Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:23463
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 28TH PHALGUNA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 89 OF 2023
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 28.03.2023 IN OA NO.943 OF 2018 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/APPLICANTS 5 & 6, 8 AND 13 IN THE ORIGINAL
APPLICATION:
NARINDER KUMAR,
AGED 36 YEARS
S/O. SH VIJAY KUMAR, SAINI,R/O. H.NO. 5056,
GALI NO. 01, NEW ADARSH NAGAR, KOTKHALSE,
AMRITSAR, PUNJAB, PIN - 143003
VINIT,
AGED 28 YEARS
S/O. SURENDER KUMAR SHARMA, VPO PILANA,
DALAL PANA, TEHSIL KALANAUR,
DISTRICT ROHTAK – 124202 NOW RESIDING AT HOUSE NO. 312,
SANJAY COLONY, ROHTAK (HARYANA), PIN - 124001
HARISH CHANDER,
AGED 35 YEARS
S/O. DHANI RAM, HOUSE NO. 200,
BACK SIDE GURUDWARA, DARIA,
CHANDIGARH, PIN - 160101
PANKAJ KUMAR,
AGED 33 YEARS
S/O. BALWANT SINGH, WARD NO. 03,
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
VILLAGE PANAPARI HAR (182), DHIRA,
DISTRICT, KANGRA – 176064,
(HIMACHAL PRADESH), PIN – 176064.
BY ADVS.
GIRIJA K GOPAL
K.N.VIGY
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS 1 TO 3:
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE , SOUTH BLOCK,
NEW DELHI, PIN - 110001
THE CHIEF ENGINEER (N.W.),
KOCHI.P.O, NAVAL BASE,
KATARI BAGH, KOCHI, PIN - 682007
THE SOUTHERN COMMAND (HEADQUARTERS),
PUNE, MAHARASHTRA, PIN - 400104
BY ADV
P.R.AJITH KUMAR
THIS
19.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
OP
(CAT)
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
ADMISSION
ON
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 19th day of March, 2025
AMIT RAWAL, J.
1.
The question involved in this case is, can the
Department change the rules of the game already set out in the
notification inviting applications for filling up the post of
Chowkidar (Khansama) in the Military Engineering Services.
Respondents caused a notification on 28.09.2015 specifying the
qualifications for the aforementioned post and assigned 100 marks,
out of which 65 marks for the written test and 25 marks for the
practical test, and 10 marks for the qualification. Two (2) days
before the written test could be held, came out with an order
Annexure A2 dated 28.01.2016, dispensing with the practical test
and allotting the 25 marks to the written test, i.e., 90 marks for the
written test and 10 marks for the qualification. All the
candidates/aspirants who submitted applications participated in the
written test but could not get qualified, which gave a cause of action
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
to file the OA. Before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Model
Recruitment Rules of 2013, 2019 and 2023 had been relied upon to
establish that all the aforementioned rules contained the element of
trade test. The decision of the respondents in doing away with the
practical test based upon the speech of the Hon’ble Prime Minister
on the independence day in the year 2015, was only with respect to
the interview whereas the interview and practical test are paused
apart. For Khansamas, the practical test is inevitable as, written test
would not be sufficient to ascertain cooking skills.
2. Respondents contested the claim and stated that trade
test/ practical was only for qualifying, but not essential for the
purpose of selection. Learned Tribunal on analysis of the pleadings,
dismissed the case.
3.
Smt.Girija K. Gopal, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioners, raised the submission that the rules of
game, as per the settled law, after having been notified, few days
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
before
the
written
test,
cannot
be
changed.
All
the
applicants/aspirants were hopeful of getting the employment as they
had excellent cooking skills and would have obtained 100% marks
in the practical test. But in the absence of practical test, written test
cannot be a yardstick for assessing the qualities and capabilities of
the Khansamas.
4.
The model rules of 2013, subsequent to the
notification in 2018 and 2021, envisage a trade test/ practical test for
Khansamas. It is not understandable, for the period in question,
how and in what manner the respondents dispensed with the
practical test. Such an exercise is wholly erroneous, arbitrary and
illegal.
5.
On the other hand, Sri. Ajith Kumar, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the Union of India supported the
finding of the Tribunal much less the stand taken in the reply
statement and stated that the skill test was only a qualifying test and
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
since there could be a possibility of partiality or biasness, the
practical test was merged with the written test.
All
the
aspirants could not have achieved the qualifying marks in the
written test, therefore, there was no selection in pursuance to the
notification of 2015, but did not deny the existence of the practical
test in the pre- notification rules, i.e., 2013 and post- notification
rules, i.e., 2018 and 2020, and submitted that, it is only for the
qualifying purposes but not as a magna carta.
6.
We have heard the counsel for the parties and
appraised the paper book.
7.
No doubt, when the notification Annexure A1, on
28.09.2015, was caused, the department had fixed the qualification
and assigned the marks of 100 by bifurcating it as 10 vis-a-vis
qualifications, 65 marks for written test and 25 for practical test, but
later merged the marks of 25 with the written test by raising the
limit from 65 to 90. No doubt, the rules of game cannot be permitted
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
to be changed, but the fact remains that all the applicants
participated but not selected.
8.
It is not a case that any of the candidate was
selected and therefore it is a case of discrimination as enshrined
under Article 16 of the Constitution of India. It is also settled law
that after having been participated, cannot assail the criteria, at the
best, could have challenged the same by not participating in the
written test. Be that as it may. Though the Department had not
considered the aspect of interview vis-a-vis the trade test
in a
correct perspective, the fact remains that the interview as well as the
practical test are not identical. There are different parameters and
particularly for the post in question, without the practical test, the
selection would not be possible.
9.
In the absence of any discrimination, we cannot
implore upon the department to undertake the task of selection again
by incorporating the practical test, as the selection was in respect of
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
the sanctioned post vacant in 2015. We have not been apprised as to
what procedure has been followed to cause the aforementioned
notification in view of the model rules of 2018 and 2021. In the
absence of the same we would not be in a position to comment
upon the conduct of the respondents. At the best, the petitioners are
entitled to some compensation in terms of money but not in the
proceedings under the administrative tribunal. We do not find any
illegality and perversity. No ground for interference is made out.
OP(CAT) stands dismissed.
Sd/AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
HKH/19.03.2025
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 89/2023
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A1
A TRUE COPY OF THE EMPLOYMENT NOTICE NO.
20168/LRS 13-14/EIC 1 DATED 28/9/2015
ANNEXURE A2
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION DATED
28..01..2016 OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL [
PERSONAL ] MILITARY SERVICE
ANNEXURE A3
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE ISSUED BY THE
RESPONDENT INFORMING ONE AMONG THE
APPLICANTS TO APPEAR FOR DOCUMENT
VERIFICATION
ANNEXURE A4
A TRUE COPY OF THE FINAL RESULT DATED
13..12..2017
ANNEXURE A5
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
3..10..2018 OF THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL CHANDIGARH BENCH IN OA NO.
060/00126/2018
ANNEXURE A6
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 3..5..2018
BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE R1
A TRUE COPY OF DOP & T LETTER NO.
39020/2/2016-ESTT [ B ] DATED 27..6..2016
ANNEXURE R2
A TRUE COPY OF SOP, 1997 ISSUED BY
ENGINEER - IN - CHIEF'S BRANCH
EXHIBIT P1
A TRUE COPY OF OA NO.943/2018 FILED BY
THE APPLICANTS BEFORE THE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
EXHIBIT P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE QUESTION PAPER
ATTEMPTED BY THE PETITIONERS
EXHIBIT P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT DATED
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
31.5.2019 FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS
EXHIBIT P4
A TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY
STATEMENT DATED 27.9.2019, FILED BY THE
RESPONDENTS ALONG WITH ANNEXURE
EXHIBIT P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
28..3..2023 IN ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.
180/00943/2018 PASSED BY THE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL , ERNAKULAM BENCH
EXHIBIT P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE OM NO. 39020/01/2013ESTT(B) –PART DATED 29.12.2015 ISSUED BY
THE DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
EXHIBIT P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE MEMORANDUM
BEARING NO.F.NO.DPE-GM-01/0001/2015-GMFTS-4857 DATED 14.12.2015 WAS ISSUED BY
THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC ENTERPRISES,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
EXHIBIT P8
A TRUE COPY OF OM NO 3/2/2009-DIR.(C)
DATED 22.5.2013 ISSUED BY THE DOP&T
PRESCRIBING MODEL RECRUITMENT RULES FOR
VARIOUS POSTS IN CANTEENS/TIFFIN ROOMS
LOCATED IN CENTRAL GOVERNMENT OFFICES
EXHIBIT P9
A TRUE COPY OF DO & PT O.M NO 3/3/2018 –
DIR (C) DATED 18.4.2018
EXHIBIT P10
A TRUE COPY OF O.M NO 11/2/2020 –DIR ( C)
DATED 13.7.2021
EXHIBIT P11
A TRUE COPY OF O.M NO.03/02/2009-DIR
(CAN) DATED 5.6.2014 ISSUED BY THE
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL & TRAINING
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE R3(A)
TRUE COPY OF THE MILITARY ENGINEER
O.P.(CAT) No.89/2023
2025:KER:23463
SERVICES [KHANSAMA CHAWKIDAR] RECRUITMENT
RULES, 2012
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review