Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 01.07.2019
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
Appellants
:
1.
The Municipal Commissioner,
Gangtok Municipal Corporation,
Deorali, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Buddhiman Ghatani,
Son of D.P. Ghatani,
R/o Thangsing Bodang,
Khamdong, East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami,
Wife of Late H.K. Biswakarma.
2.
Ms. Sikha Singh,
D/o Late H.K. Biswakarma.
[Residents of Upper Gairigaon,
Gorubattan, District Darjeeling,
West Bengal].
3.
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
Hill Cart Road, Ganesh Ram Compound,
Mahanandapara, Siliguri,
West Bengal.
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-----------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Ms. Tashi Doma Sherpa, Advocates for
the Appellants.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. K.B. Chhetri and Mr.
Sunil Baraily, Advocates for Respondents No. 1 and 2.
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for Respondent No. 3.
-----------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
The learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East
Sikkim at Gangtok (hereinafter „learned Tribunal‟) vide the
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
impugned Judgment dated 28.07.2017, in MACT Case No. 27
of 2016 (Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami and Another v. Municipal
Commissioner, Gangtok Municipal Corporation and Others)
directed payment of compensation of Rs.17,29,380/- (Rupees
seventeen lakhs, twenty nine thousand, three hundred and
eighty) only, to the Respondents No. 1 and 2 (Claimants No.
1 and 2 before the learned Tribunal) by the Appellant No. 1
(Opposite Party No. 1 before the learned Tribunal) along with
interest fixed thereon. Aggrieved thereof the Appellants No. 1
and 2 are before this Court.
2.
A motor vehicle accident occurred on 04.07.2015
at a place known as “32 Number,” whereby a commercial
vehicle bearing No. WB-76-7946 (Tata Sumo, Gold), driven
by the deceased from Gangtok to Siliguri, allegedly hit a
parapet and a telephone pole on the left side of the road and
was thereafter struck from behind by the Truck bearing No.
SK-01-D-2807, driven by the Appellant No. 2 (Opposite Party
No. 2 before the learned Tribunal). This caused the Sumo to
careen off about 100 feet below the road, leading to the
instantaneous death of the deceased. Respondent No. 1, wife
of the deceased and Respondent No. 2, his daughter claimed
compensation of Rs.20,04,386/- (Rupees twenty lakhs, four
thousand, three hundred and eighty six) only.
3.
Before the learned Tribunal, the Appellants No. 1
and 2 (Opposite Parties No. 1 and 2, therein) vehemently
denied the claims of the Respondents and averred that the
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
accident occurred solely on account of the fault of the
deceased. Neither was the vehicle of the Appellant No. 1
involved in the alleged accident nor was the Appellant No. 2
responsible for rash and negligent driving or the death of the
deceased.
4.
The Respondent No. 3 averred inter alia that the
cause of accident and the death of the victim was the
outcome of the rash and negligent driving on the part of the
Appellant No. 2, who failed to maintain a safe braking
distance. Besides the deceased was the owner of the vehicle
and being the Insured did not come within the ambit of Third
Party and hence could not be compensated.
5.
The learned Tribunal after due consideration of
the pleadings struck one issue for determination viz.
“(1) Whether the Claimants are entitled
to the compensation claimed? If so, who
is liable to compensate them?”
On consideration of the entire evidence on record and the
documents
pronounced
furnished
the
before
impugned
it,
the
learned
Judgment
Tribunal
granting
the
compensation supra to the Respondents No. 1 and 2.
6.
Before
this
Court,
learned
Counsel
for
the
Appellants put forth the contention that it is doubtful as to
whether the deceased was a kin of Respondents No. 1 and 2
as Exhibit 2, the First Information Report (for short „FIR‟)
lodged by one Ratan Pradhan before the Police Inspector,
Singtam Police Station mentioned the name of the deceased
as “Chaman Diyali” and not “Harka Raj Biswakarma” the
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
person the Respondents No. 1 and 2 claim is their kin and
finds place in the Claim Petition. The name of the deceased
on Exhibit 12, the Income Tax Return Verification Form,
allegedly of the deceased also differs. That, the name of the
deceased in the Property Seizure Memo Exhibit 3, the Inquest
Report Exhibit 4, the Death Certificate Exhibit 8, Driving
Licence Exhibit 9 and the PAN Card Exhibit 10, all vary,
consequently raising doubts on the very identification of the
deceased. It was next contended that although the accident
occurred on 04.07.2015, Exhibit 12 is dated 03.11.2015
much after the accident, thereby raising doubts on the
income of the deceased. Besides, the Claim Petition has been
filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for
short the „M.V. Act‟) with no proof of rash and negligent
driving on the part of the Appellant No. 2 who was in fact
acquitted of charges under Sections 279, 336, 337, 338 and
304 A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short the 'IPC') by
a Magisterial Court. That the accident occurred on account of
the deceased overspeeding and overtaking the vehicle of the
Appellant No. 2 and thereby due to his own fault, hence, the
Appellant No. 1 could not be held liable to pay compensation.
Towards this submission reliance was placed on Surendra
Kumar Arora and Another v. Manoj Bisla and Others 1, Minu B.
Mehta
and
Another
v.
Balakrishna
Ramchandra
Nayan
and
Another2 and Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Meena Variyal and
(2012) 4 SCC 552
(1977) 2 SCC 441
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
Others3. The next argument advanced was that although the
allegation of the Investigating Officer (for short „I.O.‟) in the
Criminal Case was that the vehicle of the Appellant No. 1 hit
that of the deceased, sans Mechanical Report, thus rendering
the allegation inconsequential. That, the statements of the
passengers in the ill-fated vehicle recorded under Section 161
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short „Cr.P.C.‟)
in the Criminal Case did not reveal that the Truck hit the
Sumo from behind. Hence, in view of the afore detailed
circumstances,
the
findings
of
the
learned
Tribunal
is
perverse and deserves to be set aside. To bolster his
contentions reliance was placed on Nishan Singh and Others v.
Oriental Insurance Company Limited through Regional Manager
and Others4
and Cholamandalam General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
through Regional Manager v. Smt. Badami and Others 5.
7.
Per
contra,
learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
Respondents No. 1 and 2 while disputing the contentions of
learned Counsel for the Appellants No. 1 and 2, walked this
Court through the evidence of the Appellant No. 2 and
contended that it was the driver, Appellant No. 2 no less, who
had admitted his complicity in the accident. This was
substantiated by the evidence of the Respondent No. 2. In
light of the admission of the Appellant No. 2 the contention of
the Counsel for the Appellants concerning absence of rash
and negligent driving is contradicted. The I.O. discovered that
(2007) 5 SCC 428
(2018) 6 SCC 765
MANU/RH/0525/2018
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
the front of the Truck had sustained damages which sufficed
as proof of the accident having been caused by it. Exhibit 3,
the Property Seizure Memo prepared in connection with the
Criminal Case fortifies that the front right side of the truck
was damaged lending credence to the fact of accident and
proof of rash and negligent driving of Appellant No. 2. The
fact of the accident is also supported by Exhibit 2, the FIR
pertaining to the incident. That, this Court in The Branch
Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited v. Sa-Ngor
Chotshog Centre and Another6
has held that a conviction
recorded by a Criminal Court is enough to hold that the driver
had driven the vehicle rashly and negligently but his
acquittal, on the other hand, would be no ground to dismiss
the claim petition. That, in Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance
Company Limited and Others7 the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has
observed that when the accused were to be acquitted in a
criminal case, the same may be of no effect on the
assessment of the liability required in respect of motor
accident
cases
by
the
Tribunal.
That,
the
differences
emerging in the name of the victim on various documents has
been
clarified
by
Exhibit
21,
the
Affidavit
sworn
by
Respondent No. 1 and relied on by Respondent No. 2 which
remained undecimated in cross-examination. It was also
contended that even if the party has failed to exhibit
documents the claim petition cannot be dismissed. On this
count, strength was garnered from Vimla Devi and Others v.
MANU/SI/0013/2019
(2018) 5 SCC 656
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
National Insurance Company Limited and Another 8. That, non-
examination of relevant witnesses is not an issue in matters
under the M.V. Act and the evidence on record is to be
analysed to ascertain whether it suffices to answer the issue
raised as observed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Sunita
and Others v. Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation and
Another9.
However, on the computation of compensation
learned Senior Counsel urged that in view of the decision in
National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi and Others 10,
future prospects may also be granted on the income of the
deceased and compensation under other heads may be
modified in terms of the said Judgment.
8.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Respondent
No.
submitted that since the learned Tribunal has not ordered
payment to be made by Respondent No. 3 he had nothing to
add to the instant matter.
9.
I have heard in extenso and considered the rival
submissions of learned Counsel for the parties. I have also
carefully perused the impugned Judgment including the
documents and evidence on record as well as the citations
made at the Bar.
10.
The only question that arises for determination
before this Court is whether there was any error in the
findings of the learned Tribunal.
(2019) 2 SCC 186
AIR 2019 SC 994
2017 (4) TAC 673
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
11.
Exhibit 2 is the FIR dated 04.07.2015, lodged by
one Ratan Pradhan, an employee of the Sikkim Manipal
University, informing that the same morning at around 5.20
a.m., the vehicle (Tata Sumo Gold bearing No. WB-76-7946)
in which the Auditors of the University were travelling to
Siliguri from Gangtok had met with an accident. At the spot
he found that the Sumo had fallen into the river and one
Truck bearing No. SK-01-2807 of the Gangtok Municipal
Corporation was standing at a distance of about 100 feet
away from the accident spot and the body of the deceased
“Chaman Diyali” on the road side having been taken out from
the river by the villagers. It was his summation that the
Truck could have been instrumental in causing the accident
as one side of the Truck was damaged.
12.
In this context, while addressing the doubts
raised by the Appellants with regard to the identity of the
victim caused by the variation of his name in different
documents, I have examined the concerned documents.
Undoubtedly the name of the victim in Exhibit 4 the Inquest
Report, Exhibit 5 Challan forwarding the dead body for Post
Mortem Examination and Exhibit 9 his Driving Licence, all
record his name as “Harka Raj Biswakarma.” In Exhibit 8, his
Death Certificate, it is recorded as “Harkaraj Singh (Kami)”
while in Exhibit 10, his PAN Card, it is recorded as “Harkaraj
Singh Kami.” Exhibit 11, the Certificate of Enlistment of the
victim for his Tours and Travels Office also reflects his name
as “Harkaraj Singh” leading to discombobulation. However,
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
from the evidence of the Respondent No. 2 it is clear that
Respondent No. 1 her mother, the wife of the victim has
sworn an Affidavit, Exhibit 21, wherein she has clarified inter
alia that the Affidavit was sworn to declare that the names
“Harka Raj Biswakarma,” “Harka Raj Singh Kami,” “Harka Raj
Singh” and “Chaman Diyali” denotes and relates to one and
the same person, that is, her husband. No contrary evidence
on this aspect was furnished by the Appellants. Thus, Exhibit
21 is accepted on this count.
13.
A doubt ensued on Exhibit 12, Income Tax Return
Verification Form being dated 03.11.2015 while the victim
was already deceased on 04.07.2015. It has been clarified by
Respondent No. 2 that Exhibit 12 pertains to a particular
Financial Year and cannot be submitted as and when a person
passes away. Exhibit 12 thus pertains to the relevant
Financial Year, besides which, Respondent No. 1 survives him
and
has
taken
necessary
steps
as
required.
The
circumstances of Exhibit 12 having been explained, there can
be no doubt that this document establishes the per annum
income of the deceased.
14.
While
addressing
the
question
of
rash
and
negligent driving, the Appellant No. 2 has stated that when
his vehicle crossed the Water Garden, he saw the vehicle
bearing No. WB 76 7946 which had overtaken his vehicle at
full speed, skid off the metalled road, hit an electric post and
then fall into the river. However, his cross-examination
elicited an admission as hereunder extracted;
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
“… It is not a fact that no other vehicle or
vehicles were involved in the said accident.
(Witness volunteers to state that; it was only
him and his vehicle involved in the said
accident.) …”
Nothing could be clearer on this point to establish his role in
the accident. Cross-examination of the witness coupled along
with meticulous scrutiny of Exhibit 3, the Property Seizure
Memo in G.R. Case No. 339 of 2015, arising out of Singtam
Police Station Case bearing FIR No. 47 of 2015, reveals that
the front right side of the Truck bearing No. SK-01-D-2807
was damaged. No explanation was forthcoming from the
Appellants on the reason as to the damage on the Truck.
15.
In support of the Appellants that rash and
negligent driving was not proved, the Judgment of the
learned trial Court acquitting the Appellant No. 2 was filed
before this Court in I.A. No. 2 of 2018. The Judgment inter
alia at Paragraph 7 reads as follows;
“7. The other witnesses PW2 first
informant is not a eye witness (sic), PW 3 to
PW 6 are seizure witnesses, PW 7 is the doctor
who conducted autopsy on the deceased, PW 9
is the motor vehicle inspector and PW 10 is the
investigating Officer. Thus there exists no
evidence that the accused is the driver of the
garbage truck, there is also no evidence that
the accused was driving the said truck at the
time of the accident. More importantly there is
no evidence that the accused drove the truck
rashly or negligently or committed any act
which was rash or negligent. The evidence of
the investigating officer that the garbage truck
followed closely and hit the Tata Sumo has no
evidence apart from his. The case of the
prosecution has no iota of evidence to sustain
the accusation as framed against the accused.”
Evidently the learned trial Court truncated the proceedings
under Section 258 of the Cr.P.C. being convinced that no
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
evidence sustained the accusations against the accused/
Appellant No. 2. Whether the findings of the learned trial
Court is correct in view of the evidence before it is another
question altogether.
16.
Exhibit 22 which is the Final Report submitted by
the I.O. of the Criminal Case supra reflects inter alia that the
surface width of the asphalt road where the accident occurred
is approximately 25 feet wide with 2.3 feet width on the left
flank and 4 feet width on the right flank of the road with
parapets on the left side and easily accommodates two
vehicles on either direction. At the time of the accident, there
was reportedly no traffic except the vehicles involved in the
accident and the weather was clear with visibility up to 100
metres ahead. No brake marks or skid marks were found on
the spot to indicate that the Appellant No. 2 had applied the
brakes at the relevant time to establish efforts exercised to
prevent an accident.
17.
Although reliance was placed by the Appellants on
Nishan Singh and Others supra
assistance sought thereof is
misplaced. In the said matter a Maruti car was driving behind
a truck and dashed into it. According to the Claimants therein
viz. occupants of the car, the truck driver suddenly applied
the brakes when the said truck was in the centre of the road,
bringing it to the right side, as a result of which the Maruti
car collided with the back of the truck. The Tribunal concluded
that the driver of the Maruti car was responsible for rash and
negligent driving consequently neither the truck driver nor
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
the insurer of the truck were liable to pay the compensation.
The
matter
went
before
the
Hon‟ble
High
Court
of
Uttarakhand which similarly dismissed the Appeal reiterating
the finding recorded by the Tribunal observing inter alia that
the driver of the Maruti car had failed to keep sufficient
distance between the two vehicles, running in the same
direction. The Appellants assailed the finding of the Tribunal
and the Hon‟ble High Court before the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that the Maruti
car which was following the truck was expected to maintain a
safe distance as envisaged in Regulation 23 of the Rules of
the Road Regulations, 1989. It was further held that the
expression
“sufficient
distance”
as
given
in
the
said
Regulations has not been defined anywhere however the
thumb rule of “sufficient distance” is at least a safe distance
of two to three seconds gap in ideal conditions to avert
collision and to allow the following driver time to respond.
The distance of 10 to 15 feet between the truck and the
Maruti car was certainly not a safe distance for which the
driver of the Maruti car must take the blame. That having
been said, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court would also mull over
whether the Tribunal should have at least answered the issue
of contributory negligence of the truck driver in favour of the
Appellants/Claimants and held as follows;
“14. …The
question
of
contributory
negligence would arise when both parties are
involved in the accident due to rash and
negligent driving. In a case such as the
present one, when the Maruti car was
following the truck and no fault can be
attributed to the truck driver, the blame must
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
rest on the driver of the Maruti car for having
driven his vehicle rashly and negligently. The
High Court has justly taken note of the fact
that the driver and owner of the Maruti car, as
well as insurer of that vehicle, had not been
impleaded as parties to the claim petition. The
Tribunal has also taken note of the fact that in
all probability, the driver and owner of the
Maruti car were not made party being close
relatives of the appellants. In such a situation,
the issue of contributory negligence cannot be
taken forward. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
No support can be gained by the Appellants from the
aforestated citation which in fact assists the case of the
Respondents.
18.
In British Columbia Electric Railway Company Limited
v. Loach11, an
accident similar to the one under discussion
arose. It was observed therein as follows;
“... The accident which gave rise to the
action occurred while the deceased was being
driven by another man in a wagon called a
“rig.” The highway along which the wagon was
proceeding crossed the appellants‟ track on the
level at a point near a station and an orchard.
While the wagon was being driven across the
track it was run into by an electric car
belonging to the appellants, with the result
that the deceased was killed. ...
…………………………………………………………………………………..
In the present case their Lordships are
clearly of opinion that, under proper direction,
it was for the jury to find the facts and to
determine the responsibility, and that upon the
answers which they returned, reasonably
construed, the responsibility for the accident
was upon the appellants solely, because,
whether Sands got in the way of the car with
or without negligence on his part, the
appellants could and ought to have avoided
the consequences of that negligence, and
failed to do so, not by any combination of
negligence on the part of Sands with their
own, but solely by the negligence of their
servants in sending out the car with a brake
whose inefficiency operated to cause the
collision at the last moment, and in running
the car at an excessive speed, which required
AIR 1916 PC 208
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
a perfectly efficient brake to arrest it. Their
Lordships will accordingly humbly advise His
Majesty that the appeal should be dismissed
with costs. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
19.
In the instant case, it is worth noting that: (i)
except the evidence of Appellant No. 2 who has stated that
the Sumo overtook him, no other evidence is factored in on
this aspect from any other witnesses; (ii) it is clear that the
road surface was adequately wide and (iii) even assuming
that the vehicle of the deceased being a smaller and faster
vehicle, had overtaken the Truck driven by the Appellant No.
2, no rule of the road bars overtaking. If one vehicle
overtakes the other, the overtaken vehicle is required to
exercise caution and responsibly maintain a safe distance
thereafter. There is no evidence whatsoever to indicate that
the Sumo was driven at breakneck speed whereby the driver
lost control and hit the electric pole. At this juncture, we may
relevantly refer to the principle of res ipsa loquitur, a doctrine
that infers negligence from the very nature of an accident or
injury in the absence of direct evidence on how any person
has behaved. In other words, the aforestated principle refers
to "the thing speaks for itself" and infers negligence from the
very nature of an accident in the absence of direct evidence.
The damage to the Truck is a clear indication that the Truck
was responsible for having hit the Sumo from behind.
Contributory negligence, in my considered opinion cannot be
invoked neither can it be an issue in the circumstances. Thus
it cannot but be concluded that the Truck was instrumental in
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
the accident. That having been said it may be reiterated that
the principles governing rash and negligent driving as
required to be proved under Section 166 of the M.V. Act and
its non-requirement under Section 163 A of the M.V. Act as
sought to be urged by learned Counsel for the Appellants are
no more res integra and do not merit a protracted discussion
herein.
20.
Now to address the argument of the Appellants
that the Criminal Case was devoid of Mechanical Report to
establish that the Truck hit the Sumo, it would be apposite to
reiterate that the M.V. Act is benevolent legislation and the
absence of a Motor Vehicle Inspector‟s Report does not
demolish the claim of the Respondents No. 1 and 2. In Vimla
Devi’s case supra the Hon‟ble Supreme Court was considering
the Judgment of the Tribunal which dismissed the claim
petition of the Appellants holding that though the Claimants
had filed the documents but did not exhibit them thus
denying the Insurance Company an opportunity of crossexamining the Claimants' witnesses on the documents. The
Hon'ble High Court in appeal agreed with the decision. To the
contrary the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while allowing the claim
petition observed as hereunder;
“..............................................................
15. At the outset, we may reiterate as
has been consistently said by this Court in a
series of cases that the Act is a beneficial
piece of legislation enacted to give solace to
the victims of the motor accident who suffer
bodily injury or die untimely. The Act is
designed in a manner, which relieves the
victims from ensuring strict compliance
provided in law, which are otherwise
applicable to the suits and other proceedings
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
while prosecuting the claim petition filed
under the Act for claiming compensation for
the loss sustained by them in the accident.
........................................................................
20.1. Firstly, the appellants had adduced
sufficient evidence to prove the accident and
the rash and negligent driving of the driver of
the offending vehicle, which resulted in death
of Rajendra Prasad.
20.2. Secondly, the appellants filed
material documents to prove the factum of the
accident and the persons involved therein.
20.3. Thirdly, the documents clearly
established the identity of the truck involved in
the accident, the identity of the driver driving
the truck, the identity of the owner of the
truck, the name of the insurer of the offending
truck, the period of coverage of insurance of
the truck, the details of the lodging of FIR in
the police station concerned in relation to the
accident.
20.4. In our view, what more documents
could be filed than the documents filed by the
appellants to prove the factum of the accident
and the persons involved therein.
........................................................................
20.8. Seventhly, if the Court did not
exhibit the documents despite the appellants
referring to them at the time of recording
evidence, then in such event, the appellants
cannot be denied of their right to claim the
compensation on such ground. In our opinion,
it was nothing but a procedural lapse, which
could not be made basis to reject the claim
petition. It was more so when the appellants
adduced oral and documentary evidence to
prove their case and the respondents did
nothing to counter them.”
(Emphasis supplied)
It goes without saying that the principles so enunciated have
equal applicability herein.
21.
In light of the aforementioned reasons, I am of
the considered opinion that the Respondents No. 1 and 2
were able to prove the fact of the accident and the rash and
negligent act of the Appellant No. 2. Consequently as the
Truck belongs to the Appellant No. 1, they become vicariously
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
liable for the act of their employee and thereby liable to pay
the compensation.
22.
So
concerned,
the
far
as
computation
learned
Tribunal
of
compensation
correctly
adopted
is
the
Multiplier of “9” for calculating loss of income in terms of the
approved table laid down in Sarla Verma (Smt.) and Others vs.
Delhi Transport Corporation and Another12
as the age of the
deceased was 56. However, future prospects was
not
granted. In this context, we may beneficially refer to the
ratiocination of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in National
Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 13, wherein it
was held as follows;
“61. ...
(iii) While determining the income, an
addition of 50% of actual salary to the income
of the deceased towards future prospects,
where the deceased had a permanent job and
was below the age of 40 years, should be
made. The addition should be 30%, if the age
of the deceased was between 40 to 50 years.
In case the deceased was between the age of
50 to 60 years, the addition should be 15%.
Actual salary should be read as actual salary
less tax.
(iv) In case the deceased was selfemployed or on a fixed salary, an addition of
40% of the established income should be the
warrant where the deceased was below the
age of 40 years. An addition of 25% where the
deceased was between the age of 40 to 50
years and 10% where the deceased was
between the age of 50 to 60 years should be
regarded as the necessary method of
computation. The established income means
the income minus the tax component.”
(Emphasis supplied)
(2009) 6 SCC 121
AIR 2017 SC 5157
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
The income of the deceased was reflected as Rs.2,61,980/(Rupees two lakhs, sixty one thousand, nine hundred and
eighty) only, per annum as per Exhibit 12. Hence, in view of
the ratio supra of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, it is evident
that where the deceased was on a fixed income and between
the age of 50 to 60 years, an addition of 10% of the
established income should be made towards future prospects.
Thus, 10% shall be calculated as future prospects.
23.
So far as loss of estate, loss of consortium and
funeral expenses are concerned, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
in Pranay Sethi (supra), inter alia held as follows;
“(viii)
Reasonable
figures
on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate,
loss of consortium and funeral expenses
should
be
₹15,000/-,
₹40,000/and
₹15,000/- respectively.”
(Emphasis supplied)
Later in time, in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram
and Ors.14,
while discussing the right to consortium, the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court determined as under;
“8.7 A Constitution Bench of this Court in
Pranay Sethi (supra) dealt with the various
heads under which compensation is to be
awarded in a death case. One of these heads is
Loss of Consortium.
In legal parlance, "consortium" is a
compendious
term
which
encompasses
'spousal consortium', 'parental consortium',
and 'filial consortium'.
The right to consortium would include
the company, care, help, comfort, guidance,
solace and affection of the deceased, which is
a loss to his family. With respect to a spouse,
it would include sexual relations with the
deceased spouse.
Spousal consortium is generally defined
as rights pertaining to the relationship of a
husband-wife which allows compensation to
the surviving spouse for loss of "company,
MANU/SC/1012/2018
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
society, co-operation, affection, and aid of the
other in every conjugal relation."
Parental consortium is granted to the
child upon the premature death of a parent,
for loss of "parental aid, protection, affection,
society, discipline, guidance and training."
........................................................................
A few High Courts have awarded
compensation on this count. However, there
was no clarity with respect to the principles on
which compensation could be awarded on loss
of Filial Consortium.
The amount of compensation to be
awarded as consortium will be governed by
the principles of awarding compensation
under 'Loss of Consortium' as laid down in
Pranay Sethi (supra). ...”
(Emphasis supplied)
24.
Consequently
Rs.15,000/-
(Rupees
fifteen
thousand) only, is granted towards funeral expenses in terms
of Pranay Sethi and Others (supra) instead of Rs.25,000/(Rupees twenty five thousand) only, granted by the learned
Tribunal. Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, is
granted towards loss of estate in terms of Pranay Sethi and
Others
(supra) instead of Rs.2,500/- (Rupees two thousand
and five hundred) only, granted by the learned Tribunal. Rs.
40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only, each, is granted to
the Respondents No. 1 and 2 towards “spousal consortium”
and “parental consortium” respectively,
General Insurance Co. Ltd.
in terms of Magma
(supra) instead of Rs.1,00,000/-
(Rupees one lakh) only, granted by the learned Tribunal. The
question of compensation on account of “loss of love and
affection” as granted by the learned Tribunal, in view of the
ratio supra becomes superfluous and is deducted from the
compensation
amount.
With
regard
to
the
amount
of
Rs.5,000/- (Rupees five thousand) only, having been granted
towards “Cost of transportation of the victim to the Hospital,”
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
no evidence has been furnished by the Respondents No. 1
and 2 to support such claim, hence cannot be granted and is
duly deducted.
25.
In conclusion, in light of the above discussions
and findings, the compensation which is found to be just is as
follows;
Annual Income of the deceased
Rs.2,61,980.00
Add 10% of Rs.2,61,980.00 as future prospects
Rs.26,198.00
Yearly income of the deceased
Rs.2,88,178.00
Less 1/3 of Rs. 2,88,178.00
[deducted from the said amount in consideration
of the instances which the victim would have
incurred towards maintenance had he been
alive.]
Rs.96,059.00
Net yearly income
Rs.1,92,119.00
Multiplier of ‘9’ adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s case (supra) (Rs.1,92,119 x 9)
Rs.17,29,071.00
Add Funeral expenses in terms of
Pranay Sethi’s case (supra)
Rs.15,000.00
Add Loss of consortium
[Rs.40,000/- each, payable to Respondents
No. 1 and 2 as spousal consortium and
parental consortium, respectively] in terms of
Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd.’s case
(supra)
Rs.80,000.00
Add Loss of estate in terms of
Pranay Sethi’s case (supra)
Rs.15,000.00
Total
Rs.18,39,071.00
(Rupees eighteen lakhs, thirty nine thousand and seventy one)
only.
26.
The Respondents No. 1 and 2 shall be entitled to
simple interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount, with
effect from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the
learned Tribunal till full realisation.
27.
The
awarded
amount
shall
be
paid
to
the
Respondents No. 1 and 2 within one month from today,
MAC App. No. 11 of 2017
The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.
failing which, the Appellant No. 1 shall pay simple interest @
12% per annum from the date of filing of the Claim Petition
till realisation, duly deducting the amounts, if any, already
paid by it to the Respondents No. 1 and 2.
28.
In
the
end
result,
the
computation
of
compensation of the learned Tribunal stands modified to the
extent above.
29.
Appeal dismissed.
30.
No order as to costs.
31.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned
Tribunal for information.
32.
Records of the learned Tribunal be remitted
forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
01.07.2019
ml
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review