Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
11.09.2026
Court No. 236
Item No. 06
Sandip
W.P.A. 28677 of 2023
Sri Mrinal Samanta
Vs.
The Chief General Manager, State Bank of India & Ors.
Mr. Anupam Hait
…for the Petitioner.
Mr. Debashis Saha,
Mr. Avirup Ray Sanyal,
Ms. Sucheta Pal,
Mr. Jyotishman Sarkar
… for the SBI.
Mr. Arik Banerjee,
Mr. Pujon Chatterjee
…for the Respondent no. 6.
1. Affidavit-of-service, filed by the petitioner in Court
today, is taken on record.
2. The petitioner intended to purchase a flat in a project,
namely, “The Pyramid” at Narayanpur, Rajarhat,
Gopalpur, Kolkata – 700136. The petitioner applied to
the respondent bank for a housing loan and in this
regard a tripartite agreement was executed between the
respondent Bank, the developer and the petitioner on
June 16, 2016.
Subsequently, disputes cropped up
between the parties, which compelled the petitioner to
file the present writ petition.
3. The petitioner, by filing this writ petition, has sought for
the following reliefs:“a) A Writ of or in the nature of Mandamus by
directing and commanding the Respondents No. 2
and 3, subordinates and each one of them to show
cause as to why the letter vide No RACPC/BID/2122/2045
dt.
11-08-2021
for
the
immediate
submission of the original TITLE DEED of flat No
17-4/G in the project “THE PYRAMID” for the
equitable
mortgage
failing
which
penal
compounding interest @ 2% on the HBA and also
again further such threating notice served to the
petitioner on the same issue vide letter No.
RACPC/BID/22-23/57 dt. 30-03-2022 be stayed or
stopped.
b) A Writ of or in the nature of Mandamus by
directing and commanding the Respondents No. 2
and 3, subordinates and each one of them to show
cause as to why the petitioner’s monetary rights,
property rights, life and liberty should not to be
protected and if no sufficient cause has been shown
then directing the Respondents concerned to
protect the petitioner’s rights as per Annexure P-23
and P-24 to their Writ Petition and make the rule
absolute;
c) A Writ of or in the nature of Mandamus directing
and commanding the RACPC, Bidhannagar, the
Respondent No. 1 to make proper investigation of
the association involved in the personnel of Bank
who made approval of the housing project “THE
PYRAMID’ as the SBI’s approved project and
allured the petitioner to invest his hard-earned
money in the project which has no valid sanction
plan for raising 10th storied building.
d) A writ in the nature of Mandamus by directing
and commanding the Respondent No. 1 to 3 to
refund the entire money of 29,63,276/- (rupees
twenty-nine
lakhs
sixty-three
thousand
two
hundred seventy-six) as well as accrued interest @
18% per annum to the petitioner.
e) A writ in the nature of prohibition the
Respondents No. 4 to 6 to not to dealt with further
with the property in housing project “THE
PYRAMID’.
f) A Writ in the nature of certiorari by directing the
Respondents concerned and each one of them to
transmit and certify all the relevant papers and
documents in connection of this case before this
Hon’ble Court so that the conscionable justice may
be rendered and/or administered.”
4. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent no. 6,
at the threshold, raised the point of maintainability of the
writ petition. He submitted that the dispute involved in
the writ petition is a private dispute between the
petitioner, the developer and the bank. He referred to the
letter dated August 11, 2021 at page 172 of the writ
petition, which was issued by the Chief Manager
[Maintenance],
RACPC
Bidhannagar
SBI
to
the
petitioner whereby the bank requested him to submit the
original title deed of mortgage in connection with
Housing Loan Account No. – 35801716923. By the said
letter the bank informed the petitioner that the title deed
of the property had not been submitted by him for
creation of an equitable mortgage, which amounted to a
violation of the agreement executed between the bank
and the petitioner.
5. In reply, the learned advocate appearing for the
petitioner, on the point of maintainability, submitted
that the Developer had adopted unfair trade practices to
the extent that proper sanction for the building was not
obtained and the bank, by suppressing vital information,
approved the said project and sanctioned the housing
loan in favour of the petitioner. He further submitted
that due to the misdeeds committed by the respondents,
he was unable to submit the title deed within time to the
Bank.
6. Heard the parties.
7. It appears that the dispute between the bank and the
petitioner is private in nature and such dispute falls
within the realm of private law and no public law
element is involved herein.
The writ petition also
involves disputed questions of fact, particularly, the
petitioner’s prayer seeking refund of Rs. 29,63,276/from the bank, which cannot be decided in writ
proceedings.
8. In M.P. Power Management Co. Ltd. vs. Sky
Power Southeast Solar India (P) Ltd., reported in
(2023) 2 SCC 703, the Hon’ble Apex Court in
paragraph 77, inter alia, observed as follows:
“77. It is while dealing with the said case that this
Court no doubt proceeds to, inter alia, lay down as
following after adverting to ABL [ABL International
Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corpn. of India Ltd.,
(2004) 3 SCC 553] also : (Joshi Technologies
case [Joshi Technologies International Inc. v. Union
of India, (2015) 7 SCC 728] , SCC pp. 766-68, paras
69-70)
“69. The position thus summarised in the aforesaid
principles has to be understood in the context of
discussion that preceded which we have pointed out
above. As per this, no doubt, there is no absolute bar
to the maintainability of the writ petition even in
contractual matters or where there are disputed
questions of fact or even when monetary claim is
raised. At the same time, discretion lies with the High
Court which under certain circumstances, it can
refuse to exercise. It also follows that under the
following circumstances, “normally”, the Court
would not exercise such a discretion:
69.1. The Court may not examine the issue unless the
action has some public law character attached to it.
69.2. Whenever a particular mode of settlement of
dispute is provided in the contract, the High Court
would refuse to exercise its discretion under Article
226 of the Constitution and relegate the party to the
said
mode
of
settlement,
particularly
when
settlement of disputes is to be resorted to through the
means of arbitration.
69.3. If there are very serious disputed questions of
fact which are of complex nature and require oral
evidence for their determination.
69.4. Money claims per se particularly arising out of
contractual obligations are normally not to be
entertained except in exceptional circumstances.
70. Further, the legal position which emerges from
various judgments of this Court dealing with
different situations/aspects relating to contracts
entered into by the State/public authority with
private parties, can be summarised as under:
70.1. At the stage of entering into a contract, the
State acts purely in its executive capacity and is
bound by the obligations of fairness.
70.2. State in its executive capacity, even in the
contractual field, is under obligation to act fairly and
cannot practise some discriminations.
70.3. Even in cases where question is of choice or
consideration of competing claims before entering
into the field of contract, facts have to be investigated
and found before the question of a violation of Article
14 of the Constitution could arise. If those facts are
disputed and require assessment of evidence the
correctness of which can only be tested satisfactorily
by taking detailed evidence, involving examination
and cross-examination of witnesses, the case could
not be conveniently or satisfactorily decided in
proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution. In
such cases the Court can direct the aggrieved party
to resort to alternate remedy of civil suit, etc.
70.4. Writ jurisdiction of the High Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution was not intended to
facilitate
avoidance
of
obligation
voluntarily
incurred.
70.5. Writ petition was not maintainable to avoid
contractual obligation. Occurrence of commercial
difficulty, inconvenience or hardship in performance
of the conditions agreed to in the contract can
provide no justification in not complying with the
terms of contract which the parties had accepted
with open eyes. It cannot ever be that a licensee can
work out the licence if he finds it profitable to do so :
and he can challenge the conditions under which he
agreed to take the licence, if he finds it commercially
inexpedient to conduct his business.
70.6. Ordinarily, where a breach of contract is
complained of, the party complaining of such breach
may sue for specific performance of the contract, if
contract is capable of being specifically performed.
Otherwise, the party may sue for damages.
70.7. Writ can be issued where there is executive
action unsupported by law or even in respect of a
corporation there is denial of equality before law or
equal protection of law or if it can be shown that
action of the public authorities was without giving
any hearing and violation of principles of natural
justice after holding that action could not have been
taken without observing principles of natural justice.
70.8. If the contract between private party and the
State/instrumentality and/or agency of the State is
under the realm of a private law and there is no
element of public law, the normal course for the
aggrieved party, is to invoke the remedies provided
under ordinary civil law rather than approaching
the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India and invoking its extraordinary jurisdiction.
70.9. The distinction between public law and private
law element in the contract with the State is getting
blurred. However, it has not been totally obliterated
and where the matter falls purely in private field of
contract, this Court has maintained the position that
writ petition is not maintainable. The dichotomy
between public law and private law rights and
remedies would depend on the factual matrix of each
case and the distinction between the public law
remedies
and
private
law
field,
cannot
be
demarcated with precision. In fact, each case has to
be examined, on its facts whether the contractual
relations between the parties bear insignia of public
element. Once on the facts of a particular case it is
found that nature of the activity or controversy
involves public law element, then the matter can be
examined by the High Court in writ petitions under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India to see whether
action of the State and/or instrumentality or agency
of the State is fair, just and equitable or that relevant
factors are taken into consideration and irrelevant
factors have not gone into the decision-making
process or that the decision is not arbitrary.
70.10. Mere reasonable or legitimate expectation of a
citizen, in such a situation, may not by itself be a
distinct enforceable right, but failure to consider and
give due weight to it may render the decision
arbitrary, and this is how the requirements of due
consideration of a legitimate expectation forms part
of the principle of non-arbitrariness.
70.11. The scope of judicial review in respect of
disputes falling within the domain of contractual
obligations may be more limited and in doubtful
cases the parties may be relegated to adjudication of
their rights by resort to remedies provided for
adjudication of purely contractual disputes.”
9. In Punjab National Bank vs. Atmanand Singh,
reported in (2020) 6 SCC 256, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in paragraph 22, inter alia, observed as follows:
“22. We restate the above position that when the
petition raises questions of fact of complex nature,
such as in the present case, which may for their
determination
require
oral
and
documentary
evidence to be produced and proved by the party
concerned and also because the relief sought is
merely for ordering a refund of money, the High
Court should be loath in entertaining such writ
petition and instead must relegate the parties to
remedy of a civil suit. Had it been a case where
material facts referred to in the writ petition are
admitted facts or indisputable facts, the High Court
may be justified in examining the claim of the writ
petitioner on its own merits in accordance with law.”
10. The bank issued the letter for submission of the original
title deed for mortgage on August 11, 2021 and the
instant writ petition was affirmed on December 18, 2023,
challenging the said letter dated August 11, 2021.
Therefore, this writ petition also suffers from gross delay
and laches.
11. On the issue of ‘delay and laches’ in writ proceedings, the
Supreme Court, in Tridip Kumar Dingal v. State of
W.B., reported in (2009) 1 SCC 768, had the occasion
to observe:
“56. “…… It is well settled that power to issue a writ
is discretionary. One of the grounds for refusing
reliefs under Article 32 or 226 of the Constitution is
that the petitioner is guilty of delay and laches.
57. If the petitioner wants to invoke jurisdiction of a
writ court, he should come to the Court at the earliest
reasonably possible opportunity. Inordinate delay in
making the motion for a writ will indeed be a good
ground for refusing to exercise such discretionary
jurisdiction. The underlying object of this principle is
not to encourage agitation of stale claims and
exhume matters which have already been disposed of
or settled or where the rights of third parties have
accrued in the meantime ....
58. There is no upper limit and there is no lower
limit as to when a person can approach a court. The
question is one of discretion and has to be decided on
the basis of facts before the court depending on and
varying from case to case. It will depend upon what
the breach of fundamental right and the remedy
claimed are and when and how the delay arose.
59. We are in respectful agreement with the
following observations of this Court in P.S.
Sadasivaswamy v. State of T.N. [(1975) 1 SCC 152 :
1975 SCC (L&S) 22] : (SCC p. 154, para 2)
“2. … It is not that there is any period of limitation
for the courts to exercise their powers under Article
226 nor is it that there can never be a case where the
courts cannot interfere in a matter after the passage
of a certain length of time. But it would be a sound
and wise exercise of discretion for the courts to refuse
to exercise their extraordinary powers under Article
226 in the case of persons who do not approach it
expeditiously for relief and who stand by and allow
things to happen and then approach the court to put
forward stale claims and try to unsettle settled
matters.”
12. In view of the above, the writ petition stands dismissed.
13. However, dismissal of the writ petition shall not preclude
the
petitioner
from
taking
appropriate
steps
in
accordance with law.
14. There shall be no order as to costs.
15. Urgent photostat certified copy of the order, if applied
for, be given to the parties, upon usual undertakings.
(Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review