Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$
$
%
%
!
!
!
!
&
##
'#
(#
*
!
"
#
SUMITRA SHERIGAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
$
%
&
'
(
)
-2-
!
"
(
(
#
#
)
(
!
(
"
!
(
#
*
!
$
%
)
+
#
+
,
"-
&
,
./
)
,
,
!/ ! "!""
)
/# "! .
/# "! .
-3-
,
)
(
)
)
)
)
!
%
12134536
29;1 72 6:1
)
)&
7 /# "! . 73 6:1
78 " 534 # 93
44969735;
8:7<6 B <95;
%
1397<
9=9; )>4?1
59@:><
A27<
7><6CD :5=1 29;14 6:98 5EE15; @:5;;13?93? 6:1
F>4?G136 534 41@<11 45614 !/ !
"!"" HI J:9@: 6:1 8>96
27< E5<696973 J58 41@<114 534 6:1 E;59369228 J1<1 :1;4
13696;14 67 "
"
6:
8:5<1 93 6:1 8>96 8@:14>;1 E<7E1<6918
:1 E5<6918 8:5;; :13@127<6: H1 <121<<14 67 58
6:1I J1<1 5<<5I14 H127<1 6:1 <95;
#
7><6
:1 E;15493?8 6:56 5<1 1K6<5@614 HI 6:1
<95;
7><6 93 968 F>4?G136 J7>;4 8:7J 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 534
412134536
67 # 5<1 89H;93?8 J:9;1 412134536
5<1 6:1 J9=18 72 6:1 412134536
" 534 #
-4-
<18E1@69=1;I
><=1I
HI
:1 E;59369228 @73613414 6:56 6:1 ;534 93
78 ".! " ".. # . " J1<1 7J314 534 E78818814
G6
:11G5LL5
J:7 98 6:1 ?<534G76:1< 72 6:1
E;59369228 534 412134536
67 #
;15=93? H1:934 :1< 873
53>G536:5EE5 J:7 98 6:1 256:1<
72 6:1 E;59369228 534 412134536
561<
:11G5L5 4914
67 #
1 4914 5H7>6
I15<8 E<97< 67 6:1 29;93? 72 6:1 8>96 534 6:19< G76:1<
" I15<8 E<97< 67 6:1 4561 72 29;93? 72 6:1 8>96
7381M>136;I
6:1 E;59369228 534 412134536
8>@@11414 67 6:1 527<18594 E<7E1<6918
6:1 ;534 93
><=1I
9;;5?1 534 6:1 ;534 93
><=1I
67 #
:1I @736134 6:56
896>5614 56
54;5E><
7 " / 896>5614 56
9;;5?1 J58 7J314 534 E78818814 HI
9@:5;9
53>G536:5EE5 534
6:56 5261< :98 4156: 6:1I :54 8>@@11414 67 6:1 527<18594
E<7E1<6918
#"
"
9L1J981 6:1 ;5348 93
896>5614
9@:5;9
><=1I
9;;5?1
J1<1
78 #"
7J314
E78818814 HI
G6
>;9?5GG5 6:1 G76:1< 72 6:1 E;59369228
534 412134536
67 # 534 6:56 6:1I 8>@@11414 67 6:1
527<18594 E<7E1<6918
:1 E;59369228 @;59G14 6:56 5;; 6:1
-5-
E<7E1<6918 J1<1 F7936;I 7J314 534 E78818814 HI 6:1
E;59369228 534 412134536
67 #
:1I @736134 6:56 6:1
4121345368 93 7<41< 67 41E<9=1 6:1 ;5J2>; 8:5<1 72 6:1
E;59369228 @7;;>414 J96: 6:1 <1=13>1 5>6:7<96918 534 ?76
1361<14 6:19< 35G18 93 6:1 <1=13>1 <1@7<48 J96:7>6 6:1
@738136 72 6:1 E;59369228 534 H1:934 6:19< H5@L
:1
E;59369228 6:1<127<1 @5;;14 >E73 6:1 4121345368 67 E5<696973
534 :5347=1< 81E5<561 E788188973 72 6:19< "
6:1 8>96 8@:14>;1 E<7E1<6918
6:1<127<1
6:
8:5<1 93
J:9@: J58 <12>814 534
6:1 E;59369228 J1<1 54=9814 67 29;1 5 8>96 27<
E5<696973
:1 4121345368 5EE15<14 6:<7>?: 6:19< @7>381;
12134536
7 " 29;14 :98 J<96613 86561G136
547E614 HI 412134536
78 #
J:9@: J58
12134536
7"
494 376 498E>61 :98 <1;569738:9E J96: 6:1 E;59369228
@73613414 6:56 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 H1;73?14 67 6:19<
53@1867<8 534 6:56 6:1I 86774 93 6:1 35G18 72 6:1
4121345368
893@1
69G1
9GG1G7<95;
:1<127<1
:1
@73613414 6:56 6:1 M>186973 72 E5<69697393? 6:1 E<7E1<6918
-6-
494 376 5<981
1 5;;1?14 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 5<1 376
8:5<1:7;41<8 534 @7E5<@131<8 534 6:1I J1<1 376 93
E:I89@5; E788188973 72 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918
1 @73613414
6:56 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 J1<1 6:1 1K@;>89=1 E<7E1<6918 72
6:1 <18E1@69=1 4121345368 J:781 35G18 J1<1 G13697314
93 6:1 <1=13>1 <1@7<48 534 6:1I J1<1 93 @>;69=56973 534
13F7IG136 534 J1<1 4<5J93? 6:1 H1312968 2<7G 6:1
7=1<3G136 8>@: 58 8>H894I
J59=1< 72 ;753
16@
@73613414 6:56 E;59369228 93 7<41< 67 >8><E 6:1 =5;>5H;1
E<7E1<6918 72 6:1 4121345368 :54 29;14 6:1 =1K5697>8 8>96
1 2><6:1< @73613414 6:56 6:1 8>96 98 H5<<14 HI ;9G9656973
58 6:1 <1=13>1 47@>G1368 72 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 86774 93
6:19< 35G18 2<7G G53I I15<8 534 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 494
376 65L1 53I 861E8 67 @;59G 6:19< 8:5<1 93 6:1 8>96
E<7E1<6918
:1I 5;87 @;59G14 6:56 6:1I J1<1 93 ;5J2>;
E788188973 72 6:1 E<7E1<6918 27< G7<1 6:53 "! I15<8 534
6:1<127<1
6:1I :54 E1<21@614 6:19< 696;1 7=1< 6:1 8>96
E<7E1<6918 HI 54=1<81 E788188973
@7361369738 6:1 <95;
5814 73 6:181 <9=5;
7><6 2<5G14 6:1 27;;7J93? 988>18
-7-
N
!
"
#
$
%
3 8>EE7<6 72 6:1 5881<69738 G541 93 6:1 E;5936
E;5936922
7 " J58 1K5G9314 58
1K5G9314 58
(" 534
K8
(
534 J963188 J58
! J1<1 G5<L14
:1
4121345368 494 376 ;154 53I 1=9413@1 534 494 376 G5<L
53I 47@>G1365<I 1=9413@1
47@>G1365<I 1=9413@1
6:1
5814 73 6:1 7<5; 534
<95;
7><6 :1;4 6:56 6:1
E;59369228 :54 E<7=14 6:19< <1;569738:9E J96: 6:1 4121345368
534 :1;4 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 5<1 13696;14 67 53 1M>5; 8:5<1 93
-8-
6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 5;73? J96: 412134536
:1<127<1
" 534 #
96 41@<114 6:1 8>96 534 41@;5<14 6:56 6:1
E;59369228 5<1 13696;14 67
6:
8:5<1 15@: 93 6:1 8>96
E<7E1<6918 J:9;1 412134536
67 # J1<1 13696;14 67 6:1
6:
<1G59393? #
93 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918
193? 5??<91=14 HI
6:1 8594 F>4?G136 534 41@<11 4121345368 " 534 # 5<1
H127<1 6:98
/
7><6 93 6:98 5EE15;
:1
8>HG96614
;15<314
6:56
6:1
@7>381;
27<
4121345368
6:1
4121345368
:54
8>229@9136;I
@7GE1385614 6:1 E;59369228 HI ?9=93? ?7;4 7<35G1368 56 6:1
69G1 72 6:19< <18E1@69=1 G5<<95?18
412134536
:1 5;87 @7361348 6:56
)5G5;5GG5 J58 ?9=13 ;534 93
54;5E><
9;;5?1 534
9@:5;9
9;;5?1 67J5<48 :1< 8:5<1
><=1I
><=1I
7 ".! " 72
:1 6:1<127<1 @7361348
6:56 6:1 E;59369228 :54 5@@1E614 6:98 5<<53?1G136 534 :5=1
5;;7J14 6:98 86561 72 52259<8 67 @73693>1 27< 7=1< G53I
I15<8 534 6:1<127<1 6:1I 5<1 1867EE14 2<7G 37J @;59G93?
6:56 6:1<1 J58 37 E5<696973 72 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918
:1
6:1<127<1 @7361348 6:56 6:1 9GE>?314 F>4?G136 534
-9-
41@<11 E58814 HI 6:1
<95;
5;87 @7361348 6:56 6:1
6:56 6:1
1=13>1
<95;
7><6 G1<968 9361<21<13@1
:1
7><6 494 376 3769@1 6:1 25@6
1@7<48 86774 93 6:1 35G18 72 412134536
27< 5 ;73? 69G1 534 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 494 376
1KE;593 6:1 <15873 27< 376 5EE<75@:93? 6:1
15<;9186 E7936 72 69G1
7><6 56 6:1
:1 6:1<127<1 @7361348 6:56 6:1
E;59369228 :5=1 ;786 6:19< <9?:6 67 @;59G 27< E5<696973
&
6:1 ;15<314 @7>381; 27< 6:1 E;59369228
@73613414 6:56 6:1 <1;569738:9E 72 6:1 E;59369228 J96:
412134536
67 # 98 376 93 498E>61
1 @7361348 6:56
412134536
7 " 93 :98 J<96613 86561G136 494 376 498E>61
6:1 25@6 6:56 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 J1<1 196:1< 7J314 534
E78818814 HI
53>G536:5EE5 7<
6:1I 4914 936186561
>;9?5GG5 534 6:56
1 6:1<127<1 @7361348 6:56
E;59369228 H193? 6:1 ;5J2>; :19<8 72
6:1
53>G536:5EE5 534
>;9?5GG5 5<1 13696;14 67 53 1M>5; 8:5<1 HI =9<6>1 72
1@6973
72 6:1
934>
>@@188973
@6
. /
:>8 :1
@7361348 6:56 6:1 9GE>?314 F>4?G136 534 41@<11 E58814
- 10 -
HI 6:1
<95;
7><6 98 F>86 534 E<7E1< 534 4718 376 J5<<536
53I 9361<21<13@1 56 6:1 :5348 72 6:98
7><6
(1 :5=1 @738941<14 6:1 8>HG9889738 72 6:1
;15<314 @7>381; 27< 412134536
78 " 534 # 58 J1;; 58 6:1
;15<314 @7>381; 27< 6:1 E;59369228
.
:1 73;I E7936 6:56 5<9818 27< @738941<56973 93
6:98 5EE15; 98 58 >341<
N(:16:1< 6:1<1 J58 8>229@9136 1=9413@1 27<
6:1
<95;
7><6 67 41@<11 6:1 8>96 27<
E5<696973OP
!
:1 E;59369228 8E1@929@5;;I 5=1<<14 93 6:1 E;5936
6:56 6:1 ;5348 H15<93?
><=1I
78 ".!
9@:5;9
9;;5?1 86774 93 6:1 35G1 72
5261<
:1<
4156:
J1<1
G6
8>@@11414
"..
# . " 72
:11G5LL5 534
HI
:1<
53>G536:5EE5 534 ;561< 5261< :98 4156: J1<1 8>@@11414
HI 6:1 E;59369228 534 412134536
@73613414 6:56 6:1 ;5348 93
54;5E><
67 #
9L1J981 6:1I
><=1I
><=1I
7 " / 72
9@:5;9
9;;5?1 534 6:1 ;534 93
- 11 -
9;;5?1 J58 7J314 534 E78818814 HI
53>G536:5EE5 534
5261< :98 4156:
96 J58 8>@@11414 HI 6:1 E;59369228 534
4121345368
67 #
:1I 5;87 5=1<<14 6:56 ;5348 93
534 #"
" 72
><=1I
7 #"
9@:5;9
9;;5?1 86774 93 6:1
35G1 72
>;9?5GG5 534 5261< :1< 4156:
4121345368
6:1I 534
67 # :54 8>@@11414 67 53 1M>5; 8:5<1
:1I 5;87 @73613414 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 534 412134536
67 # J1<1 G1GH1<8 72 5 F7936 25G9;I 534 6:56 6:1
8>96 E<7E1<6918 J1<1 6:19< 53@186<5; F7936 25G9;I E<7E1<6918
534 6:56 6:1I J1<1 H193? @>;69=5614 F7936;I HI 6:1 E;59369228
534 412134536
412134536
?76 :1< 35G1 1361<14 93 <18E1@6 67 6:1
;534 H15<93?
><=1I
67 #
><=1I
7 ".! " 72
:1I 5;87 @73613414 6:56
9@:5;9
54;5E><
9;;5?1 534
9;;5?1- J:9;1 412134536
?76 :98 35G1 1361<14 93 <18E1@6 72 ;5348 93
" 534
72 ;5348 93
9@:5;9
><=1I
54;5E><
1361<14 93 6:1
1=13>1
><=1I
9;;5?1 534 5;87 93 <18E1@6
78 ".. " # . " #"
9;;5?1- J:9;1
7"
412134536
534 #"
" 72
7 # ?76 :98 35G1
1@7<48 93 <18E1@6 72 ;5348 93
- 12 -
><=1I
"
><=1I
78 ".. "
54;5E><
# . "
#"
534 #"
9;;5?1- J:9;1 412134536
<18E1@6 72 ;534 93
7" /
412134536
><=1I
><=1I
9;;5?1 534 ;5348 93
" 72
9@:5;9
?76 :1< 35G1 1361<14 93
9@:5;9
9;;5?1- J:9;1
?76 :1< 35G1 1361<14 93 <18E1@6 72 ;534 93
7 " / " 72
9@:5;9
9;;5?1
12134536
7 " J:7
29;14 :98 J<96613 86561G136 494 376 413I 6:1 5H7=1 25@68
>6 73 6:1 @736<5<I :1 @73613414 6:56 6:1 4121345368
J1<1 93 E788188973 72 6:1 E<7E1<6918 27< 5 ;73? 69G1 534
6:56 6:1 E;59369228 :54 5@M>918@14 6:98 86561 72 52259<8
5;87
@73613414
6:56
6:1
E;59369228
5<1
F7936
E788188973 72 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 534 6:56 6:1I J1<1 376
13696;14 67 53I 8:5<1
1 5;87 @;59G14 6:56 893@1 6:1
4121345368 J1<1 93 E788188973 72 6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 27<
7=1< "! I15<8 6:1I :54 E1<21@614 6:19< 696;1 HI 54=1<81
E788188973
:98 6:1<127<1 1865H;98:18 H1I734 47>H6 6:56
6:1 4121345368 5@L37J;14?14 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 534
412134536
67 # J1<1 13696;14 67 >349=9414 8:5<1 93
6:1 8>96 E<7E1<6918 58 6:1I :54 5;; 93:1<9614 6:1 8>96
- 13 -
E<7E1<6918 2<7G 6:19< E5<1368
H127<1 6:1
E;59369228
<95;
:1<1 98 37 G561<95; E;5@14
7><6 67 498H1;91=1 6:1 @581 72 6:1
:1 4121345368 494 376 1=13 1361< 6:1 J963188
H7K 67 498@<1496 6:1 1=9413@1 544>@14 HI
(
("
:1I 494 376 E<74>@1 53I 47@>G1368 67 1865H;98: 6:56 6:1I
:54 53I 9341E134136 696;1 67 6:1 E<7E1<6918
:1<127<1 93
=91J 72 6:1 >3498E>614 25@68 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 534
412134536
67 # 5<1 89H;93?8 534 :54 93:1<9614 6:1
E<7E1<6918 72 6:19< E5<1368
6:
>349=9414
:1
<95;
6:1I J1<1 13696;14 67 53
8:5<1 15@: 93 6:1 8>96 8@:14>;1 E<7E1<6918
7><6 :58 @738941<14 6:1 85G1 93 6:1 <9?:6
E1<8E1@69=1 534 :58 <9?:6;I :1;4 6:56 6:1 E;59369228 5<1
13696;14 67
6:
8:5<1 93 6:1 8>96 8@:14>;1 E<7E1<6918
(1
47 376 2934 53I 1<<7< 93 6:1 5EE<1@956973 72 1=9413@1 HI 6:1
<95;
7><6 534 6:1 F>4?G136 534 41@<11 E58814 41@;5<93?
6:56 6:1 E;59369228 5<1 13696;14 67
8@:14>;1 E<7E1<6918
538J1<
6:1
E7936
6:
8:5<1 93 6:1 8>96
3 6:56 =91J 72 6:1 G5661<
27<
@738941<56973
2<5G14
HI
J1
>8
- 14 -
5@@7<493?;I
13@1
6:98 5EE15; ;5@L8 G1<96 534 98
5@@7<493?;I 5EE15;
+(
'
!)
!
+(
'
;
"/
!
!
&
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review