Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.B.:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC. Appeal No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri,
S/o T.B. Chettri,
Aged about 45 years,
R/o Development Area,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
… Appellant
versus
1. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan,
Aged about 71 years,
R/o Development Area,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2. The Branch Manager,
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance
Company Limited,
Saharan House, 2nd Floor,
Above ICICI Bank,
2nd Mile, Sevoke Road,
Siliguri, West Bengal.
... Respondents
Application under Section 173 of the Central Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988.
Appearance:
Mr. Ajay Rathi and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa, Advocates
for the Appellant.
Mr. Rinzing Dorjee Tamang, Advocate for Respondent
No.1.
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for Respondent No.2.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
(25.09.2018)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
This is an appeal filed by the Appellant under Section 173 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (the said Act) against the order dated
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
23.02.2018 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Claims
Tribunal), East Sikkim at Gangtok directing the Appellant to pay a
sum of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) as interim relief
on account of injuries to the Claimant in view of Section 140 of the
said Act in MACT Case No.26 of 2016. In re: Yallwwa (Smt.) & Ors. v.
The National Insurance Company Ltd. & Anr.1 the Supreme Court
would hold that an order of the Claims Tribunal awarding
compensation under Section 140 is appealable under Section 173
as it amount to an “award” under Section 168 of the said Act.
Section 169 of the said Act provides for the procedure and powers
of the Claims Tribunal. It reads as under:
“169. Procedure and powers of Claims Tribunals.—(1) In
holding any inquiry under section 168, the Claims Tribunal may, subject
to any rules that may be made in this behalf, follow such summary
procedure as it thinks fit.
(2) The Claims Tribunal shall have all the powers of a Civil Court
for the purpose of taking evidence on oath and of enforcing the
attendance of witnesses and of compelling the discovery and production
of documents and material objects and for such other purposes as may
be prescribed; and the Claims Tribunal shall be deemed to be a Civil
Court for all the purposes of section 195 and Chapter XXVI of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974).
(3) Subject to any rules that may be made in this behalf, the Claims
Tribunal may, for the purpose of adjudicating upon any claim for
compensation, choose one or more persons possessing special knowledge
of and matter relevant to the inquiry to assist it in holding the inquiry.”
2.
Section 169 makes it abundantly clear that an inquiry is
required to be held under Section 168 of the said Act. While doing
so, subject to any rules that may be made in this behalf, summary
2007 6 SCC 657
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
procedure as the Claims Tribunal thinks fit is required to be
followed. The Claims Tribunal also has all the powers of the Civil
Court for the purpose of taking evidence on oath and of enforcing
the attendance of witnesses and of compelling the discovery and
production of documents and material objects and for such other
purposes as may be prescribed.
3.
In exercise of the powers conferred by Sections 28, 38, 65,
95, 96, 107, 111, 138 and 176 read with Section 211 of the said
Act the State Government made the Sikkim Motor Vehicles Rules,
1991 (the said Rules) which was published in the Sikkim
Government Gazette on 05.10.1991 on which date it came into
force. Chapter VIII of the said Rules relates to the establishment of
Claims Tribunal.
4.
The said Rules under Chapter VIII prescribe two sets of
procedure to examine a claim under Section 166 and a claim
under Chapter X of the said Act.
5.
Rule 247 to Rule 265 of the said Rules govern an application
for compensation under Section 166 of the said Act. Detailed
procedure
regarding
the
form
of
application
(Rule
247);
examination of the application (Rule 248); summary dismissal of
application (Rule 249); notice to parties involved (Rule 250);
appearance and examination of parties (Rule 251); summoning of
witnesses (Rule 252); appearance of legal practitioner (Rule 253);
local inspection (Rule 254); inspection of vehicle (Rule 255); power
of summary examination (Rule 256); method of recording of
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
evidence (Rule 257); adjournment of hearing (Rule 258); co-opting
of persons during inquiry (Rule 259); framing of issues (Rule 260);
determination of issues (Rule 261); maintaining of diary of
proceedings (Rule 263); judgment and award of compensation
(Rule 263); enforcement of award of the Claims Tribunal (Rule
264); the applicability of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) in
certain cases (Rule 265); form and number of appeals against the
decision of Claims Tribunal (Rule 266); and fees payable for
preferring the application under Section 166 of the said Act (Rule
267); have been made in Chapter VIII consisting of Rules 247 to
267 of the said Rules.
6.
The
procedure
prescribed
by
the
said
Rules
for
the
determination of a claim under Section 166 of the said Act is fairly
detailed and elaborate compared to the procedure prescribed
under Rules 268 to 275 of the said Rules for determination of a
claim under Chapter X of the said Act.
7.
An application in the case of a claim under Chapter X of the
said Act, which includes a claim under Section 140 is however,
governed by Rules 268 to 275 of the said Rules.
8.
Rule 268 of the said Rules provides as under:
“268. Application for claim.- (I) Every application in the case of
claim under Chapter X of Act, shall be made in Form SKV-71
(2)
Every applicant along with application for claim shall
pay a fee of ten rupees.”
9.
Rule 269 of the said Rules provides as under:
“269. Consideration of the claim.- The Claims Tribunal shall
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
follow the procedure of summary trail as contained in the code of
Criminal Procedure, 1898, (Central Act 5 of 1974) for the purpose of
adjudicating and awarding a claim under Chapter X of the Act.”
10. The summary trial procedure as contained in the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.) is required to be followed for
the purpose of adjudicating and awarding a claim under Chapter X
of the said Act.
11. Rule 270 to Rule 275 of the said Rules is relevant for the
purpose of determination of the award of the claim made under
Chapter X of the said Act and the basis on which the award of the
claim is to be made.
12. Section 262 Cr.P.C. provides that in trials under Chapter XXI
Cr.P.C. the procedure specified in Cr.P.C. for the trial of summons
case shall be followed. Chapter XX Cr.P.C. provides for trial of
summons cases by Magistrates. Section 251 Cr.P.C. provides for
substance of accusation; Section 252
Cr.P.C. provides for
conviction on plea of guilty; Section 253 Cr.P.C. provides for
conviction on plea of guilty in absence of accused in petty cases
and Section 254 Cr.P.C. provides for procedure when not
convicted. When an application under Section 140 of the said Act
is contested Section 254 Cr.P.C. and 255 Cr.P.C. would be
relevant. Section 254 Cr.P.C. reads as under:
“254. Procedure when not convicted.(1) If the Magistrate
does not convict the accused under section 252 or section 253, the
Magistrate shall proceed to hear the prosecution and take all such
evidence as may be produced in support of the prosecution, and
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
also to hear the accused and take all such evidence as he produces
in his defence.
(2) The Magistrate may, if he thinks fit, on the application of
the prosecution or the accused, issue a summons to any witness
directing him to attend or to produce any document or other thing.
(3) The Magistrate may, before summoning any witness on
such application require that the reasonable expenses of the
witness incurred in attending for the purposes of the trial be
deposited in Court.”
(Emphasis supplied)
13. Section 255 Cr.P.C. reads as under:
“255. Acquittal or conviction.(1) If the Magistrate, upon taking
the evidence referred to in section 254 and such further evidence, if
any, as he may, of his own motion, cause to be produced, finds the
accused not guilty, he shall record an order of acquittal.
(2) Where the Magistrate does not proceed in accordance
with the provisions of section 325 or section 360, he shall, if he
finds the accused guilty, pass sentence upon him according to law.
(3) A Magistrate may, under section 252 or section 255,
convict the accused of any offence triable under this Chapter,
which from the facts admitted or proved he appears to have
committed, whatever may be the nature of the complaint or
summons, if the Magistrate is satisfied that the accused would not
be prejudiced thereby.”
(Emphasis supplied)
14. Section 255 provides for acquittal or conviction upon
determination after taking evidence under Section 254 Cr.P.C.
15. Section 169 of the said Act read with the relevant provisions
of the said Rules relating to the procedure to be followed in case of
a claim under Chapter X of the said Act and the relevant
provisions for summary trials in Cr.P.C. makes it unequivocally
clear that even for determination of the liability under Section 140
of the said Act the procedure prescribed for coming to a conclusion
must be undertaken by the Claims Tribunal before awarding the
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
claim or rejecting it. The procedure for the determination of a claim
under Section 140 of the said Act is not as exhaustive as a claim
under Section 166 of the said Act. Although the procedure
prescribed provides for a summary procedure under the Cr.P.C.
the orders which need be passed is not of conviction or acquittal
but for determining whether the claimant is entitled to the award
under Section 140 of the said Act. The claim under Chapter X of
the said Act is of civil nature although the said Rules prescribe a
summary trial procedure applicable in criminal cases.
16. Rule 274 of the said Rules provides that the Claims Tribunal,
before whom an application for compensation liability arising out
of the provisions of Chapter X has been made, shall dispose of
such application within 45 days from the date of receipt of such
application. The mandate of the Rule 274 must be strictly followed.
In the present case the application for claim of compensation
under Section 140 of the said Act was preferred on 27.06.2016.
The impugned order awarding Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five
thousand) to the Claimant was made on 23.02.2018 after one year,
seven months and twenty seven days. The afore-quoted Rules
provide “summary procedure” for determining the liability under
Section 140 of the said Act. The perusal of the records, however,
reflect that the Claims Tribunal failed to follow the “summary
procedure” as prescribed and determined the award without even
examining the ingredients of Section 140 of the said Act in the
period of one year, seven months and twenty seven days. The very
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
purpose of providing the “summary procedure” as well as fixing a
time frame to do so was lost in the process.
17. In re: Yallwwa (Smt.) & Ors. (supra) the Supreme Court would
hold:
“9. It is not in dispute that an award of the Tribunal is to be made
in terms of Section 168 of the Act. For the said purpose, the Tribunal is
required to issue a notice to the insurer and give the parties an
opportunity of being heard. While making an award in terms of Section
168 of the Act, the procedure laid down under Section 166 of the Act is
required to be complied with. The proviso appended to Section 168 of the
Act, however, lays down that where such application makes a claim for
compensation under Section 140 in respect of the death or permanent
disablement of any person, such claim and any other claim (whether
made in such application or otherwise) for compensation in respect of
such death or permanent disablement shall be disposed of in accordance
with the provisions of Chapter X of the Act.
10. Section 140, as noticed hereinbefore, provides for no fault
liability. It uses the words “accident arising out of the use of a motor
vehicle”, “the owner of the vehicle” and when more than two vehicles are
involved, “the owners of the vehicles” shall, jointly and severally, be
liable to pay compensation. The said provision, therefore, makes the
owners of the vehicles liable but not the insurer per se. Irrespective of the
fact whether a claim petition is required to be adjudicated under Chapter
X or Chapter XII of the Act, it is permissible to raise a defence in terms of
sub-section (2) of Section 149 of the Act. It is even possible for the owner
of the vehicle to raise a contention that his vehicle being not involved in
the accident, he is not liable to pay any amount in terms of Section 140 of
the Act.
11. One of the defences available to the insurer is breach of
conditions specified in the policy. When such a defence is raised, the
Tribunal is required to go into the said question. Section 140 of the Act
does not contemplate that an insurance company shall also be liable to
deposit the amount while it has no fault (sic obligation) whatsoever in
terms of sub-section (2) of Section 147 of the Act.
12. There cannot be any doubt that an appeal is a creation of a
statute.
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
13. It may be noted that Chapter X of the Act provides for no forum
for enforcement of the right under Section 140. The only forum available
is in Chapter XII. The right under Section 140 can only be enforced under
Section 168 as an award. An appeal, therefore, lies under Section 173
against such an award seeking to enforce the right under Section 140.
14. In P. Ramanatha Aiyar's Law Lexicon, 3rd Edn., 2005 at p.
427, it is stated:
“ ‘Award’ means an arbitration award [Arbitration Act (10 of 1940),
Section 2(b)]
‘Award’ means an interim or a final determination of any industrial
dispute or of any question relating thereto by any Labour Court,
Industrial Tribunal or National Industrial Tribunal and includes an
arbitration award made under Section 10-A. [Industrial Disputes Act (14
of 1947), Section 2(f).]”
15. In Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mohiuddin Kureshi [(1994) 1
ACJ 74 : (1994) 1 Pat LJR 79] a Division Bench of the Patna High Court
observed: (ACJ pp. 76-77, paras 7, 9 & 11)
“7. Section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act which is in Chapter
X of the said Act provides for liability to pay compensation on the
principle of no fault. An owner of a vehicle thus would be liable to
pay compensation in case death or permanent disablement to any
person has resulted from an accident arising out of use of a motor
vehicle or vehicles and the amount of such compensation in terms
of Section 140(2) is fixed as Rs 25,000 in case of death and Rs
12,000 in case of permanent disablement.
Sub-section (3) of Section 140 postulates that the claimant
shall not be required to plead and establish that the death or
permanent disablement in respect of which claim was made was
due to any wrongful act, neglect or default of the owner or owners
of the vehicle or vehicles concerned or of any other person.
***
9. Section 141 of the said Act, however, provides that right to
claim in terms of Section 140 shall be in addition to any other right
under the provisions of the said Act or any other law for the time
being in force.
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
Sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 141 of the said Act read
thus:
‘(2) A claim for compensation under Section 140 in respect of death
or permanent disablement of any person shall be disposed of as
expeditiously as possible and where compensation is claimed in respect
of such death or permanent disablement under Section 140 and also in
pursuance of any right on the principle of fault, the claim for
compensation under Section 140 shall be disposed of as aforesaid in the
first place.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), where in
respect of the death or permanent disablement of any person, the person
liable to pay compensation under Section 140 is also liable to pay
compensation in accordance with the right on the principle of fault, the
person so liable shall pay the first-mentioned compensation and—
(a) if the amount of the first-mentioned compensation is less than
the amount of the second-mentioned compensation, he shall be liable to
pay (in addition to the first-mentioned compensation) only so much of the
second-mentioned compensation as is equal to the amount by which it
exceeds the first-mentioned compensation;
(b) if the amount of the first-mentioned compensation is equal to or
more than the amount of the second-mentioned compensation, he shall
not be liable to pay the second-mentioned compensation.’
***
11. From a conjoint reading of the aforementioned provisions, there
cannot be any doubt that an application under Section 140 of the said Act
can be filed separately.
However, Section 166 of the said Act contemplates filing of a
composite application, as is evident from the proviso appended to subsection (2) of Section 166 of the said Act.”
16. The question which is required to be considered is what would
be the meaning of the term “award” when such a contention is raised.
Although in a given situation having regard to the liability of the owner of
the vehicle, a Claims Tribunal need not go into the question as to whether
the owner of the vehicle in question was at fault or not, but determination
of the liability of the insurance company, in our opinion, stands on a
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
different footing. When a statutory liability has been imposed upon the
owner, in our opinion, the same cannot extend the liability of an insurer
to indemnify the owner although in terms of the insurance policy or under
the Act, it would not be liable therefor.
17. In a given case, the statutory liability of an insurance
company, therefore, either may be nil or a sum lower than the amount
specified under Section 140 of the Act. Thus, when a separate application
is filed in terms of Section 140 of the Act, in terms of Section 168 thereof,
an insurer has to be given a notice in which event, it goes without saying,
it would be open to the insurance company to plead and prove that it is
not liable at all.
18. Furthermore, it is not in dispute that there can be more than
one award, particularly when a sum paid may have to be adjusted from
the final award. Keeping in view the provisions of Section 168 of the Act,
there cannot be any doubt whatsoever that an award for enforcing the
right under Section 140 of the Act is also required to be passed under
Section 168 only after the parties concerned have filed their pleadings
and have been given a reasonable opportunity of being heard. A Claims
Tribunal, thus, must be satisfied that the conditions precedent specified
in Section 140 of the Act have been substantiated, which is the basis for
making an award.
19. Furthermore, evidently, the amount directed to be paid even in
terms of Chapter X of the Act must as of necessity, in the event of noncompliance with directions, has to be recovered in terms of Section 174 of
the Act. There is no other provision in the Act which takes care of such a
situation. We, therefore, are of the opinion that even when objections are
raised by the insurance company in regard to its liability, the Tribunal is
required to render a decision upon the issue, which would attain finality
and, thus, the same would be an award within the meaning of Section
173 of the Act.”
[Emphasis supplied]
18. In the present case along with an application under Section
166 of the said Act for compensation a separate application under
Section 140 of the said Act was also preferred before the Claims
Tribunal on 27.6.2016. Written objection thereto was filed by the
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
Appellant on 26.12.2016. In the written objection the Appellant
claimed that the vehicle was insured with the Respondent No.2
and had valid insurance certificate at the time of the accident
covering period of insurance from 22.04.2015 to midnight of
21.04.2016 vide policy certificate no. OG-16-2451-1801-0000003.
The Appellant also pleaded that he had no liability towards the
claimant as the vehicle was insured and had valid insurance
certificate at the time of accident of the said vehicle. The insurance
policy certificate was filed by the Appellant along with his reply to
the claim made by the claimant i.e. the Respondent No.1 under
Section 166 of the said Act.
19. The no fault liability of the owner is absolute under Section
140 of the said Act. Between the owner and owners of the motor
vehicle or motor vehicles the liability is also joint and several.
However, when the owner claims to have been indemnified by the
insurer against the said liability under Section 140 of the said Act
the Claims Tribunal is required to issue notice upon the insurer, if
not already done, hear the Claimant, owner and the insurer to
determine if no fault liability of the owner has in fact been
indemnified by the insurer by execution of the policy following the
procedure laid down. In that event it would be open to the
insurance company to plead and prove that it is not liable at all.
20. Chapter XI of the said Act deals with insurance of motor
vehicles against third party risk. Section 145(c) of the said Act
provides that the word “liability”, wherever used in relation to the
death of or bodily injury to any person, includes liability in respect
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
thereof under Section 140. Section 146 of the said Act mandates
that no person shall use, except as a passenger, or cause or allow
any other person to use, a motor vehicle in a public place, unless
there is in force in relation to the use of the vehicle by that person
or that other person, as the case may be, a policy of insurance
complying with the requirements of Chapter XI of the said Act.
21. Section 147 of the said Act deals with requirements of
policies and limits of liability. Section 149 of the said Act provides
for the duty of the insurers to satisfy judgments and “awards”
against persons insured in respect of third party risks. As per
Section 149 of the said Act, if, after a certificate of insurance has
been issued under sub-section (3) of Section 147 in favour of the
person by whom a policy has been effected, judgment or “award”
in respect of any such “liability” as is required to be covered by a
policy under clause (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 147 of the said
Act (being a liability covered by the terms of the policy) is obtained
against any person insured by the policy, then, notwithstanding
that the insurer may be entitled to avoid or cancel or may have
avoided or cancelled the policy, the insurer shall, subject to the
provisions of Section 149, of the said Act, pay to the person
entitled to the benefit of the decree any sum not exceeding the sum
assured payable thereunder, as if he were the judgment debtor, in
respect of the liability, together with any amount payable in
respect of costs and any sum payable in respect of interest on that
sum by virtue of any enactment relating to interest on judgments.
Section 149(2) of the said Act provides that no sum shall be
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
payable by an insurer under sub-section (1) in respect of any
judgment or “award” unless, before the commencement of the
proceedings in which the judgment or “award” is given the insurer
had notice through the Court or as the case may be, the Claims
Tribunal of the bringing of the proceedings. In such an event the
insurer shall be made a party and could defend the action on any
of the grounds specified under sub-section (2) of Section 149 of the
said Act. The explanation to Section 149 of the said Act provides
that for the purpose of the said Section “award” means an
“award” made by that Tribunal under Section 168 of the said Act.
22. This Court has perused the orders passed by the Claims
Tribunal from 27.6.2016 till the passing of the impugned order
dated 23.2.2018. The orders do not reflect that it satisfied itself of
the requirements of Section 140 of the said Act and determined the
ingredients thereof. This was a requirement under the substantive
law contained in Section 140 of the said Act without fulfilment of
which no order under the said section could have been passed. It
also does not reflect that the Claims Tribunal followed the said
Rules contained in Rule 268 to Rule 275 as mandated by Section
169 of the said Act nor any “summary procedure” which is required
to be followed to make an inquiry to be satisfied that the claim
under Section 140 of the said Act is valid and ought to be granted.
The words “subject to” before the words “any rules that may be
made in this behalf, follow such summary procedure as it thinks fit.”
reflects the clear intention of the legislature that if rules have been
made the rules ought to be followed. The expression “subject to”
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
conveys the idea of the said Rules yielding place to the “summary
procedure” as the Claims Tribunal “thinks fit.”
This was the
procedural law which was required to be followed by the Claims
Tribunal while determining whether or not the Claimant was
entitled to an “award” under Section 140 of the said Act. When the
said Rules provide for the procedure to be followed to determine
the claim under Section 140 it was incumbent upon the Claims
Tribunal to have followed the said procedure.
23. Section 140 of the said Act provides as under:
“140. Liability to pay compensation in certain cases on the
principle of no fault.— (1) Where death or permanent disablement of
any person has resulted from an accident arising out of the use of a
motor vehicle or motor vehicles, the owner of the vehicle shall, or, as the
case may be, the owners of the vehicles shall, jointly and severally, be
liable to pay compensation in respect of such death or disablement in
accordance with the provisions of this section.
(2) The amount of compensation which shall be payable under subsection (1) in respect of the death of any person shall be a fixed sum of
1[fifty thousand rupees] and the amount of compensation payable under
that sub-section in respect of the permanent disablement of any person
shall be a fixed sum of 2[twenty-five thousand rupees].
(3) In any claim for compensation under sub-section (1), the
claimant shall not be required to plead and establish that the death or
permanent disablement in respect of which the claim has been made was
due to any wrongful act, neglect or default of the owner or owners of the
vehicle or vehicles concerned or of any other person.
(4) A claim for compensation under sub-section (1) shall not be
defeated by reason of any wrongful act, neglect or default of the person
in respect of whose death or permanent disablement the claim has been
made nor shall the quantum of compensation recoverable in respect of
such death or permanent disablement be reduced on the basis of the
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
share of such person in the responsibility for such death or permanent
disablement.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2) regarding
death or bodily injury to any person, for which the owner of the vehicle is
liable to give compensation for relief, he is also liable to pay
compensation under any other law for the time being in force: Provided
that the amount of such compensation to be given under any other law
shall be reduced from the amount of compensation payable under this
section or under section 163A.”
24. A bare reading of Section 140 of the said Act reflects that
without
a
determination
about
the
factum
of
“death”
or
“permanent disablement” resulting from an accident arising out of
the use of a motor vehicle the “owner” of the vehicle cannot be
held liable to pay compensation in respect of such “death” or
“permanent disablement” in accordance with the provisions of the
said section. The determination as to who is the “owner” of the
said motor vehicle is also imperative. The word “owner” has been
defined under Section 2(20) of the said Act. Section 140(3) of the
said Act makes it clear that in any claim for compensation under
Section 140(1) of the said Act the Claimant shall not be required to
plead or establish that the “death” or “permanent disablement” in
respect of which the claim has been made was due to any wrongful
act, neglect or default of the “owner” or owners of the vehicle or
vehicles concerned or of any other person. Section 140(4) of the
said Act further provides that the claim for compensation under
section 140(1) shall not be defeated by reason of any wrongful act,
neglect or default of the person in respect of whose “death” or
“permanent disablement” the claim has been made nor shall the
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
quantum of compensation recoverable in respect of such “death”
or “permanent disablement” be reduced on the basis of the share of
such person in the responsibility for such “death” or “permanent
disablement”. The proviso to Section 140 of the said Act provides
that the amount of compensation to be given under any other law
shall be reduced from the amount of compensation payable under
Section 140 or under Section 163A of the said Act.
25. To attract the liability of the “owner” under Section 140 of the
said Act all that is required is an accident arising out of the use of
a motor vehicle leading to “death” or “permanent disability” of any
person. The liability of the “owner” is without fault but the fact of
ownership of the motor vehicle is also required to be determined.
The inquiry to award the compensation under Section 140 of the
said Act is limited but the inquiry is a must. As held by the
Supreme Court in re: Eshwarappa alias Maheshwarappa & Anr. v. C. S.
Gurushanthappa & Anr.2 the Supreme Court would hold:
“20. The provisions of Section 140 are indeed intended to provide
immediate succour to the injured or the heirs and legal representatives of
the deceased. Hence, normally a claim under Section 140 is made at the
threshold of the proceeding and the payment of compensation under
Section 140 is directed to be made by an interim award of the Tribunal
which may be adjusted if in the final award the claimants are held
entitled to any larger amounts. ............”
26. Without determining whether the “death” or “permanent
disablement” has been caused as a result of an accident arising
out of the use of the motor vehicle or motor vehicles and is owned
(2010) 8 SCC 620
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
by the “owner” no order under Section 140 of the said Act may be
passed. Section 142 of the said Act provides that for the purpose of
Chapter X, “permanent disablement” of a person shall be deemed
to have resulted from an accident of the nature referred to in subsection (1) of Section 140 if such person has suffered by reason of
the accident, any injury or injuries involving- (a) permanent
privation of the sight of either eye or the hearing of either ear, or
privation of any member or joint; or (b) destruction or permanent
impairing of the powers of any member or joint; or (c) permanent
disfigurement of the head or face. The order to be passed under
Section 140 of the said Act must be passed urgently but cautiously
to meet the requirement of the law i.e. to award compensation to
the person who has suffered due to the accident without
determination of any fault or negligence. Section 141 (2) of the said
Act provides that a claim for compensation under Section 140 of
the said Act in respect of “death” or “permanent disablement” of
any person shall be disposed of as expeditiously as possible and
where compensation is claimed in respect of such “death” or
“permanent disablement” under Section 140 and also in pursuance
of any right on the principal of fault, the claim for compensation
under Section 140 of the said Act shall be disposed of as aforesaid
in the first place. This, however, does not mean no inquiry is
required to be conducted. An order passed under Section 140 of
the said Act without determination following the procedure
prescribed would have no sanctity in the eyes of law. The
impugned order dated 23.2.2018 does not reflect that the Claims
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
Tribunal had even prima facie determined the ingredients of
Section 140 of the said Act vis-à-vis the facts of the present case.
The Claims Tribunal records that a perusal of the FIR dated
23.4.2016 reveal that the Claimant sustained “severe injuries”.
Whether the severe injuries resulted in “death” or “permanent
disablement”, which is the sine-qua-non of Section 140 of the said
Act is not reflected in the impugned order.
27. The Claims Tribunal must always remember that procedural
and substantive laws need to work together to ensure that justice
is not only done but also seen to be done. Following the prescribed
procedure ensures fairness and avoids arbitrariness in the process
of determination. Procedural law engrafted in Rule 268 to Rule 275
of the said Rules would ensure due process which is fundamental
to justice dispensation. Procedural due process is a right of the
parties who may be affected by the award passed under Section
140 of the said Act. Procedural due process embodies the notion of
legal fairness. It is equally important to keep in mind that the
fundamental facts, as laid down above, being the ingredients of
Section 140 of the said Act must be determined before passing an
award under the said provision even if it is interim in nature.
28. In
view
of
the
aforesaid,
the
impugned
order
dated
23.02.2018 is set aside, the application filed by the Claimant
under Section 140 of the said Act shall be reconsidered by the
Claims Tribunal along with the objection filed by the Appellant
after considering all the relevant material on record and following
the procedure prescribed. The application made by the Respondent
MAC. App. No. 06 of 2018
Shri Narendra Kumar Chettri v. Shri Ashok Kumar Pradhan & Anr.
No.1 under Section 140 of the said Act along with the objection
filed by the Appellant is restored to the files of the Claims Tribunal
for reconsideration as per law. As the pleadings are complete with
regard to the claim under Section 140 of the said Act the Claims
Tribunal shall dispose of the said claim expeditiously.
The appeal
is allowed.
Judge
25.09.2018
to/
Index: yes/No
Internet: yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review