The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. It is settled law that any corrigendum issued will not be prospective but relate back to the amendment already in force with effect from 01.08.2023, whereas the examination for second year of the medical college commenced on 30.07.2023 and ended on 11.08.2023; in between, the notification had been brought into force meaning thereby, in the midst of the examination and would have applicability to the students undertaking the examination. There is no dispute that the ratio decidendi WA NO. 403 OF 2025 -112025:KER:22334 culled out in the judgment supra, but the fact remains it was not a new amendment but a corrigendum and definitely would relate back to the date of the amendment issued on 01.08.2023. Finding of fact and law, in such circumstances, do not require a different interpretation. We do not find any merit in the writ appeal. Writ appeal standss dismissed. Sd/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 9TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 01.12.2023 IN WP(C) NO.34075 OF
2023 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT(S)/4TH RESPONDENT:
NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION
POCKET-14, SECTOR-8, DWARAKA PHASE-I, NEW DELHI,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY., PIN - 110077
BY ADV.
SRI.K.S.PRENJITH KUMAR, CGC
RESPONDENT(S)/PETITIONER & RESPONDENTS 1,2 & 3:
ANTONY P. ALAPPAT,
AGED 22 YEARS,
S/O. PAUL ALAPPAT, ALAPPATU HOUSE, PUTHUKKAD P.O.,
THIRISSUR DISTRICT., PIN - 680301
KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES,
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR, MULANKUNNATHUKAVU,
THRISSUR. PIN - 680596
THE CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATIONS,
KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES,
MULANKUNNATHUKAVU, THRISSUR. PIN - 680596
THE PRINCIPAL,
GOVERNMENT MEDICAL COLLEGE, MULANKUNNATHUKAVU,
THRISSUR., PIN - 680596
BY ADVS.
BINNY THOMAS
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-22025:KER:22334
SRI.P.SREEKUMAR (SR.)(K/410/1994)
SRI.B.S.SHIVAJI
SMT.HELEN P A
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
28.02.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-32025:KER:22334
JUDGMENT
AMIT RAWAL, J.
The present intra court appeal is directed against
the judgment of the Single Bench whereby, going by the
amendment dated 01.08.2023, allowed the writ petition
of the respondent – petitioner, declaring him to be
passed in the second year examination of MBBS of a
Medical College affiliated to Kerala University of Health
Sciences, Thrissur.
2.
At the time when the examination of
second year commenced, i.e., in July, 2023 and ended on
on 11.08.2023, the condition of qualifying the said
examination as per the amendment dated 01.08.2023
was to obtain 50% of mark in aggregate in both papers
together as well as 50% marks in the examination
conducted by the University separately, in theory and
practical.
However, a corrigendum on 01.09.2023 was
issued, whereby it was made clear that the condition of
50% in both practical and theory would not be necessary
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-42025:KER:22334
as it could be in aggregate of 60:40 and vice versa.
Respondent-petitioner in the subjects of Microbiology
and Pharmacology did not obtain 50% each in aggregate
on one of the examinations out of the second year, either
of the practical or of the theory. Having not cleared the
examination gave a cause of action to approach the
Court. The contention that the corrigendum would not
be applicable to the respondent/petitioner as it came into
force only on 01.09.2023, is the sole point to be
determined by us.
3.
Learned Single Judge noticed the fact
that the earlier amendment Ext.P1 was with effect from
01.08.2023 and the corrigendum would relate back to
the amendment and not from the date of the issuance of
the corrigendum. By noticing the above, the single Judge
has given the following findings in paragraphs 3 to 5 of
the judgment:
“3. The grievance of the petitioner is
that the petitioner has been declared as failed
since
the
petitioner
has
not
scored
50%
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-52025:KER:22334
aggregate
and
40%
minimum
in
the
examinations. The petitioner submits that the 4 th
respondent has issued guidelines whereby the
minimum required mark has been amended and
as
per
the
present
requirement
which
is
produced as Ext.P3, in a subject with two
papers, the student has to score minimum 40%
aggregate and in cases where there is a
practical along with theory paper, the candidate
has to obtain 50% mark in aggregate and 60:40
minimum or 40:60 minimum in the University
conducted examinations separately in theory
and practical.
4. Going by the amendment which has
come into effect from 01.08.2023, the petitioner
submits that he is entitled to be declared as
passed. The contention is that the examination
started on 30.07.2023 and ended on 11.08.2023
and as such, it is a case where the examinations
were completed only after the amendment came
into force. The learned Standing Counsel for the
University
contends
that
the
amended
notification will apply only to examinations
which are notified after the amendment.
5.
The
contention
raised
by
the
Standing Counsel for the 4th respondent cannot
be countenanced. The amendment has to be
prospectively applied to all cases where the
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-62025:KER:22334
examinations are held after the amendment and
the Pass Board meets to decide on the result.
The application cannot be restricted on the
basis of the notification of the examination.
In
the
above
circumstances,
the
petitioner is entitled to succeed. The writ
petition is allowed. The respondents 1 and 2 are
directed to declare the petitioner as successfully
completed
the
subjects
Pharmacology
and
Microbiology of 2nd professional MBBS Degree
supplementary examination held in July, 2023
and issue a fresh mark sheet accordingly.
Necessary orders shall be issued within three
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy this
judgment.”
4.
The intra court appeal is accompanied by
an application seeking condonation of delay of 282 days,
primarily on the ground that, similarly situated persons
studying
in
various
medical
colleges
affiliated
by
different Universities have been knocking the doors for
treating them as passed in the subjects on account of the
judgment rendered by the Single Bench of this Court.
5.
Mr.P.Sreekumar, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Smt.Helen P.A., appearing on behalf of the
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-72025:KER:22334
respondent submitted that the findings of the Single
Bench cannot be stated to be perverse or erroneous for
the reason that the interpretation of the corrigendum
relate back to the date of the notification dated
01.08.2023 in correct perspective. The amendment was
during the midst of the examination.
It was submitted
that
01.08.2023,
prior
to
the
amendment
of
the
requirement was 50% aggregate in both the papers.
6.
In
rebuttal,
Mr.K.S.Prenjith
Kumar,
learned Central Government Counsel relied upon the
judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court in Sree
Sankaracharya University of Sanskrit Vs. Dr.Manu
(2023 KHC 6578) to contend that where a subsequent
order of such modification has been issued whether it
can be made retrospectively or not, it has been held that
if the said clarification is substantive to the amendment,
it will have retrospective effect otherwise prospective.
7.
We have heard learned counsel for the
parties and appraised the paper book.
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-82025:KER:22334
8.
The reason for seeking condonation of
delay was that, under the wrong advice had challenged
the order of the Single Bench before the Honourable
Supreme Court which was withdrawn and in this
conspectus
the
delay
of
days
has
occurred.
Considering the fact that the delay was not intentional,
we hereby condone the delay.
9.
issued
Concededly,
by
the
National
prior
to
Medical
the
notification
Commission
on
01.08.2023, the requirement of law for the student to
pass a particular year was 50% in aggregate in both
practical
and
theory.
However,
with
effect
from
01.08.2023 condition was that if one subject has two
papers it has to be 50:50 and in the examination
conducted by the University the candidate is required to
obtain 50% in practical and 50% in theory.
The
corrigendum,
the
condition
issued
from
50:50
on
to
01.09.2023,
changed
60:40
vice
and
versa.
Respondent-petitioner by relying upon the corrigendum
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-92025:KER:22334
dated 01.09.2023 contended that obtaining of minimum
required marks or more than the required in the
practical, and less marks in theory or vice versa, would
be squarely falling within the conditions of corrigendum.
For the sake of brevity, the conditions of corrigendum,
Ext.P3 reads as under:
“Subject: Competency Based Medical
Education
Curriculum
(CBME)
Guidelines-
National Medical Commission.
Kindly refer to the communication of
even no. dated 01st August, 2023 on the above
mentioned subject and to inform that provisions
at page 58 of CBME is amended as under:
Page
Guidelines
of
CBME Amended page 58 of
CBME Guidelines
In subjects that have In subjects that have
two papers, the learner two papers, the learner
must secure minimum must secure minimum
50%
of
marks
in 40%
of
marks
in
aggregate (both papers aggregate (both papers
together) to pass in the together) to pass in the
said subject.
said subject.
Criteria for passing in a Criteria for passing in
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-102025:KER:22334
subject:
A
candidate a subject: A candidate
shall obtain 50% marks shall obtain 50% marks
in University conducted in aggregate and 60:40
examination separately (minimum)
in
Theory
Practical
and
In
(practical University
conducted
examination separately
clinical and viva voce) in
Theory
in order to be declared Practical
passed
subject.
40:60
In (minimum).
Includes:practical/
as
or
in
and
in
(practical
that includes:
practical/clinical
and
viva voce) in order to
be declared as passed
in that subject.
”
10. It is settled law that any corrigendum issued
will not be prospective but relate back to the amendment
already in force with effect from 01.08.2023, whereas the
examination for second year of the medical college
commenced on 30.07.2023 and ended on 11.08.2023; in
between, the notification had been brought into force
meaning thereby, in the midst of the examination and
would have applicability to the students undertaking the
examination. There is no dispute that the ratio decidendi
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-112025:KER:22334
culled out in the judgment supra, but the fact remains it
was not a new amendment but a corrigendum and
definitely
would
relate
back
to
the
date
of
the
amendment issued on 01.08.2023.
Finding of fact and law, in such circumstances,
do not require a different interpretation. We do not find
any merit in the writ appeal.
Writ appeal standss
dismissed.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
vv
WA NO. 403 OF 2025
-122025:KER:22334
APPENDIX OF WA 403/2025
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A1
TRUE COPY OF GRADUATE MEDICAL
EDUCATION, REGULATIONS, 2023 ISSUED BY
THE APPELLANT HEREIN
ANNEXURE A2
A TRUE COPY MCI, GRADUATE MEDICAL
REGULATIONS, 1997
ANNEXURE A3
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
07.03.2024 IN SLP(C) NO. 5451 OF 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review