Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SHARMA
Date: 2023.10.12 10:48:43 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022
1. Shri N. Sarat Singh, aged about 64 years, S/o (L) N.
Modhumangol Singh, a resident of Thangmeiband
Yumnam Leikai, P.O. Lamphelpat & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
2. Shri Th. Bimol Singh, aged about 55 years, S/o 9l) Th.
Dwijamani Singh of Ward No. 3, Ningthoukhong, P.O. &
P.S. Bishnupur, Bishnupur District, Manipur.
… PETITIONERS
-VERSUS1. The State of Manipur through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Manipur, Secretariat South Block,
Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal – 795001.
2. The Manipur Lokayukta through its Secretary, 3rd Floor
Directorate Complex, 2nd M.R. North AOC, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District – 795001.
3. Shri Ngangom Ibotombi Singh, S/O (L) Ng. Parijat
Singh of Oinam Bazar Makha, P.O. & P.S. Nambol,
Bishnupur District, Manipur.
… RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |2
WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Shri A. Rajendra Sharma, aged about 64 years, S/o (L) A.
Gourahari Sharma, a resident of Sagolband Mantri Lekai,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur –
795001.
… PETITIONER
-VERSUS1. The Manipur Lokayukta through its Secretary, having
its office at the Manipur Lokayukta, 3rd Floor,
Directorate Complex, 2nd M.R. North A.O.C., Imphal,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal East, Manipur – 795001.
… OFFICIAL RESPONDENTS
2. Shri Ngangom Ibotombi Singh, S/o. (L) Ngangom
Parijat Singh of Oinam Bazar Makha, P.O. & P.S.
Nambol, Bishnupur District, Manipur- 795134,
… PRIVATE RESPONDENTS
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.
in WP(C) No. 833 of 2022
Mr. N. Jotendro, Sr. Adv.
in WP(C) No. 828 of 2022/.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. M. Rarry, Advocate
Mr. H. Debendra, Dy. AG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
15.09.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
11.10.2023
::
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |3
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel for the
petitioners in WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and Mr. N. Jotendro, learned
senior counsel for the petitioners in WP(C) No. 828 of 2022; Mr. H.
Debendra, learned Deputy AG assisted by Mr. I. Amri, learned
counsel for the respondent State and Mr. M. Rarry, the learned
counsel for the respondent Manipur Lokayukta in both the
Respondents. Inspite of notice none appeared for the respondent
No. 2 and 3/complainant.
2.
W.P.(C) No.833 of 2022 has been filed by the
petitioners for issuance of a writ of mandamus to close the
Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 pending on the file of the Manipur
Lokayukta as not maintainable being hit by limitation.
3.
W.P.(C) No.828 of 2022 has been filed by the
petitioner to set aside the Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 along with
its order dated 8.9.2022 and its subsequent orders passed in the
said complaint case pending on the file of the Manipur Lokayukta in
view of Section 53 of the Manipur Lokayukta Act, 2014, as the
complaint with regard to the alleged offence in connection with the
construction of associated 33 KV transmission line for the project
had been made after the expiry of a period of seven years from the
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |4
date on which the construction of associated 33 KV transmission
line for the project had been completed and commissioned after
successfully tested on 14.8.2015 and taken over by the petitioner
on the same day.
4.
Since the relief sought in these writ petitions is one and
the same, both the writ petitions were taken up together and
disposed of by this common order.
5.
Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the
petitioners submitted that a Complaint Case No.2 of 2020 was
registered by the Manipur Lokayukta and, on 7.2.2022, an order
was passed in the said complaint case directing for investigation
into the matter by registration of an FIR against some officials
including the petitioners and also a direction was given to remove
the petitioner Sarat Singh from his post pending investigation.
Challenging the order dated 7.2.2022, W.P.(C) No.168 of 2022 and
other connected writ petitions are filed. Pending W.P.(C) No.168 of
2022 and other connected writ petitions, one Meghachandra Singh
had filed PIL No.10 of 2022 for implementation of the
recommendation made by the Manipur Lokayukta in its judgment
dated 7.2.2022 and by the judgment and order dated 25.7.2022, the
said PIL No.10 of 2022 was dismissed as withdrawn. Another
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |5
W.P.(C) No.660 of 2022 has been filed by one Mutum Waiojit Meitei
against the State and the petitioner Sarat Singh for issuance of quo
warranto contending that the extension of the service of the
petitioner Sarat Singh, after retirement in the post of MD, MSPCL,
is against the provisions of the recruitment rules coupled with a
prayer for removal from the post. The petitioner Sarat Singh and
the State took a stand in the said writ petition that the continuation
of the petitioner Sarat Singh in the post of MD, MSPCL was not by
way of extension of service after retirement, but by way of
appointment on contract basis pursuant to the public advertisement
at national level which was resorted to by the authorities as per the
rules.
6.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that one
such complaint seems to have been filed before the Manipur
Lokayukta by the respondent Ngangom Ibotombi Singh in
Complaint Case No.5 of 2022. Without ascertaining the veracity
and the documents for substantiating the allegation in the
complaint, the Manipur Lokayukta initiated action even to the extent
of invoking power under Section 22 of the said Act demanding
information from the Power Department as enumerated in its order
dated 8.9.2022. Vide letter dated 14.9.2022, the Power Department
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |6
directed the office of the petitioner Sarat Singh to make available
the documents.
7.
The learned senior counsel submitted that during
examination, it has come to know that the alleged complaint relating
to construction of associated 33 KV line for the turn-key project was
completed on 14.8.2015 and as 7 years have lapsed, it has become
an issue which cannot be looked into by the Manipur Lokayukta and
accordingly,
the
Power
Department
was
apprised
and
subsequently, it seems that the Power Department has been
pleased to inform the Manipur Lokayukta that the complaint is time
barred in view of Section 53 of the said Act and a request has been
made not to proceed with the proposed enquiry. However, without
appreciating the stand of the Power Department, the Manipur
Lokayukta has passed an order on 23.9.2022 directing to make
available all the documents by 10.10.2022.
8.
The learned senior counsel next submitted that the
complaint case was filed before the Manipur Lokayukta not on the
basis of the authenticated documents and information, but by some
summary information provided by some individual working in the
Department for meeting his vested interest. In order to bring such
nefarious activities of some employees working in the Department
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |7
sponsoring unfounded complaint, an application has been made by
the petitioner Bimol Singh, who was the then DGM, Sub-station
Division No.III stating that the alleged complaint relating to the
construction of associated 33KV line was already completed as far
back as 14.8.2015 and the non-execution of sending end bay for
the project as alleged in the complaint is irrelevant since in the work
order for the project, there is no provision for execution of sending
end bay at New Chayang. When the counsel went to the Manipur
Lokyukta for filing such application, it was informed by the official of
the Manipur Lokayukta that the application filed is returned on the
instruction of the Chairperson for the reason that even the
preliminary enquiry has not been commenced and being premature.
According to the learned senior counsel, returning the said
application is against the accepted norms.
9.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
despite the fact that the work was completed in August, 2015, the
Manipur
Lokayukta
not
appreciating
the
stand
of
the
Government,has been insisting on making enquiry which otherwise
is outside its jurisdiction, thereby making it clear that it has become
an instrument at the hands of persons who indulged in making
complaints on surmises and information provided against the official
documents and records. Hence, the petitioners have approached
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |8
this Court for interference stating that the systematic harassment in
the name of investigation/enquiry at the behest of the some vested
interested individual is to be prevented.
10.
The learned senior counsel urged that the petitioner
Sarat Singh whose contract appointment to the post of MD, MSPCL
has been over by March, 2023, however, he has become a victim
of unfounded allegation initiated by the staged complaint before
different forums by vested interested officials.
11.
Mr. N. Jotendro, the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner in W.P.(C) No.828 of 2022 submitted that taking
cognizance of the Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 for the alleged
offence after seven years is illegal, malafide and arbitrary in nature
in view of Section 53 of the said Act. As such, the complaint case
along with its order dated 8.9.2022 and the subsequent orders
passed thereon are liable to be quashed.
12.
Adding further, the learned senior counsel submitted
that the petitioner was working and discharging his duty as Deputy
General Manager (DGM), Transmission Division-III at the time of
taking over the project on 14.8.2015 and that the completed
transmission line facility has also taken over by the petitioner
Rajendra Sharma, DGM, TD-III, Manipur State Power Company
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
Page |9
Limited on the same day on 14.8.2015. Without looking into the
provision of the said Act, the Manipur Lokayukta has taken
cognizance of the Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 on 8.9.2022 and,
therefore, the same is liable to be quashed.
13.
Mr. M. Rarry, the learned counsel for the respondent
Manipur Lokayukta submitted that no cause of action have arisen
for filing the writ petitions and the writ petitioners are premature. The
impugned orders are not adverse to the interest of any person, as
the decision as to who are to be arrayed as respondents in the
preliminary enquiry is yet to be decided. In other words, the writ
petitions have been filed based on the pre-conceived presumption
to illegally and malafidely to stop the quasi-judicial authority from
discharging its function, though Lokayukta functioning being directly
investigative in nature as declared by the Constitution Bench of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Nagendra Nath Bora v.
Commissioner of Hills Division and Appeals. The petitioners have
no locus standi to challenge the impugned orders or the complaint
case, as the case may be. They cannot step into the shoes of other
State Government officers’ who were called to produce documents
as per the provisions of the said Act. The petitioners are not
aggrieved parties in law, as the impugned orders do not in any
manner affect the fundamental rights of the petitioners to invoke the
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 10
writ jurisdiction. The petitioners have not approached this Court
with clean hands and are guilty of concealing material facts and
documents. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the writ
petitions.
14.
Heard the learned Government Advocate for the
respondent State.
15.
This Court considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
16.
As could be seen from the records, before filing the
present writ petitions, challenging the order dated 7.2.2022 passed
by the Manipur Lokayukta in Complaint Case No.2 of 2020, the
petitioner Sarat Singh filed W.P.(C) No.168 of 2022 to set aside the
order dated 7.2.2022. Similar writ petition, being W.P.(C) No.161
of 2022, has been filed by Th. Kamiinimohan Singh challenging the
order dated 7.2.2022. Th. Bimol Singh also filed W.P.(C) No.171
of 2022 assailing the said order. In addition, the petitioner Sarat
Singh filed W.P.(C) No.255 of 2022 restraining the Manipur
Lokayukta from taking any action for implementation of its
recommendation at para 25(D) made in the order dated 7.2.2022.
Though the petitioners in the said writ petitions insisted for an
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 11
interim order, by the common order dated 4.7.2022, the learned
Single Judge of this Court has not granted any interim order.
17.
W.P.(C) Nos.833 and 828 of 2022 have been filed by
petitioners for issuance of direction to close the Complaint Case
No.5 of 2022 on the ground that the same is barred by limitation. In
the said writ petitions, the petitioners have also sought for an order
restraining the Manipur Lokayukta from proceeding with the
Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 pending disposal of the writ petitions.
18.
On 29.9.2022, when W.P.(C) No.833 of 2022 was
taken up for hearing, this Court passed the following order:
“[1] Heard Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel
for the petitioner and perused the record.
[2] Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner argued the case that prima facie the
compliant taken by the Manipur Lokayukta in
complaint case No. 5 of 2022 is not at all
maintainable only on the ground that as per the
Section 53 of Manipur Lokayukta Act if the alleged
occurrence was lapsed for 7(seven) years, the
complaint should not be taken by the Lokayukta.
Mr. H.S Paonam, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner further raised another ground that in
order dated 23.09.2022, the Manipur Lokayukta
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 12
has passed an order in which in para No.9 of order
dated 23.09.2022 which read as follows:
“Put up the case on 10.10.2022 for the
personal appearance of (i) Administrative
Secretary,
Department
Government
of
Manipur
of
and
OrjubalaHaorongbam,
Deputy
(power)
of
Government
Power,
(ii)
Mrs.
Secretary
Manipur
on
10.10.2022 at 11:00 am,
However of the Manipur Lokayukta Act, the
learned Lukayukta have no power to issue any
notice
for
personal
appearance
of
the
Administrative office concerned. But by the order
dated
23.09.2022
of
the
learned
Manipur
Lokayukta directly issued order for personal
appearance
of
the
Administrative
officer.
Therefore, once the complaint itself is not
maintainable one before the Lokayukta and order
dated 23.09.2022 is also not maintainable one.
[3] Mr. Mr. Rarry, learned Standing counsel
represented the petitioner has not served case
papers to him before taking up the matter for
admission since he is the standing counsel for the
Manipur Lokayukta. Anyhow, Mr. H. S Paoanam ,
learned senior counsel for the petitioner has given
all the paper to Mr. M. Rarry, learned standing
counsel in the open Court.
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 13
[4] After gone through the writ petition and
documents, Mr. M. Rarry, learned Standing
counsel for the Manipur Lokayukta represented
the compliant case is not taken for registration as
on date by the Manipur Lokayukta and the very file
of the writ petition is premature one. Therefore, for
proper instruction from the Manipur Lokayukta and
for filing counter affidavit, he seeks time.
[5] Mr. HS Paonam learned senior counsel for the
petitioner
has
produced
certificate
dated
14.08.2015 which read as follows:
Handing over/Taking Over (Certificate)
Date 14/08/2015
Project: Installation of 2x5 MVA, 33/11 kV
Sub-Station along with the associated 33 KV
line and related Civil works at Sugnu in
Thoubal District on turn-key basis.
Ref.:
LOA
No.
4/109/33KV/SUG/13ED(PURCH)/706-17, dated 02/07/2014.
Name of Line: Associated 33 kV
transmission line.
With reference to the above mentioned
LOA/Work Order, the construction activities
of the associated 33 kV transmission line of
the above project has been completed by
tapping from existing 33 kV transmission line
from New Chayang to Joupi in looping in —
looping out (LILO) configuration by M/s
Shyama Power India Limited, Gurgaon, and
the line has been successfully tested and
commissioned on 14/08/2015 in presence of
MSPCL
officials.
The
completed
transmission line facility is taken over by the
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 14
Dy. General Manager, TD-IIl, Manipur State
Power Company Limited (MSPCL) on this
day i.e., 14/08/2015.
‘For and behalf of
Manipur State Power
Company Limited
For and Behalf of
Shyama Power
India Limited.
DGM, TD-III
(taken over)
Project manager
(handing over)
[6] As per the above certificate dated 14.08.2015
issued by Shyama Power India Limited which was
handing over/taking over on 14.08.2015, it is made
clear that as per the Section 53 of the Manipur
Lokayukta Act, 2014, the complaint is time barred
one. Apart from this the learned Lokayukta has no
right to pass any order for the personal
appearance
officers
concerned
as
ordered
23.09.2022.
[7] Therefore, prima facie of the petitioner is made
out the case before this Court.
[8] Accordingly, this writ petition is admitted.
[9] Notice to the respondents. Since Mr. Rarry,
learned counsel takes notice for the Lokayukta, no
formal notice is required.
[10] Post this matter on 20.10.2022.
[11] Till such time, there shall be an order of
interim stay of the order dated 23.09.2022 passed
by learned Manipur Lokayukta.
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 15
[12] Print the name of Mr. Rarry in the cause list.”
19.
The Manipur Lokayukta filed MC (WP) No.346 of 2022
to vacate the said interim order dated 29.09.2022. After hearing the
respective learned counsel, this Court, by the order dated
19.12.2022, dismissed MC (WP) No.346 of 2022. Paragraphs 28
and 29 of the said order are relevant and the same are quoted
hereunder:
“28. Nothing has been produced by the petitioners
to show that as against the interim order date
22.12.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.938 of 2022, an
appeal has been preferred. In view of the said
interim order passed in W.P.(C) No.938 of 2022
thereby restraining the enquiry officer from taking
further proceedings and consequential action in
respect of Complaint Case No.5 of 2022, no contra
view is possible in this case, as no appeal has
been preferred against the interim order dated
22.11.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.938 of 2022.
29. For the foregoing discussions, this Court is of
the view that thee is no merit in MC (W) No.346 of
2022 and accordingly dismissed and thus, the
interim order dated 29.9.2022 passed in W.P.(C)
no.833 of 2022 is made absolute till the disposal
of the writ petition.”
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 16
20.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of MC (WP) No.346 of
2022, Manipur Lokayukta had preferred S.L.P.(C) No.2069 of 2023
before the Hon’ble Apex Court and the Hon’ble Apex Court, vide
order dated 3.2.2023, disposed of the SLP. The order of the Apex
Court reads thus:
“Noticing that by the impugned order that the High
Court has made the interim order absolute, we are
not inclined to interfere with the impugned order.
Without expressing any view on the merits of the
contentions of the parties, we only request the
High Court to dispose of the writ petition itself
within a period of three months from the date of
production of the copy of this order before the High
Court.
The Special Leave Petition is disposed of
accordingly.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed
of.”
21.
According to the petitioners, the execution of
associated 33 KV transmission line pursuant to the letter of award
dated 2.7.2014 which is the prime focus of allegation of the
complainant in the complaint has been successfully completed and
after following the due process as per the procedure, including
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 17
testing and commissioning in the presence of MSPCL official,
handing over and taking over of the completed work was done on
14.8.2015 between the executing agency, namely M/s.Shyama
Power (India) Private Limited and the MSPCL, represented by its
DGM, Transmission Division-III (petitioner in W.P.(C) No.828 of
2022).
Thus, it is the specific case of the petitioners that the
complaint filed before the Manipur Lokayukta in respect of
associated 33 KV transmission line of the project was only on
31.08.2022. Therefore, the Manipur Lokayukta has no authority to
enquire into the matter based on the said complaint. Reliance is
placed on Section 53 of the said Act.
22.
Section 53 of the said Act reads thus:
“53. The Lokayukta shall not inquire or
investigate into any complaint, if the complaint
is made after the expiry of a period of seven
years from the date on which the offence
mentioned in such complaint is alleged to
have been committed.”
23.
On the other hand, it is the say of the Manipur
Lokayukta that if the completion of the project as per the document
dated 14.8.2015 is accepted to be correct, it would certainly justify
the allegation that the project for laying 33 KV transmission line of
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 18
20 kms. from 33/11/KV substation New Chayang to Sugnu had
been commissioned by tapping only 3 km. from the existing 33 KV
new Chayang-Joupi line at Khongnang Paishabi and there was
embezzlement of funds and materials for the remaining 17 kms.
Thus as per the available record, the complaint case is not barred
by limitation.
According to the learned counsel for the Manipur
Lokayukta, disputed question of facts ought not to be decided in the
writ petition.
24.
In reply, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners
submitted that the project has three components, namely (a) line
portion – string of a new 33 KV associated transmission line; (b)
sub-station portion – installation of a new 2x5 MVA 33/11 substation; and (c) civil works. The allegation in the complaint case is
misappropriation of public fund due to non-execution of 17 km of 33
KV transmission line.
25.
In the briefing report filed along with the complaint, the
complainant has stated as under:
“The project “Installation of 2x5 MVA 33/11 KV
substation at Sugnu along with associated 33 KV
line and related works in Thoubal, district was
taken up by MSPCL during the period 2014 to
2017 under NLCPR and state fund. /the approved
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 19
project cost is Rs.5.39 cr. Minister of Doner
accorded sanction of the fund for the project on
28.02.2014 as revealed in the report “24x7
POWER FOR All- Manipur” A joint initiative of
Government
Of
India
and
Government
Of
Manipur”. The statement in the report was jointly
signed by the than commissioner (Power),
Manipur and the than Joint Secretary (Power),
GOI.
The project was executed by M/S Shyama Power
India Pvt. Ltd. On turnkey basis. The length of the
associated 33 kv Transmission line fro 33/11 KV
substation New chayang to Sugunu as per the
approved scheme is 20 twenty Km. However, the
substation has been commissioned by erecting a
line of 3 km, tapping from the existing 33 KV New
chayang-Joupi
line
at
KhongnangPaishabi.
Embezzlement of the fund released from Doner
Ministry and the state government for supply and
erection of the balance 17 Km long 33 KV
Transmission line and one 33 KV sending end bay
along with the equipmetns at 33 KV Substatiion,
New chayang is evident.
Many mandatory
equipmetns and elements for a power substations
like Lightening arrestors, Circuit Breakers and
Isolators are also missing in the field. The civil
works like cable trench and the fencing et are also
not as per standards.
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 20
The company failed to produce the relevant
records and information for the said project when
asked for by one RTI activist Joykumar Singh as
published in Local media.
Shri N.Sarat Singh,
Managing Director, MSPCL, has utilised all the
funds including the sum sanctioned for the works
and supply for the 17 Kms of 33 KV line and the
sending End Bay which had not been constructed.
The Managing Director, MSPCL, being the
executive head and drawing and disbursing officer
of the company in collision with the consignee of
the project, the concern field Engineers and the
Turn Key agency has intentionally made room for
short supply of materials, skip erection works and
misappropriated the public fund for their personal
gains. The unauthorised change in the scope of
work and supply, non execution of 17 kms of the
33 KV line and the sending end bay but incurred
expenditure of the said works and supply implies
that embezzlement and misappropriation of public
fund has been committed.”
26.
According to the petitioners, the work schedule of the
work order specifies different timelines for completion of the work
for line portion and substation portion.
The completion of line
portion is independent of the other two components and the
associated 33 KV line was completed and test charged by
14.8.2015. According to the petitioners, the completion of the sub-
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 21
station portion is dependent on the completion of the associated
transmission line and the substation was subsequently completed
on a later date. The petitioners stated that the line component i.e.
the associated 33 KV line was completed on 14.8.2015 and has
never claimed that the whole project was completed by 14.8.2015.
27.
It is not necessary that all the components have to be
completed at the same point of time, as each component will have
different completion schedule specified in the work order as well.
Since the work schedule for the line portion where the allegation of
misappropriation of fund is already barred by limitation under
Section 53 of the said Act, the respondent Manipur Lokayukta
deliberately misled by trying to broaden the ambit of the complaint
in order to suit convenience. The respondent cannot misconstrue
a
complaint
alleging
an
offence
of
embezzlement
and
misappropriation of public fund due to non-execution of 17 km of 33
KV transmission line and sending end bay of New Chayang as the
complaint against the project Installation of 2x5 MVA, 33/11 KV
substation along with associated 33 KV line and related civil works
at Sugnu in Thoubal District on turn-key basis in a manner to suit
without any basis.
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 22
28.
The learned counsel for the Manipur Lokayukta
submitted that even if the line portion of new 33 KV line of 20 kms.
is shortened to only 3 kms., the line portion of 20 kms. was not
completed on the date mentioned by the petitioners on 14.8.2015
as the handing over/taking over certificate is not available in the
Government record and this shows that the said alleged handing
over/taking over certificate is a manufactured and doctored one.
29.
In reply, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners
submitted that the handing over/taking over certification is a
document executed between the implementing agency i.e. MSPCL
and the turn-key firm as per the agreement entered between the
two parties. This document certifies the completion of a portion of
the work executed by the turn-key firm and that the turn-key firm
has executed the portion of the work as per the technical
specification and certifies healthiness of the completed portion of
the work. However, the NLCPR guideline mandates submission of
documents like utilization certificates, quarterly progress report,
inspection reports through the planning department at the time of
seeking funds for the subsequent instalments from the Ministry.
30.
Drawing this Court’s attention to the inspection report
of the General Manager, Sub-station Circle, who is the Nodal
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 23
Officer, the learned senior counsel submitted that in the said report
the Nodal Officer furnished the overall progress of the project in
general which does not particularly specify the completion of each
component. Since sub-station and related civil works were not
completed during the time of inspection, the Nodal Officer had
furnished a general status of the project even though the line portion
was completed quite beforehand. This Court finds some merit in
the submission made by the learned senior counsel for the
petitioners.
31.
The handing over/taking over certificate dated
14.8.2015 filed along with the writ petition reads thus:
Handing Over/Taking Over (Certificate)
Date: 14/08/2015
Project: Installation of 2x5 MVA, 33/11 kV Substation along with the associated 33 kV line and
related Civil Works at SugnuThoubal District on
turn-key basis.
Ref:
LOA
No.4/109/33KV/SUG/13-
ED(PURCH)706-17, dated 02/07/2014.
Name of Line: Associated 33 kV transmission line.
With reference to the above mentioned LOA/Work
Order, the construction activities of the associated
33 kV transmission line of the above project has
been completed by tapping from the existing 33 kV
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 24
transmission line from New Chayang to Joupi in
looping in – looping out (LILO) configuration by
M/s.Shyama Power India Limited, Gurgaon, and
the line has been successfully tested and
commissioned on 14/08/2015 in presence of
MSPCL officials. The completed transmission line
facility is taken over by the Dy. General Manager,
TD-III, Manipur State Power Company Limited
(MSPCL) on this day i.e. 14/08/2015.
32.
For and behalf of
Manipur State Power
Company Limited
For and behalf of
Shyama Power
India Limited
Sd/-xxx
DGM, TD-III
(Taken Over)
Project Manager
(Handing Over)
To controvert the handing over/taking over certificate
dated 14/08/2015 produced by the petitioners, the respondent
Manipur Lokayukta has not produced any document. Therefore, it
is clear that the execution of the associated 33 KV transmission line
pursuant to the letter of award dated 2.7.2014 which is the prime
focus of allegation of the complainant in the Complaint Case No.5
of 2022 was successfully completed and after following the due
process including the testing and commissioning in the presence of
the officials of MSPCL, the handing over and taking over of the
completed work was done on 14.08.2015 between the executing
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 25
agency and the MSPCL. Nobody has questioned the certificate of
handing over/taking over till date.
33.
As could be seen from the records, irrespective of the
actual state of affairs which may not be disputed about the
completion of the project in the month of August, 2015, the Manipur
Lokayukta without appreciating the stand of the Government, called
for personal appearance of the petitioners under the guise of
enquiry which prima facie is outside its jurisdiction.
34.
It is settled law that under the guise of enquiry and/or
investigation, the authorities shall not harass the individual at the
behest of the vested interested persons.
35.
As stated supra, Section 53 of the said Act bars the
taking up of the complaint in respect of the allegation of committing
offence after the expiry of seven years. The work in question was
completed way back on 14.8.2015, however, the Complaint Case
No.5 of 2022 based on the complaint lodged by the Shri Ngangom
Ibotombi Singh against the petitioners and M/s.Syama Power
(India) Private Limited was taken up for adjudication on 8.9.2022 by
the Manipur Lokayukta.
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 26
36.
A perusal of the File produced by the parties in respect
of Complaint Case No.5 of 2022, makes it is clear that Shri
Ngangom Ibotombi Singh has filed the complaint before the
Manipur Lokayukta on 31.8.2022. According to the petitioners, the
work in question was completed on 14.8.2015 and the complaint as
per the File was lodged on 31.8.2022, which is beyond the period
of seven years as per Section 53 of the said Act. The complainant
Shri Ngangom Ibotombi Singh was impleaded as party respondent
in these writ petitions. Despite service, he has not appeared before
this Court. Lodging complaint before the Manipur Lokayukta and
tracing evidence through the Manipur Lokayukta cannot be
permitted. It is the bounden duty of the complainant to produce all
the records in support of the complaint while filing the complaint
case. However, in the case on hand, the complainant has failed to
do so. When the complainant is arrayed as party respondent in the
writ petition and notice served on him, it is his bounden duty to
appear before the Court and put forth his stand.
37.
At this juncture, the learned counsel for the Manipur
Lokayukta submitted that the impugned orders passed in the
complaint case are not adverse to the interest of any person, as the
decision as to who are to be added as respondents in the
preliminary enquiry is yet to be decided and that the writ petitions
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 27
have been filed based on the pre-conceived presumption. In the
given facts and circumstances of the case, it cannot be said that the
writ petitions are filed prematurely.
38.
It is also the argument of the learned counsel for the
Manipur Lokayukta that even a layman or a common man will
understand that the case of the complainant that the petitioners and
others had embezzled and misappropriated the fund for the project
i.e. Installation of 2x5 MVA, 33/11 KV Sub-station along with the
associated KV line and related civil works at Sugnu in Thoubal
District on turn-key basis by stringing only 3 kms. of line that too by
shortening the line portion from original contract of 20 kms. and also
not constructed the sub-station of the project has no legs, as either
the complainant or the Manipur Lokayukta proved the same.
39.
It is true that the disputed question of fact cannot be
decided in the writ petition, however, it is the duty of the parties in
the writ petition to prima facie prove their case. In the instant case,
it is the say of the petitioners that way back in August, 2015, the
work was completed. To prove the same, they have produced the
handing over/taking over certificate.
To disprove the said
certificate, no material has been produced by the respondent
Manipur Lokayukta. No prima facie proof to show the alleged
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 28
misappropriation of funds by the petitioners as alleged by the
respondent Manipur Lokayukta is placed on record. Under the garb
of enquiry/investigation, evidence cannot be traced out to suit a
person and that the authority of the Lokayukta cannot be misused.
40.
As stated supra, as per Section 53 of the said Act, the
Lokayukta shall not inquire into any complaint, if the complaint is
made after the expiry of a period of seven years from the date on
which the offence mentioned in such complaint is alleged to have
been committed.
41.
In the case on hand, the petitioners have established
prima facie that line component i.e. the associated 33 KV line, was
completed on 14.8.2015. Thus, it is clear that the complaint is
clearly barred by limitation and in the time barred complaint, the
Manipur Lokayukta cannot issue notices under the guise of enquiry
or verifying the records. Admittedly, the Manipur Lokayukta ought
not to have ordered enquiry, as the work was completed way back
on 14.08.2015 and to that effect proof has also been produced
before this Court. In view of the above, the petitioners have legal
right to maintain the present writ petitions.
42.
Section 14 of the Manipur Lokayukta Act, 2014 deals
with the enquiry to be conducted into any matter involved in or
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 29
arising from or connected with any allegation of corruption made in
the complaint by the Lokayukta. Section 14(1) of the Act provides:
“14. (1) Subject to the other provisions of this Act,
the Lokayukta shall inquire or cause an inquiry to
be conducted into any matter involved in, or
arising from, or connected with, any allegation of
corruption made in a complaint in respect of the
following namely:(a)
…
(b)
…
(c)
…
(d)
all officers and employees of the State, from
amongst the public servants defined in subclause (i) and (ii) of clause (c) of section 2
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988
when serving or who has served, in
connection with the affairs of the State;
(e)
all officers and employees referred to in
clause (d) or equivalent in any body or
Board or corporation or authority or
company or society or trust or autonomous
body
(by
whatever
name
called)
established by an Act of the State
Legislature or wholly or partly financed by
the State Government or controlled by it;
(f)
…
(g)
…
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 30
(h)
43.
...”
Thus, from the above, it is clear that a complaint before
the Manipur Lokayukta by the complainant against any authority,
including the public office, needs to satisfy the condition mentioned
in Section 14(1) of the said Act. In the case on hand, as stated
supra, the condition stipulated in Section 14(1) of the said Act has
not been fulfilled by the complainant and the said fact was not
properly analyzed by the Manipur Lokayukta while coming to the
conclusion to issue notice to the respondents therein for
appearance and the production documents for preliminary enquiry.
That apart, expanding the scope of enquiry beyond the allegation
made in the complaint is against the objective of the said Act. Such
intention to have a roving enquiry cannot be permitted.
44.
It is also the submission of the learned senior counsel
for the petitioners that with a good intention, the petitioners have
discharged their official function and, therefore, the petitioners have
to be protected by the provision of Section 50 of the Act.
45.
Section 50 of the said Act provides:
“50. No suit, prosecution or other legal
proceedings under this Act shall lie against
any public servant, in respect of anything
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 31
which is done in good faith or intended to be
done in the discharge of his official functions
or in exercise of his powers.”
46.
Taking cognizance by the Manipur Lokayukta of a
complaint filed by the complainant, who was a retired IAS officer,
against the petitioners beyond the statutory period as provided
under Section 53 of the said Act and the non-consideration of the
aspect of Section 50 of the said Act has infringed the fundamental
rights of the petitioners guaranteed under Articles 14 and 21 of the
Constitution of India.
47.
A retired high functionary of the State Government
cannot be accused by another retired high functionary to meet
personal agenda after a long time before the Lokayukta.
48.
It is to be noted that the series of actions are
undertaken by the Manipur Lokayukta in connection with the
Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 even though the aforesaid action
purportedly has taken in connection with altogether a different
Complaint Case No.2 of 2020 and, as such, the claim of bonafide
is highly misplaced for not accepting the stand of the Government.
As regards to the issue raised in Complaint Case No.5 of 2022, it is
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
P a g e | 32
clear that the same is time barred and it would be out of the purview
of the Manipur Lokayukta as per the scheme of the said Act.
49.
For all the reasons stated above,
a)
Both the writ petitions WP(C) No. 833 of 2022
and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022 are allowed.
b)
The Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 pending
on the file of the Manipur Lokayukta against
petitioners is closed.
c)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 833 of 2022 and WP(C) No. 828 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review