Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/narasappa-vs-bheemayya-20260120/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Civil

Narasappa vs Bheemayya

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Karnataka High Court
Date
20 January 2026
Case No.
RFA 200162/2025
Result
Partly allowed
Bench
R.nataraj, Tyagaraja N. Inavally
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

-1- ! " # # $ $ % "" & ) ! " SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA # ! # $ % ! ' ( -2- ! & ' ( $ ) ! $ Deleted vide court order dated 11.11.2025 * ! " ## ! # # ! + $ " -3- ! $ ! , $ ! ) $ ! $ ' $ ( ! * % $ ! ! $ $ -4- ! ! & ' " # . . "!" " ( $ " - * % *# "! % - !* "!"# % - % -- $ / % % / % % $ ' / 01 2131425467 % " # 542 %( 8 *# "! 05:1 39;12 6097 5<<15; =05;;14>94> 601 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 25612 " !* "!"# CD E09=0 601 7@96 38B 21=;5B56984 83 696;1 -5- 83 601 <;59469337 542 68 21=;5B1 6056 601 ;854 B59712 CD 601 213142546 8 # 3B8A 601 213142546 57 486 C94294> 84 8 *# "! E57 39;12 38B 5 601 <;59469337 E57 21=B112 " 01 7@96 94 21=;5B56984 6056 601 <;59469337 5B1 601 5C78;@61 8E41B7 83 7@96 7=012@;1 <B8<1B6D 542 38B <1B<16@5; 94?@4=6984 542 68 21=;5B1 6056 601 ;854 B59712 CD 601 213142546 601 213142546 8 # 3B8A CD =B15694> =05B>1 8:1B 601 7@96 <B8<1B6D 97 9;;1>5; @41438B=15C;1 542 486 C94294> 83 601 <;59469337 542 38B =8471F@14695; B1;913 83 B1=6939=56984 83 B1:14@1 B1=8B27 01 <;59469337 =;59A12 6056 601 7@96 <B8<1B6D E57 <@B=05712 CD 6019B 35601B 54@A54605 3B8A 54>5 !" ! 54@A5 , * 601B15361B 097 45A1 E57 1461B12 94 601 B1:14@1 B1=8B27 01 7592 54@A5 , 54@A54605 2912 # D15B7 <B98B 68 601 39;94> 83 601 7@96 ;15:94> C10942 097 38@B 7847 45A12 011A5DD5 09AA5DD5 5>5B122D , 5B575<<5 542 6E8 25@>061B7 45A12 4?545AA5 01 79H =09;2B14 83 5>5<<5 542 09AA5GG5 542 54@A5 , 54@A54605 -6- 052 7@==11212 68 097 <B8<1B6917 542 601D 5;; =847696@612 5 ?8946 35A9;D 01D =;59A12 6056 94 8B21B 68 5:59; ;854 3B8A 39454=95; 947696@69847 542 C54G7 542 5;78 5:59; 7@=0 8 8<1B569:1 78=916917 35=9;96917 <B8:9212 CD 8:1B4A146 601D >86 6019B 45A17 1461B12 94 601 B1:14@1 B1=8B27 94 B17<1=6 83 <8B69847 83 601 7@96 <B8<1B6D 8E1:1B 601B1 E57 48 <5B696984 8B 29:97984 5A84>76 601A 01D =;59A12 6056 601 213142546 8 " 542 0@7C542 83 213142546 1461B12 94 B17<1=6 83 ! I I "!! 61BA7 !) 54@A54605 35601B 83 213142546 8 # >86 6019B 45A17 5=B17 !" >@4657 94 A@656984 <B8=11294>7 =;59A94> 68 C1 601 784 83 9G1E971 601 213142546 9461BB12 94 B17<1=6 83 ! @B:1D 54@A5 , 8 " >86 097 45A1 >@4657 94 097 45A1 57 601 784 83 601 <;5946933 8) 01D =;59A12 6056 E09;1 601 <;59469337 C1;84>12 68 8;;5 =5761 601 2131425467 C1;84>12 68 29>5 5761 542 E09;1 601 <;59469337J 7@B45A1 E57 7@B45A1 2131425467 E57 52E5; 601 525>5A528229 01B138B1 601 <;59469337 =;59A12 6056 601D 5B1 486 B1;5612 -7- 68 601 2131425467 94 54D A5441B 542 6056 601 B1:14@1 B1=8B27 CB8@>06 5C8@6 CD 601 2131425467 5B1 5;; 3B5@2@;146 542 5B1 486 C94294> @<84 601 <;59469337 6056 213142546 01D 5;78 =;59A12 8 # 052 5:59;12 5 ;854 3B8A 601 213142546 84 601 71=@B96D 83 601 <B8<1B6D 542 6056 601 75A1 E57 486 C94294> @<84 601A # 056 7@AA847 94 601 7@96 E57 71B:12 84 601 2131425467 01 2131425467 76561A146 8E1:1B 6019B =8@471; B169B12 3B8A 601 =571 01B15361B 601 213142546 39;12 5 EB96614 292 486 5<<15B 542 292 486 <5B69=9<561 94 601 6B95; C@6 B1A59412 5C7146 213142546 39;12 097 EB96614 76561A146 542 =;59A12 6056 96 E57 486 5E5B1 83 601 5771B69847 A521 94 <5B5 " 68 83 601 <;5946 6 =84614612 6056 96 052 754=698412 5 ;854 68 213142546 8 # 94 5==8B254=1 E960 ;5E 542 57 <1B 601 <B17=B9C12 <B8=12@B1 542 =;59A12 6056 601 <;59469337 05:1 48 B9>06 68 711G 38B 5 21=B11 6056 601 ;854 5:59;12 CD 213142546 :892 8 # 3B8A 213142546 97 9;;1>5; 4@;; 542 -8- 5712 84 60171 B9:5; =8461469847 601 6B95; 8@B6 3B5A12 977@17 542 716 28E4 601 =571 38B 6B95; 01 <;5946933 A5BG12 H 213142546 E57 1H5A9412 57 #" 542 1H5A9412 $" 542 $# 292 486 =B877 1H5A941 60171 E96417717 542 292 486 ;152 54D 1:9214=1 $ E57 1H5A9412 57 $ 542 A5BG12 01 213142546 H # 5712 84 601 5C8:1 542 65G94> 9468 5==8@46 601 35=6 6056 601 213142546 6B95; 052 486 =84617612 601 7@96 601 8@B6 21=B112 601 7@96 83 601 <;59469337 542 21=;5B12 6056 601 <;59469337 5B1 601 8E41B7 83 601 7@96 <B8<1B6D 542 5;78 01;2 6056 601 ;854 5:59;12 CD 601 213142546 601 213142546 8 # 3B8A 292 486 C942 601 <;59469337 194> 5>>B91:12 CD 601 7592 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 601 213142546 5B1 C138B1 6097 8@B6 01 ;15B412 =8@471; 38B 213142546 7@CA96612 6056 601 2131425467 E1B1 @45E5B1 5C8@6 601 21=B11 <57712 57 6019B 5ED1B 052 B169B12 3B8A 601 =571 542 601D 052 48 9469A56984 6056 601 =571 <B8=11212 1H -9- <5B6D 1 =8461427 6056 601 B95; 8@B6 057 >B54612 5 21=B11 83 21=;5B56984 94 601 35=1 83 :5B98@7 B1:14@1 28=@A1467 E09=0 9429=5612 6056 213142546 E1B1 601 8E41B7 83 601 <B8<1B6D 94 F@176984 542 601B138B1 7@CA967 6056 54 8<<8B6@496D 2171B:17 68 C1 >B54612 68 601 2131425467 68 =846176 601 7@96 84 A1B967 1 601B138B1 <B5D7 6056 601 9A<@>412 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 C1 716 57921 542 54 8<<8B6@496D C1 >B54612 68 601 2131425467 68 =846176 601 7@96 84 A1B967 ) 601 ;15B412 =8@471; 38B 601 <;59469337 =84614212 6056 601 >B54235601B 83 601 <;59469337 052 <@B=05712 601 <B8<1B6D 94 61BA7 83 5 :5;92 75;1 2112 94 601 D15B * 1 5;78 =8461427 6056 601 <;59469337 5B1 486 B1;5612 68 601 2131425467 94 54D A5441B E056781:1B =8461427 6056 601 2131425467 05:1 65G14 52:5465>1 83 601 79A9;5B96D 94 601 45A17 83 601 35601B 83 601 <;59469337 542 6019B 35601B 542 05:1 CB8@>06 5C8@6 :5B98@7 B1:14@1 146B917 94 6019B B17<1=69:1 45A17 94 B17<1=6 83 601 7@96 <B8<1B6D 601B138B1 =8461427 1:14 - 10 - 8<<8B6@496D 97 >9:14 68 213142546 601D E9;; 486 C1 94 5 <8796984 68 <B8:1 6019B 21314=1 57 601D 5B1 94 48 E5D B1;5612 68 601 <;59469337 542 601D C1;84> 68 6E8 29331B146 =57617 542 C1;84> 68 6E8 29331B146 08@7108;27 1 601B138B1 =8461427 6056 48 @713@; <@B<871 E8@;2 C1 71B:12 94 B1768B94> 601 7@96 542 5;;8E94> 54 8<<8B6@496D 68 601 2131425467 68 =846176 601 7@96 84 A1B967 $1 05:1 =847921B12 7@CA9779847 A521 CD 601 ;15B412 =8@471; 38B 601 <;59469337 542 601 ;15B412 =8@471; 38B 213142546 C138B1 @7 542 <1B@712 601 B1=8B27 <;5=12 01 84;D <8946 6056 5B9717 38B 8@B =847921B56984 94 6097 5<<15; 97 KE01601B 54 8<<8B6@496D 057 68 C1 >B54612 68 213142546 68 =846176 601 7@96 84 A1B967LM * 6 97 765612 94 601 ?@2>A146 <57712 CD 601 8@B6 9671;3 6056 601 B95; 2:8=561 38B 213142546 B169B12 3B8A 601 =571 542 6056 213142546 486 <5B69=9<561 94 601 7@96 542 292 486 ;152 54D 1:9214=1 01 2131425467 =;59A12 696;1 68 =1B6594 <8B69847 83 601 7@96 - 11 - <B8<1B6D 01 <;59469337 5B1 5;78 =;59A94> 696;1 68 601 ;542 @B:1D 01B138B1 608@>0 601 2131425467 E1B1 486 29;9>146 94 21314294> 601 7@96 1:14 5361B 601D 14>5>12 2:8=561 D16 601D =54486 C1 =8421A412 @4015B2 01 94=84:14914=1 =5@712 68 601 <;59469337 =54 C1 7@965C;D =8A<1475612 542 601 2131425467 =54 C1 <@6 84 61BA7 78 57 68 147@B1 6056 601D 28 486 3@B601B <B86B5=6 601 <B8=11294>7 ?@769=1 097 E8@;2 5;78 7@C 71B:1 601 1427 83 8471F@146;D E1 5B1 83 601 8<94984 6056 608@>0 601 2131425467 05:1 486 A521 8@6 54 1H6B58B2945BD =571 38B @<716694> 601 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 <57712 CD 601 8@B6 B95; D16 794=1 601 9A<@>412 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 5331=67 601 <B8<B9165BD B9>06 696;1 542 9461B176 83 213142546 94 601 7@96 <B8<1B6917 54 8<<8B6@496D 2171B:17 68 C1 >B54612 68 213142546 84 A1B967 68 =846176 601 7@96 ==8B294>;D 601 <8946 38B =847921B56984 3B5A12 CD @7 97 547E1B12 94 35:8@B 83 213142546 ! 4 :91E 83 601 5C8:1 E1 <577 601 38;;8E94> - 12 - 9( 01 5<<15; 97 5;;8E12 94 <5B6 99( 01 9A<@>412 ?@2>A146 542 21=B11 <57712 CD 601 B95; 8@B6 97 716 57921 01 7@96 C138B1 601 B95; 8@B6 97 B1768B12 7@C?1=6 68 <5DA146 83 =876 ! !!! <5D5C;1 CD 213142546 68 <;5946933 68 ) 8B 6019B ;1>5; B1<B17146569:17 94 1F@5; <8B69847 C138B1 601 B95; 8@B6 84 601 41H6 2561 83 015B94> 999( 6 97 A521 =;15B 6056 93 213142546 B95; 359; 68 <5D 601 =876 601 8@B6 705;; B1961B561 ?@2>A146 <57712 84 " 9:( B95; !* "!"# 8@B6 705;; 3B5A1 3B170 977@17 93 41=1775BD 84 601 41H6 2561 83 015B94> 542 B1=8B2 601 1:9214=1 542 =B877 1H5A9456984 83 601 <;59469337 601 977@17 ?@7693D B171B:94> 601 B9>06 68 ;152 B1C@665; 1:9214=1 CD <;59469337 B95; 2131425467 8@B6 A5D 28 78 705;; 5;78 ;152 6019B - 13 - 1:9214=1 C138B1 601 B95; 8@B6 542 5;78 A5G1 601A71;:17 5:59;5C;1 38B =B877 1H5A9456984 CD 601 <;59469337 B95; 8@B6 705;; B171B:1 ;9C1B6D 68 601 <;59469337 68 ;152 54D B1C@665; 1:9214=1 :( B95; 8@B6 705;; 14215:8B 68 297<871 83 601 7@96 E96094 5 <1B982 83 79H A84607 3B8A 601 2561 83 601 <5B6917 =84=;@294> 6019B 1:9214=1 :9( 01 <;59469337 705;; 5<<15B C138B1 601 B95; 8@B6 84 "! !" "!" *' & ( *' & '<B5 '<5B5 976 8 ( 68 142( ; 8 "* % (

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Karnataka HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →