The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. The jurisdiction of the Court to record evidence should be exercised promptly so that there may not be further chance of tampering with the articles.” The jurisdiction of the Judicial Magistrate First Class is not ousted from releasing the said vehicle on interim custody as there is no rider in the Adhiniyam to restrict the power of the Judicial Magistrate to release the seized vehicle on interim custody. In the case of Mukhtar Husain Vs. State of M.P. [2019(II) MPWN 44] it has been held that :“13. The observation made by the Revisional Court is not proper that the JMFC has no competence to determine whether the Collector has any power to confiscate the vehicle or not. When a specific question was raised before the JMFC as well as before the Revisional Court about competency of the Collector for initiating the confiscation proceeding of the vehicle, it was the duty of the Court to determine as to whether that power is vested with the Collector or not but without dealing with the said question, rejecting the application for release of vehicle only on the ground that the confiscation proceeding is proposed by the Collector, the request of release of vehicle should not have been turned down. Therefore, in my opinion the order passed by the JMFC as well as the Revisional Court are not sustainable in the eyes of the law, therefore, they are set aside. The application submitted by th…
8. I am in complete agreement with the aforesaid order. It is hence held that the impugned orders passed by the Courts below are contrary to law hence deserve to be and are hereby set aside and the application of the petitioner for release of the vehicle bearing registration No.M.P. 12 - GA 0193 is allowed and the respondent is directed to release the said vehicle of the petitioner bearing registration number M.P. 12 - GA 0193, on his furnishing adequate security, as directed by the trial Court. The petitioner is also directed that during the pendency of trial, he shall not sale or dispose of the vehicle and shall produce it before the Court as and when so directed by the trial Court. In the event of confiscation order by the competent authority or Collector, the applicant shall keep the vehicle present positively for confiscation. 9 . Accordingly, this petition stands allowed and disposed off on the above terms. C.c. as per rules.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 9th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 33342 of 2021
BETWEEN:MUKESH S/O RIJDHIYA TOKARE, AGED ABOUT 24
YEA R S , OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE, R/O. GRAM
BAKHATARIYA, ACHALI, TEHSIL AND DISTT. BARWANI
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPLICANT
(BY SHRI SANTOSH KUMAR MEENA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
APPLICANT)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION HOUSE
OFFICER THROUH P.S. PALSOOD DISTT. BARWANI
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI VISHAL PANWAR - P.L. FOR RESPONDENT/STATE)
This application coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
1. Heard.
2 . This petition is filed under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C has been
preferred by the petitioner / accused being aggrieved by order dated 13/5/2021
passed by the Special Judge, Barwani, District Barwani in Criminal Revision
No.25/2021 whereby the order dated 8/4/2021 passed by the Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Barwani in Crime No.107/2021 has been affirmed whereby an
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/10/2024
2:15:00 PM
application under Sections 451 and 457 of the Cr.P.C had been rejected.
3 . Brief facts of the case are that on 25/3/2021 police got a secret
information from the informant that in a pick up vehicle bearing registration
No.M.P. 12-GA 0193, illegal transportation of calf is being made for the
purpose of slaughtering them. Acting upon the said information the police party
reached the spot and during search it was found that the vehicle was loaded
with six calf without any valid permit which was seized by the police and
offence under Sections 4, 6 and 9 of M.P. Govansh Vadh Pratished Adhiniyam,
2004 (in short 'the Adhiniyam, 2004') read with Section 11 - D of Prevention of
Cruelty to Animals Act has been registered against the petitioner.
4. During the investigation the petitioner had preferred an application for
release of the seized vehicle which has been rejected by both the Courts below.
Therefore, this petition has been filed.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is the
registered owner of the seized vehicle. He was using the vehicle for his business
purposes. The trial Court has erred in not considering the important aspect that
there is no bar provided under the Adhiniyam of 2004. The seized vehicle is
lying in an open area in Police Station and there is no proper arrangement for its
care. Vehicle is deteriorating day by day. He further submitted that trial is
pending since long before the concerned trial Court and the confiscation
proceedings have been finalized against the petitioner before the final judgment
of the trial Court. Hence, he prays that both the impugned orders be set aside
and the seized vehicle be handed over to the applicant on Supurdagi.
6. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent / State opposes the
petition and prays for its rejection by submitting that the vehicle in question is
subject matter of confiscation proceeding and the Collector, Barwani has
Signature Notthe
Verified
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/10/2024
2:15:00 PM
given information regarding the confiscation to the concerned Magistrate and
the police officers, therefore, no ground is available to the petitioner to
handover the said vehicle.
7 . Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon an order dated
19/9/2022 passed by the Coordinate Bench in M.Cr.C.No.11099 of 2022
(Suresh Khede V/s. State of M.P.) in which it has been held as under :"As per Section 11(5) of the Adhiniyam of 2004, it is clear that in
case of any violation of Section 4, 5, 6-A and 6-B, the Police Authorities
is empowered to seize the vehicle or cow progeny and beef. The District
Magistrate is having power to confiscate the same in a manner
prescribed under Rules 5 and 6 of the Rules of 2012, which deals,
confiscation, and appeal are relevant, however, it is reproduced as
under:“Rule 5. Confiscation by District Magistrate.-In case of any violation of Section 4, 5, 6, 6-A and 6-B, the
police shall be empowered to seize the vehicles, cow progeny and
beef as per the provisions of Section 100 of Criminal Procedure
Code, 1973 (No.2 of 1974) in following manner:
(i) He shall take possession of the vehicle.
(ii) He shall intimate the Veterinary Department to take in custody
of the cow-progeny and beef.
(iii) The beef of cow- rogeny shall be disposed of by the
Department by such procedure as he deems fit.
Rule 6. Manner of Appeal.-- Any person aggrieved by an order of
confiscation under sub-section (5) of Section 11 of the Act, may prefer
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/10/2024
2:15:00 PM
an appeal in writing to the Divisional Commissioner within thirty days
of the date of knowledge of such order. Every appeal shall be made
under sub-section (1) of Section 11-A of the Act."
After perusal of the aforesaid, it is apparent that in the Adhiniyam
of 2004 no procedure has been prescribed for the proceedings of
confiscation and no rules have been framed under the said Act. On
perusal of the aforesaid provisions, it is evident that there is no provision
to restrict the jurisdiction of the Judicial Magistrate First Class to
release the seized property on interim custody during the pendency of
investigation or trial. Where a specific restriction is not made in the
provision of the Act, jurisdiction of the Judicial Magistrate cannot be
deemed to be ousted.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Sunderbhai Ambalal
Desai Vs. State of Gujarat, AIR 2003 SC 638 has held as under:“The powers under Section 451 Cr.P.C. should be exercised
expeditiously and judiciously. It would serve various purposes
namely:
1. Owner of the article would not suffer because of its remaining
unused or by its misappropriation.
2. Court or the police would not be required to keep the
article in safe custody.
3. If the proper panchnama before handing over possession
of article is prepared, that can be used in evidence instead of its
production before the Court during the trial. If necessary, evidence
could also be recorded describing the nature of the property in
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/10/2024
2:15:00 PM
detail:
and
4. The jurisdiction of the Court to record evidence should be
exercised promptly so that there may not be further chance of
tampering with the articles.”
The jurisdiction of the Judicial Magistrate First Class is not
ousted from releasing the said vehicle on interim custody as there is no
rider in the Adhiniyam to restrict the power of the Judicial Magistrate to
release the seized vehicle on interim custody.
In the case of Mukhtar Husain Vs. State of M.P. [2019(II)
MPWN 44] it has been held that :“13. The observation made by the Revisional Court is not
proper that the JMFC has no competence to determine whether the
Collector has any power to confiscate the vehicle or not. When a
specific question was raised before the JMFC as well as before the
Revisional Court about competency of the Collector for initiating
the confiscation proceeding of the vehicle, it was the duty of the
Court to determine as to whether that power is vested with the
Collector or not but without dealing with the said question,
rejecting the application for release of vehicle only on the ground
that the confiscation proceeding is proposed by the Collector, the
request of release of vehicle should not have been turned down.
Therefore, in my opinion the order passed by the JMFC as well as
the Revisional Court are not sustainable in the eyes of the law,
therefore, they are set aside. The application submitted by the
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/10/2024
2:15:00 PM
petitioner for release of the vehicle bearing registration No.UP90T- 2766 is allowed and the respondents are directed to release the
seized vehicle of the petitioner bearing registration No.UP90-T-
766 on his furnishing adequate security as directed by the Trial
Court. The petitioner is also directed that during the pendency of
the trial, he shall not sell or dispose of the vehicle and shall
produce before the Court as and when so directed by the Trial
Court.”
8. I am in complete agreement with the aforesaid order. It is hence held
that the impugned orders passed by the Courts below are contrary to law hence
deserve to be and are hereby set aside and the application of the petitioner for
release of the vehicle bearing registration No.M.P. 12 - GA 0193 is allowed and
the respondent is directed to release the said vehicle of the petitioner bearing
registration number M.P. 12 - GA 0193, on his furnishing adequate security, as
directed by the trial Court. The petitioner is also directed that during the
pendency of trial, he shall not sale or dispose of the vehicle and shall produce it
before the Court as and when so directed by the trial Court. In the event of
confiscation order by the competent authority or Collector, the applicant shall
keep the vehicle present positively for confiscation.
9 . Accordingly, this petition stands allowed and disposed off on the
above terms.
C.c. as per rules.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
SS/-
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 1/10/2024
2:15:00 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review