Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on:
Pronounced on:
Uploaded on:
21.07.2026
07.08.2026
07.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Mac App No. 177/2024 (O&M)
New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
Through:
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Mr. Amrit Sarin, Advocate
Q
Vs
.…. Respondent(s)
Parvaiz Ahmed Bhat and others
Through:
Mr. Arjun Mengi, Advocate for R- 1
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The instant appeal is directed against the award dated 10.08.2024 passed by
the MACT Tribunal, Ramban (for short, the "Tribunal") in the claim
petition titled "Pervaiz Ahmed Bhat vs. General Manager, New India
Assurance Company Ltd. and Others," whereby the learned Tribunal
awarded compensation of Rs. 52,79,945/-, along with interest at the rate of
7.5% per annum from the date of institution of the claim petition till the
realization of the award amount, in favour of respondent No. 1 and against
the respondent-driver/owner. Further, the appellant-insurance company was
directed to satisfy the award, with liberty to recover the same from the
respondent-driver/owner.
2.
The appellant has assailed the award on the following grounds:
i)
That the learned Tribunal has not taken into consideration that the
contributory negligence of the claimant-respondent No. 1 cannot be
overruled.
ii)
That the claimant-respondent No. 1, even if presumed to be a driver,
has suffered permanent disability only to the extent of 75% of his
right leg and the said disablement when compared with the whole
body certainly would certainly stand reduced to some extent say up
to 25%. However, the learned Tribunal has erroneously awarded
compensation by treating the claimant-respondent No. 1 as having
suffered 100% functional disability, which is contrary to the
medical evidence on record.
iii) That the alleged accident took place in 2018, as such, the wages
payable to a skilled worker, as prescribed under SRO 460 of 2017
dated 26.10.2017 were applicable, which fixed the monthly wage at
Rs. 10,500/- per month but the learned Tribunal has arbitrarily
determined monthly income of respondent No. 1 as Rs, 15,000/- per
month.
iv) That the claimant had not proved anything so far as the future
medical expenses is concerned nor has the hospital prescribed so,
still the Tribunal without any basis has awarded Rs. 1.00 lac as
compensation under the head of future medical expenses in favour
of respondent No. 1.
v)
That the learned Tribunal ought to have granted less compensation
under the heads of pain and suffering and loss of amenities of life.
Mac App No.177/2024
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company reiterated the
submissions made in the memo of appeal. He vehemently contended that
there was no evidence on record to substantiate the claim for future medical
expenses and, therefore, the learned Tribunal was not justified in awarding
compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/- under the head of future medical expenses.
4.
Mr. Arjun Mengi, learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 1,
submitted that the learned Tribunal has rightly assessed and awarded the
compensation in accordance with the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court. He, therefore, contended that the present appeal is devoid
of merit and deserves to be dismissed.
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6.
The record depicts that respondent No. 1 filed a claim petition before the
learned Tribunal under Sections 140 and 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act for
grant of compensation on account of injuries suffered by him in a road
traffic accident, that took place at Gugava Pul, Gatampur Janpad Kanpur
Nagar (Uttar Pradesh) on 16.09.2018 at about 1.00 PM. The respondent No.
1 claimed to have suffered various injuries all over the body due to accident
and more particularly, amputation of his right leg. It was stated by the
respondent No. 1 that he was getting salary of Rs. 25,000/- per month by
profession as driver and in addition to that, he was getting Rs. 500/- per trip
and in a month, he would get addition sum of Rs. 5,000/- for trips. He
further claimed that he was earning Rs. 10,000/- per month from
agricultural pursuits. On the basis of these assertions, respondent No. 1
claimed that his total monthly income was Rs. 40,000/-.
Mac App No.177/2024
7.
Appellant and respondent Nos. 2 and 3 were put to notice but respondent
Nos. 2 and 3 did not cause appearance, as such, they were set ex parte.
Appellant-insurance Company filed the response before the Tribunal,
thereby objecting the claim of the respondent No. 1. On the basis of the
pleadings of the parties, following issues were framed:
i)
Whether the petitioner was driving the vehicle (Truck) bearing
No. HR 68B-0354 and met with an accident at Gugava Pul,
Gatampur Janpad Kanpur Nagar (Utter Pradesh) due to rash and
negligent driving by the respondent No. 3 who was plying the
offending vehicle bearing registration No. MH43Y-9530,
collided his vehicle, as a result of which petitioner received
grievous injury on head, chest and other parts of body and also
lost his right leg, leading to his permanent disablement?------OPP
ii) In case issue No. 1 is proved in affirmative, whether the
petitioner is entitled to receive the compensation, if yes, to what
amount and from whom?
........OPP
iii) Whether the offending vehicle was being driven at the time of
accident in contravention of terms and conditions of the
insurance policy and the driver was not holding a valid and
effective driving license, route permit and fitness certificate at
the time of accident, as such, the respondent insurance company
is not liable to pay compensation to the petitioner?-- OPR-1
iv) Relief?”
8.
In support of his claim, respondent No. 1 examined himself as well as PWs
Javed Ahmed, Imtiyaz Ahmed, Manzoor Ahmed, and Dr. Rafi. On the
other hand, the appellant–Insurance Company examined RW Aman Ghai,
Assistant Manager, New India Insurance Company Ltd., in support of its
defence.
9.
Learned Tribunal in terms of award dated 10.08.2024 granted compensation
of Rs. 52,79,945/- in favour of respondent No. 1 along with interest @7.5%
from the date of institution of the claim petition till its realization.
Mac App No.177/2024
10.
The first contention raised by the appellant-Insurance Company is that the
learned Tribunal has not considered that in the instant case, the contributory
negligence of the claimant cannot be overruled.
11.
The claimant/respondent No. 1 besides examining himself, also examined
PWs Javed Ahmed, Imtiyaz Ahmed, Manzoor Ahmed and Doctor Rafi in
support of his claim. Respondent No.1 and his witness namely Jawed
Ahmed have categorically stated that the accident took place due to rash
and negligence driving of the driver of the vehicle bearing registration No.
MH43Y 9530. The appellant-Insurance Company did not examine any
witness to rebut the evidence led by respondent No. 1, as such, it cannot be
said that there was contributory negligence on the part of respondent No. 1.
Strangely, the appellant-Insurance Company has not taken the plea that
there was contributory negligence on the part of respondent No. 1 but has
taken a plea that contributory negligence of respondent No. 1 cannot be
ruled out. Accordingly, there is no force in this contention of the appellant,
as such, the same is rejected.
12.
Secondly, it was contended by the appellant that the learned Tribunal has
considered the disablement of respondent No. 1 as 100%, whereas he had
suffered 75% disablement of his right leg and when compared with the
same, the same would be reduced. The respondent No. 1 by way of his
statement as well as statement of PWs Javed Ahmed and Manzoor Ahmed
have categorically proved that the respondent No. 1 was working as a
driver. Dr. Rafi, in his statement, has stated that he has lost his right leg in
the accident. He has further stated that the diagnosis of respondent No. 1
was above knee amputation lower limb and his permanent disability was
Mac App No.177/2024
75% of the involved limb on the right side of the body. The disability
certificate issued by the board of Doctors bears his signatures. He proved
the disability certificate, which was exhibited as EXPW-P2. During his
cross-examination, he admitted that the injured was a driver by profession
and, owing to the injuries sustained by him, he was no longer capable of
driving any vehicle. He further deposed that, in view of the nature of the
claimant's occupation, his functional disability was 100%.
13.
In Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India, in “Sarnam Singh vs. Shriram
General Insurance Co. ltd. and ors”. 2023 LiveLaw (SC) 498, has
observed as under:
“9.As to how compensation, in case where permanent disability of
an injured affects his functional disability, is to be assessed has
been considered by this Court, repeatedly. Reference can be made
to the judgment of this Court in Mohan Soni vs. Ram Avtar Tomar
And Others. In the aforesaid case the injured was working as a cart
puller. As a result of the accident, his left leg was amputated. His
permanent disability was assessed at 60%. The Tribunal assessed
the compensation taking the loss of earning at 50% on the
theory that he can still do some other work while sitting. The
High Court did not disturb the finding regarding loss of income
on account of disability. This Court found that the Tribunal
was in error in taking the loss of earning at 50% as the injured
was 55 years of age and it may be difficult for him to find a job
at that stage. In fact, any physical disability resulting from an
accident has to be judged with reference to the nature of the
work being performed by the person who suffered disability.
The same injury suffered by two different persons may affect
them in different ways. Loss of leg by a farmer or a rickshaw
puller may be end of the road as far as his earning capacity is
concerned. Whereas, in case of the persons engaged in some
kind of desk work in office, loss of leg may have lesser effect.
This Court enhanced the loss of earning capacity from 50% to
90%.
10. Applying the same principle to the case in hand, we find that
the appellant herein was working as a gunman with Bharat
Hotel Limited. On account of amputation of his right leg above
the knee, he was terminated from service w.e.f. 31.05.2015. It is
not a matter of dispute that a person with his right leg
amputated cannot perform the duty of a gunman. This is his
functional disability. He was 50 years & 5 months old at the
time of accident. Considering the aforesaid facts, in our view,
the Tribunal was right in assessing the loss of earning capacity
Mac App No.177/2024
of the appellant at 100% and assessing the compensation
accordingly. The High Court was in error in reducing the loss
of earning capacity to 80%, relying upon the judgment of High
Court, despite there being a judgment of this Court available
on the issue.”
Emphasis added.
14.
In “R. Halle vs. Reliance General Insurance Company ltd.”, 2026 Live
Law (SC) 261, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:
“21. However, the High Court, while observing that physical
disability cannot be mechanically equated with functional
disability, reduced the functional disability suffered by the
appellant-claimant from 63% to 30% without adverting in
detail to the medical evidence on record, particularly the
findings of the Medical Board and the neuropsychological
report evidencing cognitive deficits suffered by the appellantclaimant as a consequence of the injuries suffered in the
accident. No independent contra material was placed on record
by the respondent- insurer to displace the evidentiary value of
the disability certificate. In our considered view, such reduction
of the functional disability, in the absence of convincing
evidence impeaching the credibility of the medical certificates
placed on record by the appellant-claimant and without
assigning cogent reasons, was not at all justified. For ready
reference, the relevant extract from the impugned judgment is
reproduced herein below: “10. According to the claimant he was earning a sum of
Rs.29,108/- per month by working as a Manager in a private
concern, which has been proved through Exs.21 to 25. Thus, the
Tribunal has arrived the amount under the head of loss of
earning power, by multiplying the disability as 63%. It appears
to be on the higher side. Though the Medical Board has
assessed the physical disability of the claimant as 63%, after
going through the records, we have come to the conclusion
that the functional disability suffered by the claimant would
be 30%. After adding 40% towards future prospectus, the total
income of the claimant is arrived at Rs.40,751/-, rounded off to
Rs.40,000/-. Thereby, the claimant is entitled for an amount of
Rs.24,48,000/- (Rs.40,000/- x 12 x 30% x 17); Rs.1,00,000/- for
Loss of amenities; Rs.2,00,000/- under Pain and sufferings;
since the claimant was unmarried at the time of accident and
sustained grievous injuries in the accident, an amount of
Rs.2,00,000/- is granted towards loss of marital prospectus; The
amounts awarded under the heads of Medical expenses,
Transportation to hospital, Extra nourishment and Damage to
clothing and articles are confirmed.”
Mac App No.177/2024
22. A careful reading of the aforesaid extract indicates that the
High Court merely adverted to the general principles governing
assessment of disability and, without undertaking any
independent analysis of the evidence on record, abruptly
concluded that the functional disability suffered by the
appellant- claimant would be 30%. There is no discussion as to
why the medical findings, the disability certificate issued by the
competent Medical Board, or the neuropsychological report
were doubtful or insufficient to sustain the conclusion reached
by the MACT. Equally, while reducing the quantum of
compensation, no specific or cogent reasons have been assigned
for curtailing the amounts awarded under the heads of “Loss of
Amenities” and “Pain and Suffering,” which were based on the
nature and gravity of the injuries sustained by the appellantclaimant. In our considered opinion, such conclusions, abruptly
arrived at without proper re-appreciation of the evidence and
without recording adequate reasons, are in the nature of
presumptions and assumptions and cannot be sustained in the
eyes of law.
****************
25. In order to determine the functional disability suffered by
the appellant-claimant, it is necessary to advert to the findings
recorded by the Medical Board with respect to the permanent
physical disability, as well as the neuropsychological
assessment report placed on record. Both these documents
remained uncontroverted and hence, they provide credible
expert evidence so as to assess the extent and nature of
disability. The true nature and extent of the injuries, and their
impact on the cognitive and functional abilities of the
appellant-claimant, can be properly appreciated only upon a
careful consideration of these materials. For ready reference, the
relevant extracts from the said documents are reproduced herein
below: “Neuropsychological Assessment Report: Interpretation &
Conclusion
• Memory Scale shows that his verbal and Visual memory is
impaired severely.
•On tests for frontal lobe functioning-impairment.
• On the test for parietal lobe functioning, normal
performance shows that the lobe function is intact.
The IQ range of 65,fall into the category of Mild Intellectual
Disability. Report of the Medical Board.
Case of Head injury treated conservatively, facial injury x left
femur fracture treated by surgical intervention. Above injury
has resulted in partial blindness, cognitive impairment and
partial lom of Rom and stability of left knee.
His disability due to above injuries sixty three percent
(63%).”
[Emphasis supplied]
Mac App No.177/2024
26. Having bestowed our anxious consideration to the material
placed on record, we find that the disability certificate issued by the
Medical Board clearly records that the appellant-claimant had
suffered a head injury treated conservatively, facial injury, and left
femur fracture treated by surgical intervention. These injuries
progressively resulted in partial blindness, cognitive impairment
and partial loss of range of motion and stability of the left knee.
The neuropsychological assessment further evidences severe
impairment in verbal and visual memory, impairment of frontal
lobe functions and an IQ score of 65, placing the appellantclaimant in the category of Mild Intellectual Disability. These
findings, read conjointly, demonstrate that the injuries suffered by
the appellant-claimant were not merely orthopedic in nature, but
had significant neurological sequelae directly impacting his
functional and cognitive abilities.
27. This Court, in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, has authoritatively
laid down the principles governing assessment of permanent and
functional disability for the purpose of awarding compensation. It
has been held that the percentage of permanent disability
assessed by a medical expert cannot be mechanically equated
with the percentage of loss of earning capacity. What is
required to be determined is the actual impact of such
disability on the earning capacity of the injured, having regard
to his avocation, age and the nature of work performed. The
Tribunal is required to undertake a structured analysis to
ascertain the activities the claimant can or cannot perform
post-injury, the nature of his profession prior to the accident,
and whether the disability has resulted in total incapacity or
merely restricted or reduced earning capacity. For ready
reference, the relevant extracts from the said judgment are
reproduced hereinbelow: “9. The percentage of permanent disability is expressed by the
doctors with reference to the whole body, or more often than
not, with reference to a particular limb. When a disability
certificate states that the injured has suffered permanent
disability to an extent of 45% of the left lower limb, it is not
the same as 45% permanent disability with reference to the
whole body. The extent of disability of a limb (or part of the
body) expressed in terms of a percentage of the total
functions of that limb, obviously cannot be assumed to be the
extent of disability of the whole body. If there is 60%
permanent disability of the right hand and 80% permanent
disability of left leg, it does not mean that the extent of
permanent disability with reference to the whole body is
140% (that is 80% plus 60%). If different parts of the body
have suffered different percentages of disabilities, the sum
total thereof expressed in terms of the permanent disability
with reference to the whole body cannot obviously exceed
100%.
“10. Where the claimant suffers a permanent disability as a
result of injuries, the assessment of compensation under the
head of loss of future earnings would depend upon the effect
and impact of such permanent disability on his earning
capacity. The Tribunal should not mechanically apply the
percentage of permanent disability as the percentage of
economic loss or loss of earning capacity. In most of the
cases, the percentage of economic loss, that is, the percentage
Mac App No.177/2024
of loss of earning capacity, arising from a permanent
disability will be different from the percentage of permanent
disability. Some Tribunals wrongly assume that in all cases,
a particular extent (percentage) of permanent disability
would result in a corresponding loss of earning capacity, and
consequently, if the evidence produced show 45% as the
permanent disability, will hold that there is 45% loss of
future earning capacity. In most of the cases, equating the
extent (percentage) of loss of earning capacity to the extent
(percentage) of permanent disability will result in award of
either too low or too high a compensation.
11. What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the effect
of the permanent disability on the earning capacity of the
injured; and after assessing the loss of earning capacity in
terms of a percentage of the income, it has to be quantified
in terms of money, to arrive at the future loss of earnings (by
applying the standard multiplier method used to determine
loss of dependency). We may however note that in some cases,
on appreciation of evidence and assessment, the Tribunal may
find that the percentage of loss of earning capacity as a result of
the permanent disability, is approximately the same as the
percentage of permanent disability in which case, of course, the
Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for determination of
compensation. (See for example, the decisions of this Court
in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
13. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent disability on
the actual earning capacity involves three steps. The Tribunal
has to first ascertain what activities the claimant could carry on
in spite of the permanent disability and what he could not do as
a result of the permanent disability (this is also relevant for
awarding compensation under the head of loss of amenities of
life). The second step is to ascertain his avocation, profession
and nature of work before the accident, as also his age. The third
step is to find out whether (i) the claimant is totally disabled
from earning any kind of livelihood, or (ii) whether in spite of
the permanent disability, the claimant could still effectively
carry on the activities and functions, which he was earlier
carrying on, or (iii) whether he was prevented or restricted from
discharging his previous activities and functions, but could carry
on some other or lesser scale of activities and functions so that
he continues to earn or can continue to earn his livelihood.”
28. In view of the principles laid down by this Court in Raj
Kumar (supra), as consistently affirmed thereafter, the assessment
of functional disability must be grounded in a realistic
appraisal of the impact of the injury on the claimant’s capacity
to earn. The inquiry is not confined to the numerical percentage of
physical impairment certified by the Medical Board, but extends to
evaluating whether the claimant, in light of his educational
background, skill set and nature of employment, is capable of
meaningfully pursue his avocation.”
15.
Further, in “M Paramesh vs. VRL Logistics ltd. and another, 2026 INSC
655, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:
Mac App No.177/2024
“By virtue of the aforesaid amputation, the appellant has effectively
lost his capacity to continue the work of a mason, which was
admittedly the sole avocation being pursued by him for earning his
livelihood. It is not even the case of the respondents that the
appellant was engaged in any other sedentary occupation or that
despite the amputation suffered by him, his earning capacity
remained unaffected.
16.
The ratio laid down in the aforesaid judgments is that the assessment of
functional disability must be determined on the basis of the impact of the
injuries on the claimant's earning capacity and is not confined to the
numerical percentage of permanent physical disability certified by the
Medical Board. Applying the ratio laid down in the aforesaid judgments to
the facts of the present case, this Court finds no infirmity in the
compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal towards loss of earning
capacity. In view of the above, this Court does not find any force in this
contention of the appellant, as such, the same is also rejected.
17.
Thirdly, it was contended that the monthly income of respondent No. 1 was
required to be determined in terms of SRO 460 of 2017 dated 26.10.2017 as
Rs. 10,500/- per month. A perusal of the statement of Pervaiz Ahmed Bhat,
respondent No. 1 reveals that he was earning Rs. 40,000/- per month, but
the learned Tribunal has not considered his income as Rs. 40,000/- per
month. Learned Tribunal has considered the income of respondent No. 1 as
15,000/- per month. In his statement, respondent No.1 has stated that he
was the only bread earner of the family and has four children, i.e. two sons
and two daughters and all were minors. As respondent No. 1 was
maintaining his family including four minor children also, so the learned
Tribunal has rightly considered Rs. 15,000/- as the monthly income of the
respondent No. 1. The statement of respondent No. 1 with regard to his
Mac App No.177/2024
income has been corroborated by PW Manzoor Ahmed. The monthly
income of the respondent No. 1 determined at the rate of Rs. 15,000/- per
month is neither exorbitant nor excessive in the facts and circumstances of
the case. As such, there is no force in this contention too, the same is
rejected.
18.
Fourthly, it was contended that there was no evidence with regard to future
medical expenses, therefore, Rs. 1.00 lac could not have been awarded
under the head of future medical expenses. It needs to be noted that the
learned Tribunal has awarded Rs. 5,00,000/- under the head of artificial
limb and as such, this Court finds substance in the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the appellant that there was no evidence with regard to
the future medical expenses, particularly when Rs. 5,00,000/- have been
awarded to the respondent No. 1 for the artificial limb. Accordingly, this
Court is of the considered view that the compensation of Rs. 1.00 lac
granted under the head of future medical expenses could not have been
granted by the learned Tribunal, but at the same time, it is found that the
compensation under this head was not considered while calculating the
compensation.
19.
Lastly, the contention of the appellant is that the learned Tribunal has
awarded excessive compensation on account of damages for pain and
suffering and loss of amenities of life. So far as application of multiplier of
17 and enhancement of income by 40% on account of future prospects are
concerned, this court does not find any infirmity in the same.
20.
The record depicts that Rs. 1,00,000/- each was awarded under both the
heads of “Loss of Amenities” and “Pain and Sufferings” and the same is
Mac App No.177/2024
neither exorbitant nor excessive warranting interference of this Court.
However, this court finds that the learned Tribunal has committed mistake
while calculating the total compensation. At page-23 of the award, learned
Tribunal has granted Rs. 95,945 as medical expenses, Rs. 50,000/ each as
“Attendant Charges”, “Transport Charges” and “Special Diet Charges” and
Rs. 1.00 lac as future medical expenses, which aggregates to an amount of
Rs. 3,45,945/. However, while calculating the compensation at page No. 25
of the award, the Tribunal has granted Rs. 2,95,945/ besides compensation
of Rs. 1.00 lac each under the heads of “Pain &Sufferings” and “Loss of
Amenities of life” in addition to Rs. 5.00 lacs for purchase and maintenance
of Artificial Limb and has not awarded the compensation under the head of
Future Medical Expenses.
21.
In view of the above, the instant appeal is partly allowed to the extent of
setting aside the compensation granted under the head of future medical
expenses and reducing the compensation by 50,000/ calculated wrongly by
the learned Tribunal.
22.
Accordingly, the award is modified to the following extent:
i)
Loss of future earnings-
Rs. 42,84,000/-
ii)
Expenses relating to medical,
expenses, attendant charges
transportation, diet charges,
Rs.2,45,945/-
iii)
Artificial limb
Rs. 5,00,000/-
iv)
Compensation on account of
pain and suffering and trauma
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Loss of amenities of life
and expectation of life
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Total
Rs. 52,29,945/-
v)
Mac App No.177/2024
23.
Other terms and conditions of the award, including direction regarding
payment of interest, shall remain the same. The excess amount of
compensation, if deposited with the Registry of this Court, be released in
favour of the appellant. The balance amount along with interest be
released in favour of respondent No. 1 after due identification by the
learned counsel representing him, after the payment of Court fee in terms
of award dated 10.08.2024.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
07.08.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
Rakesh Kumar
2026.08.07 17:11
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Jammu
Mac App No.177/2024
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review