Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.377 of 2023
Sri Nataraj Datta,
S/O- Late Nirad Ranjan Datta,
Resident of -19, Shibnagar, Santi
Para, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin 799001, Age -64 years
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura
(To be represented by the Secretary cum
Commissioner,
Department
of
Science,
Technology and Environment, Government of
Tripura), New Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S -New Capital
complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799010
2.
The Secretary
Department of Finance, Government of
Tripura , New Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S - New
Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799010
3.
The Director
Department of Science, Technology and
Environment, Govt. of Tripura, Vigyan
Bhavan,
Gorkhabasti,
PN
Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799006
4.
Tripura State Council for Science and
Technology
represented by it's Member Secretary,
Department of Science, Technology and
Environment, PN Complex, Vigyanbhavan,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799006.
5.
The Joint Member Secretary
Tripura State Council for Science and
Technology, Department of Science,
Technology
and
Environment,
PN
Complex Vigyan Bhavan, Gorkhabasti
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin -799006
6.
Life Insurance Corporation of India
To be represented by the Manager I /C,
(Pension and Group Schemes) Silchar
Divisional Office, Meherpur, P.O- Silchar,
District -Cachar, Assam-788015
……… Petitioner(s)
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner (s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samar Das, Adv.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
:
30.11.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
08.01.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The petitioner, joined in the post of Research Officer
[Engineering]
under
the
Tripura
State
Council
for
Science
&
Technology [in short, the State Council], a society registered under
the Societies Registration Act, 1860 in the Department of Science,
Technology and Environment on 30.11.1987. He later on got
promotion to the post of Principal Scientific Officer (Space Application)
w.e.f.
21.11.2012
and
ultimately
retired
from
the
service
on
31.10.2019. As averred, when he was in service, the State Council in
its meeting of Executive Committee passed resolution on 22.12.2015,
that a Trust would be formed comprising of Joint Member Secretary of
the State Council, Joint Director, Department of Science, Technology
and Environment, Government of Tripura i.e. DDO & HOO of the State
Council and the Accounts Officer to manage LICI Linked Defined
Benefit Pension Scheme w.e.f. 01.01.2016.
[2]
Accordingly, a Deed of Trust was executed on 27.01.2016
between the State Council and the Joint Member Secretary of the
State Council. Some terms and conditions of the said Trust relevant to
the issues involved in this writ petition are highlighted below:
***
***
*****
Trust
Irrecoverable
These presents shall constitute a Trust
upon which Trust shall be irrevocable in
India. No moneys belonging to the Scheme
in the hands of the Trustees shall be
recoverable by the Employer nor shall the
Employer have any lien or change of any
description on the Scheme.
Employer to
make
contributions
The Employer agrees to make the
contributions to the Trustees as provided
in the Rules and the Trustees shall utilise
the same for paying premium under the
aforesaid Master Policy.
Power to
Amend the
Scheme
The Trustees may at any time by a
resolution in writing signed by not less
than two of them and with the consent in
writing of the employer as also of the LIICI
where the variations have a bearing on the
terms and conditions of the Master Policy
effected with the LICI but not otherwise
alter, vary or amend any of the trusts or
provisions of this Deed and the Rules.
PROVIDED THAT no such alterations or
variations shall be inconsistent with the
main objects of the trust hereby created
nor shall such alterations or variations in
any way prejudice the rights or interests of
the Member or his Beneficiaries.
Employer’s
Right to
amend
Scheme
(a) (i) The Employer may also at any
time give three months notice in
writing to the Trustees, of its
intention to amend the scheme and
it shall be lawful for the Trustees to
give effect to such amendment or
alteration. Such amendment shall
ordinarily have effect from the
anniversary
of
the
date
of
commencement
of
the
Scheme
which next follows the date on
which the notice has been served.
(ii) Any amendment shall not effect
the benefits already secured for
Members under the Rules and more
particularly by the premiums paid to
the LICI upto the date of such
amendment.
Provision of
Pension
On behalf of the Employer the Trustees
shall provide fund for the payment of
pension in defined benefit mode for the
Members or for their Beneficiaries as the
case may be, by entering into a Scheme
with the LICI. The Trustees shall be
responsible for deduction of Income Tax
chargeable on any payment made by them
to any member or his Beneficiary and shall
deduct the relevant tax or duty therefrom
and account for the same to the
government of India.
Termination
of Trust
[3]
(i)
Winding up of the Employees’
establishment(Unless
such
winding up The trust Fund hereof
shall be wound up only on the is
for the purpose of amalgamation,
reconstitution or reconstruction).
Application
for
approval
of
winding up of the fund shall be
made within reasonable time but
not exceeding six months of
winding
up
of
the
council/Establishment.
(ii)
Upon the winding up of the Trust
Fund, the Trustees shall, after
obtaining prior permission from
the
Employer
make
such
arrangement with the LICI as to
provide in the first instance, for
the payment of pension in
respect of the Members or the
Beneficiaries (i) who are already
in receipt of pensions under the
Master Policy before the date of
winding up and (ii) who have
become
entitled
to
receive
specified amounts of pension and
other from a future date by
reason of the exercise of the
option to receive such deferred
benefits.
The
Trustees
shall
utilize the amount standing to
their credit
in the running
account
held
by
LICI
in
proportion
to
the
benefits
accrued for the Members on the
date of winding up for securing
pensions and other benefits of
the same nature as specified in
these Rules to such persons as
may then be Members of the
Scheme or to their Beneficiaries,
as the case may be, irrespective
of whether or not such members
of Beneficiaries have become
entitled to the benefits under the
Scheme.
From the said Deed of Trust, it appears that the basic
object of the trust was for making provisions for some post retirement
benefits for employees the State Council upon their retirement from
service or upon earlier cessation of service or in the event of their
death, for their wives/husband, children or dependents and to set up
non-contributory superannuation scheme for them. At the time of
execution of said Deed of Trust, ‘Rules of the State Council Employees
Group Superannuation Scheme for Defenied Pensionary Benefit to the
Employees of the State Council For Science and Technology’ were also
framed. Following 03 Nos. of LICI scheme were also introduced
thereby w.e.f. 01.01.2016 after Finance Department concurred for the
same vide no. 1208/FIN(G)/15 dated 04,11,2015 as evident from the
Annexure-3 of the writ petition:
[4]
i)
Leave
Encashment
Encashment Scheme),
(Employees
Group
Leave
ii)
Death cum Retirement Gratuity (Employees Group
Gratuity Assurance Scheme),
iii)
Pension (Employees Group Superannuation Scheme).
This way the EPF Pension Scheme as was prevalent at that
time was discontinued and as alleged, the petitioner exercised his
option in favour of the above said Defined Benefit Pension Scheme. It
was the grievance of the petitioner that after his retirement he was
not given full and final payment of all post-retirement benefits based
on said Deed of Trust or the amount payable under said defined
schemes of LICI.
[5]
Meanwhile,
the
Finance
Department,
Government
of
Tripura issued Memorandum No. F.4(246)DSTE/Estt./Pt.-III/5566-70
dated 07.08.2017 making certain observations on above said schemes
and thereafter the Special Secretary, Science, Technology and
Environment Department communicated the following observations
and directed to revise the calculation sheet of the premium accrued
with the LIC based schemes:
[i] Pension may be calculated @50% of last basic pay
drawn without considering DA.
[ii] Family Pension may be calculated @50% of last basic
pension drawn (without dearness relief).
[iii] No lumpsum amount/corpus shall be returned to the
nominee on death of pensioner. The lumpsum amount, if
any, may be added to the Corpus Fund so that the volume
of the same increase and after a certain period of time
there
will
be
no
requirement
for
payment
of
premium/current service cost.
[iv] Insurance coverage shall not be applicable.
[v] Gratuity may be calculated on Basic Pay and length of
service only.
[vi] Benefit of encashment of leave to the credit of the
employee to the maximum of 300 days shall be subject to
adoption of the same in respect of the autonomous bodies
of ST &E Department.
[6]
Thereafter, vide letter dated 26.12.2019 [Annexure-4 of
the writ petition], i.e. after the retirement of the petitioner, the Joint
Member Secretary of the State Council informed the LICI that in
pursuance of the instruction of the Finance Department, the above
said 3[three] LICI Schemes were to be discontinued. While the
petitioner was in service, two departmental proceedings were initiated
against him, which were challenged by him in W.P.(C) No.90 of 2020
with further challenge of the matter of discontinuation of said Pension
Scheme but the High Court by order dated 05.02.2020 [Annexure-6
of the writ petition] observed that the matter of discontinuation of
Pension Scheme was completely unrelated with the disputed issues
involved in that writ petition and therefore, liberty was given to the
petitioner to file separate petition for said purpose.
[7]
The petitioner subsequently filed writ petition bearing
W.P.(C) No.150 of 2020 regarding claim of such post-retirement
benefits based on such LICI Retirement Scheme which was disposed
of by the learned Single Judge on 11.08.2022 with the following
observations:
In my opinion, considering the fact that the entire
property was entrusted to the Trust, the Council being the
establishment of this Government of Tripura cannot put
any restriction asking the LICI not to release pensionary
benefits in favour of the retired employees. It is the Trust
and the Trust alone who can impose such restriction upon
the LICI.
Furthermore, it comes to fore that before forming Trust
and the agreement with LICI, the retired employees of
the Council including the petitioner was under EPF
scheme. Such EPF scheme was closed by the Council on
the pretext that the contribution would be deposited to
the LICI and the employees would get pension as per the
new scheme. Due to such closer of scheme and switching
over to pension scheme, and thereafter non-payment of
pensionary benefits under the scheme to the retired
employees is illegal and arbitrary.
Learned Government Advocate appearing for the Council
has failed to inform this court as regards the fate of the
employees after retirement. The legitimate right of the
retired employees, in my opinion, cannot be taken away
by the Council-respondent in the manner it issued the
impugned letter dated 26.12.2019 asking the LICI for
discontinuing the policy mentioned in the said letter for
granting pension to the retired employees of the Counsel
is detrimental to the interest of the retired employees
without making any alternative arrangement for
providing retiral benefits in favour of the retired
employees like the petitioner.
In view of the above, and since the Trust has not taken
any decision in this regard, I direct the LICI to release the
pension alongwith all statutory benefits in favour of the
petitioner in consonance with his entitlement of such
pension as per the scheme.
It is directed that the Council shall initiate or facilitate the
process of granting such pension with all statutory
benefits to the petitioner by the LICI within a period of 2
(two) months from the date of receipt of this order.
However, the Council-respondent has every right to make
appropriate provision for providing appropriate retiral
benefits to its retired employees with the established
principle of law and till then the impugned decision
communicated vide letter dated 26.12.2019 to the LICI
would have no force in the eye of law.
With the aforesaid direction, the instant petition stands
allowed and disposed.
[8]
It is the further grievance of the petitioner that despite the
order passed in the said writ petition being W.P.(C) No.150 of 2020
extracted hereinabove, the respondents did not comply with said
directions of the High Court in time bound manner for which he filed
contempt proceeding bearing Contempt Case (C) No.142 of 2022 and
during pendency of such contempt proceeding, the State Council
accorded sanction of Rs.13,69,000/- as leave encashment and
Rs.4,00,000/- as gratuity in favour of the petitioner though according
to him, he was entitled to the gratuity amount of Rs.21,08,000/-. Said
contempt petition was disposed of by the learned Single Judge vide
order dated 24.03.2023 with the following observation:
Taking note of the affidavit sworn by the respondentcontemnors, Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for
the petitioner has submitted that the respondentcontemnors have not implemented the order what is
required to be complied with under the said order.
According to Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for
the petitioner, the order has partially been complied with,
but not in whole.
In this situation, if, according to the petitioner, the order
has not been complied with wholly, the petitioner may file
a representation to the competent authority ventilating
his grievance and his further entitlement within 2(two)
weeks from today.
After receipt of the said representation, the competent
authority shall reconsider and dispose of the same with
speaking order in accordance with rules within a period of
2(two) months and inform the petitioner accordingly.
In view of the above observation and directions, this
contempt application stands closed.
[9]
Meanwhile, vide letter dated 18.03.2023 [Annexure-15 of
the writ petition], the Head of Office & DDO of the Sate Council sent a
letter to the LICI enclosing a ‘Deed of Variance’ which was executed in
connection the Group Superannuation Scheme for Defined Pensionary
Benefit to the employees of the State Council and therefore, LICI was
requested to amend the provision of the master policy, namely LIC’s
New Group Superannuation Cash Accumulation Plan in line with the
provision of Deed of Variance and also simultaneously requested the
LICI
to release the monthly pension of the petitioner as per the
amended policy. Vide sanction memo dated 22.03.2023 [Annexure-16
of the writ petition] the State Council also sanctioned monthly arrear
pension of the petitioner to the tune of Rs.16,42,800/- for the period
from 01.11.2019 to 28.02.2023 @ Rs.41,070/- per month [60% of
admissible
Pension
of
Rs.68,450/-]
provisionally
subject
to
finalisation of commutation of pension on receipt of the option of the
writ petitioner for commutation as per terms of ‘Deed of Variance’.
The Trustee of State Council also communicated a letter of request
dated 31.03.2023 [Annexure 18 of the writ petition] to the LICI to
release monthly pension @ Rs.41,070/- to the petitioner for the
month of March, 2023.
[10]
The petitioner in terms of the order dated 24.03.2023
passed in the said contempt proceedings submitted representation on
30.03.2023 and then on 17.04.2023 to the Member Secretary of the
State Council claiming further amount under post-retirement benefits
as per the original Deed of Trust.
[11]
In turn, the Joint Member Secretary of the State Council
vide letter dated 25.05.2023 [Annexure-23 of the writ petition]
informed the petitioner that in view of the judgment of W.P.(C)
No.150 of 2020, amendment proposal as per observation of the
Finance Department, Government Tripura and subsequent revision
proposal, a Deed of Variance was executed by the Trustee of the State
Council to provide retrial benefits to its employee at par with the
benefits of the State Government employees and therefore, the
petitioner being the retired employee of the State Council provisions
have been made to provide him retiral benefits at par with the State
Government employees under the amended LICI Scheme for which
Deed of Variance had already been registered.
[12]
Finally, being aggrieved by the said action of the respondents,
the petitioner has approached the writ jurisdiction of this court again
seeking the following reliefs:
i. Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to sanction and release regular monthly
pension, leave encashment benefit and other pensionary
benefits to the Petitioner, in terms of Defined Benefit
Pension Scheme (Trust Deed), as has been affirmed and
settled by the Hon’ble High Court, vide Order, dated,
11.08.2022, passed in WPC No-150 of 2022.
ii. Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby quash and
cancel the letter, dated, 18.03.2023, issued by the HoO &
DDO, TSCST and communicated to the Br. Manager, P &
GS Unit, LICI. (Annexure- 15 to the writ petition).
iii. Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby quashing and
cancelling the letter, dated, 25.05.2023, issued by the
Joint Member Secretary, TSCST, (Annexure- 23 to the writ
petition).
iv. Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to act in compliance with the Order, dated,
11.08.2022, passed by the Hon’ble High Court in WPC NO150/2020.
v. Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby declaring
that, the pensionary benefits of the Petitioner is covered
under Trust Deed (Defined benefit pension Scheme) and
the Deed of Variance has no manner of application so far
determining the post retiral benefits of the Petitioner is
concerned.
vi. Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby directing the
Respondents to refix & release all pensionary benefits of
the Petitioner with 9% interest on the basis of trust deed,
which was in force at the time of retirement of the
Petitioner on superannuation.
vii. Make the rules absolute,
viii. Call for records,
[13]
The core issue involved in this writ petition is that whether
the post-retirement benefits of the petitioner should be paid as per
the benefits as provided in the original Deed of Trust and LICI
Schemes subscribed thereupon or as per the terms of Deed of
Variation. Admittedly, the Deed of Variation was executed after the
retirement of the petitioner.
[14]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioner strenuously argued that no retrospective effect of the
said Deed of Variance could be given to the deprivation of the
petitioner as already option was taken by the department from the
petitioner to be governed by the terms and conditions of the trust and
therefore, rule of promissory estoppel will be applicable in this case.
According to Mr. Roy Barman, even the original terms and conditions
regarding post-retirement benefits were varied later on as per the
instructions of the Finance Department, same cannot be made
applicable in case of the petitioner as he retired prior to execution of
said deed of variance. According to him, intentionally the State
Council is causing delay to provide full benefits under original Defined
Benefit Pension Scheme to the petitioner to his serious financial loss
and harassment.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel further
argued that the details of LICI Linked Terminal Benefit Schemes as
were introduced through the said trust was duly informed to the
Finance Department by the State Council vide letter dated 13.12.2018
[Annexure-R/3 of the counter affidavit of the respondent Nos.4 & 5]
and therefore, the Finance Department had full knowledge of the
same. According to Mr. Roy Barman, when a trust is created, Finance
Department cannot have any dominion over the trust property, rather
the Trustee will only have the full authority and control over such
property.
[15]
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel while arguing that
the rule of promissory estoppel is applicable in the instant case, relied
on a decision of the Apex Court in Lal Ram Vs. Jaipur Development
Authority, (2016) 11 SCC 31 wherein at para 131 the following
preconditions were laid down by the Apex Court to apply such
principle in case of government:
(a) A clear and unequivocal promise, knowing and intending
that it would be acted upon by the promisee;
(b) On such acting upon the promise by the promisee, it would
be inequitable to allow the promisor to go back on the
promise.
[16]
In Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. and others etc. versus
M/S Tata Communications Ltd. etc. [Civil Appeal No.1699-1723
of 2015], as further relied upon by Mr. Roy Barman, Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed the followings:
The power to make retrospective legislations enables the
Legislature to obliterate an amending Act completely and
restore the law as it existed before the amending Act, but
at the same time, administrative/executive orders or
circulars, as the case may be, in the absence of any
legislative competence cannot be made applicable with
retrospective
effect.
Only
law
could
be
made
retrospectively if it was expressly provided by the
Legislature in the statute.
[17]
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel also referred
another decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the State of
Jharkhand and Ors. vs. Brahmputra Metallics Ltd. and Ors.,
[decided on 01.12.2020 in Civil Appeal Nos.3860-3862 of 2020],
wherein law relating to promissory estoppel and doctrine of ‘legitimate
expectation’ were discussed in details. At Para-31 it was observed
that India has adopted a more expansive statement of the doctrine of
promissory
estoppels
and
the
court
has
given
an
expansive
interpretation to the doctrine of promissory estoppel in order to
remedy the injustice being done to a party who has relied on a
promise.
[18]
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel appearing for
the respondents No.4 & 5 argued that the State Government had
made certain observation for correction of the Deed of Trust and
accordingly, same was done and the petitioner himself being a person
holding responsible post in the State Council was under obligation for
proper implementation of actual object of the scheme and the
directions of the Government. Mr. Bhattacharya further added that
the petitioner did not challenge the Deed of Variation in the present
writ petition and therefore, cannot argue on the validity of such Deed
of Variance. Mr. Bhattacharya also pointed out that the instructions of
the Finance Department for correction of the original Deed of Trust
was prior to the retirement of the petitioner and basic fund flow for
implementation of the schemes in the State Council was sourced from
Finance Department and therefore, without approval of Finance
Department or in disobedience to their instructions, it is/was not
possible to extent any sort of benefit to any employee of the State
Council. Mr. Bhattacharya referring to Annexure-R/3 of the counter
affidavit of respondents No.4 & 5 i.e. the letter dated 13.12.2018
issued by Senior Scientific Officer of the State Council to the Finance
Department enclosing the details of LICI Linked Terminal Benefit
Scheme, submitted that the same was issued after the Finance
Department had issued such instructions and the present writ
petitioner was also signatory in the said letter which was issued in
dire disregards to the instruction of Finance Department. Therefore,
when the observation of the Finance Department was in existence, no
entitlement of the petitioner accrued as per the previous scheme.
[19]
Mr. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel strongly refuted
the claim of the petitioner by further submitting that earlier the writ
court did not settle the issue that the petitioner was entitled to get
the post-retirement benefits as per the old scheme. According to him,
retrospective effect of rules is permissible when the total scheme
became unsettled after the observations of the Finance Department
and later on, same was settled by an execution of Deed of Variance.
Next point, he argued, was that the implementation of any scheme
introduced has always bearing upon the fund flow as received from
the State Government and therefore, granting of any benefit based on
trust was not permissible. He further argued that as per the earlier
scheme there was no scope for payment of any gratuity and that has
been brought only through the new scheme. Mr. Bhattacharjee,
learned senior counsel also referred some portion of the observation
of the Writ Court in W.P.(C) No.150 of 2020 to the effect that the
State Council has every right to make appropriate provision for
providing appropriate retiral benefits to its retired employees with the
established principle of law and till then the impugned decision
communicated vide letter dated 26.12.2019 to the LICI would have no
force in the eye of law.
[20]
To buttress his submission that the department has
properly implemented such direction of the court by way of execution
of said Deed of Variance, finally, Mr. Bhattacharya, learned senior
counsel argued that despite instruction of Finance Department issued
in the year 2017, the petitioner deliberately caused delay in
processing the file to get higher benefits after his retirement and
therefore, he is not entitled to any relief as claimed.
[21]
Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the
respondents No.1,2 & 3 also argued that the Deed of Trust was not
final rather only starting phase of the process, subject to clearance
by the Finance Department and Department of Science, Technology
and Environment which got the final shape by way of execution of
Deed of Variance and the petitioner had full knowledge of the entire
process as he worked in different posts in the State Council. More so,
any rules/scheme created by any department is subject to the
approval of the Finance Department of the State and therefore,
according to him also, the petitioner is not entitled to get any post
retirement benefit as per the previous scheme.
[22]
As discussed in details above, the Deed of Trust was
created in pursuance of the concurrence of Finance Department
issued vide No.1208/FIN(G)/15
dated 04.11.2015 followed by the
decision of the Executive Committee of the State Council and 3[three]
different scheme viz. Leave Encashment (Employees Group Leave
Encashment Scheme), Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity (Employees
Group Gratuity Assurance Scheme) and Pension (Employees Group
Superannuation
Scheme)
were
introduced
through
LICI
w.e.f.
01.01.2016 as revealed from Annexure-3 of the writ petition. Option
was also obtained from the employees of the State Council and the
petitioner accordingly opted for coverage under those schemes
leaving the EPF Scheme discontinued.
[23]
Accordingly, Deed of Trust was also executed which was
made irrevocable as indicated above, having certain powers to amend
the scheme. Certain rules namely, Rules of Tripura State Council for
Science,
Technology
and
Environment
Employees
Group
Superannuation Scheme for Defined Pensionary benefit
to the
employees of Tripura State Council for Science and Technology were
also framed which also made certain provisions for benefits of the
employees on their normal retirement like commutation of pension
etc.
[24]
Taking of option from the petitioner to come under the
coverage of said schemes, was an implied promise of the employer
giving rise to a legitimate expectation in the mind of the petitioner
that he would be governed by the said scheme and would get all the
benefits under the said scheme on his retirement.
[25]
In National Buildings Construction Corporation vs. S.
Raghunathan and others, reported in (1998) 7 SCC 66, it was
observed by the Apex Court that the doctrine of "Legitimate
Expectation" has its genesis in the field of administrative law. The
Government and its departments, in administering the affairs of the
country, are expected to honour their statements of policy or
intention and treat the citizens with full personal consideration without
any iota of abuse of discretion. The policy statements cannot be
disregarded unfairly or applied selectively.
[26]
Already in earlier writ petition bearing No. W.P.(C) No.150
of 2020, the disputed issues were dealt with by a coequal Bench and
it was held that the entire property was entrusted to the trust, the
council being the establishment of the Government of Tripura cannot
put any restrictions asking the LICI not to release pensionary benefits
in favour of the retired employees. It was also observed that earlier
the EPF Scheme was closed on the pretext that the contribution would
be deposited to the LICI and employees would get pension as per the
new scheme. Therefore, non-payment of pensionary benefits under
said new scheme was illegal and arbitrary. The letter dated
26.12.2019 [Annexure-4 of the writ petition] issued to LICI regarding
discontinuation of said 3[three] LICI Schemes was also held to be
detrimental to the interest of the retired employees without making
any alternative arrangement for providing retiral benefits in favour of
the retired employees like petitioner and accordingly, LICI was
directed to release the pension along with all statutory benefits in
favour of the petitioner in consonance with his entitlement as per that
scheme. But as it appears, just by highlighting and giving over
emphasis on some portion of observations of that Bench that the
Council-respondents have every right to make appropriate provisions
for providing appropriate retiral benefits to its retired employees with
the established principle of law, the respondents have attempted to
bring the present petitioner under coverage of the benefits available
under the Deed of Variance, which is not permissible at law.
[27]
The Apex Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. (supra)
has already held that any Government circular/order cannot be given
retrospective effect. Therefore, the Deed of Variance cannot be
allowed to be applied retrospectively upon the petitioner by the
respondents. As per enclosure R/3 of the counter affidavit as indicated
above, under the previous scheme total 39 numbers of employees
were
covered
and
till
13.12.2018
total
financial
benefits
of
Rs.88,87,169/- was provided to the employees under the said
scheme. Therefore, the petitioner cannot be allowed to be treated
arbitrarily and inequally with other retired employees who have been
already provided such benefits under the previous scheme. Indeed
there is no dispute that the fund flow is sourced from the state
exchequer and therefore, the respondents have their every right to
make appropriate provisions for providing retiral benefits to the
employees of the State Council but after such new provisions are
made by the respondents, same cannot be applied retrospectively.
[28]
In view of above, the writ petition is allowed. It is held that
the post-retiral benefits of the petitioner will be guided by the scheme
under the Deed of Trust i.e. LICI Linked Terminal Benefit Scheme as
was introduced from 01.01.2016 and therefore, the petitioner will be
entitled post-retiral benefits as per above said 3[three] schemes of
LICI i.e. LIC’s New Group Gratuity Cash Accumulation Plan, LIC’s New
Group Leave Encashment Plan and LIC’s New Group Superannuation
Cash Accumulation Plan. It is also held that the Deed of Variance will
have no retrospective effect and subsequently the letter dated
18.03.2023 issued by the Head of Office and DDO, Tripura, State
Council to the Senior Manager, P & GS Unit, LICI of India, Division
Office Meherpur, Silchar-15 [Annexure-15 of the writ petition] will
have no application in case of the present petitioner. The respondents
are therefore, directed to make payment within 8[eight] weeks from
today of all the post-retiral benefits to the petitioner as per above said
3[three] Schemes apart from other benefits, if any, which he is
otherwise entitled as per other rules/laws, after making of adjustment
of what have already been paid.
JUDGE
SATABDI
DUTTA
Sujay
DUTTA
Date: 2024.01.09 10:34:04
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review