Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON
PRONOUNCED ON
: 04.11.2025
: 15.06.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.D. MARIA CLETE
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
1.Mrs.B.Kousalya
W/o. G.Boopalan, D/o. Late Thiruveedhi, No.18,
Old No.47, S.S.V.Koil 2nd St, Melpattadai, Perambur,
Ch-11.
2. Mrs.Gowri
W/o. Rajkumar And D/o. Late Thiruveedhi, No.15,
Bajanaikoil St, Royapuram, Ch-13.
..Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. T.Jayabalan
S/o Late Thiruveedhi, No.3/9, Rohini Street, Palani Street,
Rajaji Nagar, Villivakkam, Chennai 600 049.
2. N.Lalitha
W/o Late Narayanasamy, D/o Late Thiruveedhi, No.10/44,
Thayuma Nagar, New Street, Thathankuppam, Villivakkam,
Chennai 600 049.
3. M.Baby Kumari
W/o Mohan, D/o Late Thiruveedhi, No.10/44, Thayuma Nagar,
New Street, Thathankuppam, Villivakkam, Chennai 600 049.
4. T.Muthuraman
S/o Late Thiruveedhi, No.25/5, New Street, Thathankuppam,
Villivakkam, Chennai 600 049.
5. T.Rajendran
S/o Late Thiruveedhi, No.106-b, 9th Cross Street, North
Jagannathan Nagar, Villivakkam Chennai 600 049.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
6. T.Muruganandhan
S/o Late Thiruveedhi, No.16/36, 1st Cross Street,
Savadi Salai, Korattur, Chennai 600 080.
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER: Appeal suit filed praying to set aside the judgment and decree dated
12-01-2018 of the Learned XVIII Additional District Judge, City Civil Court,
Chennai in OS NO.7887 of 2012.
For Appellant(s):
For Respondent(s):
M/s.N.Ramesh
Revathy Radhakrishnan
V.Logesh
M/s.C.Shankar
P.Stalin Selvasekaran
K.Vaidhyanathan For R1 To R3 And R5
M/s.J.Franklin
S.Karthik For Rr 4 And 6, In Sr Stage
JUDGMENT
This appeal has been filed by the plaintiffs challenging the judgment and
decree dated 12.01.2018 passed by the learned XVIII Additional Judge, City
Civil Court, Chennai, in O.S.No.7887 of 2012, whereby the suit filed for
partition and separate possession was dismissed.
2.
For convenience, the parties are referred to as they were arrayed before
the trial Court.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
3.
The plaintiffs, are the daughters of late M.Thiruveedhi through his second
wife, Annammal. According to them, Thiruveedhi had two wives, namely
Kamalammal and Annammal. Defendants 1 to 3 and 5 were born through
Kamalammal, while the plaintiffs and defendants 4 and 6 were born through
Annammal.
4.
The case of the plaintiffs is that the suit property bearing Door No.26/5,
New Street, Thathankuppam, Villivakkam, Chennai, measuring about 1200
sq.ft., comprised in S.F.No.91, old S.No.249/part, Block No.91, was assigned by
the Government in favour of their father, Thiruveedhi, under an assignment
patta dated 01.07.1974. It is their further case that Thiruveedhi put up a
residential building in the suit property and remained in possession and
enjoyment of the same till his death on 04.03.2000. Since he died intestate, the
plaintiffs claim that all his children are entitled to equal shares in the suit
property.
5.
The plaintiffs further pleaded that, after the death of Thiruveedhi, the first
defendant, Jayabalan, being the eldest male member of the family, took control
of the suit property, leased it out, and enjoyed the income derived therefrom
without effecting partition among the legal heirs. The plaintiffs therefore issued
a legal notice dated 21.06.2012 demanding partition. The first defendant sent a
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
reply dated 27.06.2012 denying their claim, which necessitated the filing of the
suit for partition, separate possession and plaintiffs share in the rent and income
yielded from the schedule property.
6.
The first defendant filed a written statement and it was adopted by the
second and third defendants by filing a memo to that effect. The first defendant
denied the plaintiffs’ claim that late M.Thiruveedhi was the owner of the suit
schedule property bearing Door No.26/5, New Street, Thathankuppam,
Villivakkam, Chennai, measuring about 1200 sq.ft., and that the said property
had been assigned to him by the Government under assignment patta dated
01.07.1974. According to the first defendant, the plaintiffs have not properly
described the suit property and there is ambiguity in the plaint schedule.
7.
The specific case of the first defendant is that he has been in possession
and enjoyment of the property from the year 1968 onwards. According to him,
the land comprised in Survey No.249 of Konnur Village was originally
classified as road in the survey and settlement register and, being a prolonged
resident of Konnur Village, he was in possession of a portion of the land. He
pleaded that he constructed a thatched house thereon and that, in the year 1976,
the Special Tahsildar, Saidapet, issued an assignment patta in his favour in
respect of Plot No.7-A at Thathankuppam, Konnur Village, under proceedings
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
dated 20.05.1976.
8.
The first defendant further pleaded that the suit property is not joint
family property and that late M.Thiruveedhi had no title or ownership over the
same. It is his case that he continued to be in absolute possession and enjoyment
of the property, put up a hut in the year 1975 and later constructed an R.C.C.
structure in the year 1993. He claimed that he enjoyed the property as absolute
owner till the year 2009 and thereafter settled the property in favour of his wife
under the settlement deed dated 23.09.2009, who is presently in possession and
enjoyment of the same.
9.
The first defendant also contended that the suit for partition is not
maintainable either in law or on facts. According to him, the plaintiffs had kept
quiet for nearly 12 years after the death of their father and had filed the suit only
with an intention to harass him. On the above pleadings, the first defendant
prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs.
10.
The trial court framed the following issues on 03.08.2013:
1. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get 1/8 th share in the suit
property?
2. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get share in the rent and income
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
yielded from the suit property?
3. Whether it is true that the plaintiffs are not in joint possession of the
suit property?
4. To what relief are the plaintiffs entitled for?
11.
Before the trial court, on the plaintiffs’ side, P.W.1 to P.W.5 were
examined and Exs.A1 to A10 were marked. Ex.A1 was the settlement register
extract; Ex.A2 was the FMB sketch; Ex.A3 was the death certificate of
Thiruveedhi; Ex.A4 was the legal heir certificate; Ex.A5 was the encumbrance
certificate; Ex.A6 and Ex.A7 were notice and reply; Ex.A8 photographs with
CD; Ex.A9 police complaint; and Ex.A10 Form-I notice by the Tahsildar. Ex.C1
Town Survey register extract.
12.
On the side of the defendants, the first defendant, T.Jayabalan, was
examined as D.W.1 and Exs.B1 to B13 were marked. Ex.B1 is the marriage
invitation dated 07.11.2003. Exs.B2 and B3 are the assignment pattas dated
20.05.1976 issued in the name of T.Jayabalan by the Special Tahsildar, and
Ex.B4 is also an assignment patta issued in his favour by the Special Tahsildar.
Exs.B5 and B6 are the true copies of the settlement deeds. Ex.B7 is the copy of
the property tax assessment card, Ex.B8 is the Chennai Metropolitan Water
Supply and Sewerage Board tax receipt, and Ex.B9 is the Electricity Board
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
receipt. Ex.B10 is the encumbrance certificate dated 01.03.2010. Ex.B11 is the
certified true copy of the settlement deed dated 25.08.2004, Ex.B12 is the
certified true copy of the sale deed dated 14.09.2004, and Ex.B13 is the copy of
Transfer O.P. Petition No.14 of 2016 dated 15.10.2015.
13.
On appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence adduced on either
side, the Trial Court held that the plaintiffs had failed to prove that the suit
property was assigned in favour of late M.Thiruveedhi. The Trial Court found
that Ex.A1 contained corrections and overwriting and that the description of the
property in the plaint schedule did not tally with Exs.A1, A2 and A10. It further
held that the plaintiffs had not properly described the suit property by giving
boundaries and had also failed to amend the plaint schedule despite the
discrepancy being pointed out by the defendants.
14.
The Trial Court, relying upon Exs.B2 to B9, held that the first defendant
had established his possession and enjoyment over the suit property. The
allegation that Exs.B2 to B4 were forged was rejected on the ground that the
plaintiffs had not discharged the burden of proving the said allegation.
Accordingly, the Trial dismissed the suit without costs.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
15.
Aggrieved by the Judgment and decree, the plaintiffs have preferred the
present appeal contending that the trial court erred in rejecting the certified copy
of the assignment patta and revenue records standing in the name of
Thiruveedhi. They contend that revenue officials confirmed the assignment in
favour of Thiruveedhi and that the Form-I notice also stood in his name. They
further contend that the first defendant’s pattas were forged, unsupported by
revenue records, and could not have been issued in his favour when he was a
young unmarried son. They also contend that the trial court wrongly relied upon
tax receipts and possession documents in the first defendant’s name, though he
was only the eldest male member managing family property. The appellants also
submit that after the death of Thiruveedhi on 04.03.2000, all his children
became entitled to 1/8th share each under Hindu succession law, and that the trial
court failed to appreciate this legal consequence.
16.
The learned counsel for the appellants/plaintiffs would submit that the
Trial Court erred in dismissing the suit for partition, despite the plaintiffs having
established that the suit property originally belonged to their father, late
M.Thiruveedhi. It is submitted that the suit property bearing Door No.26/5, New
Street, Thathankuppam, Villivakkam, Chennai, comprised in S.F.No.91, old
S.No.249/part, was assigned by the Government in favour of M.Thiruveedhi
under assignment patta dated 01.07.1974. Since Thiruveedhi died intestate on
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
04.03.2000, the plaintiffs and defendants, being his legal heirs, are each entitled
to 1/8th share in the suit property.
17.
The learned counsel would further submit that the Trial Court wrongly
discarded Ex.A1 Settlement Register, Ex.A10 Form-I notice and Ex.C1 revenue
record merely on the ground of corrections, overwriting and discrepancy in the
block number. According to the learned counsel, the discrepancy between Block
No.91 mentioned in the plaint schedule and Block No.31 found in the revenue
records is only a clerical or survey discrepancy and does not affect the identity
of the property, which is otherwise identifiable by door number, survey number,
extent and location.
18.
It is further submitted that official revenue records maintained in the
regular course of official duty carry a presumption of correctness under the
Indian Evidence Act, and such presumption cannot be displaced by minor
clerical discrepancies. In support of this submission, the learned counsel relied
upon Balwant Singh v. Daulat Singh, (1997) 7 SCC 137, Union of India v.
Pramod Gupta, (1997) 9 SCC 78, State of A.P. v. Star Bone Mill and Fertilizer
Co., (2013) 9 SCC 319, and Partap Singh v. Shiv Ram, AIR 2020 SC 1382.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
19.
The learned counsel would also submit that the Trial Court wrongly relied
upon Exs.B2 and B3, the alleged assignment pattas produced by the first
defendant. It is contended that the said documents were not proved in the
manner known to law and their genuineness could not be verified by the
Tahsildar, who was examined as P.W.5. According to the learned counsel, the
first defendant produced those documents belatedly and failed to establish that
they related to the suit property. It is further submitted that Exs.B2 and B3 relate
to different plots in S.F.No.249 and not to the suit property in S.F.No.91.
20.
The learned counsel further contended that the Trial Court failed to
properly appreciate the admissions made by the first defendant as D.W.1.
According to the learned counsel, D.W.1 admitted the relationship between the
parties, the death of Thiruveedhi, and the fact that the plaintiffs are also legal
heirs of Thiruveedhi. It is therefore submitted that, once the relationship and
common source of title are admitted, the plaintiffs, being daughters of
Thiruveedhi, are entitled to equal shares along with the other legal heirs.
21.
The learned counsel would submit that the finding of the Trial Court
regarding improper description of the property is erroneous. The suit property
has been sufficiently described by door number, street, village, survey number,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
old survey number, extent and nature of property. Minor omission or
discrepancy in the description cannot defeat a suit for partition when the
property is otherwise identifiable from the pleadings and evidence. In this
regard, reliance was placed upon Karam Chand v. Board of Revenue, Rajasthan,
AIR 2005 Raj 284, Abdul Hamid v. Nur Mohd., AIR 1976 Del 328, and
Nagindas Ramdas v. Dalpatram Iccharam, AIR 1974 SC 471.
22.
The learned counsel would also submit that the Trial Court failed to
protect the statutory rights of the plaintiffs, who are daughters of late M.
Thiruveedhi. It is submitted that, under the Hindu Succession Act, sons and
daughters are Class-I heirs and are entitled to equal shares in the property of a
male Hindu dying intestate. Reliance was placed upon Vineeta Sharma v.
Rakesh Sharma, AIR 2020 SC 3717, Danamma v. Amar, (2018) 3 SCC 343, and
E. Parashuraman v. V. Doraiswamy, (2006) 1 SCC 658.
23.
The learned counsel further relied upon Lachman Singh v. Kirpa Singh,
(1987) 2 SCC 547, and Prem Singh v. Birbal, (2006) 5 SCC 353, to contend that
partition is a matter of right among co-sharers and that such right cannot be
defeated on technical objections or by one co-sharer setting up exclusive title on
the basis of doubtful documents.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
24.
On the above submissions, the learned counsel prayed that the judgment
and decree of the Trial Court be set aside and a preliminary decree be passed for
partition of the suit property into eight equal shares, allotting 1/8 th share each to
the plaintiffs and other legal heirs of late M.Thiruveedhi, together with
consequential reliefs.
25.
The learned counsel for the respondents/defendants would submit that the
suit for partition itself is not maintainable as framed. According to him, the
plaintiffs have not established that the suit property belonged to late
M.Thiruveedhi. It is submitted that when the first defendant is in possession of
the property in his own right and when he disputes the very title of Thiruveedhi,
the plaintiffs ought to have filed a suit for declaration of title and recovery of
possession, and not a bare suit for partition.
26.
The learned counsel would further submit that the plaintiffs have not
proved that the suit property was assigned in favour of late M.Thiruveedhi.
Except Ex.A1 Settlement Register, no independent or reliable document has
been produced to establish title in favour of Thiruveedhi. It is contended that
Ex.A1 contains corrections and overwriting with regard to the plot number,
extent and block number, and no initials or authentication are found against
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
such corrections. It is further submitted that Ex.A1 was obtained only under the
Right to Information Act and that the competent authority who issued or
maintained the original assignment records was not examined. Though the
plaintiffs examined revenue officials, the Special Tahsildar, who is said to have
issued the assignment patta, was not examined.
27.
It is further contended that the suit property was originally Government
land and that, on the basis of long possession, patta was issued in favour of the
first defendant. The first defendant has produced Exs.B2 to B4 assignment
pattas and other revenue and tax records to show that he has been in possession
and enjoyment of the property from the year 1976. According to the learned
counsel, such possession remained undisputed for several years and the
plaintiffs did not challenge the patta or the possession of the first defendant
during the lifetime of Thiruveedhi or immediately after his death.
28.
The learned counsel would also submit that the plaintiffs have not
specifically pleaded that Exs.B2 to B4 were obtained by fraud or fabrication. In
the absence of specific pleadings containing particulars of fraud, as required
under Order VI Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the plaintiffs cannot be
permitted to contend that the assignment pattas produced by the first defendant
are fraudulent or forged. It is submitted that vague allegations are not sufficient
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
to dislodge documents produced by the first defendant.
29.
The learned counsel would further contend that the plaintiffs have not
challenged the pattas issued in favour of the first defendant. The first defendant
had also executed a settlement deed in favour of his wife, Ramani Jayabalan, in
the year 2009, and even the said settlement deed has not been challenged in the
suit. Therefore, without seeking declaration of title and without challenging the
documents relied upon by the first defendant, the plaintiffs are not entitled to
seek partition.
30.
It is also submitted that the plaintiffs have failed to establish either title or
joint possession. They have not proved that the suit property was the selfacquired property of late M. Thiruveedhi or that it was available for partition
among his legal heirs. On the other hand, the documents produced by the first
defendant establish that he has been in continuous possession and enjoyment of
the property in his own right.
31.
In support of his submissions, the learned counsel relied upon Lachman
Singh v. Kirpa Singh and others, AIR 1987 SC 1616, Rangammal v.
Kuppuswami and another, (2011) 12 SCC 220, State of Andhra Pradesh and
others v. Star Bone Mill and Fertilizer Company, (2013) 9 SCC 319, and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
Jagdish Prasad Patel (Dead) through LRs. v. Shivnath and others, (2019) 6 SCC
82. Relying upon the above decisions, the learned counsel prayed that the
findings of the Trial Court be confirmed and the appeal be dismissed.
Points for Consideration:
32.
The following points arise for consideration in this appeal:
1. Whether the suit schedule property belonged to late Thiruveedhi?
2. Whether the suit schedule property is available for partition among
the legal heirs of late Thiruveedhi?
3. Whether the judgment and decree of the Trial Court are liable to be
set aside?
Point Nos. 1 and 2:
33.
The plaintiff instituted the suit for partition on the footing that the suit
schedule property was originally assigned in the name of her father, late
Thiruveedhi. According to the plaintiff, late Thiruveedhi thereafter put up a
house in the said property, possessed and enjoyed it as its absolute owner, and
died intestate leaving behind the plaintiffs and defendants as his legal heirs. The
relationship between the parties is not in dispute. It is admitted that the plaintiffs
and defendants are the legal heirs of late Thiruveedhi.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
34.
It is also not in dispute that, on the date of filing of the suit, the suit
property was in the actual physical possession of the first defendant, who, being
the eldest member of the family, was managing the property. However, the first
defendant specifically contends that his possession is not as one of the legal
heirs of late Thiruveedhi, but in his own independent right. According to him,
the assignment was made in his favour; he put up the construction in the
property; and he has been in continuous possession and enjoyment of the same
as its absolute owner for more than three decades.
35.
The core issue, therefore, is whether the suit property belonged to late
Thiruveedhi, as claimed by the plaintiffs, or whether it independently belongs to
the first defendant. Since the plaintiffs claim title to the suit property only
through late Thiruveedhi, the burden squarely rests upon them to establish that
late Thiruveedhi had title to the property.
36.
To prove the title of late Thiruveedhi, the plaintiffs mainly rely upon
Exs.A1, A2 and A10. Ex.A1 is the SLR extract. The Trial Court noticed certain
discrepancies and overwriting in the said document and, for that reason,
declined to place reliance upon it. The principal reason given by the Trial Court
was that the property mentioned in Ex.A1 is situated in Block No.31, whereas,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
even according to the plaintiffs, the suit property is situated in Block No.91.
Ex.A2, the Field Measurement Book, also relates to Block No.31. Similarly,
Ex.A10, Form No.1 issued under the Natham Scheme enquiry, stands in the
name of Thiruveedhi, but it too pertains to the property situated in Block No.31.
37.
The plaintiffs have not established that Exs.A1, A2 and A10 relate to the
suit schedule property. They have also not explained how documents pertaining
to Block No.31 can be connected to the suit property, which, as per the plaint
schedule, is situated in Block No.91.
38.
Further, the plaintiffs have not produced any independent document to
show that late Thiruveedhi was in possession and enjoyment of the suit
property. No house tax receipt, water tax receipt, electricity service record, or
other revenue or municipal record has been produced in support of their claim.
39.
In these circumstances, this Court finds no infirmity in the conclusion of
the Trial Court that the plaintiffs have failed to establish that late Thiruveedhi
owned the suit property.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
40.
On the other hand, the first defendant, in support of his claim that the
property was originally assigned in his favour, relies upon Exs.B2 to B4,
namely, the assignment orders standing in his name. He has also produced
Exs.B7 to B9, namely, the Corporation tax demand card, Metro Water tax
records, and electricity bills, all standing in his name for a considerable period.
41.
These documents lend probability to the case of the first defendant that he
has been in possession and enjoyment of the suit property in his own right,
while paying public taxes and statutory charges in respect of the same.
42.
Though the plaintiffs have disputed the genuineness of the documents
produced by the defendants and alleged that they are forged and created for the
purpose of the case, the plaintiffs cannot succeed merely on the weakness of the
defence. It is well settled that a plaintiff must establish her own case
independently, on the strength of her own pleadings and evidence.
43.
In the present case, as already discussed, the plaintiffs have failed to
establish that late Thiruveedhi had title to the suit property.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
44.
In the absence of proof that the suit property belonged to late
Thiruveedhi, the question of treating it as partible property among his legal heirs
does not arise. Consequently, the suit property cannot be subjected to partition.
Accordingly, Point Nos. 1 and 2 are answered against the plaintiffs.
Point No. 3:
45.
In view of the findings rendered on Point Nos. 1 and 2, this Court finds
no valid ground to interfere with the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court. The judgment and decree under appeal do not suffer from any illegality,
perversity, or infirmity warranting interference by this Court and the judgment
and decree of the Trial Court are liable to be confirmed. Accordingly, Point No
3 is answered against the plaintiffs.
46.
In the result, the appeal is dismissed and the judgment and decree of the
Trial Court are confirmed. Having regard to the relationship between the parties,
there shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous
petition(s), if any, shall stand closed.
15.06.2026
ay
Index:Yes/No
Speaking Order /Non-speaking order
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
DR. A.D. MARIA CLETE, J
ay
To
1. The XVIII Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai
2.The Section Officer,
V.R.Records,
Madras High Court.
PRE DELIVERY JUDGMENT
A.S. No. 659 of 2019
15.06.2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review