Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
$
%
"
"
!#
"
&&
'&
)
! "#$
%
&
'
"
((
(
(
(
! "#)
(
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
#
! "#$
*
((
(
!"
+
(
(
*"
! "*
(
(
!
! "*
%
&
,
'
"-
(
-2-
,
"##
,
(
"
#$
#"
"$"
,
") #)
*
##)
&
##$
,
##)
'
,
(
.
"
%
/01 123456 788279 01 8:2;2::26 <= 62;25675>
3/79925?05? >/2 @A6?B25> 756 623:22 67>26 "
4 "$"
<:2D0>=
E>/2 ,0:1>
@A6?B25>
4*
##) <=
660>04579
882997>2
4:62:
##$ <=
C;4: <:2D0>= E>/2 :079
01>:03> A6?2
4A:>FG
67>26
660>04579
#$ #"
4"
871126
0@78A: C;4:
H/03/ 345;0:B26 >/2
") #)
##)
0D09 A6?2 & :
871126
5'
0@78A:
4A:>FG
/2 89705>0;; /71 ;0926 >/2 1A0> ;4: 87:>0>045 756
1287:7>2 8411211045 4; /2: " *:6 1/7:2 05 >/2 1A0> 13/26A92
8:482:>= 345>25605? >/7> 62;25675>
/2: <:4>/2: 756 62;25675>
62;25675>
4"
4 " 0 2 78829975> /2:205 01
01 H0;2 4; 62;25675>
4"
4 * 01 >/2 10<905? 4; <4>/ 89705>0;; 756 62;25675>
756 62;25675>
41 + 756
7:2 >/2 67A?/>2:1 4;
-3-
62;25675>
41 " 756
=
+
"
=
+
"
D0997?2
J
334:605? >4 >/2 89705>0;; 9756 <27:05?
B271A:05?
73:21 $ ?A5>71 756 9756 <27:05?
B271A:05? + 73:21
10>A7>26 7>
7I/7567I0
0@78A: C;4: <:2D0>= K>/2 1A0> 8:482:>021LG 7:2 >/2
75321>:79 8:482:>021 4; 89705>0;; 756 62;25675>1
>/2 89705>0;; 62;25675>
41 " 756 *
/2 B4>/2: 4;
75?7DD7 1496 84:>0451
4; /2: 8:482:>= 6A:05? /2: 90;2 >0B2 756 :2B70505? 2M>25> 4; "#
73:21 $ ?A5>71 05 9756 <27:05?
57B2
1/2 6026 45 #
=
+
" :2B70526 05 /2:
#* ")!$ 756 62;25675>
4 " ?4>
BA>7>26 /01 57B2 05 :21823> 4; >/2 8:482:>= H/03/ 01 >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>=
4H2D2:
>/2 89705>0;; 756 62;25675>1
345>05A26 05 8411211045 4; >/2 17B2
62;25675>
5 >/2 =27: "))
4 " 2;;23>26 87:>0>045 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92
8:482:>=
7994>>26
=
"
5 >/2 1>:25?>/ 4; >/2 17B2 62;25675>
4"
1>7:>26 3970B05? :0?/> 4D2: >/2 :2B70505? 9756 <27:05?
=
+
+
" B271A:05?
+
73:21
4;
73:2 $ ?A5>71
>4
/01
/2 145 4; >/2 62;25675>
4 " 6026 011A29211 >H4 =27:1 8:04: >4 >/2 051>0>A>045 4; >/2 1A0>
7>2:
>/2 89705>0;; 05101>26 ;4: 87:>0>045 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92
8:482:>021 05 >/2 =27:
<= 62;25675>
##
4H2D2: >/2 17B2 H71 841>84526
4 " 756 ;05799= 625026
2532 >/2 89705>0;; ;0926
-4-
>/2 1A0> ;4: 87:>0>045 756 1287:7>2 8411211045 4; /2: " *:6 1/7:2
05 >/2 1A0> 8:482:>021
*
;>2: 12:D032 4; 1ABB451 >/2 62;25675>1 78827:26
<2;4:2 >/2 >:079
4A:> 756 ;0926 H:0>>25 1>7>2B25> 345>25605?
>/7> >/2 1A0> 8:482:>021 7:2 54> 75321>:79 8:482:>021 4; 89705>0;;
756 62;25675>1
334:605? >4 >/2B
7> 54 8405> 4; >0B2
87:>0>045 H71 2;;23>26 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1706 13/26A92 8:482:>021
71 3970B26 <= >/2 89705>0;;
066A
7671/0D7887
334:605? >4 >/2 62;25675>1 452
75AB7?456 A562: 7 :2?01>2:26 ?0;> 6226
67>26
#" ")+# ?0;>26 >/2 9756 <27:05?
+
B271A:05?
") 73:2
?A5>71 >4 >/2 B4>/2: 4; 62;25675>
4"
75?7DD7
A:05? /2: 90;2>0B2 1/2 1496 + 73:21 4; 9756 >4 452
0667887
7MB75
7957D7: 05 >/2 =27: ")$#
=
7>2: 05 >/2 =27: ")$+ 1/2
?7D2 A8 /2: :0?/> 05 >/2 :2B70505? 8:482:>= >4 /2: 459= 145
62;25675>
7?705 1496
4 " <= H7= 4; 713/=7>
79I0
73:21 4; 9756 4A> 4; >/2
75?7HH7 6026 45 #
5 >/2 =27: ")$
=
+
"
/2 1706
#* ")!$ 756 57B2 4; 62;25675>
H71 25>2:26 05
05 :21823> 4; >/2
=
"# 73:2 $ ?A5>7
334:605?9= >/2 62;25675>
+
1/2
4"
" B271A:05?
4 " 1A3322626
>/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>= 756 345>05A26 05 8411211045 4; >/2
-5-
17B2
5 >/2 =27: "))
62;25675>
4 " 87:>0>04526 >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>= <2>H225 /01 ;7B09= B2B<2:1
1A< 60D0626 71
=
<27:05?
+
"
=
+
" B271A:05?
B271A:05? + 73:21
=
+" "
45 *# #"
##
62;25675>
41 "
/2 9756 H71
73:2 $ ?A5>7 756
5 >/2 87:>0>045 >/2 9756
H71 ?0D25 >4 /01 145 756 7;>2: /01 627>/
>/2 17B2 H71 1>75605? 05 >/2 57B2 4;
+ 756
> 01 345>25626 >/7> >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>021 H2:2 ;79925 >4 >/2 1/7:2 62;25675>1 6A:05?
>/2 90;2>0B2 4; >/2 B4>/2: 4; 62;25675> 54 " 756 10532 >/25
>/2= 7:2 05 >/2 97H;A99 8411211045 756 25@4=B25> 4; >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>021 756 7> 54 8405> 4; >0B2 >/2 8:482:>021 H2:2
05 @405> 8411211045 4; 89705>0;; 756 62;25675>1
/2
8:7=1 >4 601B011 >/2 1A0>
+
/2
:079
4A:> 7;>2: 3451062:05? >/2 :0D79 8927605?1
;:7B26 >/2 :292D75> 011A21 756 45 711211B25> 4; 4:79 756
643AB25>7:= 2D062532 623:226 >/2 1A0> ?:75>05? " *:6 1/7:2 05
>/2 1A0> 8:482:>021 756 4:62:26 ;4: 87:>0>0451 <= B2>21 756
<4A561
5 788279
>/2
,0:1>
882997>2
4A:>
:2
788:2307>045 4; >/2 643AB25>1 756 2D062532 7D7097<92 45
-6-
:234:6
601B01126 >/2 788279 756 >/2:2<= 345;0:B26 >/2
@A6?B25> 756 623:22 871126 <= >/2
62;25675>
4 " 01 <2;4:2 >/01
4A:>
27:6
927:526
>/2
:079
4A:>
34A5129
2532 >/2
;4:
>/2
78829975>1 62;25675>1 756 :21845625> 89705>0;;
$
> 01 345>25626 <= >/2 927:526 34A5129 ;4: >/2
78829975> >/7> >/2
:079
4A:> 756 >/2 ,0:1>
882997>2
4A:> /7D2
?:4119= 2::26 H/092 871105? >/2 @A6?B25> <= 623:2205? >/2 1A0>
H0>/4A> 788:2307>05? >/2 2D062532 756 643AB25>1 45 :234:6 05
7 :0?/> 82:1823>0D2
334:605? >4 /0B >/2 1A0> ;4: 87:>0>045 01
54> B705>7057<92 H0>/4A> 3/79925?05? >/2 >:751;2: 4; >/2 >0>92 4;
1A0> 8:482:>021 05 ;7D4A: 4; >/2 62;25675> 54 "
927:526 34A5129
7660>04579 011A2
>/2 >:079
334:605? >4 >/2
4A:> /71 2::26 05 751H2:05?
4 " 45 >/2 ?:4A56 >/7> >/2 62;25675>
4 " 606
54> 8:4D2 >/7> /2 /71 92?799= 73JA0:26 :0?/>1 4D2: >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>021 756 71 1A3/ /2 01 54> >/2 7<149A>2 4H52: 4;
>/2 1A0> 8:482:>021 62180>2 /2 73JA0:26 >/2 8:482:>021 >/:4A?/
M
) >/2 D7:760
713/=7>
,A:>/2: >/2 2D062532 4;
M
79I0 2M23A>26 <= /01 B4>/2:
( " 3927:9= 62803>1 >/7> <7126 45
) 799 >/2 :2D25A2 25>:021 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021
-7-
7:2 B762 05 >/2 57B2 4; 62;25675>
4"
71 1A3/
/2
87:>0>04526 >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 <2>H225 /0B129; 756 /01
;7B09= B2B<2:1
5 1A3/ 30:3AB1>75321 >/2 1A0> ;0926 <= >/2
89705>0;; 01 54> B705>7057<92 756 7334:605?9= 8:7=1 >4 601B011
>/2 1A0> ;0926 <= >/2 89705>0;;
!
927:526 34A5129 ;4: >/2 :21845625>
1A<B0>>26 >/7> 89705>0;; 62;25675>
<205? 3/096:25 4; 62327126
4 " 756 62;25675>
4*
7:2 25>0>926 ;4: " *:6
75?7DD7
1/7:2 273/ 05 >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 71 >/20: B4>/2: 6026
05>21>7>2
927D05?
<2/056
/2:
>/:22
3/096:25
;A:>/2:
345>25626 >/7> 76B0>>269= >/2 B4>/2: 4; 89705>0;; 62;25675>
41 " 756 * /71 54> 2M23A>26 75= H099 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>021 756 <7126 45
62;25675>
M
)
>/2 D7:760
>/2
4 " 25>2:26 /01 57B2 05 >/2 BA>7>045 :2?01>2: 756
1A<12JA25>9= 2;;23>26 7 87:>0>045 <2>H225 /0B129; 756 /01
;7B09= B2B<2:1
#$ ")$+
62;25675>
> 01 345>25626 >/7> 71 82: >/2 D7:760 67>26
>/2 8:482:>= H71 BA>7>26 05 >/2 57B2 4; >/2
4 " 6A:05? >/2 90;2 >0B2 4; 89705>0;;F1 B4>/2:
1A3/ 0> 01 JA0>2 3927: >/7> >/2 62;25675> 54 " 01 897=05? ;:7A6
45 >/2 89705>0;; 756 05 4:62: >4 ?:7< >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021
-8-
<= 3499A605? H0>/ :2D25A2 4;;030791
25>2:26 /01 57B2 05 >/2
:2D25A2 :234:61 756 >/2:27;>2: <= 87:>0>04526 >/2 17B2
<2>H225 /01 ;7B09= B2B<2:1
:079
4A:> 756 >/2 ,0:1>
>/2 1A0>
882997>2
/2 1A<B0>>26 >/7> >/2
4A:> /7D2 :0?/>9= 623:226
334:605?9= /2 8:7=1 >4 601B011 >/2 788279 8:2;2::26
<= >/2 62;25675>1
)
845 /27:05? 45 76B011045 >/01
4A:> ;:7B26 >/2
;4994H05? 1A<1>75>079 JA21>0451 4; 97H
"#
/7D2 ?0D25 B= 75M04A1 3451062:7>045 45 >/2
1A<B0110451 B762 <= >/2 927:526 34A5129 ;4: >/2 :21823>0D2
87:>021 756 >/2 643AB25>1 7D7097<92 45 :234:6
""
1 34A96 <2 ?7>/2:26 ;:4B >/2 :234:61
>/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>021 7:2 >/2 129; 73JA0:26 8:482:>021 4; 452
75?7DD7 H/4 01 >/2 B4>/2: 4; 89705>0;; 62;25675>
41 " 756
-9-
*
> 01 54> 05 6018A>2 >/7> >/2 1706
75?7DD7 6026 05>21>7>2
01 >/2 345>25>045 4; >/2 62;25675>
4; 62327126
75?7DD7
>
4 " >/7> 6A:05? >/2 90;2>0B2
1/2 ?7D2 A8 /2: :0?/> 05 >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>021 >4 /0B <= H7= 4; 8713/=7> B79I0 756 7;>2:
>/2 /2: 627>/ 05 >/2 =27: ")!$ /2 1A3322626 >/2 8:482:>021
5 37:2;A9 82:A179 4;
M
) >/2 57B2 4; >/2 62;25675>
4"
H71 25>2:26 05 >/2 BA>7>045 :2?01>2: 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0>
13/26A92 8:482:>021 <= D0:>A2 4;
67>26
713/=7>
79I0
/2 17B2 01
#$ ")$+ 756 0BB2607>29= >/2 :2D25A2 25>:021 H2:2
B762 05 >/2 57B2 4; 62;25675>
75?7DD7 6026 45 #
#* ")!$
4"
6B0>>269=
4H2D2:
>/2 1706
75?7DD7 606 54>
2M23A>2 75= H099 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021
1A3/ 30:3AB1>75321 0> 37554> <2 1706 >/7> >/2
75?7DD7 /76
H01/ >4 ?0D2 7H7= >/2 25>0:2 1A0> 8:482:>021 05 ;7D4A: 4;
62;25675>
4"
/2 D7:760 8713/=7> B79I0 01 54> 1A884:>26 <=
75= 4>/2: 643AB25>1 2M23A>26 <= 62327126
75?7DD7 756 >/2
17B2 01 459= H:0>>25 <= :2D25A2 4;;032:1 H/092 BA>7>05? >/2
57B2 4; 62;25675>
8:482:>021
>/2 ,0:1>
4 " 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92
1 1A3/ 05 B= 3451062:26 D02H >/2
882997>2
:079
4A:> 756
4A:> /7D2 :0?/>9= /296 >/7> >/2 62327126
75?7DD7 6026 05>21>7>2 756 >/2 89705>0;; 756 62;25675>
41 "
- 10 -
756 * 7:2 /2: 3/096:25 799 4; >/2B 7:2 2JA799= 25>0>926 ;4: " *:6
1/7:2 273/ 05 >/2 1A0> 8:482:>021
334:605?9= >/2 1A<1>75>079
JA21>0451 4; 97H :70126 7<4D2 7:2 751H2:26 05 >/2 52?7>0D2
/2 788279 973I1 B2:0>1 756 >/2 17B2 01 907<92 >4 <2
*+
'
"
(
"
B1:
01> 4
"
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review