Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.08.22
TELEN KOM Date:
12:23:00 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(WP(C))No.189 of 2023
Ref: WP(C)No.833 of 2022
1. Shri. N. Sarat Singh, aged about 65 years, (L) N. Modhumangol
Singh, a resident of Thangmeiband Yumnam Leikai PO Lamphelpat
& PS Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
2. Shri Th. Bimol singh, aged about 55 years, S/o (L) Th. Dwijamani
Singh of Ward No.3, Ningthoukhong P.O. & PS Bishnupur,
Bishnupur District, Manipur.
…Applicants
– Versus –
1. Shri Ngangom Ibotombi Singh, S/o (L) Ng. Parijat Singh of Oinam
Bazar Makha, PO & PS Nambol, Bishnupur District, Manipur.
….Principal Respondents.
2. The State of Manipur through the Chief Secretary, Government of
Manipur, Secretariat South Block, Babupara, PO & PS Imphal795001.
3. The Manipur Lokayukta through its Secretary, 3rd Floor Directorate
Complex, 2nd MR North AOC, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West District795001.
….Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the applicant
:
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. M. Rarry Adv.
Date of hearing & reserved.
:
01.08.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
:
08.08.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. H. S Paonam, learned senior counsel for the petitioners
and Mr. M. Rarry, the learned counsel for the respondent No.3.
[2]
This petition has been filed by the petitioners to implead Ngangom
Ibotombi Singh as respondent No.3 in the writ petition.
[3]
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the petitioners have
filed WP (C) No.833 of 2022 inter alia praying for closing of the Complaint
Case No.5 of 2022 as not maintainable, as the same is barred by limitation.
He would submit that the said Complaint Case was filed by the proposed
respondent before the Manipur Lokayukta alleging that a project “Installation
of 2x5 MVA 33/11 KV sub-station at Sugnu along with associated 33 KV line
and related works” in Thoubal District was taken up by MSPCL during the
period 2014 to 2017 under NLCPR and State fund. The contract work of the
said project was executed by M/s.Shyama Power India Private Limited on
turnkey basis. The length of the associated 33 KV transmission line from
33/11 KV sub-station New Chayang to Sugnu as per the approved scheme
is 20 kilo meter. However, the sub-station has been commissioned by
erecting a line of 3 kilo meter tapping from the existing 33 KV New ChayangJoupi line at Khongnang Paishabi, thereby embezzling the fund released
from Ministry and the State Government for supply and erection of the
balance 17 Km long 33 KV transmission line and one 33 KV sending end bay
along with the equipment at 33 KV sub-station, New Chayang. Since the
project was completed on 14.8.2015 itself and 7 years have passed by, it
has become an issue which cannot be looked into by the Manipur Lokayukta.
[4]
Learned counsel further submitted that while filing the writ petition, the
proposed respondent, who is the complainant, was not made as a party in
bonafide belief that he is not a necessary party, as the issue involved as to
whether the Complaint Case is time barred has to be decided on the basis
of the documents with the State Government.
However, in order to avoid
any complicacy, including of providing an opportunity to the proposed
respondent/complainant, it is just and proper to implead him as respondent
in the writ petition.
According to learned counsel, the impleadment of
Ngangom Ibotombi Singh will not prejudice the right of any party. Therefore,
the petitioners may be permitted to implead the said Ngangom Ibotombi
Singh as third respondent in the writ petition.
[5]
The learned counsel for the respondent Manipur Lokayukta submitted
that the petitioners have obtained stay of the proceedings of the Complaint
Case and, after concluding the final arguments in the light of the time limit
fixed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, they have come forward with the
present petition stating that it has been filed to avoid complicacy. According
to the learned counsel, the said plea is bereft of any boanfide and the same
is made only to delay the disposal of the writ petition with an express
objective to violate the timely disposal of the writ petition.
[6]
The learned counsel further submitted that despite filing a defective
and illegal writ petition by a person who is not an aggrieved person in law,
nor having any locus standi, nor having a legal right to sue, the petitioners
have enjoyed the interim stay of the proceedings before the Manipur
Lokayukta and, that too, behind the back and without knowledge of the
complainant. According to the learned counsel, despite the time limit fixed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the petitioners have filed the present petition to
further delay the disposal of the writ petition. If the petition is allowed, it
would amount to approving the abuse of the process of law by the petitioners.
Thus, prayed for dismissal of the petition.
[7]
Heard the learned Government Advocate for the respondent State.
[8]
This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
[9]
The petitioners, who are the original writ petitioners, have filed the writ
petition for issuance of a writ of mandamus for closing the Complaint Case
No.5 of 2022 as not maintainable, being barred by limitation, and restraining
the respondent Manipur Lokayukta from further proceeding with the
Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 pending on its file.
[10]
Pleadings were exchanged by the parties and now the writ petition is
at part-heard stage.
[11]
In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent Manipur
Lokayukta, dated 18.10.2022, it has been stated as under:
“1.4 The petitioner has not approached this Hon’ble Court with clean
hands and is guilty of concealing material facts and documents and
as such the present petition is liable to be dismissed in view of the
judgment of K.D.Sharma supra and is bad in law for non-jonder of
necessary party being the Complainant namely Shri Ngangom
Ibotombi Singh.”
[12]
Admittedly, the plea of non-joinder has been raised by the respondent
Manipur Lokayukta way back on 18.10.2022 itself. But the petitioners have not
taken any steps to implead the proposed respondent at the earlier point of time.
Now only the petitioners have filed the present petition praying for impleadment
of the proposed respondent stating that in order to avoid any complicacy,
including for providing an opportunity to him, the proposed respondent should
be added as party respondent.
[13]
Though the petition for impleading the complainant in Complaint Case
No.5 of 2022 has been filed belatedly, taking into consideration the issue
involved and to avoid any complicacy, the proposed respondent is a necessary
party to the writ petition and no prejudice would be caused to either of the
respondents in the writ petition, if he is added as party respondent in the writ
petition at this stage. The contention of the respondent Manipur Lokayukta that
the petition has been filed only to drag on the case cannot be countenanced.
[14]
It is trite that the Court has the power to strike out the name of the
parties improperly joined or add a party either on an application or without
application of either party in its own discretion, but the condition precedent is
that the Court must be satisfied that the presence of the party to be added,
would be necessary, in order to enable the Court to effectually and
completely adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the
proceedings. To array a person as party-respondent/party-defendant is not
a substantive right but one of procedure and the Court has discretion in its
proper exercise. The object of the Rule is to bring on record all the persons
who are parties to the dispute relating to the subject-matter so that the
dispute may be determined in their presence, at the same time without any
protraction, in convenience, and to avoid multiplicity of proceedings.
A
person may be added as a defendant to the suit though no relief may be
claimed against him/her provided his/her presence is necessary for a
complete and final decision on the question involved in the suit.
[15]
As stated supra, the Complaint Case No.5 of 2022 has been filed by
the proposed respondent against the petitioners. The petitioners seek to
close the said Complaint Case alleging that the project in question has
already been completed long time back on 14.8.2015 and it would be outside
the purview of the Manipur Lokayukta as per the scheme of the Manipur
Lokayukta Act, 2014. When such being the plea/case of the petitioners, the
presence of the proposed respondent is very much required. In his absence,
if any order is passed, it would definitely affect his interest. In fact, in the
affidavit-in-opposition to the present petition filed by the respondent Manipur
Lokayukta, it has been stated that “the writ petitioners have already enjoyed
interim stay of the proceeding before the Manipur Lokayukta and that too, all
behind the back and knowledge of the complainant”.
Therefore, if the
proposed respondent is added as party respondent, no prejudice would be
caused to the respondents in the writ petition.
[16]
It is apposite to mention that aggrieved by the order dated 19.12.2022
in MC (WP (C)) No.346 of 2022 passed by this Court, the Manipur Lokayukta
filed Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.2069 of 2023 before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court. By the order dated 3.2.2023, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court passed the following order:
“Noticing that by the impugned order that the High Court has made
the interim order absolute, we are not inclined to interfere with the
impugned order. Without expressing any view on the merits of the
contentions of the parties, we only request the High Court to dispose
of the writ petition itself within a period of three months from the date
of production of the copy of this order before the High Court.
The Special Leave Petition is disposed of accordingly.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.”
[17]
As the writ petition could not be disposed of within the time limit, this
Court sought extension of time for three months from 8.5.2023. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court, under order dated 18.7.2023 in Miscellaneous Application
No.1559 of 2023 in SLP (C) No.2069 of 2023, granted further time of three
months to conclude the trial in W.P. (C) No.833 of 2022.
18.7.2023 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reads thus:
The order dated
“1. Perused the office report and letter dated 5 th July, 2023, sent by
the Registrar General, High Court of Manipur requesting therein to
extend time for three months from 08.05.2023 for disposing of the
W.P.(C) No.833 of 2022.
2. We accede to his request and grant further time of three month to
conclude the trial in W.P.(C) No.833 of 2022.
3. The Misc. Application is disposed of accordingly.”
[18]
As stated supra, since the Complaint Case sought to be closed by the
petitioners has been filed by the proposed respondent, any order passed
behind his back would definitely be prejudicial to his interest. Therefore, this
Court is of the view that the petitioners are right in seeking impleadment of
the proposed respondent, namely Ngangom Ibotombi Singh, as third
respondent in the writ petition. In fact, the respondent Manipur Lokayukta
itself raised a plea that the writ petition suffers from non-joinder of necessary
party i.e. the complainant in Complaint Case No.5 of 2022. A person who is
likely to suffer from the order of the Court and has not been impleaded as a
party, has a right to ignore the said order as it has been passed in violation
of the principles of natural justice.
[19]
The judgment in the case of Ranjan Kumar etc. V. State of Bihar and
others, Civil Appeal Nos.4455-4458 of 2009, dated 16.4.2014 relied upon by
the learned counsel for the respondent Manipur Lokayukta is not applicable,
as the said judgment deals with candidates who had taken part in the
selection process and it was held that they cannot challenge the mode of
examination. Admittedly, the facts of the instant case are not similar to case
of Ranjan Kumar, supra.
[20]
Another decision relied upon by the learned counsel for the Manipur
Lokayukta is ILR (2009) VI Delhi 83 (Office of Lokayukta v. Govt. of NCT of
Delhi and another). The said case relates to power of the Lokayukta to
conduct preliminary enquiry.
entirely different.
The issue involved in the present petition is
In the instant petition, this Court cannot decide or
deliberate on the power of the Manipur Lokayukta to deal with the case.
Therefore, the decision in ILR (2009) VI Delhi 83, supra, relied upon by the
learned counsel for the respondent Manipur Lokayukta is also not applicable,
as this Court has not delved into the power of Manipur Lokayukta to deal with
the case.
[21]
The impleadment of Ngangom Ibotombi Singh will not prejudice the
right of any party.
That apart, as stated supra, since the petitioners have
challenged the complaint lodged by Ngangom Ibotombi Singh, he ought to
be impleaded as party respondent in the writ petition. No order can be
passed behind the back of a person adversely affecting him and such an
order, if passed, is liable to be ignored being not binding on such a party as
the same has been passed in violation of the principles of natural justice.
Time and again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the litigant has to
ensure that the necessary party is before the Court, otherwise, the
proceedings will have to fail. Therefore, if Ngangom Ibotombi Singh is
impleaded as respondent in the writ petition, no prejudice would be caused
to him. On the other hand, it would be very much helpful for this Court to
decide the writ petition after hearing the plea of Ngangom Ibotombi Singh.
Therefore, in the interest of justice and for proper adjudication of the writ
petition, this Court is inclined to allow the present petition.
[22]
In the result,
(1) M.C.No.189 of 2023 is allowed.
(2) The proposed respondent Ngangom Ibotombi Singh
is ordered to be impleaded as third respondent in the writ
petition.
(3) The Registry is directed to carry out necessary
amendment in the writ petition.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review