohol. However, in this case there is no reliable
evidence to prove that the 3rd respondent was under the influence of alcohol at
the time of driving the vehicle. Therefore, the Tribunal was not justified in
ordering pay and recovery, and as such, the said finding is liable to be set aside
and the 1st respondent/owner of the vehicle is exonerated from the liability.
20. In the result, these Appeals are disposed of directing the 2nd
respondent to deposit a total sum of Rs.2,77,630/- (Rupees Two Lakh Seventy
Seven Thousand Six Hundred and Thirty Only), less the amount already
deposited, if any, along with interest rate as ordered by the Tribunal, from the
date of the petition till deposit/realisation, with proportionate costs, within a
period of two months from today (enhanced compensation will carry interest
@8%) .
MACA NOs. 2390 & 711 OF 2012
2025:KER:10500
21. On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal shall disburse
the entire amount to the petitioner, excluding court fee payable, if any, without
delay, as per rules.
22.
The learned counsel for the 1st respondent/owner of the
offending vehicle submitted that the 1st respondent has already paid Rs.83,789/and as such they are entitled to get back the said amount from the insurance
company. Therefore, there will be a direction to the 2 nd respondent to pay a sum
of Rs.83,789/- to the 1st respondent from out of the compensation payable to
the petitioner.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
SMA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review