Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
ON THE 31st OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. PETITION No. 2912 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM UJJAIN COMMISSIONER
CHATRAPATI SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
MANI SHANKAR S/O
(MADHYA PRADESH)
KALUJI GRAM NIMANWASA
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2907 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM UJJAIN COMMISSIONER
CHATARPATI SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
ANIL
S/O
RAMSWAROOP GRAM
BHERUNALA UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
IMLIPURA,
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
RESPONDENT [R-1].
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2908 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATARPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
RAKESH
S/O
SUKHRAM
DAUDKHEDI, (MADHYA PRADESH)
PARMAR VILALGE
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2909 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM UJJAIN COMMISSIONER
CHATRAPATI SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
DHARMENDRA S/O
(MADHYA PRADESH)
VISHNU GRAM
BHICHHODH
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2910 of 2020
BETWEEN:Signature Not Verified
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
MANISH S/O TEJULAL CHOUHAN GRAM TEKRIYAPET,
JILA UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2911 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
SURAJ S/O JITENDRA GRAM NIMANVASA, (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2913 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
MAHENDRA
S/O
(MADHYA PRADESH)
SAJAN GRAM
DOUDHKHEDI
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2914 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATARPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
AKHILESH S/O MADAN GRAM BHICHHODH (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2915 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM UJJAIN COMMISSIONER
CHATRAPATI SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
)
AND
ARUN S/O MAHENDRA GRAM NIMANWASA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
MISC. PETITION No. 2916 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER .
AND
PANKAJ S/O KALUJI GRAM BHICHHODH (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
MISC. PETITION No. 2917 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER .
)
AND
RAKESH
S/O
GOVARDHAN GRAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
NIMANWASA
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
MISC. PETITION No. 2918 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM UJJAIN COMMISSIONER
CHATRAPATI SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER )
AND
SANTOSH
S/O
MOHAN GRAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
BHICHHDAUDH
.....RESPONDENTS
(MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY APPEARED FOR RESPONDENT.
)
MISC. PETITION No. 2919 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
SHRI MUKESH RAV JADHAV, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER)
AND
NIRAJ S/O MOHAN GRAM KAITHA, TEH. TARANA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
MISC. PETITION No. 2920 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER)
AND
RAHUL S/O MOHANLAL GRAM BHICHHODH (MADHYA
PRADESH)
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
MISC. PETITION No. 2921 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM UJJAIN COMMISSIONER
CHATRAPATI SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER)
AND
SANTOSH S/O RADHESHYAM GRAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
BHICHHODH
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
MISC. PETITION No. 2922 of 2020
BETWEEN:NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM COMMISSIONER CHATRAPATI
SHIVAJI BHAVAN, AGAR ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI KAILASH VIJAYWARGIYA APPEARED FOR PETITIONER.
)
AND
SUMITABH S/O SURESH ATTI. VISHVA BANK COLONY
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
MISC. PETITION No. 2992 of 2020
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
BETWEEN:MUNICIPAL CORPORATION THR ITS COMMISSIONER
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(MS RACHANA ZAMINDAR , ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER)
AND
BHIM SINGH S/O SHRI BIHARILAL JAI SINGHPURA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAHESH KUMAR CHOUDHARY, ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
Heard on the question of admission and interim relief.
This order shall govern disposal of aforesaid batch of writ petitions,
viz..M.P. No. 2912/2020, M.P. No. 2907/2020, M.P. No. 2908/2020, M.P. No.
2909/2020, M.P. No. 2910/2020, M.P. No. 2911/2020, M.P. No. 2913/2020,
M.P. No. 2914/2020, M.P. No. 2915/2020, M.P. No. 2916/2020, M.P. No.
2917/2020,
M.P.
No.
2918/2020,
M.P.
No.
2919/2020,
M.P.
No.
2920/2020, M.P. no. 2921/2020, M.P. No. 2022/2020 & M.P. No. 2992/2020.
Regard being had to the similitude of the controversy involved in the
aforesaid cases, they have been heard analogously and disposed of by this
common order.
For the sake of convenience, facts of M.P. No.2912/2020 are taken up.
The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has
been filed by the petitioner being aggrieved by the order passed by the Labour
Court in case no. 148/2019/ID ACT(Ref) in award dated 01.07.2020.
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
2.
Facts giving rise to the present petition are that petitioner is a body
constitution under the provision of Nagar Palik Nigam Adhiniyam 1956[referred
to as "Act of 1956" hereinafter]. Respondent has filed statement of claim u/S 10
B and 2(A) of the Industrial Dispute Act (referred to as "ID Act" hereinafter)
before the Labour Court, Ujjain claiming that petitioner has given oral
appointment to the respondent on the post of daily wager on 10.03.2016 fixing
the salary of Rs. 5,500 p.m.Thereafter, in the year 2019 by an oral order,
service of respondent was discontinued without giving any prior notice and any
compensation and without adhering to the principle of 'last come first go'.
Petitioner has duly submitted its reply stating that petitioner/Corporation has
never employed the respondent in the Garden department of the
petitioner/Corporation and when respondent has never been employed, the
question of discontinuing his services in the petitioner/Corporation does not
arise and, therefore respondent is not entitled for any of relief in the form of
compensation etc
The petitioner/Corporation has engaged an outsourcing
agency i.e. M/S Raj Security Force, Bhopal and has entered into an agreement
and given
work order for providing manpower from time to time to the
petitioner/Corporation and payment regarding the same is being done to the
Contractor. In case, the respondent has worked through the outsourcing agency
M/S Raj Security Force, he was not employed by the petitioner/Corporation
directly and is considered to be an outsourced employee and, therefore, there is
not employee and employer relation between the petitioner /Corporation and
respondent. Petitioner has filed an application before the Labour Court for
impleading M/S Raj Security Force as a party which was rejected. Labour
Court ignoring the fact that respondent has neither produced any document in
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
support of his claim nor produced any independent witness and on the
contrary, petitioner/Corporation has produced requisite documents in support
of his case has passed the impugned award.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner/Corporation submitted that learned
Labour Court has passed the impugned award going against the documents and
evidence produced on record only on the basis of false and unconstitutional
basis. Petitioner is a civic body constituted under the provisions of the Act of
1956 and does not come under the provisions of ID Act and therefore does not
fall within the purview of industrial dispute u/S 2(A) of the ID Act and the M.P.
Civil Services Rules are applicable to the petitioner/Corporation and the
recruitment of employees
will be done in terms of the M.P Nagar Palik
Nigam(Adhikarioyon Evam Sevwakon Ki Niyukti Evam Seva Ki Sharten) Rules,
2000[referred to as "Rules of 2000" hereinafter]. No recruitment shall be done
without following the Rules of 2000.The Labour Court has committed error of
law
in considering the respondent as employee of petitioner/Corporation.
However, from the evidence produced on record by the petitioner/Corporation,
it is evident that respondent has neither worked under the petitioner/Corporation
even for a single day nor petitioner/Corporation has appointment him. There is
no employee/employer relationship between the two. To fulfill the day to day
manpower requirements, pettioner/Corporation engaged outsourcing agencies
by giving work orders to different agencies and M/S Raj Securities has also
been given the work order of providing manpower pursuant to which, the
contractor provides manpower from time to time as per the agreement entered
between the petitioner and the agency. Clause 31 of the said agreement clearly
mentions that a workers kept by the contractor cannot be considered as the
worker of Corporation. Pursuant to the said agreement, the workers provided
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
by
the
Contractor
cannot
be
considered
as
the
workers
of
petitioner/ Corporation. Petitioner has adduced evidence before the Labour
Court, Ujjain
which were exhibited from D-1 to D-25 to the said effect.
Learned Labour Court without appreciating the evidence produced by the
petitioner has passed the award in favour of the respondent which is bad in law.
Petitioner has filed an application for impleading M/S Raj Security Force as a
party which was also rejected by the Labour Court. Petitioner has duly filed
detailed reply taking objection on the fact that respondent was never employed
by the petitioner and has been outsourced by the Contractor who has employed
the respondent. In support of his claim, petitioner has produced the agreement,
work order, record relating to payment and other documents which have not
been taken into account. Respondent has shown his appointment and
discontinuation as oral in the statement of claim before the Labour Court and
petitioner/Corporation has never given him appointment or discontinued his
services by any order. Under such circumstances, the burden of proof lies on
the respondent. On the contrary, respondent has not produced any evidence
oral or documentary in support of his claim. Even otherwise, petitioner has
produced requisite documents to show that respondent is not employee of the
petitioner/Corporation as defined u/S 2 of the ID Act. Moreso, respondent has
not even worked for a single day in the petitioner/Corporation, therefore the
question of working for 240 days does not arise as there is no Muster Roll
maintained by the petitioner/Corporation in terms of Section 25(d) of the ID
Act. Respondent has failed to prove the duration of work, appointment,
documentary proof of salary and recruitment by the petitioner/Corporation.
Hence, the Labour Court has committed grave error of law while passing the
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
award despite availability of evidence in favour of the petitioner and the same is
liable to be set aside.
4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that
learned Labour Court after appreciation of evidence available on record has
passed the award. He further submitted that the respondent sworn in an affidavit
mentioning that he has worked in the Udhyan Vibhag of petitioner/Corporation
as a daily wager on consideration of Rs. 5,500 p.m.
from 10.03.2016 to
14.03.2019 and his services were discontinued by the petitioner orally on
14.03.2019 without any notice or retrenchment compensation.
5. Learned counsel resting his argument on Ex. D-14 and D-15 submits
that as per the said documents payment of workers has been made through
bank account of Indian Overseas Bank which is in the name of Ujjain Nagar
Palika Nigam. This makes it loud and clear that it is the petitioner who has
recruited the respondent and other workers and, therefore, petitioner is making
the payment. The Labour Court has given the finding that Exhibit D-15 proves
that petitioner has employed the respondent and held the discontinuance of
service of respondent as illegal retrenchment and directed the petitioner to
continue the service of respondent within two months. Hence, no error is
apparent in award so passed and the present miscellenous petition deserves to
be dismissed.
6. Heard, learned counsel for both the parties and perused the record.
7 . It is not disputed that the petitioner/Corporation is a civic body
constituted under the provisions of Act of 1956 and for recruitment of
employees, separate set of rules i.e. Rules of 2000 are being taken into
consideration. Therefore, provisions of ID Act under which the impugned
award has been passed by the Labour Court are not applicable on the
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
petitioner/Coproration. Even otherwise, on a close reading of the impugned
award, it came to surface that petitioner/Corporation outsourced workers from
time to time through various agencies. Petitioner/Corporation has produced
documents regarding outsourcing of workers through work order from M/s Raj
Security Force for a limited period. Thus, it is very much clear that there is no
employee employer relationship between the petitioner and respondent. Hence,
the claim of the respondent that though he has been employed by the petitioner,
however since the petitioner has failed to follow the provisions as provided
u/S 25(F) and 25(G) of the ID, the discontinuation of respondent from services
orally falls under the category of illegal retrenchment cannot be accepted.
Merely on the ground that petitioner/Corporation has an account in the Indian
Overseas Bank through which payment of salary has been made to the
petitioner does prove the employee and employer relation between the two.
8.
Under such circumstances,
Labour Court without properly
appreciating the oral and documentary evidence produced on record by the
petitioner and in the absence of any documentary evidence produced by the
respondent, has passed award in favour of the respondent which seems to be
erroneous as merely payment of salary/wages from the bank account which is in
the name of Municipal Corporation does not bestow any right to the
respondent to claim himself as an employee of the Corporation, especially in the
absence of any documentary proof in that regard as respondent on his own
saying submits that he was appointed and discontinued orally. There is no
documentary evidence available on record. Hence, the impugned award is liable
to be set aside.
9.
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
In view of the above discussion, the award dated 01.07.2020 passed
by the Labour Court in Case No. 148/2019/ID Act(Reference) is hereby set
aside.
10. Petition stands allowed.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
sh
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 2/3/2024
12:20:00 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review