Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
A.S.No.485 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON
PRONOUNCED ON
: 04.11.2025
: 15.06.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.D. MARIA CLETE
A.S. No.485 of 2019
1.Mrs.B.Kousalya,
W/o.G.Boopalan,
D/o.Late Thiruveedhi
No.18 (old no.47)S.S.V.Koil 2nd street,
Melpattadai, perambur,
chennai – 11.
2.Mrs.Gowri,
W/o.Rajkumar & D/o.Late Thiruveedhi,
No.15 Bajanaikoil street,
Royapuram, Chennai 13.
..Appellants/Plaintiffs
Vs.
1.T.Jayabalan
S/o.Late Thiruveedhi
NO.3/9, Rohini Street,
Palani Street, rajaji nagar
villivakkam, Chennai – 49.
2.T.Muthuraman,
S/o.Late Thiruveedhi
No.25/5, New street,
Thathankuppam,
Villivakkam, Chennai – 49.
3.T.Muruganandham
S/o.Late Thiruveedhi
1/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
No.16/36, 1st cross street,
Savadi Salai, Korattur,
Chennai 80.
..Respondents/defendants
PRAYER: Appeal suit filed praying to set aside the Judgment and decree dated
12.01.2018 made in O.S.No.854 of 2014 on the file of the XVIII Additional
Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai by allowing this first appeal before this Court
and thus render justice.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.N.Ramesh
For Respondent(s):
Mr.C.Sankar for R1.
Mr.J.Franklin for R2 & R3.
JUDGMENT
This appeal is filed by the plaintiffs against the judgment and decree dated
12.01.2018 passed by the learned XVIII Additional Judge, City Civil Court,
Chennai, in O.S.No.854 of 2014, whereby the suit filed by the plaintiffs for
partition and permanent injunction was dismissed.
2.
For convenience, the parties are referred to as they were arrayed before
the trial Court.
3.
The plaintiffs states that they and the defendants are children of late
M.Thiruveedhi. Thiruveedhi had two wives, namely T.Kamalammal and
2/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
Annammal, who were sisters. The first defendant Jayabalan, and also
N.Lalitha, Baby Kumari and Rajendran, were born through the first wife
Kamalammal. The plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 were born through the
second wife Annammal. Both the families were living together.
4.
According to the plaintiffs, Annammal, mother of the plaintiffs and
defendants 2 and 3, was assigned by the Government a vacant land at New
Street, Thathankuppam, Villivakkam, Chennai, in S.No.92, measuring
0.01.31.5 hectares. The suit was filed in respect of this property, treating it as
Annammal’s property.
5.
The plaintiffs further pleaded that Thiruveedhi owned another property
measuring about 1200 sq.ft. in S.No.91, adjacent to the present suit property.
According to them, after Thiruveedhi died intestate on 04.03.2000, the first
defendant, being the eldest male member, took control of the property in
S.No.91, and as he refused partition, the plaintiffs filed O.S.No.7887 of 2012 in
respect of that property.
6.
The plaintiffs pleaded that Annammal died on 03.09.1995, leaving
behind the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 as her legal heirs. Therefore, after
Annammal’s death, the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 allegedly inherited the
suit property and continued in joint possession and enjoyment.
3/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
7.
Since the suit property was adjacent to the family property, the plaintiffs
pleaded that they and defendants 2 and 3 had permitted the first defendant to
use it only as a matter of family relationship. According to them, such oral
permission stood revoked when dispute arose.
8.
The plaintiffs further alleged that because they had filed the partition
suit in respect of their father’s property, the first defendant developed enmity,
attempted to interfere with their possession, and tried to grab the suit property.
The 1st defendant has no right or title in the suit property and he is no way
concerned with the suit property. He is neither a co- owner nor share holder in
the suit property.
9.
On these pleadings, the plaintiffs sought partition into four shares,
allotment of 1/4th share each to both plaintiffs, appointment of Commissioner,
and permanent injunction against the first defendant.
10.
The first defendant, in his written statement, denied the plaintiffs’ claim
that Annammal was the owner of the suit property comprised in S.No.92,
measuring 0.01.31.5 hectares, and put the plaintiffs to strict proof of the same.
4/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
11.
He further contended that the suit property had not been properly
described by metes and bounds and that the description furnished in the plaint
was vague and uncertain. Though he admitted that he is the stepson of
Annammal, he pleaded that he cannot be treated as her lineal descendant for the
purpose of claiming or resisting partition in respect of her property.
12.
The principal defence of the first defendant is that he is the absolute
owner of the property bearing Plot No.7-B, measuring about 0.03 cents or 1308
sq.ft., and Plot No.7-C, measuring about 0.1½ cents or 654 sq.ft., together with
a small A.C.C. roof building situated at New Street, Thathankuppam,
Villivakkam, comprised in Survey No.249, Konnur Village. According to him,
except the name of the street, the plaint schedule property does not tally with
his property, either with reference to the survey number, extent, or block
number.
13.
The first defendant also raised a plea of non-joinder of necessary party
by contending that the present owner of the property had not been impleaded in
the suit. According to him, the property presently belongs to his wife, Smt.
Ramani Jayabalan, and the plaintiffs, by suppressing the said material fact,
have instituted the suit with an improper description of the property and on
payment of insufficient court fee.
5/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
14.
He further pleaded that the suit is barred by limitation, since the
plaintiffs were aware of the settlement deed executed in the year 2009, but had
failed to institute the suit within the prescribed period. He also denied that the
suit property is joint family property and asserted that he had been in absolute
possession and enjoyment of the property from the year 1968. According to
him, he initially put up a thatched house, subsequently made further
constructions, and the property has been assessed in his name from the year
1993 onwards.
15.
It is his further case that he settled the property in favour of his wife
under a registered settlement deed dated 21.07.2006, registered as Document
No.3606 of 2006, and that from the date of such settlement, his wife has been
in possession and enjoyment of the property as its absolute owner. He also
relied upon the assignment patta dated 20.05.1976, said to have been issued in
respect of Plot Nos.7-B and 7-C in his favour.
16.
On the above pleadings, the first defendant contended that the suit for
partition is not maintainable either in law or on facts and prayed for dismissal
of the suit.
6/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
17.
Defendants 2 and 3, in their written statement, supported the case of the
plaintiffs. They admitted the relationship pleaded in the plaint and stated that
the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 were born to Thiruveedhi through
Annammal, whereas the first defendant was born to Thiruveedhi through
Kamalammal.
18.
They further admitted that their mother Annammal was the owner of the
suit schedule property bearing Door No.26/5, New Street, Thathankuppam,
Villivakkam, Chennai, comprised in S.No.92 and measuring 0.01.31.5 hectares
of vacant land. According to them, after the death of Annammal on 03.09.1995,
the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 have been in joint possession and
enjoyment of the suit property.
19.
Defendants 2 and 3 therefore pleaded that each of them is entitled to a
1/4th share in the suit property along with the plaintiffs, and stated that they
have no objection for partition of the suit property into four equal shares.
20.
On the above pleadings, the trial Court framed the following issues:
1.Whether the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 are in joint possession of
the suit property?
2.Whether each plaintiffs are entitled for 1/4th share?
3.Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to permanent injunction as prayed
7/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
for?
4.Whether the plaintiffs properly described the suit property in the plaint
schedule?
5.Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
6.Whether the suit is barred by limitation?Whether the plaintiffs are
entitled for preliminary decree as prayed in the suit ?
7.To what relief is the plaintiff entitled for ?
21.
Before the trial court, on the plaintiffs’ side, P.W.1 to P.W.3 were
examined. Exs.A1 to A6 were marked. Ex.A1, true copy of settlement register
for municipal towns dated 18.03.2013; Ex.A2, F.M.B. sketch; Ex.A3, death
certificate of Annammal; Ex.A4, Form-I given by Tahsildar; Ex.A5,
encumbrance certificate; and Ex.A6, plaint copy in O.S.No.7887 of 2012. On
the defendants’ side, D.W.1 was examined. Exs.B1 to B8 were marked. Ex.B1
to Ex.B3, assignment pattas dated 20.05.1976 in the name of Jayabalan issued
by Special Tahsildar; Ex.B4 and Ex.B5, settlement deeds; Ex.B6, property tax
assessment card; Ex.B7, Chennai Metro Water and Sewerage Board receipt;
and Ex.B8, Electricity Board receipt. Exs.C1 to C3 were also marked. Ex.C1
was town survey register extract, Ex.C2 was Form-I by Tahsildar, and Ex.C3
was letter of Tahsildar, Ayanavaram Taluk.
8/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
22.
The Trial Court, on appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence,
held that the plaintiffs had failed to prove that the suit property belonged to
Annammal or that it was allotted to her under any valid assignment. The Trial
Court found that Ex.A1 contained corrections and overwriting and was not
properly authenticated. It also relied upon Exs.B1 to B8 produced by the first
defendant to hold that possession and enjoyment were with the first defendant.
23.
The Trial Court further held that the plaintiffs themselves had pleaded
that the first defendant was permitted to use the property, and therefore the plea
of joint possession by the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 was not established.
Consequently, the Trial Court rejected the claim of the plaintiffs that they and
defendants 2 and 3 were entitled to 1/4th share each in the suit property.
24.
The Trial Court also found that the plaint schedule property was not
properly described by metes and bounds and that there was uncertainty
regarding the identity of the property, particularly in view of the discrepancy in
survey number, block number and boundaries. It further took note of the first
defendant’s plea that the property had been settled in favour of his wife,
Ramani Jayabalan, who was not impleaded as a party, and that no relief had
been sought against the settlement deed. On the above findings, the Trial Court
dismissed the suit without costs.
9/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
25.
Aggrieved by the judgment and decree of the trial court the plaintiffs
prefered this appeal and contends that the trial Court erred in dismissing the
suit for partition. They contend that the first defendant has no connection with
the suit property because it belonged to Annammal, who was the mother of the
plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3. They further contend that the plaintiffs and
defendants 2 and 3 alone are Annammal’s heirs and that each is entitled to
equal share. They further contend that the property of Thiruveedhi in S.No.91
is adjacent to the suit property and that, because of family relationship, the first
defendant was only permitted to use the suit property. According to them, such
permission was later revoked. They also contend that the trial Court failed to
appreciate the plaintiffs’ evidence, failed to consider the evidence regarding
partition, and wrongly concluded that the plaintiffs were not entitled to
partition.
26.
The learned counsel for the appellants/plaintiffs would submit that the
Trial Court erred in dismissing the suit, notwithstanding the revenue records
produced on the side of the plaintiffs to show that the suit property was
assigned in favour of late Annammal. According to the learned counsel, Ex.A1
Settlement Register and Exs.C1 to C3 revenue records, produced through the
Tahsildar, establish that the property comprised in S.No.92 was assigned to
Annammal and that, on her death, the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3, being
her legal heirs, became entitled to 1/4th share each.
10/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
27.
The learned counsel would further submit that the Trial Court ought not
to have rejected the plaintiffs’ documents merely on the ground of corrections,
overwriting or discrepancy in the block number. It is contended that official
revenue records maintained in the ordinary course carry a presumption of
correctness and that minor clerical discrepancies would not destroy their
evidentiary value. In support of this submission, reliance was placed on
Balwant Singh v. Daulat Singh, (1997) 7 SCC 137, Union of India v. Pramod
Gupta, (1997) 9 SCC 78, and State of A.P. v. Star Bone Mill & Fertilizer Co.,
(2013) 9 SCC 319.
28.
The learned counsel would also submit that the Trial Court wrongly
relied upon Exs.B1 to B3 produced by the first defendant, though the said
documents related to Plot Nos.7-B and 7-C in S.F.No.249 and not to the suit
property in S.No.92. It is further submitted that the genuineness of those
documents was not established and that the revenue official was unable to
verify the same from the official records. Therefore, the first defendant had
failed to rebut the plaintiffs’ case based on official revenue records.
29.
It is further submitted that defendants 2 and 3 had categorically admitted
that the suit property belonged to Annammal, that the plaintiffs and defendants
2 and 3 are her legal heirs, and that each of them is entitled to 1/4th share. The
learned counsel would submit that such admissions ought to have been given
11/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
due weight by the Trial Court. In this regard, reliance was also placed on
Nagindas Ramdas v. Dalpatram Iccharam, AIR 1974 SC 471, to contend that
admissions made in pleadings stand on a higher footing.
30.
The learned counsel would further contend that the suit for partition
with a consequential prayer for injunction is maintainable and that the plaintiffs
were not required to file a separate suit for declaration or recovery of
possession. Reliance was placed on Sukh Ram v. Harbheji, AIR 1969 SC 1114,
in support of the contention that in a partition suit, consequential relief can be
sought against a person interfering with the enjoyment of the property.
31.
On the issue of description of property, the learned counsel relied upon
Karam Chand v. Board of Revenue, Rajasthan, AIR 2005 Raj 284, and Abdul
Hamid v. Nur Mohd., AIR 1976 Del 328, to submit that minor errors in survey
number, block number or description are not fatal when the property is
otherwise identifiable from the pleadings and evidence.
32.
The learned counsel also referred to Lachman Singh v. Kirpa Singh,
(1987) 2 SCC 547, E. Parashuraman v. V. Doraiswamy, (2006) 1 SCC 658,
Bhagwan Dass v. Girdhari Lal, (2007) 11 SCC 218, Prem Singh v. Birbal,
(2006) 5 SCC 353, and Guru Amarjit Singh v. Rattan Chand, (1993) 4 SCC
349, in support of the appellants’ case. On the above submissions, the learned
12/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
counsel prayed that the judgment and decree of the Trial Court be set aside and
that a preliminary decree be passed declaring 1/4th share each in favour of the
plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3, together with consequential injunction.
33.
The learned counsel for the respondent/ defendant would submit that
the suit for partition itself is not maintainable. According to him, the first
defendant is only the stepson of Annammal and, therefore, the plaintiffs cannot
seek partition as against him without first establishing their title to the suit
property. It is submitted that, if at all the plaintiffs claim title over the property,
their proper remedy was to file a suit for declaration of title and recovery of
possession, and not a bare suit for partition and injunction.
34.
The learned counsel would further submit that the plaintiffs have not
proved that the suit property belonged to Annammal. Except Ex.A1 Settlement
Register, no independent document has been produced to show that Annammal
had title over the property. Even Ex.A1 contains corrections and overwriting,
and no initials or authentication are found against such corrections. It is also
submitted that Ex.A1 was obtained only under the Right to Information Act and
the competent authority who issued or maintained the relevant assignment
records was not examined. Though the plaintiffs examined the Tahsildar, the
patta was said to have been issued by the Special Tahsildar, who was not
examined.
13/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
35.
It is further contended that the suit property is Government land and
that, on the basis of possession, patta was issued in favour of the first
defendant. The first defendant has produced Exs.B1 to B3 pattas and other
documents to show his possession and enjoyment of the property from the year
1976. According to the learned counsel, such possession remained undisputed
for several years, and the plaintiffs did not challenge the same either during the
lifetime of Annammal or immediately after her death.
36.
The learned counsel would also submit that the plaintiffs have not
pleaded that Exs.B1 to B3 were obtained by fraud. In the absence of specific
pleadings containing the particulars of fraud, as required under Order VI Rule 4
of the Code of Civil Procedure, the plaintiffs cannot be permitted to contend
that the pattas produced by the first defendant are fraudulent or fabricated. It is
submitted that vague allegations are not sufficient to dislodge official
documents produced by the first defendant.
37.
The learned counsel would further contend that the plaintiffs did not
challenge the pattas issued in favour of the first defendant and filed the suit
only after the settlement deed was executed. Even the said settlement deed has
not been challenged in the suit. Therefore, without seeking declaration of title
and without challenging the documents relied upon by the first defendant, the
plaintiffs are not entitled to seek partition.
14/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
38.
It is also submitted that the plaintiffs have failed to establish either title
or joint possession. They have not proved that the property was the separate
property of Annammal or that it was available for partition among the plaintiffs
and defendants 2 and 3. On the other hand, the documents produced by the first
defendant establish that he has been in possession and enjoyment of the
property in his own right.
39.
In support of his submissions, the learned counsel relied upon Lachman
Singh v. Kirpa Singh and others, AIR 1987 SC 1616, Rangammal v.
Kuppuswami and another, (2011) 12 SCC 220, State of Andhra Pradesh and
others v. Star Bone Mill and Fertilizer Company, (2013) 9 SCC 319, and
Jagdish Prasad Patel (Dead) through LRs. v. Shivnath and others, (2019) 6 SCC
82. Relying upon the above decisions, the learned counsel prayed that the
findings of the Trial Court be confirmed and the appeal be dismissed.
40.
The following points arise for consideration in this appeal:
1. Whether the suit for partition and bare injunction arraying the nonsharer first defendant is maintainable?
2. Whether the relief of bare injunction sought against the first defendant is
maintainable?
3. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
15/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
4. Whether the judgment and decree of the Trial Court is liable to be set
aside?
Point Nos. 1 to 3:
41.
The relationship between the parties is not in serious dispute. The
plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 are the children born to late M. Thiruveedhi
through Annammal whereas the first defendant is the son born to late M.
Thiruveedhi through his first wife, Kamalammal.
42.
The plaintiffs instituted the suit claiming partition of the suit property on
the footing that it originally belonged to late Annammal and that, upon her
demise, the plaintiffs and defendants 2 and 3 succeeded to the same.
Defendants 2 and 3, in their written statement, have admitted the claim of the
plaintiffs and have expressed their willingness for division of the property by
metes and bounds.
43.
Thus, there is no real lis or contest between the plaintiffs and defendants
2 and 3 with regard to the partition of the suit property.
44.
However, the first defendant resisted the suit by specifically disputing
Annammal’s title to the suit property. His categorical defence is that the suit
property never owned by Annammal, but was assigned in his favour by the
competent authority, and that he has been in continuous possession and
16/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
enjoyment of the property for several decades in his own independent right.
45.
In support of his claim, the first defendant relied upon the assignment
records, the settlement deeds executed in favour of his wife, and the municipal,
Metro Water and electricity records to substantiate both his title and possession.
46.
On the side of the plaintiffs, reliance is mainly placed upon Ex.A1, the
SLR extract, and the allied documents, to contend that the suit property
belonged to Annammal. However, as rightly noticed by the Trial Court, there
are material discrepancies with regard to the block number and the identity of
the property. While the plaintiffs have described the suit property as being
situated in one block number, the documents relied upon by them do not fully
correlate with the plaint schedule property.
47.
Further, the plaintiffs have not placed any convincing material to
establish their actual physical possession over the suit property, particularly
after the alleged revocation of the permissive occupation said to have been
granted in favour of the first defendant.
48.
On the contrary, the first defendant has consistently asserted
independent title and possession over the suit property. He has also pleaded that
he had settled the property in favour of his wife under Exs.B4 and B5, thereby
contending that the present interest in the property vests with the settlee.
17/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
49. Though this specific plea was raised, the alleged present holder of interest
in the property has not been impleaded as a party to the suit. In such
circumstances, the objection regarding non-joinder of a necessary party cannot
be brushed aside.
50.
In such circumstances, where serious disputes arise with regard to title,
identity, and actual possession of the suit property, and where the contesting
defendant sets up an independent title adverse to the plaintiffs and defendants 2
and 3, a prayer for partition and for bare injunction against such defendant
cannot be maintained without seeking a declaration of title.
51.
Further, when the first defendant has pleaded that the property has been
settled in favour of his wife, the person in whose favour the settlement is said
to have been made ought to have been impleaded as a party. Without
impleading the alleged present holder of interest in the property, the suit suffers
from non-joinder of a necessary party.
52.
As held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi
Reddy reported in 2008 (4) SCC 594 , where title itself is in serious dispute, a
suit for mere injunction is not the appropriate remedy.
53.
The Trial Court, on proper appreciation of the oral and documentary
evidence, has taken note of these infirmities and dismissed the suit. This Court
finds no perversity, illegality, or material infirmity in the said findings
warranting interference in appeal. Points 1 to 3 are answered accordingly.
18/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
Point No. 4:
54.
In view of the findings rendered on Point Nos. 1 to 3, this Court finds no
valid ground to interfere with the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court. The judgment and decree under appeal do not suffer from any illegality,
perversity, or material infirmity warranting interference by this Court and are
liable to be confirmed.
55.
In the result, the appeal is dismissed and the judgment and decree of the
Trial Court are confirmed. Having regard to the close relationship between the
parties, there shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petition(s), if any, shall stand closed.
15.06.2026
ay
Index:Yes/No
Speaking Order /Non-speaking order
19/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.485 of 2019
DR. A.D. MARIA CLETE, J
ay
To
1.The XVIII Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai
2. The Section Officer,
V.R.Records,
Madras High Court.
PRE DELIVERY JUDGMENT
A.S. No. 485 of 2019
15.06.2026
20/20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review