Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:21057
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 14TH PHALGUNA, 1946
DBP NO. 123 OF 2014
IN THE MATTER OF TDB-REPORT NO.140 OF 2014 - COMPLAINT
RELATES TO INCOMPLETION OF CONSTRUCTION OF AN AUDITORIUM IN
THE NETTORKKOTTU DEVASWOM - SUO MOTU PROCEEDINGS INITIATEDREG
PETITIONER:
NETTORKKOTTU TEMPLE ADVISORY COMMITTEE
THRIKKARIYOOR GROUP, MOOVATTUPUZHA
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
BY ADVS.
SRI.R.BINDU SASTHAMANGALAM
SRI.PRASANTH M.P
RESPONDENTS:
THE SECRETARY, TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD
NANTHANCODE, KAWDIAR POST
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695003
*2
THE MUVATTUPUZHA MUNICIPALITY REP. BY SECRETARY
MUVATTUPUZHA P O., ERNAKULAM DISTRICT (ADDL. R2
IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED 27.10.2014 IN DBP
123 OF 2014)
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
**3
THE CONTRACTOR, SRI. M.C. ELDHO
MOLEKUDIYIL HOUSE, NELLAD P. O., MUDAVUR (VIA),
MUVATTUPUZHA (IMPLEADED AS ADDL. R3 AS PER ORDER
DATED 27.10.14 IN DBP 123 OF 2014)
***4
DISTRICT CONTRACTORS AND LABOURERS CO-OPERATIVE
SOCIETY LTD. NO. E1238 REP. BY PRESIDENT
A. P. SAJI, POST BOX NO. 24, MUVATTUPUZHA P. O.,
PIN - 686 661 (IMPLEADED AS ADDL. R4 AS PER ORDER
DATED 17.07.2017 IN DBP 123 OF 2014)
#5
THE ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
ELECTRICAL SUB DIVISION, MUVATTUPUZHA. (IS
SUOMOTU IMPLEADED VIDE ORDER DATED 10.02.2022 IN
DBP 123 OF 2014)
##6
SRI.K.B.VIJI
V.B.ENGINEERS, ELECTRICAL ENGINEERS AND
CONTRACTORS, AIRPORT ROAD, KALADY–682574 (IS
IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL 6TH RESPONDENT VIDE ORDER
DATED 09.06.2022 IN DBP.NO.123 OF 2014)
###7
THE CHIEF ELECTRICAL INSPECTOR (* IMPLEADED)
ELECTRICAL INSPECTORATE , THIRD FLOOR,REVENUE
TOWER, PARK AVENUE , ERNAKULAM-682011 (IS SUO
MOTU IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL R7 VIDE ORDER DATED
19.07.2022 IN DBP 123 OF 2014)
@8
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE SPECIAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
REVENUE
(DEVASWOM)
DEPARTMENT,
GOVERNMENT
SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695 001,
@@9
SENIOR DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
KERALA STATE AUDIT DEPARTMENT,
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD AUDIT,
NANTHANCODE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM (ADDL R8 & R9 ARE
SUO MOTU IMPLEADED VIDE ORDER DATED 05.03.2025 IN
DBP NO.123 OF 2014)
BY ADVS.
SRI.M.V.S.NAMBOOTHIRI, SC, TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
BOARD
SRI.R.K.MURALEEDHARAN
PHILIP J.VETTICKATTU
B.PRAMOD
GOVERNMENT PLEADER
SRI.R.KRISHNAKUMAR, SC, TDB
G.SANTHOSH KUMAR (P).
SHRI.G.BIJU,SC,TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD
SAJITHA GEORGE(K/497/2005)
NEENU BERNATH(K/000575/2013)
OTHER PRESENT:
SRI. S. RAJMOHAN, SR. GP;
SRI. G. BIJU, SC, TDB;
SRI. P. RAMACHANDRAN, AMICUS CURIAE;
SRI. A.S. P. KURUP, ADVOCATE COMMISSIONER;
SRI. B. PREMOD, SC, KSEB
THIS DEVASWOM BOARD PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 05.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
ORDER
Anil K. Narendran, J.
This DBP is registered based on TDB Report No.140 of 2014
of the learned Ombudsman in Complaint No.225 of 2014 made by
the Temple Advisory Committee of Nettorkkottu Bhagavathi
Temple, which is a temple under the management of the
Travancore
Devaswom Board.
The subject
matter of that
complaint is the delay in completion of the construction of an
auditorium, the construction of which was started as early as in
the year 2009, based on a decision taken by the Travancore
Devaswom Board on 07.08.2008. The administrative sanction for
the construction of the ground floor of the building was accorded
at an estimate cost of Rs.63 lakhs. The administrative sanction for
the construction of the first floor was granted by the Devaswom
Board on 10.02.2010, at an estimate cost of Rs.96,90,000/-. Both
these works were approved by this Court in different Maramath
petitions and the works were also completed. An another sum of
Rs.5 lakhs was spent for plumbing work. However, the auditorium
could not be inaugurated, as interior works including ceiling,
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
arrangement for sound proofing echo system and fire safety
measures have not been undertaken. The electrical work would be
done only along with these works, as wiring has to done before
placing false ceiling. Since large amounts have already been spent
and to get proper income from the auditorium, it was pointed out
that air conditioning of the hall is also required, which will be part
of the electrical work. Chairs also have to be purchased. Unless
and until these works are also completed, the investment of
Rs.1,64,90,000/- will be a waste and no returns could be obtained
from such investments.
2.
On
13.10.2014,
when
this
report
came
up
for
consideration, this Court by a detailed order, directed the
Secretary of the Travancore Devaswom Board, the Chief Engineer
and the concerned Executive Engineer to be present in Court on
27.10.2014 at 10.15 a.m. Paragraph 1 of the said order reads thus;
''The report dated 11.09.2014 submitted by the
learned Ombudsman appointed by this Court reveals a
very sorry state of affairs in the matter of construction
of an auditorium in the premises of Nettorkottu
Devaswom
in
Muvattupuzha.
The
work
of
the
auditorium commenced in the year 2009. Initially
administrative sanction for construction of the ground floor
was accorded by the Travancore Devaswom Board at an
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
estimated cost of Rs.63,00,000/-. Later, construction of the
first floor was also sanctioned at an estimated cost of
Rs.96,90,000/-. Both the works were approved by this
Court and the works were completed. Still later, plumbing
work was also completed. But till date the auditorium has
not been commissioned. It is stated that fire safety
measures have not been installed and that sound proofing
and false ceiling works have also not been done. The
learned Ombudsman has also reported that though the
learned Ombudsman had sent notice to the Secretary,
Travancore Devaswom Board, there was no representation
or reply when the complaint was taken up on 29.07.2014,
20.08.2014 and 03.09.2014. In such circumstances we are
of the opinion that the Secretary/Chief Engineer, Travancore
Devaswom Board and the Engineer in charge of the
construction should be present in this Court on the next
posting date to explain the reason why even five years after
the commencement of the construction, the auditorium has
not been commissioned. We also deem it appropriate to
direct them to file separate statements showing the
amounts already spent on the auditorium. The said officers
shall also state whether they have any idea about the
further expenditure required to commission the auditorium
and whether an estimate in that regard has been prepared.''
3.
The order dated 13.10.2014 was followed by an order
dated 27.10.2014, whereby, an Advocate Commissioner was
appointed to inspect the building in question along with an expert
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
engineer for the purpose of ascertaining whether the estimate
prepared for the work is in order, whether the work has been
carried out in accordance with the specification stipulated by the
Board and also to prepare a fair estimate of the expenditure likely
to be involved to complete the construction and to put the
auditorium to profitable use. The said order reads thus;
''When this petition came up before us on 13.10.2014,
taking note the fact that the construction of an auditorium
which commenced in year 2009 has not so far been
completed,
we
directed
the
Secretary/Chief
Engineer,
Travancore Devaswom Board and the Engineer in charge of
the construction to be present in person today to explain the
reason why even five years after the commencement of the
construction, the auditorium has not been commissioned.
We also directed them to file separate statements showing
the amounts already stent on the auditorium and the further
expenditure required to complete the construction and to
commission the auditorium.
2. Pursuant thereto, the Executive Engineer, Travancore
Devaswom Board, Kottayam Division has filed a statement
dated
13.10.2014.
He
is
also
present
in
person.
Sri.P.R.Balachandran Nair, Secretary, Travancore Devaswom
Board has filed a statement dated 26.10.2014 and he is also
present in person. The Chief Engineer has filed a statement
dated 25.10.2014, but he is not present in person on
account of previous commitments.
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
3. The statements disclose that though the permission of this
Court was sought and obtained for constructing the ground
floor
of
the
auditorium
at
an
estimated
cost
of
Rs.68,00,000/-, the work was tendered to Sri.M.C.Eldho at
45% above the sanctioned estimate. A copy of this Court's
order dated 04.12.2008 in D.B.A.No.105 of 2008 granting
permission to construct the ground floor of the auditorium is
not produced. It is also not known whether the work was
awarded to Sri.M.C.Eldho at 45% above the estimate rate
with the sanction of this Court. The statements also disclose
that later the Board decided to construct the first floor at an
estimated
cost
of
Rs.96,90,000/-
and
for
the
said
construction also, the permission of this Court was sought
and obtained in D.B.A.No.21 of 2010, and, the said work was
awarded 58% above the estimate rate to Sri.M.C.Eldho. The
statements disclose that notwithstanding the fact that more
than Rs.3 crores has been spent, the construction of the
auditorium has not been completed and that a further sum
of Rs.2.60 crores is required to complete the work. On a
perusal of the statements filed by the Executive Engineer
and others we are of the opinion that further construction
will involve expenditure over and above the said estimate,
since the practice prevalent in the Board is to award the work
at a higher rate. From the materials on record we are
satisfied that a thorough probe into the construction of the
auditorium in the lands belonging to Nettorkkottukavu
Bhagavathi Temple should be conducted. The work started
at the instance of Muvattupuzha Municipality which resolved
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
on 16.6.2008 to request the Travancore Devaswom Board to
construct a shopping complex and an auditorium in the lands
belonging to Nettorkkottukavu Devaswom. The reason
stated was that Muvattupuzha is fast developing and it lacks
an auditorium. The Board responded promptly by deciding
to construct the ground floor of an auditorium at an
estimated cost of Rs.68,00,000/- on 07.08.2008, within 52
days thereafter. Officers of the Board or the members of the
Board do not appear to have taken note of the fact that an
incomplete building would not fetch any income and that the
work has been pending for the past more than five years.
Even now one is not certain as to whether by spending a
further sum of Rs.2.60 crores, as stated by the officers of
the Board, the construction of the work can be completed or
whether anyone will come forward to complete the work at
the estimated cost or whether, as in the past, the work will
be tendered at a higher rate. In such circumstances we
deem it appropriate to direct the Secretary, Travancore
Devaswom Board to file a list of members of the Board who
were in office during the period from 07.08.2008 till date.
The Secretary of the Board shall also file a list of
officers/employees who were/are in service and were/are
directly concerned with the work in question including the
officers who were concerned with the preparation of the
estimates and the supervision of the work. We also deem it
appropriate to implead the Muvattupuzha Municipality and
the contractor to whom the work was awarded and to further
direct the Secretary, Travancore Devaswom Board to
produce the entire files for scrutiny before the Hon'ble
Ombudsman appointed by this Court within one week from
DBP No.123 of 2014
today,
for
the
purpose
of
enabling
2025:KER:21057
the Advocate
Commissioner, whom we propose to appoint, to inspect the
incomplete building with the aid of an expert Engineer of the
Commissioner's choice and to submit a report to this Court
as to whether the estimates prepared for the work were in
order, whether the work has been carried out in accordance
with the tender specifications stipulated by the Board and
also to prepare a fair estimate of the expenditure likely to
be involved to complete the construction of the auditorium
and to commission it.
We accordingly implead the Muvattupuzha Municipality
represented by its Secretary, Muvattupuzha P.O. Ernakulam
District, as the additional second respondent and the
contractor Sri.M.C.Eldho, Molekudiyil House, Nellad P.O.,
Mudavur (Via.), Muvattupuzha, as the additional third
respondent. We also appoint Sri.A.S.P.Kurup, Advocate
practicing in this Court, as Advocate Commissioner, to
inspect the building in question along with an expert
Engineer for the purpose of ascertaining whether the
estimates prepared for the work were in order, whether the
work
has
been
carried
out
in
accordance
with
the
specifications stipulated by the Board and also prepare a fair
estimate of the expenditure likely to be involved to complete
the construction and to put the auditorium to profitable use.
The Secretary, Travancore Devaswom Board shall, for the
purpose of enabling the Advocate Commissioner to carry out
the inspection, produce the relevant files for scrutiny before
the Hon'ble Ombudsman appointed by this Court within two
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
weeks from today. It will be open to the Advocate
Commissioner and the expert Engineer, whom he chooses,
to go through the files in the office of the Hon'ble
Ombudsman for the purpose of conducting the inspection.
The Advocate Commissioner shall, after inspection, submit a
report to this Court within four weeks from today. The Board
shall pay to the learned Advocate Commissioner the sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees One lakh only) towards remuneration
and to meet the expenses of the expert. In the event of this
Court finding that the work in question was undertaken
without a proper estimate being prepared, the said amount
will be liable to be recouped from the officers concerned in
the preparation of the estimate and in execution of the work.
The remuneration shall be paid within a week from today
directly to the Advocate Commissioner. Registry to issue
notice by special messenger to additional respondents 2 and
3 at the expense of the Travancore Devaswom Board.''
4.
The order dated 27.10.2014 was followed by an order
dated 14.10.2015, which reads thus;
''Pursuant to the earlier orders, the Executive Engineer,
Kottayam division is present with the original files. On the
basis of the files, he has answered our queries in relation to
the contract. The initial PAC was fixed at Rs.63,00,000/- on
the basis of 2008 schedule. The additional items for which
sanction is now sought for are valued at Rs.2.75 crores, on
the basis of 2012 schedule of rates. The concept of additional
work in excess quantity in works contract of this nature is
not a new phenomenon. There is abundant literature both in
the realm of engineering and also law as to how additional
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
items and excess quantities will have to be worked out and
as to the reasonable yardstick which could be applied in
construction contracts which include additional items and
excess quantities. One issue that we see is, the Board had in
its wisdom conceived the structure and given out a contract
in 2008. That is the contract which was given for
Rs.63,00,000/- PAC and 45% excess was the awarded
amount. This means that the total amount for that structure
alone had come to more than Rs.83,00,000/-. The uphold
revision of rates from 2008 to 2012 is stated to be around
50%. If that were so, the estimated amount for the
additional items which is now shown as Rs.2.75 crores would
have been valued only at 1½ of it in 2008. What is surprising
is that the additional items are nothing but materials
required for air conditioning and furnishing the auditorium
and also to provide various other systems for fire fighting etc.
2. We wonder for ourselves as to whether if the contract was
given in one go after fixing a total PAC in 2008, the work
would have been awarded in the manner in which it has been
done now. Even if it were to be taken that the Board had
attempted to act prudently in the financial aspect, we are
sure that it can miserably take. The total expenditure
incurred for the construction of the building less the
additional items which are now going to be carried out when
evaluated taking into consideration the value of the
additional items the arithmetical calculations in that regard
would intrigue any accountant or engineer who would
definitely have to ultimately say that the Board would have
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
stood to gain from spending the huge amounts which it now
has to, if the works were awarded as a single unit on the
basis of the 2008 schedule.
3. We are told that the extra items now sought to be done
are yet to be tendered and that the contractor who has done
the work so far was awarded only the civil work for the
building.
Having
regard
to
the
peculiar
facts
and
circumstances of the case, we grant permission to the Board
to carry out the works of the extra items which are now
stated to be remaining and ensure that the auditorium is fully
operational within a period of six months. The learned
Commissioner will continue to report to this Court the
progress of the work. Such report may be filed before the
learned Ombudsman at the first instance. We refer this
matter back to the learned Ombudsman to hear the Board
and the learned Commissioner and also to consider whether
guidelines could be issued to revamp and if necessary, restructure
the
Board's
process
of
awarding
such
emoluments.''
5.
Pursuant to the directions contained in the order dated
14.10.2015, the learned Ombudsman has filed TDB Report No.3
of 2017. The said report reads thus;
"When the above DBP came up for consideration before the
Honourable High Court on 14.10.2015, the Honourable High
Court referred the matter back to the Ombudsman to hear
the Board and the learned Advocate Commissioner and also
to consider whether guidelines could be issued to revamp
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
and if necessary, restructure the Board's process of
awarding such emoluments.
2. The matter related to estimate sanction for the
construction of auditorium in Nettoorkottu Kavu Devaswom.
As a result of some additional huge expenditure required for
completing the project, it became necessary to file sanction
petition. The Honourable High Court noticed that the original
estimate was prepared in 2008 for Rs.63 lakhs, but the
additional items for which sanction was sought for were
valued at Rs.2.75 Crores on the basis of 2012 Schedule of
Rates. It noticed that the additional items are nothing but
materials required for air conditioning and furnishing the
auditorium and to provide other systems, fire fighting etc.
The Honourable High Court in paragraph 2 of the Order
expressed that if the contract was given in one go in 2008
itself, it would have been awarded in the manner in which it
has been done now and the Board would have stood to gain
from spending huge amounts. However, having regard to
the
particular
facts and circumstances
of
the
case,
permission was granted to the Board for the extra works to
be carried out to make the auditorium operational. The
learned Advocate Commissioner was directed to file reports
on the progress of the work. Such reports have to be filed
before the Ombudsman at the first instance. It is in that
context, that the matter was required to be considered by
this Office.
3. Learned Advocate Commissioner has filed fourth interim
report dated 27.04.2016. A Report was submitted by the
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
Ombudsman on the third interim report submitted by the
Advocate Commissioner. Orders have already been passed
by the Honourable High Court on the said report.
4. In the fourth interim report, certain suggestions are
made in paragraph 10 of the same for consideration for
formulating guidelines in the matter of tendering the works
relating to the temple. Copies of the same was served on
the Executive Engineer, TDB, Kottayam as also the Kerala
State Audit Department, TDB Audit enabling them to file
their remarks or suggestions, if any, vide my proceedings
dated 27.04.2016. After successive postings of the case, the
Travancore Devaswom Board made a suggestion by their
letter dated 31.05.2016 that the present limit of Rs.10 lakhs
for sanction of maramath works from the Honourable High
Court be increased to Rs.30,00,000/- and to allow fifteen
per cent excess. It is also stated that the Executive Engineer
has been authorised to file a report in the matter.
5. As a matter of fact, the Board filed DBA.No.16 of 2016
and pursuant to the Order passed by the Honourable High
Court referring the same to me, I have already filed a report
as TDBR. No. 140 of 2016 in DBA.No. 16 of 2016 and
pending consideration before the Honourable High Court
regarding the enhancement of the ceiling for obtaining
sanction from the Honourable High Court.
6. The Executive Engineer had filed a draft guidelines, copy
of which is marked as Annexure A. Actually, the guidelines
were submitted to the Chief Engineer and in my proceedings
dated 26.09.2016 the Board was informed that in the
absence of any separate guidelines filed by the Board, the
draft guidelines submitted by the Executive Engineer will be
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
accepted as one approved by the Board and since no
separate remarks were filed, the same was taken as
guidelines submitted by the Board. Copy of the proceedings
of this Office dated 26.09.2016 is marked as Annexure B.
Separate remarks were filed by the Audit before the
Honourable High Court with copy to this office. Thereafter,
the matter was posted on different dates for discussion and
a report is submitted on the various suggestions made by
the Advocate Commissioner as follows:
Para 10(i) of the Report:
The Advocate Commissioner points out that special rates
are to be prepared for temple works taking into account the
actual price of the materials, labour charges etc. and the
rates are to be prepared by an expert technical team
knowing about the special nature of the temple work and
subject to revision every year. The rate applicable to PWD
work in general has to be abandoned for such temple work.
The Audit in their remarks stated that the Travancore
Devaswom Board has adopted Delhi Schedule of Rates
effective from 1.4.2016 and it is learnt that the Travancore
Devaswom Board has already prepared special rates for
temple and temple related works, not included in the DSR
and the same is under consideration of the Chief Engineer
of the Board. Further, the Board also provides reasonable
time for temple related work in the general schedule having
due regard to the fact that limited working hours alone are
available in the temple. Hence they suggest that the present
prevailing practice is more acceptable and continued.
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
In the draft guidelines submitted by the Executive Engineer,
it is admitted that DSR rates and Rules of Kerala PWD are
followed for maramath works in the Travancore Devaswom
Board. The temple works are to be categorised in two types,
namely, renovation of Sreekovil, Nalambalam, Balikkalpura,
Namaskaramandapam,
Thidappilly,
Well,
Elamathil,
Subshrines in the Sreekovil in the First Category and the
general
works
construction
of
outside
new
the
Chuttambalam,
namely
building,
Nadapandal,
Anakottil,
Pradakshinavazhi, etc. in the Second Category. The main
wood used for the maramath arfe Anjili and teak wood, MP
roofing, Ashlar stones, country bricks, etc. which are double
the present schedule of rates. Skilled labourers for the
temple works are rear and the rates are also exorbitant
besides, normal working hours are not available. Hence it is
suggested to implement special rates for the works
mentioned in the First Category taking into account short
working time.
Suggestions:
After considering the proposal as aforesaid, it is suggested
that now that the Delhi Rates are adopted for the Devaswom,
the works included in the First Category mentioned by the
Executive Engineer for special rates, is a matter for
consideration by the Board based on report to be submitted
by the Chief Engineer as pointed out by the Audit remarks.
Hence let that process be continued and the Board would
consider the incorporation of special rates for special items
of work, not included in the Delhi Rates.
Para 10(ii) of the Report:
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
In the report of the Advocate Commissioner under para
10(ii), the suggestion is to treat the construction including
Dwajam to be treated as separate category other than civil
construction like Sadyalayam, compound wall etc. In view
of the suggestions in paragraph 10(i), this is redundant.
Para 10(iii) of the Report:
Estimate
once
preared
takes
a
longer
time
for
administrative sanction and contract sanction. This has to
be limited to 30 days time for final sanction after submission
of the estimate. Office procedure may be revamped. Once
an estimate is prepared by the Executive Engineer and
received by the Chief Engineer, time limit may be presribed
for completing examination and place it before the Board to
enable the Board to take a decision.
The Executive Engineer points out in his draft that if the
contract sanction is not accorded within six months, the
contractor can step back from the contract. Because of the
office procedure, more than six months is taken for getting
approval. The suggestion is that the present powers of the
Board and officials for granting administrative sanction of
the contract and the Board can approach the Honourable
High Court for necessary variation in the order regarding
ceiling. The audit agrees with the suggestion made by the
Advocate Commissioner for fixing the time limit for sanction.
Suggestion:
It is suggested that once an estimate is prepared and
submitted, the Chief Engineer has to consider and take a
decision within three weeks and submitted to the Board for
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
consideration and the Board to take a decision within a
period of one month thereafter. There should be an
accountability for the delay unless occasion due to any
special circumstances to be offered by the concerned official.
Para 10(iv) of the Report:
It is pointed out by the Advocate Commissioner that there
are three stages of negotiation after inviting the tender
before the work is awarded. Hence it is suggested that all
these negotiations must be completed within a period of 45
days to avoid claim for enhancement.
The audit has pointed out that for completing all the
formalities, a time limit of 45 days be fixed from the date of
selection of the successful bidder.
Suggestion:
Once a successful bidder is selected, negotiation formalities
are to be completed as far as possible within a period of 45
days.
Para 10(v) of the Report:
There are large number of Devaswom properties in
neglected condition. They have to be demolished and
protected over by fencing with barbed wire and constructing
a
compound
wall.
Delay
will
result
in
unnecessary
encroachment.
Audit agrees with the suggestion. It is said that the
encroachment of Devaswom land is brought to the notice of
the Honourable High Court in various Audit Reports, but the
Devaswom authorities have taken a lookwarm attitude.
Suggestion:
It is a fact that the Special Tahsildar through various reports
has pointed out that after putting the boundary stones after
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
surveying the land, unless emergent steps are taken to
protect the land, future encroachment on the same land
cannot be prevented. In this regard I have filed a report as
TDBR.No.111 of 2016 after considering a complaint filed
before this Office. The suggestion is to constitute a team by
the Devaswom authorities to look into all trespass cases and
to give instructions to the Executive Engineer concerned to
take measures for protecting the land by fencing the area at
the first instance once survey is completed and report is
received from the Special Tahsildar
This may be considered.
Para 10(vi) of the Report:
Lack of supervision for works above Rs. 1 crore on the part
of the higher officials of the Maramath Department
It is pointed out that the work is supervised by Supervisors
who are overburdened to visit various places of construction.
This results in dilution of the work. Physical supervision by
the Assistant Engineer, Executive Engineer including Chief
Engineer be insisted upon where the works involves more
than Rs. 1 crore.
The Audit has accepted the suggestion as the present
system of supervision is not upto the mark.
Suggestion:
In marmath works involving above Rs.1 crore, the Chief
Engineer must visit the construction site as far as possible,
at least once in six weeks/two months and the Executive
Engineer at least twice in a month. A visiting book should
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
be kept at the site to note the date and time of inspection
by the concerned officer.
Para 10(vii) of the report:
It is suggested that ITI Certificate holders' serivices can be
used by the Travancore Devaswom Board paying stipend
allowance of Rs.5,000/-. This will solve the problem of
dearth for supervisory staff
Audit suggested to limit the above suggestion only for
works above estimated rate of Rs.5 lakhs.
Suggestion:
Recruiting apprentices to supervise the work by paying a
paltry amount will not be advisable as it may lead to
corruption. Further, there are restrictions for recruitment of
employees except through procedure established by law.
Instead, the strict supervision by the Assistant Engineer or
by Junior Engineer, more often will ensure the quality of the
work. The Temple Advisory Committee and the Devaswom
Officer may keep a vigil of the work so that the progress of
the work and the quality will be under the vigil of the public.
Para 10(ix) of the report:
E-tender adopted by the Travancore Devaswom Board is
stated to be effective for the general civil work. However, it
will not be practical for renovation work of the Sreekovil,
Namaskaramandapam etc. which are governed by the
principles of "Vasthu" and tradition. Since these works are
to be done by traditional families who are not familiar with
the E-tender system, the availability of such experts should
be ensured by traditional way of tendering.
The Audit suggests to empanel the traditional skilled
workers so that whenever there is special works, they can
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
be intimated of the tender and they can apply by registered
post so that both the skilled workers can also be participated
in the tender.
Suggestion:
Instead of giving away E-tender system, the suggestion putforth by the Audit is more acceptable while E-tenders can be
continued to be followed, simultaneously traditionally skilled
workers may be emapanelled and whenever works are ready,
intimation may be given to the empanelled persons enabling
them to apply by registered post as well.
Para 10(x) of the report:
Essential parts of a temple are Sreekovil, Namaskara
Mandapam, Balikkalpura, Dwajam, Gopuram, Lake and
Alankara Gopuram at the main road entrance. With respect
to Gopuram, it is suggested that the same can be
constructed by the Board by sharing the expense at 50:50
between the Temple Advisory Committee and the Board.
Attractive kanikkanvanchi can also be installed on the road
side for offering by the public.
The Audit has agreed with the suggestion to share the
expenditure on 50:50 basis by the Temple Advisory
Committee and the Devaswom. Since it is an ornamental
work, unless substantial amount is contributed by the
Temple Advisory Committee, it will be a heavy burden on
the Devaswom fund.
The Executive Engineer has also agreed with the suggestion
to share the expenditure by the Committee. He has also
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
agreed to the suggestion to have more number of
Kanikkavanchi at prime locations.
Suggestion:
The construction of Alankara Gopuram as far as possible
should be taken up and given priority only if at least 50% of
the estimated cost is contributed by the Temple Advisory
Committee for the time being. As regards the suggestion for
installation of Kanikkavanchi in the road, it is considered not
advisable, since there is security problem and as part of the
redeployment, the staff strength of security staff is
proposed to be reduced. Keeping of more number of
Kanikkavanchies will cause to be extra-burdened on the
security staff to prevent theft. Hence attractive vanchies can
be kept at the important locations within the temple after
selecting the locateion by the temple authorities.
Para 10(xi) of the report:
Construction of Sadyalayam:
Before making construction of Sadyalayam, feasibility report
has to be prepared as essential, as there are restrictions
regarding the functions to be conducted and the nature of
the food to be supplied which is likely to lesser the income.
Hence the suggestion is to have Sadyalayam outside the
temple for making good use of the same.
It is pointed out by the Audit that many of the Sadyalayams
of Travancore Devaswom Board have resulted in sheer
waste because of the lack of road accessibility, etc.
Suggestion:
No hard and fast rule can be made in this regard.
Constructing a Sadyalayam totally in distant place in the
temple may not be an encourging suggestion as far as the
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
devotees are concerned for conducting Annadanam etc.
However, if there are available land outside the premises of
the temple for construction of Kalyanamandapam etc. that
is to be taken separately depending upon the availability of
fund,
space,
feasibility,
etc.
However,
whenever
an
Annadanamandapam, Kalyanamandapam etc. for which an
estimate has to be prepared, a feasibility report has to be
submitted. As of now, whenever maramath petitions are
considered, I use to insist for detailed statements regarding
its feasibility which can be made compulsory so that these
aspects can be considered while granting sanction by the
Honourable High Court.
Para 10(xii) of the report:
Improvements to be made to the temple ponds under the
Kavumkulam Renovation Programme by the Government:
Suggestion:
Even now, many of the temple ponds are included in such
schemes at the instance of the Local MLA. No specific
direction is felt necessary in this regard.
Para 10(xiii) of the report:
This again a repetition regarding the applicability of the PWD
rates. However, the suggestion is to increase the limit of the
various sanctioning authorities. For the Executive Engineer,
sanctioning limit is Rs.2 lakhs to be increased to Rs.3 lakhs,
Chief Engineer from Rs.5 lakhs to Rs.7 lakhs and the
Devaswom Board from Rs. 10 lakhs to Rs. 15 lakhs.
Suggestion:
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
As regards the sanctioning limit is concerned, it is now
prescribed by the orders passed by the Honourable High
Court. The limit of the Board is sought to be increased on
which the report is pending consideration as TDBR. No.140
of 2016 in DBA.No.16 of 2016. The Honourable High Court
may consider whether the limit prescribed for the Officers
could also be increased proportionately, in case that will help
reducing the delay in completing the formalities relating to
the tender of small works and for administrative sanction.
The suggestion of the Advocate Commissioner is nominal
and hence can be considered.
7. There are some other points made mention of in the
report of the Advocate Commissioner in paragraphs 8 and 9.
They are dealt with as hereunder:
(i) Pavement of granite stones in the Pradakshina Vazhi:
It can be considered as regards the major temples having
substantial income, but no hard and fast rule can be made
in this regard. The cost of vitrified tiles will be cheaper
compared to granite/ashlar stones. Hence, in small temples,
it cannot be insisted to pave granite stones.
(ii) Regarding preservation of carvings/sculptures, etc.:
The survey of the temples where there are such carving has
to be first ascertained. The concerned Executive Engineer
can prepare necessary estimate as and when there is a
demand by the Temple Advisory Committee and the public
of the locality so that the cost incurred can be contributed
by the devotees.
(iii) Regarding the disposal of the materials available after
demolishing the old buildings:
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
While preparing maramath petition, an estimate has to be
taken regarding the availability of the materials and the cost.
While inviting the tenders, these materials also have to be
tendered and the amount received can be utilised for
renovation work.
For the disposal of the materials as aforesaid, the limit is
only Rs. 10,000/- for the Chief Engineer. As regards the
Executive
Engineer,
it
is
Rs.5,000/-.
This
creates
unnecessary delay in disposal of the materials collected
from the dismantled buildings and got ruined. In order that
these materials are disposed of without incurring loss to the
Devaswom, the suggestion is to increase the limit fixed for
the Chief Engineer from Rs. 10,000/- to Rs.40,000/- and for
the Executive Engineer from Rs.5,000/- to Rs.30,000/-.
Appropriate Orders may be passed."
6.
By the order dated 10.01.2017, after considering the
fifth interim report dated 03.01.2017 of the learned Advocate
Commissioner, the Temple Advisory Committee was directed to
carry out the process of extending the utility of Kalyanamandapam
for the time being, pending consideration of the matter.
7.
On
02.04.2018,
when
this
DBP
came
up
consideration, this Court passed the following order;
"Heard the matter in detail. With regard to the balance work
completed by the 4th respondent contractor, a Society
registered under the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, in
for
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
connection with the affairs of the Nettorkottukavu Temple,
various interim orders came to be passed by this Court on
different dates. On the last occasion, it was brought to the
notice of this Court that the electrical connection could not
be given to the main line, for want of numbering the building
and that the lapse in this regard was only on the part of the
Devaswom or the civil contractor. The learned counsel for
the 4th respondent electrical contractor submits that the
work completed by the 4th respondent was assessed and
the bill submitted was sanctioned as per Ext.R4(d) dated
21.07.2017, for a total sum of Rs.41,22,597.24 including 5%
OH charges. The learned counsel submits that, based on the
interim
orders
passed
by
this
Court,
a
sum
of
Rs.30,00,000/- has been released and the balance amount
payable is Rs.11,22,597.24/-. This amount is stated as
deposited by the Devaswom in the Dhanalakshmi Bank,
Kottayam Branch.
2. The learned counsel further submits that, in connection
with the installation of Transformer, a further sum of
Rs.40,00,000/- is due, to be cleared by the Devaswom. The
petitioner has been required to produce the M-book for
clearing the said amount, but, in fact, the M-book is now in
the custody of the Executive Engineer of the Devaswom at
Kottayam. The said book has to be forwarded to the
Assistant Engineer (Electrical), Kottayam of the Travancore
Devaswom Board for clearing the amount payable in respect
of the Transformer installation. It, however, is still kept in
the custody of the Executive Engineer stating that, only after
clearance of the balance amount in respect of first
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
transaction, would it be possible to return it to the Assistant
Engineer (Electrical).
3. The learned standing counsel for the Devaswom submits
that the entire amount is not disbursed, as the system is yet
to be connected to the main lines and if at all there occurs
any defect/lapse in this regard, it has to be rectified by the
contractor; adding that it is only a prudent action. The
learned counsel for the 4th respondent submits that the
installation is now working on generator and that the system
is never defective. It is stated that the 'Auditorium' is being
used for various functions and that the Devaswom is
generating funds.
4. In the said circumstance, we find it appropriate to direct
the Devaswom Board to release the balance amount covered
by Ext. R4(d), after giving credit to the amounts already
paid to the 4th respondent pursuant to the interim orders
passed by this Court. This shall be on giving an 'undertaking'
in the form of 'bond' by the 4th respondent, that if at all any
further defect/lapse is noted, the same shall be rectified at
the cost of the 4th respondent. The undertaking made by
the learned counsel for the 4th respondent in this regard
before this Court is also recorded. It is ordered accordingly.
Appropriate steps shall be taken by the authorities of the
Devaswom in connection with the clearance of the
amount payable to the 4th respondent with regard to the
installation of the Transformer as well. Transmission of
the M-book shall be effected forthwith, if the version
stated by the 4th respondent contractor is correct. This
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
shall be done at the earliest, at any rate, within 'two
weeks' from the date of receipt of a copy of this order."
8.
Thereafter, by the order dated 30.09.2020 this Court
directed the Board to take over the task of running the auditorium.
The said order reads thus;
“Going by the endorsement in Judges' papers the captioned
DBP was closed on 02.04.2018. Nonetheless, the parties
would contend that it is nothing but a wrong endorsement
evincible by a mere perusal of the order dated 02.04.2018.
Hence, for proceeding further with the DBP as also for
considering the Interlocutory Applications filed in the DBP
this imbroglio has to be solved. We will consider this issue
first. A careful scanning of the DBP registered based on TDB
Report No.140 of 2014 would reveal that many issues
pertaining
to
the
construction
of
an
auditorium
in
Nettorkottukavu Devaswom call for consideration therein.
However, only one issue was actually addressed as per
order dated 02.04.2018. We say so because it is evident
from the records that earlier Report No.4 dated 27.04.2016
was filed by the Advocate Commissioner appointed by this
Court
whereby
and
whereunder
he
made
certain
suggestions, though not pertaining to the work in question
but on the general aspects. It is also relevant to note that
the learned Ombudsman for Travancore and Cochin
Devaswom Boards also filed TDB Report No.3 of 2017 on
the aforesaid issue. The proceedings would reveal that on
those reports orders are yet to be passed, in other words,
they are still pending consideration. In that context, it is
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
only apposite to refer to an order passed in the captioned
DBP dated 11.04.2017. As per the said order the DBP was
directed to be posted immediately after vacation 'for
consideration further course of action pursuant to Report
No.3/2017 submitted by the learned Ombudsman and
Report No.4 dated 27.04.2016 submitted by the learned
Advocate
Commissioner'.
Commissioner
evidently
The
learned
submitted
before
Advocate
the
Court
regarding the submission of Report No.5 as well and also
about his proposal to file final report immediately. There
are certain other aspects also require consideration in the
DBP. The order dated 02.04.2018 would reveal that when
the matter was taken up on that day for consideration,
finding that electrical connection was not given to the main
line for want of numbering the building, it was observed
that such a situation had occurred on account of the lapse,
either on the part of the Devaswom Board or on the part of
the Civil Contractor. In such circumstances, as is evident
from
the
order,
appropriate
directions
were
issued.
Paragraph 4 of the said order would reveal that an interim
direction was issued to the Devaswom Board to release the
balance amount covered by Ext.R4(d), after giving credit to
the amounts already paid to the 4th respondent, the
Contractor. The 4th respondent was also directed to give an
undertaking in the form of a bond to the effect that, if at
all, any further defect/lapse is noted, the same would be
rectified at its costs. It is submitted by the learned counsel
appearing for the 4th respondent that in compliance with
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
the directions therein such a bond was executed and
thereafter a portion of the amount which is covered by
Ext.R4(d) was paid. It is also his contention that as relates
the electrical works for which contract was executed with
the 4th respondent by the Devaswom Board the entire
works
were
completed.
He
also
asserts
that
after
completion of the works, though electrical connection was
not given, using the generator installed in the premises of
the
auditorium
inauguration
of
the
auditorium
was
conducted in the year 2017 itself. Subsequently, a
transformer was also installed in its premises. As per the
order, taking note of all the circumstances directions were
given to ensure that steps are taken for getting electric
connection to the auditorium. On going through the order
dated 02.04.2018 though a ministerial endorsement to the
effect that the DBP was closed was made in the Judges'
papers we have no hesitation to hold that, in troth, the DBP
was not closed. In the said circumstances, the wrong
endorsement to the effect that the DBP was closed stands
deleted.
2. We will now proceed to consider the question relating the
delay in getting electrical connection to the auditorium
despite the lapse of more than two years since the order
dated 02.04.2018. It is to be noted that the construction in
question is an auditorium and evidently, it was completed
in the year 2017 itself. Its inauguration was also conducted
in the year 2017. What is remaining to be done is only
giving electrical connection to the auditorium and in that
regard, the learned counsel for the 4th respondent
submitted that the sole process which is yet to be
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
completed is 'charging' of the main line. Thus, the fact is
that even after 2½ years since then, electrical connection
is yet to be given or rather 'charging' is yet to be done.
During the course of arguments the learned Standing
Counsel for Travancore Devaswom Board handed over a
copy of the letter bearing No.49/K/20-21 dated 22.07.2020
of the Executive Engineer, Electrical Division Chengannur to
the Chief Engineer General, Trivandrum. Going by the said
letter the electrical work was commenced in 2016. It is only
profitable to extract the following recital from the said letter
in the contextual situation:"Now the auditorium runs on 3 Phase temporary
connection and 125 KVA DG Set. Permanent
electrical connection had not yet availed from
KSEB due to the non-execution of the following
works.
1) Control wiring of transformer
2) Primary and secondary connections of
transformer
3) Submission of scheme to the electrical
inspectorate and getting approval
4) Remittance of statutory fee to the electrical
inspectorate and KSEB"
We are at a loss to understand how remittance of statutory
fees to the electrical inspectorate and KSEB could be taken
as a work yet to be executed by the Contractor. There is
nothing on record to indicate that it was also a matter to be
carried out by the Contractor. The learned Standing Counsel
drew our attention to the last limb of the said letter which
reads thus:-
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
"I may also report that a demand notice worth
Rs.1,13,600/- towards the fee for availing HT
connection was issued to Assistant Commissioner,
TDB, Thrikkariyoor, from the Deputy Chief
Engineer, Electrical circle office, Perumbavoor on
22.03.2019. But it is learned that the amount was
not remitted yet."
3. The said letter dated 22.07.2020 would reveal that
pursuant to an order from the Chief Engineer General of
Travancore
Devaswom
Board
the
Executive
Engineer,
Electrical Division, Chengannur inspected the auditorium on
20.07.2020
along
with
Assistant
Engineer
Electrical,
Kottayam. The fact is that despite the order dated
02.04.2018 and the order said to have been issued by the
Deputy Chief Engineer, Electrical circle office, Perumbavoor
dated
22.03.2019,
referred
to
in
the
letter
dated
22.07.2020 no concrete steps were taken for getting
electrical connection to the auditorium. The submissions
made before us by the learned Standing Counsel for
Travancore Devaswom Board and the learned counsel for
the 4th respondent would reveal that in respect of giving of
electrical connection a process of charging the main line is
yet to take place and in that regard necessary fee has to be
paid to the electrical inspectorate and KSEB by the
Travancore Devaswom Board. In the light of the order dated
02.04.2018 it can only be said that the very purpose of the
said order is yet to be accomplished. The Board and the 4th
respondent accuse each other for the lapse and delay.
Pending consideration of such issues we think it only
appropriate to issue a direction to the Secretary, Travancore
Devaswom Board to see that the statutory fee to the
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
electrical inspectorate and KSEB is paid within a period of
two weeks from today so as to get the main line to the
auditorium 'charged'. The submission made by the learned
Standing Counsel for Travancore Devaswom Board is that to
enable remittance certain documents are to be received
from the 4th respondent Contractor. As noticed hereinbefore,
as early as on 02.04.2018 the 4th respondent submitted
before this Court that the entire electrical works were
completed. In such circumstances, necessary documents, if
any, in the possession of the 4th respondent, required for
the aforesaid purpose shall be handed over by the 4th
respondent on specific request for any such document by
the Secretary, TDB. On such receipt, the remittance of the
statutory fee to the electrical inspectorate and KSEB, shall
be effected. All such steps shall be done within the above
stipulated period.
4. I.A.No.1 of 2020 in DBP.No.123 of 2014 is filed by the
President
of
the
Temple
Advisory
Committee
of
Nettorkottukavu which was dissolved. It is stated therein
that as per order dated 10.01.2017 this Court entrusted the
task of putting the auditorium in use in a profitable manner,
pending further decision by the Travancore Devaswom
Board with the Temple Advisory Committee. On 18.08.2020
a notice was issued to him under orders of the Devaswom
Board by the Administrator Officer Nettorkkottukavu temple.
As per the same, he was required to hand over the
possession of the auditorium by name Tejaswini auditorium',
within 7 days. In the above I.A. his prayer is to the effect
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
that handing over of the possession may be directed to be
done only after obtaining orders from this Court and also in
the presence of Advocate Commissioner appointed in this
case by this Court and after preparing an inventory in
respect of the articles and materials. It is submitted that
certain officials of the Devaswom Board forcibly entered into
the auditorium and virtually took possession forcibly. It is
further submitted by the learned counsel that on that day
the original key of the auditorium was also handed over. The
response in respect of such is yet to be placed on record by
TDB. It is a fact that though the Temple Advisory Committee
accepted the task of conducting the auditorium pursuant to
the order of this Court dated 10.01.2017 accounts relating
to the amounts received and the expenses incurred incurred
are yet to be submitted for auditing. The learned counsel
submitted that accounts were never been called for. Be that
as it may, the fact is that accounts are yet to be audited.
The learned Standing Counsel submitted that he is not
aware whether the original keys were handed over or not.
The right of the TDB to run the auditorium is indisputable.
Hence, pending consideration of other issues there will be
an order to the effect that if the original key of the
auditorium was not handed over by the 4th respondent to
the officials of TDB it shall be done on 08.10.2020, in the
presence of the Advocate Commissioner appointed by this
Court in this case. If the key was already handed over, after
recording the said factum and after verification of the said
aspect from both the sides, the Advocate Commissioner
shall prepare an inventory of the articles and materials
which are in the auditorium and in the other annexed rooms.
DBP No.123 of 2014
9.
2025:KER:21057
The submission made by the learned Standing Counsel
for Travancore Devaswom Board is that in terms of the order dated
30.09.2020, the auditorium is now under the management of the
Travancore Devaswom Board. The said order was followed by
another order dated 23.07.2021, which reads thus;
"The captioned DBP was registered based on TDB Report
No.140/2014
complaints
of
in
Complaint
No.225
non-completion
of
of
construction
relating
of
an
auditorium in Nettorkottukavu Temple in Ernakulam. The
4th respondent society is the Electrical Contractor for the
work. According to it the works are completed. But,
according to the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB), the
works are yet to be completed. The learned Standing
Counsel for TDB sumits that the Kerala State Electricity
Board (KSEB) required TDB to complete certain works and
to submit completion report for the purpose of energising
the Transformer installed in the site in question. The learned
Standing Counsel further submits that some more works
have to be done before energising the Transformer. At this
juncture, the learned counsel appearing for the 4th
respondent submitted that it would be dangerous to
energise the Transformer straightaway without recalibration.
It is submitted that the Transformer was unloaded in the
premises about three years back. In such circumstances, it
is to be verified whether recalibration is required before
energising the same. The rival contentins would reveal that
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
the construction of the auditorium was completed and it has
been functioning now, using generators. Therefore, the only
question now to be resolved is whether the Transformer can
be straighaway energised after completing the works which
according to the KSEB remaining to be done before
energising the Transformer. The word of caution sounded by
the 4th respondent society is not a matter to be brushed
aside. Taking note of the said circumstances, we are of the
view that the competent engineers attached to the TDB and
Electrical Engineers of KSEB can conduct a joint Inspection
regarding the necessity or otherwise of recalibration of the
Transformer which is installed in the premises of the
auditorium for the purpose of energising the same. To
enable such a joint inspection it will be open to the TDB to
make a requistion to the competent authority of the KSEB
to depute competent Electrical Engineers to conduct an
inspection to decide on the requirement or otherwise of
recalibration of the Transformer. They may do so within a
week from today. On receipt of such requisition the officer
concerned of the KSEB shall ensure deputation of competent
Engineer for the aforesaid purpose within a week thereafter.
After such inspection a report on the requirement or
otherwise of recalibration, shall be furnished to this Court
on or before 11.08.2021. Further orders would be passed
on perusing such a report. It will also be open to the parties
to move this Court before 11.08.2021."
10.
On
08.04.2022,
when
this
DBP
came
consideration, this Court passed the following order;
up
for
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
Electrification work of the auditorium of Nettoorkottu Kavu
Devaswom is yet to be completed. The 4th respondent, a
Society registered under the Kerala Co-operative Societies
Act is the contractor. The contract was entered into on
13.06.2016. The work was agreed to be completed within
six months. Since there was delay in completion of the work,
this Court had to intervene in the matter on several
occasions. This Court on 02.04.2018 while considering the
matter, noticed that there was only a slow progress in the
work
and
both
sides,
the
1st
respondent-Travancore
Devaswom and the 4th respondent-contractor were hurling
allegations at each other. After considering the matter in
detail, this Court on the said day directed as follows:
"4. In the said circumstance, we find it appropriate to direct
the Devaswom Board to release the balance amount covered
by Ext.R4(d), after giving credit to the amounts already paid
to the 4th respondent pursuant to the interim orders passed
by this Court. This shall be on giving an 'undertaking' in the
form of 'bond' by the 4th respondent, that if at all any
further defect/lapse is noted, the same shall be rectified at
the cost of the 4th respondent. The undertaking made by
the learned counsel for the 4th respondent in this regard
before this Court is also recorded. It is ordered accordingly."
2. Despite such undertaking, there still occurred delay in
completing the remaining work. The matter has again come
up for consideration before this Court on 30.09.2020. This
Court took cognizance of the fact that the auditorium was
running on 3-phase temporary connection and 125 KVA DG
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
set and that causes much loss to the Devaswom Board.
Hence it was held that permanent electric connection from
the Kerala State Electricity Board should immediately be
availed, and therefore, the 4th respondent should complete
the work without any further delay. Accordingly, this Court
passed the following order:
"The submissions made before us by the learned
Standing Counsel for Travancore Devaswom Board and
the learned counsel for the 4th respondent would
reveal that in respect of giving of electrical connection
a process of charging the main line is yet to take place
and in that regard necessary fee has to be paid to the
electrical inspectorate and KSEB by the Travancore
Devaswom Board. In the light of the order dated
02.04.2018 it can only be said that the very purpose
of the said order is yet to be accomplished. The Board
and the 4th respondent accuse each other for the lapse
and delay. Pending consideration of such issues we
think it only appropriate to issue a direction to the
Secretary, Travancore Devaswom Board to see that the
statutory fee to the electrical inspectorate and KSEB is
paid within a period of two weeks from today so as to
get the main line to the auditorium 'charged'. The
submission made by the learned Standing Counsel for
Travancore Devaswom Board is that to enable
remittance certain documents are to be received from
the 4th respondent Contractor. As noticed herein
before, as early as on 2.4.2018 the 4th respondent
submitted before this court that the entire electrical
works were completed. In such circumstances,
necessary documents, if any, in the possession of the
4th respondent, required for the aforesaid purpose
shall be handed over by the 4th respondent on specific
request for any such document by the Secretary, TDB.
On such receipt, the remittance of the statutory fee to
the electrical inspectorate and KSEB, shall be effected.
All such steps shall be done within the above stipulated
period."
DBP No.123 of 2014
3.
On
13.08.2021,
the
1st
2025:KER:21057
respondent Tranvancore
Devaswom Board pointed out the unceasing delay in
completion of work of electrification and energizing the
transformer. The works remained to be completed before
energisation of the transformer were brought to the notice
of this Court. The 4th respondent then contended that the
estimated cost of the remaining work was Rs.2,94,000/- and
he was short of funds. This Court after taking into all aspects
directed the 1st respondent to release an amount of Rs.3
lakhs with a direction that within three weeks of receipt of
the above said amount, the 4th respondent should carry out
the works specifically mentioned in paragraph No.6 of
additional statement filed by the
1st respondent on
13.08.2021. The amount was accordingly released and the
4th respondent does not dispute that fact.
4. Still, the work remained incomplete and when the matter
was taken up for consideration on 21.12.2021, the learned
counsel appearing for the
4th respondent reported no
instruction from the party and therefore this Court gave
direction to the Superintendent of Police, Muvattupuzha to
ensure personal appearance of the 4th respondent, District
Contractors
and
Labourers
Co-operative
Society
Ltd.
Accordingly, on 23.12.2021, the President of the 4 th
respondent Society appeared before this Court. He then
undertook to complete the work without any further delay
and that at any rate within two weeks. That undertaking was
also recorded by this Court.
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
5. The learned Standing Counsel for the Travancore
Devaswom Board filed a statement that the work remained
incomplete and also pointing out the works remain to be
completed. This Court therefore directed the additional 5th
respondent to conduct an inspection and submit a report
regarding the present status of the electrification work.
Accordingly, the 5th respondent inspected the premises and
submitted a report dated 21.02.2022. In that report, the
Assistant
Executive
Engineer,
Electrical
Sub
Division,
Muvattupuzha, additional 5th respondent, pointed out nine
items of work yet to be completed for energisation of the
transformer. The 4th respondent filed a counter affidavit in
answer to the said report. The learned Standing Counsel for
the
1st respondent filed additional
statements dated
23.03.2022 and 05.04.2022.
6. Heard the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the 1st
respondent and the learned counsel appearing for the 4th
respondent.
7. In the counter affidavit, the 4th respondent took the view
that works noted to be incomplete in the report dated
21.02.2022 are only trivial in nature. Out of nine items, item
No.7, namely fencing and yard metalling is not a part of the
contract and it has to be done independently. Item No.1 is
obtaining approval from the Electrical Inspectorate, for
which no work at the site is required. The learned Standing
Counsel appearing for the 1st respondent would submit that
work of providing a canopy to the transformer is the
responsibility of the Board and that would be done by the
Board. Thus excepting the works of providing canopy to the
DBP No.123 of 2014
transformer
and
fencing
and
yard
2025:KER:21057
metalling all the
remaining works are the responsibility of the 4th respondent.
8. The learned counsel appearing for the 4th respondent
would contend that there was delay in making payment by
the 1st respondent and that has contributed to the delay in
completion of the work. In the additional statement dated
05.04.2022 filed by the 1st respondent it is stated that
Rs.52,50,000/- has already been paid to the 4th respondent.
Pursuant to the order dated 13.08.2021, Rs.3 lakhs was
paid to him, when in his view, Rs.2,94,000/- was the
estimated value of the remaining work. Therefore, the 4 th
respondent cannot have any complaint that on account of
non-payment of money, there occurred delay.
9. This Court accepted more than once the undertakings
made by the 4th respondent to complete the work within a
time frame. Repeatedly, this Court issued directions to the
4th respondent to complete the work within the specified
period in the respective orders. Despite such undertakings
and directions from this Court, the 4th respondent did not
care to complete the work and see that the transformer is
energized.
10. The 4th respondent is bound by the conditions of the
contract. It is a work contract. It is not for this Court to
intervene at every stage of the work and ensure progress.
In case there is lapse on the part of the 4th respondent in
accomplishing the work in terms of the contract, certainly
the consequences would have to follow. That apart, the 4 th
respondent did not oblige the directions of this Court and
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
also failed to honour the undertakings he has made before
this Court. We are refraining from commenting any further
on those aspects at this stage.
11. A contractor cannot protract his work under the contract
stating one of the other excuses, which is untenable in the
circumstances of the contract. The remaining work as
pointed out by additional 5th respondent in his report dated
21.02.2022
shall
be
completed
and
the
transformer
energized within one month from today.
12. We accordingly direct that,(i) within one month from today, the 1st respondent shall
see that the works of providing canopy to the transformer
and fencing and yard-metalling are done on its initiative.
(ii) within one month from today, the 4th respondent shall
complete the entire remaining work and get the transformer
energized.
(iii) In case any help or assistance in processing papers
relating
to
obtaining
permission
from
the
Electrical
Department and the Kerala State Electricity Board Limited
is required to the 4th respondent, officials of the 1st
respondent, within a day of receipt of the request, shall do
the needful.
13. We make it clear that any lapse on the part of the 4 th
respondent will invite not only action for violation of the
terms of the contract, but also penal consequences for
violation of the undertakings made by him before this Court
and for disobedience of the repeated directions given to him
by this Court.”
DBP No.123 of 2014
11.
2025:KER:21057
On 09.07.2024, the learned Standing Counsel for
Travancore Devaswom Board submitted that steps are being taken
to execute a service connection agreement as requested by the
Executive Engineer, KSEB, which shall be executed within two days.
Thereafter, on 18.07.2024, the learned Standing Counsel for KSEB
submitted that measures have been taken and energization will
be carried out on that day. The said submission was recorded.
12.
Today, when this matter is taken up for consideration,
it is submitted at the Bar that energization has already taken place
on 18.07.2024.
13.
Heard the learned Standing Counsel for Travancore
Devaswom Board for the Board and its officials, the learned
counsel for the 4th respondent District Contractors and Laborers
Cooperative Societies Ltd., the learned counsel for the additional
6th respondent, the learned Standing Counsel for KSEB, the
learned Amicus Curie for the learned Ombudsman and also the
learned Senior Government Pleader for the additional 8 th
respondent State and the additional 9th respondent Senior Deputy
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Travancore Devaswom
Board Audit.
14.
Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act,
1950 enacted by the State Legislature makes provision for the
administration, supervision and control of incorporated and
unincorporated
Devaswoms
and
of
other
Hindu
Religious
Endowments and Funds. Section 15A of the Act, inserted by Act 5
of 2007, with effect from 12.04.2007, deals with duties of the
Board. As per Section 15A, it shall be the duty of the Board to
perform the following functions, namely, (i) to see that the regular
traditional rites and ceremonies according to the practice
prevalent in the religious institutions are performed promptly; (ii)
to monitor whether the administrative officials and employees and
also the employees connected with religious rites are functioning
properly; (iii) to ensure proper maintenance and upliftment of the
Hindu religious institutions; (iv) to establish and maintain proper
facilities in the temples for the devotees. As per Section 16 of the
Act, the Board shall, subject to the provisions of Part I of the Act,
exercise supervision and control over the acts and proceedings of
all officers and servants of the Board and of the Devaswom
Department. As per Section 31 of the Act, subject to the provisions
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
of Part I and the rules made thereunder, the Board shall manage
the properties and affairs of the Devaswoms, both incorporated,
and unincorporated as heretofore, and arrange for the conduct of
the daily worship and ceremonies and of the festivals in every
temple according to its usage.
15.
In Ram Mohan Das v. Travancore Devaswom
Board [1975 KLT 55] a learned Single Judge of this Court held
that, under Section 31 of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious
Institutions Act, the Travancore Devaswom Board shall manage
the properties and affairs of the Devaswoms, both incorporated
and unincorporated and arrange for the conduct of the daily
worship and ceremonies and of the festivals in every temple
according to its usage. The position of the Board in regard to the
Devaswoms - incorporated and unincorporated - is analogous to
that of trustees. Any improper act of the Trustees could be
questioned by a worshipper.
16.
In M.V. Ramasubbiar v. Manicka Narasimachara
[(1979) 2 SCC 65], in the context of Sections 49, 51 and 52 of
the Trusts Act, 1882, the Apex Court explained the nature of the
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
fiduciary position of the trustee and his duties and obligations. It
is the duty of the trustees of the property to be faithful to the Trust
and execute any document with reasonable diligence in the
manner of an ordinary prudent man of business would conduct his
own affairs. A trustee could not, therefore, occasion any loss to
the Trust and it is his duty to sell the property if at all that was
necessary, to the best advantage. Paragraph 4 of that decision
reads thus;
“4. There is some controversy on the question whether
defendant 1 made an outright purchase of the suit property
for and on behalf of the trust for Rs. 21,500 on April 19,
1959, or whether he intended to purchase it for himself and
then decided to pass it on to the trust, for defendants have
led their evidence to show that the property was allowed to
be sold for Rs.21,500, which was less than its market value,
as it was meant for use by the trust and that Defendant 1
was not acting honestly when he palmed off the property to
his son soon after by the aforesaid sale deed Ext.B13 dated
July 14, 1960. The fact, however, remains that Defendant 1
was the trustee of the property, and it was his duty to be
faithful to the trust and to execute it with reasonable
diligence in the manner an ordinary prudent man of
business would conduct his own affairs. He could not
therefore occasion any loss to the trust and it was his duty
to sell the property, if at all that was necessary, to best
advantage. It has in fact been well recognised as an
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
inflexible rule that a person in a fiduciary position like a
trustee is not entitled to make a profit for himself or a
member of his family. It can also not be gainsaid that he is
not allowed to put himself in any such position in which a
conflict may arise between his duty and personal interest,
and so the control of the trustee's discretionary power
prescribed by Section 49 of the Act and the prohibition
contained in Section 51 that the trustee may not use or deal
with the trust property for his own profit or for any other
purpose unconnected with the trust, and the equally
important prohibition in Section 52 that the trustee may not,
directly or indirectly, buy the trust property on his own
account or as an agent for a third person, cast a heavy
responsibility upon him in the matter of discharge of his
duties as the trustee. It does not require much argument to
proceed to the inevitable further conclusion that the Rule
prescribed by the aforesaid sections of the Act cannot be
evaded by making a sale in the name of the trustee's
partner or son, for that would, in fact and substance,
indirectly benefit the trustee. Where therefore a trustee
makes the sale of a property belonging to the trust, without
any compelling reason, in favour of his son, without
obtaining the permission of the court concerned, it is the
duty of the court, in which the sale is challenged, to examine
whether the trustee has acted reasonably and in good faith
or whether he has committed a breach of the trust by
benefitting himself from the transaction in an indirect
manner. The sale in question has therefore to be viewed
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
with suspicion and the High Court committed an error of law
in ignoring this important aspect of the law although it had
a
direct
bearing
on
the
controversy
before
it.”
(underline supplied)
17.
In A.A. Gopalakrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom
Board [(2007) 7 SCC 482] a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex
Court held that the properties of deities, temples and Devaswom
Boards, require to be protected and safeguarded by their
trustees/archakas/shebaits/employees.
Instances
are
many
where persons entrusted with the duty of managing and
safeguarding the properties of temples, deities and Devaswom
Boards have usurped and misappropriated such properties by
setting up false claims of ownership or tenancy, or adverse
possession. This is possible only with the passive or active
collusion of the authorities concerned. Such acts of ‘fence eating
the crops’ should be dealt with sternly. The Government, members
or trustees of boards/trusts, and devotees should be vigilant to
prevent any such usurpation or encroachment. It is also the duty
of courts to protect and safeguard the properties of religious and
charitable institutions from wrongful claims or misappropriation.
18.
In Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair
[(2013) 3 KLT 132] a Division Bench of this Court noticed that
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
in A.A. Gopalakrishnan [(2007) 7 SCC 482] a Three-Judge
Bench of the Apex Court emphasised that it is the duty of the
courts to protect and safeguard the interest and properties of the
religious and charitable institutions. The Division Bench further
noticed that the relevant principles under the Hindu law will show
that the deity is always treated similar to that of a minor and there
are some points of similarity between a minor and a Hindu idol.
The High Court is the guardian of the deity and apart from the
revisional jurisdiction under Section 103 of the Kerala Land
Reforms Act, 1963, the High Court is having inherent jurisdiction
and the doctrine of parens patriae will also apply in exercising the
jurisdiction.
19.
In Abu
K.S. v. Travancore
Devaswom
Board
[2022:KER:6409 : 2022 SCC OnLine Ker 1642] a Division
Bench of this Court, in which one among us [Anil K. Narendran,
J.] was a party, was dealing with a case in which Kuthaka right for
running
Aymanam
Sri.
Narasimha-swami
Auditorium
(sadyalayam) constructed by the Travancore Devaswom Board
was auctioned for a period of two years. The writ petitioner, who
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
was the successful bidder, remitted only 50% of the auction
amount on 18.07.2019. Though he had defaulted payment of the
balance amount of Rs.1,20,500/-, he was permitted to continue
to occupy the sadyalayam, even beyond the period of auction, i.e.,
beyond 31.07.2021. The concerned Assistant Commissioner and
the Sub Group Officer have not taken any action against him till
the order of this Court dated 01.02.2022, whereby they were
directed to take over possession of the sadyalayam forthwith, if
found necessary with police assistance. In the said decision,
relying on the decision of the Apex Court in M.V. Ramasubbiar
v. Manicka Narasimachara [(1979) 2 SCC 65], this Court
found that, the concerned officers of the Travancore Devaswom
Board, who have permitted the successful bidder (who has
remitted only 50% of the auction amount) to continue to occupy
the sadyalayam, even beyond the period of the auction, have not
shown reasonable diligence in the manner of an ordinary prudent
man of business to conduct his own affairs.
20.
In Suo motu v. State of Kerala and others [2022
(2) KHC 411] this Court held that in view of the provisions under
the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act and the
law laid down in the decisions referred to supra, the 3rd respondent
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
Travancore Devaswom Board is duty bound to ensure proper
administration, supervision and control of Sabarimala Devaswom,
which is an incorporated Devaswom mentioned in Schedule I of
the said Act, under the Chengannur Group. The Board has a
statutory duty to monitor whether its administrative officials and
employees and also the employees connected with religious rites
are functioning properly. The Board is duty bound to exercise
proper supervision and control over the acts and proceedings of
all officers and servants and to manage the properties and affairs
of Sabarimala Devaswom and conduct daily worships and
ceremonies and also festivals in the temple according to its usage.
The position of the Board in this regard is analogous to that of
trustees, as held by this Court in Ram Mohan Das [1975 KLT
55]. Any improper act of the trustees could be questioned by a
worshiper.
21.
In Suo motu [2022 (2) KHC 411] this Court held
that the Travancore Devaswom Board and those entrusted with
the duty of managing the properties and affairs of Sabarimala
Devaswom are duty bound to protect the properties of the deity
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
from any wrongful claims, theft or misappropriation. The position
of the Board in this regard is analogous to that of trustees. Any
such wrongful claims, theft or misappropriation with the passive
or active collusion of the authorities concerned, which are acts of
‘fence eating the crops’ should be dealt with sternly. The deity
being a perpetual minor, this Court is having inherent jurisdiction
to protect and safeguard the interest and properties of the deity
and the doctrine of parens patriae will also apply in the exercise
of such jurisdiction.
22.
In the instant case, as already noticed hereinbefore,
the construction work of the auditorium in question was started in
the year 2009. From the year 2017 to 2022, the auditorium was
managed by the Temple Advisory Committee and thereafter from
the year 2022 onwards it is under the management of the
Travancore Devaswom Board. Due to the delay in installation of
transformer for drawing high tension power supply to the
auditorium, for a considerably long period, the auditorium was
functioning with generator backup.
23.
In the order dated 27.10.2014, a Division Bench of this
Court noticed that, notwithstanding the fact that more than Rs.3
Crores has been spent, the construction of the auditorium could
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
not be completed and a further sum of Rs.2.60 Crores is required
to complete the work. In that order the Division Bench observed
that a thorough probe into the construction of the auditorium in
the Devaswom land of Nettorkottukavu Bhagavathi Temple should
be conducted. By the order dated 14.10.2015 the Division Bench
referred the matter back to the learned Ombudsman to consider
whether guidelines could be issued to revamp and if necessary,
restructure the process of the Board in awarding contract works.
Pursuant to that direction, the learned Ombudsman has filed TDB
Report No.3 of 2017, in which various suggestions have been
made, which are extracted hereinbefore at paragraph 5. In the
said report, the learned Ombudsman has also considered the
suggestions put forth by the State Audit Department.
24.
Having considered the pleadings and materials on
record and also the submissions made at the Bar, we deem it
appropriate to dispose of this DBP by directing the additional 9 th
respondent Senior Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit Department,
Travancore Devaswom Board Audit to conduct audit of the entire
income and expenditure in connection with the construction work
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
of the auditorium of Nettorkottukavu Bhagavathi Temple, including
the income and expenditure when the auditorium was managed
by the Temple Advisory Committee from the year 2017 to 2022
and thereafter when it is under the management of the Travancore
Devaswom
Board.
The
relevant
accounts
with
supporting
documents by the Temple Advisory Committee and the Travancore
Devaswom Board shall be made available to additional 9 th
respondent Senior Deputy Director, within a period of one month
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. The
Chief Engineer, Travancore Devaswom Board shall ensure that the
State Audit Department is provided with the relevant records
relating to the construction work in question and the concerned
Assistant Devaswom Commissioner as well as the Deputy
Devaswom Commissioner shall ensure that the accounts and other
records, which are necessary for the State Audit Department to
complete the audit of accounts, are provided to the Senior Deputy
Director, by the concerned officer of the Devaswom and the office
bearers of the Temple Advisory Committee, so as to enable the
Senior Deputy Director to complete the statutory audit, without
any delay. After completing the statutory audit, the report of the
State Audit Department shall be filed before this Court, which shall
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
be numbered as a DBAR and placed for consideration before the
Division Bench dealing with Devaswom matters.
It would be open to additional 9th respondent Senior Deputy
Director to file interim reports before this Court, in case further
directions of this Court are necessary for completing the statutory
audit, which shall also be numbered as DBAR and listed before the
Division Bench dealing with Devaswom matters.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
MSA
DBP No.123 of 2014
2025:KER:21057
APPENDIX OF DBP 123/2014
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R4(y)
THE ORIGINAL ELECTRONIC TRIVECTOR METER
ROUTINE TEST REPORT DATED 5/4/2021
ISSUED BY ITS MANUFACTURER L & T
AUTOMATION PRODUCTS
Exhibit R4(z)
ORIGINAL TEST CERTIFICATE OF CT & PT
DATED 2/12/2021 ISSUED BY KSEB,
ANGAMALLY
Annexure R4(AA)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 2-8-2023
ISSUED BY THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
TRIKARIYOOR GROUP DEVASWOM TO THE
ASSISTANT ENGINEER, KSEB SECTION,
MUVATTUPUZHA
Annexure R4(BB)
TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT SHOWING
REMITTANCE OF RS.2,490/- TOWARDS
APPLICATION FEE DATED 3-8-2023
Annexure R4(CC)
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION FORM
SUBMITTED TO THE KSEB DATED 15-12-2022
Annexure R4(CC) a
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED NIL
Annexure R4(DD)
TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT SHOWING
REMITTANCE OF RS.10,538/- ON 3-8-2023
VIDE RECEIPT NO.0275254,
Annexure R4(EE)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 3-8-2023
ISSUED BY THE ASSISTANT ENGINEER
ELECTRICAL SECTION, MUVATTUPUZHA TO THE
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER TMR METER TESTING
UNIT DATED 3-8-2023
Annexure R4(FF)
TRUE COPY OF THE REQUISITION FOR METER
TESTING IN FORM – 1, DATED 3-8-2023
Annexure R4(GG)
TRUE COPY OF THE TEST CERTIFICATE
BEARING FILE NO.TMR/AGY/52/2023-24/74,
DATED 5-8-2023
DBP No.123 of 2014
Annexure R4(HH)
2025:KER:21057
TRUE COPY OF THE REQUEST DATED 5-8-2023
SUBMITTED BY THE DEPONENT BEFORE THE
ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, TMR
SECTION, KSEB, ANGAMALY,
Annexure R4(II)
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY GIVEN BY THE
ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, TMR
SECTION KSEB, ANGAMALY,
Annexure R4(JJ)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 5-8-2023
SUBMITTED BY THE DEPONENT BEFORE THE
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, THIRUVITHAMKOOR
DEVASWOM BOARD
Annexure R4(KK)
TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT SHOWING
REMITTANCE OF RS.1180 FOR INSPECTION FEE
Annexure R4(LL)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 5-8-2023,
ISSUED BY THE ASSISTANT ENGINEER, KSEB
ELECTRICAL SECTION, MUVATTUPUZHA, TO THE
DEPUTY CHIEF ELECTRICAL INSPECTOR
Annexure R4(MM)
TRUE COPY OF THE COVERING LETTER ALONG
WITH WHICH ANNEX.R4(LL) WAS FURNISHED TO
THE DEPUTY CHIEF ELECTRICAL INSPECTOR
AND RECEIPT SHOWING SUBMISSION OF THE
SAME
Annexure R4(OO)
TRUE COPY OF THE COVERING LETTER DATED
21-08-2023 ISSUED BY THE ASST.DEVASWOM
COMMISSIONER THRIKKARIYOOR GROUP
Annexure R4 (NN)
TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT DATED
17/08/2023 FORWARDED TO
THE ,ASST.ENGINEEER, KSEB SECTION
MUVATTUPUZHA BY THE DEPUTY CHIEF
ELECTRICAL INSPECTOR FROM THE OFFICE OF
THE DEPUTY CHIEF ELECTRICAL INSPECTOR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review