Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 22.07.2026
Pronounced on : 31.07.2026
CORAM :
The Hon'ble Mr.Justice N.SATHISH KUMAR
and
The Hon'ble Mr.Justice M.JOTHIRAMAN
A.S.No.920 of 2012
and
M.P.No.1 of 2012
Mrs.L.Raniammal (died)
2.L.Vasanthakumar
(Appellant died, A2 is brought on record
as LR.s of deceased first appellant, namely
L.Raniammal vide order dated 28.10.2022
in CMP. No.11425 of 2019 in AS No.920 of 2012)
Vs.
1.K.C.Saradambal (died)
2.R.Durgarani
3.E.Karpagam
4.Navaneetha Krishnan
5.Keerthana
[Respondent 4 and 5 are declared as major and
their guardian Mr.O.M.Saravanan is discharged
from guardianship of RR4 and 5 vide order
dated 23.07.2024 made in CMP Nos.29427 and
29428 of 2023 in AS No.920 of 2012]
1/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
.. Appellant
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
6.J.Chitra
7.B.Indira
8.R.Sundarajan
9.R.Soundarajan
10.R.Vijaya
11.R.Sathya
12.R.Vidya
13.R.Sujatha
14.R.Kowsalya
15.D.Navaneedam
16.K.C.Madanagopal
17.K.C.Dilli Babu
18.K.C.Jayagopal (died)
19.K.Sundaraj
20.P.Menaga
21.L.Suresh
22.I.Vijayabaskar
[RR20 to 22 are brought on record as
LR.s of deceased appellant, namely L.Raniammal
vide order dated 28.10.2022 made in
CMP Nos.11425, 11426 and 11428 of 2019
in AS No.920 of 2012]
23.Yamuna Bai
24.J.Sathiskumar
25.J.Rathish
[R18 died, RR23 to 25 are brought on record
as LR.s of deceased 18th respondent K.C.Jayagopal
vide order dated 28.02.2023 made in CMP
Nos.4349, 4352 and 4353 of 2023 in
AS No.920 of 2012]
.. Respondents
This appeal suit has been filed under Section 96 of the Civil Procedure
Code, 1908 seeking to set aside the decree made in OS No.335 of 2004
dated 30.03.2012 on the file of the Additional District Judge, Fast Track
Court No.1, Chengalpattu insofar as the same is made against the
2/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
appellant that is dismissing the suit for partition in respect of item
nos.146, 148 to 150 of the suit schedule property by allowing the appeal
and grant decree of partition in all the suit properties and thus render
justice.
For Appellant
: Mr.S.Vasudevan
For Respondents : Mr.P.H.Aravindh Pandian, SC
for Mr.S.Udhayakumar
for RR8,9,17,18,23,24 and 25
Mr.S.Parthasarathy, SC
for Mr.K.S.Navin Balaji for R19
---JUDGMENT
N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.
The plaintiff challenging the dismissal of the suit in O.S.No.335 of
2004 by the learned Additional District Judge, Fast Track Court No.1,
Chengalpattu, vide judgment dated 30.03.2012 has filed the present
appeal in respect of properties mentioned in item nos.146, 148 to 150.
2.The parties in this judgment are hereinafter referred to as per
their rankings before the trial court.
3.The facts in the present case are as follows:
3/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
3.1.According to the plaintiff, the entire suit properties belonged to
her father one K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu and he died intestate on 27.11.1978
leaving behind the plaintiff and defendants as his legal heirs. The
plaintiff,
14th
and
15th
defendants
are
daughters
and
one
K.C.Ramachandran is the son of late K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. The first
defendant is the wife of K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. The second defendant is
the wife of K.C.Ramachandran, since deceased. The third defendant is the
grand son’s wife of late K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. Defendants 4 and 5 are
great grand son and great grand daughter of late K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu.
The defendants 6, 7, 10, 11, 12 and 13 are grand daughters of late
K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. 8th and 9th defendants are grand sons of late
K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. Defendants 16 to 18 are sons of late
K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. The 19th defendant is the purchaser of 5/8th share in
the entire suit properties from other defendants. According to the plaintiff,
defendants 1 to 13, 16 to 18 appropriated income from the bus service
and lands without giving shares to the plaintiff.
3.2.Further, it is the plaintiff’s case that substantial lands in
Keezakarana Chithamnur and Tirukachur villages have been acquired by
the government for the benefit of the industrial unit and the compensation
is yet to be paid by the government. Therefore, the plaintiff and
4/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
defendants are entitled to shares in the plaint schedule properties as per
the Hindu law. The plaintiff is entitled to 1/8th share in the suit properties.
Since the joint ownership of the properties has not been beneficial to the
plaintiff, she has sent a legal notice on 05.09.1998 to the defendants
demanding partition of plaint schedule properties. The defendants
attempted to sell the substantial portion of the suit properties. Being the
co-owner, the plaintiff is entitled to preliminary decree of 1/8th share in all
the suit properties.
3.3.The defendants 3 to 5 filed written statement denying that the
entire suit properties belonged to Chinnaiya Naidu. According to him,
item nos.126 to 139, 142, 146 and 148 are exclusive properties belonged
to late K.C.Ramachandran and only his wife and children are entitled to
shares in those properties. Further, it is their contention that defendant
nos.2, 8, 9, 16 to 18 appeared to have received their portion of
compensation amount regarding the lands of K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu
acquired by the government and also in respect of lands of
K.C.Ramachandran acquired by the Government for Ford company and
National Highways. Therefore, they are accountable for the same. This
defendant has also filed a suit in O.S.No.161 of 1997 for partition of the
properties left by K.C.Ramachandran. According to them, they are
5/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
entitled to 33/160 and 33/640 shares in the schedule mentioned
properties. The third defendant has also filed an additional written
statement for herself and for 4th and 5th defendants, stating that item
no.149 belonged to K.C.Ramachandran and they are not the properties of
K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. The item no.150 belonged to K.C.Ramachandran
and his brother having jointly purchased by them and it is their exclusive
possession and enjoyment and therefore, the plantiff cannot claim any
share in those items.
3.4.The 6th defendant has filed a written statement contending that
item nos.126 to 139, 142, 146, 148 are properties of K.C.Ramachandran
and therefore, his wife and children alone are entitled to shares in those
properties. This defendant has also filed a suit in O.S.No.113 of 1997 for
partition of properties left by K.C.Ramachandran. Hence, according to
her, she is entitled to 1/10th share in the properties of late
K.C.Ramachandran and 1/80th share in the properties of late
K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. The 6th defendant has also filed additional written
statement. According to her, item no.150 belonged to K.C.Ramachandran
and his brothers having jointly purchased by them and they were in
exclusive possession and enjoyment of the same.
6/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
3.5.The 7th defendant has filed a written statement accepting that
some of the averments made by the plaintiff in the plaint are true.
According to her, the defendants 1, 2, 8 to 13 and 16 to 18 were colluding
together and appropriated the income from the properties to themselves
without sharing the income to the plaintiff and also to this defendant and
therefore, this 7th defendant is also entitled to 1/8 th share in the plaint
schedule mentioned properties. This defendant has also filed a suit in
O.S.No.222 of 1998 on the file of the Additional Sub Court, Chengalpattu
for partition and for separate possession of her due share in respect of the
properties mentioned in that plaint schedule.
3.6.The 9th defendant has filed a written statement which was also
adopted by defendants 2, 8, 10 to 13 and 17. It was stated that even
during the life time of Chinnaiya Naidu, the suit item nos.1 to 29 in
Kizhakaranai village were acquired by the government and Chinnaiya
Naidu himself had received the entire compensation from the
government. Item nos.132 to 137 were sold by Chinnaiya Naidu and the
suit was bad for non joinder of purchasers. The other suit items are
imaginary and the plaintiff has included the properties of strangers as if
they are available for partition. The suit item no.148 never belonged to
Chinnaiya Naidu. The Shanmugananda Bus service is exclusive property
7/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
of defendants 2, 8 and 9. The Shanmugananda bus service is a private
limited company governed by the Companies Act and therefore, if at all,
the plaintiff has to file a suit for dissolution and winding up of the
company and for accounts. Hence, the suit in respect of item no.148 is not
maintainable. The plaintiff is not in possession of any properties and the
court fee paid is incorrect.
3.7.The 8th defendant has filed additional written statement stating
that suit item nos.30, 31, 33, 34, 36 to 41, 43, 51, 60, 61, 66 to 69, 75 to
96, 101 to 111 in Sengundram village were sold away by K.R.Chinnaiya
Naidu long prior to the filing of the suit. Item no.35, i.e., S.No.22/4 was
repeated as item nos.42 and 49 over again and similarly, item no.32 was
repeated as item no.99 again. The suit item nos.112 to 117 and 120 to 123
were sold by K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu several decades ago. Item nos.126 to
132 never owned and possessed by Chinnaiya Naidu and item nos.133 to
137 also never belonged to Chinnaiya Naidu. Item no.146 was purchased
on 25.08.1962 by Shanmugananda Bus Service Private Limited and was
not the individual property of Chinnaiya Naidu. The suit item no.148,
Shanmugananda Bus Service Private Limited consists of several
shareholders and was not the individual property of Chinnaiya Naidu.
Therefore, a partition suit cannot be filed as shareholder will not have any
8/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
share in the property of the company. The 8th defendant purchased the
shares of Chinnaiya Naidu and the individual shares of 17th and 18th
defendants in Shanmugananda Bus service. The buses mentioned in the
suit schedule item no.148 do not exist. There was partnership concern,
namely K.R.C.Chandran Bus service and as per the partnership deed
dated 25.3.1994, the K.R.C.Chandran Bus service belonged to defendants
2, 8 and 9. The suit item no.l50 was purchased by K.C.Ramachandran
and his three bothers jointly in the year 1969. Therefore, they are separate
properties. The plaintiff has also filed a suit in O.S.No.307 of 1984
claiming those properties as available for partition. The said suit was
resisted by K.C.Ramachandran, the husband of second defendant. The
said suit was dismissed on 18.1.1990. Further, in the additional written
statement filed by the 8th defendant, he has stated that the buses bearing
registration nos.TN 21 J 1166 and TN 21 J 5999 were purchased in the
year 2006 by this defendant and his brother Sundarrajan, 9 th defendant
and their mother Durgarani, the second defendant who are partners of
K.R.C.Chandran bus service. The route for this bus was also owned by
Ramachandran, father of this 8th defendant and 9 th defendant and
husband of the second defendant and they constituted partnership of
K.R.C.Chandraan Bus service. The buses purchased in the year 2006
9/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
cannot be claimed by the plaintiff as the property of her father. Similarly,
with regard to item no.3 of suit item no.149, the Carriage Spare Bus did
not contain any registration numbr and hence, those properties also
cannot be claimed.
3.8.The 18th defendant has filed a written statement stating that
most of the suit properties mentioned in the schedule were sold by
Chinnaiya Naidu even during his life time. Some of the properties of
Chinnaiya Naidu were partitioned orally among sons even during the life
time of Chinnaiya Naidu. The rest of the properties of Chinnaiya Naidu
were partitioned among the sons after his demise. The plaintiff has never
been in joint possession of any of the properties. Therefore, he has
disputed the claim of the plaintiff. The 18th defendant has also filed an
additional written statement. The suit filed by the plaintiff in O.S.No.307
of 1984 along with others was already dismissed. If really the plaintiff
has any share in item no.150, she would not have agreed to go along with
others and she would have contested the suit alone by herself and hence,
the 18th defendant disputed the claim of the plaintiff.
3.9.The 19th defendant is the purchaser of some the suit properties
and he has purchased the same from the other co-owners. He became
entitled to 5/8th share in survey nos. 22/2B, 27, 51/2, 56/2, 68/1A1,
10/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
68/1A3, 75/1, 78/5, 82/3B, 110/1C, 123/1A, 124/6, 131, 132/2, 79/2,
26/1D, 26/11, 83/2, 84/2, 86/2, 89/4 (89/4A), 137/2 and 5/8 th share in the
Well in S.No.56/2. He has filed a suit in O.S.No.59/2004 seeking for
partition and separate possession of 5/8th share.
4.Based on the above pleadings, the following issues were framed
by the trial court:
(i)Whether the plaintiff is entitled for partition as prayed for?
(ii)To what other reliefs?
The purchaser 19th defendant has also filed a suit in O.S.No.59 of 2004.
The said suit was also tried along with O.S.No.335 of 2004. A joint trial
was conducted. On the side of the plaintiff, P.Ws.1 to 3 were examined.
Exs.A.1 to A.32 documents were marked. On the side of the defendants,
the defendants 8 and 19 were examined as D.Ws.1 and 2 and documents
Exs.B.1 to B.27 were marked. The trial court dismissed the suit filed by
the subsequent purchaser holding that he can work out his remedy in the
final decree proceedings since he was the subsequent purchaser. In
respect of the suit filed by the plaintiff herein, the trial court decreed the
suit in respect of item nos.30 to 41, 43 to 48, 50 to 98, 100 to 145, 147
and dismissed the suit in respect of item nos.1 to 29, 42, 49, 99, 146, 148
to 150.
11/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
5.As against the dismissal of O.S No.59 of 2004, the purchaser has
filed A.S.No.916 of 2012 before this court and further, as against the
preliminary decree granted in favour of the plaintiff in O.S.No.335 of
2004 in respect of some of the suit properties, he has filed A.S.No.915 of
2012. In the present appeal, namely A.S.No.920 of 2012, as the original
plaintiff died, her son was prosecuting the appeal and the other children
of the original plaintiff were made as respondents. In the above appeals,
namely A.S.Nos.915 and 916 of 2012, it was submitted that except the
contesting respondent, namely 21st respondent in A.S.No.915 of 2012 and
17th respondent in A.S.No.916 of 2012, all other legal heirs of the original
plaintiff have already sold their shares to the appellant, namely 19 th
defendant in O.S.No.335 of 2004. When the above two appeals, namely
A.S.Nos.915 and 916 of 2012 came before this court, the second
appellant in A.S.No.920 of 2012, who is now prosecuting the said appeal,
has agreed to sell an extent of 30 cents at the rate of Rs.3700/- per square
feet and the purchaser, namely the appellant in A.S.Nos.915 and 916 of
2012 has also agreed to purchase the same within a period of three weeks
after the payment of the entire sale consideration. In view of the said
agreement reached between the contesting appellant and the subsequent
purchaser, who was plaintiff in O.S.No.59 of 2004, both appeals filed by
12/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
the subsequent purchaser, namely A.S.Nos.915 and 916 of 2012 were
disposed of by this court vide a common judgment dated 22.07.2026.
6.Now, the present appeal has been filed challenging the dismissal
of the suit in O.S.No.335 of 2004 in respect of item nos.146, 148 to 150.
The second appellant, who is now prosecuting the appeal, is the son of
the original plaintiff Raniammal. The main challenge made in this appeal
is against the dismissal of the suit in respect of various items of suit
properties, insofar as item nos. 1 to 29 are concerned, the learned counsel
for the appellant has fairly submitted before this court that the lands were
already acquired by the State Government under Exs.A.21 and A.22 and
the compensation was already paid under Ex.A.23. Therefore, nothing is
available for partition. Further, in respect of item nos.31, 32, 33, 36, 40,
41, 48, 50, 52 to 59, 62 to 65, 97 and 98, an extent of 7 acres and 61 cents
have already been sold out, out of 7 acres and 91 cents and therefore, only
30 cents is available for partition which the second appellant is entitled
to. It is submitted that the second appellant has also agreed to sell 30
cents to the 19th defendant in the suit which has also been recorded in the
judgment in A.S.No.915 and 916 of 2012 vide judgment dated
22.07.2026. Hence, the learned counsel for the appellant submitted that
the second appellant is giving up the rights in those items. The learned
13/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
counsel has also submitted that in respect of item nos.42 and 49 of the
suit schedule property, as the same has been repeated again, the same is
deleted in the decree and the second appellant is not claiming any right in
those properties. Therefor, now the main challenge is the dismissal of the
suit in respect of item nos.146, 148, 149 and 150. According to the
learned counsel for the appellants, in item no.150, after acquisition by the
Government, still there is 1 acre and 70 cents available and according to
him, the compensation amount has already been deposited in the LAOP
Court. Therefore, the second appellant is having shares in respect of item
nos.146, 148, 149 and 150. The learned counsel has submitted that the
trial court has dismissed the suit in respect of those items without
appreciating proper evidence.
7.It is contended by the learned counsel for the appellants/original
plaintiff that item no.146 is the property in the name of Shri
Shanmugananda Bus Service private limited. According to him, the bus
service was operated by plaintiff’s father and after his demise, the
permission has been changed to his elder son K.C.Ramachandran.
Therefore, according to him, this is also the property of the family.
Similarly, item no.148 is also the property of the bus service and
therefore, the plaintiff is certainly entitled to a share and suit item no.149
14/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
is also owned by her father and after his demise, the permission has been
transferred to his elder son. Therefore, according to the learned counsel,
the plaintiff is entitled to the share. It was further contended that, in the
company, the father had 9000 shares in which the plaintiff is entitled to
1125 shares, but the shares have been transferred illegally in favour of the
other defendants. It was therefore, contended that the transfer of shares to
the other defendants is not valid in the eye of law. In this regard, the
plaintiff has also filed a company petition in C.P.No.1006/111/SRB/2007
before the Company Law Board, Southern Region Bench, Chennai,
wherein the Company Law board had directed the company to transmit
1125 shares in the name of the plaintiff/petitioner and the said order has
now been challenged by the defendants. Therefore, the learned counsel
submitted that as per the evidence of P.W.2, the bus was originally owned
by the father Chinnaiya Naidu and after his death, the permit has been
transferred. Admittedly, there is no evidence to show that the plaintiff has
given no objection for transfer of the permit. Therefore, the learned
counsel would submit that in the absence of any evidence to show that the
plaintiff has also given consent to transfer the permit, transferring the
permit in the name of other legal heir will not give absolute right to the
permit holder and it is only a joint property and therefore, the plaintiff is
15/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
entitled to share in the company property also.
8.The learned counsel for the appellants/plaintiff has further
submitted that in respect of item no.150, though the property was
purchased in the name of sons of Chinnaiya Naidu in the year 1969, the
same has been purchased by the father only as joint family property.
Therefore, the plaintiff is entitled to share in that property also which has
not been taken note of by the trial court. According to the learned
counsel, Ex.A.13, a copy of the plaint in O.S.No.307 of 1984 filed by the
plaintiff and other sons would show that the father was the only earning
member in the joint family. Though the sale deed dated 08.01.1969 in
respect of item no.150 stood in the name of the sons of Chinnaiya Naidu,
the other sons pleaded in the above plaint that the purchase was only for
the benefit of the joint family members. Therefore, when such a stand
was taken by the other sons, according to the learned counsel for the
plaintiff, though item no.150 was purchased in the name of the sons, the
said property also should be treated as joint family property. In item
no.150, out of 4 acres and 8 ¼ cents, most of the extent have also been
acquired by the government for laying railway line cross bridge and
remaining extent of 1 acre and 70 cents is available for partition and that
the land acquisition compensation has also been deposited in the said land
16/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
acquisition proceedings. Therefore, according to the learned counsel, the
plaintiff is entitled to partition.
9.Further, the annual return of Shanmugananda Bus Service Private
Limited marked as Ex.A.27 would show that the father Chinnaiya Naidu
had 9000 shares. Therefore, once the entire bus service company is run by
the family, the plaintiff being the joint family member is certainly entitled
to share in the property.
10.The learned Senior counsel appearing for some of the
respondents / defendants would submit that the company was established
in the year 1961 during the life time of their father and it is the property
of the company and therefore, the same cannot be the subject matter of
partition. Though the plaintiff has filed an application before the company
law board to claim the share of her father, which was allowed by the
Company Law Board, the same is challenged in the appeal before the
appellate forum. In any event, as far as the company’s asset is concerned,
the remedy lies before the Company Law Board and not in the partition
suit. Further, admittedly there is no evidence to show that the joint family
runs the company. The father died in the year 1978 and the transfer of the
permit happened in the year 1979. The transfer of permit would not have
happened unless the other legal heirs of the permit holder gives their no
17/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
objection as per the Motor Vehicles Act which was also clearly spoken to
by P.W.2. Therefore, when the bus service permit has been transferred in
the name of one son and the partnership firm was constituted among
them, the business at no stretch of imagination is the joint family
business.
11.Further, it is contended that in the entire plaint, there is
absolutely no pleading as to the nature of the joint family business, how
the joint family was constituted and when the company came into
existence, etc., Whereas from the pleadings of the plaintiff in the earlier
suit filed by her in the year 1984 in O.S.No.307 of 1984, it clearly shows
that there was no joint family nucleus available in the family and it is
only the individual property, out of which he has purchased certain
properties. Therefore, in the absence of any pleadings as to the existence
of the joint family nucleus, the plaintiff cannot lay any share in the
property, particularly in the company’s property. Further, in respect of
item no.150, this property was purchased in the name of sons of
Chinnaiya Naidu and as they were minors at the relevant point of time, as
guardian, the father has purchased the property. Even assuming that the
father has contributed money, there is no bar under the law to purchase
the property in the name of the sons by the father for their benefit.
18/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
Therefore, the moment the transfer is effected in the name of the sons as
early as in the year 1969, now over the passage of so many years, the
plaintiff without any basis or pleadings cannot base her case as if the
properties are also joint family properties.
12.Further, it was contended that under Ex.A.5, the father and sons
have already partitioned the property on 05.12.1959 and certain
properties were allotted to sons. Later, under Ex.A.6, the property was
purchased by K.C.Ramachandran and others when he was aged about 30
years. Though the brother of K.C.Ramachandran were minors and
represented by their father, the fact remains that Ramachandran had
separate properties by virtue of partition under Ex.A.5 as early as on
05.12.1959. Therefore, at no stretch of imagination, item no.150 which is
the subject matter of Ex.A.6 should be treated as joint family property.
Further, it was contended that in the original plaint, this property was not
included and later it was included by amended plaint. All the facts clearly
show that it is only a speculative litigation in order to claim the share in
the company and in the property. Hence, the learned counsel opposed the
appeal.
13.In the light of the above submissions, now the points that arise
for consideration in this appeal are as follows:
19/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
(i)Whether the properties comprised in item nos.146,
148, 149 and 150 are joint family properties of late Chinnaiya
Naidu?
(ii)Whether the plaintiff can claim share in the
company’s properties?
(iii)To what other relief, the parties are entitled to?
Points (i) to (iii) :
14.The main issue is with regard to item nos.146, 148 and 149
being the company properties and item no.150 which was purchased
under Ex.A.6 by K.C.Ramachandran, the elder son of Chinnaiya Naidu
and other sons who are minors. A careful perusal of plaint pleadings
would show that absolutely there is no pleadings as to when and how the
joint family was constituted and how the properties have been dealt with.
The plaintiff at the time of filing of the suit was aged about 60 years.
Except stating that the properties belonged to Chinnaiya Naidu, the plaint
does not disclose as to how item nos.146, 148 and 149 came into
existence and how item no.150 was purchased. A careful perusal of
Ex.A.5 partition deed would indicate that the properties have been
partitioned among the father and sons and some of the properties have
been allotted to all the sons. On a careful perusal of Ex.A.6, it is seen that
20/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
the first son was aged about 30 years of age and other sons were minors
represented by the father and the property was purchased in the name of
sons. It was purchased in the year 1969. This aspect was never pleaded in
the plaint, whereas it is pleaded as if the properties are joint family
properties, only in the evidence.
15.It is relevant to note that much emphasis is made to Ex.A.13,
plaint filed by the plaintiff in O.S.No.307 of 1984, wherein the plaintiff
along with other brothers filed the suit for permanent injunction against
first defendant therein, namely K.C.Ramachandran from alienating the
properties. The said suit has been filed in respect of item no.150 and other
properties. When the said plaint is carefully seen, it would really indicate
that there was no ancestral nucleus of any kind and her father
K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu alone was the only earning member in the joint
family. Be that as it may, the said suit came to be dismissed as early as in
the year 1990 and the same has not been prosecuted. The said suit was
also resisted by K.C.Ramachandran denying the contentions of the
plaintiff. Therefore, once the sons were already given sufficient properties
in the year 1959 under Ex.A.5, partition deed and at the time of purchase
in the year 1969, the elder son was aged about 30 years, merely because
the father stood as guardian for other sons, it cannot be held that those
21/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
properties were purchased only out of the father’s income. Even
assuming that such properties were purchased by the father, it should be
held that such purchase was only for the benefit of the sons alone. If the
intention of the father to treat such purchase only for the members of the
family, the plaintiff and other daughter’s name also would have been
found place. Therefore, merely because the plaintiff and other brothers
have joined together against the elder son and filed the suit in the year
1984, that cannot be a ground to hold that the entire property is the joint
family property, particularly in the absence of any pleadings with regard
to the joint family, etc.,
16.Further, there was no reason as to why the plaintiff has not
prosecuted the suit in O.S.No.307 of 1984 but after 20 years, the present
suit came to be filed. Therefore, the conduct of the parties cannot be
ignored altogether. Once the properties stand in the name of the sons and
that too purchased after the partition in the family and they were also
allotted certain properties, merely because the father stood as guardian for
some of the minors, now it is too late for the plaintiff to contend that
these properties which stood in the name of the brothers, are also joint
family properties. Absolutely, there is no pleadings whatsoever in the
plaint to show that the suit properties are joint family properties. Except
22/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
contenting that the suit properties belonged to the father, no other
pleadings whatsoever was made. Further, a perusal of Ex.A.13 plaint
clearly indicates that there was no joint family nucleus to purchase the
property. Such being the position, it has to be held that it is the properties
of brothers and the plaintiff cannot claim any share in the property in item
no.150.
17.Item no.146 was admittedly purchased by the private limited
company under Ex.B.1. Further, the Article of Association Ex.A.2 and the
balance sheets Ex.A.3 and Ex.A.4 were also filed. The plaintiff has
claimed share in her father’s share. According to the plaintiff, the father
had 9000 shares in the company in which she is entitled to 1125 shares.
Therefore, having claimed shares of her father, now the plaintiff cannot
lay her claim over the property of the company. Admittedly, the plaintiff
has
already
approached
the
Company
Law
Board
in
C.P.No.1006/111/SRB/2007 for transfer of the share left by her father and
by order dated 11.06.2008, the Company Law Board directed the
company to transmit 1125 shares in the name of the plaintiff. The said
order is now under challenge in the appeal before the appellate forum.
Such being the position, having claimed right in respect of the shares held
by her father, now she cannot lay her claim over the property of the
23/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
company and therefore, she has to work out her remedy in respect of the
shares held by her father in the Company Law Board appellate forum
alone. Therefore, we are of the view that the plaintiff is not entitled to
share in the company’s property.
18.Similarly, it is the contention that the bus service is also a
family property. It is relevant to note that when Ex.A.27 Annual return
filed by the company is carefully perused, it is seen that the company is
incorporated and registered on 27.05.1961 onwards. Therefore, without
claiming any right over the property, now after several decades, i.e., after
40 years, the plaintiff claiming shares over the property of the company
in our view is not maintainable.
19.The evidence of P.W.1
would clearly show that she never
claimed any share in the properties for all these years and she does not
even know the registration number of the bus, etc., She has no knowledge
whatsoever with regard to the affairs of the company. Therefore, after 40
years, the plaintiff claiming share in the company’s property in our view
is an attempt to make an unjust enrichment. Further, it is to be noted that
despite filing the suit in the year 1984 claiming right in the suit
properties, when the same was contested by filing written statement by
K.C.Ramachandran, the suit was allowed to be dismissed by the plaintiff
24/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
and others. If really, there was any share for which the plaintiff is entitled
to, her normal conduct would be to file a suit at the earliest point of time
which was not done. Further, her evidence during cross examination
clearly shows that she has admitted that during the life time, her father
has given her properties and she has also sold one acre of the property.
She has admitted in her evidence that ‘vd; mg;gh vdf;F brhj;J bfhLj;Js;shh;
vd;why; mJ rhp jhd;/ me;j brhj;jpy ; xU Vf;fh; kl;Lk; tpw;gid bra;Js;nsd;/ ’. It is
relevant to note that she was given property by her father. Further, her
admission in the cross examination, as extracted above, would clearly
indicate that she had already sold one acre out of the property given by
her father. This fact was never disclosed by the plaintiff. But, the plaint
proceeds as if the entire properties are joint family properties. Further, she
has also denied that her father had divided the share in the company
during his life time. She has feigned ignorance to the said fact also.
Admittedly, her father died in the year 1978.
20.The evidence of P.W.2, when carefully seen, would show that
P.W.2 is an assistant in the RTO Office. His evidence clearly indicate that
the bus stood in the name of the father K.R.Chinnaiya Naidu. After his
death, permit of the bus has been transferred in the name of
K.C.Ramachandran. The said transfer was effected on 20.12.1979 and
25/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
another transfer was also effected on 20.12.1989, for which documents
Exs.P.18, Ex.P.19 and Ex.P.20 were produced. It is relevant to note that
when the permit was transferred on 20.12.1989, the Tamil Nadu Motor
Vehicles Rules, 1989 came into force. Rule 214 clearly shows that the
transfer of permit on death of permit holder can be done only on
production of the legal heirship certificate issued by an officer of the
revenue department not below the rank of a Tahsildar and No Objection
Certificate from all the legal heirs other than the applicant, if there are
more than one legal heir to the deceased permit holder. Therefore, only
when no objection is given by others, the transfer is effected. P.W.2, in his
evidence, also has clearly admitted that only on the basis of the no
objection certificate given by the others, the transfer of permit is effected
to one of the legal heirs.
21.Further, the another transfer was effected in the year 20.12.1979
which was governed by the Indian Motor Vehicles Act, 1939. Section 61
of the Indian Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 dealt with the transfer of permit
on death of holder. As per this provision, the transport authority on
application made within three months of the death of the holder of a
permit can transfer the permit to the person succeeding to the possession
of the vehicles covered by the permit. Therefore, when the evidence of
26/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
P.W.2 itself clearly indicates that only on the no objection certificate from
the other legal heirs, the transfer was effected as early as in the year 1979
and 1989 under Ex.A.18, Ex.A.19 and Ex.A.20. Therefore, it is for the
plaintiff to establish that no such no objection certificate whatsoever was
given by her. There is nothing on record on the side of the plaintiff to
deny the evidence of P.W.2 in this regard. But on the contrary, it is
evident that no objection certificate was given by other legal heirs.
Further, there is no contra evidence to the effect that no objection was not
given by other legal heirs. Such being the position, once the permit has
been transferred to one of the legal heirs in the year 1979 and 1989, it
cannot be said that such transfer is also for the benefit of the joint family.
22.Admittedly, after the transfer of permit, there was partnership
entered into between the defendants in respect of the bus service which
was also clearly established on record. P.W.1 has also admitted in her
evidence that the bus service is under the control of her brother for all
these years. Since the permit was also transferred in individual name and
operated by brothers from the year 1979 onwards, the plaintiff, after a
lapse of many years, cannot contend that there are joint family properties
and the same were dealt with by the joint family. Therefore, we are of the
considered view that the trial court dismissing the suit in respect of item
27/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
nos.146, 148, 149 and 150 is proper. Hence, we do not find any merit in
the appeal preferred by the plaintiff. The petitioner was granted
preliminary decree in respect of the suit item nos.30 to 41, 43 to 48, 50 to
98, 100 to 145, 147 for allotment of 1/7th share in those suit items.
Therefore, the plaintiff has to work out her shares as declared in the
preliminary decree by the trial court.
23.In the result, the present appeal suit filed by the plaintiff is
dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petition is closed.
(N.S.K., J.) (M.J.R., J.)
31.07.2026
Index : Yes / No
Speaking Order /Non speaking order
vvk
To
1.The Additional District Judge,
Fast Track Court No.1,
Chengalpattu.
2.Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madras High Court,
Chennai.
28/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3180
A.S.No.920 of 2012
N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.
and
M.JOTHIRAMAN, J.
vvk
judgment in
A.S.No.920 of 2012
31.07.2026
29/29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review