Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 19th NOVEMBER, 2016
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.A. No.01 of 2016
in
MAC App. No.07 of 2016
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
Gangtok Branch,
31-A National Highway,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Mrs. Bed Maya Sharma,
Aged 44 years,
W/o Late Dhanpati Sharma
2.
Ms. Babita Sharma,
Aged 27 years,
D/o Late Dhanpati Sharma
3.
Ms. Anita Sharma,
Aged 23 years,
D/o Late Dhanpati Sharma
4.
Ms. Manita Sharma,
Aged 23 years,
D/o Late Dhanpati Sharma
5.
Ms. Sapanan Sharma,
Aged 20 years,
D/o Late Dhanpati Sharma
6.
Master Youraj Sharma,
Aged 17 years,
S/o Late Dhanpati Sharma
All residents of Sama Sivik,
Lingdum Busty,
P.O. Dhajey, Ranka,
P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
7.
Mr. Tashi Pintso Bhutia,
S/o Late Phu Tshering Bhutia,
R/o Lall Market,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in MAC App. No.07 of 2016
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs.
Mrs. Bed Maya Sharma and Others
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Thupeden G. Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Mr. Leada T. Bhutia and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa,
Advocates for the Respondents No.1 to 6.
Mr. Ashok Pradhan, Advocate for Respondent No.7.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Assailing the Judgment and Award dated 25-11-2015,
passed by the Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East
Sikkim at Gangtok, in MACT Case No.19 of 2015, directing the
Appellant Company/Opposite Party No.1, to pay Rs.11,67,000/(Rupees eleven lakhs, sixty seven thousand) only, with interest @
10% per annum, on the said sum, to the Respondents No.1 to
6/Claimants, the instant Appeal has been filed.
2.
The Appeal is accompanied by an Application for
condonation of delay.
The grounds put forth for the delay are
that;
(i)
A delay of five days occurred while applying for the
impugned
Judgment,
which
was
then
made
available on 19-12-2015, thus the limitation period
for presenting the Memo of Appeal was on or
before 14-03-2016, however, a delay of 174 days
have occurred.
(ii)
After receiving a certified copy of the impugned
Judgment, it was delivered to the Branch Office of
the Appellant Company on 22-01-2016 along with
the Counsel’s opinion.
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in MAC App. No.07 of 2016
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
(iii)
vs.
Mrs. Bed Maya Sharma and Others
The said Judgment was forwarded to the Divisional
Office at Siliguri, which in turn, forwarded it to the
Regional Office at Kolkata, for taking necessary
steps.
(iv)
The Legal Cell at the Regional Office at Kolkata
approved the proposal for preferring an Appeal.
After receiving the approval, the matter was
returned to Siliguri Divisional Office from where it
was again forwarded to the Gangtok Branch Office
with directions to file an Appeal.
(v)
Thereafter, some time ensued in drafting the
Appeal, added to which the Appellant Company
being a Central Government Undertaking collective
decisions and sanctions of various Departments are
required, as a result of which, the elapse of time
and the consequent the delay.
That, in view of the grounds it is prayed that the delay be
condoned.
3.
Per contra, the grounds put forth by Appellant were
vehemently opposed by the Respondents No.1 to 6, inter alia, on
grounds that the statutory provisions requires that “sufficient
cause” has to be made out for the delay, but the Appellant has
failed to put forth any sufficient grounds, except stating that the
File moved from one Office to the next. No dates save the date
on which the impugned Judgment was forwarded to the Branch
Office at Gangtok being 22-01-2016 has been revealed.
During
the process of File movement where the delay actually occurred
has not been explained hence, the Application deserves to be
dismissed as also the Appeal.
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in MAC App. No.07 of 2016
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
4.
vs.
Mrs. Bed Maya Sharma and Others
I have heard the submissions put forth by Learned
Counsel for the parties and carefully considered the same.
5.
The second Proviso to Section 173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, provides that the High Court may entertain
the Appeal after the expiry of the said period of ninety days, if it
is satisfied that the Appellant was prevented by “sufficient cause”
from preferring the Appeal in time.
6.
It would be useful to consider the conspectus of facts
placed before this Court by the Appellant for the present purpose.
Although for brevity, the submissions are not being reiterated, it
is clear that the impugned Judgment was pronounced on 25-112015, copy applied for belatedly on 01-12-2015, copy made
available on 19-12-2015, copy forwarded to the Branch Office
Gangtok on 22-01-2016 and thereafter to the Divisional Office at
Siliguri, subsequently the Memo of Appeal has been filed on 0309-2016, when by the admission of the Appellant, it ought to
have been filed on or before 14-03-2016.
7.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Esha Bhattacharjee vs.
Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and Others1
while referring to various authorities on condonation of delay has
summarised grounds for condonation or otherwise as follows;
“21. From the aforesaid authorities the principles
that can broadly be culled out are:
21.1. (i) There should be a liberal, pragmatic,
justice-oriented, non-pedantic approach while dealing
with an application for condonation of delay, for the
1. (2013) 12 SCC 649
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in MAC App. No.07 of 2016
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs.
Mrs. Bed Maya Sharma and Others
courts are not supposed to legalise injustice but are
obliged to remove injustice.
21.2. (ii) The terms "sufficient cause" should be
understood in their proper spirit, philosophy and purpose
regard being had to the fact that these terms are basically
elastic and are to be applied in proper perspective to the
obtaining fact-situation.
21.3. (iii) Substantial justice being paramount and
pivotal the technical considerations should not be given
undue and uncalled for emphasis.
21.4. (iv) No presumption can be attached to
deliberate causation of delay but, gross negligence on the
part of the counsel or litigant is to be taken note of.
21.5. (v) Lack of bona fides imputable to a party
seeking condonation of delay is a significant and relevant
fact.
21.6. (vi) It is to be kept in mind that adherence
to strict proof should not affect public justice and cause
public mischief because the courts are required to be
vigilant so that in the ultimate eventuate there is no real
failure of justice.
21.7. (vii) The concept of liberal approach has to
encapsule the conception of reasonableness and it cannot
be allowed a totally unfettered free play.
21.8. (viii) There is a distinction between
inordinate delay and a delay of short duration or few
days, for to the former doctrine of prejudice is attracted
whereas to the latter it may not be attracted. That apart,
the first one warrants strict approach whereas the second
calls for a liberal delineation.
21.9. (ix) The conduct, behaviour and attitude of
a party relating to its inaction or negligence are relevant
factors to be taken into consideration. It is so as the
fundamental principle is that the courts are required to
weigh the scale of balance of justice in respect of both
parties and the said principle cannot be given a total go
by in the name of liberal approach.
21.10. (x) If the explanation offered is concocted
or the grounds urged in the application are fanciful, the
courts should be vigilant not to expose the other side
unnecessarily to face such a litigation.
21.11. (xi) It is to be borne in mind that no one
gets away with fraud, misrepresentation or interpolation
by taking recourse to the technicalities of law of
limitation.
21.12. (xii) The entire gamut of facts are to be
carefully scrutinized and the approach should be based on
the paradigm of judicial discretion which is founded on
objective reasoning and not on individual perception.
21.13. (xiii) The State or a public body or an
entity representing a collective cause should be given
some acceptable latitude.
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in MAC App. No.07 of 2016
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs.
Mrs. Bed Maya Sharma and Others
22. To the aforesaid principles we may add some
more guidelines taking note of the present day scenario.
They are:
22.1. (a) An application for condonation of delay
should be drafted with careful concern and not in a
haphazard manner harbouring the notion that the courts
are required to condone delay on the bedrock of the
principle that adjudication of a lis on merits is seminal to
justice dispensation system.
22.2. (b) An application for condonation of delay
should not be dealt with in a routine manner on the base
of individual philosophy which is basically subjective.
22.3. (c) Though no precise formula can be laid
down regard being had to the concept of judicial
discretion, yet a conscious effort for achieving consistency
and collegiality of the adjudicatory system should be
made as that is the ultimate institutional motto.
22.4. (d) The increasing tendency to perceive
delay as a non-serious matter and, hence, lackadaisical
propensity can be exhibited in a nonchallant manner
requires to be curbed, of course, within legal
parameters.”
8.
In view of the principles elucidated hereinabove, no
further explanation is required on what grounds the Court should
consider condoning or not condoning the delay.
On the
touchstone of the principles exposited hereinabove, we may look
to the grounds put forth by the Appellant.
The Appellant has
failed not only to furnish details for the delay on a day to day
basis, but no explanation is forthcoming for the delay even on a
week to week basis. This Court is conscious and aware of the fact
that the Appellant is a Central Government Undertaking where
collective decisions and sanctions of various Departments are
required prior to preferring an Appeal. In other words, being an
unwieldy
Organisation
cumbersome.
decision-making
process
can
be
But at the same time would it mean that
accountability has to be abandoned by the Appellant Company,
and merely because the Organisation is unwieldy, does it mean
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in MAC App. No.07 of 2016
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
Mrs. Bed Maya Sharma and Others
vs.
that various Departments within it have to be disorganised so as
to be unable to take a decision on something as important as
filing an Appeal when they are aggrieved by the award of the
Learned Claims Tribunal? It should not be so. It is assumed that
an Organisation has a separate unit for dealing with such matters
which
ought
to
function
diligently.
There
cannot
be
any
mechanical condonation of delay by this Court only on the
administrative grounds furnished by the Appellant. If such were
to be the case and administrative delay the only ground for
condoning delay for every unwieldy or Central Government
Organisation then every such Organisation would be able to
approach the Court at any belated time and expect the delay to
be condoned. I am afraid that the grounds have to be bona fide
and the cause sufficient, for delay to be condoned. The grounds
put forth by the appellant brook no consideration as they are
appear to be flimsy and without substance.
9.
In view of the fact that no sufficient grounds have
been made out by the Appellant, it goes without saying that the
delay cannot be condoned.
10.
The
Application
is
accordingly
rejected
consequently the Appeal.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
19-11-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
Internet : Yes
and
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review