The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In view of the foregoing discussion, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is modified as under: Permanent disability Rs.3,50,280/(i.e. Rs.6950+40% PF=9730 x 12=116760 x 15 (multiplier)=1751400 x 20/100 (PD)) Other conventional heads i.e. loss Rs.2,30,000/of income/medical expenses/pain and suffering/special diet/future treatment etc. TOTAL Rs. 5,80,280/-
16. In view of above, the award passed by the Tribunal is modified as above. In the result, the appeal filed by the Insurance Company is 12:15:37 PM allowed to the extent indicated herein above and the cross objection filed by the respondent/claimant is dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA
PRADESH
AT INDOR E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 24 th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 5604 of 2022
BETWEEN:NATIONAL
INSURANCE
COMPANY
LIMITED
THROUGH
MANAGER KSHETRIYA KARYALAY VIDHIK PRAKOSH INDORE
BHARAT ME NIGMIT PANJIKRAT AVM PRADHAN KARYALAY 03
MIDILATAN STREET POST BOX NO. 9229 KOLKATA 700-071
PAKSHIM BANGAL AVM NAGESHWAR MARG BADNAWAR
DISTRICT
DHAR
M.P.
KSHETRIYA
KRAYALAY
310-323
BENCHMARK BUSINESS PARK AVM A -3 P.U. 4 VIJAY NAGAR.
DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI ANIL KUMAR GOYAL, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT)
AND
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
1.
DHYANSINGH S/O RAJU, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: DIRVER 59/2, KRISHNBAG COLONY, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
KAILASH DUDVE S/O NARAYAN GRAM PIPLOD, TEHSIL
PANSEMAL DISTRICT BADWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
JITENDRA S/O BABULAL BARELA PACHADIA MOHALLA,
PALSUD THANA RAJPUR DISTRICT BARWANI (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI HIMANSHU PALIWAL, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENT [R-1].)
This appeal coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
This appeal by the Insurance Company under section 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act is arising out of the award dated 28.09.2022
passed by 25th Member, MACT, Indore in Claim Case No.1629/2017
on the ground of false implication of the offending vehicle and seeking
setting aside the award/ reduction in compensation awarded by the
Tribunal.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that on 22.10.2016 in the morning at
07.00 a.m claimant/respondent No.1 Dyansingh was going on a
motorcycle as pillion rider from Rajpur to Barwani. The motor cycle
was driven by his Jija Umrao.
When they reached near Rajpur-
Barwani road they stopped the motor cycle on the side of the road to
answer the natural call, the respondent No.3 came on a motorcycle
bearing registration no.MP-46-MK-9216 rashly and negligently and hit
the claimant due to which Dyansingh received grievous injuries on his
body. He was admitted in Barwani hospital wherefrom he was referred
to Union Hospital, Indore for further treatment. As per the PDC injured
Dyansingh sustained 35% permanent disability on his body. He filed a
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
claim petition before the Tribunal against owner, driver and insurance
company of the offending vehicle seeking compensation of Rs.20
lakhs.
3.
The Tribunal closed the right of the respondents No.1 & 2, driver
and owner of the offending vehicle, to file written statement. The
Insurance Company filed the written statement and denied all the
averments made in the pleadings and stated that owner and driver of
the offending vehicle have breached the terms and conditions of the
insurance policy and that the FIR regarding the accident was lodged
with delay and the said delay has not been explained properly.
4.
The Tribunal framed issued on the basis of the pleadings of both
parties and after taking evidenc e of both parties, the claim petition was
allowed and awarded compensation of Rs.6,28,424/- with interest in
favour of the claimant and against the insurance company.
5.
Being aggrieved by the said award, insurance company has filed
this appeal and submitted that Tribunal has committed grave error in
assessing 35% permanent disability of the claimant.
He further
submitted that doctor has stated in his evidence that claimant has
suffered 35% permanent disability on his leg but Tribunal has assessed
total 35% permanent disability on whole body. He further submitted
that Tribunal has committed error in holding that offending vehicle had
caused the accident.
The claimant has not explained the delay in
lodging the FIR. The claimant has falsely implicated the vehicle for
seeking compensation, hence prays for exoneration of the insurance
company from its liability.
6.
On the other hand, claimant’s counsel prayed for rejection of this
appeal.
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
7.
Claimant has filed a cross objection under Order 41 Rule 22
CPC (DOC No.4935/2023) for enhancement of compensation and
submitted that Tribunal has committed error in holding the income of
the claimant as Rs.6000/- per month. He has submitted that claimant
was a driver and was earning Rs.10,000/- per month, therefore, the
income of the claimant ought to have been assessed as Rs.10,000/ - per
month.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that claimant
has not explained the delay in lodging the FIR.
He submitted that
accident was occurred on 22.10.2016 and FIR was lodged on
20.11.2016, therefore, the delay is not explained.
9.
Considering the document produced before the Tribunal it is
found that according to Ex.P/9 Rojnamcha, the district hospital,
Barwani had sent the information to the police station on 22.10.2016
that Dyansingh s/o Raju came for treatment due to road accident,
therefore, the information regarding accident was sent to the police
station on the same date. According to Ex.P/10 dated 26.10.2016, the
statement of Umrao who accompanied with the claimant at the time of
accident, he has mentioned the registration number of the offending
vehicle in his statement.
10.
It is settled law that delay in filing the FIR is not fatal either in
criminal case or in claim case provided that sufficient and cogent
reason for delay in filing the FIR is given. The Apex Court in the
case of Ravi vs. Badrinarayan and others – AIR 2011 SC 1226 in
para 20 & 21 has held as under:
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
[20] It is well-settled that delay in lodging FIR cannot be a
ground to doubt the claimant's case. Knowing the Indian
conditions as they are, we cannot expect a common man to first
rush to the Police Station immediately after an accident. Human
nature and family responsibilities occupy the mind of kith and
kin to such an extent that they give more importance to get the
victim treated rather than to rush to the Police Station. Under
such circumstances, they are not expected to act mechanically
with promptitude in lodging the FIR with the Police. Delay in
lodging the FIR thus, cannot be the ground to deny justice to the
victim. In cases of delay, the courts are required to examine the
evidence with a closer scrutiny and in doing so; the contents of
the FIR should also be scrutinized more carefully. If court finds
that there is no indication of fabrication or it has not been
concocted or engineered to implicate innocent persons then,
even if there is a delay in lodging the FIR, the claim case cannot
be dismissed merely on that ground.
[21] The purpose of lodging the FIR in such type of cases is
primarily to intimate the police to initiate investigation of
criminal offences. Lodging of FIR certainly proves factum of
accident so that the victim is able to lodge a case for
compensation but delay in doing so cannot be the main ground
for rejecting the claim petition. In other words, although lodging
of FIR is vital in deciding motor accident claim cases, delay in
lodging the same should not be treated as fatal for such
proceedings, if claimant has been able to demonstrate
satisfactory and cogent reasons for it. There could be variety of
reasons in genuine cases for delayed lodgment of FIR. Unless
kith and kin of the victim are able to regain a certain level of
tranquility of mind and are composed to lodge it, even if, there
is delay, the same deserves to be condoned. In such
circumstances, the authenticity of the FIR assumes much more
significance than delay in lodging thereof supported by cogent
reasons.
11.
Keeping in view the verdict of the Apex Court in the case of
Ravi (supra) coupled with the perusal of documents Ex.P/9 & P/10 it is
clear that on the same date the information of the accident was
received by the police station and police enquired the matter and after
taking the statement in enquiry on 26.10.2016 Umrao gave his
statement in which the registration number of the offending vehicle
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
was mentioned, therefore, in the considered opinion of this Court, the
contention of the counsel for the insurance company that the delay in
lodging the FIR has not been explained properly by the claimant has no
substance.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that Tribunal
has committed error in holding 35% permanent disability on the whole
body of the claimant. He submitted that Dr.Ashish Malhotra has stated
in his examination in chief that Medical Board has found 35%
permanent disability on the left leg of the claimant i.e Ex.P/16. The Xray report is Ex.P/17. Therefore, considering the evidence of PW/2
Dr.Ashish Malhotra it is clear that 35% permanent disability is in
respect of left leg of the claimant and not on the whole body. So in the
considered opinion of this Court Tribunal has committed error in
holding that claimant got 35% permanent disability on the whole body.
So in the considered opinion of this Court, the permanent disability
sustained by the claimant so far as whole body is concerned, ought to
be 20% and the compensation ought to have been assessed on that
basis.
13.
Learned counsel for the respondents has submitted that Tribunal
has committed error in holding the income of the claimant as Rs.6000/per month. He has submitted that claimant is a driver and he is a skilled
labour but respondent/claimant has failed to adduce any evidence that
the claimant is a trained and professional driver and doing the driving
work, however, he has not produced not a single document to show
that he is a driver by profession. Claimant has also not able to adduce
any document in respect of his income, hence the contention of the
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
claimant that his income was Rs.10000/- per month has not been
proved.
14.
According to the circular dated 22.10.2016 regarding the
minimum wages prevalent in the year 2016, the income of an unskilled
labour was Rs.6950/- per month which can be taken as the income of
the claimant in the year 2016. Therefore, in the considered opinion of
this Court, Tribunal has committed an error in assessing the income of
the claimant as Rs.6000/- per month and the just and proper income of
the claimant was Rs.6950/- per month.
15.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the compensation awarded
by the Tribunal is modified as under:
HEAD
AMOUNT
Permanent disability
Rs.3,50,280/(i.e.
Rs.6950+40%
PF=9730 x 12=116760 x
15 (multiplier)=1751400
x 20/100 (PD))
Other conventional heads i.e. loss Rs.2,30,000/of income/medical expenses/pain
and suffering/special diet/future
treatment etc.
TOTAL Rs. 5,80,280/-
16.
In view of above, the award passed by the Tribunal is modified
as above. In the result, the appeal filed by the Insurance Company is
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
allowed to the extent indicated herein above and the cross objection
filed by the respondent/claimant is dismissed.
(HIRDESH)
JUDGE
hk/
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 2/1/2024
12:15:37 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review