Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
SRINAGAR
Reserved on:
20.07.2026
Pronounced on: 24.07.2026
Uploaded on:
24.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
WP(C) No.2838/2023
NAZNEENA GOWHER
...PETITIONER(S)
Through: - Mr. J. H. Reshi, Advocate, with
Mr. Shah Murtaza, Advocate.
Vs.
UT OF J&K AND ORS.
…RESPONDENT(S)
Through: - Mr. T. A. Lone, Dy. AG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioner, through the medium of present petition,
has challenged order No.CDPO/Poshan/Kvp/2023/928-32,
dated 17.10.2023, whereby the order of promotion issued in
her favour as Anganwadi Worker in terms of Order No. CDPO
/Kvp/2019/873-77 dated 18.02.2019 has been cancelled
with immediate effect.
2)
As per the case set up by the petitioner, she came to be
appointed as an Anganwadi Helper in Anganwadi Centre
Kral Mohalla, Seer, in terms of Order No.CDPO/Kvp/2006/
487-88 dated 08.02.2006, after participating in the selection
process. It has been submitted that vide Order No.1086WP(C) No.2838/2023
DSWK of 2014 dated 28.02.2014, Smt. Sunita Kumari, who
was functioning as Anganwadi Worker in Anganwadi Centre
Astan Mohalla, Seer-B (Ward No. 6), came to be promoted as
Supervisor, as a result whereof, the post of Anganwadi
Worker fell vacant. The said post was advertised by the
official respondents in terms of Notice No. CDPO/KVP/2015
dated 12.11.2015. However, the said Advertisement Notice
was challenged by the petitioner before this Court vide SWP
No.2834/2015 on the ground that she was about to complete
ten years of service as Anganwadi Helper and, therefore, in
terms of Government Order No.07-SW of 2010 dated
18.01.2010, she was entitled to be considered for promotion
to the said post. The Advertisement Notice dated 12.11.2015
was stayed by this Court in terms of interim order dated
31.12.2015, but the main writ petition came to be dismissed
by this Court in terms of judgment dated 24.10.2017.
3)
It is being submitted that pursuant to the judgment of
this Court, the official respondents proceeded to conclude
the selection process for the post of Anganwadi Worker for
Anganwadi Centre Astan Mohalla Seer-B. According to the
petitioner, out of seven candidates who had applied for the
post, only one candidate (respondent No. 7 herein), was
found eligible. In terms of the norms in vogue, vide Order No.
CDPO/KVP/2015/1094-96 dated 31.03.2018 issued by
WP(C) No.2838/2023
respondent No. 5, Advertisement Notice dated 12.11.2015
came to be cancelled because only one applicant was found
eligible.
4)
While respondent No.7 made a representation against
the cancellation of the Advertisement Notice, the petitioner
also made a representation dated 02.11.2018, seeking
promotion to the post of Anganwadi Worker on account of
cancellation of the Advertisement Notice (supra).
5)
When no action was taken by the official respondents
on the representation of the petitioner, she filed a writ
petition bearing SWP No.119/2019, wherein an interim
order came to be passed on 25.01.2019, directing the official
respondents to consider the representation of the petitioner.
Pursuant to the aforesaid direction, the petitioner was
formally promoted as Anganwadi Worker for Anganwadi
Centre Astan Mohalla Seer-B in terms of Order No.CDPO/
Kvp/2019/873-77 dated 18.02.2019, issued by respondent
No.5. After issuance of the aforesaid order, the petitioner
withdrew the writ petition bearing SWP No.119/2019.
6)
It has been submitted that a complaint was filed by
respondent No.7 against the order of promotion issued in
favour of the petitioner. In this regard, respondent No. 3, vide
Order No.480-SMD of 2019 dated 31.07.2019, directed an
WP(C) No.2838/2023
enquiry into the matter. During the course of the enquiry,
response of the petitioner was also sought, which she
submitted
vide
her
application
dated
20.06.2020.
Respondent No.7 also filed an appeal before the Deputy
Commissioner, Anantnag, against the promotion order
issued in favour of the petitioner. Thereafter, respondent
No.5 proceeded to cancel the promotion of the petitioner in
terms of the impugned order dated 17.10.2023.
7)
The petitioner has challenged the impugned order on
the ground that the same has been passed without adhering
to the principles of natural justice, inasmuch as the
petitioner has neither been afforded an opportunity of being
heard nor has she been associated with the enquiry. It has
further been contended that once the Advertisement Notice
dated 12.11.2015 was cancelled, respondent No.7 had no
cause to challenge the promotion of the petitioner.
8)
The official respondents, in their reply to the writ
petition, while admitting the factual aspects of the case as
stated by the petitioner, have submitted that the petitioner
had challenged the order whereby an enquiry into the matter
had been instituted by filing WP(C) No.3407/2019, which
came to be disposed of in terms of order dated 25.11.2019,
whereby it was directed that, in case the respondents
contemplate to take any action adverse to the interests of the
WP(C) No.2838/2023
petitioner, whether pursuant to the enquiry envisaged in the
impugned order or otherwise, the same shall be taken only
after affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard to the
petitioner.
9)
It has also been submitted that in terms of the
directions dated 24.10.2017 passed in SWP No.2834/2015,
the official respondents were directed to finalize the process
of selection of Anganwadi Worker initiated pursuant to
Advertisement Notice dated 12.11.2015 in accordance with
the norms governing the field. Pursuant to these directions
passed by this Court, the official respondents called the
relevant records and, after examining the same, decided to
process the matter in the light of the directions of the Court
after providing an opportunity of being heard to the
petitioner and thereafter the impugned order cancelling the
promotion of the petitioner was issued. The official
respondents have contended that the petitioner is otherwise
not eligible for promotion to the post in question as per the
requisite qualification, as such, her claim deserves to be
rejected.
10)
Respondent No. 7 has also filed her reply to the writ
petition, wherein she has, more or less, admitted the factual
aspects of the matter. It has been submitted that the Enquiry
Officer
has,
WP(C) No.2838/2023
in
his
report,
clearly
stated
that
the
Advertisement Notice had been cancelled without the
approval of the District Selection Committee and that the
promotion order issued in favour of the petitioner as
Anganwadi Worker was also without the approval of the
competent authority and, accordingly, the promotion order
issued in favour of the petitioner promoting her as
Anganwadi Worker has been cancelled. It has been
submitted that, pursuant to order dated 25.11.2019 passed
in WP(C) No.3407/2019, a show cause notice was issued to
the petitioner. It has also been submitted that, as soon as
respondent No.7 came to know about the issuance of
promotion order in favour of the petitioner, she filed an
appeal before the Deputy Commissioner, Anantnag, against
the said order. However, during the pendency of the said
appeal, the promotion order issued in favour of the petitioner
came to be cancelled in terms of the impugned order dated
17.10.2023 and, consequently, the appeal was rendered
infructuous.
11)
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
12)
As already stated, the factual aspects of the case are,
more or less, admitted by the parties. The petitioner is
claiming promotion to the post of Anganwadi Worker on the
ground that she has put in more than ten years’ service as
WP(C) No.2838/2023
Anganwadi Helper. In terms of Government Order No.07-SW
of 2010 dated 18.01.2010, which was in vogue at the
relevant time, one of the criteria for selection of an
Anganwadi Worker was that, whenever a vacancy of
Anganwadi Worker arises due to resignation, promotion or
for any other reason other than the death of the worker, the
same was to be filled up from amongst the Helpers of the
village, subject to the Helper possessing a minimum
qualification of matriculation and experience of not less than
ten years at the time of accrual of the vacancy. It was further
provided that, whenever any Helper is not eligible for
engagement as Anganwadi Worker, the vacancy shall be
advertised and filled up as per the procedure laid down for
general selection.
13)
From the above it is clear that, in order to be eligible for
being considered for promotion to the post of Anganwadi
Worker, an Anganwadi Helper should possess a minimum
qualification of matriculation and experience of not less than
ten years at the time of accrual of the vacancy. Admittedly,
the petitioner, at the time of accrual of the vacancy, was not
in possession of ten years' experience as Anganwadi Helper.
This position has been admitted by the petitioner herself in
para (7) of the writ petition, wherein it has been stated that
she was lacking experience by three months at the time
WP(C) No.2838/2023
when Smt. Sunita Kumari was promoted as Supervisor,
which resulted in accrual of the vacancy of Anganwadi
Worker in Anganwadi Centre Astan Mohalla Seer-B. This
aspect of the matter is further clarified when we calculate
the period from the date of initial appointment of the
petitioner as Anganwadi Helper in terms of order dated
08.02.2006 up to 28.02.2014, when Smt. Sunita Kumari
was promoted as Supervisor. In fact, total experience at the
back of the petitioner as on 28.02.2014 was only eight years
and it was less by two years.
14)
This Court has, while deciding SWP No.2834/2015 vide
judgment dated 24.10.2017, clearly recorded a finding that
the petitioner did not possess the requisite experience of ten
years and, as such, was not eligible for promotion to the post
of Anganwadi Worker. It was further observed that the
official respondents were obliged to take recourse to the
process of filling up the post of Anganwadi Worker in
accordance with the procedure by inviting applications. The
Court after recording the aforesaid findings, directed the
official respondents to finalize the process of selection in
accordance with the norms governing the field. Merely
because the official respondents could not find sufficient
number
of
eligible
candidates
after
issuing
the
Advertisement Notice pursuant to the directions dated
WP(C) No.2838/2023
24.10.2017, the same does not alter the situation so far as
eligibility of the petitioner for promotion to the post of
Anganwadi Worker is concerned.
15)
As already stated, the eligibility of the petitioner for
promotion to the post of Anganwadi Worker has to be
reckoned as on the date of accrual of the vacancy, which, in
the instant case, is 28.02.2014. Therefore, the petitioner is
not eligible for promotion to the post of Anganwadi Worker
and the official respondents are bound to fill up the said post
by inviting applications from the open market in accordance
with the prescribed norms, even if they have to issue
advertisement notices repeatedly until the post is filled up
from the open market.
16)
So far as the contention of the petitioner that the
official respondents while
issuing the impugned order of
cancellation of her promotion have not adhered to the
principles of natural justice, in this context, it is to be noted
that the petitioner herself has, in her writ petition, admitted
that the Enquiry Officer had sought a response from her
which was submitted by her in terms of application dated
20.06.2020. Therefore, the official respondents have clearly
adhered to the principles of natural justice before issuing the
impugned order of cancellation of her promotion. The fact
WP(C) No.2838/2023
that the petitioner has been allowed to submit her
response/representation before taking any action against
her, satisfies not only the principles of natural justice but it
also satisfies the requirements of order dated 25.11.2019
passed in WP(C) No.3407/2019. Therefore,
it cannot be
stated that the official respondents, while passing the
impugned order, have either violated the principles of
natural justice or the directions passed by this Court in
WP(C) No.3407/2019.
17)
For what has been discussed hereinbefore, it is clear
that even as per the petitioner's own case, she was not
eligible for promotion at the time when the vacancy of
Anganwadi Worker at Anganwadi Centre Astan Mohalla
Seer-B had accrued. Therefore, there is no ground to
interfere in the impugned order passed by the official
respondents whereby promotion order of the petitioner has
been cancelled. The petition lacks merit and is dismissed
accordingly. Interim direction dated 03.11.2023 shall stand
vacated with immediate effect.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
SRINAGAR
24.07.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: YES/NO
WP(C) No.2838/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review