Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.656/2025
MVS Engineering Private Limited, represented by its Director E-24, East of
Kailash, New Delhi-110065 Email: b.das@ mvsengg.com
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by its Secretary, Animal Resource
Development Department, Government of Tripura Prani Sampad Bikash
Bhawan, Pandit Nehru Complex, Gurkhabusti, P.O.-Kunjaban, PIN-799006,
West Tripura Email: ardd.tripura@gmail.com, tr032@ifs.nic.in
2. Tripura Livestock Development Agency represented by its Chief Executive
Officer, Astabal, Agartala, Tripura-799001, Email: ardd.tripura@gmail.com,
tr056@ifs.nic.in, tripuralivestockd@yahoo.com
3. Stirling Cryogenics India Private Limited, 139/A-2, First Floor, Antriksh
Bhawan, 22, Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi-110001 Also at:E-43, Ground
Floor, Sector-63, Noida, U.P.-201309 a.bhutani@stirlingcryogenics.co.in
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, Sr. Advocate,
Ms. Sumi Datta, Advocate,
Ms. Sampa Das Deb, Advocate,
Mr. Samrat Sarkar, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya, G.A.,
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. Amrit Lal Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Date of hearing & judgment
: 16.01.2026.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(M.S. Ramachandra Rao, C.J.)
Heard both sides.
2.
In this Writ Petition, the petitioner has assailed the action of the
respondent No.2, Tripura Livestock Development Agency, in rejecting the bid
of the petitioner and accepting the bid of the respondent No.3 with regard to an
e-Tender for procurement and installation of 3 nos. of medium Liquid Nitrogen
Plant along with 125 kVA voltage Stabilizer for West Tripura, Gomati and
Unakoti Districts to strengthen the AI Network in Tripura State during the year
2025-26, which decision was taken on 29.10.2025.
3.
The principal contention of the petitioner is that as per Clause-43
of the tender (Annexure-11), the financial turnover of a bidder should be more
than Rs.7 (seven) crore per annum in the preceding three years, and though the
respondent No.3 had only a turnover of Rs.863.18 lakhs in 2022-23,
Rs.1076.00 lakhs in 2023-24 and Rs.511.06 lakhs in 2024-25, the respondent
No.3 had been awarded the said work arbitrarily in violation of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
4.
Counsel for the petitioner contends that since the respondent No.3
did not have a turnover of more than Rs.7(seven) crore for 2024-25 financial
year, it was not open to the respondent No.2 to treat the respondent No.3 as
eligible and consider to award the contract to the respondent No.3 on
29.10.2025. He also contended that the respondent No.2 was not right in
disqualifying or rejecting the bid of the petitioner.
5.
On 20.11.2025, when this Writ Petition was listed before us, we
passed the following order:
"Issue notice to respondents No.2 & 3.
Prime facie the selection of third respondent as the
agency for procurement and installation of three numbers of
medium liquid nitrogen plants along with 125 KVA voltage
stabilizer for West Tripura, Gomati and Unakoti Districts to
strengthen AI network in Tripura State during 2025-26 with
the subject Tender on 29.10.2025 vide Annexure-11 appears to
be arbitrary because, as per the said tender requirement
(Clause 43), the financial turnover of a bidder should be more
than Rupees Seven Crore per annum in the preceding three
years, but as per the summary note on technical bid filed at
Annexure-12 along with the Technical Bid Evaluation
Statement, the third
respondent does
not
fulfil
this
requirement.
Therefore, the second respondent is restrained from
executing any agreement, or awarding the subject Contract to
the third respondent until further orders.
List on 11.12.2025."
6.
Thereafter, the respondents No.2 and 3 have filed counter
affidavits.
7.
It is the stand of the respondent No.2 in the counter affidavit that
the petitioner has been rightly disqualified in the technical evaluation of his bid
by the Technical Evaluation Committee, but respondent No.3 had fulfilled the
turnover requirement of Rs.7(seven) crore for the last three financial years as
per total turnover certificate specified for the tender, which was also certified
by an independent Chartered Accountant.
8.
Both the counsel for respondents No.2 and 3 have drawn the
attention of this Court to Annexure-7, format of total turnover certificate, which
indicated that apart from the financial turnovers for the years 2022-23, 2023-24
and 2024-25, there is a column providing for "average" of three financial years.
According to the said respondents, the "average" turnover for the above
financial years relating to the respondent No.3 is Rs.816.75 crores and,
therefore, the respondent No.3 was rightly held eligible, and that because of the
interim order passed by this Court on 20.11.2025, no agreement or letter
awarding the contract to the respondent No.3 was done.
9.
Neither of the respondents' counsel dispute the fact that Clause-43
in the tender did not mention about "average" turnover of three years, and it
mentioned only that financial turnover of a bidder should be more than
Rs.7(seven) crores per annum in the preceding three years. In other words, the
tender requirement is that for "each" of the three preceding years, the financial
turnover of a bidder should be more than Rs.7(seven) crores per annum.
Therefore, there was no question of taking the "average" turnover of all the
three years and making the respondent No.3 qualify in the technical evaluation
done by the respondent No.2's Technical Evaluation Committee.
10.
The Supreme Court of India in the case of Ramana Dayaram
Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India & others1 has held that an
Executive Authority must be rigorously held to the standards by which it
professes its actions to be judged, and it must scrupulously observe those
standards on pain of invalidation of an act in violation of them. It held:
"10. Now, there can be no doubt that what paragraph (1) of the
notice prescribed was a condition of eligibility which was required
to be satisfied by every person submitting a tender. The condition
of eligibility was that the person submitting a tender must be
conducting or running a registered IInd Class hotel or restaurant
and he must have at least 5 years' experience as such and if he did
not satisfy this condition of eligibility, his tender would not be
eligible for consideration. This was the standard or norm of
eligibility laid down by respondent 1 and since the respondents 4
did not satisfy this standard or norm, it was not competent to
Respondent 1 to entertain the tender of Respondents 4. It is a wellsettled rule of administrative law that an executive authority must
be rigorously held to the standards by which it professes its actions
to be judged and it must scrupulously observe those standards on
pain of invalidation of an act in violation of them. This rule was
(1979) 3 SCC 489
enunciated by Mr Justice Frankfurter in Viteralli v. Saton [359 US
535 : Law Ed (Second series) 1012] where the learned Judge said:
“An executive agency must be rigorously held to the
standards by which it professes its action to be judged .…
Accordingly, if dismissal from employment is based on a
defined procedure, even though generous beyond the
requirements that bind such agency, that procedure must be
scrupulously observed .... This judicially evolved rule of
administrative law is now firmly established and, if I may
add, rightly so. He that takes the procedural sword shall
perish with the sword.”
This Court accepted the rule as valid and applicable in
India in A.S. Ahluwalia v. Punjab [(1975) 3 SCC 503, 504 : 1975
SCC (L&S) 27 : (1975) 3 SCR 82] and in subsequent decision
given in Sukhdev v. Bhagatram [(1975) 1 SCC 421, 462 : 1975
SCC (L&S) 101 : (1975) 3 SCR 619] , Mathew, J., quoted the
above-referred observations of Mr Justice Frankfurter with
approval. It may be noted that this rule, though supportable also
as an emanation from Article 14, does not rest merely on that
article. It has an independent existence apart from Article 14. It is
a rule of administrative law which has been judicially evolved as a
check against exercise of arbitrary power by the executive
authority. If we turn to the judgment of Mr Justice Frankfurter and
examine it, we find that he has not sought to draw support for the
rule from the equality clause of the United States Constitution, but
evolved it purely as a rule of administrative law. Even in England,
the recent trend in administrative law is in that direction as is
evident from what is stated at pages 540-41 in Prof Wade's
“Administrative Law”, 4th Edn. There is no reason why we should
hesitate to adopt this rule as a part of our continually expanding
administrative law. Today with tremendous expansion of welfare
and social service functions, increasing control of material and
economic resources and large scale assumption of industrial and
commercial activities by the State, the power of the executive
Government to affect the lives of the people is steadily growing.
The attainment of socio-economic justice being a conscious end of
State policy, there is a vast and inevitable increase in the
frequency with which ordinary citizens come into relationship of
direct encounter with State power-holders. This renders it
necessary to structure and restrict the power of the executive
Government so as to prevent its arbitrary application or exercise.
Whatever be the concept of the Rule of Law, whether it be the
meaning given by Dicey in his “The Law of the Constitution” or
the definition given by Hayek in his “Road to Serfdom” and
“Constitution of Liberty” or the exposition set forth by Harry
Jones in his “The Rule of Law and the Welfare State”, there is as
pointed out by Mathew, J., in his article on “The Welfare State,
Rule of Law and Natural Justice” in “Democracy, Equality and
Freedom” [Upendra Baxi, Ed. : Eastern Book Co., Lucknow
(1978) p. 28] “substantial agreement in juristic thought that the
great purpose of the rule of law notion is the protection of the
individual against arbitrary exercise of power, wherever it is
found”. It is indeed unthinkable that in a democracy governed by
the rule of law the executive Government or any of its officers
should possess arbitrary power over the interests of the individual.
Every action of the executive Government must be informed with
reason and should be free from arbitrariness. That is the very
essence of the rule of law and its bare minimal requirement. And to
the application of this principle it makes no difference whether the
exercise of the power involves affectation of some right or denial
of some privilege."
11.
The Supreme Court thus emphasized the need to structure and
restrict the power of the Executive Government so as to prevent its arbitrary
application or exercise and held that every action of the Executive Government
must be informed with reason and should be free from arbitrariness.
12.
There is no explanation offered by the respondents to support the
deviation from the tender condition, except to say that the format of the
annexure where the financial turnover is to be furnished by a bidder also
indicated the "average" turnover and, therefore, it is permissible for the
respondent No.2 to take that into account while deciding that the respondent
No.3 was eligible.
13.
In our opinion, the format will not override the condition in the
tender which mandated that the financial turnover of the bidder should be more
than Rs.7(seven) crore per annum in the preceding three years, i.e. in "each" of
the preceding three years. So it was not permissible for the respondent No.2's
Technical Evaluation Committee to take the average turnover of the three years
and then make the respondent No.3 eligible in the technical evaluation
arbitrarily.
14.
In this view of the matter, the Writ Petition is allowed; the decision
of 29.10.2025 taken by the respondent No.2 making the respondent No.3
eligible as per the Technical Evaluation Committee's decision for award of the
contract is, therefore, set aside; and the respondent No.2 is directed to issue a
fresh tender for procurement and installation of the 3 nos. of medium Liquid
Nitrogen Plant along with 125 kVA voltage Stabilizer for West Tripura, Gomati
and Unakoti Districts. No costs.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(BISWAJIT PALIT, J)
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
Pulak
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2026.01.19 17:46:57 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review