Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 26th November, 2025
Pronounced on: 10th March, 2026
%
CRL.M.C. 4541/2025, CRL.M.A. 19789/2025
MS. RITU GUPTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Arundhati Katju Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Animesh Kumar, Mr.
Nishant Kumar, Dr Sumit Kumar, Ms
Aprajita, Ms. Shristi Borthakur, Mrs.
Palak Joshi, Mr. Shikhar Khanna and
Mr. Prashant Shukla, Advs.
versus
KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK LTD
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Adv.
CRL.M.C. 4542/2025, CRL.M.A. 19791/2025
MS. MANISHA GUPTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Arundhati Katju Sr. Advocate
with
Mr.
Animesh
Kumar,
Mr.Nishant Kumar, Dr Sumit Kumar,
Ms Aprajita, Ms. Shristi Borthakur,
Mrs. Palak Joshi, Mr. Shikhar Khanna
and Mr. Prashant Shukla, Advs.
versus
KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK LTD
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Adv.
CRL.M.C. 7226/2025, CRL.M.A. 30346/2025 & 30347/2025
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
MR KUNJ GUPTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Arundhati Katju Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Animesh Kumar, Mr.
Nishant Kumar, Dr Sumit Kumar, Ms
Aprajita, Ms. Shristi Borthakur, Mrs.
Palak Joshi, Mr. Shikhar Khanna and
Mr. Prashant Shukla, Advs.
versus
KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Adv.
CRL.M.C. 7262/2025, CRL.M.A. 30467/2025 & 30468/2025
MS POOJA GUPTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Arundhati Katju Sr. Advocate
with
Mr.
Animesh
Kumar,
Mr.Nishant Kumar, Dr Sumit Kumar,
Ms Aprajita, Ms. Shristi Borthakur,
Mrs. Palak Joshi, Mr. Shikhar Khanna
and Mr. Prashant Shukla, Advs.
versus
KOTAK MAHINDRA BANK LTD & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The aforesaid four Petitions have been filed under Section 528 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 for quashing of Complaint Case
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (hereinafter
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
referred to as “NI Act”) read with Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”), as well as the Cognizance Order
dated 06.06.2024 passed by learned M.M. Further, Quashing of the Order
dated 22.04.2025 of learned ASJ in Criminal Revision Petitions, which
upheld the Order of Ld. MM, has also been sought, by way of the present
Petitions.
2.
The aforesaid four Petitions had been filed by the Complainant under
Section 138 Act read with Section 420 IPC in regard to the dishonour of
Cheque dated 20.02.2024 amounting to Rs. 70,00,000/- each and also to
challenge the Order of Cognizance dated 29.06.2024.
3.
It is explained that Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd./the Complainant had
granted financial assistance of Rs. 40,00,00,000/- to KRPM Infrastructure
Pvt. Ltd., in which the Petitioners Ritu Gupta, Manisha Gupta, and Kunj
Gupta had stood as Guarantors while Pooja Gupta was the Director. The
Term Loan was for a period of 7 years. Two undated Cheques drawn in
favour of the Bank superscribing “Amount not exceeding 40 crores” were
handed over as security.
4.
The Complainant deposited these undated and blank cheques given by
the Petitioners as Security for the Term Loan, without raising any demand
for any sum of money and without giving any intimation to the Petitioners.
5.
It is submitted that Petitioner, Pooja Gupta is the Director in KRPM
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. who entered into a Master Facility Agreement dated
24.03.2023 with the Respondent/Complainant Bank for a Term Loan for a
sum of Rs. 40,00,00,000/- which was sanctioned vide Sanction Letter dated
24.03.2023. Pooja Gupta with other Directors of KRPM, also executed a
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
Deed of Guarantee dated 24.03.2023 in favour of the Complainant
Bank.
6.
Out of the amount of Rs. 40,00,00,000/-, Rs. 3,33,33,333.32 were
disbursed under the Master Facility Agreement between 05.05.2023 to
20.02.2024. The Sanction Letter dated 24.03.2023 and Master Facility
Agreement, did not specify any particular due date and did contain any
repayment schedule. Hence, without issuing a Demand Notice, the
Complainant could not have alleged a Default.
7.
On 20.02.2024, the Complainant filled the signed undated and blank
cheques with an amount and date convenient to it and presented the four
cheques each in the sum of Rs. 70,00,000/-, for encashment which was
returned vide Memo dated 21.02.2024 for the reason “Funds Insufficient”.
8.
The Complainant also served a Notice dated 05.05.2024 under
Section 138 NI Act, in respect of the dishonour of the Cheques and
thereafter, preferred four Complaint Case in the Patiala House Courts, New
Delhi. The learned M.M took cognizance on the Complaints on
29.06.2024.
9.
The Petitioners have asserted that from 20.02.2024 to 03.06.2024 the
Borrowers had paid Rs. 2,68,15,181/- to the Complainant Bank, but the
same was not brought to the Notice of learned M.M. at the time when
Cognizance was taken on the Complaint under Section 138 NI Act.
10.
Four Criminal Revision Petitions were preferred before Learned
District & Sessions Judge, vide Criminal Revision No. 51/2025, 52/2025,
97/2025 and 98/2025, but they got dismissed on 22.04.2025 by relying upon
Sripati Singh vs. The State of Jharkhand & Anr., (2022) 18 SCC 614.
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
11.
The present Petitions have been filed against the Impugned Order of
the learned M.M. dated 06.06.2025 taking Cognizance and the Revisional
Order dated 22.04.2025upholding the Order of Ld. MM.
12.
The Orders have been challenged on the Grounds that the Security
Cheques for clearance, were deposited by the Complainant without raising
any demand for any sum of money and without any intimation to the
Petitioners. The loan had not been recalled by the Bank, nor was the
Account classified as NPA and as on date, there is no Outstanding Debt, in
the Loan Account. The EMIs have been paid on monthly basis, by KRPM
Infrastructure Pvt. Limited.
13.
In case of Loan transactions, the liability of the Guarantor arises when
the Borrower is unable to or defaults in paying the Loan Amount. There is
no outstanding debt in the Loan Account, as the EMIs have been paid
regularly. The substantial amount of Rs. 2,68,15,181/- has been paid from
20.02.2024 to 03.06.2024, in discharge of the Liability.
14.
These material facts have been suppressed and not brought to the
notice of the Learned M.M. who took Cognizance on the Complaint on
29.06.2024. Such concealment of post-dated payments, amounts to gross
abuse of Judicial process, for which reliance is placed on Pioneer Drip
Systems Pvt. Ltd. vs. Jain Irrigation Systems Ltd., 2009 SCC OnLine Bom.
2046.
15.
The Master Facility Agreement dated 24.03.2023 clearly stipulated
the limited purpose of the Undated Security Cheques and its purpose was to
serve as a mechanism to secure repayment of the Loan in its entirety and not
piecemeal, towards individual instalments. The cheque was neither linked to
a defined repayment schedule nor was it issued against any specific EMI or
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
date-wise obligation. These Security Cheques could have been invoked upon
the crystallization of total Liability i.e. upon recall of the entire Loan amount
or upon definitive Notice of Default.
16.
The Judgment of Sripati Singh, (supra) relied upon by the Learned
District Judge, is clearly distinguishable on the facts. The Security Cheques
were to be used against repayment of entire Loan and not against in default
of any instalment.
17.
It is further stated that even if it is assumed that there was a default
under the Loan, the Complainant Bank could not unilaterally revise the EMI
and apply Compound Interest, thereby causing a financial burden upon the
Borrower, who has continued to make repayments under the revised terms.
As reflected in the Statement of Account, the substantial amount of
Rs.3,33,33,333.32 between 05.05.2023 to 20.02.2024 has been paid, which
indicates that the Borrower was actively serving the Loan, albeit under the
enhanced EMI structure imposed by the Bank. Despite this, the Bank
proceeded to encash the undated Security Cheques by filling an amount of
Rs. 70,00,000/- and without formal recall of the Loan.
18.
The acts of the Complainant termed as double vexatious; first by
extracting higher repayments through increased EMIs and compounding;
and second, by invoking the Security Cheque, originally meant as a last
resort tool, in the event of total Loan recall or final default. With the revised
EMIs, an altered situation is created.
19.
Hence, presenting the Cheque despite active servicing of the Loan, is
not only contractually impermissible, but also an abuse of Section 138
proceedings. Moreover, the Master Facility Agreement dated 24.03.2023
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
clearly recorded that such Undated Cheques were in lieu of repayment of the
Loan with the superscription “Amount not exceeding 40 crores”.
20.
Section 138 (a) NI Act provides that a Cheque must be presented to
the Bank within six months from the date of its drawn or within its validity,
whichever is earlier, which has also been affirmed by the Supreme Court in
MSR Leathers vs. S. Palaniappan, (2013) 1 SCC 177 and also by Coordinate
Bench of this Court in Ansh Chug vs. Pradeep Kumar, CRL.M.C2973/2018.
21.
Admittedly, the Cheques that were issued on 24.03.2023, were
presented on 20.02.2024 i.e. after 11 months which is well beyond the
statutory six months validity. Even if the Cheques were undated at the time
when they were issued, the date would be reckoned on 24.03.2023 i.e. the
date on which the Loan Agreement was executed and the Cheques were
handed over to the Complainant Bank. There was no timeline agreed upon
between the parties and there was no Recall Notice and the Cheque was
presented after expiry of six months period; therefore, the condition laid
down in Clause (a) proviso to Section 138 NI Act, were not met.
22.
It is further contended that the impugned Cheques were Security
Cheques and not for the entire Loan and not against any specific repayment
transaction. Reliance is placed on Sampelly Satyanarayana Rao vs. India
Renewable Energy Development Agency Ltd., (2016) 10 SCC 458, wherein
it was clarified that though the word “Security” is used in Clause 3.1(iii) of
the Agreement, it refers to the Cheques being towards payment of
instalments, which is not so in the present case. There were no subsisting
outstanding dues on the date of presentation of the Cheques, as the EMIs
were being paid regularly and the Account was not classified as NPA.
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
23.
It is further contended that the Complaint was filed on 01.01.2024 by
the Officer of the Bank, in terms of Board Resolution No.372D dated
31.03.2023. However, this Resolution expressly authorized certain Officers
to file Complaints and was valid only upto 31.03.2024. The Complaint was
filed on 01.01.2024 i.e. after the expiration of the Resolution. Therefore, the
person who had signed, verified and instituted the Complaint on behalf of
the Complainant Bank, was not authorized under Resolution No. 372D.
Therefore, the Complaint has not been instituted by a legally competent
person.
24.
It is further contended that Clause 2 of the Guarantee Deed stated that
Guarantor shall be liable to pay the secured obligations, only upon a specific
and formal demand being made by the Bank. The Guarantor’s liability was
contingent on receipt of such a demand and the obligation to pay arises
“forthwith upon such demand being made”. In the absence of any such
demand, no Liability under the Guarantee could have crystallized in law.
Reliance is placed on Syndicate Bank vs. Channaveerappa Beleri, (2006) 11
SCC 506.
25.
It is claimed that the Learned Sessions Judge erroneously relied upon
the Clause in the Master Facility Agreement, which provided that if the
Loan Account is overdue, it would be classified as Special Mention Account
initially as SMA-0, then SM-1 and thereafter SMA-2 and eventually as a
Non-Performing Asset (NPA). However, it has not been considered that no
such classification was ever made by the Respondent Bank, even though it is
their own internal standard for identifying incipient stress.
26.
Moreover, this clause forms part of the Master Facility Agreement
executed between KRPM Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. (the borrower) and the
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
Respondent Bank and did not bind the Guarantors in any manner. The
Petitioner/Guarantors were solely governed by the Deed of Guarantee,
Clause 2 of which expressly provided that the Guarantor’s Liability arises
only upon a specific and formal demand made by the Bank, which has not
been made in this case.
27.
Clause 9.4 of the Master Facility Agreement provided an exhaustive
mechanism to be adopted by the Bank, in case of an event of default which
included recalling the facilities cancelling undisbursed amounts, enforcing
securities and initiating appropriate legal proceedings. Significantly, none of
these contractually stipulated remedies, have been invoked by the
Complainant Bank which has in a manifestly, arbitrarily and prejudicial
manner, circumvented its own Agreement and hastily proceeded to present
the undated Security Cheques, without first invoking any preconditions for
Default or Recovery.
28.
The Guarantor by the very nature of their role, is not in a position to
ascertain real time defaults by the borrower, unless the demand is raised by
the Bank. In the instant case, no such demand has been made by the Bank.
It has completely bypassed its own contractual protocol, effectively shortcircuiting both the Primary Loan Arrangement and the Guarantee Contract,
rendering the initiation of Criminal Proceedings against the Petitioners,
unsustainable in law.
29.
Moreover, the Charge under Section 420 IPC, is a misnomer. It is
imperative that there must be a mens rea from the very inception, to
constitute an offence of Cheating. Mere Civil wrong or infringement of a
Civil Right, does not give rise to any Criminal Prosecution. Reliance is
placed on Suryalakshmi Cotton Mills Limited vs. Rajvir Industries Limited
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
and Ors., (2008) 13 SCC 678 and Rekha Jain vs. State of Karnataka and
Anr., (2022) 18 SCC 174.
30.
In the end, it is submitted that the facts as narrated by the
Complainant, did not have any ingredients of the offence of alleged
Cheating by the Petitioners and, therefore, no such proceedings can be
initiated against the Petitioners.
31.
A prayer is, therefore, made that the Impugned Complaint and the
Summoning Order as well as the Proceedings emanating therefrom, may be
quashed.
32.
Ld. Counsel for Respondent had opposed the Petition and
explained that there was an Outstanding Debt of Rs.2,16,19,854.53/- as on
20.02.2024, and the Guarantee Cheques of Rs. 70,00,000/- each of the four
Guarantors, had been rightly presented. The Cheques were dishonored and,
therefore, the Complaint under Section 138 had been filed.
33.
The learned M.M. has rightly Summoned the Petitioners and the
Order has been upheld by the Learned District Judge vide Order dated
22.04.2025. The Petitions are, therefore, liable to be rejected.
Submissions heard and record perused.
34.
The Complainant Bank/Respondent had granted Financial Assistance
to KRPM Infrastructure (Borrower) by way of a Term Loan of Rs.
40,00,00,000/-. The Master Facility Agreement dated 24.03.2023 was
executed between the parties. The Sanction Letter dated 24.03.2023 was
accordingly issued. A Deed of Guarantee was also executed by the
Guarantors, including the four Petitioners, in favour of the Complainant.
35.
In the Complaint under Section 138 NI Act, it was asserted that there
was an outstanding debt of Rs. 2,86,19,854.53 as on 20.02.2024, and in
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
order
to
realize
the
same,
the
four
Cheques
of
the
four
Guarantors/Petitioners in the sum of Rs.70,00,000/- each dated 20.02.2024
were presented which got dishonored for “Insufficiency of Funds”.
36.
To appreciate the contention, it would be pertinent to refer to the
requisite terms of the Master Facility Agreement dated 24.03.2023. They
are:
“Clause 1.1.9 “Due Date” means, in respect of any
amount payable under any of the Facilities, the date on
which such amount falls due in terms of this Agreement
and/or the Facility Letter; and if such date falls on a day
which is not a Business Day at the place of the Branch or
where the payment is to be made, the immediately
preceding Business Day.
Clause 1.1.11 “Event(s) of Default” shall mean each of
the events of default mentioned in Article 9 hereunder
and any events of defaults mentioned in any of the
Transaction Documents including the Facility Letter.
Clause 1.1.20 “Guarantor” shall mean the person(s) {If
any} who have issued/may be required to issue,
guarantee(s) in favour of the Bank, inter alia,
guaranteeing the performance of the obligations of the
Borrower to the Bank under an pursuant to the
Agreement.
Clause 1.1.23 “Outstanding Balance(s)” shall mean
collectively the Facilities, interest, compound interest,
Additional Interest, any other charges, dues and monies
payable, costs and expenses reimbursable, as outstanding
from time to time and whether any of them are due or not
for the time being and whether under this Agreement
and/or any of the Transaction document(s).”
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
37.
Further, Article 8 provided for Security as per Facility Letter, for
Individual Facility. It provided that Borrower shall secure the due payment,
repayments, etc. of the entire outstanding balance to the Bank, which
shall provide a Security, who shall furnish at its/his own cost such additional
Security of such value and in such manner, as may be required by the Bank
from time to time. It further provided that the entire Security shall be a
continuing Security, till the final Settlement of the dues.
38.
Admittedly, the Petitioners who are also the Directors of KRPM
Infrastructure, had stood as Guarantors in terms of the Deed of Guarantee
and had given blank Undated Cheques to the Bank.
39.
According to the Complainant, because there was an Overdue Amount
as on 20.02.2024, the four Cheques of the four Guarantors, got presented by
the Bank. On the other hand, it has agitated by the petitioners that, in fact
there was no termination of Loan Agreement and determination of Default
amount; default of individual instalment, did not entitle the Bank to present
the Security Cheques.
40.
It is pertinent to note, that this is the continuing Loan facility and the
Master Facility Agreement continues to prevail till date; it has not been
terminated and there is no final calculation of the Outstanding Liabilities.
41.
Article 9 lists the events of Default and consequences thereof. The
relevant part of the Article 9 reads as under:
“Article 9
EVENTS OF DEFAULT AND CONSEQUENCES
THEREOF:
Clause 9.1 Happening or occurrence of any of the
following events shall constitute an “Event of Default”
I. Failure and/or breach on Borrower’s/guarantor(s)
part to perform any of the obligations or terms or
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
conditions applicable under this Agreement/ Facility
Letter/ Transaction Documents/ other documents/ any
other agreement with any other bank, financial
institutions, creditor or any other person including nonpayment in full of any part of the Outstanding Balance
when due or when demanded by Bank;
...
V. If the Borrower or Guarantor fails to pay any of its
debts or defaults under any contract or agreement with
any party including any bank, financial Institutions,
creditor or any other person.
...
XVIII. Inability of the Borrower (or the security
provider and/or the guarantor) to repay debts to any
person or any steps being taken by any person
accelerating the payment obligation of the Borrower/
security provider/ guarantor (prior to the relevant due
date either for payment of interest or principal or
instalment) or declaration by any person of an event of
default (howsoever described) under their respective
arrangements with the Borrower (or the security provider
and/or the guarantor) or any event which under any law,
statute, rule ordinance etc. would have the effect of
suspending or waiving all or any right of the creditors
generally, against the Borrower (or the security provider
and/or the guarantor) or in respect of any contract or
agreement concerning the Borrower (or the security
provider and/or the guarantor);
XIX…..
Clause 9.2 If any Event of Default or any event which,
after the notice or lapse of time or both would constitute
an Event of Default shall have happened, the Borrower
shall forthwith given the Bank notice thereof in writing
clarifying such Event of Default, or such event.”
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
42.
In terms of the Master Facility Agreement, the Petitioners had signed
Deed of Guarantee dated 24.03.2023. The following Clauses of Deed of
Guarantee are pertinent and reproduced as under:
“Clause 2.
The Guarantor hereby guarantees as
primary obligator and not merely as surety, the
discharge of the Secured Obligations by the Borrower
and
hereby irrevocably,
unconditionally
and
unequivocally undertakes to the Bank that, the
Guarantor shall, on each demand by the bank from time
to time, forthwith unconditionally and irrevocably pay to
the Bank and make good all amounts demanded in
respect of the Secured Obligations, without any counterclaim, set-off, protest, despite or demur, Any such
demand made by the Bank on the Guarantor shall be
final, conclusive and binding notwithstanding any
difference or any dispute between the Bank and the
Borrower or any arbitration or other legal proceedings,
pending before any court, tribunal, arbitrator or any
other authority. All such payments to be made by the
Guarantor shall be made forthwith upon each such
demand being made and in the event of failure by the
Guarantor to make payment in accordance with the
terms of this Clause, the Guarantor shall pay interest
thereon at the rate of Additional demand/ claim till the
date of payment without prejudice to any in addition to
any other remedies that the Bank may have against the
Guarantor and/or the Borrower.”
Clause 4 Since the security/guarantee hereunder has
been issued/created for covering/securing all the
Facilities from time to time within the Overall Limit, the
same shall not be affected by any grant of totally new or
otherwise limits/account/Facilities, change in, addition
to, inter-change, additions, reduction, supplementing,
revisions,
enhancements,
revolution/revolving,
substitution, renewals, extensions, cancellations,
restricting of any of the Facilities or new or additional
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
Facilities from time to time including any limits/sublimits thereof forming part of the Overall Limit from time
to time; and the security/guarantee shall extend to any
continue to cover the entire Overall Limit
notwithstanding any such grant of totally new or
otherwise limits/accounts/Facilities or otherwise,
change,
inter-change,
enhancement,
addition,
reduction,
modification,
supplement,
renewal,
substitution (part or whole), revolution/revolving,
cancellation, restructuring of any of the Facilities which
form part of the Overall Limit from time to time, without
any further act, deed or writing on the part of any person,
including in all cases of any such grant of totally new or
otherwise limits/accounts/Facilities, change, Interchange, enhancement, addition, reduction, modification,
supplement, renewal, substitution (part of whole),
revolution/revolving,
substitution,
cancellation,
restructuring of any of the Facilities, limits or sub-limits
thereof from time to time.”
“Clause 9: The Bank shall have full liberty, without
notice to the Guarantor to exercise at any time and in
any manner any power or powers reserved to the Bank
under the Master Facility Agreement, to enforce or
forbear to enforce payment of any amounts due to the
Bank under the Master Facility Agreement or any of the
remedies or securities available to the Bank, to enter
into any composition or compound with or to grant time
or any other indulgence to the Borrower and the
Guarantor shall not be released by the exercise by the
Ban of its liberty in regard to the matters referred to
above or by any act or omission on the part of the Bank
or by any other matter or thing whatsoever which under
the law relating to sureties would but for this provision
have the effect of so releasing the Guarantor and the
Guarantor hereby wives in favour of the Bank so far as
may be necessary to give effect to any of the provisions of
this Deed, all the suretyship and other rights which the
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
Guarantor might otherwise be entitled to under
Applicable law. The guarantor also agrees that he/it will
not be entitled to the benefit of subrogation vis-a-vis
securities or otherwise until the Secured Obligations have
been discharged in full. In particular, the Guarantor
hereby waives all the rights available to sureties under
Sections 133, 134, 135, 139 and 141 of the Indian
Contract Act, 1872.”
“Clause 11: The Deed shall be enforceable against the
Guarantor notwithstanding that any post-date cheques,
negotiable instruments, security and/or securities
comprised in any Instrument(s) executed or to be
executed in favour of the Bank (including the Transaction
Documents) shall, at the time when the proceedings are
taken against the Guarantor on this Deed, be outstanding
or unrealised or lost.”
“Clause 18.8: Restructuring/ change/ modification/
renewal/ enhancement of any of the Facilities or by any
change in the terms and conditions of the
facility/sanction.”
43.
From the meaningful reading of the Master Facility Agreement along
with Deed of Guarantee, it is evident that there are various events listed, on
the happening of which, it can be held that a default has occurred. Article 9
(XVIII) specifically states that Inability of the Borrower (or the security
provider and/or the guarantor) to repay debts to any person or any steps
being taken by any person accelerating the payment obligation of the
Borrower/ security provider/ guarantor, would be one event of Default.
However, there is nothing evident from the averments in the Complaint that
there is a default by the Borrower as they are unable to pay the loan. The
Security cheque, by its very definition, can be presented only when the
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
Principal borrower has defaulted in the Payment. The loan account is
subsisting and re-structured the instalments by imposing a higher rate of
interest and the Company has been following the financial discipline and the
Default if any already stands rectified, as payments are being made by the
Company, and is continuing to do so.
44.
The Petitioners have explained that the substantial amount of Rs.
2,68,15,181/- was paid between 20.02.2024 to 03.06.2024. Moreover, the
Complainant Bank unilaterally revised the EMIs and applied Compound
Interest, thereby causing a double burden upon the Borrower, which has
continued to make repayment under the revised terms. As reflected in the
Statement of Account, a substantial amount of Rs.3,33,33,333.32/- between
05.05.2023 to 20.02.2024, has also been paid.
45.
In the aforesaid circumstances, it cannot be said that there was default
event, in terms of Clause Article 9 of the Master Facility Agreement,
especially when the Bank has exercised the option of re-structuring of
Loan.
46.
Another significant aspect is that the Bank was required to have
issued a prior Notice of Demand on the KRPM and on the Guarantors to
seek rectification of the alleged Default and should have thereafter, invoke
the security cheques. Clause 9.2 of the Master Facility Agreement clearly
encapsulates that “If any Event of Default or any event which, after the
notice or lapse of time or both would constitute an Event of Default shall
have happened. Borrower shall forthwith given the Bank notice thereof in
writing clarifying such Event of Default, or such event.” There is no
averment that any prior Notice was given to the Borrower or to the
Guarantors.
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
47.
Considering the various terms of the Master Facility Agreement and
the Deed of Guarantee, Equity and Principles of Natural Justice mandated
that a prior Notice to the Borrower, to explain the default, was required to be
given, before presentation of Security Cheques.
48.
It is significant to note that Respondent Bank has failed to controvert
the assertions made in the Petition, either by way of a Reply or Written or
Oral Submissions, to explain if infact, there was a default.
49.
Even if it is held that technically, there may have been an Outstanding
Amount as on 20.02.2024, for which the Bank may have invoked the
Security Cheques, considering that it is a business commercial venture, it is
not even in the interest of either party if such Complaints under Section 138
NI Act is permitted to be continued, especially when the alleged Default of
the Outstanding Amount has already been addressed along with enhanced
Rate of Interest and the Agreement is subsisting.
50.
Considering the totality of circumstances, to permit continuation of
such a Complaint, would indeed be a process of law and not in the interest
of Justice.
51.
The Complaints are hereby, quashed and the Petitions are allowed.
Pending Applications are disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MARCH 10, 2026
Va
KUMAR BHATT
17:20:30
CRL.M.C.4541/2025 and Ors.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review