Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:1:
2025:KER:3138
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JOHNSON JOHN
THURSDAY, THE 16TH DAY OF JANUARY 2025 / 26TH POUSHA, 1946
MACA NO. 1673 OF 2019
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 14.06.2012 IN O.P(MV) NO.822 OF 2009 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, KOLLAM
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
MUMTHAS, AGED 35 YEARS
D/O RAFEEKA BEEVI, MUMTHAS MANZIL, VALATHUNGAL P.O.,
ERAVIPURAM VILLAGE, KOLLAM DISTRICT.
NAISHANA SHA, AGED 11 YEARS,
D/O. MUMTHAS NADHIRSHA, MUMTHAS MANZIL, VALATHUNGAL P.O.,
ERAVIPURAM VILLAGE, KOLLAM DISTRICT.
NINA SHA, AGED 10 YEARS,
D/O. MUMTHAS NADHIRSHA, MUMTHAS MANZIL, VALATHUNGAL P.O.,
ERAVIPURAM VILLAGE, KOLLAM DISTRICT.
[MINOR APPELLANTS 2 AND 3 ARE REPRESENTED BY IST APPELLANT,
MOTHER AS GUARDIAN OF THE MINORS]
BY ADVS.
R.RAJESH (VARKALA)
SRI.M.KIRANLAL
SRI.MANU RAMACHANDRAN
SRI.T.S.SARATH
SRI.K.P.JABBAR
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS 1 TO 5 & PETITIONER 1, 2 & 4:
MOHAMMED RAFI, S/O JALALUDHEEN, KOCHUKADA VADAKKATHIL,
POROORKARA, EDAPPALLYCOTTA P.O., PANMANA VILLAGE,
KARUNAGAPPALLY, KOLLAM DISTRICT-691 583.
RENJU R., S/O. RAJASEKARAN NAIR, VRINDAVAN, MEKKUMURI,
THANEERKULAM, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT.
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:2:
2025:KER:3138
THE MANAGER, THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., THODUPUZHA,
KERALA-685 584.
BY ADVS.
R1 & R2 BY SRI.V.MADHUSUDHANAN
R3 BY SRI.S.K.AJAY KUMAR
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
15.01.2025, THE COURT ON 16.01.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
HEARD
ON
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:3:
2025:KER:3138
JOHNSON JOHN, J.
--------------------------------------------------------M.A.C.A No. 1673 of 2019
-------------------------------------------------------Dated this the 16th day of January, 2025.
JUDGMENT
The appellants are the petitioners in O.P.(MV) No. 822 of 2009 on
the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kollam and they are
challenging the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal
under various heads as inadequate.
2. The appellants are the legal heirs of the deceased Nadirshaw,
who died in a motor vehicle accident occurred on 11.06.2009. According
to the appellants, on the date of occurrence, while the deceased was
travelling as a passenger in a scorpio car driven by the 2 nd respondent
in a rash and negligent manner, it caused to hit on electric post and
thereby, the deceased sustained serious injuries and subsequently,
succumbed to his injuries on the same day.
3. Before the Tribunal, PW1 examined and Exhibits A1 to A6 were
marked from the side of the petitioners and no evidence adduced from
the side of the respondents.
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:4:
2025:KER:3138
4. After trial and hearing both sides, the Tribunal found that the
accident occurred because of the negligence on the part of the 2 nd
respondent and that respondents 1 to 3 are jointly and severally liable to
pay compensation.
The Tribunal awarded a total compensation of
Rs.8,60,000/- to the claim petitioners.
5. Heard both sides and perused the records.
6. The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the Tribunal
fixed only a notional income of Rs.6000/- and the same is on the lower
side. It is argued that the deceased was working as salesman in Oman
and earning 225 omani rial per month at the time of the accident and
the Tribunal has not properly appreciated the evidence of PW1 and
Exhibit A6 in this regard.
7. But, the learned counsel for the insurance company pointed out
that in cross examination, PW1 admitted that Exhibit A6 is only a
photocopy and that no document is available to show that the deceased
was working abroad at the time of the accident. PW1 further admitted
that the copies of passport and visa of the deceased are not produced.
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:5:
2025:KER:3138
The evidence of PW1 in cross examination shows that she has no direct
knowledge regarding the occupation and income of the deceased and in
that circumstance, I find no reason to interfere with the finding of the
Tribunal that the evidence of PW1 and Exhibit A6 cannot be relied upon
to record a finding regarding the income of the deceased.
8.
The
decision
of
the
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
Ramachandrappa v. Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co.Ltd.
[(2011) 13 SCC 236] and Syed Sadiq and Others v. Divisional
Manager, United India Insurance Company [(2014) 2 SCC 735 =
2014 KHC 4027] shows that even in the absence of any evidence, the
monthly income of an ordinary worker has to be fixed as Rs.4,500/- in
respect of the accident occurred in the year 2004 and for the subsequent
years, the monthly income could be reckoned by adding Rs.500/- each
per year. If the monthly income of the deceased is calculated by
adopting the above principle, it will come to Rs.7,000/- as the accident
occurred in the year 2009. Therefore, I find that the monthly income of
the deceased at the time of the accident can be fixed as Rs.7,000/- for
assessing the compensation.
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:6:
2025:KER:3138
9.
The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in National
Insurance Co.Ltd. v Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and
Jagdish v. Mohan [(2018) 4 SCC 571] shows that the benefit of
future prospects should not be confined only to those who have a
permanent job and would extend to self-employed individuals and in
case of a self-employed person, an addition of 40% of the established
income should be made where the age of the victim at the time of the
accident was below 40 years.
10. The Tribunal accepted 17 as the multiplier and deducted onethird of the income towards personal and living expenses of the
deceased. The learned counsel for the appellants pointed out that claim
petitioners 1 to 3 are the wife and children of the deceased and the 5 th
petitioner is the mother of the deceased and therefore, they are
dependants and the finding of the Tribunal that the mother of the
deceased cannot be treated as a dependant is not sustainable. It is
argued that the mother of the deceased is unemployed and was
depending on the deceased.
11.
The decision of the Honourable Supreme Court in Sarla
Varma v. Delhi Transport Corporation [2010 (2) KLT 802 (SC)]
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:7:
2025:KER:3138
shows that the deduction towards personal and living expenses should
be one-fourth, where the dependent family members are 4 to 6 and
therefore, I find that in this case, only one-fourth is to be deducted
towards personal and living expenses of the deceased. Thus, while
reassessing the compensation for loss of dependency as per the revised
criteria, the amount would come to Rs.14,99,400/- [7000 + 40%) x ¾ x
12 x 17].
12.
(Supra)
The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi
would
show
that
the
reasonable
amount
payable
on
conventional heads namely loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral
expenses
should
be
Rs.15,000/-,
Rs.40,000/-
and
Rs.15,000/-
respectively and that the aforesaid amount should be enhanced by 10%
in every three years. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rojalini Nayak &
Ors v. Ajit Sahoo (2024 KHC Online 8300) by adopting the above
metric
awarded
a
compensation
of
Rs.48,400/-
towards
loss
of
consortium and Rs.18,150/- each towards funeral expenses and loss of
estate. Therefore, the amount awarded by the Tribunal towards funeral
expenses and loss of estate will be modified to Rs.18,150/- each and the
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:8:
2025:KER:3138
petitioners will also be entitled for Rs.48,400/- towards loss of
consortium. The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shriram
General Ins.Co.Ltd. v. Bhagat Singh Rawat (2023 KHC Online
7244) shows that the compensation under the heads of loss of love and
affection and loss of consortium cannot be granted to each legal
representative of the deceased and in view of the said position, the
petitioners are not entitled for a separate amount towards loss of love
and affection.
13.
Tribunal
The learned counsel for the appellants pointed out that the
has
not
sufferings. and that
awarded
any
compensation
towards
pain
and
the provisions of the Kerala Torts (Miscellaneous
Provisions) Act, 1976 would show that the right to sue for compensation
for pain and suffering would survive upon the legal heirs, if the injured
died at a later point of time and in this case, even though the death
occurred on the same day, it was at a later point of time and therefore,
considering the facts and circumstances, I find that a sum of
Rs.10,000/- can be allowed to the petitioners towards pain and
sufferings of the deceased.
14. In conclusion, the enhanced amount of
compensation, as modified as a result of the above discussion is
encapsulated, in a tabular format herein below:
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
:9:
2025:KER:3138
Sl.
No
Particulars
Loss of dependency
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal (Rs.)
Final
Amount
Payable
8,16,000/-
14,99,400/-
4,000/-
18,150/-
10,000/-
18,150/-
Loss of estate
Funeral expenses
Loss of consortium
Love and affection
10,000/10,000/-
NIL
NIL
10,000/-
7,000/-
7,000/-
10,000/-
10,000/-
8,67,000
(mistakenly
shown as
Rs.8,60,000/in the award of
the Tribunal)
16,11,100/-
Pain and sufferings
Medical and Miscellaneous
expenses
Transportation expenses
Total amount Payable
48,400/-
15. Accordingly, the total amount of compensation payable to the
petitioners is determined as Rs.16,11,100/-.
In the result, this appeal is allowed, and the appellants/petitioners
are allowed to recover the compensation amount of Rs.16,11,100/(Rupees
Sixteen Lakhs Eleven Thousand and One Hundred only) with
M.A.C.A. No. 1673/2019
: 10 :
2025:KER:3138
interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim
petition till the date of realization with proportionate costs from the
respondents. The third respondent insurance company shall deposit the
said amount together with interest and costs before the Tribunal within a
period of three months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
judgment.
sd/-
JOHNSON JOHN,
JUDGE.
Rv
The judgment in M.A.C.A No. 1673 of 2019 dated 16.01.2025 is
corrected by incorporating the sentence that “the appellants are not
entitled for interest on the enhanced amount for the period covered by
the delay”, as per order dated 07.03.2025 in I.A. No. 1/2025 in M.A.CA.
No. 1673 of 2019.
sd/- Deputy Registrar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review