The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. In the case of Dulari Singh and others Vs. Tribhuvan Murari Dubey and another, 2010 (4) MPLJ, Note 10, it is held that burden of proof for breach of policy lies upon insurance company so it is the duty of insurance company to prove that driver of offending vehicle had no effective and valid driving licence at the time of accident. But, in the present case, insurance company has not produced any document showing that driver of the offending vehicle did not have any valid and effective driving licence and offending vehicle was being driven by the driver in contravention of the policy of insurance company. So, without adducing any evidence, appellant/insurance company is not able to prove that at the time of accident, the driver of offending vehicle was not having valid and effective driving licence. --6-10. In view of aforesaid discussion, it was not found proved that at the time of accident, the driver of offending vehicle was not having any valid and effective licence and offending vehicle was being driven in contravention of the insurance policy, hence, present appeal being devoid of merits is hereby dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
--1--
IN THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 5922 of 2019
BETWEEN:NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. BRANCH MANAGER OFFICE, RATLAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI PRADIP KUMAR GUPTA AND SHRI BHASHKAR AGRAWAL, LEARNED
COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT)
AND
1. SMT. SHAMIM BANO W/O FARIDUDDIN ANSARI, AGED ABOUT 40
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE HOUSE NO. 4, VED VYAS COLONY,
RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. FAKHRUDDIN S/O LATE FARIDUDDIN ANSARI, AGED ABOUT 21
YEARS, HOUSE NO. 4, VED VYAS COLONY, RATLAM (MADHYA
PRADESH)
3. IRFANUDDIN S/O LATE FARIDUDDIN ANSARI, AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: NIL HOUSE NO. 4, VED VYAS COLONY, RATLAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4. KU. SAIMA MINOR THROUGH NATURAL GUARDIAN MOTHER
SHAMIMA BANO W/O FARIUDDIN ANSARI, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE HOUSE NO. 4, VED VYAS COLONY,
RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
5. NANDLAL S/O GULABSINGH MAYDA, AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, GRAM
TAMBOLIYA, TEHSIL RAWTI, DIST RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
6. RAJKUMAR S/O RATANLAL THROUGH NANDLAL S/O GULABSINGH
MAYDA, AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, GRAM TAMBOLIYA, TEHSIL RAWTI,
DIST RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(NONE APPEARED FOR RESPONDENTS)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
--2-following:
ORDER
This miscellaneous appeal by appellant/insurance company for
exoneration of liability under Section 173 of Motor Vehicle Act has been
filed challenging the impugned award dated 21.11.2017 passed by Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Ratlam in Claim Case No.148/16 whereby
tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs.7,56,000/- as compensation with interest
@6% p.a. to the claimants from the date of institution of claim petition by
the claimants.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that on 08.01.2016, when deceased
Fariuddin along with one Moinuddinn Pathan was going on Activa
motorcycle bearing registration number MP-45-D-3269 from Petlawad to
Ratlam, offending vehicle No.MP-43-MA-3694 came in a very rash and
negligent manner and dashed the motorcycle of the deceased due to which
Fariuddin fell down from motorcycle and sustained grievous injury on his
head. He was immediately taken to Civil Hospital, Petlawad where doctor
declared him dead.
3.
Claimants filed claim case against respondent Nos.5 and 6- the driver
and the owner of the offending vehicle as well as appellant-insurance
company for compensation of Rs.27,00,000/- towards death of husband of
respondent No.1 and father of respondent Nos.2 to 4 before the tribunal.
Respondent No.6 was ex-parte before the tribunal and did not file written
statement. Respondent No.5 filed written statement before the tribunal and
denied all the allegations and submitted that offending vehicel was insured
with the appellant/insurance company so he is not liable to pay
compensation. Appellant-insurance company also filed written statement
and denied all the allegations and submitted that driver and owner of the
--3-offending vehicle has breached the terms and conditions of insurance
company so insurance company is not liable to pay any compensation.
Tribunal after framing issues and after appreciating evidence on record
passed an award of Rs.7,56,000/- against respondent Nos.5 and 6 jointly
and severely with 6% interest per annum.
4.
Being aggrieved by the award, appellant-insurance company filed
this present appeal mainly on the ground that driver of the offending
vehicle was not having valid and effective driving licence, hence, it is a
breach of terms and conditions of insurance policy. Tribunal has also not
appreciated the fact that police registered crime under Section 3/181, which
is indicative of the fact that driver of the offending vehicle was not
possessing valid and effective driving licence at the time of accident so
insurance company is not liable to pay the compensation.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent/claimants
submitted that tribunal has rightly passed the award and prayed for
dismissal of the present appeal.
6.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of
the case.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellant argued that police registered a case
under Section 3/181 against the driver of offending vehicle so it is the duty
of driver of offending vehicle to prove that he was having valid and
effective driving licence at the time of accident. Learned counsel has placed
reliance upon a judgment delivered by the Apex Court in the case of
Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs. Premlata Shukla and others,
207 (13) SCC, 476. The Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment in para
Nos.12 to 15 has held as under:“12. In Narbada Devi (supra) whereupon reliance has been
--4-placed, this Court held that contents of a document are not
automatically proved only because the same is marked as an
Exhibit. There is no dispute with regard to the said legal
proposition.
13. However, the factum of an accident could also be proved
from the First Information Report. It is also to be noted that
once a part of the contents of the document is admitted in
evidence, the party bringing the same on record cannot be
permitted to turn round and contend that the other contents
contained in the rest part thereof had not been proved. Both
the parties have relied thereupon. It was marked as an Exhibit
as both the parties intended to rely upon them.
14. Once a part of it is relied upon by both the parties, the
learned Tribunal cannot be said to have committed any
illegality in relying upon the other part, irrespective of the
contents of the document been proved or not. If the contents
have been proved, the question of reliance thereupon only upon
a part thereof and not upon the rest, on the technical ground
that the same had not been proved in accordance with law,
would not arise.
15. A party objecting to the admissibility of a document
must raise its objection at the appropriate time. If the objection
is not raised and the document is allowed to be marked and
that too at the instance of a party which had proved the same
and wherefor consent of the other party has been obtained, the
former in our opinion cannot be permitted to turn round and
raise a contention that the contents of the documents had not
been proved and, thus, should not be relied upon. In Hukam
Singh (supra), the law was correctly been laid down by the
Punjab and Haryana High Court stating;
"8. Mr. G.C. Mittal, learned counsel for the
respondent contended that Ram Partap had
produced only his former deposition and gave no
evidence in Court which could be considered by the
Additional District Judge. I am afraid there is no
merit in this contention. The Trial Court had
discussed the evidence of Ram Partap in the light of
the report Exhibit D.1 produced by him. The
Additional District Judge while hearing the appeal
could have commented on that evidence and held it
to be inadmissible if law so permitted. But he did not
at all have this evidence before his mind. It was not a
--5-case of inadmissible evidence either. No doubt the
procedure adopted by the trial Court in letting in a
certified copy of the previous deposition of Ram
Partap made in the criminal proceedings and
allowing the same to be proved by Ram Partap
himself was not correct and he should have been
examined again in regard to all that he had stated
earlier in the statement the parties in order to save
time did not object to the previous deposition being
proved by Ram Partap himself who was only crossexamined. It is not a case where irrelevant evidence
had been let in with the consent of the parties but the
only objection is that the procedure followed in the
matter of giving evidence in Court was not correct.
When the parties themselves have allowed certain
statements to be placed on the record as a part of
their evidence, it is not open to them to urge later
either in the same Court or in a court of appeal that
the evidence produced was inadmissible. To allow
them to do so would indeed be permitting them both
to appropriate and reprobate."
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that Apex Court has held that
where parts of a document have been relied on by both the parties then Claims
Tribunal may rely on the same irrespective of whether the contents of the
document have been proved or not.
9.
In the case of Dulari Singh and others Vs. Tribhuvan Murari Dubey
and another, 2010 (4) MPLJ, Note 10, it is held that burden of proof for breach
of policy lies upon insurance company so it is the duty of insurance company to
prove that driver of offending vehicle had no effective and valid driving licence
at the time of accident. But, in the present case, insurance company has not
produced any document showing that driver of the offending vehicle did not
have any valid and effective driving licence and offending vehicle was being
driven by the driver in contravention of the policy of insurance company. So,
without adducing any evidence, appellant/insurance company is not able to prove
that at the time of accident, the driver of offending vehicle was not having valid
and effective driving licence.
--6-10.
In view of aforesaid discussion, it was not found proved that at the
time of accident, the driver of offending vehicle was not having any valid
and effective licence and offending vehicle was being driven in
contravention of the insurance policy, hence, present appeal being devoid
of merits is hereby dismissed.
(HIRDESH)
JUDGE
N.R.
Digitally signed
by NARENDRA
KUMAR RAIPURIA
Date: 2024.01.27
15:43:48 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review