The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. In view of the above, this LAA is thus allowed re-fixing the land value at Rs.35,220.90/- per Are (Rs.27,093/- + 30% of Rs.27,093/-). The appellant/claimant shall be entitled to compensation at the said rate commensurate to the extent of land acquired from him. He shall also be entitled to all the statutory benefits including the interest along with proportionate cost. The judgment and decree dated 09.09.2016 in LAR No.3 of 2011 of the Principal Subordinate Judge’s Court, Kollam, shall stand modified to the said extent. It is noted that there has been a filing delay of 57 days and this Court had vide order dated 14.07.2017 in C.M.Appl.No.390 of 2017 condoned the delay. It is noted that the delay occasioned in filing the LAA is only 57 days which is not substantial. Hence no deduction in interest and statutory benefits need to be made from the amounts awarded to the appellant/claimant. The cross-objection filed by the State is dismissed. Sd/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
LA.APP.NO.269 OF 2017
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED
09.09.2016 IN LAR NO.3 OF 2011 OF PRINCIPAL SUBORDINATE
JUDGE'S COURT, KOLLAM
APPELLANT/CLAIMANT:
N.BABU
S/O.NARAYANAN, KUZHIKKA THEKKAKKARA,
KOTTAKKAKOM MURI, CHAVARA VILLAGE, KOLLAM
DISTRICT FROM THEKKATHIL VEEDU,
KULANGARABHAGAM MURI, CHAVARA VILLAGE.
BY ADV SRI.PRATHEESH.P
RESPONDENT/STATE:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,
CIVIL STATION, KOLLAM - 691 013.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
KERALA WATER AUTHORITY, VELLAYAMBALAM,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695033.
BY ADVS.
REKHA C.NAIR, SR.GOVERNMENT PLEADER, R1
P.M.JOHNY, SC, R2
THIS
LAND
ACQUISITION
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD ON 02.04.2025, ALONG WITH CO.52/2018, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
C.O.NO.52 OF 2018
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED
09.09.2016 IN LAR NO.3 OF 2011 OF PRINCIPAL SUBORDINATE
JUDGE'S COURT, KOLLAM
CROSS OBJECTOR/1ST RESPONDENT/1ST RESPONDENT IN LAR:
STATE OF KERALA
REPESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR
KOLLAM.
BY ADV.
SMT.REKHA C.NAIR, SR.GOVERNMENT PLEADER
RESPONDENTS/APPELLANT AND 2ND RESPONDENT/CLAIMANT & 2ND
RESPONDENT IN LAR:
N.BABU
S/O.NARAYANAN, KUZHIKKA THEKKAKKARA
KOTTAKKAKOM MURI, CHAVARA VILLAGE
KOLLAM DISTRICT (FROM THEKKATHIL VEEDU
KULANGARABHAGAM MURI, CHAVARA VILLAGE)
PIN 691583
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
KERALA WATER AUTHORITY,
VELLAYAMBALAM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695010
BY ADVS.
PRATHEESH.P., R1
P.M.JOHNY, SC, R2
THIS CROSS OBJECTION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
02.04.2025, ALONG WITH LA.App..269/2017, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 02nd day of April, 2025
[LA.App.No.269/2017 & C.O.No.52/2018]
This appeal is filed by the appellant challenging the
judgment and decree dated 09.09.2016 in LAR No. 3 of 2011 of the
Principal Subordinate Judge’s Court, Kollam. Appellant was the
claimant in the LAR. A Cross Objection numbered as C.O. No. 52 of
2018 has been filed by the State from the same judgment and
decree. Both the LAA and C.O. are considered and disposed of
together.
2. The Kerala Water Authority acquired 08.70 Ares of land
owned by the claimant comprised in Re.Sy Nos. 395/4, 11, 12, and
17 of Chavara Village in Karunagappally Taluk to implement a water
supply scheme. The notification under Section 4 (1) was published
in the Official Gazette on 31.10.2002. By the award dated
25.10.2003, an extent of 7.9 Ares of land owned by the claimant
was acquired by paying compensation @ Rs.14,472/- per Are in
respect of properties in Sy.Nos 395/4,11 and 17 and Rs.16,612/- per
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
Are in respect of properties having an extent of 0.80 Ares in Sy.
No.395/12. Possession of the land was taken on 03.07.2004. A total
compensation of Rs.1,99,058/- had been awarded by the LAO. The
claimant received the amount under protest and moved an
application for reference. In the LAR before the Sub Court, the
claimant sought an enhancement of land value to Rs.2,00,000/- per
cent. Compensation for improvements at Rs.50,000/- as well as for
injurious affection were also sought. The Sub-Court in the reference
refixed the land value @ Rs.28,990/- per Are. Aggrieved by the
same, seeking further enhancement, the claimant has filed this LAA.
3. Heard Sri. Pratheesh P., Advocate for the appellant, Smt.
Rekha C.Nair learned Government Pleader for 1 st respondent and
Sri.P.M. Johny, Advocate, for the 2nd respondent.
4. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the
Sub-Court overlooked Exts.A1 to A5 produced by the claimant. The
property covered vide Exts.A1 and A2 sale deeds were similar in
nature to the acquired land and the land value therein ought to have
been adopted. In Exts.A1 and A2, the land value originally arrived at
was Rs.15,525/- per cent, which was later enhanced after
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
negotiation between the parties out of court and was fixed at
Rs.31,050/- per cent. The acquired property is just 400 meters from
the National High Way. The LAO had adopted the land value of a
property covered by the sale deed dated 16.11.2000. The said
property is situated 2 Kms. away from the acquired property. The
court below granted a meagre 7% enhancement overlooking the
fact that Section 4(1) notification with respect to acquired property
was two years subsequent to the execution of the said sale deed.
Reliance is placed on the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in
Jage Ram (dead) through LRs v. Union of India and another
[2017 KHC 6392] and it is contended that compensation can be
determined by adding 15% of the value of the sale consideration per
year keeping in mind the escalation in price of the lands day by day.
The Sub Court erred in granting only 7% escalation. As regards the
value of improvements too, the compensation awarded by the
reference court is inadequate and abysmally low. Injurious affection
to the property also ought to have been noted by the reference
court.
5. Per contra, the learned Senior Government Pleader
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
reiterated the contentions put forth in the C.O. and submitted that
the reference court had without any basis enhanced the land value
based on a document bearing No.5492 /2000 dated 16.11.2000,
which had been considered by the LAO and found to be not similar
to the acquired land. The land value in the said document is much
higher than the market value of similar land in the locality. The
property covered by the said document is situated 2 Km. away from
the acquired land and was of superior nature to the acquired land.
The learned Senior Government Pleader thus sought to set aside
the judgment and decree.
6.
Heard both sides and perused the records. It is noted
that of Exts. A1 to A5 marked by the claimant, Exts. A1 and A2
relate to properties purchased by Indian Rare Earths Ltd. which is a
Public Sector Undertaking. The land value with respect to the
property covered by the said documents is seen to be Rs.31,050/per cent. Two reasons were stated by the reference court to discard
Ext. A1 and A2 viz., the relevant properties were purchased by way
of out-of-court settlement and that the claimant had not taken steps
to identify the said properties.
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
The reference court then proceeded to rely on as
7.
exemplar, a property shown as item No.6 in Ext.R3 general note to
award comprised in Sy.No.391/22 and covered by sale deed
No.5492/00 dated 16.11.2000. The said reliance is assailed by the
claimant stating that the said property is not a comparable property
as the acquired property is just 400 meters from the National High
Way. The said sale deed is of the year 2000 whereas the notification
is dated 31.10.2002. There is around 2 year difference between the
same. Overlooking the dictum in Jage Ram (supra) the reference
court granted only 7% enhancement to the land value taking note of
the lag of one year. The same ought to have been 15% per year.
8.
It is noted that Exts.A1 and A2 relate to properties
purchased by Indian Rare Earths Ltd., a PSU. The reason stated for
not relying on the said document is that IRE purchased the same
after negotiation and an out of court settlement. The other reason
stated for not relying on Exts.A1 and A2 concern the alleged nonidentification of the said properties by the Advocate Commissioner.
Exts.X1 and X1 (a) are the mahazar and the commission report
respectively. It is true that there has been no effort to identify the
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
relevant property so as to afford a comparison of the same with
acquired land. The discarding of Exts.A1 and A2 by the Sub Court
cannot be termed as improper or erroneous.
9. The reliance on Ext.R3 regarding the property situated
in Sy.No.391/22 and covered by sale deed No.5492/00 dated
16.11.2000 is correct and valid. The said property is the suitable
exemplar and was validly relied on by the reference court.
However, the reference court erred in limiting the per-year
enhancement to 7% overlooking the dictum in Jage Ram (supra).
The said error requires amendment. The contention in the C.O. that
the reference court had without any basis enhanced the land value
based on a document bearing No.5492/2000 dated 16.11.2000
which had been considered by the LAO and found to be not similar
to the acquired land is unsustainable in the light of the facts and
circumstances discernible in evidence. Following the dictum in Jage
Ram (supra) and taking note of the fact that sale deed No. 5492/00
is dated 16.11.2000 and the notification under Section 4 (1) was
published in the Official Gazette on 31.10.2002, the claimant is
entitled to 30% increase in the land value @15% per year for two
LA.APP. NO.269 OF 2017
CO NO. 52 OF 2018
2025:KER:29330
years.
10. In view of the above, this LAA is thus allowed re-fixing the
land value at Rs.35,220.90/- per Are (Rs.27,093/- + 30% of
Rs.27,093/-).
The appellant/claimant shall be entitled to compensation at the
said rate commensurate to the extent of land acquired from him. He
shall also be entitled to all the statutory benefits including the
interest along with proportionate cost. The judgment and decree
dated 09.09.2016 in LAR No.3 of 2011 of the Principal Subordinate
Judge’s Court, Kollam, shall stand modified to the said extent. It is
noted that there has been a filing delay of 57 days and this Court
had vide order dated 14.07.2017 in C.M.Appl.No.390 of 2017
condoned the delay. It is noted that the delay occasioned in filing the
LAA is only 57 days which is not substantial. Hence no deduction in
interest and statutory benefits need to be made from the amounts
awarded to the appellant/claimant. The cross-objection filed by the
State is dismissed.
Sd/-
SYAM KUMAR V. M.
JUDGE
csl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review