Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on: 15.09.2026
Pronounced on: 18.09.2026
Uploaded on: 18.09.2026
SWP No. 2883/2016
Neena Sharma
...Petitioner /Appellant(s)
Through: -
Mr. A. K. Gandotra, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. Lakshi Bral, Advocate
Vs.
State of J&K and others
Through: -
...Respondent(s)
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Mr. Kartikay Sharma, Advocate
Mr. Sachin Sharma, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present writ petition, has
challenged the panel prepared by respondent No. 4 for the post of Rehbar-eTaleem Teacher in Government High School, Saroti, Village Khabber, to the
extent of her exclusion from the said panel.
2.
According to the petitioner, respondent No. 3, Chief Education
Officer, Rajouri, issued Advertisement Notice dated 04.10.2013, inviting
applications for engagement of ReT Teachers in far-flung areas of District
Rajouri. The said Advertisement Notice included four posts of ReT Teachers
in Government High School, Saroti, Village Khabber, Zone Moghla. It has
been submitted that as many as 12 candidates applied for four posts,
including the petitioner herein. The merit list was prepared by respondent
No. 4, in which the petitioner figured at Serial No. 4, whereas the private
respondents figured below her.
3.
It has been submitted that, against the candidates figuring at Serial
Nos. 1 and 2 of the merit list, an endorsement was made that they are not
physically residing in the relevant village. Regarding the candidate figuring
at Serial No. 3, it has been endorsed that the said candidate has been
empanelled for Government Primary School, Changi. Thus, according to the
petitioner, she was the most meritorious candidate in the panel eligible for
engagement. However, in the merit list, it has been endorsed that the
petitioner is not eligible on the ground that she is not physically residing in
the relevant village. It has been contended that the verification regarding the
residential status of the petitioner was conducted by the Tehsildar concerned
at the behest of the Chief Education Officer, Rajouri, and the Tehsildar
submitted a report regarding the residential status of the petitioner vide
communication dated 24.04.2015, confirming that the petitioner is a resident
of the relevant village.
4.
On the basis of these assertions, the petitioner has sought quashment
of the merit panel issued by respondent No. 4, to the extent it holds the
petitioner ineligible on the ground that she is not the resident of the relevant
village.
SWP No. 2883/2016
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the official respondents has submitted
that, during the pendency of the present writ petition, the Rehbar-e-Taleem
Scheme was closed in terms of Government Order No. 919-Edu of 2018
dated 16.11.2018. The said order became the subject matter of consideration
and determination before the Supreme Court in the case of Union Territory
of Jammu and Kashmir and others v. Saba Wani, SLP (Civil) No. 12210
of 2013. The Supreme Court laid down the guidelines with regard to cases in
which the rights of candidates stand protected despite the closure of the
Scheme. According to the learned AAG, Mr. Raman Sharma, the rights of
present petitioner are not protected in terms of the directions issued by the
Supreme Court in the aforesaid judgment and, as such, the writ petition
deserves to be dismissed.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6.
Before determining the issue as to whether the rights of the petitioner
are protected despite the closure of the ReT Scheme in terms of the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Saba Wani's case (supra), it would be
apposite to notice the directions issued by the Supreme Court as contained in
paragraph 25 of the said judgment. The same is reproduced as under:
25. In this view of the matter, we deem it appropriate to
issue following directions –
(a) The Closure Order of ReT Scheme dated 16.11.2018 for
cancellation/withdrawal shall not retrospectively impair the
right of the candidates found placed in the select panel. In
view of the discussion made hereinabove, the candidates
placed in respective select panels shall be issued
engagement/appointment orders as per their position in the
select panel having regard to the available vacancies.
SWP No. 2883/2016
(b) The State shall issue the formal engagement orders to
the candidates of select panel within a period of eight weeks
in terms of the direction (a) above.
(c) Candidates appointed as per directions (a) and (b) from
the select panel under the ReT Scheme are directed to
acquire minimum qualification prescribed under NCTE
Regulations and Notifications, including to qualify the TET,
within 3 years and 3 attempts from date of their
engagement/ appointment. In this regard, the State is
directed to organize the TET annually. After successfully
acquiring the minimum qualification and passing TET
within prescribed time limit, the services of such appointees
shall be, accordingly, regularized on completion of two
years of service thereafter.
(d) The direction (c) above shall be applicable to the other
similarly situated candidates who have already been
appointed from the select panels under the ReT Scheme
after 23.08.2010 i.e., the date of NCTE notification
prescribing minimum qualifications and prior to the
issuance of Closure Order, and do not possess minimum
qualification including TET as per the notification of
NCTE. However, those appointees shall acquire prescribed
qualification within the time as specified in direction (c).
(e) It is obligatory upon this Court to direct that once the
candidates/appointees under the ReT Scheme have acquired
the prescribed qualifications and qualified the TET as
indicated above, the seniority of all such candidates/
appointees shall be redrawn and determined by the
competent authority of the State, maintaining their
respective positions in the select panels uninfluenced by the
date of appointment, joining or regularization. The inter se
seniority shall also be determined accordingly.
(f) It is further directed that if the candidates/appointees
including those already appointed and regularized who do
not acquire/possess the requisite qualifications in terms of
the NCTE notifications and fail to qualify the TET within
the period prescribed hereinabove, the State is at liberty to
dispense with their services as the mandate of Article 21-A
of the Constitution of India cannot be left at altar even while
rendering complete justice invoking Article 142 of the
Constitution of India. It is further clarified that those
candidates/appointees would not have any claim with
respect to seniority or regularization as directed
hereinabove.
(g) The directions issued hereinabove are in rem and shall
apply mutatis mutandis to the candidates already appointed
pursuant to 74 advertisements that are subject matter of
present proceedings, though they are not party to the present
appeals. In view thereof, this judgment shall be widely
publicized, and all the candidates/appointees shall be duly
informed of these directions so that they can take recourse
for acquiring the minimum qualification as per NCTE
Regulations and Notifications, if they have not already
acquired the same.
SWP No. 2883/2016
(h) The directions contained in clauses (a) to (g)
hereinabove shall apply to all the candidates who are
litigating in any Court and such cases have been filed prior
to the date of this judgment. It is further clarified that
candidates who have not already filed cases in any Court
shall neither acquire any fresh cause of action by virtue of
these directions nor be entitled to seek any further directions
from any Court in that regard.
(i) At the cost of repetition, it is clarified that this judgment
shall not be construed as reviving the ReT Scheme for any
purpose whatsoever, nor shall it be interpreted so as to
create or confer any right upon candidates who were not
part of a prepared select panel or who failed to approach the
Court timely. Moreover, these directions are being issued in
the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case invoking
the power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India and
it shall not be treated as precedent in any manner
whatsoever.
(j) In view of the observations made in para 24 above, we
believe that the State Government shall apply their mind to
the facts and circumstances of the case and the situation
prevalent in the State and to take an appropriate decision
with respect to the revision of the honorarium of such
teachers as they deem fit.
7.
From a perusal of the aforesaid directions, particularly direction No.
(a), it is clear that the closure of the ReT Scheme would not affect the rights
of candidates found to have been placed in the select panel. As per direction
No. (g), the order issued by the Supreme Court is in rem. Further, as per
direction No. (h), the directions contained in clauses (a) to (g) would apply
to all candidates who were litigating before any Court and whose cases had
been filed prior to the date of the said judgment. It has been further clarified
that candidates who have not already filed cases before any Court would
neither acquire any fresh cause of action by virtue of the directions of the
Supreme Court nor they would be entitled to seek any further directions
from any Court in that regard. The Supreme Court has made it clear that the
said judgment shall not be construed as reviving the ReT Scheme, nor shall
it be interpreted as creating or conferring any right upon candidates who
SWP No. 2883/2016
were not part of a prepared select panel or who failed to approach the Court
timely.
8.
The question that arises for consideration is as to what is meant by the
expression "select panel". This aspect of the matter has also been dealt with
by the Supreme Court in paragraph 17 of the judgment. In the said para of
the judgment, the Supreme Court has noticed the various stages of selection
under the ReT Scheme. These include identification of posts, advertisement,
receiving applications, scrutiny of applications, empanelment of eligible
candidates, preparation of a master panel for issuance of tentative selection
list, publication of the tentative selection list, and subsequent approval by the
Directorate and issuance of engagement orders.
9.
Thus, it is only when the select panel is approved by the Directorate
that it would qualify as a "select panel" within the meaning of direction
No. (a) of paragraph 25 of the judgment passed by the Supreme Court. If the
selection process has not reached the stage of approval of the select panel by
the Directorate, the rights of the candidates, after the closure of the ReT
Scheme, are not protected in terms of the judgment passed by the Supreme
Court.
10.
Now, coming to the facts of the present case, according to the
petitioner, her name figured in the merit list issued by the Zonal Education
Officer concerned, wherein it was mentioned that she is not eligible as she is
not physically residing in the relevant village. The selection process in
respect of the petitioner had not even reached the stage of preparation of the
SWP No. 2883/2016
final panel by the Zonal Education Officer, much less its approval by the
Directorate. Therefore, the right of the petitioner to pursue the present writ
petition, in the face of the closure of the ReT Scheme and the directions
issued by the Supreme Court in Saba Wani's case, does not survive.
11.
Learned counsel for respondent No. 8 has submitted that the name of
respondent No. 8 figures in the final select panel prepared by the concerned
Zonal Education Officer and, as such, his right is protected by the judgment
passed in Saba Wani's case (supra). Since this Court is not considering the
issue with regard to the maintainability of the writ petition of respondent No.
8, it would be an unnecessary academic exercise for this Court to deal with
the contention raised by learned counsel for respondent No. 8. In any case,
once the writ petition filed by the petitioner is held to be not maintainable, it
is not open to this Court to issue any direction in favour of respondent No. 8
in the present writ petition.
12.
For the foregoing reasons, it is held that with the closure of ReT
scheme and subsequent judgment of Supreme Court in Saba Wani’s case
(supra), the right of the petitioner does not survive. The writ petition is,
accordingly, dismissed.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
Jammu:
18.09.2026
Karam Chand
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
KARAM CHAND
2026.09.18 16:25
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
SWP No. 2883/2016
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review