Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
KHOIROM Digitally
KHOIROM
SINGH
BIPINCHAN BIPINCHANDRA
Date: 2024.03.04
DRA SINGH 13:57:53 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(C) No. 424 of 2022
1.
Nameirakpam Nodiachand Singh, aged about 85 years,
son of late N. Thambaljao Singh, resident of Uripok
Yambem Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District – Imphal
West, Manipur.
2.
Sarangthem Kulla Singh, aged about 86 years, son late
S. Jatra Singh, resident of Uripok Yambem Leikai, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, District Imphal West, Manipur.
3.
Sairem Angou Singh, aged about 73 years, son of late S.
Nilakomol Singh, resident of Uripok Khoisnam Leikai,
P.O & P.S. Imphal, Manipur.
…. Petitioners
- Versus –
1. The
State
of
Manipur
represented
by
Secretary/Commissioner, Education (S), Government of
Manipur, South Block, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
District: Imphal West, Manipur.
2. The Director of Education (S), Government of Manipur, at
Lamphelpat near DC Office Complex, PO & PS Lamphel,
District: Imphal West, Manipur.
3. The Zonal Education Officer, Zone-I, Government of
Manipur at Lamphelpat DC Office Complex, PO & PS
Lamphel, District: Imphal West, Manipur.
4. The Head Master, Sakhi Devi Girls’ High School, Uripok, PO
& PS Imphal, District : Imphal West, Manipur.
5. L. Prameshwar Singh, Member of School managing
Committee of Sakhi Devi Girls’ High School, Uripok PO & PS
Imphal, District: Imphal West, Manipur.
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 1
6. Dr. W. Chandrakanta Singh, Member of School Managing
Committee of Sakhi Devi Girls’ High School, Uripok PO & PS
Imphal, Distrct: Imphal West, Manipur.
7. M. Geeta Devi, Member of School Management Committee
of Sakhi Devi Girls’ High School.
…. Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Th. Henba, Advocate
For the respondents :
Mr. S. Nepolean, Government Advocate
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, Sr. Advocate
Date of hearing
16.02.2023
:
Date of Judgment &
Order
:
29.02.2024
JUDGMENT&ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. Th. Henba, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, Mr. S. Nepolean, learned GA appearing for the State and Mr. Kh.
Tarunkumar, learned senior advocate assisted by Ms. Kh. Nirmala, Advocate
appearing for the respondents No. 4 to 8.
[2]
In the year 1972, the Sakhi Devi Girls’ High School was
established in the name of the mother of petitioner No. 1. Vide order dated
29.08.1974, the constitution of the said school was approved by the
Government of Manipur and also directed to form regular committee based
on the constitution. The petitioner No. 1 is the founder of the school,
petitioner No. 2 is one of the donors and petitioner No. 3 is one of the
subscribers of the school. On 01.10.1980, the Government of Manipur had
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 2
sanctioned Grant-in-aid to the school with 3(three) numbers of approved
teaching staff and 1 number of approved non-teaching staff.
[3]
As per the approved rule i.e. The Manipur Aided High and
Higher Secondary School (Managing Committee) Rules, 1975 vide order
dated 30.01.1975, every Government Aided High School shall be governed
by a Managing Committee. Accordingly, first Managing Committee of the
school, after having sanction of government Grant-in-Aid School vide order
dated 01.10.1980, was formed and the same was sent for approval to the
Inspector of Schools, the Managing Committee consisting of 9 (nine)
members was approved vide order dated 22.12.1980 of the Inspector of
Schools, Zone-I, Government of Manipur.
[4]
As per the Rules, 1975, after election and nomination of the
members are over, all the members of the managing committee shall elect
the president and secretary simultaneously from amongst the members, but
head master and teaching representatives shall not be eligible for the said
election.
[5]
Since the managing committee constituted vide order dated
23.09.2017 is going to expire, the respondent No. 3 i.e. ZEO (Z-I) informed
the head master of the school (respondent No. 4) through official letter
dated 20.07.2020 to submit the name of the members for constitution of
new managing committee as per the Rule, 1975. Based on the meeting the
school managing committee held on 08.08.2020, resolutions have made in
connection with election of guardian representatives to be held on
14.10.2020, enlistment of other members for constitution of new SMC
(school management committee) in time and publication in local daily for
advertisement of necessary information for the election as per the
resolutions No. 1, 2 and 5 respectively.
[6]
After
holding
election
of
guardian
representatives
on
14.10.2020 with 7 (seven) members whereby, M. Geeta Devi and H. Jina
Sharma were elected uncontested as guardian representatives, a notification
dated 18.12.2020 issued by the head master of the school for election of one
donor and one subscriber representative for formation of the SMC to be held
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 3
on 13.01.2021 was published in local daily on 19.12.2020. However, the
head master submitted a proposed list of SMC without representative of
donor and subscriber on 16.02.2021 on the premises that the existing SMC
expires on 16.03.2021 and the ZEO (Zone-I), Imphal West, Government of
Manipur approved the SMC of the school constituted vide order dated
04.03.2021 of the ZEO (Zone-I), Imphal West, impugned herein, as per the
resolution of the SMC meeting held on 14.10.2020. The order dated
04.03.2021 is reproduced herein below:
“Annexure – A/9
GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
OFFICE OF THE ZONAL EDUCATION OFFICER, ZONE-I
KHOYATHONG, IMPHAL – 795001
ORDERS
Imphal the 4th March, 2021
No. 6/6/2021-ED(Z-I)/Aided:
The
School
Managing
Committee of Shakhi Devi Girls’ H/S, Imphal (Aided) newly constituted
as per resolution no. 1 and 2 of the School Managing Committee held
on 14.10.2020 consisting of the following members is hereby approved
with immediate effect.
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Name of member/office
bearer
N. Nodiachand Singh
S. Tomba Singh (H/M, I/C)
L. Prameshwar Singh
Dr. W. Chandrakanta Singh
A. Bimola Devi
M. Geeta Devi
H. Jina Devi
A.I. Concerned
Designation
Founder
Ex-Officio Member
Local Educationalist
Medical Representative
Local Educationalist
Guardian Representative
Guardian Representative
Teacher Representative
Donor
Subscriber
Govt. Nominee
The order is issued in pursuance of the Provision contained Chapter
– VI, Section-I, Rule-2 of the Manipur Education Code, 1982.
Sd/(SuchetaKhumukcham)
Zonal Education Officer, Zone-I
Government of Manipur”
[7]
Despite objection made by the petitioner No. 1 that the SMC
was illegally formed, as per the resolution of the SMC meeting held on
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 4
13.03.2021, A. Bimola Devi and L. Prameswar Singh were re-elected as
president and secretary respectively of the committee vide order dated
20.03.2021, impugned herein, which reads as under:
“Annexure –A/12
GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
OFFICE OF THE ZONAL EDUCATION OFFICER, ZONE-I
KHUYATHONG, IMPHAL-795001
ORDERS
Imphal, 20th March, 2021
No.6/6/2021-ED(Z-I)/Aided :
Election of the following members
as Office bearers of the School Managing Committee of Shakhi Devi Girls’
High School (Aided) vide resolution no. 1 and 2 of dated 13.03.2021 is
hereby approved.
1.
2.
Smt. A. Bimola Devi
Shri L. Prameshor Singh
-
President
Secretary
Sd/(Sucheta Khumukcham)
Zonal Education Officer, Zone-I
Government of Manipur”
On the basis of the applications submitted by Shri S. Kulla
Singh and Sairem Angouba Singh who had been elected as donor and
subscriber representatives, even though the head master intimated to the
ZEO (Zone-I) for inclusion of their names in the list of SMC, no action has
been taken up by the ZEO (Zone-I).
[8]
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submitted
that the constitution of the SMC of the school was illegal inasmuch as the
same was not in conformity with the relevant provisions of the Rules, 1975.
Therefore, the petitioner No. 1 submitted his representation dated
28.03.2022 to the ZEO (Zone-I), Imphal West with copy to the Director
Education (S), Government of Manipur. However, no action has been taken
up.
Accordingly, the present writ petition has been filed praying for
issuance of a writ of certiorari for quashing the order No. 6/6/2021-ED(ZI)/Aided dated 04.03.2021 of the ZEO (Zone-I) approving the constitution of
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 5
the school management committee and also the order of even number dated
20.03.2021 of ZEO(Zone-I) approving the election of the office bearer of the
school management committee of the school aforementioned.
On perusal of the order dated 04.03.2021 of the ZEO, Zone-I
as reproduced above and order dated 20.03.2021 of ZEO, Zone-I thereby
approving the election of the office bearer of the school managing committee
as reproduced above and on perusal of the steps taken by the headmaster of
the school and further perusal of “The Manipur Aided High and Higher
Secondary School (Managing Committee) Rules, 1975” and in the absence of
specific instructions made in the said Rules in regard to the constitution of
the school managing committee, I am of the view that the allegation made
by the petitioner that the constitution of the school managing committee of
the school was illegal cannot be sustained.
[9]
The learned GA appearing the respondents has filed their
objection stating that the petitioner No. 1, who is stated to be founder of the
school, is not infirmity with the documents annexed in the instant writ
petition and is not the founder of the school. Vide order dated 29.08.1974
issued by the Inspector of Schools, Central District, Z-I, the name of the
petitioner No. 1 was reflected as former secretary of the school. Further, in
the order dated 22.12.1980 issued by the Inspector of Schools, Zone –I,
Government of Manipur, Th. Sakhi Devi has been recorded as founder of the
school and the name of the petitioner was recorded as donor of the school
and therefore, there cannot be two founders in the school. Moreover, there
is also a girls’ school namely, Ibotonsana Girls’ Higher Secondary School
within the radius of 500 metres from the said school. The petitioners No. 2 &
3, who have claimed as donor and subscriber of the school, have never
applied to become a donor and subscriber of the school despite notice being
published in the local daily. Moreover, their records are also not available in
the school.
It is further submitted that no illegality was committed by the
SMC that the writ appeal being W.A. No. 55 of 2022 was allowed by the
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court vide order dated 14.06.2022 wherein,
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 6
the judgment & order dated 08.02.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No. 822 of 2017
was quashed and set aside. The Hon’ble Court also held that all the
consequential proceeding issued in pursuance of the judgment & order will
stand nullified.
[10]
The learned GA further submits that when the said newly
constituted SMC was approved by the ZEO, Zone-I, Government of Manipur
on 04.03.2021, impugned herein, the petitioner No. 1 did not raise any
objection. Only when the notice was issued by the Headmaster (I/C) of the
school for election of president and secretary of the SMC, the petitioner No.
1 made objection without raising any reason except mentioning that there is
objection. The inclusion of donor and subscriber in the SMC of the said
school was also done by following due process of law and provision of the
Rules, 1975. There is no violation of the rules. In respect of election of the
guardian representatives, M. Geeta Devi and H. Jina Sharma@Devi were
elected as un-contest guardian representatives since they have submitted
their
applications
to
be
nominated/elected/appointed
as
guardian
representatives. No other applicants have submitted their applications before
the election except the two elected applicants aforementioned.
It has also been submitted that at the relevant point of time,
there was only one approved teacher in the school who is now holding the
post of Headmaster on in-charge basis and as such, the approved teacher of
the school was elected as teachers’ representative. Accordingly, there is no
any illegality in electing the only approved teacher of the school as teachers’
representative of the SMC of the school.
[11]
Further, it has been submitted by the learned GA that as
proposed by the Headmaster (I/C) of the school, the ZEO, Zone-I has
nominated
the
four
persons
namely,
L.
Prameshwor
Singh
(Local
Educationalist), Dr. W. Chandrakanta Singh (Medical Representative/Local
Educationalist), A. Bimola Devi (Local Educationalist) and the concerned
Assistant Inspector of School as government nominee, as the same has
already been approved.
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 7
[12]
The petitioners have filed their affidavit-in-rejoinder to the
affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondents stating that relevant
documents of becoming founder of the school are in the custody of SMC.
When enquiry through RTI, vide letter dated 14.02.2023 of the SPIO/ZEOZone-I, only 6 (six) documents have been furnished to the petitioners
relating to approval of SMC stating that most of the documents relating to
approval of constitution of SMC are misplaced due to frequent shifting of this
zonal office from one place to another. The writ appeal being W.A. No. 55 of
2022 was allowed on technical ground such as non-impleadment of
necessary party.
[13]
The main contention raised by the respondents herein are The petitioners have no locus standi to file the present petition
as the petitioner No. 1 himself is included in the list of committee members
constituted vide 04.03.2021 issued by Zonal Education Officer, Zone – I. In
the said order the name of the petitioner No. 1 appears at Sl. No. 1 as
founder. However, the learned GA submits that in the order dated
29.09.2014 issued by the Inspector of School, Central District, Zone-I, the
name of the petitioner No. 1 was recorded as donor of the school. It is
further submitted that the petitioner No. 2 & 3 who claim themselves as
donor and subscriber of the school, have never applied to become a donor
and subscriber despite notice being published in the local daily. In support of
their
case,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents
relied
upon“Commissioner of Income Tax, Calcutta V. M/s Braithwaite & Co. Ltd.
[(1993) 2 SCC 262]” and the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Para No. 8 observed
that “8.
We find support in view taken by us in the following cases. In
Ramanasari V. MuthusamiNaik Section 18 of the Madras Rent
Recovery Act VIII of 1865 required that, in fixing the day of sale, not
less than seven days must be allowed from the time of the public
notice and not less than 30 days from the date of distraint. The sale
was held on February 13, but the notice was published on February
6. It was held that ‘not less than’ means the same as “clear” and
seven whole days must elapse between the day of the notice and the
day fixed for sale. In Railway Sleepers Supply Company, Re2 the
expression “not less than” given number of days means “clear days”.
It was held that the expression “not less” indicates “a minimum”.”
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 8
The learned GA submits that 2 (two) guardian representatives
namely, M. Geeta Devi and H. JinaSharma@Devi were elected as guardian
representatives as they were the only guardians who submitted the
applications to be nominated/appointed/elected as guardian representatives
of the school managing committee and they were appointed after duly
notified in one of the local daily newspapers.
The learned GA further submits that there is a gap of one
month between the period of the constitution of school managing committee
and its approval.Inspite of this gap, the petitioners were silent without
raising any objection, as such the constitution of the school managing
committee and its election of Smt. A. Bimola Devi and L. Prameshwor Singh
as president and secretary, becomes legal. Further, it is submitted that the
inclusion of donor and subscriber in the school managing committee of the
aforesaid school was done by due process of law and provision of the High
and Higher Secondary School (Managing Committee) Rules, 1975.
Further, it is submitted by the learned GA that at the relevant
time of the formation of the committee, there was only one approved in the
above said school, as such, the said approved teacher was appointed/elected
as teachers’ representative. All these processes were done in the presence
and knowledge of the petitioner No. 1.
Further, the learned GA referred to Annexure – A/7 wherein, a
notice was issued by the Headmaster (I/C) of the school dated 18.12.2020
for election of the donor and subscriber for the formation of school managing
committee slated to be held on 13.01.2021.
For reference the Annexure-A/7 is extracted hereunder:
“OFFICE OF THE
SHAKHI DEVI GIRLS’ HIGH SCHOOL
GOVT. AIDED
URIPOK, IMPHAL
NOTICE
Imphal the 18th Dec. 2020
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 9
SH/D/G/H/S/2020.
It is hereby informed that the election
of one Donor and one Subscriber representative for the formation of
the SMC dated 13.01.2021 at 11 am. Any interested individuals must
apply for subscriber and donor on or before 11.01.2021. For details
contact H/M in-charge during office hour.
Sd/
S. Tomba Singh
i/c High Master
Shakhi Devi Girls’ School
Imphal”
Perused the Annexure – A/7 and the same is corroborated
with the submission made above by the learned GA.
Further, it is submitted the learned GA that the nomination of
[14]
the
said
(four)
persons
namely,
L.
Prameshwor
Singh
(Local
Educationalist), Dr. W. Chandrakanta Singh (Medical Representative/Local
Educationalist), A. Bimola Devi (Local Educationalist) and concerned
Assistant Inspector of School as government nominee, was approved by the
concerned authority already.
It is further submitted that the notice for the meeting for the
constitution of the committee was properly served to the petitioner No. 1 on
06.03.2021 and meeting for the nomination of the committee was fixed on
13.03.2021 as such, there is no ground to raise the allegation that the
petitioner No. 1 was not properly informed.
[15]
As per Rule 2 of the Manipur Aided High and Higher Secondary
School (Managing Committee) Rules, 1975 (hereinafter referred as the said
Rules, 1975), there should be a school managing committee which is to be
approved by the Inspector of Schools and Managing Committee shall consist
of (i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
Head Master (Ex-Officio member)
2 Teachers representatives to be elected by the
approved teaching staff excluding head master
2 Guardian Representatives to be elected by guardians
from among them whose names are entered in the
school Admission register.
1 member to be elected by donors (of not less than Rs.
500/-) from amongst themselves in the list.
Founder if any or a person nominated by him – founder
nominate his / her successor and shall furnish copies of
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 10
(vi)
(vii)
[16]
The main issues put up by the petitioner are –
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
[17]
this nomination to the head master and Director of
Education.
1 member to be elected by Subscribers of Rs. 25/- and
above annually from among themselves in the list.
4 members of which 1 is representative of Edn.
Dept. and 3 local persons interested in Education all
nominated by
Inspector of School and out of said
3 one will be a medical practitioner if any and one will be
a female member.
Whether there was election of Guardian Representatives
amongst them?
Whether there was election of Donors representative
amongst
them?
Whether 4 local member nominees from Education
Department shown in the SMC are really nominated:
Whether first meeting of newly constituted SMC held on
13.03.2020 by issuing notice dated 06.03.2020 was a
meeting
after issuing notice of clear 7 days as per
Rule 3 of the said Rules, 1975?
From perusal of the application of the petitioners as well as the
counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents of which are discussed
above and after hearing the learned counsels for the parties, I am of the
view that the election of the members of the school managing committee of
Sakhi Devi Girls’ High School which is impugned herein as Annexure – A/9
were done properly by taking proper steps by publication in the local daily
newspaper. The above issues put up by the learned counsel for the
petitioners are well answered and elaborately explained to the fact that the
constitution of the school managing committee was done properly as per
available Rules, 1975. The submissions made above by the learned counsel
for the respondents are sufficient to answer the above mentioned issues.
Mention is made herein that on perusal of the said Rules, there
is no specific guidelines for the election of the School Managing Committee
members, and in this situation, it is difficult to say that steps taken by the
authority are enough or not.
[18]
The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that after the
first meeting of the newly formed SMC was held on 13.03.2020, notice was
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 11
issued on 06.03.2020 thereby not complying with the provision of the said
Rules as the said Rules says 7 (seven) days’ notice is to be given. In this
regard, the learned counsel for the petitioners relied on “Pioneer Motors (P)
Ltd. V. Municipal Council [AIR 1967 SC 684]”. In Para No. 8, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that
“8.
The words “not being less than one month” do imply that clear one
month’s notice was necessary to be given, that is, both the first day and the
last day of the month had to be excluded. To put it in the language used by
Maxwell on Interpretation of Statutes, 10thEdn., P. 351:
“When …..’not less than’ so many days are to intervene, both the
terminal days are excluded from the computation.”
That does not seem to have been in the present case. But in order
to decide whether this portion of the proviso is a mandatory provision, it is
convenient to see the object for which it has been enacted. Under Section
78, the procedure is laid down for the levying of a new tax, which has to be
done by a resolution. But in the proviso, it is stated that before such a
resolution can be passed, a notice to that effect has to be published in the
Official Gazette and also in one Malayalam or Tamil newspaper having
circulation within the municipality. Then comes the period for inviting
objections. The object of notifying in the Gazette and Local Newspaper is
both to give notice to the public and particularly to the persons who are
likely to be taxed and to invite their objections. For this purpose, the proviso
required a reasonable period of not less than one month to be given. The
object of the provision is to give reasonable time and opportunity and it is
given as a guidance that reasonable time would be a month. The use of the
words “reasonable period” before the words “not being less than one
month” is significant. If sufficient time has been given for the invitation of
the objections which only just falls short of the period mentioned in the
proviso, then it would serve the object of the legislature. The provision in
regard to time in the context must be held to be directory and not
mandatory.”
[19]
But, in the present case, the school managing committee has
given sufficient time i.e. there is a gap of 1 (one) month between the
constitution of school managing committee and its approval. As such, the
above Hon’ble Supreme Court’s observation is not applicable in the present
case. Further, it is seen that the nomination of the said 4 persons namely, L.
Prameshwor Singh (Local Educationalist), Dr. W. Chandrakanta Singh
(Medical
Representative/Local
Educationalist),
A.
Bimola
Devi
(Local
Educationalist) and concerned Assistant Inspector of School and the same
was approved by the concerned authority already. Further, it is seen that the
notice for the meeting for the constitution of the committee was properly
served to the petitioner No. 1 on 06.03.2021 and meeting the nomination of
the committee was fixed on 13.03.2023 thereby showing that the petitioner
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 12
No. 1 was properly informed. It is further seen and satisfied that the
petitioners failed to show that they have the locus standi to file the present
petition.
[20]
Therefore, after having considered the facts and circumstances
of the case and in the background of the discussions made hereinabove and
on taking an overall view, I find no merit in the present writ petition,
accordingly, this writ petition is dismissed and disposed of.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Bipin
Writ Petition (C) No. 424 of 2022
Page 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review