The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, the present appeals succeed. The impugned judgments and orders passed by the High Court [Abdul Matin Mallick v. Subrata Bhattacharjee (Banerjee), OnLine Cal 3853] , [Subrata Bhattacharjee (Banerjee) v. Abdul Matin Mallick, 2021 appellate court are hereby quashed and set aside. Consequently, the pre-emption application submitted by the original preemptors 4 Respondents 1 to 3 herein stands dismissed. Respondents 1 to 3 4 original pre-emptors are permitted to withdraw the amount, which they might have deposited either along with the preemption application and/or any subsequent deposit pursuant to the orders passed by the High Court.
8. In the decision of Chitta Ranjan Misra vs. Subrata Majhi and others decided in CO 451 of 2023 this Court discussed the scope and the effect of the decision in Barasat Eye Hospital (supra). This Court held that the law laid down in Barasat Eye Hospital (supra) was a law declared and it had a retrospective effect. The relevant portions are quoted below:5Upon a meaningful reading of the decision, it is evident that the object of the said decision was to put to rest the controversy in respect of exercise of such a weak right, especially in the matter of short deposits. The Apex court took note of the fact that the decision would have a far larger ramification, as many cases were pending before this High Court on this point. Secondly, the law was in existence since 1955, but the interpretation of the same in respect of the requirement to deposit the consideration amount was finally put to rest in the decision of Barasat Eye Hospital (supra). It was a law declared on the point and will have a retrospective effect. The Hon8ble Apex Court was of the view that if short deposits were allowed, a weak right would give rise to speculative suits. In the decision of Abdul Matin (supra), a similar view was taken by the Hon8ble Apex Court upon relying on the decision in Barasat Eye Hospital (supra). The Hon8ble Apex Court was dealing with Misc. Preemption Case No.8 of 2012 which had been filed …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
02.02.2026
Sl. No.05
Court No.06
Cp
C.O. 4371 of 2025
Nepal Chandra Saha Roy & Anr.
vs.
Najira Gazi & Ors.
Mr. Debasis Roy, Sr. Advocate
Ms. Srijata Mukherjee
… for the petitioners.
1. This is an application challenging an order
dated November 17, 2025, passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), 6th
Court, Alipore, District 3 South 24 Parganas,
in Misc. Case No.38 of 2025.
2. By the order impugned, the learned court
rejected an application filed by the petitioners
seeking a direction upon the manager of the
bank to freeze the amount of Rs.98,36,959/standing in the name of Nepal Chandra Saha
Roy, bearing SBI Account No.33723306251,
IIM Joka Branch and Tapan Chandra Saha
Roy bearing SBI Account No.11408480426,
Kulerdari SBI Branch. The learned court held
that Section 8 of the West Bengal Land
Reforms Act mandated that consideration
amount along with 10% had to be deposited
by the petitioners along with the application
for preemption. Thus, the prayer of the
petitioners for freezing the bank account, was
not allowed. The court held that freezing the
account was not equivalent to the statutory
mandate to deposit the consideration money
along with 10% thereof under Section 8 of the
West Bengal Land Reforms Act.
3. Mr. Roy, learned senior advocate for the
petitioners, submits that the bank rules did
not permit the petitioners to withdraw the
money in cash at a time and, as such, the
prayer was made before the learned court for
freezing of the account.
4. In my view, the prayer was in the nature of
attachment of the account of the petitioners.
This is not a situation in which such order by
the court would absolve the petitioners from
the statutory mandate of compulsory deposit
of the consideration money along with 10%
thereof
along
with
the
application
for
preemption. The law mandates that the
consideration amount along with the 10% of
the consideration money must be deposited
with the application for preemption, at least
within the period of limitation as has been
prescribed by the statute. The right of
preemption does not trigger unless such
amount is deposited.
5. On November 17, 2025, the court had no
authority under the law to pass orders to
freeze the amount as prayed for by the
petitioners
towards
compliance
of
the
statutory mandate under Section 8 of the
West Bengal Land Reforms Act. The relevant
decisions of the Hon8ble Apex Court are
discussed below in support of the contention
that there was no scope for the court to allow
the application by freezing the account of the
petitioners, in lieu of deposit of the money in
court. The full amount must be deposited as
per law.
6. The relevant paragraphs of Barasat Eye
Hospital & Ors. Vs. Kaustabh Mondal
reported in (2019) 19 SCC 767 :29. We are, thus, firmly of the view that
the pre-requisite to even endeavour to
exercise this weak right is the deposit of
the amount of sale consideration and the
10% levy on that consideration, as
otherwise, Section 8(1) of the said Act will
not be triggered off, apart from making
even the beginning of Section 9(1) of the
said Act otiose.
30. We are not inclined to construe the
aforesaid provisions otherwise only on the
ground that there are no so-called 5penal
provisions6 included. The provisions of
Sections 8 and 9 of the said Act must be
read as they are. In fact, it is a settled rule
of construction that legislative provisions
should be read in their plain grammatical
connotation, and only in the case of
conflicts between different provisions
would an endeavour have to be made to
read them in a manner that they co-exist
and no part of the rule is made
superfluous.
[British
India
General
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Itbar Singh, AIR
1959 SC 1331] The interpretation, as we
have adopted, would show that really
speaking, no part of either Section 8, or
Section 9 of the said Act is made otiose.
Even if an inquiry takes place in the aspect
of stated consideration, on a plea of some
fraud or likewise, and if such a finding is
reached, the amount can always be
directed to be refunded, if deposited in
excess. However, it cannot be said that a
discretion can be left to the pre-emptor to
deposit whatever amount, in his opinion,
is the appropriate consideration, in order
to exercise a right of pre-emption. The full
amount has to be deposited.
31. We may also note that, as a matter of
fact, the pre-emptor in the present case i.e.
the respondent has not filed any material
to substantiate even the plea on the basis
of which, even if an inquiry was held,
could a conclusion be reached that the
stated consideration is not the market
value of the land.
32. We also believe that to give such a
discretion to the pre-emptor, without
deposit of the full consideration, would
give rise to speculative litigation, where the
pre-emptor,
by
depositing
smaller
amounts, can drag on the issue of the
vendee exercising rights in pursuance of
the valid sale deed executed. In the present
case, there is a sale deed executed and
registered, setting out the consideration.6
7. Abdul
Matin
Mallick
vs.
Subrata
Bhattacharjee (Banerjee) reported in AIR
2022 SC 2175 was also dealing with the
issue of short deposit by a non-notified co-
sharer, and the objection was with regard to
inflated amount quoted in the sale deed.
The Hon8ble Apex Court applied the law
declared in Barasat Eye Hospital (supra)
in the said case as well. The said ratio was
applied
to
a
pending
proceeding.
The
relevant portions of Abdul Matin Mallick
(Supra) are quoted below:52.1. That the disputed property in
question, which was the subject-matter of
application for pre-emption before the
Appropriate Authority under the West
Bengal
Land
Reforms
Act,
(hereinafter referred to as 5the 1955 Act6)
belonged to one Khudiram Bhattacharya,
who died on 17-4-2001 leaving behind
him, surviving his widow Purnima
Bhattacharya who also died on 14-8-2001
and
three
sons,
namely,
Subrata,
Debabrata and Ratan (the pre-emptors
herein) and two daughters Kalyani and
Alpana, the vendors of the pre-emptee
(appellant herein). On the death of
Khudiram Bhattacharya and his widow,
the aforesaid three sons and two
daughters inherited the property in
question each having undivided 1/5th
share therein. The daughters of the
original owner 4 Khudiram Bhattacharya
sold their undivided 2/5th share in the
property in question to the appellant
herein 4 pre-emptee, Abdul Matin Mallick
vide registered sale deed dated 23-112011. The sale in favour of the appellant
by the daughters of the said Khudiram
Bhattacharya was sought to be pre-empted
by
the
sons
of
said
Khudiram
Bhattacharya on the ground that their
sisters have transferred their undivided
share in the property in question to the
appellant, a stranger to the said property
without serving statutory notice under
sub-section (5) of Section 5 of the 1955
Act. The said application under Section 8
of the 1955 Act was registered as Misc.
Pre-emption Case No. 8 of 2012 before the
learned trial court.
***
6.1. Thus, as observed and held by this
Court in the aforesaid judgment in Bishan
Singh [Bishan Singh v. Khazan Singh, AIR
1958 SC 838] , the right of pre-emption is
5a very weak right6. That being the
character of the right, any provision to
enforce such a right must, thus, be strictly
construed. [Barasat Eye Hospital [Barasat
Eye Hospital v. Kaustabh Mondal, (2019)
19 SCC 767 : (2020) 4 SCC (Civ) 810] ]
6.2. The submission/contention on behalf
of the pre-emptee that, as in the present
case,
along
with
the
pre-emption
application, the pre-emptors did not
deposit the entire sale consideration with
10% additional sale consideration, and
therefore their pre-emption application
was not required to be further considered
and no further enquiry as contemplated
under Section 9 of the 1955 Act would be
maintainable is concerned, identical
question came to be considered by this
Court in Barasat Eye Hospital [Barasat
Eye Hospital v. Kaustabh Mondal, (2019)
19 SCC 767 : (2020) 4 SCC (Civ) 810]
wherein at paras 23 to 33, it is observed
and held as under : (SCC pp. 779-81)
6.3. Therefore, deposit of the entire sale
consideration with additional 10% of the
sale consideration along with the preemption application is a statutory and
mandatory requirement and it is a
precondition before any further enquiry as
contemplated under Section 9 of the Act is
held. In the present case, admittedly, the
pre-emptors had not deposited the entire
sale consideration with additional 10% of
the sale consideration along with the preemption application. The aforesaid aspects
have not been considered either by the
first appellate court or even by the High
Court in this case.
***
7. Now, so far as the submission on behalf
of the pre-emptors that they bona fide
believed that the sale consideration
mentioned in the sale deed is in favour of
the vendee, who is an outsider (outside the
family) was higher than the actual sale
consideration and therefore, they did not
deposit the entire sale consideration with
additional 10% of the sale consideration
along with the pre-emption application is
concerned, it is to be noted that the
aforesaid cannot be a ground not to
comply with the condition of deposit as
required under Section 8 of the 1955 Act.
At the most, such a dispute can be the
subject-matter of an enquiry provided
under Section 9 of the Act. As observed
hereinabove, the enquiry under Section 9
with respect to the sale consideration in
the sale deed would be only after the
condition of deposit of entire sale
consideration with additional 10% as
provided under Section 8 of the Act has
been complied with.
8. Now, so far as the submission on behalf
of the pre-emptors that the contention of
non-deposit
of
the
entire
sale
consideration with additional 10% of the
sale consideration by the pre-emptors was
not raised before the courts below and has
been raised for the first time before this
Court, and therefore the same be not
considered/permitted to be raised now, is
concerned, it is to be noted that the said
contention would go to the root of the
matter on maintainability of the preemption application as without complying
with the statutory requirements as
mentioned under Section 8 of the 1955
Act, the same is not maintainable. It is an
admitted position that the pre-emptors
had not deposited the entire sale
consideration with additional 10% of the
sale consideration along with the preemption application as required under
Section 8 of the Act in the instant case. In
view of the aforesaid admitted position, we
have considered the submission on behalf
of the appellant on non-fulfilment of the
condition mentioned in Section 8 of the
Act.
9. At this stage, it is required to be noted
that even the High Court in the impugned
judgment and order has permitted the pre-
emptors to deposit the balance sale
consideration. However, faced with the
decision of this Court in Barasat Eye
Hospital [Barasat
Eye
Hospital v. Kaustabh Mondal, (2019) 19
SCC 767 : (2020) 4 SCC (Civ) 810] and in
light of the observations made by us
hereinabove that along with the preemption application, the pre-emptors have
to deposit the entire sale consideration
with additional 10% and only thereafter
the further enquiry can be conducted as
per Section 9 of the 1955 Act and
therefore, unless and until the same is
complied with, the pre-emption application
would not be maintainable, the High Court
is not justified in permitting the preemptors to now deposit the balance sale
consideration with additional 10% while
deciding the revision application. Such a
direction/permission/liberty
would
go
against the intent of Section 8 of the 1955
Act.
10. In view of the above and for the
reasons stated above, the present appeals
succeed. The impugned judgments and
orders passed by the High Court [Abdul
Matin Mallick v. Subrata Bhattacharjee
(Banerjee),
SCC
OnLine
Cal
3853] , [Subrata
Bhattacharjee
(Banerjee) v. Abdul Matin Mallick, 2021
SCC OnLine Cal 3548] and that of the first
appellate court are hereby quashed and
set aside. Consequently, the pre-emption
application submitted by the original preemptors 4 Respondents 1 to 3 herein
stands dismissed. Respondents 1 to 3 4
original pre-emptors are permitted to
withdraw the amount, which they might
have deposited either along with the preemption
application
and/or
any
subsequent deposit pursuant to the orders
passed by the High Court.
8. In the decision of Chitta Ranjan Misra vs.
Subrata Majhi and others decided in CO
451 of 2023 this Court discussed the
scope and the effect of the decision in
Barasat Eye Hospital (supra). This Court
held that the law laid down in Barasat Eye
Hospital (supra) was a law declared and it
had a retrospective effect. The relevant
portions are quoted below:5Upon a meaningful reading of the
decision, it is evident that the object of the
said decision was to put to rest the
controversy in respect of exercise of such a
weak right, especially in the matter of
short deposits. The Apex court took note of
the fact that the decision would have a far
larger ramification, as many cases were
pending before this High Court on this
point. Secondly, the law was in existence
since 1955, but the interpretation of the
same in respect of the requirement to
deposit the consideration amount was
finally put to rest in the decision of
Barasat Eye Hospital (supra). It was a
law declared on the point and will have a
retrospective effect. The Hon8ble Apex
Court was of the view that if short deposits
were allowed, a weak right would give rise
to speculative suits.
In the decision of Abdul Matin (supra), a
similar view was taken by the Hon8ble Apex
Court upon relying on the decision in
Barasat Eye Hospital (supra). The
Hon8ble Apex Court was dealing with Misc.
Preemption Case No.8 of 2012 which had
been filed before the trial court. The Misc.
preemption case was dismissed by the trial
court. Misc. Appeal No.7 of 2014 was
preferred. The Misc. Appeal was allowed
and the order of the learned trial court was
set aside. The application for pre-emption
was allowed on the ground of cosharership. The first appellate court
allowed
deposit
of
the
balance
consideration money. Aggrieved, the preemptee approached the High Court. The
High Court dismissed the revisional
application by upholding the order of the
first appellate court and also upholding
the decision of the first appellate to allow a
belated
deposit
of
the
balance
consideration money. Such order was
challenged in Civil Appeal No.3500 of
2022. In such a pending proceeding, the
decision of Barasat Eye Hospital (supra)
was referred to and it was held that the
learned lower appellate court was not
justified in permitting the preemptor to
deposit the balance consideration money
with additional 10% and the High Court
was also not justified in upholding such
decision.
Thus the Apex Court applied the decision
of Barasat Eye Hospital (supra) even in a
pending preemption case of 2012, and set
aside the order of the High Court passed in
C.O.4266 of 2016. The decision of Barasat
Eye Hospital (supra) was rendered in 2019.
In
the
decision
of
Assistant
Commissioner, Income Tax Rajkot v.
Saurashtra Kutch Stock Exchange
Ltd., reported (2008) 14 SCC 171, the
Hon8ble Apex Court held as follows:735. In our judgment, it is also well
settled that a judicial decision acts
retrospectively.
According
to
Blackstonian theory, it is not the
function of the court to pronounce a
5new rule6 but to maintain and
expound the 5old one6. In other
words, Judges do not make law, they
only discover or find the correct law.
The law has always been the same. If
a subsequent decision alters the
earlier one, it (the later decision)
does not make new law. It only
discovers the correct principle of law
which
has
to
be
applied
retrospectively. To put it differently,
even where an earlier decision of the
court operated for quite some time,
the decision rendered later on would
have retrospective effect clarifying
the legal position which was earlier
not correctly understood.8
In the decision of P.V. George and
Others v. State of Kerala and
others, reported in (2007) 3 SCC
557, the Hon8ble Apex Court held
that the law declared by a court will
have retrospective effect if not
otherwise stated to be so specifically.
The decision of the Hon8ble Apex
Court was a law declared on the
point that deposit of the full amount
stated as the sale consideration
together with further deposit of 10%
was a precondition to filing an
application under Section 8(1) of the
West Bengal Land and Land Reforms
Act, 1995. The conflicting legal
position was clarified, interpreted,
rectified and altered. The decision
has a retrospective effect and will
apply to pending proceedings.6
9. The revisional application stands dismissed
accordingly.
10. Although
Mr.
Roy
submits
that
the
petitioners had filed the application at the
very inception and the delay was on the
part
of
the
court
to
dispose
of
the
application, in my view, the said application
did not merit any consideration at the first
instance as the same was misconceived.
Furnishing
the
pre-deposit
is
a
pre-
condition and a statutory mandate as
discussed hereinabove. There is also no
scope to permit belated deposit beyond the
period of limitation prescribed under the
statute. The right of preemption has not yet
triggered off in case of the petitioners.
Applications of such kind only triggers
speculative, litigations, which is harassive
for the person who purchases the property,
having invested such a huge amount.
11. There shall be no order as to costs.
12. Parties
are
to
act
on
the
server
copy of this order.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review