Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Revision Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
---------------------------------------------------------------------C.R.P. No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd.,
A Company incorporated under
the Sikkim Companies Act, 1961
having its Registered Office at
Majitar Rangpo, East Sikkim.
… Petitioner.
versus
1.
Smt. Urmila Pradhan,
Wife of Late Khagendra Raj Pradhan,
residing at Kashi Raj Pradhan Marg,
P.O. & P.S. – Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Kishor Raj Pradhan,
S/o Late Khagendra Raj Pradhan,
residing at Kashi Raj Pradhan Marg,
P.O. & P.S. – Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
Shri Swarup Raj Pradhan,
S/o Late Chet Raj Pradhan,
residing at Kashi Raj Pradhan Marg,
P.O. – Gangtok, East Sikkim.
4.
The State of Sikkim,
Through the Secretary,
Land Revenue & Disaster
Management Department,
Government of Sikkim,
New Secretariat, Development Area,
Gangtok-737 101, East Sikkim.
5.
The Revenue Officer,
having its Office at District Collectorate,
P.O. Gangtok, P.S. Sadar,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
6.
Shri Alok Raj Pradhan,
Son of Late Bhim Raj Pradhan,
resident of Casa-Vera,
Laxmi Niwas Complex,
Kashi Raj Pradhan Marg, Namnang,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
7.
Shri Bhaskar Raj Pradhan,
Son of Late Bhim Raj Pradhan,
resident of Casa-Vera,
Laxmi Niwas Complex,
Kashi Raj Pradhan Marg, Namnang,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
8.
Smt. Bindu Mati Pradhan,
Wife of Late Bhim Raj Pradhan,
resident of Casa-Vera,
Laxmi Niwas Complex,
Kashi Raj Pradhan Marg, Namnang,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Respondents.
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Dewashis Baruah, Mr. Biswajit Kumar, Ms. Nirmala
Upadhyaya and Mr. Passang Tsh. Bhutia, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. Bhola N. Sharma, Advocate for Respondents No. 1 and
3.
Mr. N. Rai, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Malati Sharma and Mr.
Suraj Chhetri, Advocates for Respondent No. 2.
Mr. Santosh Kr. Chettri, Assistant Government Advocate
for State-Respondents No. 4 and 5.
Mr. T.B. Thapa, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Pema Yeshey
Bhutia, Ms. Yangchen Doma Gyatso, Mr. Tashi Rapten
Barfungpa and Ms. Tshering Palmoo Bhutia, Advocates for
Respondents No. 6, 7 and 8.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
JUDGMENT
(21.09.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The petitioner herein filed a suit for declaration and
other reliefs against the 1st to 5th respondents/defendants and
late Bhim Raj Pradhan, father of the 6th and 7th respondents and
husband of the 8th respondent, who was impleaded as proforma
defendant at Sl. No. 6, on 27th May 2014.
Late Bhim Raj
Pradhan filed written statement on 02nd September 2014.
On
20th January 2015, late Bhim Raj Pradhan died leaving behind his
sons, 6th and 7th respondents and wife, the 8th respondent herein.
2.
The brief facts as projected by the petitioner are that
on 17th March 2015, learned counsel, Ms. Yangchen Doma
Gyatso, appearing for the proforma defendant 6 informed the
petitioner/ plaintiff and the court about proforma defendant’s
death on 20th January 2015.
As evident from the proceedings
dated 17th March 2015, it was averred that the advocate
appearing for the plaintiff retired from the suit on personal
grounds.
The plaintiff and his constituted attorney were
informed through the Personal Manager, Mr. M.B. Majhi.
matter was adjourned to 22nd April 2015.
The
On 22nd April 2015,
the plaintiff remained absent without having taken any step to
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
bring legal heirs of the deceased proforma defendant 6 on
record. The suit was again taken up on 08th May 2015, wherein
one Mr. Durga Prasad Luitel, Advocate appeared for the plaintiff
and sought adjournment on the ground that he was recently
appointed by the plaintiff. The matter was adjourned to 28 th May
2015. On 28th May 2015, again time was sought by the counsel
for the petitioner/ plaintiff to obtain certain documents from the
Land Revenue Department. The suit again appeared in the court
on 03rd July 2015, when the advocate appearing for the plaintiff
sought for some more time to take necessary steps for
substitution
of
legal
heirs
of
the
deceased
defendant
6.
Accordingly, time was granted and the matter was adjourned to
be listed on 03rd September 2015.
3.
On 03rd September 2015, an application under the
provisions of Order XXII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
“CPC”),
filed
by
the
petitioner/plaintiff was taken on record, wherein it was stated
that the deceased Bhim Raj Pradhan was survived by his wife
Smt. Bindu Mati Pradhan and two sons namely, Mr. Bhaskar Raj
Pradhan and Mr. Alok Raj Pradhan.
A prayer was made to
implead Mr. Alok Raj Pradhan as proforma defendant 6, in place
of the deceased proforma defendant 6, late Bhim Raj Pradhan.
Before that Mr. Alok Raj Pradhan and Mr. Bhaskar Raj Pradhan
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
filed two caveats separately on 20th August 2015 (registered as
Caveat No. 25 of 2015 and Caveat No. 26 of 2015 respectively)
in the pending suit.
On 03rd September 2015, two advocates
namely, Ms. Pema Yeshey Bhutia and Mr. Hissay Dorjee Bhutia,
appeared for the deceased 6th defendant. Notices were issued on
the caveats as well as on the application to bring legal heirs after
the death of the deceased defendant 6 on record, returnable on
14th
October
2015.
On
14th
October
2015,
both
the
caveators/legal heirs of the deceased defendant 6 appeared
through advocate.
Mr. Alok Raj Pradhan filed reply to the
application for substitution on 14th October 2015, contesting that
the suit stands abated against the deceased proforma defendant
6, as such his name be deleted from the array of the parties.
4.
Subsequently, on 29th March 2016, the petitioner/
plaintiff filed an application under Order XXIII Rule 1 (3) read
with Section 151 CPC stating that due to inadvertence and
oversight, proper relief could not be made in the suit and as such
the plaintiff be allowed to withdraw the present suit with liberty
to file a fresh on the same cause of action. The legal heirs of the
deceased defendant 6 contested the application.
The learned
District Judge by impugned order dated 27th April 2016 allowed
the application of the plaintiff to withdraw the suit and also
dismissed the application of the plaintiff to bring legal heirs of the
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
deceased proforma defendant 6 on record, holding that the suit
against the proforma defendant stands abated.
It was further
directed that the plaintiff shall remove/dismantle the temporary
structure that has been recently constructed on the suit property,
in the following terms: “For the reasons mentioned above and
interpreting the meaning of “sufficient grounds” in a
liberal manner, the application of the Plaintiff under
Order XXIII Rule 1 (3) CPC, 1908 is allowed, in the
interest of justice and is accordingly disposed of.
However, the same is subject to the following
conditions:
1.
The cause of action shall remain the
same.
2.
The suit against Proforma Defendant No.
6 stands abatement, and
3.
The Plaintiff shall remove/ dismantle the
temporary structure that has been
recently constructed on the suit property.
Since condition number (3) mentioned above,
would serve the purpose of Defendant No. 1, 2 and 3
for seeking temporary injunction, the said application
is also disposed accordingly.
In terms above, the Plaintiff is permitted to
withdraw the present suit and file afresh on the same
cause of action.
The Suit No. 06 of 2014 accordingly stands
disposed of.”
5.
Feeling aggrieved by the order holding that the suit
against the deceased proforma defendant 6 stood abated and
also direction to remove/dismantle the temporary structure that
was then constructed on the suit property and further confining
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
the liberty to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action, the
instant revision petition is filed.
6.
the
Mr. Dewashis Baruah, learned counsel appearing for
petitioner/
plaintiff
would
conditions is patently illegal.
contend
that
imposition
of
It is further contended that the
petitioner/ plaintiff was neither properly advised nor given proper
legal assistance after the original advocate, appearing for the
plaintiff, withdrew from the suit, without consent and information
to the plaintiff.
Proceedings under Order XXII CPC are not penal
in nature but are only a procedure devised to ensure an effective
adjudication after affording an opportunity to all the concerned
parties.
The same ought to have been considered liberally,
particularly when the legal heirs of the deceased defendant 6 had
filed caveats themselves and participated in the proceedings
thereafter.
Mr.
Baruah
would
further
contend
that
the
application to bring legal heirs of the deceased defendant 6 could
not be filed within time due to the fact that the Personal Manager
present in the court could not understand the gravity of the
matter. The original advocate, who retired from the suit, did not
inform about the death of the proforma defendant 6, even on
information given in the court. Some time was taken while
engaging a new counsel.
In such a process, the delay was
neither unreasonable nor intentional.
The learned court ought
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
not to have imposed conditions to file a fresh suit on the same
cause of action, when new developments have been taken place
in the cause of action. It is also urged that while permitting the
plaintiff to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit, no
interim
temporary
injunction
is
permissible
in
law.
Not
permitting to implead the legal heirs of the deceased defendant 6
in the proposed suit is not just and proper for judicious
adjudication of the dispute.
7.
Mr.
Baruah
had
emphatically
and
vehemently
contended that the plaintiff had difficulty in getting legal
assistance, as no counsel in Sikkim is willing to take up the
matter.
It is further urged that the petitioner/ plaintiff could
engage an advocate only in the first week of May 2015 and
accordingly, an adjournment was sought on 08th May 2015 by the
advocate. In fact, the petitioner came to know about the death
of proforma 6th defendant only on 03rd July 2015, when the
Senior Counsel appearing for the 1st, 2nd and 3rd respondents
informed the learned trial court and also to the new advocate
appearing for the petitioner/ plaintiff.
The petitioner/ plaintiff
faced a lot of difficulty in engaging a counsel here and a counsel
from Siliguri was engaged to represent the petitioner before the
learned trial court.
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
8.
Referring to observations made by the Supreme Court
in Gema Coutinho Rodrigues (Smt.) v. Bricio Franciso Pereira and
others1, Sardar Amarjit Singh Kalra (Dead) by LRs. And others v.
Pramod Gupta (Smt.) (Dead) by LRs. And others 2 , Mithailal
Dalsangar Singh and others v. Annabai Devram Kini and others 3,
K Rudrappa v. Shivappa 4 and Banwari Lal (Dead) by Legal
Representatives and another v. Balbir Singh5, Mr. Baruah submits
that in the facts of the case, the application for substitution ought
to have been allowed with full liberty to the plaintiff to file a fresh
suit on the subject matter.
9.
In response, Mr. T.B. Thapa, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the 6th to 8th respondents would contend that if an
application, on coming to know the death of the proforma
defendant 6, is not filed within 90 days, the title suit vis-à-vis
proforma defendant 6 stood abated under the provision of Order
XXII Rule 4 sub-rule (3) CPC read with Article 120 of the
Limitation Act, the right enures in favour of the 6 th, 7th and 8th
respondents.
It is further contended that if an application for
setting aside the abatement is not filed within 60 days, i.e. on or
before 19th June 2015, no application for abatement was
maintainable, as prescribed under Article 121 of the Limitation
(1993) 2 SCC 620
(2003) 3 SCC 272
(2003) 10 SCC 691
(2004) 12 SCC 253
(2016) 1 SCC 607
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
Act.
Mr. Thapa would further submit that mere filing of caveat
by two sons on 20th August 2015, on expiry of 90+60 days does
not amount to participation or acquiescence, the 8th respondent
did not file any caveat and subsequent participation with the sole
purpose to protect their interest does not alter the legal bar. It is
emphatically urged by Mr. Thapa that no further order or action
is necessary after expiry of 90 days, as the suit stands abated
vis-à-vis late proforma 6th defendant on expiry of 90 days, i.e. on
20th April 2015.
Thereafter, the only remedy available to the
petitioner/ plaintiff was to file an application within 60 days from
the date of expiry of 90 days for setting aside the abatement,
which was not done.
10.
In the case on hand, no application was filed within
limitation time.
The application filed subsequently on 03 rd
September 2015 did not disclose any sufficient ground, as
required, for setting aside the abatement, after condonation of
delay, if permissible in the facts of the case. Thus, the revision
petition deserves to be dismissed.
11.
To bolster his submission, Mr. Thapa referred and
relied on Sadassiva Rauji Gaitonde and others v. Jose Joaquim
Fonseca 6 , Shyam Ray v. Haramani Dei (deceased by LR) and
AIR 1976 Goa, Daman & Diu 11
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
others7, Salil Dutta v. T.M. and M.C. Private Ltd.8, and Balwant
Singh (Dead) v. Jagdish Singhand others9.
12.
Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel and Mr. Bhola N.
Sharma, learned counsel appearing for other respondents have
not advanced any arguments except that if the application for
substitution seeks impleadment of only one of legal heirs, as the
case is herein, the application deserves to be rejected at the
threshold.
13.
On careful examination of the submissions put forth
by the learned counsel appearing for the parties, perusal of the
pleadings and documents appended thereto, it is manifest that
the factual events are not disputed by either party.
14.
Indisputably, the application to bring the legal heirs of
the deceased proforma defendant 6 could be filed only on 03 rd
September 2015, but on the day, the two sons of the deceased
proforma defendant 6 appeared through caveats, however, the
wife was not represented.
It is pertinent to state here that two
legal heirs, as aforestated, of the deceased proforma defendant
filed caveats on 20th August 2015, which were taken along with
the application for substitution on 03rd September 2015.
It is
again not disputable that the death of the deceased proforma
AIR 1984 67
(1993) 2 SCC 185
(2010) 8 SCC 685
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
defendant 6 took place on 20th January 2015, which was
informed to the court on 17th March 2015.
However, on 17th
March 2015, it is noticed from the proceedings of the court that
the advocate appearing for the plaintiff retired from the suit on
personal grounds.
It is stated by the petitioner herein that the
advocate appearing for the plaintiff withdrew from the suit
without giving any information and consent.
As such, the
information of the death of the proforma defendant 6 was not
communicated to the plaintiff. The personal manager appearing
on the date was not aware of the legal complications and did not
inform the plaintiff.
15.
In the facts of the case, when it is alleged that the
advocates of the Sikkim were not willing to appear for the
plaintiff and an advocate was engaged from Siliguri, who had
sought certain adjournments on few dates, it cannot be held that
the reasons for not filing the application were not sufficient.
It is
relevant to mention here that the application under Order XXII
Rule 4 CPC did not mention the difficulty faced by the plaintiff in
engaging a local counsel, except that the counsel appearing for
the plaintiff withdrew from the suit for personal reasons but it is
pleaded strongly herein.
The plaintiff in its application, after
stating the fact that the deceased proforma defendant 6 was
survived by two sons and his wife, had chosen to implead only
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
one son, Mr. Alok Raj Pradhan, as legal heir.
On this, the
application cannot be rejected as rightly held by the Supreme
Court in Gema Coutinho Rodrigues (Smt.)1. The Supreme Court
in the case held that in the event, an application is made to bring
one of the heirs on record, the trial Court ought to direct the
plaintiff to bring other legal heirs of the deceased on record
without rejecting the application, as under: “5.
It appears that the gift deeds were made by
deceased brother's brother-in-law in pursuance of
power of attorney in his favour. So long as one of the
heirs has been brought on record who substantially
represented estate of deceased plaintiff, the
application could not be dismissed on the ground that
the suit has abated or it could not proceed. Trial court
should have directed the appellant to implead other
heirs if any, of the deceased mother who was also a
party to the suit by way of defendants. But the
application for being brought on record by the
appellant could not have been rejected. We,
accordingly, set aside the order of the trial court dated
March 19, 1979 as well as the order of the High Court
dated January 11, 1983 and direct the trial court to
bring the appellant on record as legal heir of the
deceased plaintiffs and permit the appellant to implead
any other heirs as co-defendants.”
16.
Now coming to the question, as to whether the
learned trial court was right in granting liberty to file a fresh suit
on the same cause of action, which has been agitated by the
petitioner herein.
The petitioner in its application under Order
XXIII Rule 1 (3) CPC seeking withdrawal of the suit has
specifically mentioned to file fresh suit on the same cause of
action and the learned trial Judge acceded to the request of the
petitioner and granted the same. Needless to state that if a new
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
cause of action arises that could not have been permitted by the
learned trial Judge, as no liberty is necessary for assailing the
new cause of action, if any.
The petitioner has not sought
permission to withdraw the suit on the same subject matter.
17.
In Vallabh Das v. Dr. Madan Lal and others10, referred
by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, the Supreme
Court has examined the difference between the cause of action
and subject matter.
In the case therein, the plaintiff sought
withdrawal of the suit with liberty to file a fresh in respect of the
subject matter of the suit. In the case on hand, the withdrawal
of the suit was sought on the same cause of action. It is for the
petitioner to take a decision on fresh cause of action.
The
learned trial Judge has rightly confined the liberty to the same
cause of action as pleaded by the petitioner/ plaintiff.
The
Supreme Court in Vallabh Das10, held as under: “5.
Rule 1, Order XXIII, Code of Civil Procedure
empowers the courts to permit a plaintiff to withdraw
from the suit brought by him with liberty to institute a
fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of that suit
on such terms as it thinks fit. The term imposed on
the plaintiff in the previous suit was that before
bringing a fresh suit on the same cause of action, he
must pay the costs of the defendants. Therefore we
have to see whether that condition governs the
institution of the present suit. For deciding that
question we have to see whether the suit from which
this appeal arises is in respect of the same subjectmatter that was in litigation in the previous suit. The
expression “subject-matter” is not defined in the Civil
Procedure Code. It does not mean property. That
expression has a reference to a right in the property
which the plaintiff seeks to enforce. That expression
(1970) 1 SCC 761
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
includes the cause of action and the relief claimed.
Unless the cause of action and the relief claimed in the
second suit are the same as in the first suit, it cannot
be said, that the subject-matter of the second suit is
the same as that in the previous suit. Now coming to
the case before us in the first suit Dr Madan Lal was
seeking to enforce his right to partition and separate
possession. In the present suit he seeks to get
possession of the suit properties from a trespasser on
the basis of his title. In the first suit the cause of
action was the division of status between Dr Madan Lal
and his adoptive father and the relief claimed was the
conversion of joint possession into separate
possession. In the present suit the plaintiff is seeking
possession of the suit properties from a trespasser. In
the first case his cause of action arose on the day he
got separated from his family. In the present suit the
cause of action, namely, the series of transactions
which formed the basis of his title to the suit
properties, arose on the death of his adoptive father
and mother. It is true that both in the previous suit as
well as in the present suit the factum and validity of
adoption of Dr Madan Lal came up for decision. But
that adoption was not the cause of action in the first
nor is it the cause of action in the present suit. It was
merely an antecedent event which conferred certain
rights on him. Mere identity of some of the issues in
the two suits do not bring about an identity of the
subject-matter in the two suits. As observed
in Rukhma Bai v. Mahadeo Narayan, [ILR 42 Bom 155]
the expression “subject-matter” in Order XXIII, Rule
1, Code of Civil Procedure means the series of acts or
transactions alleged to exist giving rise to the relief
claimed. In other words “subject-matter” means the
bundle of facts which have to be proved in order to
entile the plaintiff to the relief claimed by him. We
accept as correct the observations of Wallis, C.J.,
in Singa Reddi v. Subba Reddi [ILR 39 Mad 987] that
where the cause of action and the relief claimed in the
second suit are not the same as the cause of action
and the relief claimed in the first suit, the second suit
cannot be considered to have been brought in respect
of the same subject-matter as the first suit.”
18.
The third condition which is challenged herein is that
the removal/dismantle of the temporary structure that has been
recently constructed on the suit property. Before going into the
power of the court to put conditions likewise, it is apt to state
that both the parties have agreeably submitted that the said
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
temporary structure stand removed and as such it is not
necessary to go into the exercise of judicial discretion/power of
the trial court at this stage.
19.
The issue as to whether the suit stood abated vis-à-vis
deceased proforma defendant 6, in the facts of the case, requires
consideration.
As aforestated, the application was filed on 03 rd
September 2015 to bring legal heirs of the deceased defendant 6
on record, wherein the petitioner sought for impleadment of one
of the legal heirs of the deceased defendant.
It is well settled
principles of law that under Order XXII Rule 4 CPC read with
Article 120 of the Limitation Act, the suit stand abated without
there being any order on completion of 90 days.
Further, the
application may be made for setting aside the abatement within
60 days from the expiry of 90th day, in the case in hand the date
expired on 19th June 2015 and the 60th day came to an end on
20th August 2015. However, there is no quarrel on the issue that
the court is competent to condone the delay in the event,
sufficient reasons are shows for not making the application within
the limitation period of 60 days for setting aside the abatement.
The reasons shown by the plaintiff in the application does not
appear to be sufficient in strict sense, however, in the factum of
the case when the two legal heirs have filed caveat, as being
were aware of the proceedings pending against the deceased
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
defendant and also keeping in view the statement of the plaintiff
that the plaintiff faced difficulty in engaging counsel as no local
counsel was willing to accept the case on behalf of the plaintiff,
this court is of the considered view that in the interest of justice,
it is necessary to consider all the facts while condoning delay in
filing the application to bring legal heirs of the deceased
defendant on record.
20.
On invocation of doctrine of abatement, the most
effective party is the plaintiff and plaintiff’s family and estate.
The principle of abatement is involved to ensure administration of
justice as expeditiously and cheaply as possible. The abatement
merely pause the proceedings until the problem is remedied in
the pending dispute.
The Supreme Court in Rangubai Kom
Shankar Jagtap v. Suderabai Bhratar Sakharam Jedhe & others 11,
referring to the observation made by the Judicial Committee in
Brij Indar Singh v. Kanshi Ram12, held that it is the well-settled
position that if the legal representatives of a deceased plaintiff or
defendant are brought on record in an appeal or revision from an
order made in the suit, that would enure for all subsequent
stages of the suit.
AIR 1965 SC 1974
(1917) LR 44 IA 218, 228
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
21.
Mr. T.B. Thapa, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the 6th, 7th and 8th respondents, has referred two passages of the
decision rendered by the Additional Judicial Commissioner in
Sadassiva Rauji Gaitonde6, wherein it is held that under Order
XXII, Rule 4, CPC, the suit as against the deceased defendant
abates automatically whether or not an objection is taken by any
party. The legal effects of such abatement will follow and a court
of law will have to import them without waiting for formal
objection by any party.
The procedure is binding on all and it
cannot be waived expressly or by implication by any of the
parties to the suit.
After the abatement of the suit, the only
course open for the opposite party is to apply under Order XXII,
Rule 9 (2), CPC for setting aside the abatement by pleading facts
to show that the party was prevented from sufficient cause from
continuing the suit.
22.
A reference was made by him to an observation of the
learned Single Judge of the Orissa High Court in Shyam Ray7,
wherein the learned Judge held as under: “11. By reason of abatement, certain rights and
benefits accrue to the surviving defendant and also to
the legal representative of the deceased defendant
depending on the suit and the reliefs claimed. I can
see no reason either in law or equity to deprive the
defendant and the legal representative of the rights
and advantages so gained by the failure of the plaintiff
to substitute by permitting withdrawal of the suit with
liberty to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action.”
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
23.
The Supreme Court examining the facets of Order
XXII CPC on abatement in Sital Prasad Saxena (Dead) by LRS. V.
Union of India and others13, held that “…… what has been said
umpteen times that rules of procedure are designed to advance
justice and should be so interpreted as not to make them penal
statutes for punishing erring parties”.
In view of the nature of
litigation wherein the legal representatives of the deceased, the
plaintiff is sought to be impleaded belatedly.
Referring to a decision rendered in Salil Dutta8, Mr.
24.
Thapa contends that a party cannot disown its advocate at any
time and seek relief when the advocate is present in the Court
when information about the death of 6th respondent was given.
The petitioner/plaintiff cannot disown and submit that the
petitioner was not aware of the death of the 6th respondent.
25.
Mr. Dewashis Baruah, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner, referring a decision in Mithailal Dalsangar Singh3,
while considering the principles of abatement, as contemplated
under Order XXII, Rule 3, CPC, the Supreme Court held as
under: “8. Inasmuch as the abatement results in denial of
hearing on the merits of the case, the provision of
abatement has to be construed strictly. On the other
hand, the prayer for setting aside an abatement and
the dismissal consequent upon an abatement, have to
be considered liberally. A simple prayer for bringing
(1985)1 SCC 163
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
the legal representatives on record without specifically
praying for setting aside of an abatement may in
substance be construed as a prayer for setting aside
the abatement. So also a prayer for setting aside
abatement as regards one of the plaintiffs can be
construed as a prayer for setting aside the abatement
of the suit in its entirety. Abatement of suit for failure
to move an application for bringing the legal
representatives on record within the prescribed period
of limitation is automatic and a specific order
dismissing the suit as abated is not called for. Once
the suit has abated as a matter of law, though there
may not have been passed on record a specific order
dismissing the suit as abated, yet the legal
representatives proposing to be brought on record or
any other applicant proposing to bring the legal
representatives of the deceased party on record would
seek the setting aside of an abatement. A prayer for
bringing the legal representatives on record, if
allowed, would have the effect of setting aside the
abatement as the relief of setting aside abatement
though not asked for in so many words is in effect
being actually asked for and is necessarily implied. Too
technical or pedantic an approach in such cases is not
called for.
9. The courts have to adopt a justice-oriented
approach dictated by the uppermost consideration that
ordinarily a litigant ought not to be denied an
opportunity of having a lis determined on merits
unless he has, by gross negligence, deliberate inaction
or something akin to misconduct, disentitled himself
from seeking the indulgence of the court. The opinion
of the trial Judge allowing a prayer for setting aside
abatement and his finding on the question of
availability of “sufficient cause” within the meaning of
sub-rule (2) of Rule 9 of Order 22 and of Section 5 of
the Limitation Act, 1963 deserves to be given weight,
and once arrived at would not normally be interfered
with by superior jurisdiction.”
26.
Again in Sardar Amarjit Singh Kalra (Dead) by LRS.2,
a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, examining the ambit
of Order XXII, Rules 2 and 3, CPC, held as under: “26. Laws of procedure are meant to regulate
effectively, assist and aid the object of doing
substantial and real justice and not to foreclose even
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
an adjudication on merits of substantial rights of
citizen under personal, property and other laws.
Procedure has always been viewed as the handmaid of
justice and not meant to hamper the cause of justice
or sanctify miscarriage of justice. A careful reading of
the provisions contained in Order 22 CPC as well as
the subsequent amendments thereto would lend credit
and support to the view that they were devised to
ensure their continuation and culmination in an
effective adjudication and not to retard the further
progress of the proceedings and thereby non-suit the
others similarly placed as long as their distinct and
independent rights to property or any claim remain
intact and not lost forever due to the death of one or
the other in the proceedings. The provisions contained
in Order 22 are not to be construed as a rigid matter
of principle but must ever be viewed as a flexible tool
of convenience in the administration of justice. The
fact that the khata was said to be joint is of no
relevance, as long as each one of them had their own
independent, distinct and separate shares in the
property as found separately indicated in the
jamabandi itself of the shares of each of them
distinctly. We are also of the view that the High Court
should have, on the very perception it had on the
question of abatement, allowed the applications for
impleadment even dehors the cause for the delay in
filing the applications keeping in view the serious
manner in which it would otherwise jeopardize an
effective adjudication on merits, the rights of the other
remaining appellants for no fault of theirs. Interests of
justice would have been better served had the High
Court adopted a positive and constructive approach
than merely scuttled the whole process to foreclose an
adjudication of the claims of others on merits. The
rejection by the High Court of the applications to set
aside abatement, condonation and bringing on record
the legal representatives does not appear, on the
peculiar nature of the case, to be a just or reasonable
exercise of the Court's power or in conformity with the
avowed object of the Court to do real, effective and
substantial justice. Viewed in the light of the fact that
each one of the appellants had an independent and
distinct right of his own not interdependent upon one
or the other of the appellants, the dismissal of the
appeals by the High Court in their entirety does not
constitute a sound, reasonable or just and proper
exercise of its powers. Even if it has to be viewed that
they had a common interest, then the interests of
justice would require the remaining other appellants
being allowed to pursue the appeals for the benefit of
those others, who are not before the Court also and
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
not stultify the proceedings as a whole and non-suit
the others as well.”
In K. Rudrappa4, the Supreme Court commented on
27.
the hypertechnical view, while considering application for setting
aside the abatement, observed as under: “10. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, in
our opinion, the appeal deserves to be allowed. The
case of the appellant before the District Court was that
he was not aware of the pendency of the appeal filed
by his father against the order passed by the
Tahsildar. The father of the appellant died in June
1994 and the appellant came to know of the pendency
of appeal somewhere in September 1994 when he
received a communication from the advocate engaged
by his father. Immediately, therefore, he contacted
the said advocate, informed him regarding the death
of his father and made an application. In such
circumstances, in our opinion, the learned counsel for
the appellant is right in submitting that a
hypertechnical view ought not to have been taken by
the District Court in rejecting the application inter alia
observing that no prayer for setting aside abatement
of appeal was made and there was also no prayer for
condonation of delay. In any case, when separate
applications were made, they ought to have been
allowed. In our opinion, such technical objections
should not come in doing full and complete justice
between the parties. In our considered opinion, the
High Court ought to have set aside the order passed
by the District Court and it ought to have granted the
prayer of the appellant for bringing them on record as
heirs
and
legal
representatives
of
deceased
Hanumanthappa and by directing the District Court to
dispose of the appeal on its own merits. By not doing
so, even the High Court has also not acted according
to law.”
28.
Yet, again in Bhag Mal alias Ram Bux and others v.
Munshi (Dead) by LRS. And others 14 , the Supreme Court
reiterated
the
well-settled
principles
on
consideration
application for setting aside the abatement, as under: -
(2007) 11 SCC 285
of
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
26. We need to read the liberal trend on setting aside
the abatement and the issue of finality of decision on
abatement together. It is to be noted that
considerable leeway has been accorded to proceedings
to set aside abatement. Thus it follows that only
because abatement leads to serious consequences, the
emphasis on ample opportunity to set aside
abatement has been laid down.
29.
Mr. Thapa, referring to the ratio laid down by the
Supreme Court in Balwant Singh (Dead) vs. Jagdish Singh and
others9, submits that no liberal approach be adopted while
condoning the delay, particularly when an application for setting
aside the abatement is made much beyond the limitation period.
The Supreme Court, in the facts of the case, observed as under:“32. It must be kept in mind that whenever a law is
enacted by the legislature, it is intended to be
enforced in its proper perspective. It is an equally
settled principle of law that the provisions of a statute,
including every word, have to be given full effect,
keeping the legislative intent in mind, in order to
ensure that the projected object is achieved. In other
words, no provisions can be treated to have been
enacted purposelessly.
33. Furthermore, it is also a well-settled canon of
interpretative jurisprudence that the Court should not
give such an interpretation to the provisions which
would render the provision ineffective or odious. Once
the legislature has enacted the provisions of Order 22,
with particular reference to Rule 9, and the provisions
of the Limitation Act are applied to the entertainment
of such an application, all these provisions have to be
given their true and correct meaning and must be
applied wherever called for. If we accept the
contention of the learned counsel appearing for the
applicant that the Court should take a very liberal
approach and interpret these provisions (Order 22
Rule 9 CPC and Section 5 of the Limitation Act) in such
a manner and so liberally, irrespective of the period of
delay, it would amount to practically rendering all
these provisions redundant and inoperative. Such
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
approach or interpretation would hardly be permissible
in law.”
Observation of the Supreme Court was made without
referring to a decision of the Supreme Court in the Constitution
Bench, however, the observation was made in the facts of the
case, which is distinguishable in the facts of the instant case.
30.
In Banwari Lal (Dead)5, the Supreme Court examined
several decisions referred and rendered by the Supreme Court
earlier, held as under: “9.
Provisions of Order 22 CPC are not penal in
nature. It is a rule of procedure and substantial rights
of the parties cannot be defeated by pedantic
approach by observing strict adherence to the
procedural aspects of law. …………”
31.
On critical examination of the judicial pronouncements
made by the Supreme Court in various cases, it is luculent that
the main consideration is advancement of justice that takes the
precedence over rule of the procedure.
The Supreme Court in
Balwant Singh (Dead)9 has laid emphasis on following the
procedural aspect strictly in the facts of that case.
32.
In the case on hand, wherein the application was filed
belatedly and the two legal heirs have also filed caveats in the
pending suit, there is no reason to reject the application on the
ground that the limitation period was not followed strictly. The
liberal trend be read and considerable leeway be accorded to the
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
proceeding to set aside the abatement and as such strict
compliance of the rule of procedure may not be required in the
facts of the case to advance justice.
33.
As a sequel, the order to the extent of dismissing the
application to bring legal heirs of the deceased proforma
defendant 6 is quashed and abatement vis-à-vis deceased
proforma defendant 6 is set aside.
The other conditions are
upheld.
34.
The petition is allowed accordingly. No order as to
costs.
Chief Justice
21.09.2017
jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
CRP No. 01 of 2017
M/s Himalaya Distilleries Ltd. v. Smt. Urmila Pradhan & Ors.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review