Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sp. A. No.01 of 2019
(The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
Sp. A. No. 01 of 2019
1.
The Municipal Commissioner,
Gangtok Municipal Corporation,
Deorali, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Buddhiman Ghatani,
S/o D.P. Ghatani,
R/o Thangsing Bodang,
Khamdong, East Sikkim.
...Appellants
Versus
1.
Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami,
W/o Late H. K. Biswakarma,
R/o Upper Gairigaon, Gorubattan,
District Darjeeling, West Bengal.
2.
Ms. Sikha Singh,
D/o Late H. K. Biswakarma,
R/o Upper Gairigaon, Gorubattan,
District Darjeeling, West Bengal.
3.
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
Hill Cart Road, Ganesh Ram Compound,
Mahanandapara, Siliguri,
West Bengal.
...Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, C.J.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
For Appellants
: Mr. Jorgay Namka, Advocate.
For Respondent
Nos. 1 & 2
: Mr. N. Rai, Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. Sunil
Kumar Baraily, Advocate.
For Respondent No. 3
: Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate.
Date of Hearing &
Judgment
: 22.06.2020.
J U D G M E N T (O R A L)
(Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ.)
Heard
Mr.
Jorgay
Namka,
learned
Counsel,
appearing
for
the
appellants. Also heard Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr.
Sp. A. No.01 of 2019
(The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.)
Sunil Kumar Baraily, learned Counsel, appearing for respondent nos. 1 & 2
as well as Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, learned Counsel, appearing for respondent
no.3.
2.
This special appeal is directed against the judgment dated 01.07.2019
passed by the learned Single Judge in MAC App. No.11 of 2017, whereby the
appeal preferred by the present appellants against the award dated
28.07.2017 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, East
Sikkim at Gangtok in MACT Case No.27 of 2016, was dismissed.
3.
On the very first day when the appeal was listed on 21.08.2019, this
Court fixed the case for hearing on the question of maintainability of the
appeal and liberty was granted to the appellants to serve the respondents.
4.
Accordingly, we have heard the learned Counsel for the parties on the
maintainability of this appeal.
5.
Mr. Namka submits that Rule 148 of the Sikkim High Court (Practice
and Procedure) Rules, 2011 (for short, PP Rules) makes it abundantly clear
that this special appeal is maintainable before the Division Bench as
judgment of the learned Single Judge was not passed in exercise of
Appellate jurisdiction in respect of a decree or order made by a Court subject
to the superintendence of the High Court. He submits that Rule 148 of the
PP Rules does not bar an appeal before the Division Bench against the
judgment of a learned Single Judge in respect of an award or an order
passed by a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal. He has contended that Courts
and Tribunals are distinct entities and they are not one and the same thing.
In this connection, he has placed reliance on the judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in The Bharat Bank Ltd., Delhi vs. The Employee of the
Bharat Bank Ltd., Delhi, and the Bharat Bank Employees Union,
Delhi, reported in AIR 1950 SC 188 and Associated Cement Companies
Ltd. vs. P.N. Sharma and Anr., reported in AIR 1965 SC 1595. He
Sp. A. No.01 of 2019
(The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.)
contends that even the amendment of Section 100A of the Civil Procedure
Code, 1908 (for short, CPC) by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment)
Act, 2002 will not take away the Letters Patent jurisdiction of the High Court
as the Tribunal under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, MV Act) is not
a Civil Court as contemplated under CPC. In this regard, he has drawn the
attention of this Court to a judgment of the Rajasthan High Court in the case
of Fazal Ali vs. Amna Khatun & Ors., reported in AIR 2004 Rajasthan
39. He submits that in the aforesaid case, a special appeal before the
Division Bench against a judgment of a learned Single Judge in an appeal
preferred under Section 173 of MV Act was held to be maintainable by
holding that the amended provision under Section 100A CPC introduced by
the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 2002 has no impact on the
power of a Division Bench to entertain and adjudicate the matter. Mr. Namka
has also relied upon a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
P.S. Sathappan (Dead) by Lrs. vs. Andhra Bank Ltd. and Ors. reported
in (2004) 11 SCC 672.
6.
Mr. Bhutia, learned Counsel appearing for respondent no. 3, endorses
the submissions of Mr. Jorgay Namka.
7.
Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent nos. 1
and 2, submits that the issue is squarely covered by the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Geeta Devi and Ors. vs. Puran Ram
Raigar and Anr., reported in (2010) 9 SCC 84, wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court categorically held that intra-court appeal in the High Court
was not maintainable against the order of the learned Single Judge deciding
an appeal preferred against an award of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal in
view of Section 100A CPC notwithstanding anything in the High Court Rules
or the Letters Patent to the contrary. Accordingly, he submits that even if it
is construed that a special appeal was envisaged under Section 148 of the PP
Rules against the judgment of a learned Single Judge passed in an appeal
Sp. A. No.01 of 2019
(The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.)
arising out of a challenge made to an award passed by the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, the same will not, in any manner, assist the appellant in
view of the pronouncement made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Geeta
Devi (supra.). Accordingly, he prays for dismissal of the appeal as not
maintainable.
8.
At the outset, it will be appropriate to take note of Section 148 of the
PP Rules, which reads as under:“148. Letters Patent Appeals:- (1) An appeal shall lie to the
Division Bench from the Judgment (not being a judgment passed in
the exercise of appellate jurisdiction in respect of a decree or order
made by a Court subject to the superintendence of the High Court, and
not being an order made in the exercise of revisional jurisdiction, and
not being sentence or order passed or made in exercise of Criminal
jurisdiction) of a Judge of the High Court sitting singly.
(2) The period of limitation for an appeal under this rule shall be
thirty days from the date of the Judgment, decree or final order, as the
case may be.”
9.
Section 100A CPC, after the amendment of Code of Civil Procedure
(Amendment) Act, 2002, reads as follows:“100A. No further appeal in certain cases.- Notwithstanding
anything contained in any Letters Patent for any High Court or in any
instrument having the force of law or in any other law for the time
being in force, where any appeal from an original or appellate decree
or order is heard and decided by a single Judge of a High Court, no
further appeal shall lie from the judgment and decree of such single
Judge.”
Sp. A. No.01 of 2019
(The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.)
10.
Prior to the aforesaid amendment, Section 100A CPC, read as follows:“100A. No further appeal in certain cases.- Notwithstanding
anything contained in any Letters Patent for any High Court or in any
other instrument having the force of law or in any other law for the
time being in force, where any appeal from an appellate decree or
order is heard and decided by a single Judge of a High Court, no
further appeal shall lie from the judgment, decision or order of such
single Judge in such appeal or from any decree passed in such
appeal.”
11.
In P.S. Sathappan (Dead) by Lrs. (supra), an application was filed
before the execution court for setting aside the court auction. The same
being dismissed, an appeal was filed before the Madras High Court. On the
dismissal of the same by the learned Single Judge, a letters patent appeal
was filed. The same was dismissed by the Full Bench of the Madras High
Court holding that in terms of Section 104(2) CPC, an appeal to a Division
Bench against an order passed by the appellate court was not maintainable.
When the matter reached the Hon’ble Supreme Court, because of the
importance of the question, the same was referred to a Constitution Bench
for consideration. The majority view was that the appeal was maintainable.
It is to be noted at this juncture that while rendering the aforesaid decision,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court had taken note of Section 100A prior to its
amendment in 2002. While coming to the aforesaid conclusion, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had observed that at the relevant time, neither Section 100A
nor Section 104(2) CPC barred a letters patent appeal. In paragraph 30, it
was observed as follows:“………………………………… It must be stated that now by virtue of
Section 100-A no letters patent appeal would be maintainable.
However, it is an admitted position that the law which would prevail
Sp. A. No.01 of 2019
(The Municipal Commissioner, GMC & Anr. Vs. Mrs. Pabitra Singh Kami & Ors.)
would be the law at the relevant time.
At the relevant time neither
Section 100-A nor Section 104(2) barred a letters patent appeal.”
12.
A perusal of the judgment in Geeta Devi (supra) goes to show that a
learned Single Judge of the High Court of Rajasthan had decided an appeal
preferred against the award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal. An
appeal was preferred against the said judgment before the Division Bench
and the Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court had held that against the
order of the learned Single Judge, the appeal does not lie in view of Section
100A CPC. While dismissing the appeal preferred against the judgment of
the Division Bench, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that intra-court appeal
in the High Court was not maintainable in view of Section 100A CPC
notwithstanding anything in the High Court Rules or the Letters Patent to the
contrary.
13.
The law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Geeta Devi
(supra) applies on all fours to the present proceedings and, therefore, it will
not be necessary for this Court to embark upon an enquiry to find out as to
whether Section 148 of the PP Rules contemplated a special appeal of the
present nature. Even if it is assumed that Section 148 of the PP Rules did
not restrict filing of an appeal against the judgment passed by the learned
Single Judge in an appeal preferred against an award passed by the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, the same will not enure to the benefit of the
appellants in view of the dicta in Geeta Devi (supra).
14.
In view of the above discussions, we hold that this appeal is not
maintainable and accordingly, the same is dismissed. Accordingly, I.A. No.1
of 2019 and I.A. No.2 of 2020 become infructuous.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
( Arup Kumar Goswami )
Chief Justice
pm
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review