The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
07. 11.2023 by way of an appeal being WA No.98 of 2023 and vide WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023 order dated 22.11.2023, the appeal against interim order was dismissed by a Division Bench of this Court being devoid of any merit at that stage. [13] After completion of pleadings, the matter was finally heard on 15.01.2024 and reserved for order. Earlier the petitioner moved a contempt petition being Cont. Case (C) No.118 of 2023 alleging violation of the interim order dated 07.11.2023, but the same was closed on 23.11.2023 recording the submission of the respondents that the interim order had already been complied with. [14] Mr. B P Sahu, learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner has been victimised by the respondents. While contractual service of other employees appointed along with the petitioner has been extended, his service has not been extended without giving any reason and with a mala fide intention. It is pointed out that as per Clause 12 of terms of employment, a notice of 3 months would be required for termination of service and the same was not complied by the respondents. It is asserted that such action is arbitrary and violative of the principles of equality enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. It is pointed out that the plea of unsatisfactory service and adverse reports against the pe…
30. 01.2023] where it was deprecated the practice of selective absorption of similarly situated persons. Reference is made to the decision of Bombay High Court in the case of Pandurang Kashinath More v. Union of India: AIR 1959 Bom 134 to highlight the point that guarantee given by Articles 14 and 16 extends to all strata of employment whether it be temporary or permanent. Learned senior counsel also cites decision of Calcutta High Court in the case of Saroj Agarwal v. Union of India: Indiankanoon.org/ doc/4098839 where back wage was granted as the employer victimised the employee. It is prayed that the writ petition be allowed and the respondents be directed to extend the contractual service of the petitioner as done for other similarly persons and to issue experience certificate to him for applying in other institutes. WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023 [16] Per contra, Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI submits that it is the settled proposition of the law that a contract employee has no inherent right to claim for extension of his service and regularisation thereof. He draws the attention of this Court to the “Terms of Appointment for the Purely Temporary Faculty” [Page 1819 of writ petition]. Clause 1 stipulates that the appointment as Visiting Assistant Professor is purely temporary in nature. Clause 2 provides that further extension will be based …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.764 of 2023
with
MC (WP(C)) No.342 of 2023
with
MC (WP(C) No.414 of 2023
Dr.Murli Manohar, aged about 39 years,
s/o Surendra Prasad Pandit, resident of
Mirjanhat, Bhagalpur, Bihar 812005
currently residing at R2-101, IIT Manipur,
PO Mantripukhri, PS Heingang and District
Imphal East, Manipur 795002.
… Petitioner
-Versus1.
The Union of India through the Principal
Secretary/commissioner/Secretary,
Ministry of Education, Govt. of India
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi-110001.
2.
The Director, Indian Institute of
Information Technology (IIIT), Manipur,
Mantripukhri PO Mantripukhru, PS
Heingabg and District Imphal East,
Manipur.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner:
Mr.B.P.Sahu, Sr.Advocate &
Mr.A.P.Sahu, Advocate
For the Respondents:
Mr.Kh.Samarjit, DSGI &
Mr.Nongdamba, Advocate
Date of Hearing:
15.01.2024
Date of Order:
01.04.2024
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER [CAV]
[1]
Heard Mr. B. P. Sahu, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. Anjan Prasad Sahu, for the petitioner Mr. Kh. Samarjit,
learned DSGI assisted by Mr. N. Nongdamba, learned counsel for
the respondents.
[2]
It is the case of the petitioner that the petitioner was
appointed to the post of Visiting Assistant Professor in the
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering in the
Indian Institute of Information Technology Manipur, vide order
dated 25th June, 2015 on contract basis for a period of one year.
Service of the petitioner was extended from time to time. Order
dated 30th May, 2023 is the last such extension of service w.e.f.
03.06.2023 to 02.11.2023.
[3]
Assistant
It is also stated that the petitioner while serving as
Professor
in
the
Department of
Electronics
and
Communication Engineering from 1st July 2015 to 08.04.2019, the
Interim Director, IIT Manipur issued certificate dated 08.04.2019 for
his sincere service and experience. Further, the petitioner requested
the Director, IIIT Senapati, Manipur for issuance of experience
certificate for the period from 01.07.2015 to till date. The petitioner
tendered another representation dated 23.02.2023 to the Director,
IIIT, Manipur for issuance of experience certificate as he wished to
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
apply to other institutes in the interest of his career. However, the
Director assured the petitioner that his service would be extended
again till his regularization and that he needs not apply elsewhere
and on that ground experience certificate has not been issued till
date. Due to non-issuance of experience certificate, petitioner has
been deprived of his right to apply to other institutes and it is stated
that such certificate is mandatory for applying for appointment to
other institutes.
[4]
The petitioner further stated that without issuing any
termination order, he was informed verbally on 01.11.2023 that his
contract would not be extended beyond 02.11.2023 and no reason
whatsoever was assigned for the same. Further, the terms of his
employment stipulate that a notice period of three months would be
intimated before termination of contract. No such notice was issued,
nor was any show cause notice served to the petitioner.
[5]
It is submitted that the other four incumbents who had
joined IIIT, Manipur along with the petitioner have all been allowed
to continue in their service, and only the petitioner has been
personally picked and victimised. The petitioner is even more
qualified than some of the other four incumbents.
[6]
The petitioner, having no alternative, approached this
Court praying for allowing him to continue in his post and to
regularize him to the said post with all consequential benefits.
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
[7]
Respondents have filed affidavit-in-opposition stating
that the Indian Institute of Information Technology (IIIT), Manipur,
an Institute of national importance under the Ministry of Education,
Government of India,
was established under the public-private
partnership (PPP) mode under the Indian Institutes of Information
Technology (Public Private Partnership) Act, 2017 and Statute of
2017 with stock holding of (i) Govt. of India- 57.5%, (ii) Govt. Of
Manipur- 35.0%, and (iii) M/s Cyber Corporation Manipur Ltd
(CCML)- 7.5% with a view to develop new knowledge in information
technology and to provide manpower in this field. Initially, IIT,
Senapati, Manipur was established in the year 2015 and in the 2 nd
Governing Body Meeting of IIIT-Manipur held on 19.02.2015, a total
of 16 numbers of various faculty and other 22 non-faculty staff for
the institute was proposed. As a contingency plan awaiting regular
recruitment of the posts as per rules, it was further proposed to
share faculties of other nearby institutes and to explore outsourcing.
In the year 2015, the Interim Director of IIT-Manipur appointed 6
(six) Visiting Assistant Professors on temporary contract basis for a
period of one year. It is stated that the petitioner was one among
them and was appointed as Visiting Assistant Professor (on contract)
on 01.07.2015 on the basis of the resume submitted by the
applicant. It is clarified that the engagement/appointment was done
without due process of recruitment through open advertisement or
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
through a selection committee and as a stop gap arrangement till
the completion of the recruitment process on regular basis. The
contractual service of the contract Visiting Assistant Professors
including the petitioner has been extended from time to time. It is
further stated that the extension of the contract service is on the
basis of performance as per Clause 2 of the Terms of Appointment
for the Purely Temporary Faculty. Clause 3 provides that the
temporary appointment will be terminated automatically on expiry
of the contract period. Clause 12 further provides that the temporary
service is terminable with three months’ notice on either side. One
of the appointees left the institute in the year 2019 for regular
employment in some other place and out of the 6 original
appointees, only 5 Visiting Assistant Professors are remaining in the
institute. It is reiterated that the institute has the right not to
renew/extend the contractual term of the petitioner considering the
nature of his appointment and the numerous adverse reports filed
against him which were also endorsed by the Head of Department,
Electronic and Communication Engineering, Head of Academic
Section and Warden of the Girls Hostel. As per Annexure R-4 (colly)
appended to the counter affidavit, the profile of 6 Faculty recruited
in the year 2015 on temporary basis in different departments, seven
adverse remarks have been recorded in the remarks column against
the petitioner such as, (i) harassing & intimidation of a female
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
student, (ii) negligence of duty & subordination, (iii) repeated
complaints of students on his poor teaching, (iv) unauthorised
absence on 27.11.2023 & 31.10.2023, (v) disregard of institute rules
and causing nuisance, (vi) not adhering to timeline for submission
of assessment marks resulting in inordinate delay, and (vii) not
maintaining and conducting lab experiments
effectively
as
mandated. The performance of the petitioner was assessed as NOT
satisfactory. Copies of the reports from HoD (ECE), HoS (Academic),
Warden of Girl Hostels and statements of girl inmates are attached
to the profile of the petitioner.
[8]
The petitioner filed rejoinder affidavit reiterating the
contents of the writ petition and denying the allegations made
against him in the counter affidavit of the respondents. It is stated
that the petitioner has been subjected to harassment and ill
treatment with an ulterior motive to terminate him and appoint
someone else in his place. It is denied the allegation of unauthorised
absence. It is stated that the service of other candidates has been
extended while the same is illegally denied to him and the allegation
of poor performance and unsatisfactory service are an afterthought
to cover up the lapses on the part of the respondents. The nonfunctioning of the lab was due to unavailability/defective equipment
in spite of his requisition for rectification of the same. Regarding
delay in assessment of answer scripts, it is clarified that he was not
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
given sufficient time to evaluate and the department has not set any
time frame. It is also stated that the female student and hostel
warden have already withdrawn the complaint against him. It is
pointed out that the IIIT-Manipur awarded a Certificate of
Appreciation to the petitioner for highest attendance in the semester
and for his contribution on the occasion of 1st Institute Day held on
21.04.2023. Due to non-issuance of experience certificate, the
petitioner missed to appear in an interview for faculty for ISBM
College of Engineering, Pune to be held on 09.12.2023.
[9]
The respondents filed their reply to the rejoinder
affidavit filed by the petitioner. It is stated that the petitioner did not
furnish any copy of tickets to justify his late joining to duty from
leave nor did he send any mail in this regard. It is stated that service
of 4 other employees was extended based on their performance and
the same was denied to the petitioner due to poor performance and
complaints against him. Regarding the requisition submitted by the
petitioner for purchase of equipment, the same could not be
processed as it was not supported by necessary documents and
other technical defects. It is further stated that the petitioner could
not submit the assessment marks in spite of reminders from the
institute. Regarding the withdrawal of the complaint by a female
student, it is clarified that the same was addressed to the hostel
warden and not reached the office of the institute. The other 3
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
students have not retracted from their statements against the
petitioner.
[10]
Along with the writ petition, the petitioner also filed an
application being MC(WP(C)) No. 342 of 2023 for restraining the
respondents from disturbing his service during the pendency of the
writ petition. On 06.12.2023, another application being MC(WP(C))
No. 414 of 2023 was also subsequently filed for a direction to the
respondent No.2 to issue experience certificate in respect of the
petitioner for the service rendered by him in IIIT-Manipur. On
03.11.2023 this Court issued notice and learned counsel appearing
on behalf of respondents sought some time for instructions and the
matter was directed to be listed on 07.11.2023 for consideration of
interim relief.
[11]
Vide order dated 07.11.2013, this Court passed an
interim order directing the respondents to allow the petitioner to
continue in the service till next date as temporary service of four
other persons initially appointed along with the petitioner was
extended. This Court observed that the matter required hearing
after filing of counter and rejoinder affidavits and did not express
any opinion on the regularisation of the service of the petitioner.
The matter was directed to be listed on 23.11.2023 for final disposal.
[12]
The respondents challenged the interim order dated
07.11.2023 by way of an appeal being WA No.98 of 2023 and vide
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
order dated 22.11.2023, the appeal against interim order was
dismissed by a Division Bench of this Court being devoid of any merit
at that stage.
[13]
After completion of pleadings, the matter was finally
heard on 15.01.2024 and reserved for order. Earlier the petitioner
moved a contempt petition being Cont. Case (C) No.118 of 2023
alleging violation of the interim order dated 07.11.2023, but the
same was closed on 23.11.2023 recording the submission of the
respondents that the interim order had already been complied with.
[14]
Mr. B P Sahu, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner has been victimised by the respondents.
While contractual service of other employees appointed along with
the petitioner has been extended, his service has not been extended
without giving any reason and with a mala fide intention. It is
pointed out that as per Clause 12 of terms of employment, a notice
of 3 months would be required for termination of service and the
same was not complied by the respondents. It is asserted that such
action is arbitrary and violative of the principles of equality enshrined
in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. It is pointed out
that the plea of unsatisfactory service and adverse reports against
the petitioner is an after thought to cover up the observations made
by this Court as well as the Division Bench in appeal regarding nonintimation of show cause notice to the petitioner.
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
[15]
Mr. B P Sahu, learned senior counsel draws the
attention of this Court to the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Raman Kumar v. Union of India: 2023 Live Law
(SC) 520 @ Para 8 & 20 where the service of remaining 30
employees were directed to be regularised where the service of 35
similarly situated persons had already been regularised by the
authority. Reliance is also placed on a decision of a Division Bench
of this Court in the case of Central Agricultural University v.
Gopal Bhandari [WP(C) No. 765 of 2016, Order dated
30.01.2023] where it was deprecated the practice of selective
absorption of similarly situated persons. Reference is made to the
decision of Bombay High Court in the case of Pandurang
Kashinath More v. Union of India: AIR 1959 Bom 134 to
highlight the point that guarantee given by Articles 14 and 16
extends to all strata of employment whether it be temporary or
permanent. Learned senior counsel also cites decision of Calcutta
High Court in the case of Saroj Agarwal v. Union of India:
Indiankanoon.org/ doc/4098839 where back wage was
granted as the employer victimised the employee. It is prayed that
the writ petition be allowed and the respondents be directed to
extend the contractual service of the petitioner as done for other
similarly persons and to issue experience certificate to him for
applying in other institutes.
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
[16]
Per contra, Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI submits
that it is the settled proposition of the law that a contract employee
has no inherent right to claim for extension of his service and
regularisation thereof. He draws the attention of this Court to the
“Terms of Appointment for the Purely Temporary Faculty” [Page 1819 of writ petition]. Clause 1 stipulates that the appointment as
Visiting Assistant Professor is purely temporary in nature. Clause 2
provides that further extension will be based on performance and
Clause 3 prescribes for automatic termination of temporary
appointment on expiry of contract period. As per Clause 4, the
performance of Visiting Assistant Professor will be reviewed by the
authority and Clause 12 provides that the temporary service is
terminable with 3 months’ notice on either side. Learned DSGI
explains that the contract is automatically terminated by efflux of
time unless extended and 3 months’ notice is required for premature termination before expiry of the period of contract. It is
stated that the performance of other candidates is satisfactory and
hence their service has further been extended. But in the case of
the petitioner, there are lots of complaints against him and his
performance was not satisfactory to the institute as reflected in the
profile of contract Visiting Assistant Professors as enumerated in
Annexure R-4 appended to the counter affidavit of the respondents.
It is clarified that no written intimation is required for non-extension
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
of temporary engagement in terms of Clause 3 of the terms of
engagement. It is further reiterated that in view of such serious
adverse materials against him, the term of engagement of the
petitioner is not extended and he cannot claim for automatic
extension and regularisation. It is pointed out that the engagement
was done without following due process as a stop gap arrangement
at the initial stage.
[17]
Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI relies on the decision
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Yogesh Mahajan v.
Professor R C Deka: (2018) 3 SCC 218 @ Para 6 to the point
the contract employee has no right to have his or her contract
renewed from time to time. There was no material to show that the
contractual appointment was made as per prescribed rules. Reliance
is also placed on the case of Vidyavardhaka Sangha v. Y D
Deshpande: (2006) 12 SCC 482 @ Para 4 holding that ‘…. the
appointment made on probation/ad hoc basis for a specified period
of time comes to an end by efflux of time and the person holding
such post can have no right to continue on the post …. and ask for
regularisation, etc’. Referring to the above decisions, learned DSGI
submits that the petitioner who has been appointed on temporary
basis for a fixed period cannot claim for further extension as a right
and his service is terminable by efflux of time. The extension is
purely discretionary power of the respondents on appraisal of the
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
performance. In the present case, the respondents choose not to
extend the contract of the petitioner due to poor and unsatisfactory
performance. As regard application being MC(WP(C)) No. 414 of
2023 for direction for issuing experience certificate, it is submitted
that the same is not maintainable being a separate and an
independent cause. It is prayed that the writ petition along with
applications be dismissed being devoid of any merit.
[18]
This Court considers the material on record, the
submissions made at bar and the decisions cited by parties.
[19]
The point for determination involved in the
present case is whether temporary appointee for a fixed
term like the petitioner herein has an inherent right for
claiming
for
extension
of
his
appointment
and
regularisation.
[20]
Admitted facts in the present case are that the
petitioner and others were engaged on temporary basis as Visiting
Assistant Professors in IIIT-Manipur as a stop gap arrangement in
2015 at initial stage till competition of process for regular
appointments. Their service has been extended from time to time.
The initial engagement on temporary basis was not done through
open advertisement as per procedure prescribed by rules. It is clear
from a bare perusal of “Terms of Appointment for the Purely
Temporary Faculty” that the appointment is on purely temporary
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
basis for a fixed period extendable on performance basis and the
temporary appointment is automatically terminated on expiry of the
contract period. Performance will be assessed by the authority. Premature termination can be made with three months’ notice from
either side. As per the terms of temporary appointment, the
extension is performance based at the discretion of the authority
and there is no inherent right for such extension. The above cited
case laws stipulate that the temporary appointees have no right to
claim for extension and their temporary services will be terminated
with efflux of time. However, there is a caveat to this settled
principle that there can be no discrimination amongst similarly
situated persons while considering for extension or regularisation. It
is also settled law that equality under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India would extend to all employees whether regular
or contract. Within this prism, the claim of the petitioner has to be
examined.
[21]
It is the case of the petitioner that he has been
discriminated and victimised by the respondents. While other
similarly appointees have been granted extension of temporary
engagement, the same benefit is not given to the petitioner without
any reason. It is also pointed out that the allegation of not
satisfactory service and adverse report is an afterthought to dilute
the observations of this Court for not giving any reason or show
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
cause. On the other hand, it is the specific case of the respondents
that the temporary service of the petitioner has not been extended
due to non-satisfactory performance and complaints against him. As
per terms of appointment, the term of appointment can be extended
on performance basis to be evaluated by the concerned authorities
of the respondents. It is pointed out that the performance of the
petitioner is not found to be satisfactory and he is rightly not
considered for extension. It is the case of respondents that giving
reasons for non-extension of temporary service is not required as
the service is automatically terminated with efflux of time unless
extended further. The reason given in the counter-affidavit by the
respondent for non-extension is just to answer the allegations made
by the petitioner in the writ petition. It is stated that the same
cannot be construed as an afterthought.
[22]
This Court finds force in the submissions of Mr. Kh.
Samarjit, learned DSGI appearing on behalf of the respondents. As
per terms of temporary appointment, the engagement is
automatically terminated by efflux of time unless extended by the
authority on appraisal of satisfactory performance. This Court is of
the considered view that the temporary appointee has no inherent
right to claim extension and the same is discretion of the authority
on appraisal of performance. If similarly placed persons are given
extension of service, then the court can interfere and pass
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
appropriate directions in favour of similarly situated persons who
have been left out. However, in the present case, the case of four
persons whose service has been extended are not similarly situated
as that of the petitioner. The authority found the performance of
four of them as satisfactory and that of petitioner not satisfactory
as reflected in Annexure R-4 (profile of temporary Visiting Assistant
Professors engaged in 2015). The facts of the case laws cited by the
petitioner are not similar to the present case as similarly situated
persons were discriminated therein and the courts had to interfere
on the principle of equality. But, in the present case, the
performance of the petitioner is not satisfactory and he is not at par
with four other colleagues and is not considered for extension in
view of terms of appointment.
[23]
In view of the observations and findings arrived as
above, specially in Para 22, this Court does not find any merit in the
writ
petition
and
accordingly,
the
same
is
dismissed.
Interim order dated 07.11.2023 is vacated. However, in order to do
complete justice and to avoid multiplicity of litigations, the
respondents are directed to issue experience certificate to the
petitioner within a period of 15 days from the date of receiving of a
copy of this order, if the same is permissible as per rule/instruction.
The parties are directed to bear their own costs.
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
[24]
Send a copy of this order to the Director, Indian
Institute of Information Technology, Manipur at Mantripukhri for
information and necessary compliance.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
priyojit
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2024.04.02
09:57:17 +05'30'
WP(C) NO. 764 OF 2023 WITH MC(WP(C)) NOS.342 OF 2023 & 414 OF 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review