Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:11
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 3RD MARCH, 2016
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC APP. No.11 of 2015
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Gangtok Branch,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents-Claimants
:
1.
Mr. Karma Bhutia
2.
Mr. Loday Bhutia
3.
Mr. Naksing Bhutia
4.
Mr. Daba Bhutia
5.
Mr. Karma Tseten Bhutia
All are sons of
Late Sonam Palzor Bhutia,
R/o Middle Tumin Busty,
Singtam,
East Sikkim.
Respondent-Owner
:
6.
Mr. Dawa Lachungpa,
S/o K. D. Lachungpa,
R/o Lachung,
North Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. R. C. Sharma, Advocate for the Respondents No.1, 2, 4 & 5.
None for Respondent No.3.
Mr. Tshering Wangyal Bhutia, Advocate for Respondent No.6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Appeal is preferred against the Award granted in a
Claim under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, in MACT
Case No.17 of 2014 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, North
Sikkim at Mangan (for short “Claims Tribunal”).
The Claims
Tribunal vide the assailed Judgment dated 28-02-2015 ordered the
Appellant to pay compensation calculated at Rs.4,14,500/- (Rupees
four lakhs fourteen thousand and five hundred) only, with interest
@ 10% per annum, to the Claimants till full and final payment.
2.
The Respondents No.1, 2, 4 and 5 herein were the
Claimants before the Claims Tribunal and are the brothers of the
deceased, who died due to a motor accident at Dikchu-Mangan road.
Respondent No.3 another brother of the deceased has passed away
in the interim.
3.
The Claims Tribunal framed two issues and on
consideration of the entire matter reached the finding that the
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
Respondents were entitled to compensation supra against the Claim
of Rs.7,26,500/- (Rupees seven lakhs twenty six thousand and five
hundred) only, made by the Claimants.
4.
The main thrust of the arguments put forth by the
Learned Counsel for the Appellant is that the Driving Licence of the
deceased who was driving the passenger taxi vehicle, was not valid
as it was not issued by the appropriate Licensing Authority and was
procured through illegal means.
Peripheral to this argument was
the exposition that the owner Respondent No.6 having failed to
check the authenticity of the Driving Licence has acted in
contravention to Section 5 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Noncompliance of Rule 3 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, is
another point agitated as a corollary. Under this argument, it was
expostulated that as Rule 3 supra was not complied with, the
relevant Clause in the Insurance Policy was also violated.
5.
The second leg of the argument raised was that as the
deceased was a bachelor, 50% ought to have been deducted from the
amount calculated as Loss of Earnings, to the contrary a deduction of
only 1/3rd was only made. The third leg of the argument consisted of
the proposition that the award of compensation of an amount of
Rs.50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand) only, towards non-pecuniary
damages is beyond the scope of Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988.
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
6.
Per contra, the Respondents argued that although the
Appellant insists that the Driving Licence of the driver was not
genuine but to counter this allegation they have only furnished a
Verification Report obtained from the Sub-Divisional Office at
Siliguri, West Bengal, which firstly is not the appropriate Authority
not being the Licensing Authority. Secondly, during the course of
trial, the document was not exhibited and, therefore, cannot be
relied on by the Appellant at this stage. It was contended that the
evidence of Respondent No.6 clearly indicates that he had conducted
a driving test, perused the Driving Licence concluded that it was
genuine and employed the deceased. Therefore, the question of him
being negligent in allowing the deceased to drive does not arise. To
support his contentions on this point, Learned Counsel for the
Respondents placed reliance on New India Assurance Company Ltd. and
Others vs. Makhan Singh and Others1.
7.
The question for determination before this Court is
whether
the
Claims
Tribunal
has
correctly
awarded
the
compensation.
8.
Dealing with the first argument of the Appellant, that
the Driving Licence was not valid, I have to agree with the
arguments placed by the Learned Counsel for the Respondents.
Exhibit 11 which is the Driving Licence of the driver appears to have
1. II (2006) ACC 164 (P&H)
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
been issued by the Licensing Authority at Siliguri. If the Appellant
contends that the Licence was fake, it ought to have furnished proof
thereof in support of its contention by filing a document from the
concerned Authority, which is, the Licensing Authority at Siliguri
and not from the Sub-Divisional Office, which evidently is not the
appropriate Authority. In addition to the above, the said document
has not even been exhibited before the Claims Tribunal and,
therefore, cannot be taken into consideration on the urging of the
Respondents at this stage without compliance of the relevant
provisions of law. The Respondent No.6 has clearly stated that he
had taken the deceased for a test drive, was satisfied with his driving
and had found the Driving Licence to be genuine on its perusal. The
owner cannot be expected to launch an investigation into the
genuineness of the Licence when employing a driver.
9.
In this regard, one may usefully refer to the decision in
United India Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Lehru and Others2 wherein the
Hon’ble Apex Court has held as follows:“17. When an owner is hiring a driver he will
therefore have to check whether the driver has a
driving licence. If the driver produces a driving
licence which on the face of it looks genuine, the
owner is not expected to find out whether the licence
has in fact been issued by a Competent Authority or
not. The owner would then take the test of the driver.
If he finds that the driver is competent to drive the
vehicle, he will hire the driver. We find it rather
strange that Insurance Companies expect owners to
make enquiries with RTOs, which are spread all over
2. I (2003) ACC 611 (SC)
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
the country, whether the driving licence shown to
them is valid or not. Thus where the owner has
satisfied himself that the driver has a licence and is
driving competently there would be no breach of
Section 149(2)(a)(ii). The Insurance Company would
not then be absolved of liability. If it ultimately turns
out that the licence was fake the Insurance Company
would continue to remain liable unless they prove
that the owner/insured was aware or had noticed
that the licence was fake and still permitted that
person to drive. More importantly even in such a
case the Insurance Company would remain liable to
the innocent third party, but it may be able to
recover from the insured. …………………………...”
10.
While dealing with the same point, the Hon’ble Apex
Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Swaran Singh and Others3 has
held as follows:“109. ....................................................................
(iii)
The breach of policy condition e.g.,
disqualification of the driver on invalid
driving licence of the driver, as
contained in Sub-section (2)(a)(ii) of
Section 149, have to be proved to have
been committed by the insured for
avoiding liability by the insurer. Mere
absence, fake or invalid driving licence
or disqualification of the driver for
driving at the relevant time, are not in
themselves defences available to the
insurer against either the insured or the
third parties. To avoid its liability
towards the insured, the insurer has to
prove that the insured was guilty of
negligence and failed to exercise
reasonable care in the matter of
fulfilling the condition of the policy
regarding use of vehicles by duly
licensed driver or one who was not
disqualified to drive at the relevant
time.
.................................................................................”
3.
I (2004) ACC 1 (SC)
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
11.
In consideration of the above ratiocination, the
arguments of the Learned Counsel for the Appellant are untenable
on this point.
12.
Moving on to the argument with regard to the
deduction from Loss of Earnings, the argument of the Appellant
have to be conceded to inasmuch as the deceased was a bachelor. It
was held in Sarla Verma (Smt.) and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
and Another 4 that where the deceased was a bachelor, 1/2 is to be
deducted from his Loss of Earnings on the assumption that the
amount would have been incurred by the victim towards
maintaining himself had he been alive.
13.
On this count, it would be worthwhile to walk through
the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Munna Lal Jain and Another
vs. Vipin Kumar Sharma and Others5 which has reiterated the decision
in Sarla Verma’s case (supra)
the relevant portion of which is
reproduced herein below:“7. On the issue of deduction towards personal
and living expenses in Sarla Verma v. DTC [(2009) 6 SCC
121], at para 31, it was held that: (SCC p.136)
“31. ...... In regard to bachelors, normally,
50% is deducted as personal and living
expenses, because it is assumed that a bachelor
would tend to spend more on himself. Even
otherwise, there is also the possibility of his
getting married in a short time, in which
event the contribution to the parent(s) and
4.
5.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(2015) 6 SCC 347
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
siblings is likely to be cut drastically. Further,
subject to evidence to the contrary, the father
is likely to have his own income and will not be
considered as a dependant and the mother
alone will be considered as a dependant. In the
absence of evidence to the contrary, brothers
and sisters will not be considered as
dependants, because they will either be
independent and earning, or married, or be
dependent on the father.”
8. The deduction ordinarily in the case of a
bachelor at 50% was approved recently by a threeJudge Bench decision in Reshma Kumari v. Madan
Mohan [(2013) 9 SCC 65], holding that the standard fixed
in Sarla Verma on the aspect of deduction for personal
and living expenses “must ordinarily be followed
unless a case for departure in the circumstances
noted in the preceding paragraph is made out”.
………………………………..”
14.
Consequently, it emerges that the deduction in the
matter at hand would have to be 50% and not 1/3rd as made out by
the Claims Tribunal as there are no compelling reasons to deviate
from the norm set out supra.
15.
That having been settled, we may now discuss the point
of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand) only, being granted on nonpecuniary damages. In this context in Jayakodi and Others vs. Branch
Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. And Another 6 the Hon’ble Apex
Court ruled, inter alia, as follows:“4.
……………………………………………. When a
person dies in a motor accident and his dependent
legal representatives claim compensation, the
general damages is made up of the loss of dependency
6.
2010 ACJ 697
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
plus a token sum for loss to estate. In the event of a
claimant being a spouse another token amount is
awarded as loss of consortium. Actual expenditure
incurred for transporting the dead body and the
funeral, are also awarded by way of special damages.
Nothing is awardable under the head of shock and
mental agony of parents or other legal
representatives. …………………….”
16.
Bearing in mind the above ratio and also the Second
Schedule of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, it is clear that the Statute
makes no provision for compensation on account of Loss of Love and
Affection, Mental Tension and Agony, Loss of Prospective Happiness,
Loss of Companion of Brother, as claimed by the Respondents No.1,
2, 4 and 5.
That apart no reasons have been elucidated by the
Claims Tribunal for awarding compensation under this head,
consequently the sum of Rs.50,000/- is deducted.
17.
It would be beneficial at this point to also refer to the
Judgment of this Court dated 07-04-2015 in MAC App. No.21 of 2014
in the matter of The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Smt. Sujita Newar and Others, where it has been held as follows:“15. In the instant case, as stated above, the Tribunal,
on the one hand, already awarded compensation
towards the Loss of Estate and Loss of Consortium
and, on the other hand, it also awarded Rs.1,00,000/towards Non-pecuniary damages, which appears to
be a repetition. That apart, the Tribunal has not
assigned any reason for awarding this amount and
has simply said that considering the age of the
deceased and the claimants, the same is allowed. This
deserves to be set aside in view of R.D. Hattangadi
(supra) [(1995) 1 SCC 551].”
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
18.
While considering the calculation made by the Claims
Tribunal in paragraph 18 of the impugned Judgment, it is, inter alia,
recorded as “18.
……………………………………………………………….
In consideration of the fact that the victim is a
(sic) unmarried person. Accordingly, the loss of
earning is calculated as follows:
Rs. 3000/- per month – 1/3 deduction, i.e., 2000 x 18
= 3,60,000/- per annum. …………………….”
19.
The above calculation is apparently erroneous as
Rs.2,000/- x 18 would be Rs.36,000/- (Rupees thirty six thousand)
only and not Rs.3,60,000/- (Rupees three lakhs and sixty thousand)
only, per annum as calculated by the Claims Tribunal. The Loss of
Income per annum, after adopting the multiplier of ‘18’ as per the
Second Schedule of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, on account of the
age of the victim, i.e., 27 years, would be as follows:Rs.3,000/- x
(income per
month)
(per
annum)
20.
x
(correct
multiplier)
-
1/2
= Rs.3,24,000/-
(on account of the
expenses which the
victim would have
incurred towards
maintaining himself
had he been alive)
It is also noticed that in paragraph 17, the Claims
Tribunal has recorded as follows:“……………………………………………………………………..
I am of the considered opinion that the
notional income of the victim can be taken to be Rs.
3,000/- per month. ……………………….”
21.
The question of “notional income” which means
“hypothetical income” comes into play only if the deceased was a
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
non-earning person. It does not arise in the instant matter since
Exhibit 16, the Salary Certificate of the deceased, clearly indicates
that he was receiving a monthly salary of Rs.3,000/- (Rupees three
thousand) only, hence the sum of Rs.3,000/- per month was the
“actual income” of the deceased and not his “notional income”.
Hence, the amount of compensation stands re-
22.
calculated and modified as follows:Monthly income of the deceased
Rs.
Annual income of the deceased (Rs.3000 x 12 months)
Rs. 36,000.00
Less 1/2 of Rs.36,000/-
Rs. 18,000.00
(−)
3,000.00
[in consideration of the expenses which
the victim would have incurred towards
maintaining himself had he been alive]
Net yearly income
Multiplier to be adopted ‘18’
Rs. 18,000.00
Rs.3,24,000.00
(Rs.18,000 x 18)
[as per the Second Schedule of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988]
Funeral expenses
(+)
Rs.
2,000.00
(+)
Rs.
2,500.00
[as per the Second Schedule of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988]
Loss of estate
[as per the Second Schedule of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988]
Total -
Rs.3,28,500.00
(Rupees three lakhs twenty eight thousand and five hundred) only
23.
The Respondents No.1, 2, 4 and 5 shall be entitled to
simple interest @ 10% on the above with effect from the date of the
Claim made before the Claims Tribunal until full and final settlement
of the award.
24.
Before concluding the matter, it may be mentioned in
passing that the Appellant appears to have raised the issue of a
2016:SHC:11
MAC App. No.11 of 2015
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Karma Bhutia and Others
wrong multiplier having been adopted by the Respondents for
calculating the compensation, i.e., based on the age of the deceased
and not on the average age of the Claimants. This matter was not
discussed by the Claims Tribunal in its Judgment. Nevertheless since
no arguments were raised before this Court on this count, I do not
deem it necessary to delve into this question.
25.
In the result, the MAC App. is partly allowed.
26.
No order as to costs.
27.
Considering the fact that the accident took place as far
back as on 13-12-2011, the Appellant is directed to pay the award
amount to the Respondents No.1, 2, 4 and 5 within 6 (six) weeks from
today and not later than that.
28.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Claims Tribunal for
information and compliance.
29.
Records of the Claims Tribunal be returned forthwith.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
03-03-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review