Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 83
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No. :- Mac App No. 104/2022
CM No. 5255/2022
Date of Pronouncement : 12.08.2026
Uploaded on :14.08.2026
….Appellant(s)
The New India Assurance Co.
Ltd.
Through :- Mr. Vipan Gandotra, Advocate
V/s
….Respondent(s)
Bholi Devi and ors.
Through: -
Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Advocate.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The present appeal has been preferred by the appellant against the
award dated 30.05.2022 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Jammu (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”) in Claim
Petition bearing File No. 69 of 2016, titled Bholi Devi & Ors. v. The
New India Assurance Company Ltd. & Ors., whereby the appellantInsurance Company has been directed to pay compensation of
₹48,32,572/- along with interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of
institution of the claim petition till its realization.
2.
The facts, in brief, giving rise to the present appeal are that on
06.03.2016, the deceased, namely Ashok Singh Charak, along with
his wife, was proceeding towards his residence from Gangyal on a
Mac App No. 104/2022
scooter bearing registration No. JK02AG-3195. On reaching near
Kunjwani, the scooter was hit by the offending vehicle, i.e., Tractor
bearing registration No. JK02BJ-3722, which was allegedly being
driven rashly and negligently by respondent No. 6 herein. As a
consequence of the accident, the deceased fell down and sustained
grievous injuries. He was taken to Government Medical College
Hospital, Jammu, where he was declared brought dead. The legal
heirs of the deceased thereafter instituted a claim petition before the
Tribunal seeking compensation on account of his death. The
deceased was serving as an Assistant Sub-Inspector (ASI) in the J&K
Police and was stated to be 55 years of age at the time of the
accident. His annual income was assessed at ₹5,94,336/-.
3.
The claim petition was contested by respondent No. 1-Insurance
Company by filing objections, inter alia, pleading that the Tractor
bearing registration No. JK02BJ-3722 was being used for a purpose
other than that for which it had been insured. It was further pleaded
that the tractor was being plied without a valid route permit and
fitness certificate; that a trailer had been attached to it without
authorization and was loaded with building material; and that
gratuitous passengers were also travelling thereon at the time of the
accident. The Tribunal, while placing reliance upon the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Company Limited
v. Pranay Sethi & Ors., (2017) 16 SCC 680, assessed and awarded
compensation under the following heads:
Mac App No. 104/2022
i. Loss of dependency = ₹46,42,572/ii. Loss of consortium = ₹1,60,000/iii. Loss of estate = ₹15,000/iv. Funeral expenses = ₹15,000/Total compensation = ₹48,32,572/4.
The Tribunal further held the claimants entitled to interest @ 7.5%
per annum on the awarded amount from the date of institution of the
claim petition till its realization and fastened the liability to satisfy
the award upon the appellant-Insurance Company.
5.
The award has been assailed by the appellant-Insurance Company
primarily on the ground that, at the time of the accident, the
trolley/trailer attached to the tractor was not insured. It is contended
that the tractor had been insured only for agricultural purposes,
whereas, at the relevant time, the trolley attached thereto was loaded
with Bajri. According to the appellant, the insured vehicle was thus
being used for a commercial purpose in breach of the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy. On this premise, it is urged that
the appellant-Insurance Company could not have been fastened with
the liability to satisfy the award.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7.
During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the appellant,
when confronted with the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
The Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company Limited v. Smt.
Honnamma & Ors., 2025 INSC 625, sought to distinguish the same
on facts. It was contended that in the aforesaid case the deceased was
Mac App No. 104/2022
travelling in the offending tractor/trailer itself, whereas, in the case at
hand, the deceased was riding a scooter which was hit by the
offending tractor. On the strength of this factual distinction, learned
counsel submitted that the ratio of the aforesaid judgment would have
no application to the present case.
8.
The aforesaid contention requires examination in the light of the
factual matrix and the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company
Limited (supra). In the said case, the deceased was travelling on a
tractor to which a trailer had been attached and was engaged as a
coolie for unloading soil. The vehicle met with an accident and the
trailer toppled, resulting in injuries to the deceased, who subsequently
succumbed thereto. The Tribunal came to the conclusion that the risk
of an employee travelling on the tractor/trailer was not covered under
the insurance policy and, accordingly, fastened the liability upon the
owner of the vehicle. The Tribunal awarded compensation to the
extent of the statutory liability, quantified at ₹9.50 lakhs. Aggrieved
by the award, the claimants approached the High Court. The High
Court enhanced the compensation to ₹13.28 lakhs along with interest
and fastened the liability to satisfy the award upon the Insurance
Company. The Insurance Company, being aggrieved, carried the
matter to the Hon’ble Supreme Court by way of Special Leave
Petition.
Mac App No. 104/2022
9.
Upon consideration of the controversy, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
dismissed the challenge of the Insurance Company and, in paragraph
12 of the judgment, held as under:
“12. Thus, the liability of the tractor/its insurer extended to the
accident caused by the tractor resulting in the death of the
deceased, through the trailer. This being the position in the
present case, the principles emanating from the decisions where
the Courts have held that the trailer has to be separately
registered with the insurance company to make it liable, would
not be applicable. To that extent, the facts in the present case are
clearly distinguishable from the ones cited by learned counsel for
the appellant. The legislation i.e., the MV Act, being beneficial
and welfare-oriented in nature [Ningamma v United India
Insurance Co. Ltd., (2009) 13 SCC 710; K Ramya v National
Insurance Co. Ltd., 2022 SCC Online SC 1338, and; Shiva Leela
v Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., 2025
SCC Online SC 563] and ultimately the root cause of the accident
being the tractor, which was insured, this crucial fact cannot be
lost sight of.For further clarification, we might illustrate: if an
insured vehicle hits another vehicle which in turn hits a third
vehicle, then for the entire chain of accidents, the liability would
pass on to the vehicle which was the root cause of the accident
because it is the result of the action in the same chain of events
which cannot be segregated or compartmentalized. Moreover,
this Court is duty-bound to be mindful of the ground realities of
our nation and cannot let practicality be overshadowed by
technicality.”
10.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court further examined the scope of the
insurance policy and the limits of liability arising there under. Upon
construing the terms of the contract of insurance, the Court found that
the liability in respect of the deceased was covered, though subject to
the stipulated limit, and that the amount payable to the claimants
could, in any event, not be less than ₹9.50 lakhs. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court, therefore, found no infirmity in the assessment of
compensation made by the High Court. However, insofar as the
amount awarded in excess of ₹9.50 lakhs is concerned, the same was
held to be recoverable from owner of the offending vehicle.
Mac App No. 104/2022
11.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, the
mere circumstance that a trailer/trolley was attached to the insured
tractor and that the same was carrying Bajri at the relevant time
cannot, by itself, constitute a valid ground to absolve the appellantInsurance Company of its liability to satisfy the award. In the present
case, it was the insured tractor which struck the scooter on which the
deceased was travelling and thereby caused the accident. It is neither
the pleaded nor the proved case of the appellant that the accident
occurred on account of the use of the trolley attached to the tractor or
that the deceased sustained fatal injuries as a consequence of the
trolley overturning or otherwise independently contributing to the
accident.
12.
No doubt, the FIR as well as the material collected during
investigation indicate that, at the time of the accident, a trolley was
attached to the tractor and was carrying building material in the
nature of Bajri. However, there is no evidence on record to establish
any causal connection between the carrying of Bajri in the trolley and
the occurrence of the accident. There is not even a suggestion in the
evidence led before the Tribunal that the accident occurred because
the trolley was loaded with Bajri. In the absence of any such
evidence, the mere attachment of the trolley or the nature of the
material being carried therein cannot be made a ground to defeat the
legitimate claim of third-party victims.
13.
In Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company Limited (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has dealt with the question of insurance
Mac App No. 104/2022
coverage in respect of a tractor with an attached trailer. In view of the
principle enunciated therein, the contention of the appellant that its
liability stands completely excluded merely because a trolley/trailer
was attached to the insured tractor cannot be accepted. More so, in
the present case, the deceased was a third party travelling on a
scooter and was neither travelling in the tractor nor in the trolley
attached thereto.
14.
There is yet another aspect of the matter. Though a tractor is
ordinarily associated with agricultural use, the evidence brought on
record assumes significance while determining whether there was
such a fundamental breach of the policy conditions as would entitle
the insurer to avoid its liability towards a third party. The witness
examined on behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company has
admitted that the policy in question was a comprehensive policy. The
vehicle was, therefore, admittedly covered by an insurance policy
extending to third-party risk.
15.
The mere fact that a trolley attached to the tractor was carrying Bajri
would not, ipso facto, establish that the tractor was being used for a
commercial purpose in breach of the policy conditions. The nature of
the material being transported, without anything further, is not
determinative of the purpose for which the vehicle was being used.
Bajri or other construction material may conceivably be transported
for purposes connected with agricultural land, farm structures or
other activities incidental thereto. What was required to be
established by the appellant was that, at the relevant time, the insured
Mac App No. 104/2022
vehicle was in fact being used for a commercial purpose contrary to
the terms and conditions of the policy.
16.
The burden to establish breach of a policy condition of such nature as
would absolve the insurer of its liability lay upon the appellantInsurance Company. No cogent evidence has been led to discharge
the said burden. The statement of the Investigating Officer, to the
extent that a trolley was attached to the tractor and was carrying
Bajri, establishes only the physical condition of the vehicle at the
relevant time. It does not establish that the tractor was being used
commercially or for hire or reward, much less that such alleged use
had any nexus with the accident. The appellant, therefore, cannot
derive any advantage merely from the fact that Bajri was found
loaded in the trolley.
17.
Viewed thus, neither the attachment of the trolley to the insured
tractor nor the transportation of Bajri therein, in the absence of
evidence establishing a breach of the policy conditions sufficient in
law to avoid liability, can exonerate the appellant-Insurance
Company from satisfying the award passed in favour of the
claimants. The contention raised by the appellant on this score is,
accordingly, without merit.
18.
For the foregoing reasons and in the light of the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in The Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance
Company Limited v. Smt. Honnamma & Ors., 2025 INSC 625, this
Court finds no ground warranting interference with the impugned
Mac App No. 104/2022
award dated 30.05.2022 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Jammu.
19.
Consequently, the appeal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed. The
balance amount of compensation, if lying deposited and not already
released, shall be released in favour of the claimants in accordance
with the terms of the award, after due verification and completion of
requisite formalities. The record of the Tribunal be sent back
forthwith along with a copy of this judgment.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
Jammu:
12.08.2026
Pawan Angotra
Whether the order is speaking : Yes
Whether the order is reportable : Yes
Mac App No. 104/2022
Pawan Angotra
2026.08.14 10:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Jammu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review