Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:20598
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 16TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MACA NO. 1267 OF 2012
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 01.04.2011 IN OPMV NO.1002 OF 2006 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, ALAPPUZHA
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO.3:
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO.LTD.
ALAPPUZHA BRANCH, REP. BY ITS MANAGER.
BY ADVS.
SHRI.LAL K.JOSEPH, SC, NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
V.S.SHIRAZ BAVA
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS 1 TO 3 AND RESPONDENTS 1 AND 2:
BINDU
AGED 45 YEARS, W/O.M.R.PRAKASAN, MELAPPALLIL HOUSE,
M.P.WARD 9, MUHAMMA P.O., ALAPPUZHA, PIN-688525.
KRISHNA PRAKASH
AGED 9 YEARS, D/O.PRAKASHNAN MELAPPALLIL HOUSE,
M.P.WARD 9, MUHAMMA P.O., ALAPPUZHA, REP. BY HER MOTHER
& GUARDIAN BINDU, AGED 45 YEARS, W/O.M.R.PRAKASAN,
MELAPPALLIL HOUSE, M.P.WARD 9, MUHAMMA P.O., ALAPPUZHA,
PIN - 688 525.
NARAYANI
AGED 81 YEARS, W/O.LATE RAGHAVAN, &
M/O.M.R.PRAKASAN, MELAPPALLIL HOUSE, M.P.WARD 9,
MUHAMMA P.O., ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688 525.
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
B.SNEHALATHA
W/O.SIVANANDAN, SIVA NILAYAM, MAMAM, PARAYATHKONAM
P.O., KIZHUVALLAM PANCHAYATH, WARD V, ATTINGAL,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695 101.
JENIL S.S.
S/O.SIVANANDAN, SIVA NILAYAM, MAMAM, PARAYATHKONAM
P.O., KIZHUVALLAM PANCHAYATH, WARD V, ATTINGAL,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695 101.
BY ADVS.
SRI.A.T.ANILKUMAR
SMT.V.SHYLAJA
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 07.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 07th day of March, 2025
The Respondent No.3 in O.P.(M.V.) No.1002/2006 on
the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Alappuzha, is the appellant
herein. (For the purpose of convenience, the parties are hereafter referred to as
per their rank before the Tribunal).
2.
The O.P. was filed under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, by the wife, minor child and mother of the deceased by
the name of M. R. Prakasan, who died in a motor vehicle accident that
occurred on 07.01.2006. According to them, on 07.01.2006, at about 3:00
am, while the deceased was riding a Scooter, a car having Reg No.KL-16/B232, driven by the 2nd respondent in a rash and negligent manner, knocked
him down, and as a result of which he sustained serious injuries, and he
succumbed to the injuries on the same day.
3.
The 1st respondent is the owner , the 2 nd respondent is the
driver, and the 3rd respondent is the insurer of the offending vehicle.
According to the petitioners, the accident occurred due to the negligence of
the driver of the offending vehicle. The quantum of compensation claimed in
the O.P. was Rs.19,04,320/-, limited to Rs.19,00,000/-.
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
4.
The insurance company filed a written statement,
admitting the accident as well as policy, but disputing the negligence on the
part of the driver of the offending vehicle.
5.
The evidence in the case consists of the documentary
evidence Exts.A1 to A15 and B1. No oral evidence was adduced by the
respondents.
6.
After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal
found negligence on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle, awarded a
total compensation of Rs.4,82,640/-, and directed the insurer to pay the same.
7.
Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by
the Tribunal, Respondent No.3 in O.P.(MV) preferred this appeal.
8.
Now the point that arises for consideration is the
following:
1) Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal is just and reasonable?
2) Whether the accident occurred due to the negligence of the
deceased, as alleged by the appellant?
9.
Heard, Sri.Lal J. Joseph, the learned Counsel appearing
for the appellant, and Sri. A. T. Anilkumar, the learned Standing Counsel for
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
the 3rd respondent.
10.
The learned counsel for the 3rd respondent/appellant
would argue that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the deceased
himself and not because of the negligence of the 2nd respondent. However, it
is to be noted that in this case, the petitioners produced Ext.A7, a copy of the
charge sheet involved in the crime registered by the police in respect of the
above accident. In Ext.A7 there is a specific finding to the effect that the
accident occurred due to the negligence of the 2nd respondent. There is no
contra evidence in this case to disbelieve Ext.A7. In the above circumstances,
I find no merits in the argument advanced by the learned counsel for the 3 rd
respondent that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the deceased.
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioners would argue that
the notional income of the deceased fixed by the Tibunal at Rs.5,280/- is on
the lower side. He would argue that as per the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance
Insurance Co. Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236], the notional income of a coolie
during the year 2006 will come to Rs.5,500/-, and as such, the notional
income of the deceased may not be fixed below that of a coolie. The learned
counsel for the 3rd respondent relied upon the decision of a Single Bench of
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
this Court in Abbas v. Sabira [2024 (4) KLT 797] and argued that in the
absence of an appeal or cross objection from the side of the claimant,
compensation cannot be enhanced in an appeal filed by the insurance
company. He has also relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Sangit Arya and Others v. Oriental Insurance Company Limited and
Others [2020 KHC 6423].
12.
In the above decision in paragraph 9 the Apex Court held
that:
“Even though the Claimants/ Appellants herein did
not file an Appeal against the Award dated 22.12.2009 passed
by the MACT before the High Court, we deem it appropriate to
enhance the compensation by exercising our jurisdiction under
Art.142 of the Constitution of India in order to do complete
justice between the parties.”
13.
The learned counsel would argue that, in the above
decision, the compensation was enhanced by the Apex Court by invoking the
power under Article 142 of the Constitution, and as such, this Court has no
power to enhance compensation in an appeal filed by the Insurance Company.
14.
In the decision in Nagappa v. Gurudayal Singh and
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
Others, AIR 2003 SC 674, a three Judges Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court held that there is no restriction on the Tribunal or Court to award a
compensation amount exceeding the claim amount, and it is the duty of the
Tribunal/Court to award just compensation that is reasonable on the basis of
evidence produced by the High Court.
15.
In the decision in APSRTC represented by its General
Manager and Ors. v. V.M.Ramadevi, AIR 2008 SC 1221, another Bench of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court, relying upon the decision in Nagappa (supra),
upheld the action of the High Court in enhancing the compensation of the
claimant in the appeal filed by the insurance Company even though the
claimant only filed an appeal against the order of the Tribunal.
16.
In the decision in Surekha and Others v. Santhosh and
Others, 2020 ACJ 2156, the Apex Court was dealing with the case in which
the Bombay High Court ruled that though the appellants were entitled to get
an enhancement in compensation, the same cannot be granted as they failed to
file a Cross-Objection. In appeal, a three Judges Bench of the Apex Court
held in paragraph 3 that:
“By now it is well settled that in the matter of insurance claim
compensation in reference to the motor accidents, the Court
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
should not take hyper-technical approach and ensure that just
compensation is awarded to the affected person or the
claimants.”
17.
In the decision in Minu Rout & Ors. v. Satya
Pradyumna Mohapatra & Ors. [2013 10 SCC 695]. Though the claim of the
appellant is wants Rs.5,000/-, though the income claimed by the appellant was
Rs.5,000/-. The Apex Court held that for the purpose of determining the loss
of dependency, the actual entitlement of the salary of the deceased would
have been taken as Rs.6,000/- per month by the Tribunal for awarding just
and reasonable compensation, which is our statutory duty of the Tribunal and
Appellate Court.
18.
In the decision in Mubarak v. The Divisional Manager,
New India Assurance Co. Ltd, [2024 (5)KLT 803] . This Court held that it is
a duty of the Tribunal and the High Court to award just compensation under
each type, and it found necessary by ignoring the claim made in the
application for compensation. In the above decision, though the monthly
income claimed
Rs.8,000/-.
was Rs.5,000/-, the Court has enhanced the same to
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
19.
In the decision in Sasidharan Namboothiri v. Rajeev
Kesavan.[2025 KHC online 85], also this Court held that the Tribunals as
well as this Court have not only the Authority but also a duty to award just
and reasonable compensation with the claimants of the motor vehicles
accident, and for that purpose, on a deserving basis, even the notional income
can be fixed over and above what is claimed in the original petition.
20.
In the light of the above decisions, I do not find any
merits in the argument advanced by the learned counsel for the 3 rd respondent
that the notional income of the victim cannot be fixed over and above what is
claimed in the original petition. Therefore, the notional income of the
deceased is fixed at Rs.5,500/-.
21.
On the date of the accident, the deceased was aged 44
years. Therefore, 25% of the monthly income is liable to be added towards
future prospects, as held in the decision in National Insurance Co.Ltd v
Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680], and the multiplier to be applied is 14, as
held in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation (2009) 6 SCC 121.
Since the deceased was married who left behind three dependents, towards
personal and living expenses, 1/3 of the income is liable to be deducted, as
held in Sarla Verma (supra). In the above circumstances, the loss of
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
dependency will come to Rs.7,70,000/-.
22.
The Tribunal has awarded, Rs.2,000/- towards funeral
expenses, Rs.5,000/- towards loss of consortium, and Rs.5,000/- towards love
and affection. In the light of the decision in Pranay Sethi (supra), the
appellants are entitled to get a consolidated sum of Rs.15,000/- towards loss
of estate, Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses, and the dependents (parents,
children and spouse) are entitled to get a sum of Rs.40,000/- each towards
loss of consortium, with an increase of 10% in every three years. Therefore,
towards loss of estate and funeral expenses, they are entitled to get a sum of
Rs.18,150/- each. Towards loss of consortium, petitioners together are entitled
to get a sum of Rs.1,45,200 (48,400 x 3).
23.
Since compensation for loss of consortium was given,
further compensation for love and affection cannot be granted in view of the
decision in New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Somwati and Others,
(2020) 9 SCC 644. Therefore, the compensation awarded towards love and
affection is to be deducted.
24.
Towards the head ‘pain and sufferings’, the Tribunal has
awarded Rs.5,000/-, which according to the learned counsel for the
petitioners, is on the lower side. The deceased died on the date of the
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
accident. In the above circumstances, I hold that the compensation awarded
towards pain and suffering is on the lower side, and hence, it is enhanced to
Rs.25,000/-.
25.
No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other
heads, as the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just and
reasonable.
26.
Therefore, the petitioners/appellants are entitled to get a
total compensation of Rs.9,77,500/-, as modified and recalculated above and
given in the table below, for easy reference:
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Transport to hospital
1,000/-
1,000/-
Funeral expenses
2,000/-
18,150/-
Loss of consortium
5,000/-
1,45,200/-
Pain and suffering
5,000/-
25,000/-
Loss of love & affection etc.
5,000/-
Nil
Loss of dependency etc.
4,64,640/-
7,70,000/-
Loss of estate
Nil
18,150/-
4,82,640/-
9,77,500/-
Total
Enhanced to Rs.
27.
Amount awarded by
Tribunal (in Rs.)
Amount Awarded in
Appeal (in Rs.)
4,94,860/-
In the result, this Appeal is allowed in part, and the 3 rd
respondent is directed to deposit a total sum of Rs.9,77,500/- (Rupees Nine
MACA No.1267 of 2012
2025:KER:20598
Lakhs Seventy Seven Thousand and Five Hundred Only), less the amount
already deposited, if any, along with interest @ 8% per annum till
realisation/deposit, excluding interest for a period of 324 days, the period of
delay in filing the appeal, with proportionate costs, within a period of two
months from today.
On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal shall
disburse the entire amount to the petitioners, in the ratio fixed by the Tribunal,
excluding court fee payable, if any, without delay, as per rules.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
HKH/07.03.2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review