Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:47739
-1942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 1776 OF 2026
NAVNATH NAMDEV UGALMUGALE
Versus
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
.....
Advocate for Applicant : Mr. Narayan B. Narwade
APP for Respondent - State : Mr. S. D. Ghayal
.....
WITH
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 1506 OF 2026
GANESH NAVNATH UGALMUGALE
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
.....
Advocate for Applicant : Mr. Yogesh D. Kale
APP for Respondent - State : Mr. S. D. Ghayal
..…
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
DATED : 06th OCTOBER, 2026
ORDER :
1.
These applications arise out of the same crime and are
founded on common investigation papers. They have, therefore,
been heard together and are being decided by this common order.
The applicants seek regular bail under Section 483 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, in connection with
Crime No.32 of 2026 registered on 9 th January, 2026 with
Pathardi Police Station, District Ahilyanagar, for the offences
punishable under Sections 109, 115(2), 118(1), 189(2), 191(2),
191(3) and 190 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and
Tandale
-2942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
Sections 3 and 4 read with Section 25 of the Arms Act, 1959. Both
applicants were arrested on 11 th March, 2026. The charge-sheet
has been filed, and their application for regular bail before the
Sessions Court was rejected by the order dated 1 st July, 2026
passed below Exhibit 10.
2.
The first information report was lodged by Ramdas
Murlidhar Dhakane while undergoing treatment at Saideep
Hospital, Ahilyanagar. According to him, two days before the
occurrence, Ganesh had driven his motorcycle dangerously close to
his son. On 7th January, 2026, at about 8.15 p.m., his brother
Ambadas was returning home at Katewadi when a quarrel took
place near the house of Shridhar Dhakane. On hearing the
commotion, Ramdas went there and found Navnath, Vaijayanta,
Dnyaneshwar, Ganesh, Dadasaheb and Sachin abusing and
assaulting Ambadas. When Ramdas intervened, Navnath allegedly
dealt three blows with a sword on his head, causing bleeding
injuries. Dnyaneshwar is alleged to have assaulted Ramdas with a
sword on his back, both upper arms and right thigh.
3.
The prosecution further alleges that when Vinay, the son
of Ramdas intervened, Dadasaheb, Ganesh and Sachin assaulted
him with swords on his arms, left wrist, back and abdomen.
Navnath and Vaijayanta allegedly held Ambadas and assaulted
Tandale
-3942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
him with kicks and fist blows, while Dnyaneshwar inflicted a sword
injury on his abdomen. Navnath is also alleged to have fired a
country-made pistol in the air. Thereafter, the accused left two
motorcycles at the spot and departed in a Swift car. On the
allegation that the assault was committed with the intention of
causing the death of the injured, the present crime came to be
registered against six persons.
4.
The learned advocate for the applicants submits that the
occurrence has resulted in cross-cases and that the prosecution
has not disclosed the entire incident in its proper perspective.
Navnath lodged Crime No.33 of 2026 against members of the
informant's group, alleging an assault with an iron pipe and a
stone. Attention is invited to the injuries sustained by Navnath and
Dnyaneshwar and to the allegation that Ganesh was also assaulted.
It is submitted that these circumstances cast doubt upon the
prosecution's account of the commencement of the quarrel and
support the defence that the applicants' group was itself attacked.
The learned advocate also relies upon the interval of two days
before registration of the FIR, the completion of investigation, the
filing of the charge-sheet and the period of custody. He submits
that the sword was seized from the spot, rather than discovered at
the instance of either applicant, and that the country-made pistol
Tandale
-4942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
and cartridge have not been recovered.
5.
The learned advocate further submits that Vaijayanta and
Dadasaheb have been released on bail and that persons accused in
the counter-case have also obtained bail. Insofar as Ganesh is
concerned, it is submitted that the material does not distinguish
the blows allegedly inflicted by him from those attributed
collectively to Dadasaheb and Sachin. The separately described
assaults on Ramdas and Ambadas are attributed to Navnath and
Dnyaneshwar. There is no weapon recovery at Ganesh's instance,
and no criminal antecedent is disclosed against him. The
applicants are permanent residents of the address mentioned in
the applications and undertake to attend the trial and comply with
the conditions imposed by this Court.
6.
The learned APP opposes the applications on the ground
that the injured witnesses have described an armed assault which
finds support in the medical papers. Ganesh is named in the FIR
and Vinay's statement as one of the persons who assaulted Vinay
with a sword; the accusation is not confined to his presence.
Against Navnath, the prosecution relies upon the repeated sword
blows on Ramdas's head, the firing allegation and the pending cases
recorded in the Sessions Court's order. Reliance is also placed upon
the witnesses' statements, the seizure of a sword bearing blood-like
Tandale
-5942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
stains, and the articles collected during investigation. The
informant's objections, as noted in the Sessions Court's order,
concern an organised attack upon vital parts of the body and the
apprehension of threats and interference with the evidence.
7.
While
considering
these
applications,
it
is
neither
necessary nor appropriate to determine the truth of the rival
versions by a detailed assessment of the evidence. Nevertheless,
the nature of the accusation, the material concerning each
applicant, the period of custody, antecedents and the protection of
witnesses require consideration. The release of a co-accused does
not dispense with that assessment. In case of Sagar v. State of U.P.
and another, reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2584, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court explained that parity is not an automatic
entitlement to bail. The comparison must concern the role and
position of the accused in the occurrence, together with the other
relevant circumstances. The applicants' claim of parity is
considered on that basis.
8.
The medical papers do not support a submission that the
occurrence resulted only in simple injuries. Ramdas's certificate
records multiple incised wounds over the parietal and occipital
regions of the scalp, besides other injuries, and describes the injury
as grievous. Ambadas sustained a penetrating abdominal wound
Tandale
-6942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
with internal injury for which an emergency exploratory
laparotomy was performed. Vinay's certificate also records serious
injuries, including a penetrating injury on the right side of the
chest
associated
with
haemopneumothorax,
and
operative
treatment. The medical opinion on the seized sword states that the
recorded incised and penetrating wounds could be caused by that
weapon. These papers prima facie support an assault with a sharp
weapon. They do not, however, identify the author of each injury
where the statements attribute the assault collectively.
9.
The counter-case cannot be ignored. The annexed
certificates record a grievous injury to Navnath's left forearm,
including a fracture of the ulna, and serious head injuries to
Dnyaneshwar, including skull fractures. Those injuries require
consideration when the occurrence is examined at trial, and the
defence version cannot presently be dismissed as inherently
impossible. Equally, injuries on both sides do not, by themselves,
determine which group initiated the assault or whether a
particular act remained within the limits of private defence. Those
questions must remain open. Bail granted to persons accused in
the counter-case does not determine the entitlement of either
applicant in this prosecution, where the allegations and injuries
under consideration are different.
Tandale
-7942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
10.
The argument regarding delay also must be examined
with the contemporaneous papers. The injured were admitted to
hospital on the night of the occurrence. The station diary entry
dated 8th January, 2026 records the efforts to obtain their
statements and the medical advice that they were then not in a
condition to give statements. The papers thereafter record
Ramdas's fitness to give his statement, which was recorded on 9 th
January,
2026.
The
intervening
period
cannot,
therefore,
presently be treated as an unexplained circumstance rendering the
prosecution version fabricated. Whether the narration was
influenced by subsequent discussion is a matter for testing the
witnesses at trial.
11.
Turning
first
to
Navnath,
the
injured
informant
specifically attributes three sword blows on his head to him. The
location and multiplicity of the incised scalp wounds prima facie
correspond with that account. Ambadas's statement also attributes
the sword assault on Ramdas's head to Navnath. Arjun Gangadhar
Dhakane describes reaching the spot when the injured were lying
there and seeing a sword in Navnath's hand. What Ramdas
subsequently told Arjun about the preceding assault must be
distinguished from Arjun's own observations. Satish Gangadhar
Ghule describes witnessing the group assault and the firing by
Tandale
-8942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
Navnath. His statement was recorded later, on 29 th March, 2026,
and its timing and reliability remain open to examination. The
prima facie case against Navnath does not, however, depend upon
that statement alone, having regard to the injured witnesses'
accounts and the medical papers.
12.
The sword was seized from the scene and is not treated as
a discovery at Navnath's instance. Nor does the mere presence of
blood-like stains establish whose blood was present. The forensic
forwarding letters and acknowledgements in the papers are not
laboratory findings establishing a match. The clothes of Navnath
and Dnyaneshwar were produced by their relatives and seized in
the counter-case. Their stains cannot be treated as necessarily
belonging to the injured in this prosecution, especially when
Navnath and Dnyaneshwar were themselves injured. The nonrecovery of the pistol and cartridge also bears upon the proof of the
firing allegation. These limitations have been considered. Even
leaving the firing allegation and any unestablished forensic
connection aside, the specific accusation of repeated sword blows
directed at Ramdas's head, read with the medical findings, remains
substantial material against Navnath.
13.
The Sessions Court's order additionally records three
pending cases against Navnath, namely Crime Nos.17 of 2025, 345
Tandale
-9942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
of 2021 and 30 of 2023 at Pathardi Police Station. Their pendency
is not proof of guilt or an automatic bar to bail. Nevertheless, they
are relevant to the apprehension of repetition and interference,
particularly
since
two
concern
allegations
of
assault
or
intimidation. Considered with the present accusation, the weapon
allegedly used, the repeated blows to the head and the concern for
the injured witnesses, these circumstances weigh against release.
Completion of investigation, the filing of the charge-sheet and the
period of custody have been considered, but do not sufficiently
outweigh the material against Navnath at this stage. His role is
materially different from that of Vaijayanta and from the collective
role
attributed
to Dadasaheb
concerning Vinay.
Navnath's
application, therefore, deserves rejection.
14.
Ganesh's case requires a separate assessment. Ramdas
and Vinay expressly name him, with Dadasaheb and Sachin, in the
sword assault on Vinay. Arjun also states that he saw a sharp
weapon in Ganesh's hand. Ganesh cannot, therefore, be treated as a
mere spectator and Vinay's grievous injuries cannot be discounted.
However, the accusation concerning those injuries is made against
the three persons collectively, without allocating the particular
blows or identifying Ganesh as the author of the penetrating chest
injury. The repeated head blows on Ramdas and the separately
Tandale
-10942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
specified abdominal sword assault on Ambadas are attributed to
Navnath and Dnyaneshwar respectively.
15.
Section 190 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita is invoked,
and the absence of an individually allocated injury does not
exclude liability for an offence committed in prosecution of the
common object of an unlawful assembly. This Court is not deciding
that issue in Ganesh's favour. For bail, however, the specificity of
the accusation, the supporting material concerning the individual
applicant and the position of a similarly placed co-accused remain
relevant. Dadasaheb, who has been released on bail, is named with
Ganesh and Sachin in the same allegation concerning the assault
on Vinay. Ganesh's request thus involves a comparison within the
very same part of the prosecution case. It is a closer comparison
than Navnath's claim of parity with the released accused and is
considered with Ganesh's individual circumstances, rather than as
a sufficient ground by itself.
16.
No weapon has been recovered at Ganesh's instance, and
no seizure of his clothes is shown in the common papers. The
station diary contains the police account that Ganesh and
Dadasaheb stated that their clothes had been used, washed and
discarded. That entry cannot be treated as a proved admission of
participation or as a forensic connection to a particular injury.
Tandale
-11942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
Absence of a recovery does not nullify the injured witnesses'
statements, but no additional recovery is demonstrated which
connects Ganesh more specifically to the serious injury and
distinguishes him from Dadasaheb in that respect. No criminal
antecedent is disclosed against Ganesh in his application or
recorded against him in the Sessions Court's order. The
antecedents recorded against Navnath cannot be attributed to
Ganesh merely because they are related or accused in the same
crime.
17.
Ganesh has remained in custody since 11 th March, 2026.
The charge-sheet was filed on 13th April, 2026, and the case has
been committed to the Sessions Court. The earlier refusal of
anticipatory bail preceded his arrest and completion of these steps
and does not conclude his entitlement to regular bail now.
Considering the collective attribution concerning Vinay, the
release of Dadasaheb who is named in that attribution, the absence
of an antecedent disclosed against Ganesh, completion of the
principal investigation and the period already spent in custody,
this Court is satisfied that further detention of Ganesh pending
trial is not necessary. This conclusion does not rest upon a finding
that Vinay's injuries were simple or that Ganesh was not involved,
but upon the cumulative circumstances relevant to release on
Tandale
-12942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
conditions.
18.
The concern expressed for the injured witnesses deserves
protection, particularly since the parties belong to the same village
and the occurrence has resulted in cross-cases. In Ganesh's case,
that concern can be addressed by prohibiting contact with or
intimidation of prosecution witnesses, requiring him to reside
outside Katewadi for a limited period, and securing his attendance
before the investigating officer and the trial Court. Any subsequent
interference or breach would furnish a basis for seeking
cancellation of bail. Subject to these safeguards, Ganesh's
application is allowed, whereas Navnath's application is rejected.
Hence, the following order:
ORDER
(i) Bail Application No.1506 of 2026 is allowed.
(ii) The applicant - Ganesh Navnath Ugalmugale, shall be
released on bail in Crime No.32 of 2026 registered with
Pathardi Police Station, District Ahilyanagar, for the
offences referred to in paragraph 1, on executing a
personal recognizance bond of Rs.25,000/- with one or
more solvent sureties in the like amount, to the
satisfaction of the trial Court.
(iii) Ganesh shall not directly or indirectly contact, threaten,
induce or influence any prosecution witness, or tamper
with the prosecution evidence.
Tandale
-13942-BA-1776-2026 & BA-1506-2026
(iv) For six months from the date of release, Ganesh shall
reside outside village Katewadi and shall not enter that
village without prior permission of the trial Court. Before
release, he shall furnish his proposed residential address
and
mobile
number
to
the
trial
Court
and
the
investigating officer. Any subsequent change shall be
communicated to both within seven days.
(v) Ganesh shall report to Pathardi Police Station on the first
Sunday of every month between 10.00 a.m. and 12.00
noon for six months from the date of release.
(vi) Ganesh shall attend the trial Court on the dates fixed for
his appearance unless exempted by that Court, and shall
cooperate with the expeditious conduct of the trial.
(vii) Bail Application No. 1776 of 2026 preferred by Navnath
Namdeo Ugalmugale is rejected.
(viii) All observations are prima facie and confined to bail. The
trial Court shall decide the prosecution independently on
the
evidence
adduced,
uninfluenced
by
these
observations. No finding is recorded on the merits of the
counter-case or the defence of private defence.
(ix) Both applications stand disposed of accordingly.
(HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR)
JUDGE
Tandale
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review