Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
SHARMA
Date: 2023.04.19 11:10:15 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
1.
Shri. Mutum Churamani Meetei aged about 62
years S/O Late M. Iboton Meetei of Kabo Leikai
Dewlahland, P.O. & P.S.-Porompat, DistrictImphal East, Manipur who is the Secretary of the
Meetei (Meitei) Tribe Union being Regd. No. 15
of 2022,
2.
Shri. Puyam Ranachandra Singh aged about 43
years S/O Puyam Kushumani Singh of Langathel
Laikom Bazar, P.O. & P.S.-Thoubal, DistrictThoubal, Manipur who is the Member of the
Meetei (Meitei) Tribe Union being Regd. No. 15
of 2022.
3.
Shri. Thokchom Gopimohon Singh, aged about
73 years S/O Late Thokchom Somokanta Singh
of Keishamthong Laisom Leirak, P.O. & P.S.Imphal, District-Imphal West, Manipur-795001
who is the Member of the Meetei (Meitei) Tribe
Union being Regd. No. 15 of 2022.
4.
Shri. Sagolsem Robindro Singh age about 66
years S/O S. Amu Singh of Sagolband Khamnam
Bazar, P.O.-Imphal & P.S.- Lamphel, DistrictImphal West, Manipur- 795001 who is the
Member of the Meetei (Meitei) Tribe Union being
Regd. No. 15 of 2022.
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |2
5.
Shri. Elangbam Baburam aged about 76 years
S/o (L) E. Leipakmacha Singh of Keirak
Khongnang Leikai, P.S Kakching B P.O Keirak,
P.O Kakching District-Kakching, Manipur who is
the Member of the Meetei (Meitei) Tribe Union
being Regd. No. 15 of 2022.
6.
Shri. Leihaorambam Projit Singh aged about 62
years, S/o L. Surjit Singh of Sorok Atingbi Khunou
Hilghat, P.O. & P.S.-Jiribam, District-Jiribam,
Manipur-795115 who is the Member of the
Meetei (Meitei) Tribe Union being Regd. No. 15
of 2022.
7.
Shri. Thiyam Somendro Singh aged about 46
years, S/o Th. Ibobi Singh of Ningthoukhong
Ward No. 5, Ningthoukhong Kha Bishnupur, P.O.
& P.S.-Bishnupur, District-Bishnupur, Manipur795126 who is the Member of the Meetei (Meitei)
Tribe Union being Regd. No. 15 of 2022 and
8.
Shri. Mutum Nilamani Singh aged about 61 years
S/O M. Jadhop Singh of Chingdong Leikai, P.O.
& P.S.-Jiribam, District-Jiribam, Manipur-795115
who is the Member of the Meetei (Meitei) Tribe
Union being Regd. No. 15 of 2022.
……...Petitioners
-Versus-
1.
The State of Manipur represented by the Chief
Secretary, Government of Manipur and its Office
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |3
at Babupara, Old Secretariat Complex, Imphal
West, Manipur-795001.
2.
The Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Manipur and
its Office at Old Secretariat Complex, Imphal,
Manipur-795001.
3.
The
Secretary,
Tribal
Affairs
and
Hills
Department and its Office at Old Secretariat
Complex, Imphal, Manipur and
4.
The
Secretary,
Ministry
of
Tribal
Affairs,
Government of India, Shastri Bhawan New Delhi110001.
…..…Respondents
-BEFOREHON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, GA
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, DSGI
Date of Hearing and
Judgment & Order
::
27.03.2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for the petitioners.
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned Government Advocate, accepts notice
on behalf of the respondents 1 to 3 and Mr.Kh. Samarjit, learned
Deputy Solicitor General of India assisted by Mr.Paikhoma,
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |4
learned counsel, accepts notice on behalf of the fourth
respondent.
2.
By consent, the main writ petition is taken up for final
disposal at the admission stage itself.
3.
The petitioners have filed this writ petition for
issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the first respondent to
submit recommendation in reply to the Letter No.1902005/2012C&IM dated 29.5.2013 of the Government of India, Ministry of
Tribal Affairs within a period of two months or within a time frame
and to include Meetei/Meitei community in the Schedule Tribe list
of
Indian Constitution as a “tribe among tribes of Manipur”,
maintaining the tribal status of Meetei/Meitei existed before
21.9.1949 i.e. before signing of the Merger Agreement as part of
the terms and conditions of the Merger Agreement of Manipur into
the Indian Union and also direction on the fourth respondent to
restore the Scheduled Tribe status of Meetei/Meitei community.
4.
In support of the prayer made, Mr. Ajoy Pebam, the
learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the status of
Meetei/Meitei community before the execution of the Merger
Agreement dated 21.9.1949 as “tribe among tribes of Manipur”
and while merging Manipur with the Union of India, the
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |5
Meetei/Meitei has lost the identity of tribe and, therefore,
Meetei/Meitei should be included as a tribe among the tribes of
Manipur so as to preserve the said community and save the
ancestral land, tradition, culture and language.
5.
By
placing
on
record
various
documentary
references, which are annexed with the writ petition, the learned
counsel further submitted that during the preparation of Scheduled
Tribe lists of India under Article 342 of the Constitution of India,
the Meetei/Meitei community are left out.
But there are
documentary evidence wherein showing the earlier Meetei/Meitei
community also belonged to tribe community.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioners would submit
that as per Article 342(1) and 366 (19) (23) (25) of the Constitution
of India, the Meetei/Meitei community should be restored the tribe
status by recognizing as a tribe/tribal community as the Meitei are
still tribe, but the status of Meitei community were left out while
preparation of Scheduled Tribe lists. Moreover, the originality,
genuineness and distinctness of the Meetei/Meitei was better
known by the customary institutions of Manipur, State Government
and Central Government Agencies as tribe. In this regard, various
individuals, organizations including the petitioners have submitted
several representations to the concerned authorities for inclusion
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |6
by restoring the Scheduled Tribe status of the Meeitei/Meitei
community to the List of Scheduled Tribes.
7.
The learned counsel further submitted that in reply to
the representation submitted by Scheduled Tribe Demand
Committee, the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India
wrote a letter dated 29.5.2013 to the Government of Manipur
whereby requesting for specific recommendation along with the
latest socio-economic survey and ethnographic report. Despite
the letter dated 29.5.2013, the Government of Manipur failed to
submit the recommendation to the reason best known to them. In
fact, the representation dated 18.4.2022 submitted by the
petitioners was forwarded by the Government of India, Ministry of
Home Affairs to the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India
for necessary action. According to the learned counsel, Meitei
community is the one of major/principal tribe of Manipur is not
recommended by the State Government. Hence, the petitioners
have been advised to file the present writ petition.
8.
By placing on record, the order dated 26.5.2003 of
the Gauhati High Court made in W.P.(C) No.4281 of 2002, the
learned counsel submitted that pursuant to the said order,
Chongthu, Khoibu and Mate have been included in the List of
Scheduled Tribes and now there are 34 numbers of tribal
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |7
community of Manipur were included in the List of Scheduled Tribe
of the Indian Constitution, but Meetei/Meitei tribe was left out.
Arguing so, the learned counsel for the petitioner prayed for
allowing of the writ petition.
9.
This Court heard the submissions of the learned
Deputy Solicitor General of India appearing for the respondent
Union of India and the learned Government Advocate for the
respondent State on the submissions made by learned counsel for
the petitioner.
10.
The grievance of the petitioners is that while merging
Manipur with the Union of India, Meetei/Meitei of Manipur has lost
the identity of tribe and the status of the Meetei/Meitei community
before execution of the Merger Agreement on 21.9.1949 as a tribe
among tribes of Manipur should be maintained by including
Meetei/Meitei community in the List of Scheduled Tribe under the
Constitution of India.
The learned counsel for the petitioners
contended that as per the order of the Gauhati High Court dated
26.5.2003 passed in W.P.(C) No.4281 of 2002, Chongthu, Khoibu
and Mate have been included in the List of Scheduled Tribes.
Taking aid of the said order dated 26.5.2003 of the Gauhati High
Court, the learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that similar
recommendation may be made by this Court to the respondent
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |8
authorities to include Meetei/Meitei community as Scheduled
Tribe List of the Constitution of India.
11.
This Court perused the order of the Gauhati High
Court dated 26.5.2003 passed in W.P.(C) No.4281 of 2002 and
the said order reads thus:
“Heard Dr. N.K.Singh, learned counsel for the
petitioners and also heard Mr.K.Kumar, learned
Additional C.G.S.C. appearing on behalf of the
respondents 1 to 4 as well as Mr. Kh.Babul
Chandra, learned State Counsel appearing on
behalf of the State Respondents 5 and 6.
The limited grievance of the writ petitioners in this
writ petition is that pursuant to the proposal of the
Government of India to revise the list of
Scheduled Tribes of the States and Union
Territories after 50 years of the functioning of the
Constitution in terms of Articles 341 and 342 of
the Constitution of India, the Govt. of Manipur
vide
communications
dated
31.12.99
and
3.1.2001 recommended 5 (five) Tribes namely,
Inpui, Liangmai, Rongmai, Thangal and Zeme for
modification in the existing entry with 3 (three)
other Tribes namely, Chengthu, Kheibu and
Mete were proposed to inclusion as new Tribes.
But despite such recommendation of the Govt. of
Manipur, all the 8 (eight) Tribes-5 (five) Tribes for
modification and 3 (three) Tribes for inclusion in
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
Page |9
the list of Scheduled Tribes as noticed above,
have been left out of consideration by the
competent authority.
The respondents mainly respondents 1 to 4
contested this writ petition by filing the affidavitin-opposition. In paragraph 10 and 11 of the said
affidavit-in-opposition it is stated
that the
proposal for modification/inclusion of the 8 (eight)
Tribes has not been left out of consideration and
the consideration of the same is under process.
It is also averred by the contesting respondents
that
after
examination,
if
the
(eight)
communities are found to be eligible, necessary
amendments in the order specifying the list of
Scheduled Tribes of Manipur would be carried
out in terms of the provisions of Article 342 of the
Constitution.
Paragraphs 10 and 11 of the affidavit-inopposition, being relevant, are reproduced as
under:“10. That, with regard to the statements
made in para 8 of the writ petition the
deponent denies the correctness of the
same,
the
proposals
of
five
communities namely, Inpui, Liangmai,
Rongmai, Thangal and Zeme for
modifications in the existing entries of
the list of Scheduled Tribes and cases
of three tribes namely Chongthu, Koibu
and Mate for fresh inclusion are being
processed as per the approval
modalities. Thus, the averments of the
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
P a g e | 10
petitioners that the case of the above
referred eight communities has been
left out of consideration is not correct.
Their requests are under examination.
11. That, as regard to the statements
made in para 9 of the writ petition the
deponent begs to submit that the
proposals of 8 communities are under
consideration of the Government and
they are being processed as per
approved
modalities.
If
after
examination they are found eligible,
necessary amendments in the order
specifying the list of Schedules Tribes
of Manipur would be carried out as per
provisions of Article 342 of the
Constitution of India.”
In view of the above referred statements made
by the respondents and also upon hearing the
learned counsel for the parties, this Court is
inclined to dispose of the writ petition with a
direction that the respondents 1 to 4 shall
consider the case of the petitioners expeditiously
in terms of the averments made in the said
paragraphs as alluded above.
However, liberty is granted to the petitioners to
approach this Court if they are still aggrieved by
any decision taken by the Respondents 1 to 4 in
this regard.
A copy of the affidavit-in-opposition as produced
by the respondents 1-4 be kept as to form part of
the record.
This disposes of the writ petition.”
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
P a g e | 11
12.
On 18.4.2022, the Meetei (Meitei) Tribe Union
submitted a representation to the Hon’ble Union Minister of Tribal
Affairs with a copy to 12 authorities, including the Chief Secretary,
Government of Manipur seeking inclusion of Meetei/Meitei Tribe
of Manipur in the list of Scheduled Tribe under Indian Constitution.
On 31.5.2022, the Ministry of Tribal Affairs forwarded the said
representation to the Secretary, Government of Manipur. In the
said forwarding letter, it has been stated as under:
“I am directed to refer to this Ministry’s letter of
even number dated 06/03/2019, 23/07/2021,
15/02/2022 & 07.04.2022 and to forward
herewith a representation dated 18.04.2022 of
Shri Salam Gourakishwor Singh, Meetei (Meitei)
Tribe Union, Kaboleikai, Imphal East District,
Manipur 795005, which is self-explanatory, for
action as deemed appropriate.
2. Scheduled Tribes (STs) are notified under
Article 342 of the Constitution. Government of
India had on 15.6.1999 (and further revised on
25.6.2002) approved modalities for determining
claims for inclusion in and other modifications in
list of STs.
As per those modalities only
proposals recommended and justified by the
state Government concerned and agreed to by
RGI as well as NCSI are considered for
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
P a g e | 12
amendment of legislation.
All the actions are
taken as per approved modalities.
The
recommendation
State
of
the
concerned
Government is pre-requisite to process the case
further.”
13.
Thus, from the above letter correspondence of the
Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Government of India, it is clear that there
appears to be a recommendation of the State Government is
pending for inclusion of the Meetei/Meitei community in the
Scheduled Tribes list of the Constitution of India.
14.
It is not the case of the respondent State that
representations regarding inclusion of Meetei/Meitei community
as Scheduled Tribes submitted by the various Union including the
petitioners have not been received by them.
15.
At this juncture, the learned counsel for the
petitioners submitted that the Government of Manipur has been
totally violating the right to equality and right to life with dignity
which are enshrined under Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of
India, as in the case of other tribe of the State, the State
Government had recommended without any hesitation but in the
case of the Meitei community which are also one of the
major/principal tribe of Manipur are not recommended by the State
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
P a g e | 13
Government. This Court finds some force in the submission made
by the learned counsel for the petitioners, as the petitioners and
other Unions are fighting long years for inclusion of Meetei/Meitei
community in the tribe list of Manipur.
16.
Nothing has been produced by the respondents,
particularly the respondent State to show that they have sent reply
to the letter dated 29.5.2013 of the Government of India, Ministry
of Tribal Affairs. Thus, the issue of inclusion of Meetei/Meitei
community in the Scheduled Tribes list of the Constitution is
pending for nearly ten years and above.
No satisfactory
explanation is forthcoming from the side of the respondent State
for not submitting the recommendation for the last 10 years.
Therefore, it would be appropriate to direct the respondent State
to submit its recommendation to the Ministry of Tribal Affairs within
a reasonable time.
17.
In the result,
(i)
The writ petition is disposed of.
(ii)
The first respondent is directed to submit the
recommendation in reply to the letter dated
29.5.2013 of the Ministry of Tribal Affairs,
Government of India.
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
P a g e | 14
(iii) The first respondent shall consider the case
of the petitioners for inclusion of the
Meetei/Meitei community in the Scheduled
Tribe list, expeditiously, preferably within a
period four weeks from the date of receipt of
a copy of this order in terms of the
averments set out in the writ petition and in
the line of the order passed in WP(C) No.
4281 of 2002 dated 26.05.2003 by the
Gauhati High Court.
(iv) No costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 229 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review