The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 07.2001. However, the petitioners have contended that the select list was neither published in any newspaper nor displayed on the notice board. The petitioners have challenged the select list primarily on the ground that the entire selection process is arbitrary, unfair, and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. They have pleaded that despite having qualified and performed well, they were ignored without justification. They have pointed out that the selected candidates lacked prior Court experience and knowledge of Urdu, which is essential for subordinate court work, whereas petitioners Nos.1 and 2 possessed such experience and knowledge. Another ground of challenge is that the inordinate delay between the advertisement and the select list, renders the selection process doubtful.A specific challenge has been raised regarding the jurisdiction of the appointing authority. Reliance has been placed on Section 30(1) of the Civil Courts Act, which confers the power of appointment of ministerial officers upon the District Judge, subject to the control of the High Court under Section 30(4). The petitioners have contended that the High Court, being merely a controlling authority, could not have assumed the role of the appointing authority. They have argued that since the District Judge did not participate in the selection process, the entire selection stands viti…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
SWP No.1957/2001 c/w
SWP No.2190/2001&
SWP No.2206/2001
Reserved on: 26.02.2026
Pronounced on: 25 .03. 2026
Uploaded on: 27.03.2026
whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:Full
Nath Singh and others
Prem Nath and another
Suraj Parkash
Petitioners
Through: - Ms. Radha Sharma Advocate.
vs
High Court of J&K and Ladakh and others
…Respondent(s)
Through: - Mr. R.K.Gupta Sr. Advcoate with
Mr. Udhay Bhasker Advocate.
Mr. H.A.Siddiqui Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR,JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjeev Kumar, J
SWP No.2190/2001 & SWP No.2206/2001
The petitioners
do not wish to press these writ petitions.
Accordingly, both the writ petitions stand dismissed as not pressed.
SWP No.1957/2001
The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioners under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ of
certiorari for quashing the impugned select list dated 19.07.2001 issued
for the post of Junior Assistant in the Subordinate Courts by respondent
No.2 on the recommendation of the Selection Committee. The
petitioners have also prayed for a writ of mandamus directing
respondent Nos.1 and 2 to consider their candidature for the said post
strictly in accordance with the applicable rules and regulations.
Briefly stated, the case set up by the petitioners is that vide
Advertisement Notification dated 07.04.1997, applications were invited
from eligible candidates possessing the qualification of 10+2 or its
equivalent. The last date for submission was extended vide notice dated
24.02.1998. The petitioners submitted their applications, appeared in
the written examination, and qualified. They were subsequently called
for a viva voce test conducted at the High Court at Jammu. According
to the petitioners, they performed well in the interview.It is further
pleaded that respondent No.2 issued individual appointment orders on
19.07.2001. However, the petitioners have contended that the select list
was neither published in any newspaper nor displayed on the notice
board.
The petitioners have challenged the select list primarily on
the ground that the entire selection process is arbitrary, unfair, and
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. They have
pleaded that despite having qualified and performed well, they were
ignored without justification. They have pointed out that the selected
candidates lacked prior Court experience and knowledge of Urdu,
which is essential for subordinate court work, whereas petitioners
Nos.1 and 2 possessed such experience and knowledge. Another
ground of challenge is that the inordinate delay between the
advertisement and the select list, renders the selection process
doubtful.A specific challenge has been raised regarding the jurisdiction
of the appointing authority. Reliance has been placed on Section 30(1)
of the Civil Courts Act, which confers the power of appointment of
ministerial officers upon the District Judge, subject to the control of the
High Court under Section 30(4). The petitioners have contended that
the High Court, being merely a controlling authority, could not have
assumed the role of the appointing authority. They have argued that
since the District Judge did not participate in the selection process, the
entire selection stands vitiated due to lack of jurisdiction.
Objections have been filed on behalf of respondent Nos.1
to 3. It is stated that the petitioners, having failed to secure merit in
selection, have filed the present petition on imaginary grounds. The
respondents have contended that the selection was fair, transparent, and
based on merit. With regard to the availability of records, the Registrar
Vigilance have reported that the record pertaining to the selection was
submitted to the Committee but is not traceable in the office. Despite
summoning the record keeper, the record could not be found.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material on record.
The case history shows that there has been a long delay in
deciding the matter. The writ petition was admitted on 20.02.2002.
Over the years, the case moved from a Single Judge to a Division
Bench. Vide order dated 28.12.2016, the Registrar General was
directed to trace the missing record. On 14.03.2017, learned counsel for
the petitioners alleged serious irregularities, including the selection of
underage and overage candidates, as well as candidates with criminal
antecedents, and undertook to file an affidavit. The petitioners
subsequently filed a supplementary affidavit. However, in the order
dated 31.03.2018, it is recorded that the selection record was not
available despite efforts. The respondents reiterated the same position
in respect of selection record even during hearing of this petition.
From a perusal of the communication dated 19.10.2016, it
is confirmed that the record is not traceable. Despite repeated
directions, the record has not been found. In the absence of the record,
the Court is constrained to rely on the pleadings and affidavits on
record.
At this stage, it is pertinent to note that except petitioner
Nath Singh, all co-petitioners do not wish to press the petition. Their
petitions are dismissed as not pressed.
The only remaining petitioner, Nath Singh, was about 35
years old when the writ petition was filed and is now nearly 60 years
old. Even if the petitioner’s claim is accepted as correct, it is not
possible to grant him relief sought for. The Court cannot ignore the fact
that the selection took place in 2001 and the selected candidates have
been in service for more than twenty years. It has also been brought to
the notice of the Court that some of the selected candidates have even
passed away, while some have already retired. In these circumstances,
it would not be practical or fair to cancel the entire selection at such a
belated stage that too on the solitary ground that the selection record is
not traceable and, therefore, allegations made by the petitioner should
be presumed to be correct. The selection was completed long ago, and
therefore, this Court is unable to grant any relief to the petitioner. The
petition has virtually become a fait accompli.
The petitioner, having participated in the selection process,
is estopped from challenging the jurisdiction of the selection committee
constituted by the High Court to conduct the selection after finding that
he has not made it to the selection.
The
petitioner
has
made
general
allegations
of
arbitrariness and mala fides. The law relating to allegations of mala
fides is well settled. In E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu, (1974)
4 SCC 3, the Supreme Court has held that allegations of mala fides
require a high standard of proof and specific pleadings naming the
persons who acted with bias. Vague allegations are insufficient. In the
present case, the petitioner has failed to implead the persons against
whom mala fides are alleged, nor has he placed any concrete material
to substantiate such claims. It would be appropriate to reproduce
Paragraph 92 to the aforesaid extent, which is reproduced as under:
<Secondly, we must not also overlook that the burden of
establishing mala fides in very heavy on the person who
alleges it. the allegations of mala fides are often more
easily made than proved, and the very seriousness of such
allegations demands proof of a high order of credibility.
Here the petitioner, who was himself once the Chief
Secretary, has flung a series of charges of oblique
conduct against the Chief Minister. That is in itself a
rather extra-ordinary and unusual occurrence and if these
charges are true, they are bound to shake the confidence
of the people in the political custodians of power in the
State, and therefore, the anxiety of the Court should be all
the greater to insist on a high degree of proof. In this
context it may be noted that top administrators arc often
required to do acts which affect others adversely but
which are necessary in the execution of their duties.
These acts may land themselves to misconstruction and
suspicion as to the bona fide of their author when the full
facts and surrounding circumstances are not known. The
Court would, therefor be slow to draw dubious inferences
from incomplete facts placed before it by a party,,
particularly when the imputations are grave and they are
made against the holder of an office which has a high
responsibility in the administration. Such is the judicial
perspective in evaluating charges of unworthy conduct
against ministers and other high authorities, not because
of any special status which they are supposed to enjoy,
nor because they are highly placed in social' life or
administrative set up these. considerations are wholly
irrelevant in judicial approach but because, otherwise,
functioning effective y would become difficult in a
democracy. It is from this stand point that we must assess
that merits of the allegations of mala fides made by the
petitioner against the second respondent=.
It is also well settled that a candidate who participates in a
selection process without protest cannot subsequently challenge it after
being unsuccessful. Reference is made to Rekha Sharma vs.
Rajasthan High Court (2024 ) SCC Online SC 2109. It would be
appropriate to reproduce Paragraph 92 of the said judgment to the
aforesaid extent, which is reproduced as under:
<As well settled, the candidates who consciously took
part in the process of selection cannot be permitted to
question the advertisement or the methodology adopted
by the respondents for making selection, on their having
been declared as unsuccessful in the Preliminary
Examinations. The appellants after they having found that
their names do not appear in the list of successful
candidates of Preliminary 11 Examination, could not
have questioned the result on the ground that the
respondents had not declared the cut off marks for the
Persons with benchmark disabilities. As stated earlier, the
respondents have declared the cut off marks for the
persons falling under Compartmentalised Horizontal
Reservation and not for the Overall Horizontal
Reservation under which the appellants fall. Such action
could neither be said to be arbitrary nor violative of
Article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India=.
The petitioner has admittedly participated in the entire
process without raising any objection regarding the composition of the
Committee or the lack of Urdu knowledge at the relevant time. Another
significant aspect is the extraordinary lapse of time. Inordinate delay,
which of course, is not attributable to the petitioner, is another aspect
which cannot be ignored. As a result of this delay in disposal of the
case, the selected/appointed candidates have been in service for more
than two decades. Even the qualifications for the posts have been
revised to graduation with knowledge of computer typing.
For the foregoing reasons, we do not find it a fit case for
interference with the selection and appointments made more than 24
years back. The petition has become a fait accompli and is, therefore,
dismissed.
(SANJAY PARIHAR)
JUDGE
(SANJEEV KUMAR)
JUDGE
Jammu
25.03.2026
Sanjeev
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable:Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review