Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.179
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
AA No.6/2006
Reserved on: 26.02.2026
Pronounced on: 11.03.2026
Uploaded on: 11.03.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Full
M/S National Engineers “Wallia House”
Patel Nagar, Shanker Colony,
Behind Old Sabzi Mandi, Pathankot
through its partner Brij Wallia
S/O H.K Wallia.
…..Petitioners
Through: Mr. R.D.Singh Bandral, Adv.
Vs.
Union of India through
Commander Works Engineer,
Head Quarter 138 works Engineers
C/O 56 APO.
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. Vishal Sharma, DGSI with
Mr. Sumant Sudan, Adv.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
1.
Applicant-M/S National Engineers, through the medium of this
Arbitration Application under Section 34 of the J&K Arbitration & Conciliation
Act, seeks setting aside of award dated 10.08.2005 and communication dated
04.10.2005 on an application moved U/S 33 of the Act, passed by the learned
Sole Arbitrator Col. Balwinder Singh, in Arbitration Application titled
“National Engineers Vs. Commander Works Engineers, HQ 138 Works
Engineeers.” to the extent of non-payment of interest as the petitioner is entitled
to recover interest @ 24 % per annum from the date of completion of contract
agreement.
AA No.06/2006
2.
The facts in brief as narrated in the petition are that:
The petitioner-firm was allotted work vide Contract No.CWE/JP-06/9569
for providing external water lubricant pumps as long term water supply at
Nagrota and a contract agreement was made in this regard. In order to complete
the work within stipulated period, the petitioner, immediately after having the
work order, made preparation by way of mobilizing the requisite resources and
delivered pumps at Nagrota, however, the respondent instead of making payment
to the petitioner started harassing it. The Board of Officers meeting was held on
25.11.1997, who inspected the pumps at site and recommended that the accepting
officer may accept with deviation, as per prevailing practice and directed the
accepting authority to accept these pumps, even then, the payment was not made
which resulted in reference of dispute to the Arbitrator and an amount of
₹5,20,000/- was awarded without interest, which the petitioner received under
protest and filed an application under Section 33 of the Arbitration Act for
correction and interpretation of Award dated 08.09.2005 before the learned
Arbitrator, who corrected the Award, vide communication dated 04.10.2005 to
the extent that the awarded amount may be paid to the petitioner within four
months from the date of receipt of original award, however, interest was not
granted. Feeling aggrieved by the award dated 10.08.2005 and order dated
04.10.2005 passed by the learned Arbitrator, the petitioner has approached this
Court by way of filing instant petition on the strength of averments made in it.
AA No. 06/2006
3.
Upon notice, objecting the petition, respondent has filed the reply on
04.03.2008, stating therein that this petition be rejected being grossly
misconceived as the petitioner prays for grant of interest; that the award dated
10.08.2005 itself is contrary to the terms and conditions of the Agreement.
Respondent further contends that as per the contract agreement, the work was
required to be completed by 02.10.1995 as the provision of water supply was a
time bound and an important work, which petitioner did not complete within
stipulated time and thereafter, the period of contract was extended upto
30.04.1996 and the petitioner even failed to complete the supply of water pumps
of requisite specifications within extended period and his contract was cancelled.
It is further contended that even the modified pumps provided by the petitioner
were not found, as per specification mentioned in the contract agreement.
4.
Respondent also contended that the award passed by the learned
Arbitrator along with order passed under Section 33 of the Arbitration Act is
unsustainable being totally incorrect, arbitrary beyond the scope of reference as
also contrary to law and despite being the fact that petitioner failed to execute the
contract within stipulated time, the learned Arbitrator has awarded an amount of
₹5,20,000/- for which petitioner-firm is not entitled to, thus, according to
respondent, the petitioner is not entitled to the interest component.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, in furtherance to the case set up,
argued that the petitioner is entitled to receive the interest from the date he has
AA No. 06/2006
supplied the water pumps, as per specifications as well as terms and conditions of
the contract, however, the learned Arbitrator without assigning reasons
disallowed the claim of the petitioner qua grant of interest; that due to nonpayment of award, the petitioner has suffered huge losses as the petitioner has
arranged the amount on interest @ 24 % from the market, for procuring the
requisite pumps, thus, petitioner is entitled to interest @ 24% for delay in
payment of the awarded amount; that failure to make payment after completion of
the contract work, the petitioner was forced to file application under Section 33 of
the
J&K
Arbitration
and
Conciliation
Act,
on
08.09.2005
seeking
correction/interpretation of award dated 10.08.2005 along with interest, however,
the said application was disposed of on 04.10.2005, without granting interest.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further contended that Section 31(7)(a)
of the J&K Arbitration and Conciliation Act, provides that unless otherwise
agreed by the parties, where and in so far as arbitral award is for the payment of
money, the arbitral tribunal may include in the sum for which the award is made,
interest at such rate as it deems reasonable, on the whole or any part of the
money, for the whole or any part of the period between the date on which the
cause of action arose and the date on which the award is made. The petitioner
further contended that a sum directed to be paid by an arbitral tribunal award,
shall unless the award otherwise directs, carry interest at the rate of 18 % per
annum, from the date of the award, to the date of payment.
AA No. 06/2006
7.
It is also argued that since there is no such clause incorporated in the
arbitration contract, therefore, the Arbitrator has committed misconduct by not
awarding the interest and observed that claim of the petitioner is partially
sustained and upheld. In support of the petitioner’s case, the learned counsel for
the petitioner, has placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in
‘Secretary, Irrigation Department, Government of Orissa & Ors. V. G C Roy’
reported as 1992 AIR (SC) 732 and in ‘Gayatri Balasamy V. M/S ISG Novasoft
Technologies Limited’ reported as (2025) 7 SCC 1. It was finally prayed that
petition be allowed and interest @18% P.A. be also granted on the awarded
amount passed by the learned Arbitrator.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondent, ex adverso, in furtherance of the
stand taken in the reply, argued vehemently, that the petitioner is not entitled to
receive interest upon the awarded amount, which has also been wrongly awarded
by the learned Arbitrator for the reason that the petitioner had not supplied the
water pumps as per the contract within the specified period and as per the
requisite specifications; that the petitioner had provided water pumps in some
modified forms and despite extension of the time, the petitioner could not stick to
the timeline for providing water pumps which was an urgent matter and
ultimately the contract of the petitioner was cancelled. Therefore, the petitioner
for having not performed his part of the contract well in time is not entitled to
grant of any interest either pendente lite or future and that the learned Arbitrator
AA No. 06/2006
had rightly rejected the same in the impugned award dated 10.08.2005 and also
the communication dated 04.10.2005 on an application seeking modification of
the award for correction and interpretation, in terms of Section 33 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, particularly, refusing the interest.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, pursed the record and considered
their submissions.
10.
The petitioner had been allotted work vide Contract No.CWE/JP-6/95-96
dated 19.05.1995 for providing external water lubricated pumps at long term
water supply at Nagrota, which was followed by a contract agreement; as per the
conditions of the contract agreement, designing, supplying, installing, testing and
commissioning with following specifications:
(a) Deep well forced clear water lubricated vertical turbine pump only,
each having discharge of 62500 G.P.H. and a head of 35 meter
including column pipes, shafts considering 20 hours pumping suitable
for working with existing hollow shaft vertical type squirrel cage
induction motor (Frame V.H-200), 415 volts 3 phase, 50 cycles, 60
HP, 1460 RPM. Suitable for motor of make Kirloskar (Note motor
with starter are already fixed at site).
(b) Taking out/vertical turbine pumps 78 L/S, 35 meter head, oil
lubricating type from intake well at long term water supply lowered
AA No. 06/2006
upto 11 meter including column pipes shaft, bearing holder bowl assy,
stabilizing spider etc, complete with motor 60 HP, 3 phase incl
disconnection of cable connection and depositing only pump alongwith
all accessories (except Electric motor) in the MES store yard of GE
Nagrota all as directed by Engr-in-Charge.
(c) Re-installation of old vertical Hollow shaft Electric motor 3 phase, 415
volts 1460 RPM on the V.T Pump in position and making electric
connection with the Existing cable including provision for fixing
electric motor on discharge head, for an amount of Rs. 5,88,000/-. The
time period for completion of the said works was four months.
11.
On a dispute arising out of the contract, the agreement thereupon and
performance of the contract, the matter was referred to an Arbitral Tribunal of
Col. Balwinder Singh, who after proceeding in the arbitration passed an award
dated 10.08.2005, awarding an amount Rs.5,20,000/-, however, no interest was
granted. The petitioner, on 08.09.2005, moved the learned Arbitrator seeking
interpretation and modification of the award in terms of Section 33 of the Act,
however, vide communication dated 04.10.2005, the Tribunal again did not talk
of any interest component.
12.
Petitioner being not satisfied with the award and the order passed thereon
later whereby interest had not been granted to the petitioner, through the medium
of the instant petition, assailed the impugned award and order/communication on
AA No. 06/2006
the following grounds that the petitioner was entitled to be granted interest as per
statutory provision of Section 31 (7) (a) of the J&K Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, in view of the fact that the parties had not agreed otherwise to the payment of
the interest and the arbitral award being for payment of money, the Arbitral
Tribunal was under an obligation to include, any sum for which award is made,
interest at such rate as it deemed reasonable, on the whole or any part of the
money for the whole or any part of the period between the date on which the
cause of action arose and the date on which the award is made.
13.
The sole Arbitrator vide Award dated 10.08.2005 decided the arbitration
reference and granted an amount of Rs.5,20,000/- to the petitioner. On an
application dated 08.09.2005 seeking interpretation and modification of the award
dated 10.08.2005 with prayer to grant past, pendente lite and future interest gave
clarifications providing that the pumps to be taken by the Department along with
standard guarantee of the manufacturer starting from the handing/taking over
date, for use in future water supply schemes, since original site has been washed
away as recommended by the Board of Officers. Facility to store the pumps will
be provided by the department with double lock system (One lock of each party
duly sealed) and Handing/Taking over to be completed within 02 months from
the date of receipt of award, therefore, an amount of Rs.5,20,000/- was ordered to
be paid to the petitioner by the respondent, within four months from the date of
receipt of the original award. So far as the interest part is concerned in the
AA No. 06/2006
original award dated 10.08.2005, the Tribunal has returned the finding that the
same was not sustained, however, in communication dated 04.10.2005 issued,
pursuant to application filed on 08.09.2005 by the claimant seeking clarification/
interpretation of award dated 10.08.2005, the Arbitrator has not whispered
anything about the interest to which the claimants shall be entitled to.
14.
The question that craves for adjudication by this Court thus is whether a
contractor is entitled to any interest on the awarded arbitral amount, in terms of
Section 31 (7) (a) of the J&K Arbitration and Conciliation Act, which for
reference is extracted as under:
Section 31 - Form and contents of arbitral award
(7) (a) Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, where and
in so
far as an arbitral award is for the payment of
money, the arbitral tribunal may include in the sum for
which the award is made interest, at such rate as it
deems reasonable, on the whole or any part of the
money, for the whole or any part of the period between
the date on which the cause of action arose and the date
on which the award is made.
15.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in a judgment, rendered by Five Judges
Bench in a case titled “Secretary, Irrigation Department & Ors. vs. G.C Roy”,
reported as [1992] 0 AIR (SC) 732, has laid down in paragraph no.47 as follows:
47. The question still remains whether arbitrator has the
power to award interest pendente lite, and if so on
AA No. 06/2006
what principle. We must reiterate that we are dealing
with the situation where the agreement does not
provide for grant of such interest nor does it prohibit
such grant. In other words, we are dealing with a case
where the agreement is silent as to award of interest.
On a conspectus of aforementioned decisions, the
following principles emerge:
(i) A person deprived of the use of money to which he
is legitimately entitled has a right to be
compensated for the deprivation, call it by any
name. It may be called interest, compensation or
damages. This basic consideration is as valid for
the period the dispute is pending before the
arbitrator as it is for the period prior to the
arbitrator entering upon the reference. This is the
principle of Section 34, C.P.C., and there is no
reason or principle to hold otherwise in the case
of arbitration.
(ii) an arbitrator is an alternative form for resolution
of disputes arising between the parties. If so, he
must have the power to decide all the disputes or
differences arising between the parties. If the
arbitrator has no power to award interest
pendente lite, the party claiming it would have to
approach the Court for that purpose, even though
he may have obtained satisfaction in respect of
other claims from the arbitrator. This would lead
to multiplicity of proceedings.
(iii) An arbitrator is the creature of an agreement It is
open to the parties to confer upon him such
AA No. 06/2006
powers and prescribe such procedure for him to
follow, as they think fit, so long as they are not
opposed
to
law.
(The
proviso
to Section
41 and Section 3 of Arbitration Act illustrate this
point). All the same, the agreement must be in
conformity with law. The arbitrator must also act
and make his award in accordance with the
general law of the land and the agreement.
(iv) Over the years, the English and Indian Courts
have acted on the assumption that where the
agreement does not prohibit and a party to the
reference makes a claim for interest, the
arbitrator must have the power to award interest
pendente lite. The award as has not been followed
in the later decisions of this Court. It has been
explained and distinguished on the basis that in
that case there was no claim for interest but only
a claim for unliquidated damages. It has been
said repeatedly that observations in the said
judgment were not intended to lay down any such
absolute or universal rule as they appear to, on
first impression. Until Jena's case almost all the
Courts in the country had upheld the power of the
arbitrator to award interest pendente lite.
Continuity and certainty is a highly desirable
feature of law.
(v) Interest pendente lite is not a matter of substantive
law, like interest for the period anterior to
reference (pre-reference period). For doing
complete justice between the parties, such power
has always been inferred.
AA No. 06/2006
With the aforestated propositions, the court laid down the following correct
principle:
“45. Where the agreement between the parties does not
prohibit grant of interest and where a party claims
interest and that dispute (along with the claim for
principal amount or independently) is referred to the
arbitrator, he shall have the power to award interest
pendente lite. This is for the reason that in such a
case it must be presumed that interest was an
implied term of the agreement between the parties
and therefore when the parties refer all their
disputes – or refer the dispute as to interest as such
to the arbitrator, he shall have the power to award
interest. This does not mean that in every case the
arbitrator
should
necessarily
award
interest
pendente lite. It is a matter within his discretion to
be exercised in the light of all the facts and
circumstances of the case, keeping the ends of
justice in view.”
16.
Hon’ble Supreme Court, in a case titled “Gayatri Balasamy vs. M/S ISG
Novasoft Technologies Limited”, reported as (2025) 7 SCC 1, held in para 72 as
under:
“72. The next question that arises is: do courts possess
the power to declare or modify interest, especially
post award interest? In respect of pendente lite
interest, Section 31(7)(a) (Annexure A), states that
unless otherwise agreed by the parties, the arbitral
tribunal may include in its sum for the award,
AA No. 06/2006
interest, at such rate it deems reasonable on whole
or part of the money for whole or part of the period
on which the cause of action arose and the date on
which the award is made. In respect of post-award
interest, Section 31(7)(b) (Annexure A) states that
unless an award provides for interest on a sum
directed to be paid by it, the sum will carry an
interest at a 2% higher rate than the current rate of
interest prevalent on the date of the award, from the
date of the award till the date of payment. The
explanation defines the expression ‘current rate of
interest”.
17.
The Supreme Court in a case titled “M/S C & C Constructions Ltd. vs.
Ircon International Ltd.”, reported as 2025 Live Law (SC) 148, relied upon by
the respondent, held in paragraph 28 as under:
“28. In the case of Konkan Railway Corporation Limited
v. Chenab Bridge Project Undertaking in paragraph 18,
this court held thus:
“18. At the outset, we may state that the
jurisdiction of the court under Section 37 of
the Act, as clarified by this Court in MMTC
Ltd. v. Vedanta Ltd. [MMTC Ltd. v.
Vedanta Ltd., (2019) 4 SCC 163 : (2019) 2
SCC (Civ) 293] , is akin to the jurisdiction
of the court under Section 34 of the Act. [Id,
SCC p. 167, para 14:
14. As far as interference with an order
made under Section 34, as per
Section 37, is concerned, it cannot
be disputed that such interference
AA No. 06/2006
under Section 37 cannot travel
beyond the restrictions laid down
under Section 34. In other words,
the court cannot undertake an
independent assessment of the
merits of the award, and must only
ascertain that the exercise of power
by the court under Section 34 has
not exceeded the scope of the
provision.”].
Scope of interference by a court in an appeal under
Section 37 of the Act, in examining an order, setting aside
or refusing to set aside an award, is restricted and
subject to the same grounds as the challenge under
Section 34 of the Act.”
18.
The admitted factual position, in the case on hand is that there was no
provision in the agreement, with regard to payment of interest or otherwise, on
the delayed payments, to be made to the contractor. The dispute between the
parties had been referred to the Arbitral Tribunal on 20.01.2003, who answered
the arbitral reference on 10.08.2005, granting the award of Rs.5,20,000/- but with
no interest, as the learned Arbitrator had declaimed the interest, stating ‘Claim
No.3 not sustained”.
19.
It is apparent on the face of the Arbitration Award that the petitioner had
delayed in execution of the contract as the same was to be performed within a
period of four months, but the execution was not only delayed but the Water
Pumps that were supplied were also not of requisite specifications. It appears that
due to these facts in its backdrop, the learned Arbitrator declaimed grant of
interest past or pendetelite and rightly so, due to delay in execution of the contract
AA No. 06/2006
of supply of Water Pumps. The learned Arbitrator, however, did not grant the
pendente lite or future interest as well.
20.
In view of the law laid down by the Apex Court in G C Roy (supra) and
Gayatri Balasamy (supra) wherein it had been held that the arbitrator being a
creature of the agreement, has to act and make his award in accordance with the
general law of the land and the agreement and that all the courts in the country
had held the power of the arbitrator to award interest pendente lite and that
continuity and certainty is a highly desirable feature of law; that in terms of
Section 31 (7) (a) of the J&K Arbitration and Conciliation Act, the interest is
payable on the award, from the date of the award till the date of payment. The
judgment in the case of Ircon International Limited (supra) relied upon by the
respondents is not directly on the point and as such is distinguishable with regard
to powers of the courts under Sections 34 and 37 of the Act differently.
21.
The petitioner was deprived of the use of money, to which it was
legitimately entitled, has a right to be compensated for the deprivation, by
interest, compensation or damages, any name we may call. In the considered
opinion of this court, the Arbitral Tribunal, had inherent powers to compensate
the person, who has been deprived from the use of money, through payment of
interest on the awarded amount for its delayed payment.
22.
Viewed thus, even in absence of any provision in the contract agreement
in respect of interest, the learned Arbitrator was well within the jurisdiction to
award payment of future interest, over the awarded amount, in terms of Section
AA No. 06/2006
31 (7) (a) of the J&K Arbitration and Conciliation Act, as the learned Arbitrator
has fallen in error to refuse grant of interest to the petitioner.
23.
Having regard to the foregoing reasons and the observations made
hereinabove, this court is of the considered opinion that petitioner is entitled to
receive future interest on the awarded amount, from the date of Award passed by
the learned Arbitrator i.e. on August 10, 2005, till the satisfaction of the award.
24.
Viewed thus, the petition is disposed of as allowed, with modification of
the impugned award, that the awarded amount shall be paid to the petitioner along
with future simple interest @ 10% P.A. from 10.08.2005, until the whole of the
amount is paid after adjustment of the amount paid, if any, to the petitioner. No
order as to costs.
25.
The Arbitration Application, is thus disposed of as granted, alongwith
pending application(s).
(M A Chowdhary)
Judge
JAMMU
11.03.2026
Raj Kumar
Whether order is speaking: Yes/No
Whether order is reportable: Yes/No
Raj Kumar
2026.03.11 17:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
AA No. 06/2006
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review