The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. 03.2025 in Contempt Case (C) No.2920 of 2025. In the impugned judgment, while dismissing the contempt case as not maintainable, the learned Single Judge observed that the petitioner is misusing the liberty and process of the court and that any non-maintainable petition filed by him in future shall be dismissed with heavy cost.
12. The aforesaid observations made in the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge cannot be challenged by filing an intra-court appeal under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High WA NO. 617 OF 2025 2025:KER:29408 Court Act, 1958 by contending that in the said judgment an issue is decided or direction is issued by the learned Single Judge on the merits of the matter, independent of the contempt proceedings, in order to maintain an intra-court appeal under Section 5(i) of the Act. In such circumstances, this writ appeal fails on the ground of maintainability and the same is accordingly dismissed, without expressing anything on the legality or otherwise of such observations contained in the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge. Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE DSV/- WA NO. 617 OF 2025 2025:KER:29408 APPELLANT’S ANNEXURES Annexure A13
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 24.03.2025 IN Con.Case(C) NO.2920
OF 2024 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER IN THE CONTEMPT OF COURT CASE:
N.PRAKASH,
AGED 61 YEARS,
PRAJITH VIHAR AYINI ROAD MARADU P.O
ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682304.
BY ADV N.PRAKASH(Party-In-Person)
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT IN THE CONTEMPT OF COURT CASE:
BISWANATH SINHA IAS
ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT HOME (C)
DEPARTMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695001.
OTHER PRESENT:
SMT. NISHA BOSE, SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 03.04.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
JUDGMENT
Anil K. Narendran, J.
The petitioner in Contempt Case (C)No.2920 of 2024 has
filed this writ appeal, as an intra-court appeal, invoking the
provisions under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958,
challenging the judgment dated 24.03.2025 of the learned Single
Judge in that contempt case, whereby that contempt petition was
dismissed as not maintainable, with an observation that the
petitioner is misusing the liberty and process of the court and that
any non-maintainable petition filed by him in future shall be
dismissed with heavy cost. Paragraphs 4 to 6 and also the last
paragraph of that judgment read thus:
“4. In compliance with the said judgment, the Government
passed an order afresh on 18.11.2024 and the Government
held that as per Rule 120 of the Kerala Service Rules, Part
III, if the application for pension was not made within a
period of three years after the date of retirement, the same
could not be given retrospective effect without a special
Government order.
5. The said decision of the Government order dated
18.11.2024 came to be challenged by the petitioner in
W.P(C) No.42443/2024 and this court vide the judgment
dated 22.01.2025, was of the opinion that the petitioner is
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
not entitled for pension from 04.06.2009 till the date of
application made on 23.11.2021. However, this court
directed the Government to consider whether the pension
to the petitioner can be granted for a period of three years
prior to the date of his application, i.e. 23.11.2021, by
special sanction by the Government. Aggrieved by the said
judgment, the petitioner has approached the Division Bench
in W.A No. 224 of 2025.
6.This court fails to understand that when the Government
has already taken the decision in pursuance to the judgment
dated 01.07.2024 passed in W.P(C) NO. 9508/2023, the
said decision of the Government was challenged by the
petitioner before this court in W.P(C) No.42443/2024, how
the contempt of the judgment dated 01.07.2024 passed in
W.P(C) No.9508/2023 could be maintainable.
In view of the aforesaid, the contempt petition is dismissed
as not maintainable. I am of the considered view that the
petitioner is misusing the liberty and process of the Court.
Any nonmaintainable petition filed by him in future shall be
dismissed with a heavy cost."
2.
Heard the arguments of the appellant, who appeared
in person and also the learned Senior Government Pleader for the
respondent.
3.
From the grounds raised in the memorandum of the
writ appeal and also the submissions made by the appellant, who
appeared in person, we notice that the appellant is feeling
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
aggrieved by the observations made by the learned Single Judge
in the last paragraph of the judgment dated 24.03.2025 in
Contempt Case (C) No.2920 of 2025.
4.
The appellant filed W.P.(C)No.9508 of 2023 seeking a
declaration that he is entitled for pension and Death-cumRetirement Gratuity from the date of compulsory retirement, i.e.,
07.04.2006
to
the
23.11.2021.
The
date
of
petitioner
application
for
has
sought
also
pension,
for
i.e.,
other
consequential reliefs including a writ of certiorari to quash Ext.P10
Government order dated 08.03.2023. The said writ petition was
disposed of by Annexure A4 judgment dated 01.07.2024. The
operative portion of that judgment reads thus;
“In the result, Ext.P10 stands quashed, and the 2nd
respondent is directed to reconsider the claim of the
petitioner for pension and other reliefs based on Exts.P7 and
P9. Orders in this regard shall be passed within three
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment."
5.
Section 19 of the Contempt of Courts Act deals with
appeal. As per sub-section (1) of Section 19, an appeal shall lie as
of right from any order or decision of the High Court in the exercise
of its jurisdiction to punish for contempt (a) where the order or
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
decision is that of a Single Judge, to a Bench of not less than two
Judges of the Court; (b) where the order or decision is that of a
Bench, to the Supreme Court. As per the proviso to sub-section
(1) of Section 19, where the order or decision is that of the Court
of the Judicial Commissioner in any Union territory, such appeal
shall lie to the Supreme Court. As per sub-section (2) of Section
19, pending any appeal, the appellate court may order that (a)
the execution of the punishment or order appealed against be
suspended; (b) if the appellant is in confinement, he be released
on bail; and (c) the appeal be heard notwithstanding that the
appellant has not purged his contempt. As per sub-section (3) of
Section 19, where any person aggrieved by any order against
which an appeal may be filed satisfies the High Court that he
intends to prefer an appeal, the High Court may also exercise all
or any of the powers conferred by sub-section (2). As per subsection (4) of Section 19, an appeal under sub-section (1) shall be
filed (a) in the case of an appeal to a Bench of the High Court,
within thirty days; (b) in the case of an appeal to the Supreme
Court, within 60 days from the date of the order appealed against.
6.
In Midnapore Peoples’ Co. Op. Bank Ltd. v.
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
Chunilal Nanda [(2006) 5 SCC 399], after referring to the law
laid down in Baradakanta Mishra [(1975) 3 SCC 535],
Purshotam Dass Goel [(1978) 2 SCC 370], State of
Maharashtra v. Mahboob S. Allibhoy [(1996) 4 SCC 411] and
J.S. Parihar v. Ganpat Duggar [(1996) 6 SCC 291] the Apex
Court summarised the legal position emerging from those
decisions in regard to appeals filed under Section 19(1) of the
Contempt of Courts Act against orders in contempt proceedings.
Paragraph 11 of that decision reads thus;
“11. The position emerging from these decisions, in regard
to appeals against orders in contempt proceedings may be
summarised thus:
(I)
An appeal under Section 19 is maintainable only
against an order or decision of the High Court passed
in exercise of its jurisdiction to punish for contempt,
that is, an order imposing punishment for contempt.
(II)
Neither an order declining to initiate proceedings for
contempt, nor an order initiating proceedings for
contempt nor an order dropping the proceedings for
contempt nor an order acquitting or exonerating the
contemnor, is appealable under Section 19 of the
Contempt of Courts Act. In special circumstances,
they may be open to challenge under Article 136 of
the Constitution.
(III) In a proceeding for contempt, the High Court can
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
decide whether any contempt of court has been
committed, and if so, what should be the punishment
and matters incidental thereto. In such a proceeding,
it is not appropriate to adjudicate or decide any issue
relating to the merits of the dispute between the
parties.
(IV) Any direction issued or decision made by the High
Court on the merits of a dispute between the parties,
will not be in the exercise of “jurisdiction to punish for
contempt” and, therefore, not appealable under
Section 19 of the Contempt of Courts Act. The only
exception is where such direction or decision is
incidental to or inextricably connected with the order
punishing for contempt, in which event the appeal
under Section 19 of the Act, can also encompass the
incidental or inextricably connected directions.
(V)
If the High Court, for whatsoever reason, decides an
issue or makes any direction, relating to the merits of
the dispute between the parties, in a contempt
proceedings, the aggrieved person is not without
remedy. Such an order is open to challenge in an
intra-court appeal (if the order was of a learned Single
Judge and there is a provision for an intra-court
appeal), or by seeking special leave to appeal under
Article 136 of the Constitution of India (in other
cases).”
7.
(underline supplied)
In Suni B.T. v. Vinayaka Granites [2025 (1) KLT
287] a Full Bench of this Court considered the issue of
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
maintainability of an appeal under Section 19(1) of the Act and it
was held that for an appeal to lie under Section 19(1), the
impugned order must be inextricably connected with the order
punishing for contempt and cannot be independent of it. It must
flow from the order punishing for contempt. All procedural steps
leading to the order of punishment cannot be termed as incidental
to the order punishing for contempt. For the second part of clause
(IV) in Midnapore Peoples' Co. Op. Bank Ltd. [(2006) 5 SCC
399] to apply, there must be first an order punishing for
contempt. This position of law is expounded also by earlier
decisions on the subject by the Apex Court referred to earlier. An
order proceeding to frame and framing charges being merely a
stage prior to the order of punishment cannot be considered as
inextricably connected to or incidental to the order punishing for
contempt. The order inextricably connected to such orders can be
direction to purge the contempt, which also can be challenged
under Section 19(1) along with the order punishing for contempt.
It also has to be kept in mind that the judge decides whether
contempt of the "court" is committed. The contempt proceedings
are between the court and the contemnor and are not a lis
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
between the parties. When the court declares that contempt is
committed and passes an order in its contempt jurisdiction, an
appeal will lie. The contempt proceedings are not complete or final
until the punishment is rendered. The proceedings are concluded
only after the Court renders a final decision, which includes
determining a sentence upon finding the party guilty of contempt.
If any positive direction is given that is incidental to and connected
with the order of punishing for contempt, then under an appeal
filed under Section 19 can be filed challenging both the order of
punishing for contempt and the order that is incidental to it. When
any issue is decided or a direction is issued on the merits of the
matter, independent of the contempt proceedings, then an intracourt appeal (wherever such a provision exists) would be
maintainable. Hence, the scheme of Section 19 of the Contempt
of Courts Act, 1971, the Rules framed thereunder, and the
decisions of the Apex Court, particularly in the case of Midnapore
Peoples' Co. Op. Bank Ltd., indicate that only those orders
which are inextricably connected to and incidental to the order of
punishment can be the subject matter of an appeal along with the
order imposing punishment. To reiterate the phrase inextricably
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
connected or incidental "to the order imposing punishment" mean
that there must first be an order of punishment. Proceeding to
framing charges for contempt is thus not appealable under Section
19(1) of the Act.
8.
In Suni B.T. [2025 (1) KLT 287] the Full Bench
answered the reference as under;
“An appeal filed under Section 19(1) of the Contempt of
Courts Act, 1971, challenging the order when the Court,
after forming a prima facie opinion, proceeds to frame a
charge under Rule 14(b) of the Contempt of Courts (High
Court of Kerala) Rules framed under the Contempt of Courts
Act, 1971 is not maintainable.”
9.
In Sukhdeep Sangwan (Lt. Gen) v. Bijukumar S.
[2025 (2) KHC 384], a Division Bench of this Court in which both
of us were parties held that in view of the law laid down by the
Full Bench in Suni B.T. [2025 (1) KLT 287], the appellant
cannot invoke the provision under Section 19(1) of the Contempt
of Courts Act, in order to challenge the impugned orders dated
05.12.2023 in Cont.Case (C)No. 2459 of 2019 and order dated
15.07.2024 in I.A.No.2 of 2024 in Cont.Case (C)No.2459 of 2019
of the learned Single Judge, as those orders would not fall under
the category of orders which are inextricably connected to and
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
incidental to the order of punishment. Then the question that
requires consideration is as to whether those orders would fall
under the category of orders in clause (V) of the judgment of the
Apex Court in Midnapore Peoples’ Co.op.Bank Ltd. [(2006) 5
SCC 399], for maintaining an intra-court appeal from the orders
of a learned Single Judge, under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High
Court Act. In view of the law laid down by the Apex Court in the
aforesaid decision and followed by the Full Bench in Suni B.T.
[2025 (1) KLT 287] when an issue is decided or direction is
issued on the merits of the matter, independent of the contempt
proceedings, then an intra-court appeal would be maintainable
under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High Court Act. Such an intracourt appeal has to be filed as a writ appeal, which has to be listed
before the Division Bench as per the roster, and not before the
Division Bench dealing with contempt appeals.
10.
In Sukhdeep Sangwan (Lt. Gen) [2025 (2) KHC
384], on the facts of the case on hand, the Division Bench found
that the Contempt Appeal filed by the appellants-respondents
challenging the impugned orders dated 05.12.2023 in Cont.Case
(C)No.2459 of 2019 and order dated 15.07.2024 in I.A.No.2 of
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
2024 in Cont.Case (C)No.2459 of 2019 of the learned Single Judge
can only be dismissed as not maintainable; however,
without
prejudice to the right of the appellants to challenge those orders
of the learned Single Judge in an intra-court appeal filed under
Section 5(i) of the Kerala High Court Act, in case those orders fall
under the category of appealable orders, i.e., orders in which any
issue is decided or a direction is issued on the merits of the matter,
independent of the contempt proceedings.
11.
In the instant case, as already noticed hereinbefore,
the appellant is feeling aggrieved by the observations made by the
learned Single Judge in the last paragraph of the judgment dated
24.03.2025 in Contempt Case (C) No.2920 of 2025. In the
impugned judgment, while dismissing the contempt case as not
maintainable, the learned Single Judge observed that the
petitioner is misusing the liberty and process of the court and that
any non-maintainable petition filed by him in future shall be
dismissed with heavy cost.
12.
The aforesaid observations made in the impugned
judgment of the learned Single Judge cannot be challenged by
filing an intra-court appeal under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
Court Act, 1958 by contending that in the said judgment an issue
is decided or direction is issued by the learned Single Judge on the
merits of the matter, independent of the contempt proceedings, in
order to maintain an intra-court appeal under Section 5(i) of the
Act.
In such circumstances, this writ appeal fails on the ground
of maintainability and the same is accordingly dismissed, without
expressing anything on the legality or otherwise of such
observations contained in the impugned judgment of the learned
Single Judge.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
DSV/-
WA NO. 617 OF 2025
2025:KER:29408
APPENDIX OF WA 617/2025
APPELLANT’S ANNEXURES
Annexure A13
TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER DATED
22.1.2025 IN CON.CASE (C) NO.2920 OF 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review